Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicIDWIssue21To22

Go To



** Though to be fair, the writer himself did wish to have more of a backstory and/or motive for Rough Diamond, but there just wasn't any space that was allowed.

to:

** Though to be fair, the writer himself did wish to have more of a backstory and/or motive for Rough Diamond, but there just wasn't any he didn't have space that was allowed.for it.


** And fairly, the writer himself did wish to have more of a backstory and/or motive for Rough Diamond, but there just wasn't any space that was allowed.

to:

** And fairly, Though to be fair, the writer himself did wish to have more of a backstory and/or motive for Rough Diamond, but there just wasn't any space that was allowed.


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Some might see that Rough Diamond was used more of as the mysterious thief concept than an actual character. While some were fine with it for the sake of Trixie and Babs friendship, there was a feeling that more could have been done with her.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Some might see that Rough Diamond was used more of as the mysterious thief concept than as an actual character. While some were fine with it for the sake of Trixie and Babs friendship, there was a feeling that more could have been done with her.


* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like [[TheAtoner she still has to struggle to prove she's good now]], effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.

to:

* ItsShortSoItSucks: Some complaints about the arc is that it could have stand to have more space to flesh out both story and character interactions.
* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like [[TheAtoner she still has to struggle to prove she's good now]], effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.many.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Some might see that Rough Diamond was used more of as the mysterious thief concept than an actual character. While some were fine with it for the sake of Trixie and Babs friendship, there was a feeling that more could have been done with her.
**And fairly, the writer himself did wish to have more of a backstory and/or motive for Rough Diamond, but there just wasn't any space that was allowed.


* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like [[TheAtoner she still has to struggle to prove she's good now]], effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.
* ShownTheirWork:
** A very minor example: in their escape from Carneighie Hall, the characters catch an F train, which is the closest subway stop to Carnegie Hall and would, indeed, take you from Manhattan to Brooklyn (or Hooflyn). [[WordOfGod This was intentional.]]
** Babs' apartment is located at "Farrier Hill"; this is a reference to the real world Cobblers Hill in New York, but per WordOfGod, plays on the name, as cobblers would make shoes, while farriers would make horseshoes.

to:

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like [[TheAtoner she still has to struggle to prove she's good now]], effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.
* ShownTheirWork:
** A very minor example: in their escape from Carneighie Hall, the characters catch an F train, which is the closest subway stop to Carnegie Hall and would, indeed, take you from Manhattan to Brooklyn (or Hooflyn). [[WordOfGod This was intentional.]]
** Babs' apartment is located at "Farrier Hill"; this is a reference to the real world Cobblers Hill in New York, but per WordOfGod, plays on the name, as cobblers would make shoes, while farriers would make horseshoes.
many.


* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like [[TheAtoner she still has to struggle to prove she's good now]], effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.

to:

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like [[TheAtoner she still has to struggle to prove she's good now]], effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.many.
* ShownTheirWork:
** A very minor example: in their escape from Carneighie Hall, the characters catch an F train, which is the closest subway stop to Carnegie Hall and would, indeed, take you from Manhattan to Brooklyn (or Hooflyn). [[WordOfGod This was intentional.]]
** Babs' apartment is located at "Farrier Hill"; this is a reference to the real world Cobblers Hill in New York, but per WordOfGod, plays on the name, as cobblers would make shoes, while farriers would make horseshoes.


* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like she still has to struggle to prove she's good now, effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.

to:

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like [[TheAtoner she still has to struggle to prove she's good now, now]], effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.


* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like she still has to struggle to prove she's good now, effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie [[ClearMyName prove likewise]] [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.

to:

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like she still has to struggle to prove she's good now, effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie [[ClearMyName prove likewise]] ClearMyName [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.

Added DiffLines:

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: After extensive criticism for being unjustly EasilyForgiven for her bullying, Babs Seed being portrayed as feeling like she still has to struggle to prove she's good now, effort to help fellow [[HeelFaceTurn reformed antagonist]] Trixie [[ClearMyName prove likewise]] [[NotSoDifferent because of it]], and their subsequent FriendshipMoment has fully redeemed her to many.

Showing 9 edit(s) of 9

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report