Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / DoctorWhoS3E4TheDaleksMasterPlan

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Despite being a twelve-parter, this is one of the few fans think is the most ambitious as it shows how ruthless the Daleks are as they want to destroy life forms that aren't like them outside of their home planet. While the next two Dalek stories in Throughton's run are still beloved by fans, the stories during Pertwee's run don't really match up to what happened in the 1960s and it won't be until Davros shows up in Ton Baker's first season.

to:

* ToughActToFollow: Despite being a twelve-parter, this is one of the few fans think is the most ambitious as it shows how ruthless the Daleks are as they want to destroy life forms that aren't like them outside of their home planet. While the next two Dalek stories in Throughton's run are still beloved by fans, the stories during Pertwee's run don't really match up to what happened in the 1960s and it won't be until Davros shows up in Ton Baker's first season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Despite being a twelve-parter, this is one of the few fans think is the most ambitious as it shows how ruthless the Daleks are as they want to destroy life forms that aren't like them outside of their home planet. While the next two Dalek stories in Throughton's run are still beloved by fans, the stories during Pertwee's run don't really match up to what happened in the 1960s and it won't be until Davros shows up in Ton Baker's first season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon ageing the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.

to:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 16 years before [[Recap/DoctorWhoS19E6Earthshock another companion was killed off.off]]. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon ageing the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sara Kingdom, a badass space mercenary who [[TheUnfettered killed her own brother in pursuit of her goals]], then began questioning everything she'd ever learned when the Doctor's philosophy began to get to her. She even travels with the Doctor in the TARDIS for several months in a TimeSkip between episodes. She gets killed off in a slightly StupidSacrifice at the end of the story. The production team actually were open to the idea of keeping her as an ongoing character, but Creator/JeanMarsh didn't want to commit to the series full-time.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sara Kingdom, a badass space mercenary who [[TheUnfettered killed her own brother in pursuit of her goals]], then began questioning everything she'd ever learned when the Doctor's philosophy began to get to her. She If AudioPlay/BigFinishDoctorWho is to be believed, she even travels travelled with the Doctor in the TARDIS for several months in a TimeSkip between episodes. She gets killed off in a slightly StupidSacrifice at the end of the story. The production team actually were open to the idea of keeping her as an ongoing character, but Creator/JeanMarsh didn't want to commit to the series full-time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Going further, the three episode "Meddling Monk" arc in Episodes 8-10 is also largely irrelevant to the overall plot. It has been pointed out many times that it would be incredibly easy to cut Episodes 7-10 out of the story by simply having the Doctor give back the real taranium core instead of a fake one in Episode 6, which would leave the plot in exactly the same place as it ended up being at the end of Episode 10, when the Doctor finally does give back the real core. This would trim the story down to an eight-parter in a stroke.

to:

** Going further, the three episode "Meddling Monk" arc in Episodes 8-10 is also largely irrelevant to the overall plot. It has been pointed out many times that it would be incredibly easy to cut Episodes 7-10 out of the story by simply having the Doctor give back the real taranium core instead of a fake one in Episode 6, which would leave the plot in exactly the same place as it ended up being at the end of Episode 10, when the Doctor finally does ''does'' give back the real core. This would trim the story down to an eight-parter in a stroke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkhorse: Sara Kingdom, one of the best companions that never were.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Sara Kingdom, often regarded as one of the best companions that never were.

Changed: 345

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: The first ever companion deaths in the series are encountered- that of Sara Kingdom and Katarina. Is the Doctor depressed about this? Broken, that after taking up Barbara and Ian so long ago to travel in space in time, that a human died in his helpless hands? No. He shakes his head, says goodbye, and moves on. Averted by Steven, however, who is clearly distraught at their deaths (as well as that of Bret Vyon) despite only knowing them briefly, and calls out the Doctor on his reaction. Sara Kingdom also appears to get over the fact that she killed her own brother very quickly.

to:

* AngstWhatAngst: The first ever companion deaths in the series are encountered- that of Sara Kingdom and Katarina. Is the Doctor depressed about this? Broken, that after taking up Barbara and Ian so long ago to travel in space in time, that a human died in his helpless hands? No. He shakes his head, says goodbye, and moves on. Averted by Steven, however, who is clearly distraught at their deaths (as well as that of Bret Vyon) despite only knowing them briefly, and calls out the Doctor on his reaction. Sara Kingdom also appears to get over the fact that she killed her own brother very quickly. Averted by Steven, however, who is clearly distraught at Karatina, Bret and Sara's deaths despite only knowing them briefly, and calls out the Doctor on his reaction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: The first ever companion deaths in the series are encountered- that of Sara Kingdom and Katarina. Is the Doctor depressed about this? Broken, that after taking up Barbara and Ian so long ago to travel in space in time, that a human died in his helpless hands? No. He shakes his head, says goodbye, and moves on. Averted by Steven, however, who is clearly distraught at their deaths (as well as that of Bret Vyon) despite only knowing them briefly, and calls out the Doctor on his reaction.

to:

* AngstWhatAngst: The first ever companion deaths in the series are encountered- that of Sara Kingdom and Katarina. Is the Doctor depressed about this? Broken, that after taking up Barbara and Ian so long ago to travel in space in time, that a human died in his helpless hands? No. He shakes his head, says goodbye, and moves on. Averted by Steven, however, who is clearly distraught at their deaths (as well as that of Bret Vyon) despite only knowing them briefly, and calls out the Doctor on his reaction. Sara Kingdom also appears to get over the fact that she killed her own brother very quickly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: The Doctor is unfamiliar with cricket. [[Creator/PeterDavison Four incarnations later...]]

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: The Doctor is unfamiliar with cricket. [[Creator/PeterDavison [[Recap/DoctorWhoS19E5BlackOrchid Four incarnations later...]]



* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon aging the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.

to:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon aging ageing the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Going further, the three episode "Meddling Monk" arc in Episodes 8-10 is also largely irrelevant to the overall plot. It has been pointed out many times that it would be incredibly easy to cut Rpisodes 7-10 out of the story by simply having the Doctor give back the real taranium core instead of a fake one in Episode 6, which would leave the plot in exactly the same place as it ended up being at the end of Episode 10, when the Doctor finally does give back the real core. This would trim the story down to an eight-parter in a stroke.

to:

** Going further, the three episode "Meddling Monk" arc in Episodes 8-10 is also largely irrelevant to the overall plot. It has been pointed out many times that it would be incredibly easy to cut Rpisodes Episodes 7-10 out of the story by simply having the Doctor give back the real taranium core instead of a fake one in Episode 6, which would leave the plot in exactly the same place as it ended up being at the end of Episode 10, when the Doctor finally does give back the real core. This would trim the story down to an eight-parter in a stroke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Going further, the three episode "Meddling Monk" arc in Episodes 8-10 is also largely irrelevant to the overall plot. It has been pointed out many times that it would be incredibly easy to cut Rpisodes 7-10 out of the story by simply having the Doctor give back the real taranium core instead of a fake one in Episode 6, which would leave the plot in exactly the same place as it ended up being at the end of Episode 10. This would trim the story down to an eight-parter in a stroke.

to:

** Going further, the three episode "Meddling Monk" arc in Episodes 8-10 is also largely irrelevant to the overall plot. It has been pointed out many times that it would be incredibly easy to cut Rpisodes 7-10 out of the story by simply having the Doctor give back the real taranium core instead of a fake one in Episode 6, which would leave the plot in exactly the same place as it ended up being at the end of Episode 10.10, when the Doctor finally does give back the real core. This would trim the story down to an eight-parter in a stroke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Padding: This serial required lost of it to fill the requisite twelve episodes.

to:

* Padding: {{Padding}}: This serial required lost lots of it to fill the requisite twelve episodes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Padding: This serial required lost of it to fill the requisite twelve episodes.
** Episode Seven ("The Feast of Steven") was very deliberately intended as this. Since it was scheduled to be broadcast on Christmas Day, when it was assumed that many viewers would not be tuning in, the episode was deliberately written to not advance the plot at all, so viewers who missed it could come back the following week and not be lost.
** Going further, the three episode "Meddling Monk" arc in Episodes 8-10 is also largely irrelevant to the overall plot. It has been pointed out many times that it would be incredibly easy to cut Rpisodes 7-10 out of the story by simply having the Doctor give back the real taranium core instead of a fake one in Episode 6, which would leave the plot in exactly the same place as it ended up being at the end of Episode 10. This would trim the story down to an eight-parter in a stroke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SignatureScene: Ironically, the most famous scene in this epic Dalek story does not involve the Daleks at all and comes from the episode that has no relation to the rest of the serial. It is,of course, The First Doctor turning directly to camera to wish the viewers a Happy Christmas at the end of "The Feast of Steven".

to:

* SignatureScene: Ironically, the most famous scene in this epic Dalek story does not involve the Daleks at all and comes from the episode that has no relation to the rest of the serial. It is,of is, of course, The First the Doctor turning directly to camera to wish the viewers a Happy Christmas at the end of "The Feast of Steven".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SignatureScene: Ironically, the most famous scene in this epic Dalek story does not involve the Daleks at all and comes from the episode that has no relation to the rest of the serial. It is,of course, The First Doctor turning directly to camera to wish the viewers a Happy Christmas at the end of "The Feast of Steven".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: The first ever companion deaths in the series are encountered- that of Sara Kingdom and Katarina. Is the Doctor depressed about this? Broken, that after taking up Barbara and Ian so long ago to travel in space in time, that a human died in his helpless hands? No. He shakes his head, says goodbye, and moves on.

to:

* AngstWhatAngst: The first ever companion deaths in the series are encountered- that of Sara Kingdom and Katarina. Is the Doctor depressed about this? Broken, that after taking up Barbara and Ian so long ago to travel in space in time, that a human died in his helpless hands? No. He shakes his head, says goodbye, and moves on. Averted by Steven, however, who is clearly distraught at their deaths (as well as that of Bret Vyon) despite only knowing them briefly, and calls out the Doctor on his reaction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon ageing the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.

to:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon ageing aging the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sara Kingdom, a badass space mercenary who [[TheUnfettered killed her own brother in pursuit of her goals]], then began questioning everything she'd ever learned when the Doctor's philosophy began to get to her. She even travels with the Doctor in the TARDIS for several months in a TimeSkip between episodes. She gets killed off in a slightly StupidSacrifice at the end of the story. The production team actually were open to the idea of keeping her as an ongoing character, but Jean Marsh didn't want to commit to the series full-time.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sara Kingdom, a badass space mercenary who [[TheUnfettered killed her own brother in pursuit of her goals]], then began questioning everything she'd ever learned when the Doctor's philosophy began to get to her. She even travels with the Doctor in the TARDIS for several months in a TimeSkip between episodes. She gets killed off in a slightly StupidSacrifice at the end of the story. The production team actually were open to the idea of keeping her as an ongoing character, but Jean Marsh Creator/JeanMarsh didn't want to commit to the series full-time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The Daleks marching through the jungle with flamethrower torches in are utterly beautiful.

to:

* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The Daleks marching through the jungle with flamethrower torches in are utterly beautiful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: The first ever companion deaths in the series are encountered- that of Sara Kingdom and Katarina. Is the Doctor depressed about this? Broken, that after taking up Barbara and Ian so long ago to travel in space in time, that a human died in his helpless hands? No. He shakes his head, says goodbye, and moves on.



* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon ageing the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.

to:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon ageing the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.Guardian}}s.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HilariousInHindsight: The Doctor is unfamiliar with cricket. [[Creator/PeterDavison Four incarnations later...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BiggedLippedAlligatorMoment: "The Feast of Steven" has our heroes picked up by police on Christmas, getting split up on a RoaringTwenties movie set, and finally breaking the fourth wall. It should perhaps be noted that there was a good reason for this. The episode was broadcast on Christmas Day and the production team worried people might not bother tuning in to watch. By making the episode irrelevant to the plot of the complete serial as a whole, they didn't have to worry about people tuning back in the week after and not having a clue what was going on. The BLAM aspect is further emphasized when one realizes that the character of Sara Kingdom, featured in the silly goings-on in the episode, ''killed her own brother'' only a couple of weeks earlier and is supposed to be working through the guilt related to this.

to:

* BiggedLippedAlligatorMoment: BigLippedAlligatorMoment: "The Feast of Steven" has our heroes picked up by police on Christmas, getting split up on a RoaringTwenties movie set, and finally breaking the fourth wall. It should perhaps be noted that there was a good reason for this. The episode was broadcast on Christmas Day and the production team worried people might not bother tuning in to watch. By making the episode irrelevant to the plot of the complete serial as a whole, they didn't have to worry about people tuning back in the week after and not having a clue what was going on. The BLAM aspect is further emphasized when one realizes that the character of Sara Kingdom, featured in the silly goings-on in the episode, ''killed her own brother'' only a couple of weeks earlier and is supposed to be working through the guilt related to this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BiggedLippedAlligatorMoment: "The Feast of Steven" has our heroes picked up by police on Christmas, getting split up on a RoaringTwenties movie set, and finally breaking the fourth wall. It should perhaps be noted that there was a good reason for this. The episode was broadcast on Christmas Day and the production team worried people might not bother tuning in to watch. By making the episode irrelevant to the plot of the complete serial as a whole, they didn't have to worry about people tuning back in the week after and not having a clue what was going on. The BLAM aspect is further emphasized when one realizes that the character of Sara Kingdom, featured in the silly goings-on in the episode, ''killed her own brother'' only a couple of weeks earlier and is supposed to be working through the guilt related to this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sara Kingdom, a badass space mercenary who [[TheUnfettered killed her own brother in pursuit of her goals]], then began questioning everything she'd ever learned when the Doctor's philosophy began to get to her. She even travels with the Doctor in the TARDIS for several months in a TimeSkip between episodes. She gets killed off in a slightly StupidSacrifice at the end of the story.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sara Kingdom, a badass space mercenary who [[TheUnfettered killed her own brother in pursuit of her goals]], then began questioning everything she'd ever learned when the Doctor's philosophy began to get to her. She even travels with the Doctor in the TARDIS for several months in a TimeSkip between episodes. She gets killed off in a slightly StupidSacrifice at the end of the story. The production team actually were open to the idea of keeping her as an ongoing character, but Jean Marsh didn't want to commit to the series full-time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ValuesDissonance: The Doctor makes a rather racist comment as a punchline to a comedy sequence that would absolutely ''never'' be allowed on the screen today:
-->This place is a madhouse, it's all full of Arabs! Come on, let's go.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sara Kingdom, a badass space mercenary who [[TheUnfettered killed her own brother in pursuit of her goals]], then began questioning everything she'd ever learned when the Doctor's philosophy began to get to her. She even travels with the Doctor in the TARDIS for several months in a TimeSkip between episodes. She gets killed off in a slightly StupidSacrifice at the end of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Sara Kingdom, one of the best companions that never were.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off.

to:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off. The story ending with a planet-destroying weapon ageing the Doctor's (temporary) companion into a decomposed pile of dust also didn't do much to placate the {{Moral Guardian}}s.

Added: 517

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The Daleks marching through the jungle with flamethrower torches in are utterly beautiful

to:

* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The Daleks marching through the jungle with flamethrower torches in are utterly beautifulbeautiful.
* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: At the time, ''Doctor Who'' was considered a series for kids. As such, the decision to kill off not one but two ongoing characters - one of whom earlier in the story is shown murdering ''her own brother'' - in an extremely complex (for its day) storyline that was three times longer than the average story, made this one of the more controversial stories of the Classic Era, an experiment that would never again be repeated, and it would be 18 years before another companion was killed off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BizarroEpisode: "The Feast of Steven". Our heroes have a chase through Hollywood in the 1920s, get arrested by police in the 1960s, and end up BreakingTheFourthWall.
* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The Daleks marching through the jungle with flamethrower torches in are utterly beautiful

Top