History YMMV / MarvelAFreshStart

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: Dan Slott's take on ''Iron Man'' and Mark Waid's take on ''Dr. Strange'' hasn't been well-received. For Slott's ''Iron Man'', there are fans who are utterly wary of Slott's description of "''WesternAnimation/RickAndMorty'' meets ''Series/BlackMirror''" -- some are assuming that this means we're looking at fantastical sci-fi things the same way we saw Slott's take on ''Silver Surfer'', others have taken this literally and are assuming we're looking at the advent of Pickle Tony Stark. For Waid's ''Dr. Strange'', he's coming off of the popular run by Donny Cates, thus he has a ToughActToFollow. This is also because many fans feel like Waid's been off his A-Game since ''ComicBook/{{Avengers 2016}}'' and ''ComicBook/{{Champions 2016}}''.[[note]] Although his ''Home of the Brave/Out of Time'' ''ComicBook/CaptainAmerica'' work was extremely well received.[[/note]]

** The seeming pushing away of the diverse legacy characters in favour of the old guard, which is seen by many as Marvel pandering to the VocalMinority who hated them. Many also are left questioning if Marvel actually has any ideas on what to do with a number of characters, Bruce Banner being a prime example.

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: Dan Slott's take on ''Iron Man'' and Mark Waid's take on ''Dr. Strange'' hasn't been well-received. For Slott's ''Iron Man'', there are fans who are utterly wary of Slott's description of "''WesternAnimation/RickAndMorty'' meets ''Series/BlackMirror''" -- some are assuming that this means we're looking at fantastical sci-fi things the same way we saw Slott's take on ''Silver Surfer'', others have taken this literally and are assuming we're looking at the advent of Pickle Tony Stark. For Waid's ''Dr. Strange'', he's coming off of the popular run by Donny Cates, thus he has a ToughActToFollow. This is also because many fans feel like Waid's been off his A-Game since ''ComicBook/{{Avengers 2016}}'' and ''ComicBook/{{Champions 2016}}''.[[note]] Although his ''Home of the Brave/Out of Time'' ''ComicBook/CaptainAmerica'' work was extremely well recieved.[[/note]]

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Marvel seems to at least be attempting to restore the status quo. They're off to a good start by making Tony Stark and Odinson Iron Man and Thor again, respectively, along with Bruce Banner's Hulk getting a home book again. The upcoming ''Avengers'' series also seems to have a more classic lineup. Said lineup includes newest Ghost Rider, Robbie Reyes, who fans have been clamoring for more of since his ongoing was cancelled.

* ItsTheSameNowItSucks: With Mary Jane seemingly MIA at the start of Nick Spencer's run and the revelations that there will be a new LoveInterest possibly for Peter, some fans are upset because that would mean that Peter and MJ ''don't'' get back together at the end of "Go Down Swinging", Dan Slott's final storyline and, thus, the Spider-Marriage's dissolution continues onto year 12. There's also the fact that it seems that he's living in a shoddy apartment and rooming with Robbie Robinson's son again meaning that Peter is once again the "relatable loser". [[note]]''ComicBook/RenewYourVows'' is still available![[/note]]
* TheyChangedItNowItSucks:
** While happy the heroes are back, everyone is really sick of massive status quo shifts and relaunches every single year or two.
** Dan Slott's take on ''Iron Man'' and Mark Waid's take on ''Dr. Strange'' hasn't been well-received. For Slott's ''Iron Man'', there are fans who are utterly wary of Slott's description of "''WesternAnimation/RickAndMorty'' meets ''Series/BlackMirror''" -- some are assuming that this means we're looking at fantastical sci-fi things the same way we saw Slott's take on ''Silver Surfer'', others have taken this literally and are assuming we're looking at the advent of Pickle Tony Stark. For Waid's ''Dr. Strange'', he's coming off of the popular run by Donny Cates, thus he has a ToughActToFollow. This is also because many fans feel like Waid's been off his A-Game since ''ComicBook/{{Avengers 2016}}'' and ''ComicBook/{{Champions 2016}}''.[[note]] Although his ''Home of the Brave/Out of Time'' ''ComicBook/CaptainAmerica'' work was extremely well recieved.[[/note]]
* UnexpectedCharacter: Or rather "Unexpected Series" with the appearance of a brand-new series starring the Sentry. With the character being both a laughingstock and a sign of things wrong with Marvel, one would think they would stay away from him.
* WinBackTheCrowd: ''A Fresh Start'' is seemingly winning back a lot of fans who were turned off by the ridiculous storylines, relaunches, pointless deaths and Marvel's inability to commit to books, claiming books touted as ongoings suddenly being reclassified as mini-series

** Dan Slott's take on ''Iron Man'' and Mark Waid's take on ''Dr. Strange'' hasn't been well-received. For Slott's ''Iron Man'', there are fans who are utterly wary of Slott's description of "''WesternAnimation/RickAndMorty'' meets ''Series/BlackMirror''" -- some are assuming that this means we're looking at fantastical sci-fi things the same way we saw Slott's take on ''Silver Surfer'', others have taken this literally and are assuming we're looking at the advent of Pickle Tony Stark. For Waid's ''Dr. Strange'', he's coming off of the popular run by Donny Cates, thus he has a ToughActToFollow. This is also because many fans feel like Waid's been off his A-Game since ''ComicBook/{{Avengers 2016}}'' and ''ComicBook/{{Champions 2016}}''.[[note]] Although his ''Home of the Brave/Out of Time'' ''ComicBook/Captain America'' work was extremely well recieved.[[/note]]

** Dan Slott's take on ''Iron Man'' and Mark Waid's take on ''Dr. Strange'' hasn't been well-received. For Slott's ''Iron Man'', there are fans who are utterly wary of Slott's description of "''WesternAnimation/RickAndMorty'' meets ''Series/BlackMirror''" -- some are assuming that this means we're looking at fantastical sci-fi things the same way we saw Slott's take on ''Silver Surfer'', others have taken this literally and are assuming we're looking at the advent of Pickle Tony Stark. For Waid's ''Dr. Strange'', he's coming off of the popular run by Donny Cates, thus he has a ToughActToFollow. This is also because many fans feel like Waid's been off his A-Game since ''ComicBook/{{Avengers 2016}}'' and ''ComicBook/{{Champions 2016}}''.

** Dan Slott's take on ''Iron Man'' and Mark Waid's take on ''Dr. Strange'' hasn't been well-received. For Slott's ''Iron Man'', there are fans who are utterly wary of Slott's description of "''WesternAnimation/RickAndMorty'' meets ''Series/BlackMirror''" -- some are assuming that this means we're looking at fantastical sci-fi things the same way we saw Slott's take on ''Silver Surfer'', others have taken this literally and are assuming we're looking at the advent of Pickle Tony Stark. For Waid's ''Dr. Strange'', he's coming off of the popular run by Danny Coats, thus he has a ToughActToFollow. This is also because many fans feel like Waid's been off his A-Game since ''ComicBook/{{Avengers 2016}}'' and ''ComicBook/{{Champions 2016}}''.

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: While happy the heroes are back, everyone is really sick of massive status quo shifts and relaunches every single year or two.

* BrokenBase: Funnily enough, the rift appears to be between fans, most of whom appear to be happy to see the classic characters return, and retailers, who are sick of the renumbering and fear the constant relaunching will keep people away, as it's been the case with Marvel's previous initiatives.
** If there's a point of contention among the fans, however, they're due to the creative teams chosen for some of the books, in particular Ta-Nehisi Coates on Captain America and Nick Spencer on Amazing Spider-Man.
*** When it comes to Coates, some fans point out they don't want a very political book in Captain America while others point out that Captain America is meant to be political and thus Coates is a good match due to his political activism.
*** As for Spencer, the divide seems to be between those that liked his Superior Foes and Ant-Man runs and those that still resent Spencer for the whole [[ComicBook/CaptainAmericaSteveRogers Captain America]] / ComicBook/SecretEmpire fiasco from the last two years and have sworn him off, though even those fans do admit that Superior Foes and Ant-Man were really good comic books.

* ItsTheSameNowItSucks: With Mary Jane seemingly MIA at the start of Nick Spencer's run and the revelations that there will be a new LoveInterest possibly for Peter, some fans are upset because that would mean that Peter and MJ ''don't'' get back together at the end of "Go Down Swinging", Dan Slott's final storyline and, thus, the Spider-Marriage's dissolution continues onto year 12. There's also the fact that it seems that he's living in a shoddy apartment and rooming with Robbie Robinson's son again meaning that Peter is once again the "relateable loser". [[note]]''ComicBook/RenewYourVows'' is still available![[/note]]

*** As for Spencer, the divide seems to be between those that liked his Superior Foes and those that still resent Spencer for the whole [[ComicBook/CaptainAmericaSteveRogers Captain America]] / ComicBook/SecretEmpire fiasco from the last two years and have sworn him off, though even those fans do admit that Superior Foes was a really good comic book.

* ItsTheSameNowItSucks: With Mary Jane seemingly MIA at the start of Nick Spencer's run and the revelations that there will be a new LoveInterest possibly for Peter, some fans are upset because that would mean that Peter and MJ ''don't'' get back together at the end of "Go Down Swinging", Dan Slott's final storyline and, thus, the Spider-Marriage's dissolution continues onto year 12. There's also the fact that it seems that he's living in a shoddy apartment and rooming with Robbie Robinson's son again meaning that Peter is once again the "relateable loser".

** If there's a point of contention among the fans, however, they're due to the creative teams chosen for some of the books, in particular Ta-nehisi Coates on Captain America and Nick Spencer on Amazing Spider-Man.

* BrokenBase: Funnily enough, the rift appears to be between fans, who appear to be happy to see the classic characters return, and retailers, who are sick of the renumbering and fear the constant relaunching will keep people away, as it's been the case with Marvel's previous initiatives.

*** As for Spencer, the divide seems to be between those that liked his Superior Foes and those that still resent Spencer for the whole Captain America / Secret Empire fiasco from the last two years and have sworn him off, though even those fans do admit that Superior Foes was a really good comic book.

*** As for Spencer, the divide seems to be between those that liked his Superior Foes and those that still recent Spencer for the whole Captain America / Secret Empire fiasco from the last two years and have sworn him off, though even those fans do admit that Superior Foes was a really good comic book.

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: While happy the heroes are back, everyone is really sick of massive status quo shifts and relaunches every single year or two.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Marvel seems to at least be attempting to restore the status quo. They're off to a good start by making Tony Stark and Odinson Iron Man and Thor again, respectively. The upcoming ''Avengers'' series also seems to have a more classic lineup. Said lineup includes newest Ghost Rider, Robbie Reyes, who fans have been clamoring for more of since his ongoing was cancelled.

* BrokenBase: Between people who are happy to see the classic characters return, and those ''utterly'' sick of relaunches at this point.
* HilariousInHindsight: A few days before the reveal of the ''Multiple Man'' title, writer Peter David responded to a Twitter comment about Madrox's status as "most certainly not dead". At first, this looks like a case of PAD applying WordOfStPaul on a character, however it looks like he knew a thing or two!

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Marvel seems to at least be attempting to restore the status quo. They're at off to a good start by making Tony Stark and Odinson Iron Man and Thor again, respectively. The upcoming ''Avengers'' series also seems to have a more classic lineup. Said lineup includes newest Ghost Rider, Robbie Reyes, who fans have been clamoring for more of since his ongoing was cancelled.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Marvel seems to at least be attempting to restore the status quo. They're at off to a good start by making Tony Stark and Odinson Iron Man and Thor again, respectively. The upcoming ''Avengers'' series also seems to have a more classic lineup. Said lineup includes Robbie Reyes, who fans have been clamouring for more of.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Marvel seems to at least be attempting to restore the status quo. They're at least off to a good start by making Tony Stark and Odinson Iron Man and Thor again, respectively. The upcoming ''Avengers'' series also seems to have a more classic lineup. Said lineup includes Robbie Reyes, who fans have been clamouring for more of.

* BrokenBase: Between people who are happy to see the classic characters return, and those ''utterly'' sick of relaunches at this point.