Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / DoctorWhoPrisonersOfTime

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RecycledScript: Recycles some unused ideas. #6 the Master is using Autons, which was one of the ideas for Season 23. Also the motivation for the villain is partly this: [[spoiler:In an early draft of "The Long Game", Adam tried to take technology from the future to cure his dying father. Here he is angry with the Doctor for erasing future technology that could have saved his mother.]]

to:

* RecycledScript: Recycles some unused ideas. #6 the Master is using Autons, which was one of the ideas for Season 23. Also the motivation for the villain is partly this: [[spoiler:In an early draft of "The "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS27E7TheLongGame The Long Game", Game]]", Adam tried to take technology from the future to cure his dying father. Here he is angry with the Doctor for erasing future technology that could have saved his mother.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarthWiki/AwesomeMoments: Admittedly, Adam assaulting the Ninth Doctor when he shows NoSympathy towards his motivation and tells Adam he's "obsessed with a life he doesn't deserve"

to:

* DarthWiki/AwesomeMoments: Admittedly, Adam [[spoiler: Adam]] assaulting the Ninth Doctor when he shows NoSympathy towards his motivation plight in losing his mother and becoming a social recluse and tells Adam [[spoiler: Adam]] he's "obsessed with a life he doesn't deserve"deserve".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeMoments: Admittedly, Adam assaulting the Ninth Doctor when he shows NoSympathy towards his motivation and tells Adam he's "obsessed with a life he doesn't deserve"

to:

* AwesomeMoments: DarthWiki/AwesomeMoments: Admittedly, Adam assaulting the Ninth Doctor when he shows NoSympathy towards his motivation and tells Adam he's "obsessed with a life he doesn't deserve"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AwesomeMoments: Admittedly, Adam assaulting the Ninth Doctor when he shows NoSympathy towards his motivation and tells Adam he's "obsessed with a life he doesn't deserve"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* WhatAnIdiot:
** In his attempts to gain revenge on the Doctor, [[spoiler: Adam]] uses a vast amount of resources to find and recruit others the Doctor has "wronged". To this end, he revives and recruits the Animus...and plants it in the Victorian Era, where, if the Doctor failed, the Animus would have conquered Earth and rewritten his own history. Likewise, if he knew the Doctor's history, then how did he expect employing ''the Master'' would turn out well for him?
*** Could be explained as Adam over-estimating his own research; he may have just done enough to justify his own hatred of the Doctor without fully researching details such as what the Master was truly capable of.
** The Fifth Doctor gets this too, for landing, recharging, and exiting his TARDIS in the middle of ''an active battlefield''. [[IdiotBall Considering that Five knows how to pilot his TARDIS, and he had three companions with him, why didn't he just park it somewhere safe, or take provisions to keep them safe?]]
** The Overseers. They have highly advanced technology, have the human population under their control as organ donars to sustain their bodies, and a ''single'' scratch is enough to kill one of them...and yet they don't have any form of protection against harm. When one's rule over the planet is defeated by merely telling the people of such a weakness, one has to wonder why they never invested in PoweredArmor of any description.
*** May be justified by their sheer arrogance, mixed in with a philosophy of feigning power so that the humans never suspected just how weak they were.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Could be explained as Adam over-estimating his own research; he may have just done enough to justify his own hatred of the Doctor without fully researching details such as what the Master was truly capable of.


Added DiffLines:

*** May be justified by their sheer arrogance, mixed in with a philosophy of feigning power so that the humans never suspected just how weak they were.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: The Eleventh Doctor abruptly meets Rory and Amy when Frobisher releases all of the imprisoned companions. All he gives them is a jolly Hello, [[Recap/DoctorWho2012CSTheSnowmen rather undercutting the depression he went through from their passing]] (although potentially justified given the scale of the immediate threat).

to:

* AngstWhatAngst: The Eleventh Doctor abruptly meets Rory and Amy when Frobisher releases all of the imprisoned companions. All he gives them is a jolly Hello, "hello", [[Recap/DoctorWho2012CSTheSnowmen rather undercutting the depression he went through from their passing]] (although potentially justified given the scale of the immediate threat).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: The Eleventh Doctor abruptly meets Rory and Amy when Frobisher releases all of the imprisoned companions. All he gives them is a jolly Hello, [[Recap/DoctorWho2012CSTheSnowmen rather undercutting the depression he went through from their passing]].

to:

* AngstWhatAngst: The Eleventh Doctor abruptly meets Rory and Amy when Frobisher releases all of the imprisoned companions. All he gives them is a jolly Hello, [[Recap/DoctorWho2012CSTheSnowmen rather undercutting the depression he went through from their passing]].passing]] (although potentially justified given the scale of the immediate threat).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Overseers. They have highly advanced technology, have the human population under their control as organ donars to sustain their bodies, and a ''single'' scratch is enough to kill one of them...and yet they don't have any form of protection against harm. When one's rule over the planet is defeated by merely telling the people of such a weakness, one has to wonder why they never invested in power-armor of any description.

to:

** The Overseers. They have highly advanced technology, have the human population under their control as organ donars to sustain their bodies, and a ''single'' scratch is enough to kill one of them...and yet they don't have any form of protection against harm. When one's rule over the planet is defeated by merely telling the people of such a weakness, one has to wonder why they never invested in power-armor PoweredArmor of any description.

Changed: 290

Removed: 2944

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not YMMV


* TheCameo: Pretty much every companion in the series that wasn't featured in one of the chapters proper. Rory and Amy stand out as two of the few whom the Doctor greets when they're reunited.
* DemotedToExtra: Unlike the chapters preceding it, where the Doctor goes on an adventure with his companions that ends with them being kidnapped, the Eleventh Doctor's chapter starts with his adventure with Clara already over and her being kidnapped. She only gets a single on-screen cameo later on, without any dialogue.
* IdiotBall: The Eleventh Doctor summons his previous ten incarnations to [[spoiler:Adam's]] fortress between moments by doing...something with the TARDIS which turns it into a portal for all the other Doctors to travel through. Though clever, it also allows the TARDIS to become vulnerable to destruction, which would [[StuffBlowingUp allow the universe to be destroyed]]. The Eleventh Doctor had the coordinates to the place, and Ten already proved he could send messages back to his earlier incarnations through his TARDIS - what stopped him from giving coordinates that would allow ten other TARDISes to materialize?



* ProtagonistCenteredMorality: For all the damage [[spoiler: Adam]] causes, the grand theft, and the fact that he was willing to [[MoralEventHorizon murder all but ONE of the Doctor's companions]] just to spite the Doctor, he gets forgiven rather easily by ''every'' Doctor by [[spoiler: dying to stop the Master from destroying the universe]]. This is despite the fact that the entire situation was only possible thanks to [[spoiler: Adam's]] own equipment, and the Master outright confirmed he had simply let Adam continue on his own without influencing him.
** The sacrifice makes less sense, too, considering that we never learn how [[spoiler: [[FridgeLogic Adam]]]] [[FridgeLogic planned on pulling his revenge off without blowing up the universe anyways, seeing as the Doctor's companions were key in saving the universe a multitude of times]].
** Though the Overseers were using the human populace as forcible organ donars, it was also stated that they had pretty much ''saved'' the human colonies on the planet from dying off in exchange for the sacrifices. The Eighth Doctor essentially made humanity go against a contract that the oppressive force ''upheld their part, in full''. Brokering a new arrangement, or even organ donarship program wasn't even considered, even though it was established that the Overseers needed their stolen organs to survive.



* StuffedIntoTheFridge: [[spoiler: Adam's mother dies (offscreen no less) from a condition that could have been cured had the Doctor not rewritten time in some way. ''This'' is the reason for Adam's revenge, not for being left behind and trapped as a shut-in.]]
* TooStupidToLive: In his attempts to gain revenge on the Doctor, [[spoiler: Adam]] uses a vast amount of resources to find and recruit others the Doctor has "wronged". To this end, he revives and recruits the Animus...and plants it in the Victorian Era, where, if the Doctor failed, the Animus would have conquered Earth and rewritten his own history. Likewise, if he knew the Doctor's history, then how did he expect employing ''the Master'' would turn out well for him?

to:

* StuffedIntoTheFridge: [[spoiler: Adam's mother dies (offscreen no less) from a condition that could have been cured had the Doctor not rewritten time in some way. ''This'' is the reason for Adam's revenge, not for being left behind and trapped as a shut-in.]]
* TooStupidToLive:
WhatAnIdiot:
**
In his attempts to gain revenge on the Doctor, [[spoiler: Adam]] uses a vast amount of resources to find and recruit others the Doctor has "wronged". To this end, he revives and recruits the Animus...and plants it in the Victorian Era, where, if the Doctor failed, the Animus would have conquered Earth and rewritten his own history. Likewise, if he knew the Doctor's history, then how did he expect employing ''the Master'' would turn out well for him?



* WhamLine
-->'''Mysterious Figure/[[spoiler:Adam]]:''' [[spoiler:"Hello, Rose. It's been a long time."]]
* VillainDecay: The Animus, in its first appearance, was only barely defeated thanks to an untested weapon that rapidly decayed cells. Ian apparently kills it by ramming it with an old locomotive, with at least half the creature not touched. Bear in mind, this was a creature that was revived from [[FromASingleCell just an arm of the original creature]].

to:

* WhamLine
-->'''Mysterious Figure/[[spoiler:Adam]]:''' [[spoiler:"Hello, Rose. It's been a long time."]]
* VillainDecay: The Animus, in its first appearance, was only barely defeated thanks to an untested weapon that rapidly decayed cells. Ian apparently kills it by ramming it with an old locomotive, with at least half the creature not touched. Bear in mind, this was a creature that was revived from [[FromASingleCell just an arm of the original creature]].
----

Added: 909

Changed: 347

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I was a bit too polarized when writing the earlier articles; making them less charged


* IdiotBall: The Eleventh Doctor summons his previous ten incarnations to [[spoiler:Adam's]] fortress between moments by doing...something with the TARDIS which turns it into a portal for all the other Doctors to travel through. Though clever, it also allows the TARDIS to become vulnerable to destruction, which would [[StuffBlowingUp allow the universe to be destroyed]]. The Eleventh Doctor had the coordinates to the place, and Ten already proved he could send messages back to his earlier incarnations through his TARDIS - what stopped him from giving coordinates that would allow ten other TARDISes to materialize?



* ProtagonistCenteredMorality: For all the damage [[spoiler: Adam]] causes, the grand theft, and the fact that he was willing to [[MoralEventHorizon murder all but ONE of the Doctor's companions]] just to spite the Doctor, he gets forgiven rather easily by ''every'' Doctor by [[spoiler: dying to stop the Master from destroying the universe]]. Worse, not only was the situation possible thanks to [[spoiler: Adam's]] own equipment, but the Master outright confirmed he had simply let Adam continue on his own. [[FridgeLogic That said, it's questionable at how]] [[spoiler: [[FridgeLogic Adam]]]] [[FridgeLogic planned on pulling his plan without blowing up the universe anyways, seeing as the Doctor's companions were key in saving the universe a multitude of times]].

to:

* ProtagonistCenteredMorality: For all the damage [[spoiler: Adam]] causes, the grand theft, and the fact that he was willing to [[MoralEventHorizon murder all but ONE of the Doctor's companions]] just to spite the Doctor, he gets forgiven rather easily by ''every'' Doctor by [[spoiler: dying to stop the Master from destroying the universe]]. Worse, not only was This is despite the fact that the entire situation was only possible thanks to [[spoiler: Adam's]] own equipment, but and the Master outright confirmed he had simply let Adam continue on his own. [[FridgeLogic That said, it's questionable at how]] own without influencing him.
** The sacrifice makes less sense, too, considering that we never learn how
[[spoiler: [[FridgeLogic Adam]]]] [[FridgeLogic planned on pulling his plan revenge off without blowing up the universe anyways, seeing as the Doctor's companions were key in saving the universe a multitude of times]].



* TooStupidToLive: To an amazingly painful degree; in his attempts to gain revenge on the Doctor, [[spoiler: Adam]] uses a vast amount of resources to find and recruit others the Doctor has "wronged". To this end, he revives and recruits the Animus...and plants it in the Victorian Era, where, if the Doctor failed, the Animus would have conquered Earth and rewritten his own history. Likewise, if he knew the Doctor's history, then how did he expect employing ''the Master'' would turn out well for him?

to:

* TooStupidToLive: To an amazingly painful degree; in In his attempts to gain revenge on the Doctor, [[spoiler: Adam]] uses a vast amount of resources to find and recruit others the Doctor has "wronged". To this end, he revives and recruits the Animus...and plants it in the Victorian Era, where, if the Doctor failed, the Animus would have conquered Earth and rewritten his own history. Likewise, if he knew the Doctor's history, then how did he expect employing ''the Master'' would turn out well for him?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AngstWhatAngst: The Eleventh Doctor abruptly meets Rory and Amy when Frobisher releases all of the imprisoned companions. All he gives them is a jolly Hello, [[Recap/DoctorWho2012CSTheSnowmen rather undercutting the depression he went through from their passing]].
* TheCameo: Pretty much every companion in the series that wasn't featured in one of the chapters proper. Rory and Amy stand out as two of the few whom the Doctor greets when they're reunited.
* DemotedToExtra: Unlike the chapters preceding it, where the Doctor goes on an adventure with his companions that ends with them being kidnapped, the Eleventh Doctor's chapter starts with his adventure with Clara already over and her being kidnapped. She only gets a single on-screen cameo later on, without any dialogue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Fifth Doctor gets this too, for landing, recharging, and exiting his TARDIS in the middle of ''an active battlefield''. [[IdiotBall Considering that Five knows how to pilot his TARDIS, and he had three companions with him, why didn't he just park it somewhere safe, or take provisions to keep ''them'' safe?!]]

to:

** The Fifth Doctor gets this too, for landing, recharging, and exiting his TARDIS in the middle of ''an active battlefield''. [[IdiotBall Considering that Five knows how to pilot his TARDIS, and he had three companions with him, why didn't he just park it somewhere safe, or take provisions to keep ''them'' safe?!]]them safe?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProtagonistCenteredMorality: For all the damage [[spoiler: Adam]] causes, the grand theft, and the fact that he was willing to [[MoralEventHorizon murder all but ONE of the Doctor's companions]] just to spite the Doctor, he gets forgiven rather easily by ''every'' Doctor by [[spoiler: dying to stop the Master from destroying the universe]]. Worse, not only was the a situation possible thanks to [[spoiler: Adam's]] own equipment, but the Master outright confirmed he had simply let Adam continue on his own. [[FridgeLogic That said, it's questionable at how]] [[spoiler: [[FridgeLogic Adam]]]] [[FridgeLogic planned on pulling his plan without blowing up the universe anyways, seeing as the Doctor's companions were key in saving the universe a multitude of times]].

to:

* ProtagonistCenteredMorality: For all the damage [[spoiler: Adam]] causes, the grand theft, and the fact that he was willing to [[MoralEventHorizon murder all but ONE of the Doctor's companions]] just to spite the Doctor, he gets forgiven rather easily by ''every'' Doctor by [[spoiler: dying to stop the Master from destroying the universe]]. Worse, not only was the a situation possible thanks to [[spoiler: Adam's]] own equipment, but the Master outright confirmed he had simply let Adam continue on his own. [[FridgeLogic That said, it's questionable at how]] [[spoiler: [[FridgeLogic Adam]]]] [[FridgeLogic planned on pulling his plan without blowing up the universe anyways, seeing as the Doctor's companions were key in saving the universe a multitude of times]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProtagonistCenteredMorality: For all the damage [[spoiler: Adam]] causes, the grand theft, and the fact that he was willing to [[MoralEventHorizon murder all but ONE of the Doctor's companions]] just to spite the Doctor, he gets forgiven rather easily by ''every'' Doctor by [[spoiler: dying to stop the Master from destroying the universe]]. Worse, not only was the a situation possible thanks to [[spoiler: Adam's]] own equipment, but the Master outright confirmed he had simply let Adam continue on his own. [[FridgeLogic That said, it's questionable at how [[spoiler: Adam]] planned on pulling his plan without blowing up the universe anyways, seeing as the Doctor's companions were key in saving the universe a multitude of times]].

to:

* ProtagonistCenteredMorality: For all the damage [[spoiler: Adam]] causes, the grand theft, and the fact that he was willing to [[MoralEventHorizon murder all but ONE of the Doctor's companions]] just to spite the Doctor, he gets forgiven rather easily by ''every'' Doctor by [[spoiler: dying to stop the Master from destroying the universe]]. Worse, not only was the a situation possible thanks to [[spoiler: Adam's]] own equipment, but the Master outright confirmed he had simply let Adam continue on his own. [[FridgeLogic That said, it's questionable at how how]] [[spoiler: Adam]] [[FridgeLogic Adam]]]] [[FridgeLogic planned on pulling his plan without blowing up the universe anyways, seeing as the Doctor's companions were key in saving the universe a multitude of times]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Fifth Doctor gets this too, for landing, recharging, and leaving his TARDIS in the middle of ''an active battlefield''. [[IdiotBall Considering that Five knows how to pilot his TARDIS, and he had three companions with him, why didn't he just park it somewhere safe, or take provisions to keep ''them'' safe?!]]

to:

** The Fifth Doctor gets this too, for landing, recharging, and leaving exiting his TARDIS in the middle of ''an active battlefield''. [[IdiotBall Considering that Five knows how to pilot his TARDIS, and he had three companions with him, why didn't he just park it somewhere safe, or take provisions to keep ''them'' safe?!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Fifth Doctor gets this too, for landing, recharging, and leaving his TARDIS in the middle of ''an active battlefield''. [[IdiotBall COnsidering that Five knows how to pilot his TARDIS, and he had three companions with him, why didn't he just park it somewhere safe, or take provisions to keep ''them'' safe?!]]

to:

** The Fifth Doctor gets this too, for landing, recharging, and leaving his TARDIS in the middle of ''an active battlefield''. [[IdiotBall COnsidering Considering that Five knows how to pilot his TARDIS, and he had three companions with him, why didn't he just park it somewhere safe, or take provisions to keep ''them'' safe?!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProtagonistCenteredMorality: For all the damage [[spoiler: Adam]] causes, the grand theft, and the fact that he was willing to [[MoralEventHorizon murder all but ONE of the Doctor's companions]] just to spite the Doctor, he gets forgiven rather easily by ''every'' Doctor by [[spoiler: dying to stop the Master from destroying the universe]]. Worse, not only was the a situation possible thanks to [[spoiler: Adam's]] own equipment, but the Master outright confirmed he had simply let Adam continue on his own. [[FridgeLogic That said, it's questionable at how [[spoiler: Adam]] planned on pulling his plan without blowing up the universe anyways, seeing as the Doctor's companions were key in saving the universe a multitude of times]].
** Though the Overseers were using the human populace as forcible organ donars, it was also stated that they had pretty much ''saved'' the human colonies on the planet from dying off in exchange for the sacrifices. The Eighth Doctor essentially made humanity go against a contract that the oppressive force ''upheld their part, in full''. Brokering a new arrangement, or even organ donarship program wasn't even considered, even though it was established that the Overseers needed their stolen organs to survive.



* StuffedIntoTheFridge: [[spoiler: Adam's mother dies (offscreen no less) from a condition that could have been cured had the Doctor not rewritten time in some way. ''This'' is the reason for Adam's revenge, not for being left behind and trapped as a shut-in.]]
* TooStupidToLive: To an amazingly painful degree; in his attempts to gain revenge on the Doctor, [[spoiler: Adam]] uses a vast amount of resources to find and recruit others the Doctor has "wronged". To this end, he revives and recruits the Animus...and plants it in the Victorian Era, where, if the Doctor failed, the Animus would have conquered Earth and rewritten his own history. Likewise, if he knew the Doctor's history, then how did he expect employing ''the Master'' would turn out well for him?
**The Fifth Doctor gets this too, for landing, recharging, and leaving his TARDIS in the middle of ''an active battlefield''. [[IdiotBall COnsidering that Five knows how to pilot his TARDIS, and he had three companions with him, why didn't he just park it somewhere safe, or take provisions to keep ''them'' safe?!]]
** The Overseers. They have highly advanced technology, have the human population under their control as organ donars to sustain their bodies, and a ''single'' scratch is enough to kill one of them...and yet they don't have any form of protection against harm. When one's rule over the planet is defeated by merely telling the people of such a weakness, one has to wonder why they never invested in power-armor of any description.



-->'''Mysterious Figure/[[spoiler:Adam]]:''' [[spoiler:"Hello, Rose. It's been a long time."]]

to:

-->'''Mysterious Figure/[[spoiler:Adam]]:''' [[spoiler:"Hello, Rose. It's been a long time."]]"]]
*VillainDecay: The Animus, in its first appearance, was only barely defeated thanks to an untested weapon that rapidly decayed cells. Ian apparently kills it by ramming it with an old locomotive, with at least half the creature not touched. Bear in mind, this was a creature that was revived from [[FromASingleCell just an arm of the original creature]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerkassWoobie: Drake Ayelbourne and [[spoiler: Adam Mitchell]].
* RecycledScript: Recycles some unused ideas. #6 the Master is using Autons, which was one of the ideas for Season 23. Also the motivation for the villain is partly this: [[spoiler:In an early draft of "The Long Game", Adam tried to take technology from the future to cure his dying father. Here he is angry with the Doctor for erasing future technology that could have saved his mother.]]
* WhamLine
-->'''Mysterious Figure/[[spoiler:Adam]]:''' [[spoiler:"Hello, Rose. It's been a long time."]]

Top