History WebVideo / ReviewingAReviewer

As Asa is quite vocal and opinionated, he has garnered a vocal base of detractors, and often was (and still is) the subject of strong criticism. Therefore, please remember the RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment.

Oh, and he is also the son of infamous physics theorist [[Creator/BillGaede Bill Gaede]].

* "Reviewing a Reviewer! #11 City Castration (Part 2 of 2) " (WebVideo/NC17Productions' review of ''VideoGame/CityConnection'')
* "Reviewing a Reviewer #12 - It'll Turn Your Stones" (WebVideo/VideoGameCritixCornr's review of ''VideoGame/SoulCalibur'' on [[UsefulNotes/SegaDreamcast Dreamcast]] and ''VideoGame/BlazBlue'' on UsefulNotes/PlayStation3; guest-starring Judekhanzo)

* "Reviewing a Reviewer #15.2 - A View Gone Neutral" (WebVideo/TheAngryVideoGameNerd's review of ''VideoGame/CrazyCastle'', and more comparison with Joey Roo)

* "Reviewing a Reviewer #23: For Old Times' Sake Part 2" (NC17's review of ''VideoGame/{{Ballz}}'')

* "Reviewing a Reviewer #13 - Retrogamer3" (Retrogamer3's review of ''VideoGame/IkariWarriors'' on NES)
* "Reviewing a Reviewer #14 - South of The Border" - CrazyVideoGammer

* "Reviewing a Reviewer #20: Reviewing a... Rapist?" (Retrogamer3's ''The Gaming Rapist'' a.k.a. ''The Welfare Gamer'' show)

* RealSongThemeTune: The theme tune of ''Reviewing A Reviewer'' is Blue Mary's theme from the ''VideoGame/FatalFury'' game series.

As Asa is quite vocal and opinionated, he has garnered a vocal {{Hatedom}}, and often was (and still is) the subject of strong criticism. Therefore, please remember the RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgment.

* LadyLooksLikeADude: Asa is accused of misgendering Seidelman, subject of "RAR #41", who identified as female in recent years.

* "Reviewing A Reviewer #38: Popeular [=MeKanics=]" ([=MatPat=], [[WebVideo/GameTheoryWebShow The Game Theorists]])

** He started his RAR series mocking the IrateGamer's infamous videos. Gradually, though, he realized how ''way'' too many people were bashing IG after it stopped being relevant, and after someone claimed IG called him the N-word, Asa deconstructed his accusation (showing how it was easy to fabricate a browser page to make it say whatever you wanted), which was the start of good terms. He then made friends with Irate Gamer since the latter's rant on the E-begging epidemic sparked by the ''Film/AngryVideoGameNerdTheMovie'' Indiegogo campaign and Greg Pabich's ''[[VideoGame/{{Action52}} Cheetahmen II: The Lost Levels]]'' Kickstarter campaign (which showed the Angry Video Game Nerd in the promo for the Kickstarter). Though in recent times this friendship is speculated to have taken a turn for the worse, based on the non-numbered episode ''RAR: Kid Icarus, Then And Now'' (Asa made it clear that they are still on good terms, however).

** Asa had a brief falling-out with Silent Rob, going as far as making a music video to make fun of him. However, they buried the hatchet.
** Drunken Punk also had a falling-out with Asa and as of 2018, are not on good terms.

** He made friends with Irate Gamer ever since the latter's rant on the E-begging epidemic sparked by the ''Film/AngryVideoGameNerdTheMovie'' Indiegogo campaign and Greg Pabich's ''[[VideoGame/{{Action52}} Cheetahmen II: The Lost Levels]]'' Kickstarter campaign (which showed the Angry Video Game Nerd in the promo for the Kickstarter). Though in recent times this friendship is speculated to have taken a turn for the worse, based on the non-numbered episode ''RAR: Kid Icarus, Then And Now'' (Asa made it clear that they are still on good terms, however).
** After all of their numerous feuds stemming from the false-flag controversy, Asa made friends with Jfreedan enough for him to even appear in one of Asa's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fu7fkVIKDOU April Fools videos.]]

** On two April Fool's videos: in one, the Irate Gamer is shown to have taken over Asalieri's channel. In the other, it is [=JFreeDan=] who has taken over the channel, and he intends to change "Reviewing A Reviewer" to "[=RPGs=] Are Reality".

** He has adressed his own FilibusterFreefall in an episode.

* StrawFeminist: Has a strong dislike towards "third-wave" feminists and his videos strongly reflected this for a while.

* TheyCopiedItSoItSucks: Usually how he judges some reviewers influenced by the AngryVideoGameNerd or WebVideo/TheNostalgiaCritic. But this is ''definitely'' his opinion on "[[WebVideo/TheReviewReviewer Those Dudes With The Hat]]" as he thinks they stole ''his'' shtick.

* TheyCopiedItSoItSucks: Usually how he judges some reviewers influenced by the AngryVideoGameNerd or NostalgiaCritic. But this is ''definitely'' his opinion on "[[WebVideo/TheReviewReviewer Those Dudes With The Hat]]" as he thinks they stole ''his'' shtick.

* TheCameo: [[spoiler: Kai-lan]] from ''[[spoiler:WesternAnimation/NiHaoKaiLan]]'' at the end of "RAR #41".

** He made friends with Irate Gamer ever since the latter's rant on the E-begging epidemic sparked by the ''Film/AngryVideoGameNerdTheMovie'' Indiegogo campaign and Greg Pabich's ''[[VideoGame/{{Action52}} Cheetahmen II: The Lost Levels]]'' Kickstarter campaign (which showed the Angry Video Game Nerd in the promo for the Kickstarter). Though in recent times this friendship is speculated to have taken a turn for the worse, based on the non-numbered episode ''RAR: Kid Icarus, Then And Now''.

* SpoilerOpening: In the opening of RAR #41 during the Family Feud parody. The host askes the player (since Family Feud has a game) with the question "Name A Really Shitty Youtuber". The player then types "[[spoiler:Mr Ent]]". Guess what the [=RAR=] subject in the future [=RAR=]s will be.

A web series by Eric "Asalieri" Gaede (he is commonly called "Asa"). His main gimmick is that he reviews other reviewers (A meta-review show, oddly enough). He also has other assorted videos, including ''Masterpaint Theatre'', where he reads terrible fanfiction exactly the way it was worded with [[StylisticSuck intentionally bad MS paint drawings to go along with them,]].

It is worth noting that Asa is quite vocal and opinionated to the extent that he has garnered an ''extremely'' vocal {{Hatedom}}, and often was (and still is) the subject of vicious criticism to the extent of even having several of his videos falsely flagged for copyright infringement (even when said videos sometimes contained no copyrighted footage at all).

Please keep FlameBait off of this page, thank you very much. Not to be confused with WebVideo/TheReviewReviewer.

** [[Webvideo/ReactionAndReview Hellsing290]] asked him to review himself, but Asa passed on the offer. When they had a falling out, Asa did a video bearing the "RAR" name, but was more of a rant against Emer's recent actions rather than his show itself.

** He also criticizes Seidelman of ''Gameshow Garbage'' for being guilty of the same flaws he assigns to gameshows she reviews. Especially when she tries to do her ''own'' gameshow.

Please keep FlameBait off of this page, thank you very much.

** Parodied when he accuses DrunkenPunk of fat-shaming him in "RAR #41".

** Parodied when he accuses Silent Rob of fat-shaming him in "RAR #41".

** [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic Bronies]]. He is a brony himself, but is perfectly aware of the insanity of some of the MLP fanbase.

** Anyone who fat shams him as seen in "RAR #41".

* DeconstructiveParody: Asa did these to parody any reviewer featured in RAR.

* LadyLooksLikeADude: Asa is accused of misgendering Seidelman, subject of "RAR #41", who identified as a woman in recent years.

** He also criticizes Seidelman of ''Gameshow Garbage'' for being guilty of the same flaws he assigns to gameshows he reviews. Especially when he tries to do his ''own'' gameshow.

* RealSoonNow: His [[spoiler:WebVideo/TheMysteriousMrEnter]] RAR isn't completed as of October 2 but it is rumored to be released on Halloween with [[spoiler:a horror tone]].

* BilingualBonus: Asa can speak very fluent Spanish, and occasionally makes obscure puns and references in the language. He even made an RAR entirely in Spanish, and graded a Wheneverthehell contest entry made in Spanish.

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Gives a notable one to [[AtopTheFourthWall Linkara]] when criticizing him about his infamous ''"Please let the ads play"'' (aka "Adgate") message. It remains one of his most popular videos (Asalieri's).

* RealSoonNow: His [[spoiler:WebVideo/TheMysteriousMrEnter]] RAR isn't completed as of October 2 but it is rumored to be released on Halloween.

* SpoilerOpening: In the opening of RAR #41 during the Family Feud parody. The host askes the player (since Family Feud has a game) with the question "Name A Really Shitty Youtuber". The player then types "[[spoiler:Mr Ent]]". Guess what the RAR subject in the future RARs will be.

* "Reviewing A Reviewer #42: Demeaning Of Life"([=TedBarrus=])

* RealSoonNow: His [[WebVideo/TheMysteriousMrEnter spoiler:Mr. Enter]] RAR isn't completed as of October 2 but it is rumored to be released on Halloween.

* RealSoonNow: His [WebVideo/TheMysteriousMrEnter spoiler:Mr. Enter]] RAR isn't completed as of October 2 but it is rumored to be released on Halloween.

* RealSoonNow: His [[spoiler:MrEnter]] RAR isn't completed as of October 2 but it is rumored to be released on Halloween.

* SpoilerOpening: In the opening of RAR #41 during the Family Feud parody. The host askes the player (since Family Feud has a game) with the question "Name A Really Shitty Youtuber". The player then types "[[spoiler:Mr Ent]]". Guess what the 42th RAR subject will be.