History YMMV / CriticalRoleCampaignThree

** Fearne/Ashton being teased for so long led to a whole wave of these, like Mountain Goat. There's also Fearne/Chetney, who get names like [[LovableSexManiac Horn Dog.]]

** Fearne/Ashton being teased for so long led to a whole wave of these, like Mountain Goat.

** Bell's Hells' [[NayTheist kneejerk antagonism towards the gods]] has proven divisive. One segment of the fandom finds their skepticism towards the Prime Deities refreshing, viewing the divine powers of Exandria as [[JerkassGods self-righteous bullies]], [[GodsHandsAreTied useless bystanders]], and [[KnightTemplar short-sighted zealots]] who [[NiceJobBreakingItHero caused the whole issue with]] [[SealedEvilInACan Predathos]] in the first place, and are justifiably receiving their first [[WhatTheHellHero serious criticism from mortals]] in centuries. Other fans view the Hells as [[EgocentricallyReligious selfish]], [[UngratefulBastard ungrateful]] [[HollywoodAtheist Hollywood Atheists]] who [[EntitledBastard demand divine favor without doing the work of cultivating a relationship with the gods]] (even after attacking a temple, slaughtering an angel and ''summoning a'' ''[[AlwaysChaoticEvil demon]]'' ''while doing so''), [[FlatEarthAtheist ignore centuries of documented historical divine intervention in the world for the better]], and [[WeAreStrugglingTogether refuse to put aside their grievances towards the gods]] despite the fact that [[EvilVersusOblivion even the most callous deity is probably an improvement over a being called "Predathos, the World-Eater."]] Only Orym and Fresh Cut Grass have so far offered a serious defense of the Prime Deities, and F.C.G., being a newly ReligiousRobot, takes the zeal of the converted [[BeliefMakesYouStupid so far]] as to seem like a DeliberatelyBadExample of a cleric.

** Some find Otohan Thull to be genuinely intimidating, especially with hero HeroKiller status and similarities to Darth Vader, as well as the sheer power she demonstrates thanks to her effectively having two different Fighter subclasses at the same time. Others however deride her for being a BoringInvincibleVillain, [[{{Narm}} feeling that the attempts to make her cool and badass wind up making her look like she's trying too hard]], and that her lack of clear motivation makes her sound more like she's delivering action movie one-liners rather than expressing a sincerely-held belief in anything.

** Bell's Hells' [[NayTheist kneejerk antagonism towards the gods]] has proven divisive. One segment of the fandom finds their skepticism towards the Prime Deities refreshing, viewing the divine powers of Exandria as [[JerkassGods self-righteous bullies]], [[GodsHandsAreTied useless bystanders]], and [[KnightTemplar short-sighted zealots]] who [[NiceJobBreakingItHero caused the whole issue with]] [[SealedEvilInACan Predathos]] in the first place, and are justifiably receiving their first [[WhatTheHellHero serious criticism from mortals]] in centuries. Other fans view the Hells as [[EgocentricallyReligious selfish]], [[UngratefulBastard ungrateful]] [[HollywoodAtheist Hollywood Athiests]] who [[EntitledBastard demand divine favor without doing the work of cultivating a relationship with the gods]] (even after attacking a temple, slaughtering an angel and ''summoning a'' ''[[AlwaysChaoticEvil demon]]'' ''while doing so''), [[FlatEarthAtheist ignore centuries of documented historical divine intervention in the world for the better]], and [[WeAreStrugglingTogether refuse to put aside their grievances towards the gods]] despite the fact that [[EvilVersusOblivion even the most callous deity is probably an improvement over a being called "Predathos, the World-Eater."]] Only Orym and Fresh Cut Grass have so far offered a serious defense of the Prime Deities, and F.C.G., being a newly ReligiousRobot, takes the zeal of the converted [[BeliefMakesYouStupid so far]] as to seem like a DeliberatelyBadExample of a cleric.

* JustHereForGodzilla: Some fans of Campaign One started watching at episode 36, as it's when the party goes to Whitestone and interacts with Keyleth, Percy, Vex, and Pike.

* BrokenBase: Chetney using his werewolf form to attack and terrorize a shopkeeper in Jrusar over her prices. Half of the fanbase found it [[BlackComedy hilarious]], the other were disturbed that what they viewed as brutally DisproportionateRetribution was PlayedForLaughs and Chetney remained a heroic character.

* BaseBreakingCharacter: Dusk [[spoiler: a.k.a Yu Suffiad]] is an incredibly divisive character, to the point where if you search their name on Google, "Dusk Critical Role annoying" is one of the suggestions. Many fans found their antics hilarious and enjoyed their fun dynamics with the party, especially Laudna and Fearne. Others thought the very same antics were annoying, slowed plot progression, and messed with Bell's Hells' relationships while they were still developing. TheReveal partway through their arc, [[spoiler: that they're a villainous changeling agent in disguise]] didn't exactly help matters. While most agree that [[spoiler: post-InternalReveal Yu is a much more interesting LoveToHate character]], supporters feel [[spoiler: it justifies their earlier behavior as ObfuscatingStupidity]] while to detractors [[spoiler: the façade was too obnoxious and overstayed its welcome, and that Erika seemed to be trying to goad the party into [=PvP=] past the point that it was clear they weren't biting, making the scene tiresome rather than tense]]. The way the reveal was handled is also divisive, with some feeling it would've worked better in a film or TV show than in a D&D game (where most of the table wasn't looped in on the twist until it happened), or was done better by [[spoiler: Bor'Dor]] later on.

* {{Narm}}: While some find Otohan to be genuinely intimidating, others deride her for being boring, feeling that the attempts to make her cool and badass wind up making her look like she's trying too hard and that her lack of clear motivation makes her sound more like she's delivering action movie one-liners than expressing a sincerely-held belief in anything.

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation:

* IKnewIt: [[spoiler:Bor'Dor being part of the Ruby Vanguard]] was guessed at by many fans long before it was revealed.

* DesignatedHero: Though the group's more overall morally gray than any other of the past parties were, some people feel that Laudna has a notable habit of especially dipping into this after watching later episodes— namely, [[spoiler:when it came to her extreme reaction over Bor'Dor's betrayal (which even had the rest of the table balking at Marisha's actions) and her reacting to Ashton's attempt to take the shard for himself by saying that he should go and die and letting herself be partially influenced into regressing backwards by Delilah. This was especially notable in the latter case where as many of the group was more than willing to call out Ashton for his dangerous decisions, which has caused many viewers to feel like they haven't been calling out Laudna for her more morally questionable actions nearly as much as they should have been before then.]]

%%* BrokenBase: The idea of the Shard of Rau'shan going to Fearne even though she has voiced her concerns about taking it due to her fear of it turning her evil. Some feel that it should go to her because the narrative and even the nature of the shard seems to indicate that it was made for Fearne and that it will help to defend her from the Unseelie Court, while others have voiced their displeasure with how much the others in the group seem to be pushing and peer-pressuring her into taking a shard that she clearly doesn't want for understandable reasons.

* BrokenBase: The idea of the Shard of Rau'shan going to Fearne even though she has voiced her concerns about taking it due to her fear of it turning her evil. Some feel that it should go to her because the narrative and even the nature of the shard seems to indicate that it was made for Fearne and that it will help to defend her from the Unseelie Court, while others have voiced their displeasure with how much the others in the group seem to be pushing and peer-pressuring her into taking a shard that she clearly doesn't want for understandable reasons.

* ArcFatigue: Some Critters have felt the split party arc starting in Episode 52 carried on too long, and want to see [[spoiler: Laudna, Ashton and Orym]] again. This was likely done because [[RealLifeWritesThePlot Marisha needed to train for and recover from Creator Clash]].
* BaseBreakingCharacter: Dusk [[spoiler: a.k.a Yu Suffiad]] is an incredibly divisive character, to the point where if you search their name on Google, "Dusk Critical Role annoying" is one of the suggestions. Many fans found their antics hilarious and enjoyed their fun dynamics with the party, especially Laudna and Fearne. Others found the very same antics annoying, slowed plot progression, and messed with Bell's Hells' relationships while they were still developing (see DieForOurShip for one heated example). TheReveal partway through their arc, [[spoiler: that they're a villainous changeling agent in disguise]] didn't exactly help matters. While most agree that [[spoiler: post-InternalReveal Yu is a much more interesting LoveToHate character]], supporters feel [[spoiler: it justifies their earlier behavior as ObfuscatingStupidity]] while to detractors [[spoiler: the façade was too obnoxious and overstayed its welcome]]. The way the reveal was handled is also divisive, with some feeling it would've worked better in a film or TV show than in a D&D game (where most of the table wasn't looped in on the twist until it happened), or was done better by [[spoiler: Bor'Dor]] later on.

* TooBleakStoppedCaring: By the late 70's in episode count, Bell's Hells still haven't learned to truly work together as a team and none barring [[OnlySaneMan Orym and Chetney]] have overcome their emotional baggage (with Laudna and Aston's mental issues sinking to downright dangerous levels), and they're still deeply split on the matter of [[spoiler: whether the gods are worth saving]]. All this leads to a party that struggles to get things done and lacks a unified goal, which can be frustrating to watch. Of particular note are Episodes 77 and 78, which gave the party a clear new direction and downtime to prepare... which resulted in [[spoiler: Aston's disastrous attempt to absorb the shard of Rau'shan, Laudna leaning closer to Delilah]] and emotional fallout so bad the party instead needed a ''therapy retreat''.

* DesignatedHero: Though the group's more overall morally gray than any other of the past parties were, many people feel that Laudna has a notable habit of especially dipping into this after watching later episodes— namely, [[spoiler:when it came to her extreme reaction over Bor'Dor's betrayal (which even had the rest of the table balking at Marisha's actions) and her reacting to Ashton's attempt to take the shard for himself by saying that he should go and die and constantly bringing that fact up with the others. This was especially notable in the latter case where as many of the group was more than willing to call out Ashton for his dangerous decisions, which has caused many viewers to feel like they haven't been calling out Laudna for her more morally questionable actions nearly as much as they should have been before then.]]

* DieForOurShip: A variation. Some detractors of the [[spoiler: Imogen/Laudna]] ship have taken out their frustrations on ''Dusk'', blaming their flirtatious teasing for triggering the GreenEyedEpiphany that eventually led to the ship sailing.

* IdiosyncraticShipNaming: Southern Gothic has been a popular ship name for Imogen and Laudna. Similarly, [=TombStone=] has evolved for the Laudna/Ashton ship.

** The brief teamup of [[LovableSexManiac Pate de Rolo]] and Mother (Prism's crow familiar) led to the hilarious but oddly appropriate Motherfucker.

** The brief teamup of Pate de Rolo and Mother (Prism's crow familiar) led to the hilarious but oddly appropriate Motherfucker.

** When Chetney revealed his "RTA" tattoo stood for "Recognize The Alpha," Laudna remarked that "I thought it stood for Royal Tinkering Academy!" [[spoiler:Many episodes later, we learn that Laudna wasn't far off; it actually stands for Rexxentrum Toy Academy.]]

* PortmanteauCoupleName: Imodna (Imogen/Laudna); Laudmoore (Ashton/Laudna); Ashrym (Ashton/Orym); Callowmoore (Fearne/Ashton); Callowpea (Fearne/Chetney); and Imogearne (Imogen/Fearne) are among the more popular ships in the party, in addition to Dorym (Dorian/Orym) carrying over from EXU.

* ParanoiaFuel: Every moment with [[spoiler: Dusk]] becomes this once its revealed [[spoiler:they're an assassin targeting the Calloways, Fearne included.]] Even leaving the party doesn't change anything as [[spoiler:they're a ShapeShifter and ''could return as anybody else.'']]