Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / StarTrekVoyager

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Honestly, the only plausible explanation for their reproductive biology, lifespan, etc. is that some other species genetically engineered them to be pets or slaves; because there is no way a species like the Ocampa would survive for long "in the wild" with natural selection in full effect.

to:

Honestly, the only plausible explanation for their reproductive biology, lifespan, etc. is that some other species genetically engineered them to be pets or slaves; because there slaves. There is no way a species like the Ocampa would survive for long "in the wild" with natural selection in full effect.
effect; they would need their masters to take care of them, much the same way dogs and other domesticated animals are dependent on their humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Ocampa were genetically engineered]]
Honestly, the only plausible explanation for their reproductive biology, lifespan, etc. is that some other species genetically engineered them to be pets or slaves; because there is no way a species like the Ocampa would survive for long "in the wild" with natural selection in full effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Ocampan telepathy is dependent on other telepathic lifeforms to properly develop.]]
In "Cold Fire," the advanced Ocampa of Suspiria's array have a telepathic connection to her (and of course, Susperia is an extremely advanced alien). Kes's powers developed gradually ''as she trained with Tuvok,'' and they took off like a rocket after a brief conversation with Species 8472. Before the Caretaker decimated their homeworld, their planet may have been filled with other telepathic lifeforms, and a mental connection to said life was crucial in their telepathic development. And recall that Kes's branch of the Ocampa were a small group of nonconformists who grew their own food; the rest just got everything from the Caretaker. Odds are, their powers dropped not only because they "stopped using them," but because they no longer had the living connections necessary to do so. In other words, how weak or strong or out-of-control an Ocampa's powers are, is directly related to how powerful other telepaths interacting with them are.

Added: 613

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Ensign Marie Kaplan appeared in a few episodes before being killed off in "Unity." But seasons later, an ensign Kaplan is still mentioned as being alive and well. Memory Alpha assumes Voyager simply had two Ensign Kaplans; but the ship already has two Ensign Langs, so that's a stretch. The fact is, the senior staff have all died and come back more than once, so there's no reason to think no one else onboard did. There's also no reason to think the same ten people had life-changing experiences in the Delta Quadrant while the other 140 crewmembers just pressed buttons for seven years. Kaplan was somehow revived by friendly drones on that planet, got a shuttle and found her way back to Voyager not long after the end of the episode.

to:

Ensign Marie Kaplan appeared in a few episodes before being killed off in "Unity." But seasons one season later, an ensign Kaplan is still mentioned as being alive and well. Memory Alpha assumes Voyager simply had two Ensign Kaplans; but the ship already has two Ensign Langs, so that's a stretch. The fact is, the senior staff have all died and come back more than once, so there's no reason to think no one else onboard did. There's also no reason to think the same ten people had life-changing experiences in the Delta Quadrant while the other 140 crewmembers just pressed buttons for seven years. Kaplan was somehow revived by friendly drones on that planet, got a shuttle and found her way back to Voyager not long after the end of the episode. \n

[[WMG: Ensign Kaplan simply died, and the dialogue blunder was deliberate]]
The only time an "Ensign Kaplan" was mentioned being still alive, after "Unity," was in "Vis a Vis" when Harry Kim talked about a golfing match against "Ensign Kaplan" ... to ''Steth disguised as Tom.'' Kaplan was dead, and Harry knew it, and Harry knew Tom would know it. He deliberately said that because he was suspicious that something was wrong with "Tom," and wanted to see how or if he'd notice. Had the conversation lasted a bit longer, maybe Harry would've added "And after that, don't forget our double date with Kes and Seska."

Added: 738

Changed: 46

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[WMG: Ensign Kaplan came back from the dead]]
Ensign Marie Kaplan appeared in a few episodes before being killed off in "Unity." But seasons later, an ensign Kaplan is still mentioned as being alive and well. Memory Alpha assumes Voyager simply had two Ensign Kaplans; but the ship already has two Ensign Langs, so that's a stretch. The fact is, the senior staff have all died and come back more than once, so there's no reason to think no one else onboard did. There's also no reason to think the same ten people had life-changing experiences in the Delta Quadrant while the other 140 crewmembers just pressed buttons for seven years. Kaplan was somehow revived by friendly drones on that planet, got a shuttle and found her way back to Voyager not long after the end of the episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Clarified situation in the UK w.r.t. paedophile Neelix

Added DiffLines:

** Although the consent age is 16 in the UK, that doesn't say anything about social taboos. Teenage-adult relationships are frowned upon in the UK just as much as they are in other Western societies; the consent age just means two 16 year olds can go at it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: S6E1 The Doctor never was going to kill Seven of Nine]]

to:

[[WMG: S6E1 [=S6E1=] The Doctor never was going to kill Seven of Nine]]



* The Federation spaceships like the Enterprise were not military ships, they were for diplomacy and exploration, the Federation does have ships for deep space and dangerous missions that do not have places for children or families (the Defiance for example). Even when diplomacy and exploration can be dangerous, clearly is not less dangerous that having colonies or space stations, we see a lot of colonies getting destroyed by alien forces and all the things that happens in DS9, so why leave Earth for that matter if you’re afraid of people getting kill then don’t have ships, nor space stations nor colonies. And like exploration may take many many years, who would volunteer to go if they can’t bring their families with them? Also you couldn’t let crewmembers having romances and relationships among them because pregnancies can happen, and don’t let them have pets either because to some degree putting animals in danger is very similar as putting children, so you’ll have an entire ship of sexually frustrated, lonely and depressive explorers doing diplomatic work and handling many first contact situation. Clearly the idea in general is that people in exploration ships are not militars, they’re scientists, explorers, diplomats, etc., even though some have certain militar training, and thus is necessary for them to have husbands/wives, children, pets, etc., like any normal person, otherwise the ships will be mostly empty. And for the danger, again, is not more dangerous than living in a colony anyway.

to:

* The Federation spaceships like the Enterprise were not military ships, they were for diplomacy and exploration, the Federation does have ships for deep space and dangerous missions that do not have places for children or families (the Defiance for example). Even when diplomacy and exploration can be dangerous, clearly is not less dangerous that having colonies or space stations, we see a lot of colonies getting destroyed by alien forces and all the things that happens in DS9, ''[=DS9=]'', so why leave Earth for that matter if you’re afraid of people getting kill then don’t have ships, nor space stations nor colonies. And like exploration may take many many years, who would volunteer to go if they can’t bring their families with them? Also you couldn’t let crewmembers crew-members having romances and relationships among them because pregnancies can happen, and don’t let them have pets either because to some degree putting animals in danger is very similar as putting children, so you’ll have an entire ship of sexually frustrated, lonely and depressive explorers doing diplomatic work and handling many first contact situation. Clearly the idea in general is that people in exploration ships are not militars, military, they’re scientists, explorers, diplomats, etc., even though some have certain militar military training, and thus is necessary for them to have husbands/wives, children, pets, etc., like any normal person, otherwise the ships will be mostly empty. And for the danger, again, is not more dangerous than living in a colony anyway.



# For those who follow Website/SFDebris, here's a more snarky one: the security detail was essentially Starfleet's Film/PoliceAcademy unit. All the misfits and idiots who somehow got through training were all assigned to it since ''Voyager'' would be doing easy research and thus was a low-priority vessel (compared to the ''Enterprise'' or [=DS9=] which required elite security forces).

to:

# For those who follow Website/SFDebris, here's a more snarky one: the security detail was essentially Starfleet's Film/PoliceAcademy unit. All the misfits and idiots who somehow got through training were all assigned to it since ''Voyager'' would be doing easy research and thus was a low-priority vessel (compared to the ''Enterprise'' or [=DS9=] ''[=DS9=]'' which required elite security forces).

Added: 193

Changed: 157

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added theories about Seven of Nine and the Ocampa


[[WMG: Seven of Nine became a Borg Queen when she created the temporary hive mind.]]
Whether she was prepared or not, the act of creating the hive mind and linking in the others is all it takes.




to:

* The Caretakers and Ocampa are actually the same species, with the Ocampa forming the "larval" stage. Those who "died" after 9 years have actually ascended.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** That would have been a good name for The Doctor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** So, the Kazon are [[TabletopGame/Warhammer40000 Orks]]? That... Kind of makes sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Icheb grew up to be a doctor]]
We can safely assume Icheb will go into some field involving science. But growing up, he has repeatedly been used as a weapon against his will--first as a Trojan horse against the Borg, then being assimilated, and then his and the other Borgletts' attempts to assimilate after they were cut off from the Collective. Icheb will want to compensate for this guilt and escape being a tool for murder, by going into the field of medicine.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: S6E1 B'Elanna's ex-boyfriend/the ''Equinox's'' First officer, Maxwell Burke, was emotionally abusive]]

Evidence: B'Elanna practically glues herself to Tom Paris when Burke approaches her in the mess hall. Also, her line when she sees Burke on the upper level of engineering alone; "Going through my stuff again?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: S6E1 The Doctor never was going to kill Seven of Nine]]

When the Doctors ethical subroutines where removed, he immediately and gladly jumped to the aid of a hostile captain. This troper believes that even without ethics, at the very least his pride would make this scenario impossible. Instead of doing the described operation on Seven, he used her implants to create a projection of her in Cpt Ransom's holoprogram, in order to persuade him to change his ways, and to mess with him in general. The ''unpleasantness'' referred to later on the voyager was not the attempted lobomoty, but the way the Doctor did this without telling Seven, and without making any effort to make her less scared or in pain during this procedure. This troper is fairly convinced that most of this WMG was the original intention, which got lost in editing, likely to have Ransom's heel-face-turn seem more important. This WMG has the advantage of not undercutting the entire story-arc of the doctor being a sapient being and making Sevens presence in Ransom´s holoprogram significantly more sensible.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Species 8472 are [[Main/{{Starcraft}} Protoss/Zerg-Hybrids]], and the Fluid Space is what the {{Starcraft}} universe will turn into when Purity of Form and Purity of Essence are combined.]]

to:

[[WMG: Species 8472 are [[Main/{{Starcraft}} [[VideoGame/StarCraft Protoss/Zerg-Hybrids]], and the Fluid Space is what the {{Starcraft}} ''VideoGame/StarCraft'' universe will turn into when Purity of Form and Purity of Essence are combined.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** "Doo-TURRY-um" is the 24th century equivalent of "NOOK-you-lurr." Since collecting deuterium is so simple and routine people don't even think about it, so when someone says "doo-TURRY-um" everyone knows they actually mean duoterium.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* But she did! Don't you remember the final shot of "Scorpion, Part Two", with pre-catsuit Seven lying on the biobed while the camera tracks across her prominently-raised Borg implants?

to:

* But she did! Don't you remember the final shot of "Scorpion, Part Two", with pre-catsuit Seven lying on the biobed while the camera tracks across her prominently-raised Borg implants?
implants? ''Besides they are what actress Jeri Ryan actually had, so of course she had them all along''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spelling correction


* Long ago, Chakotay had a Spirit Quest that went horribly wrong. Now, every once in a while, he gets possessed by the ghost of Nicholas Cadge.

to:

* Long ago, Chakotay had a Spirit Quest that went horribly wrong. Now, every once in a while, he gets possessed by the ghost of Nicholas Cadge.Cage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
correct spelling


Elsewhere, we have seen that promotions are more likely to come from Starfleet Command, with only the occasional field promotion granted purely at the captain's discretion. So there was a reasonable explanation for Harry's LimitedAdvancementOpportunities when ''Voyager'' was out of touch with the Federation. ''But these were extremely unusual conditions and she did the extremely unusual if not unheard of for many others. She made Chakotay (a traitor in Star Fleet eyes) first officer, made people who had never been Star Fleet personnel officers like Tores (Lieutenant JG and later promoted her to Chief Engineer), she promoted Paris once, etc. There is no real explanation for not giving a field promotion to Ensign Kim''But once they had regular communications you would think that they would recommend some merit promotions to Janeway -- unless she was doctoring her reports such that the crew members she wanted to hold at their current rank were listed as losers.

to:

Elsewhere, we have seen that promotions are more likely to come from Starfleet Command, with only the occasional field promotion granted purely at the captain's discretion. So there was a reasonable explanation for Harry's LimitedAdvancementOpportunities when ''Voyager'' was out of touch with the Federation. ''But these were extremely unusual conditions and she did the extremely unusual if not unheard of for many others. She made Chakotay (a traitor in Star Fleet eyes) first officer, made people who had never been Star Fleet personnel officers like Tores Torres (Lieutenant JG and later promoted her to Chief Engineer), she promoted Paris once, etc. There is no real explanation for not giving a field promotion to Ensign Kim''But once they had regular communications you would think that they would recommend some merit promotions to Janeway -- unless she was doctoring her reports such that the crew members she wanted to hold at their current rank were listed as losers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
elaboration on the harry kim situation


Elsewhere, we have seen that promotions are more likely to come from Starfleet Command, with only the occasional field promotion granted purely at the captain's discretion. So there was a reasonable explanation for Harry's LimitedAdvancementOpportunities when ''Voyager'' was out of touch with the Federation. But once they had regular communications you would think that they would recommend some merit promotions to Janeway -- unless she was doctoring her reports such that the crew members she wanted to hold at their current rank were listed as losers.

to:

Elsewhere, we have seen that promotions are more likely to come from Starfleet Command, with only the occasional field promotion granted purely at the captain's discretion. So there was a reasonable explanation for Harry's LimitedAdvancementOpportunities when ''Voyager'' was out of touch with the Federation. But ''But these were extremely unusual conditions and she did the extremely unusual if not unheard of for many others. She made Chakotay (a traitor in Star Fleet eyes) first officer, made people who had never been Star Fleet personnel officers like Tores (Lieutenant JG and later promoted her to Chief Engineer), she promoted Paris once, etc. There is no real explanation for not giving a field promotion to Ensign Kim''But once they had regular communications you would think that they would recommend some merit promotions to Janeway -- unless she was doctoring her reports such that the crew members she wanted to hold at their current rank were listed as losers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Caretaker is Literature/{{the Wizard of Oz}}: He’s not a bad man. He’s just a very bad wizard/caretaker.

to:

* The Caretaker is Literature/{{the [[Literature/TheWonderfulWizardOfOz the Wizard of Oz}}: Oz]]: He’s not a bad man. He’s just a very bad wizard/caretaker.
wizard/caretaker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing bad links.


TNG and DS9 had Moriarty and Vic Fontaine as rough holographic equivalents, respectively. Vic Fontaine had real world awareness but was always strictly limited by his parameters, thus indicating merely simulated sentience rather than actual sentience. Moriarty seemed to come much closer, but due to careless linking of the Holodeck computer and the main computer, he was able to "outsmart Data" even outside of the holodeck. With all said and done, no strong evidence of sentience was presented in those episodes either.

to:

TNG and DS9 Deep Space Nine had Moriarty and Vic Fontaine as rough holographic equivalents, respectively. Vic Fontaine had real world awareness but was always strictly limited by his parameters, thus indicating merely simulated sentience rather than actual sentience. Moriarty seemed to come much closer, but due to careless linking of the Holodeck computer and the main computer, he was able to "outsmart Data" even outside of the holodeck. With all said and done, no strong evidence of sentience was presented in those episodes either.



The bio-neural gel packs seem to be the most likely cause of the Doctor's sentience. They are essentially biological computers, but they also "think" like any biological entity might. They get sick like any organism. They may very well be classified as life forms in the STuniverse's future. As for the Doctor, he not only started to show signs of sentience from early in the first season, but he also gained emotions that Zimmerman would have considered superfluous -- especially in the episode ''Real Life''. He advanced far beyond Data in a far shorter time span. A biological component would bring sense to what would otherwise be a gaping plot hole. Oh, and in case you're wondering about the EMH Mark I's who were converted to miners, it's likely that the gel pack technology was mass distributed in the Alpha Quadrant by then. (six years after the series began)

to:

The bio-neural gel packs seem to be the most likely cause of the Doctor's sentience. They are essentially biological computers, but they also "think" like any biological entity might. They get sick like any organism. They may very well be classified as life forms in the STuniverse's Star Trek universe's future. As for the Doctor, he not only started to show signs of sentience from early in the first season, but he also gained emotions that Zimmerman would have considered superfluous -- especially in the episode ''Real Life''. He advanced far beyond Data in a far shorter time span. A biological component would bring sense to what would otherwise be a gaping plot hole. Oh, and in case you're wondering about the EMH Mark I's who were converted to miners, it's likely that the gel pack technology was mass distributed in the Alpha Quadrant by then. (six years after the series began)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The bio-neural gel packs are responsible for the Doctor's sentience

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The bio-neural gel packs are responsible for the Doctor's sentience]]

TNG and DS9 had Moriarty and Vic Fontaine as rough holographic equivalents, respectively. Vic Fontaine had real world awareness but was always strictly limited by his parameters, thus indicating merely simulated sentience rather than actual sentience. Moriarty seemed to come much closer, but due to careless linking of the Holodeck computer and the main computer, he was able to "outsmart Data" even outside of the holodeck. With all said and done, no strong evidence of sentience was presented in those episodes either.

Meanwhile on Voyager, a sentient EMH emerged out of nowhere. It was assumed to have been because he was left running for long periods of time, but holodeck addiction ("holodiction") was a well documented condition for decades by the time Voyager's EMH was activated -- the most famous afflicted being Reginald Barclay. One could safely assume that civilians with exclusive access to a holodeck could run programs for months without interruption. This debunks the notion that time + humanoid hologram = sentience.

The bio-neural gel packs seem to be the most likely cause of the Doctor's sentience. They are essentially biological computers, but they also "think" like any biological entity might. They get sick like any organism. They may very well be classified as life forms in the STuniverse's future. As for the Doctor, he not only started to show signs of sentience from early in the first season, but he also gained emotions that Zimmerman would have considered superfluous -- especially in the episode ''Real Life''. He advanced far beyond Data in a far shorter time span. A biological component would bring sense to what would otherwise be a gaping plot hole. Oh, and in case you're wondering about the EMH Mark I's who were converted to miners, it's likely that the gel pack technology was mass distributed in the Alpha Quadrant by then. (six years after the series began)

With this theory established, it does suggest a couple things. First is that the mobile emitter likely has biological components. Second, and somewhat disturbingly, all holograms on Voyager may have been capable of sentience. Since sentience in humans doesn't manifest immediately, it's possible that the majority of holograms never achieved it. That said, when the pool hall and tropical resort were retired, the crew may have destroyed dozens of sentient beings. Those holograms were subject to similar interactions as the Doctor and were also run for long periods of time.

In other words, modern Starfleet holodecks are like concentration camps and holo-mining operations are like Gulags.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There might have been a "third option" for Seska...the Doctor. If Starfleet has a liberal enough doctor-patient confidentiality policy, she could have informed the Doctor and negotiate protection even if the Doctor was forced to inform Janeway. Seeing how Alpha Quadrant politics are of no concern to the Voyager crew, it could have happened. If anything, though, Michael Jonas is the mentally ill one. What would possess him to side with both Voyager and the Maquis' combined enemies?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Badass is no longer a trope.


As is connected with the theory above according to Q himself (albeit he is a UnreliableNarrator) the Q probably already knew about the "Truth" of the universe yet still have a "meh" attitude about it (which unto itself is proof of how pretty powerful and truly BadAss the continuum really is!). the Q probably eons ago came across the Milky Way galaxy and our little blue ball and slowly over time most of them (at least the ones who weren't complete {{JerkAss}}es) grew to have a soft spot for humanity and after a while decided to keep this area of space safe for a while.

to:

As is connected with the theory above according to Q himself (albeit he is a UnreliableNarrator) the Q probably already knew about the "Truth" of the universe yet still have a "meh" attitude about it (which unto itself is proof of how pretty powerful and truly BadAss badass the continuum really is!). the Q probably eons ago came across the Milky Way galaxy and our little blue ball and slowly over time most of them (at least the ones who weren't complete {{JerkAss}}es) grew to have a soft spot for humanity and after a while decided to keep this area of space safe for a while.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: We're actually seeing two different versions of Voyager from different timelines.]]
This is why Janeway seems to have multiple personalities; we're seeing two versions of her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Ocampa and Kazon are highly evolved plants and fungi, respectively.]]

No, the Ocampa aren't descended from literal flowers or trees. But they're plants like Zhaan from [[Series/{{Farscape}} Farscape]]. If plant-like beings were to start becoming intelligent, telepathy would be a plausible beginning for them (plausible by soft-sci-fi standards at least). Also bear in mind that moving plants exist on Earth. Add millions or billions of years, and you have an animal species that still shares traits with their plant ancestors, including that telepathy, and photosynthesis (or something similar). This would add new meaning not only to Kes's love for plants, but also to the Ocampa having their home tragically turned into a desert, and Kes's anger at the Caretaker keeping them from the sun.

Ocampan ears also have a slightly plant-like effect (shape vaguely like a leaf, ripples vaguely like a tree trunk's rings.)

As for the Kazon, fungi ancestry would not only explain the hair, but also the scavenger tendencies, and the stupidity. And also the Borg's dismissal of the Kazon being "unworthy of assimilation." The Borg aren't interested in assimilating walking mushrooms.

If it seems unlikely that plants and mushrooms would ever take on humanoid form, remember the episode of [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration TNG]] where it was revealed that all Humanois are descended from one highly advanced species that distributed its DNA throughout the galaxy. Humanoids could've evolved from anything, if alien programing was involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* I would assume that during the Cold War, they came up with a date where temporal changes are considered history and not subject to change. Because Janeway's "mission" was JUST after reliable time travel was invented in the alpha quadrant, it was before the cutoff date.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** But she did! Don't you remember the final shot of "Scorpion, Part Two", with pre-catsuit Seven lying on the biobed while the camera tracks across her prominently-raised Borg implants?

to:

** * But she did! did! Don't you remember the final shot of "Scorpion, Part Two", with pre-catsuit Seven lying on the biobed while the camera tracks across her prominently-raised Borg implants?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** But she did! Don't you remember the final shot of "Scorpion, Part Two", with pre-catsuit Seven lying on the biobed while the camera tracks across her prominently-raised Borg implants?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* A simpler explanation is that Vorik clearly has the hots for B'Elanna, in an 'opposites attract' way. The ''pon farr'' just gave him the impetus to spit it out.

Top