History WMG / PretentiousGame

In the online version of the third game, Magenta's son is colored blue. Granted, Magenta's husband and son are both colored blue in the first game, but that can be chalked up to EarlyInstallmentWeirdness. Also, since Gray is colored, well, [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin gray]] in the third game, if Magenta's son is supposed to be his, then the son ought to be gray, too, but he isn't. I'd be willing to accept that as an honest mistake by Keybol, because Magenta's son is gray-colored post-third game, except for two things: 1) One line of text in the fourth game reads, "They say history repeats itself," then the game shows Magenta's son getting into a situation that mirrors Blue's almost exactly. 2) Magenta's story in the third game starts with, "I was once a mistress, ''and always will be''." If Magenta is meant to be entirely faithful to Gray, then why the "and always will be" part? Sure, it could be a reference to [[NeverLiveItDown no one ever letting her live down the fact that she was in a relationship with Gray while he was with Peach]], but Magenta still could've said something else to convey guilt or shame, like Gray does ("I was once a player, and this is my karma").

In the online version of the third game, Magenta's son is colored blue. Granted, Magenta's husband and son are both colored blue in the first game, but that can be chalked up to EarlyInstallmentWeirdness. Also, since Gray is colored, well, [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin gray]] in the third game, if Magenta's son is supposed to be his, then the son ought to be gray, too, but he isn't. I'd be willing to accept that as an honest mistake by Keybol, because Magenta's son is gray-colored in the fourth game, except for two things: 1) One line of text reads, "They say history repeats itself," then the game shows Magenta's son getting into a situation that mirrors Blue's almost exactly. 2) Magenta's story in the third game starts with, "I was once a mistress, ''and always will be''." If Magenta is meant to be entirely faithful to Gray, then why the "and always will be" part? Sure, it could be a reference to [[NeverLiveItDown no one ever letting her live down the fact that she was in a relationship with Gray while he was with Peach]], but Magenta still could've said something else to convey guilt or shame, like Gray does ("I was once a player, and this is my karma").

The ending text in the fourth game explicitly states that Magenta has done plenty of good things. Whether she founded her own hospital or simply has the job of a doctor, it would show that she's perfectly capable of saving lives, not just ruining them.

What could have happened is this: Some time after Gray and Magenta got married, Gray fell back into his womanizing habits. When Magenta found out, instead of divorcing him straightaway like Peach did, she turned to Blue for comfort. Blue had either fallen out of love with Peach and only remained with her out of pity or [[ReplacementGoldfish he'd been using her as a placeholder girlfriend the whole time]], but either way, he and Magenta ended up having a one-night stand, which resulted in a son that Magenta passed off as her husband's. Gray might have been suspicious that his second wife was cheating on him, and the fact that he was the one to drive her to that point could have been another reason for him to feel guilty enough to become an alcoholic. Peach, however, had no idea that anything was going on between Blue and Magenta.

What could have happened is this: Some time after Gray and Magenta got married, Gray fell back into his womanizing habits. When Magenta found out, instead of divorcing him straightaway like Peach did, she turned to Blue for comfort. Blue had either fallen out of love with Peach and only remained with her out of pity or [[ReplacementGoldfish he'd been using her as a placeholder girlfriend the whole time]], but either way, he and Magenta end up having a one-night stand, which results in a son that Magenta passed off as her husband's. Gray might have been suspicious that his second wife was cheating on him, and the fact that he was the one to drive her to that point could have been another reason for him to feel guilty enough to become an alcoholic. Peach, however, had no idea that anything was going on between Blue and Magenta.