Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WhatAnIdiot / FanWorks

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/MetalGearGreen'' (A ''Manga/MyHeroAcademia'' and ''VideoGame/MetalGear'' crossover):
** Fudaki had zapped out all the villains in the flood zone and Mineta was calling for him to join them in safety.\\
'''You'd Think''': He would abide by his teacher's orders. He is a 1st year student, after all, and survival is more easier alongside a group than alone.\\
'''Instead''': He ignores them and [[LeeroyJenkins charges off to fight the USJ Nomu by himself.]]\\
'''The Result''': Fudaki is killed by the USJ Nomu due to having a mix of SuicidalOverconfidence, TooDumbToLive and just plain stupidity.
** Bakugou, Kirishima and Todoroki see the USJ Nomu was pinned, Kurogiri was incapacitated and Shigaraki was in the throes of a VillainousBreakdown because he was trapped in the USJ by the combined efforts of All Might and the Ocelot Unit.\\
'''You'd Expect:''' They let the Ocelot Unit and All Might do what they need to do. After all, they have the situation under control.\\
'''Instead:''' They jump in to fight the USJ Nomu.\\
'''The Result:''' [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Todoroki successfully gives Shigaraki cover and breaks the USJ Nomu out of being pinned, combined with Bakugou and Kirishima's brute force idea, meant that the Ocelot Unit couldn't shoot the USJ Nomu without hitting those three, and Todoroki's attempts ruined a well thought-out plan.]] Ocelot [[WhatTheHellHero rightfully calls the three out for being idiotic dumbasses for jumping into a situation that was already under control and making things more difficult.]] They narrowly escape expulsion and blacklisting by All Might's intervention, but Ocelot warns them if they try something like that again, they ''will'' be expelled and blacklisted, regardless of All Might's intervention or not.
** In Chapter 65, Bakugou finds Akatani chatting with someone on his Idroid and becomes pissed with him over the disaster of a class trial where he was knocked out effortlessly.\\
'''You'd Think''': He'd try to hold his temper in. As much as he hates Akatani, if he was caught attacking or threatening bodily harm to a TA, he would not only be expelled, but blacklisted thanks to Ocelot.\\
'''Instead''': He becomes BlindedByRage, grabs Akatani by his uniform and threatens bodily harm.\\
'''The Result''': Bakugou gets [[CurbStompBattle effortlessly beaten]], [[BoundAndGagged zip-tied in a manner that would keep him from using his Quirk on his restraints or Akatani]], and left to try and get out of them on his own.\\
'''Later''': Akatani is going over who he thinks is the bigger threat in class 1A.\\
'''You'd Think''': He'd keep his mouth shut.\\
'''Instead''': His [[SevenDeadlySins pride]] overtakes him and mocks him for having Jiro, Shoji and Koda as the biggest threats.\\
'''The Result''': Akatani tells him that they were a bigger threat than him and that he still hasn't gotten out of the zip-ties when he claimed he could be strong enough to do so effortlessly, causing most of 1A to [[ActuallyPrettyFunny laugh at him]] and destroying his reputation even further.
** In Chapter 68, Ocelot explains to Class 1A that the ones who barely passed over-relied on All Might and it cost them a lot. When Bakugou argues they {{Nerfed}} All Might, Snake explains this is designed to be as realistic as possible.\\
'''You'd Expect''': Bakugou to keep his mouth shut. He's already on thin ice and in a MSF command post.\\
'''But This Being Bakugou''': [[TooDumbToLive He calls Snake a villain to his face,]] causing all of Class 1A to [[OhCrap collectively panic.]]\\
'''The Result''': Ocelot threatens to add another week of cleaning duty to Bakugou to shut him up, but it's clear to everyone that if the MSF ''were'' villains, all of them would be leaving the MSF Command Post in body bags.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WhatAnIdiot/MetalGearGreen''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In Chapter 68, Ocelot explains to Class 1A that the ones who barely passed over-relied on All Might and it cost them a lot. When Bakugou argues they {{Nerfed}} All Might, Snake explains this is designed to be as realistic as possible.\\
'''You'd Expect''': Bakugou to keep his mouth shut. He's already on thin ice and in a MSF command post.\\
'''But This Being Bakugou''': [[TooDumbToLive He calls Snake a villain to his face,]] causing all of Class 1A to [[OhCrap collectively panic.]]\\
'''The Result''': Ocelot threatens to add another week of cleaning duty to Bakugou to shut him up, but it's clear to everyone that if the MSF ''were'' villains, all of them would be leaving the MSF Command Post in body bags.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/MyHeroAcademiaUnchainedPredator'':
** Nine, Mummy, Slice, and Chimera see that the Slayer is nearly done slaughtering all of the Sabers.\\
'''You'd Expect''': Them to run. While they are skilled at fighting, so were all of the Steel Sabers, to the point of being able to kill 246 different heroes, and they're all dead. While it could be argued that the four are more powerful than the quirkless soldiers, the Slayer has thus far made mincemeat of almost ''ten thousand'' soldiers actively trying to kill him with guns, missiles, bombs, and tanks and has thus far walked through them as if they were nothing to him (which they were). In fact, many of those kills were with his bare hands, and the streets are literally running red with rivers of blood from how many people have been reduced to something with the consistency of ground beef.\\
'''Instead''': They decide to fight the Slayer head-on and [[CurbStompBattle are promptly murdered with extreme prejudice for their troubles.]]
** When Endeavor arrives to the island in Chapter 20, showing outright hostility and anger at them not capturing the Slayer, he demands that they tell him his last location.\\
'''You'd expect''': Them to tell Endeavor to stop behaving like a raving lunatic. While it can be justified that the Slayer running free is a problem, the bottom line is that the Slayer had made mincemeat of ''ten thousand'' soldiers and royally trounced Nine and his lieutenants, and that charging headfirst would be tantamount to suicide. Not to mention he was terrifying the hostages, who had been through enough already.\\
'''Instead''': Ryukyu blurts that the Slayer's last known location was the central tower, and that Hawks went there and was about to explain that they haven't heard from him yet when he already left.\\
'''The Result''': Endeavor flies there, catches the Slayer in the main vault and unleashes a slew of attacks on the Slayer, including his ultimate move. [[NoSell It didn't work]], [[NiceJobBreakingItHero he destroyed the vault,]] and the Slayer brutalizes him in a [[NoHoldsBarredBeatdown one-sided fight.]] Recovery Girl sums it up in Chapter 27.
---> '''[=Recovery Girl=]''': It'll take at least three months for him to heal. It would've taken six months if I hadn't used my Quirk.
** When the heroes on I-Island debate on what to do in the beginning of Chapter 21, they don't know what to do regarding the Slayer due to a lack of intel and the possibility that the man is Quirkless.\\
'''You'd expect''': Them to ask the last known people who spotted the Slayer, which was Izuku, Ochako, Shoto, Melissa and Mirio. Even if this would be a problem for the heroes to ask five traumatized teens, the five teens know that the Slayer's armor can [[NoSell shrug lava off like it was nothing]]. It would enable them to come up with a plan, or at the least, realize they need All Might or someone of his strength caliber to fight the Slayer.\\
'''Instead''': They don't consider the possibility and with the exception of [[DirtyCop Slidin' Go]] and four others, rush off to fight the Slayer.\\
'''The Result''': All the heroes receive a non-lethal CurbStompBattle for their failed efforts to capture the Slayer.
** When the Slayer emerges after his fight with All Might [[CurbStompCushion with tiny dents and a fist-sized dent from All Might]], everyone is left terrified and stunned speechless as the man is basically undefeatable.\\
'''You'd Expect''': Them to ''not do anything''. While doing nothing would mean cowardice, the problem is that the Slayer has, in the span of one night, [[OneManArmy singlehandedly slaughtered]] [[HeroKiller the most infamous mercenary organization,]] [[CruelAndUnusualDeath viciously ended Wolfram's group,]] [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere forced Curator and the Volcano Thieves to retreat when it became clear to them that fighting him would be suicidal (though the heroes arriving from the mainland and the ballroom heroes being freed played a part in that)]], knocked out 48 heroes (nearly 20 in the Top Ten of at least 13 nations) and bested All Might in combat. Not only that, but even with All Might levels of strength, none of them stand a chance against the man, as even [[OOCIsSeriousBusiness Miruko views attacking the Slayer as downright suicidal and moronic.]]\\
'''Instead''': Bakugou stupidly tries to fight the Slayer, [[TooDumbToLive despite the fact All Might got bested by the man.]]\\
'''The Result''': Bakugou gets predictably captured, forcing Miruko to try and save him... and get captured as well.\\
'''Even Worse''': When Bakugou tries to use his Quirk, it's despite the fact there's a leaking gas tanker and the area surrounding the Slayer was covered in gas. Had All Might and Miruko not screamed for him not to, the Slayer would not have noticed and hurled them away until it was too late, and society's views of Bakugou, had he killed the Number 1 and 5 Pro Heroes of Japan to stop a man not even All Might can beat, would be as a future villain in the making, provided the Slayer doesn't reduce Bakugou to a mangled and mutilated corpse because of that.
** In Chapter 18, Ragdoll's usage of her Quirk on the Doom Slayer has rendered her permanently insane (until Jeremiah removed those memories 10 chapters later), and Miruko isn't aware of it.\\
'''You'd Think''': That Hawks would tell her while they were leaving the medical facility of I-Island, or in Rumi's hospital room, or literally when they and the Slayer were fighting Wolfram. The only reason he doesn't reveal this to Sayaka and Mera was because four teens were here for the meeting (that being All Might's skinny form), and finding out one of the heroes went insane by reading the man's mind would be a bad idea.\\
'''Instead''': He doesn't.\\
'''The Result''': Miruko nearly gets an [[EyeScream eye gouged out]] by a completely insane Ragdoll.

Added: 49

Removed: 5984

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WhatAnIdiot/MyHeroAcademiaUnchainedPredator''



* ''Fanfic/HarryPotterAndTheMagicOfTheBeasts'':
** Dumbledore comes to Rita and asks her to do a slander campaign on Harry and Steve Feros to cement Harry as a Dark Lord in the making and try to use it as a means to disband the IWCO.\\
'''You'd Think''': That Dumbledore would ask Rita to be an independent reporter before going through with this plan, as he was gifting Rita Harry's vault key. Even though Harry is 11, he is the ward of Steve Feros, who is an IWCO agent who has killed off the French Malfoy line and numerous evil wizards and witches. Not only that, but if it was led back to Dumbledore, he would lose his ICW position instantly.\\
'''Instead''': He doesn't, gifts Rita Harry's vault key and expects it to work.\\
'''The Result''': Dumbledore is suspended from the ICW (though he later gets back in), Rita is fired and arrested for being an illegal animagus, bank fraud and MaliciousSlander, and the Daily Prophet is disbanded for a slew of crimes.
** Tarvos finds out that Harry and Steve had killed off the bulk of the Goyle family and had brought reports of a potential traitor in Lakjin's clan.\\
'''You'd Think''': He'd keep his mouth shut throughout all of this, or at the least, until after they reveal the Goyle family name.\\
'''Instead''': He stupidly blurts out that the Goyles are trustworthy wizards, the familial name only he is aware of.\\
'''The Result''': Tarvos outs himself as a traitor and after a CurbStompBattle from Harry, is banished from the troll village. Lampshaded by Harry during the conversation.
** Dumbledore finds out about the detention Harry, Emily, Hermione, Neville, Draco and Ron got for the baby dragon egg, and while Harry managed to talk himself, Emily, Hermione and Neville to a single detention, they had to be punished.\\
'''You'd Think''': He'd not have all six of them in the Forbidden Forest for a single detention, due to Hagrid reporting something attacking unicorns. After all, if something is attacking unicorns, it can and ''will'' attack the students.\\
'''Instead''': He has their detention changed to help Hagrid find whoever's attacking the unicorns in a bid to get Ron to have Harry killed.\\
'''The Result''': The planned assassination attempt fails, [[WhatTheHellHero 3 of the house heads and the Potters call him out for essentially endangering several students for no goddamn reason whatsoever]], and despite Harry saving one attacked unicorn, it was clear that they were sent to deal with a possessed individual, as Harry explains the spell used to kill wraiths.\\
'''Furthermore''': If it had killed Emily, it would render all of his plans for naught.
** During the Basilisk attacks, the marriage contract wedding Emily to Lockhart forces Lockhart to fight the Basilisk. When he manages to get Harry's wand, Harry warns him not to do anything stupid.\\
'''You'd Think''': He'd at the least do a test spell to see if the wand will listen to him.\\
'''Instead''': He does an overpowered Obliviate spell on Harry, Lily and Neville.\\
'''The Result''': Lockhart dies from a combination of blunt force trauma and an overstressed magical core, as Harry's wand contained Veela hair as one of its cores.
** When Snape leaks Hermione's Nekomata status to the British Ministry of Magic, Fudge, Umbridge and numerous pureblood bigots are disgusted at a [[FantasticRacism half-breed]] masquerading as a [[FantasticSlur mudblood]].\\
'''You'd Think''': They would look at the ICW laws to see if Hermione is protected under ICW laws.\\
'''Or at the Least''': Tell Snape to stop trying to antagonize Harry, as the last few attempts ended with Snape with spontaneous dancing fevers and was put on probation twice.\\
'''Instead''': The two arrive with Walden [=MacNair=] to Hogwarts and announce that they will execute Hermione unless Steve comes to be executed in her stead (though they would still execute her in the end, anyway).\\
'''The Result''': Harry nearly kills Fudge by disarming [=MacNair=] and forces them to read the international laws that reveal to them that yes, Hermione is protected under ICW law, and yes, what they were doing was illegal.\\
'''To Add Insult To Injury''': Snape is forcibly stripped of everything bar teaching potions, only escaping firing due to Dumbledore giving him tenure, as well as getting the entire Fudge Admin on completely thin ice for this short-sighted stunt along with a bunch of laws to be looked over. Meaning that if there are other magical creatures that are students of Hogwarts, not only can Fudge not do shit, but the British Ministry have already lost all power in their judicial system due to it being extremely biased in favor of purebloods.
** When Dumbledore plans for the upcoming third year after letting Pettigrew escape in order to be seen as the second coming of Merlin, he focuses on the Potter twins.\\
'''You'd Think''': After the marriage contract, he'd try to not do anything rash, as despite it being destroyed, if he is caught doing something illicit, he would be out of three positions.\\
'''Instead''': He tries to use the 'I'm concerned for your safety card' to bar the two from entering Hogsmeade.\\
'''The Result''': Harry mentions that Dumbledore did jackshit about the forced marriage contract between Emily and Lockhart, forcing him to fold immediately and let them go to Hogsmeade.
** Snape decides to sell off Hermione to Walden [=MacNair=] in Chapter 24, knowing that something like this would piss Harry off immensely.\\
'''You'd Think''': He'd keep his mouth shut about this. While it can be argued that Snape despises Harry for losing a lot of power over the years, if this got to the ICW, not only would he be out of a job, but he would be arrested for violation of international law.\\
'''Instead''': He brags about it to Harry.\\
'''The Result''': Harry knocks him out, [[LaserGuidedAmnesia obliviates him of the attack,]] has him do the [[Film/TheRockyHorrorPictureShow Time Warp]], and by Christmas, [[DeathByAdaptation kills Walden MacNair in retaliation.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WhatAnIdiot/HarryPotterAndTheMagicOfTheBeasts''

Added: 508

Changed: 26

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Fudaki had zapped out all the villains in the flood zone and Mineta was calling for him to join them in safety.\\
'''You'd Think''': He would abide by his teacher's orders. He is a 1st year student, after all, and survival is more easier alongside a group than alone.\\
'''Instead''': He ignores them and [[LeeroyJenkins charges off to fight the USJ Nomu by himself.]]\\
'''The Result''': Fudaki is killed by the USJ Nomu due to having a mix of SuicidalOverconfidence, TooDumbToLive and just plain stupidity.



'''The Result:''' Todoroki successfully gives Shigaraki cover and breaks the USJ Nomu out of being pinned, combined with Bakugou and Kirishima's brute force idea, meant that the Ocelot Unit couldn't shoot the USJ Nomu without hitting those three, and Todoroki's attempts ruined a well thought-out plan. Ocelot [[WhatTheHellHero rightfully calls the three out for being idiotic dumbasses for jumping into a situation that was already under control and making things more difficult.]] They narrowly escape expulsion and blacklisting by All Might's intervention, but Ocelot warns them if they try something like that again, they ''will'' be expelled and blacklisted, regardless of All Might's intervention or not.

to:

'''The Result:''' [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Todoroki successfully gives Shigaraki cover and breaks the USJ Nomu out of being pinned, combined with Bakugou and Kirishima's brute force idea, meant that the Ocelot Unit couldn't shoot the USJ Nomu without hitting those three, and Todoroki's attempts ruined a well thought-out plan. plan.]] Ocelot [[WhatTheHellHero rightfully calls the three out for being idiotic dumbasses for jumping into a situation that was already under control and making things more difficult.]] They narrowly escape expulsion and blacklisting by All Might's intervention, but Ocelot warns them if they try something like that again, they ''will'' be expelled and blacklisted, regardless of All Might's intervention or not.

Top