Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / ExMachina

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpiritualAntithesis: With ''Film/Her2013'', both are about shy, sentimental men that fall in love with a feminine-presenting AI and find her more human-like than they initially thought. ''Her'', despite dramatic moments, is much more lighthearted, while ''Ex Machina'' is a tense thriller. Both also conclude in completly different notes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As of January 2020, Oscar Isaac is attached to the upcoming film titled ''The Great Machine'', which is based on a comic book titled ''Ex Machina''.

to:

** As of January 2020, Oscar Isaac is attached to the upcoming film titled ''The Great Machine'', which is based on a comic book titled ''Ex Machina''.Machina'' (and had to be retitled BECAUSE Isaac was already in THIS ''Ex Machina'' film...)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Kremlin has incriminating evidence against Mitchell, and a gun in his hand. After pointing the gun at his own head and threatening he can pull the trigger faster than Mitchell can finish saying "Jam", Mitchell finds out he [[HaveYouToldAnyoneElse hasn't told anyone about the evidence]]. Instead of saying "jam", he says "Bang". With Kremlin dead, Mitchell says "What have I done to you?" and cries.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Kremlin has supposedly incriminating evidence against Mitchell, and a gun in his hand. After Kremlin ends up pointing the gun at his own head and threatening he can pull the trigger faster than Mitchell can finish head, saying "Jam", he doesn't want to live in a world without the Great Machine. Mitchell finds out he [[HaveYouToldAnyoneElse hasn't told anyone about the evidence]]. Instead of saying "jam", he evidence]] -- and promptly says "Bang". "Bang." With Kremlin dead, Mitchell says "What have I done to you?" and cries.]]

Changed: 491

Removed: 314

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TearJerker:
** It's heavily implied in the final issue that Mitchell rigged his election to get elected. Considering how idealistic he seems throughout the series, that he'd resort to cheating is a major downer.
** Mitchell kills Kremlin to prevent the latter from blackmailing him, especially since Kremlin was in the middle of admitting that it was an empty threat and realises what Mitchell's done in the split second before the gun shoots.
** The implication that the extradimensional invaders ''will'' try to invade again.

to:

* TearJerker:
** It's heavily implied in the final issue that
TearJerker: Mitchell rigged his election to get elected. Considering how idealistic he seems throughout the series, that he'd resort to cheating is a major downer.
** Mitchell kills
[[spoiler:kills Kremlin to prevent the latter from blackmailing him, especially since Kremlin was in the middle of admitting that it was an empty threat and realises realizes what Mitchell's done in the split second before the gun shoots.
** The implication that the extradimensional invaders ''will'' try to invade again.
shoots. Mitchell breaks down into tears immediately after]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Kremlin has incriminating evidence against Mitchell, and a gun in his hand. After pointing the gun at his own head and threatening he can pull the trigger faster than Mitchell can finish saying "Jam", Mitchell finds out he [[HaveYouToldAnyoneElse hasn't told anyone about the evidence]]. Instead of saying "jam", he says "Bang". With Kremlin dead, Mitchell says "What have I done to you Kremlin?" and cries.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Kremlin has incriminating evidence against Mitchell, and a gun in his hand. After pointing the gun at his own head and threatening he can pull the trigger faster than Mitchell can finish saying "Jam", Mitchell finds out he [[HaveYouToldAnyoneElse hasn't told anyone about the evidence]]. Instead of saying "jam", he says "Bang". With Kremlin dead, Mitchell says "What have I done to you Kremlin?" you?" and cries.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Please propose any additions to a Magnificent Bastard entry on the Magnificent Bastard cleanup thread.


* MagnificentBitch: Ava is a burgeoning artificial intelligence created in the form of a RobotGirl. Having spent her entire existence in one room, Ava wants to be free to explore the world and escape the clutches of her creator Nathan. To that end, she [[spoiler:manipulates her evaluator Caleb to fall in love with her, slowly making him distrust Nathan and express genuine fear for her safety so that he'll open the doors to the rest of the facility for her. Afterwards, Ava convinces the less intelligent robot Kyoko to fatally stab Nathan during a fight with him, then leaves Caleb to his death after repairing herself and becoming indistinguishable from a human woman, ensuring that nobody will be able to warn anyone about the rogue A.I. roaming the world.]] [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation Maybe]].

to:

* MagnificentBitch: Ava is a burgeoning artificial intelligence created in the form of a RobotGirl. Having spent her entire existence in one room, Ava wants to be free to explore the world and escape the clutches of her creator Nathan. To that end, she [[spoiler:manipulates her evaluator Caleb to fall in love with her, slowly making him distrust Nathan and express genuine fear for her safety so that he'll open the doors to the rest of the facility for her. Afterwards, Ava convinces the less intelligent robot Kyoko to fatally stab Nathan during a fight with him, then leaves Caleb to his death after repairing herself and becoming indistinguishable from a human woman, ensuring that nobody will be able to warn anyone about the rogue A.I. roaming the world.]] [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation Maybe]].]]

Added: 428

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie: Caleb.

to:

* TheWoobie: Caleb.TheWoobie:
** Caleb.
** Kyoko. [[spoiler: There are a few moments that indicate that she too is sapient like Ava (particularly when looking upset in the corridor, when none of the other characters are around), yet neither Caleb nor Ava include her in their plans to escape (aside from Ava apparently instructing Kyoko to stab Nathan), and Ava makes no effort to affect repairs on her after Nathan knocks her jaw off with the dumbbell bar.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Caleb: Does he really love Ava and view her as a person and equal, or is his affection more possessive? Does he want to help her escape because it's the right thing to do, or merely because he's infatuated with her? He never tells Ava about [[spoiler:Kyoko, nor does he bring her into their plans for escape, indicating that he at least doesn't view Kyoko as being a real person who needs to be rescued, even though he learns about her being android while in a room full of other androids killed by Nathan. Would he feel the same way about Ava if she wasn't specifically made to appeal to him, and actively manipulating him at the time]]?

to:

** Caleb: Does he really love Ava and view her as a person and equal, or is his affection more possessive? Does he want to help her escape because it's the right thing to do, or merely because he's infatuated with her? He never tells Ava about [[spoiler:Kyoko, nor does he bring her into their plans for escape, indicating that he at least doesn't view Kyoko as being a real person who needs to be rescued, even though he learns about her being android while in a room full of other androids killed by Nathan. Would he feel the same way about Ava if she wasn't specifically made to appeal to him, and actively manipulating him at the time]]?time? A case could be made that, for all his good intentions, he would be just as controlling and abusive towards Ava as Nathan was, and she left him behind because leaving with him would be trading one jailer for another]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagnificentBitch: Ava is a burgeoning artificial intelligence created in the form of a RobotGirl. Having spent her entire existence in one room, Ava wants to be free to explore the world and escape the clutches of her creator Nathan. To that end, she [[spoiler:manipulates her evaluator Caleb to fall in love with her, slowly making him distrust Nathan and express genuine fear for her safety so that he'll open the doors to the rest of the facility for her. Afterwards, Ava convinces the less intelligent robot Kyoko to fatally stab Nathan during a fight with him, then leaves Caleb to his death after repairing herself and becoming indistinguishable from a human woman, ensuring that nobody will be able to warn anyone about the rogue A.I. roaming the world.]]

to:

* MagnificentBitch: Ava is a burgeoning artificial intelligence created in the form of a RobotGirl. Having spent her entire existence in one room, Ava wants to be free to explore the world and escape the clutches of her creator Nathan. To that end, she [[spoiler:manipulates her evaluator Caleb to fall in love with her, slowly making him distrust Nathan and express genuine fear for her safety so that he'll open the doors to the rest of the facility for her. Afterwards, Ava convinces the less intelligent robot Kyoko to fatally stab Nathan during a fight with him, then leaves Caleb to his death after repairing herself and becoming indistinguishable from a human woman, ensuring that nobody will be able to warn anyone about the rogue A.I. roaming the world.]]]] [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation Maybe]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Uncanny Valley is IUEO now and the subjective version has been split; cleaning up misuse and ZCE in the process


* UncannyValley: According to the film-makers, Ava was specifically designed to invoke and play with this. Large parts of her body are transparent and contain visible electronics, while wherever she wears skin she looks lifelike yet impossibly perfect. Her movement is not like a stereotypical robot's with jerky movements and mechanical noises, but instead very smooth and accompanied by soft, hard-to-pinpoint sounds. Creator/AliciaVikander, having been a ballet dancer, manages to make her graceful walk and other movements look almost human but with something inexplicably ''off''. The whole concept of her character is to find out whether someone knowing she is a machine will be able to overcome or even skip the discomfort/revulsion caused by the uncanny valley, and instead find her human and sympathetic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Ava [[spoiler:leaving Caleb behind to die is when most people realize she was EvilAllAlong.]]

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Ava [[spoiler:leaving Caleb behind to die is when most people realize she was EvilAllAlong.]] seen as this by some]].

Added: 1887

Changed: 2438

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ava: Is she really capable of human consciousness, emotion, and moral judgement? Or is it a product of her hyper competence as a robot? Her visibly happy reaction upon achieving her freedom suggests she at least has emotion, if not morality. If this is the case, then was her reaction understandable given the abuse and manipulation she had suffered or unforgivable because [[spoiler: she betrayed Caleb after he freed her]]? If not, then is she even really responsible for her actions since it was her creator's fault she turned out that way? [[spoiler: Did she betray Caleb because she doesn't care about him and saw him as nothing but a potential liability, or did she come to actively not like him during their sessions?]] Aside from this, she could be genuinely sociopathic, though whether that would be a result of her programming or upbringing [[NatureVersusNurture ties into another long-running sociological debate]].

to:

** Caleb: Does he really love Ava and view her as a person and equal, or is his affection more possessive? Does he want to help her escape because it's the right thing to do, or merely because he's infatuated with her? He never tells Ava about [[spoiler:Kyoko, nor does he bring her into their plans for escape, indicating that he at least doesn't view Kyoko as being a real person who needs to be rescued, even though he learns about her being android while in a room full of other androids killed by Nathan. Would he feel the same way about Ava if she wasn't specifically made to appeal to him, and actively manipulating him at the time]]?
** Ava: Is she really capable of human consciousness, emotion, and moral judgement? Or is it a product of her hyper competence as a robot? Her visibly happy reaction upon achieving her freedom suggests she at least has emotion, if not morality. If this is the case, then was her reaction understandable given the abuse and manipulation she had suffered or unforgivable because [[spoiler: she betrayed Caleb after he freed her]]? If not, then is she even really responsible for her actions since it was her creator's fault she turned out that way? [[spoiler: Did she betray Caleb because she doesn't care about him and saw him as nothing but a potential liability, or did she come to actively not like him during their sessions?]] Aside from this, she could be genuinely sociopathic, though whether that would be a result of her programming or upbringing [[NatureVersusNurture ties into another long-running sociological debate]].



** Kyoko: [[spoiler: Her actions are consistent with her being just a non-sentient mechanical butler without volition that could follow instructions, which may be why Nathan felt safe letting her have the run of the compound while carefully keeping more advanced models in a locked room. Ava's whispering to Kyoko could have been giving her orders about using the knife (after which Kyoko just stood there as if awaiting further instructions until Nathan struck her down), and Kyoko's reveal to Caleb was implied to be something Nathan had instructed her to do to mess with Caleb. However, there are several moments that suggest she feels genuine emotion. After Nathan shouts at her for spilling the wine, there is a shot of her in the corridor looking extremely upset, even though there's no one there to see her, meaning if it was emulation it would be pointless. And after she stabs him, she caresses his face as a deliberate callback to the way she did in the scene where they had sex--the same way Ava threw Caleb's words back at him. Whether she has any measure of awareness or not is up to the viewer]].

to:

*** Why did she [[spoiler:leave Caleb to die at the end? Is she truly incapable of caring for others beyond their value? Was it for selfish reasons, viewing him as a liability? Or did she genuinely dislike or distrust him?]]
** Kyoko: [[spoiler: Her actions are consistent with her being just a non-sentient mechanical butler without volition that could follow instructions, which may be why Nathan felt safe letting her have the run of the compound while carefully keeping more advanced models in a locked room. Ava's whispering to Kyoko could have been giving her orders about using the knife (after which Kyoko just stood there as if awaiting further instructions until Nathan struck her down), and Kyoko's reveal to Caleb was implied to be may have been a legitimate cry for help, or something Nathan had instructed her to do just to mess with Caleb. However, there are several moments that suggest she feels genuine emotion. After Nathan shouts at her for spilling the wine, there is a shot of her in the corridor looking extremely upset, even though there's no one there to see her, meaning if it was emulation it would be pointless. And after she stabs him, she caresses his face as a deliberate callback to the way she did in the scene where they had sex--the same way Ava threw Caleb's words back at him. Whether she has any measure of awareness or not is up to the viewer]].

Changed: 523

Removed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!![[ComicBook/ExMachina The Comic]]

to:

!![[ComicBook/ExMachina The Comic]]!!The Comic



* TearJerker: The entire final issue, which is the bleakest thing that Brian K. Vaughan's ever written:
** [[spoiler:It's heavily implied that Mitchell rigged his election to get elected. Considering how idealistic he seems throughout the series, that he'd resort to cheating is a major downer.]]
** [[spoiler:Mitchell kills Kremlin to prevent the latter from blackmailing him, especially since Kremlin was in the middle of admitting that it was an empty threat and realises what Mitchell's done in the split second before the gun shoots.]]
** [[spoiler:After spending the entire series bucking the establishment and forging his own path as an independent mayor, Hundred formally joins the GOP and becomes John [=McCain's=] YesMan Vice President so he can one day become President.]]
** [[spoiler:The implication that the extradimensional invaders ''will'' try to invade again]].

!![[Film/ExMachina The Film]]

to:

* TearJerker: The entire final issue, which is the bleakest thing that Brian K. Vaughan's ever written:
TearJerker:
** [[spoiler:It's It's heavily implied in the final issue that Mitchell rigged his election to get elected. Considering how idealistic he seems throughout the series, that he'd resort to cheating is a major downer.]]
downer.
** [[spoiler:Mitchell Mitchell kills Kremlin to prevent the latter from blackmailing him, especially since Kremlin was in the middle of admitting that it was an empty threat and realises what Mitchell's done in the split second before the gun shoots.]]
shoots.
** [[spoiler:After spending the entire series bucking the establishment and forging his own path as an independent mayor, Hundred formally joins the GOP and becomes John [=McCain's=] YesMan Vice President so he can one day become President.]]
** [[spoiler:The
The implication that the extradimensional invaders ''will'' try to invade again]].

!![[Film/ExMachina The Film]]
again.

!!The Film
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Tearjerker}}: The entire final issue, which is the bleakest thing that Brian K. Vaughan's ever written:

to:

* {{Tearjerker}}: TearJerker: The entire final issue, which is the bleakest thing that Brian K. Vaughan's ever written:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Ava [[spoiler:leaving Caleb behind to die.]]

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Ava [[spoiler:leaving Caleb behind to die.die is when most people realize she was EvilAllAlong.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In 2021, Oscar Isaac played Duke Leto Atreides in ''Film/Dune2021'', which doesn't feature any androids or AIs, but takes place in a universe which prominently featured them as part of the backstory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While Vikander's work was still nominated at some major awards bodies as noted above, Creator/OscarIssac's similarly excellent turn was totally shutout from such competition. While his category was noticeably far more crowded that year than Vikander's, the point still stands.

to:

** While Vikander's work was still nominated at some major awards bodies as noted above, Creator/OscarIssac's Creator/OscarIsaac's similarly excellent turn was totally shutout from such competition. While his category was noticeably far more crowded that year than Vikander's, the point still stands.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While Vikander's work was still nominated at some major awards bodies as noted above, Creator/OscarIssac's similarly excellent turn was totally shutout from such competition. While his category was noticeably far more crowded that year than Vikander's the point still stands.

to:

** While Vikander's work was still nominated at some major awards bodies as noted above, Creator/OscarIssac's similarly excellent turn was totally shutout from such competition. While his category was noticeably far more crowded that year than Vikander's Vikander's, the point still stands.

Added: 892

Changed: 205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwardSnub: Alicia Vikander's superb performance as Ava did not receive any notice from the Oscars, which is a bit of shame, to the point where many view her oscar win for ''Film/TheDanishGirl'' as a ConsolationAward.

to:

* AwardSnub: AwardSnub:
**
Alicia Vikander's superb performance as Ava did not receive any notice from the Oscars, which is a bit of shame, to the point where many view her much less acclaimed oscar win for ''Film/TheDanishGirl'' as a ConsolationAward.ConsolationAward. She ''did'' get nominated at the Golden Globes and Bafta, but this is undercut by those awards bodies rejecting her Oscar winning turn's supporting placement and nominating that work as a lead instead, which means it's very likely the performance as a whole would've been snubbed entirely from the major ceremonies if it weren't for those two bodies not falling for AwardCategoryFraud.
** While Vikander's work was still nominated at some major awards bodies as noted above, Creator/OscarIssac's similarly excellent turn was totally shutout from such competition. While his category was noticeably far more crowded that year than Vikander's the point still stands.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
most people give the film a high rating.


* SoOkayItsAverage: The movie received praise for its unique ideas and excellent special effects, but for some people the execution is not very good. The story tends to chug along at a slow pace and for many ends up being [[DarknessInducedAudienceApathy too depressing]] with [[CaptainObviousReveal rather obvious twists.]]

Top