Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / ChaldeaInRemnant

Go To

OR

Added: 691

Changed: 326

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
AST is now Trivia.


* AuthorsSavingThrow: The inclusion of Pyrrha as a Heroic Spirit was argued against due to her not being very noteworthy by Heroic Spirit standards. However, the author managed to turn this around by actually having it brought up and using it as a plot point to bring up how Remnant has a different World than Gaia and Alaya.

to:

* AuthorsSavingThrow: The inclusion of Pyrrha as a Heroic Spirit was argued against due to her not being very noteworthy by Heroic Spirit standards. However, HilariousInHindsight:
** In chapter 3, when
the author CCT in Vale is restored and the network is back online, Ironwood mentions that he's been growing frustrated with Jacques, who's been trying to push his way into politics. Come Volume 7, and Jacques is currently running for a seat in the Atlas Council.
** In the fanfic, Kadoc somehow
managed to turn survive the events of the Lostbelt arc and underwent AdaptationalHeroism, siding with Chaldea and living through the experience in the process. Come to find out in the second half of the Olympus Lostbelt, he sides with Chaldea and the Proper Human History resistance, though whether or not he's joined with Chaldea for good remains to be seen at the time of this around by actually having it brought up and using it as a plot point to bring up how Remnant has a different World than Gaia and Alaya.writing.

Changed: 304

Removed: 306

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorsSavingThrow:
** The inclusion of Pyrrha as a Heroic Spirit was argued against due to her not being very noteworthy by Heroic Spirit standards. However, the author managed to turn this around by actually having it brought up and using it as a plot point to bring up how Remnant has a different World than Gaia and Alaya.

to:

* AuthorsSavingThrow:
**
AuthorsSavingThrow: The inclusion of Pyrrha as a Heroic Spirit was argued against due to her not being very noteworthy by Heroic Spirit standards. However, the author managed to turn this around by actually having it brought up and using it as a plot point to bring up how Remnant has a different World than Gaia and Alaya.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While the possibility of them being summoned was discussed by fans, no one expected [[spoiler:Roman Torchwick to become a ''Pseudo-Servant,'' much less playing host to legendary GentlemanThief Literature/ArseneLupin!]]

to:

** While the possibility of them being summoned was discussed by fans, no one expected [[spoiler:Roman Torchwick to become a ''Pseudo-Servant,'' much less playing host to legendary GentlemanThief Literature/ArseneLupin!]]Literature/ArseneLupin!]]
* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical: An unusual meta version in that the author admitted he was hesitant to include the Wendigo Grimm in Chapter 7 on account of the controversy surrounding it and [=RoosterTeeth=]'s fan Grimm competition[[labelnote:Explanation]]Creator/RoosterTeeth held a competition for Full Sail University and had students submit their fan-made Grimm designs, which the public could vote on. The winner of the competition would have their Grimm be featured in Volume 8 of ''RWBY.'' The Wendigo Grimm submission proved to be popular enough to be one of the finalists, but complications and controversy and other factors caused RT to exclude the Wendigo Grimm submission and decide on the winner themselves.[[/labelnote]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding. Edit as necessary. If I'm wrong to put it in, I'm sorry.

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorsSavingThrow:
** The inclusion of Pyrrha as a Heroic Spirit was argued against due to her not being very noteworthy by Heroic Spirit standards. However, the author managed to turn this around by actually having it brought up and using it as a plot point to bring up how Remnant has a different World than Gaia and Alaya.

Added: 870

Changed: 646

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnexpectedCharacter: The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist InUniverse, but something many readers were expecting. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering that Ozpin is still around. This is even discussed between Ozma and Kadoc, with Ozma theorizing that Ozpin's participation in many of Remnant's fairy tales (The Girl in the Tower, the Two Brothers, the Four Seasons) may have provided enough of a connection to allow for his summoning.

to:

* UnexpectedCharacter: UnexpectedCharacter:
**
The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist InUniverse, but something many readers were expecting. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering that Ozpin is still around. This is even discussed between Ozma and Kadoc, with Ozma theorizing that Ozpin's participation in many of Remnant's fairy tales (The Girl in the Tower, the Two Brothers, the Four Seasons) may have provided enough of a connection to allow for his summoning.summoning.
** While the possibility of them being summoned was discussed by fans, no one expected [[spoiler:Roman Torchwick to become a ''Pseudo-Servant,'' much less playing host to legendary GentlemanThief Literature/ArseneLupin!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnexpectedCharacter: The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist InUniverse, but something many readers were expecting. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering that Ozpin is still around. This is even discussed between Ozma and Kado, with Ozma theorizing that Ozpin's participation in many of Remnant's fairy tales (The Girl in the Tower, the Two Brothers, the Four Seasons) may have provided enough of a connection to allow for his summoning.

to:

* UnexpectedCharacter: The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist InUniverse, but something many readers were expecting. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering that Ozpin is still around. This is even discussed between Ozma and Kado, Kadoc, with Ozma theorizing that Ozpin's participation in many of Remnant's fairy tales (The Girl in the Tower, the Two Brothers, the Four Seasons) may have provided enough of a connection to allow for his summoning.

Changed: 310

Removed: 240

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnexpectedCharacter: The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering that Ozpin is still around.
** Discussed between Ozma and Kadoc. Ozma theorizes that Ozpin's participation in many of Remnant's fairy tales (The Girl in the Tower, the Two Brothers, the Four Seasons) may have provided enough of a connection to allow for his summoning.

to:

* UnexpectedCharacter: The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist.twist InUniverse, but something many readers were expecting. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering that Ozpin is still around.
** Discussed
around. This is even discussed between Ozma and Kadoc. Kado, with Ozma theorizes theorizing that Ozpin's participation in many of Remnant's fairy tales (The Girl in the Tower, the Two Brothers, the Four Seasons) may have provided enough of a connection to allow for his summoning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is Trivia


* AccidentallyAccurate:
** In chapter 3, when the CCT in Vale is restored and the network is back online, Ironwood mentions that he's been growing frustrated with Jacques, who's been trying to push his way into politics. Come Volume 7, and Jacques is currently running for a seat in the Atlas Council.
** In the fanfic, Kadoc somehow managed to survive the events of the Lostbelt arc and underwent AdaptationalHeroism, siding with Chaldea and living through the experience in the process. Come to find out in the second half of the Olympus Lostbelt, he sides with Chaldea and the Proper Human History resistance, though whether or not he's joined with Chaldea for good remains to be seen at the time of this writing.

Added: 691

Changed: 274

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentallyAccurate: In chapter 3, when the CCT in Vale is restored and the network is back online, Ironwood mentions that he's been growing frustrated with Jacques, who's been trying to push his way into politics. Come Volume 7, and Jacques is currently running for a seat in the Atlas Council.

to:

* AccidentallyAccurate: AccidentallyAccurate:
**
In chapter 3, when the CCT in Vale is restored and the network is back online, Ironwood mentions that he's been growing frustrated with Jacques, who's been trying to push his way into politics. Come Volume 7, and Jacques is currently running for a seat in the Atlas Council.Council.
** In the fanfic, Kadoc somehow managed to survive the events of the Lostbelt arc and underwent AdaptationalHeroism, siding with Chaldea and living through the experience in the process. Come to find out in the second half of the Olympus Lostbelt, he sides with Chaldea and the Proper Human History resistance, though whether or not he's joined with Chaldea for good remains to be seen at the time of this writing.

Added: 240

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnexpectedCharacter: The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering Ozpin is still around.

to:

* UnexpectedCharacter: The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering that Ozpin is still around.around.
** Discussed between Ozma and Kadoc. Ozma theorizes that Ozpin's participation in many of Remnant's fairy tales (The Girl in the Tower, the Two Brothers, the Four Seasons) may have provided enough of a connection to allow for his summoning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AccidentallyAccurate: In chapter 3, when the CCT in Vale is restored and the network is back online, Ironwood mentions that he's been growing frustrated with Jacques, who's been trying to push his way into politics. Come Volume 7, and Jacques is currently running for a seat in the Atlas Council.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not what that trope is. That trope is when something considered to have pioneered a genre is considered unfunny because the genre is played out. Seinfeld was one of the more famous live action sitcoms, but with them being a dime a dozen nowadays and with better writing, Seinfeld is seen as mediocre nowadays.


* SeinfeldIsUnfunny:
** Make no mistake, a lot of people were more than happy to hear that Romani, AKA Solomon, was coming back to Chaldea via the Summoning Ritual. However, there were also just as many people who found Romani's subsequent treatment[[labelnote:Explanation]]Gudako promised that she would give him a GroinAttack if she ever saw him again, and she followed through on that promise. Afterwards, Da Vinci left him to the mercy of Nightingale, who is obsessed with treating her patients to the point of actually killing them. In this case, she was going to take a bonesaw to his bruised genitals.[[/labelnote]] following his summon to be less than hilarious.
** The constant use of GroinAttack has been something of a sore spot, despite having been done on only two occasions.

Added: 766

Changed: 647

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: Make no mistake, a lot of people were more than happy to hear that Romani, AKA Solomon, was coming back to Chaldea via the Summoning Ritual. However, there were also just as many people who found Romani's subsequent treatment[[labelnote:Explanation]]Gudako promised that she would give him a GroinAttack if she ever saw him again, and she followed through on that promise. Afterwards, Da Vinci left him to the mercy of Nightingale, who is obsessed with treating her patients to the point of actually killing them. In this case, she was going to take a bonesaw to his bruised genitals.[[/labelnote]] following his summon to be less than hilarious.

to:

* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: SeinfeldIsUnfunny:
**
Make no mistake, a lot of people were more than happy to hear that Romani, AKA Solomon, was coming back to Chaldea via the Summoning Ritual. However, there were also just as many people who found Romani's subsequent treatment[[labelnote:Explanation]]Gudako promised that she would give him a GroinAttack if she ever saw him again, and she followed through on that promise. Afterwards, Da Vinci left him to the mercy of Nightingale, who is obsessed with treating her patients to the point of actually killing them. In this case, she was going to take a bonesaw to his bruised genitals.[[/labelnote]] following his summon to be less than hilarious.
** The constant use of GroinAttack has been something of a sore spot, despite having been done on only two occasions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


SeinfeldIsUnfunny: Make no mistake, a lot of people were more than happy to hear that Romani, AKA Solomon, was coming back to Chaldea via the Summoning Ritual. However, there were also just as many people who found Romani's subsequent treatment[[labelnote:Explanation]]Gudako promised that she would give him a GroinAttack if she ever saw him again, and she followed through on that promise. Afterwards, Da Vinci left him to the mercy of Nightingale, who is obsessed with treating her patients to the point of actually killing them. In this case, she was going to take a bonesaw to his bruised genitals.[[/labelnote]] following his summon to be less than hilarious.

to:

* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: Make no mistake, a lot of people were more than happy to hear that Romani, AKA Solomon, was coming back to Chaldea via the Summoning Ritual. However, there were also just as many people who found Romani's subsequent treatment[[labelnote:Explanation]]Gudako promised that she would give him a GroinAttack if she ever saw him again, and she followed through on that promise. Afterwards, Da Vinci left him to the mercy of Nightingale, who is obsessed with treating her patients to the point of actually killing them. In this case, she was going to take a bonesaw to his bruised genitals.[[/labelnote]] following his summon to be less than hilarious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

SeinfeldIsUnfunny: Make no mistake, a lot of people were more than happy to hear that Romani, AKA Solomon, was coming back to Chaldea via the Summoning Ritual. However, there were also just as many people who found Romani's subsequent treatment[[labelnote:Explanation]]Gudako promised that she would give him a GroinAttack if she ever saw him again, and she followed through on that promise. Afterwards, Da Vinci left him to the mercy of Nightingale, who is obsessed with treating her patients to the point of actually killing them. In this case, she was going to take a bonesaw to his bruised genitals.[[/labelnote]] following his summon to be less than hilarious.
* UnexpectedCharacter: The fact that Chaldea could summon Heroic Spirits native to Remnant was a surprising twist. What people were ''not'' expecting was the author choosing Pyrrha Nikos and Ozma to be the first Remnant Servants to be summoned by Chaldea. While Pyrrha's case could be argued, Ozma's is more noteworthy considering Ozpin is still around.

Top