History YMMV / EdEddNEddyS5E19SmileForTheEd

* KarmicOverkill: Eddy is humiliated emotionally, physically and publicly, then gets punishment for things he didn't even do...all because he wanted to have a good photo and move into his brother's old room.

* NeverLiveItDown: This episode is this to Kevin and the kids, as quite a few fans have a hard time forgiving them due to the events of this episode.

* RealismInducedHorror: The abuse Eddy experiences in this episode isn't all that dissimilar from school bullying in real life, especially [[AdultsAreUseless the absence of professional help]].

* RealismInducedHorror: The abuse Eddy experiences in this episode isn't all that dissimilar from school bullying in real-life, especially with [[AdultsAreUseless the absence of professional help]].

* RealismInducedHorror: The abuse Eddy experiences in this episode isn't all that dissimilar from school bullying in real-life, especially given [[AdultsAreUseless the absence of professional help]].

* RealismInducedHorror: The bullying Eddy endures in this episode isn't much different than school bullying in real-life, especially with the [[AdultsAreUseless lack of support from the staff]].

* HarsherInHindsight: While many already found the episode quite uneasy to sit through, it has become ''much'' worse in later years with numerous cases of people dying as a result of bullying, usually from [[DrivenToSuicide suicide]]. There are also plenty of school systems that not only refuse to take action but instead punish the victim over something trivial or unrelated.

* HarsherInHindsight: While many already found the episode quite uneasy to sit through, it has become ''much'' worse in later years with numerous cases of people dying as a result of bullying, usually from [[DrivenToSuicide committing suicide]]. There are also plenty of school systems that not only refuse to take action but instead punish the victim over something trivial or unrelated.

* HarsherInHindsight: While many already found the episode quite uneasy to sit through, it has become ''much'' worse in later years with numerous cases of people dying as a result of bullying, usually from committing suicide. There are also plenty of school systems that not only refuse to take action but instead punish the victim over something trivial or unrelated.

* HarsherInHindsight: While many already found the episode uneasy to sit through, it has become ''much'' worse in later years with numerous cases of students dying as a result of bullying, usually from suicide. There are also plenty of school systems that not only refuse to take action but instead punish the victim over something trivial or unrelated.

* BrokenBase: One of the most controversial episodes. Many hate it because Eddy gets [[KidsAreCruel bullied by the kids]] and [[SelectiveEnforcement punished]] [[MisplacedRetribution over something he didn't do]]. To others, however, it's not completely terrible, since the Eds work together and are genuinely good friends to each other, which is pretty rare in season 5, where their friendship is [[WithFriendsLikeThese questionable at best]] in many episodes. There's also the BittersweetEnding which makes Eddy [[ThrowTheDogABone hopeful again]] instead of the usual DownerEnding with the Eds in pain.

* HarsherInHindsight: While many already found the episode uneasy to sit through, it has become ''much'' worse in later years where there have been numerous cases of students dying as a result of bullying, usually from suicide. There are also plenty of school systems that not only refuse to take action but instead punish the victim over something trivial or unrelated.

* BrokenBase: One of the most controversial episodes. Many hate it because KidsAreCruel and Eddy gets bullied by the kids, but to others it's not completely terrible, since the Eds work together and are genuinely good friends to each other, which is pretty rare in season 5, where their friendship is [[WithFriendsLikeThese questionable at best]] in many episodes. There's also the BittersweetEnding which makes Eddy [[ThrowTheDogABone hopeful again]] instead of the usual DownerEnding with the Eds in pain.

* HarsherInHindsight: While many already found the episode uneasy to sit through, it has become ''much'' worse in later years where numerous students in real-life have died as a result of bullying, usually from committing suicide. There are also plenty of school systems that not only refuse to take action but instead punish the victim over something trivial or unrelated.

* HarsherInHindsight: While many already found the episode uneasy to sit through, it has become even worse in later years where numerous students in real-life have died as a result of bullying, usually from committing suicide. There are also plenty of school systems that not only refuse to take action but instead punish the victim over something trivial or unrelated.

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Normally Nazz is the nice girl among the kids but despite this she still joined in on that prank on Eddy that is obviously causing him a panic attack. Did she do this because the other kids (especially Kevin) were doing it or because she was too stupid to realize what she’s REALLY doing?

* AngstAversion: This episode is so mean-spirited, even by the show's standards, that many fans find it nearly impossible to watch. In fact, a [=YouTuber=] named [[https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC1-Sc87OcXzZcblFIMbZnMA Jem Reviews]] stated that after he watched the episode, he had to get therapy due to the cruelty.

* JerkassWoobie: Eddy. All he wanted was a photo taken for his brother's room, and he not only gets humiliated by [[{{Jerkass}} Ke]][[KarmaHoudini vin]], but he [[SelectiveEnforcement got detention]] for what Kevin did (printing the ruined photo all over school), and Edd too (impersonation of the principal).

* TheWoobie: Eddy. All he wanted was a photo taken for his brother's room, and he not only gets humiliated by [[{{Jerkass}} Ke]][[KarmaHoudini vin]], but he [[SelectiveEnforcement got detention]] for what Kevin did (printing the ruined photo all over school), and Edd too (impersonation of the principal).