Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicSettingEquestrianCulture

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Pinkie Pie and the Cakes consistently use the term "baby-sitter" and they all live in Ponyville. Twilight, Shining Armor, and Cadence use the term "foal-sitter" and they all grew up in Canterlot. So the difference in language is probably regional.

to:

Pinkie Pie and the Cakes consistently use the term "baby-sitter" and they all live in Ponyville. Twilight, Shining Armor, and Cadence Cadance use the term "foal-sitter" and they all grew up in Canterlot. So the difference in language is probably regional.



* This also explains the [[StevenUlyssesPerhero stangely meaningful names]] of some ponies. Their actual names contained no lexical elements that made sense to the translators, who then just willy-nilly made up some names that the voice actors can pronounce, by random association from cutie marks or personality traits. Therefore a pony that the translators first had to name ''after'' their cutie mark appeared will often have an English name that refers to it, but nothing can be learned from the names of ponies that the translators had to name ''without'' such knowledge.

to:

* This also explains the [[StevenUlyssesPerhero stangely strangely meaningful names]] of some ponies. Their actual names contained no lexical elements that made sense to the translators, who then just willy-nilly made up some names that the voice actors can pronounce, by random association from cutie marks or personality traits. Therefore a pony that the translators first had to name ''after'' their cutie mark appeared will often have an English name that refers to it, but nothing can be learned from the names of ponies that the translators had to name ''without'' such knowledge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing until I see the episode again


* Windigos don't burn, and can't really be caught, being spirits of cold and ice and hate. You seem to have confused them for timber wolves.

to:

* Windigos don't burn, and can't really be caught, being spirits of cold and ice and hate. You seem to have confused them for timber wolves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Windigos don't burn, and can't really be caught, being spirits of cold and ice and hate. You seem to have confused them for timber wolves.

Added: 11

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The ponies wear saddles and occasionally bridles as a tribute to the now long extinct race of "gods" that created their civilization.

to:

[[WMG: The ponies wear saddles and occasionally bridles as a tribute to the now long extinct race of "gods" that created their civilization.]]


Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

Added: 514

Changed: 138

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]]The ponies wear saddles and occasionally bridles as a tribute to the now long extinct race of "gods" that created their civilization.
The social structure, buildings, economic system and agricultural society depicted in Equestria are all human. Clearly humans wiped themselves out taking the environment along with them, but not before an intelligent race of equines began to evolve. They may even have been engineered by humans. As a tribute to their long-dead gods they continued to wear saddles and bridles. Of course now saddles have a more practical function for carrying things, but bridles continue to be worn for a purely ceremonial reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Ponyville celebrates Nightmare Night differently than most Equestrian towns.]]
* This is partly to explain the whole "WTH was Celestia doing letting Nightmare Night stain her good sister's name" thing. Basically, Celestia ''did'' try her hardest to steer the holiday away from the image of Nightmare Moon... but mostly in the big, important cities like Canterlot and Manehattan, which she thought that Luna would have cared more about. Small rural center like Ponyville, she just didn't have time for, so they retained an ancient tradition into modern day, [[TruthInTelevision much like many real-life small towns across the US]]. To make things clear: other cities in Equestria do celebrate Nightmare Night, but their versions focus almost entirely on the candy and costumes, without the need for a "central" monster.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Hearth's Warming involved a StableTimeLoop. ]]
We can see a unicorn that is obviously young Starswirl living in Equestria during Tirek's first invasion. Starswirl is associated with time travel spells. It is possible that he learned it from Scorpan and accidently sent himself into the past, to before Equestria's founding. By the time he figured out how to come back, he was already an aged pony with nothing to come back to. He was also a famous unicorn wizard. Clover the Clever became his apprentice. Knowing what would happen, Starswirl taught her exactly the skills and knowledge she would need to become the royal wizard and to survive the windigos (not warning her beforehoof, as her friendship with Smart Cookie and Private Pansy had to be genuine.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Pinkamena, if memory serves, is a goddess of harvest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Considering a third of the population have fluffy feathered wings; this is unlikely. It might just be a censor some ponies use to avoid offending anyone.

Removed: 779

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Pizzas have not been invented by ponies.]]
I'm rather surprised that the single most popular party food is not seen at any party shown in the show. We've seen lots of birthday cake and cupcakes, but no pizza! A real shame too... Pizza is a great food to have, they don't even need to have any real meat on them.
* And how is a pony supposed to hold a pizza slice, let alone take one from many (outside unicorn telekinesis, of course)?
** Not much of an objection when the ponies already deal just fine with cakes and pies.
*** Not exactly Jossed, but the My Little Pony Friendship Celebration Collection Set (Toys R Us exclusive) features two ponies called Sweetie Swirl and Firecracker Burst having pizza together. How do they hold their pizza? With plastic rings, of course!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: "Pinkamina" is a term for rose quartz.]]
That's how a rock farm filly got the name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Or perhaps something like a {{Gargoyles}} Wind Ceremony. Everyone flies through the ashes (or perhaps raindrops as suggested) so that the departed will be with them always.

to:

*** Or perhaps something like a {{Gargoyles}} {{WesternAnimation/Gargoyles}} Wind Ceremony. Everyone flies through the ashes (or perhaps raindrops as suggested) so that the departed will be with them always.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The "humans must be better" argument falls flat when you remember that in real life, animals are not as intelligent as humans and are glorified in fiction, ''especially'' by Furries. Humans are, if not a myth but exist on another continent (as is done in the fanwork ''TurnaboutStorm''), probably mediocre compared to ponies but in fiction, a pony's human companion may be hyperintelligent for a human, much in the same way where a human's animal companion is hyperintelligent compared to them and others of their species.

to:

** The "humans must be better" argument falls flat when you remember that in real life, animals are not as intelligent as humans and are glorified in fiction, ''especially'' by Furries. Humans are, if not a myth but exist on another continent (as is done in the fanwork ''TurnaboutStorm''), ''WebAnimation/TurnaboutStorm''), probably mediocre compared to ponies but in fiction, a pony's human companion may be hyperintelligent for a human, much in the same way where a human's animal companion is hyperintelligent compared to them and others of their species.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The "humans must be better" argument falls flat when you remember that in real life, animals are not as intelligent as humans and are glorified in fiction, ''especially'' by Furries. Humans are, if not a myth but exist on another continent (as is done in the fanwork ''TurnaboutStorm''), probably mediocre compared to ponies but in fiction, a pony's human companion may be hyperintelligent for a human, much in the same way where a human's animal companion is hyperintelligent compared to them and others of their species.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hot Mom has been disambiguated. Examples not clearly fitting into one of the tropes other than Fetish Fuel mentioned on Hot Mom are being removed. If you think it fits one of these tropes, feel free to readd with proper context. Same with Hot Dad.


* And it's not the only topic like this, either. Consider now the term "horse's ass." Foals typically leave their mother's womb via the rear exit, so calling a pony a "horse's ass" could probably serve as a YourMom slam. Unless, of course, said pony's birth is what made his mother into a HotMom. Then he might not mind so much.

to:

* And it's not the only topic like this, either. Consider now the term "horse's ass." Foals typically leave their mother's womb via the rear exit, so calling a pony a "horse's ass" could probably serve as a YourMom slam. Unless, of course, said pony's birth is what made his mother into a HotMom.mom. Then he might not mind so much.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to the Jossed folder.


[[WMG: Ancient temples, the Sapphire Statue/Stone, and Ahuizotl don't exist in Equestria.]]
They were all just made up for the book.
* What. No. You lie. They exist, they have to. They're just like Hogwarts; they only exist to those who are worthy. THEY EXISSSSSST. The Sapphire Stone is totally on display in the Canterlot Museum most days, the exhibit is just on tour in Buckshire right now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Heart's Warming Eve was WrittenByTheWinners]]
Smart Cookie, Clover the Clever, and Private Pansy? Not so above the same kind of bad behavior, or at least guilty of different kinds of bad behavior than Chancellor Puddinghead, Princess Platinum and Commander Hurricane. But they were able to influence the depiction to make them look flawless while their counterparts were made to look bad.
* Alternatively, this is a case of HistoricalHeroUpgrade and HistoricalVillainUpgrade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Equestria has no set naming conventions.]]
Many families follow patterns (The Apple Family, the Cakes, the Pies (with Pinkie being an exception), Twilight's family, ect.), and food-related names seem commong; but there are not specific conventions on the naming of foals.

[[WMG: Ponies are given a chance to change their name when they get their cutie mark to fit it better.]]
That's why everypony's name just matches so perfectly. That CAN'T be coincidence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Note also that the Summer Sun Celebration isn't honoring ''Celestia herself'' -- it's celebrating what she ''does'', every day, and while it is in part ''thanking'' her for it, it's as much a reminder of her own ''obligations to her people'', um, Her Little Ponies.

Added: 1153

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While we don't really know how far back the events go, it wouldn't be ''totally'' unrealistic if relevent info, such as the leaders names and personalities, survived in records to the present day. After all, we know the names of a great deal of the names of the pharohs going back 5000 years.

to:

* While we don't really know how far back the events go, it wouldn't be ''totally'' unrealistic if relevent relevant info, such as the leaders names and personalities, survived in records to the present day. After all, we know the names of a great deal of the names of the pharohs pharaohs going back 5000 years.



Te celebrate the return of the Crystal Empire to Equestria, Hearth's Warming Eve shall henceforth be known as [[IncrediblyLamePun Crystmas]].

to:

Te To celebrate the return of the Crystal Empire to Equestria, Hearth's Warming Eve shall henceforth be known as [[IncrediblyLamePun Crystmas]].
Crystmas]].

[[WMG: The Hearth's Warming Eve pageant has Hidden Significance.]]
Ritualized performances are an important part of real-world magical practices, particularly in [[MysteryCult Mystery Cult]]s and the like. Many "traditions" once had arcane significance, or were performed by initiates into the mysteries.

The Hearth's Warming pageant was more than just a tradition. It's a tradition whose real significance has been largely forgotten by mainstream Equestria -- but not, of course, by the immortal Princess.

Celestia ''specifically'' "invited" the Mane Six to perform it. And in a world where FunctionalMagic is part and parcel of everyday, and every pony bears what amounts to a magic symbol on their rump, having the Bearers of the Elements of Harmony act out the story of Equestria's unification and discovery of the Magic of Friendship -- a story that's probably older than Celestia or Luna -- that's ''powerful''.

That wasn't just a quaint little holiday play. That was an ''InitiationCeremony''. It was as much a part of preparing Twilight for her apotheo ... um, "coronation" ... as any of the grand adventures and deadly villains she confronted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** "A bunch of baby clones"? After being careless with a reflective surface? [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS3E3TooManyPinkiePies Hmmm...]] [[HumorMode Sounds like a certain episode may secretly be about]] [[FridgeHorror pony abortion!]]




to:

* [[FunWithAcronyms Qualified Talent]] mark?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Joe, Trixie, Matilda, Gustave, and Philomena ''are'' real words. Joe is short for Joseph and means "he will increase" or "let him increase"; Trixie is short for Beatrix and means traveler (quite appropriate for a traveling entertainer); Matilda means "strength in battle"; Gustave means "Goth-staff"; Philomena means "friend of strength."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Equestria is a [[LadyLand Lady Land]] society not run by males, but by females. All of the political leaders are not female because a princess is glamorous, but because a conservative Pony belief is that the females are more suited for leadership roles. That's why the show focuses on a strong female cast of characters- within the realms of their society, they would function as a male roles. In a similar vein to the novel, Egalia's Daughters, the men become "masculists," as opposed to real-life feminism. They've worked their way up into equal standing with the females, but some conservative ways are still around, such as the sparkley atmosphere.

to:

Equestria is a [[LadyLand Lady Land]] society not run by males, but by females. All of the political leaders are not female because a princess is glamorous, but because a conservative Pony belief is that the females are more suited for leadership roles. That's why the show focuses on a strong female cast of characters- within the realms of their society, they would function as a male roles. In a similar vein to the novel, Egalia's Daughters, the men become "masculists," as opposed to real-life feminism. They've worked their way up into equal standing with the females, but some conservative ways are still around, such as the sparkley sparkly atmosphere.
* Given the amount of horse-related {{Furry Reminder}}s the show has, it's not that unbelievable; real horses, despite common conception otherwise, are actually matriarchial -- in a herd, the lead mare, as her name suggests, actually handles all the decision-making for the herd. The stallion's job is basically to sire foals, fight off attacking predators, and keep peace between the mares.



** Jossed as of ''A Canterlot Wedding'' - Twilight Sparkle definitely throws magic blasts around. Though that could of course be self-thought from some obscure books.

to:

** Jossed as of ''A Canterlot Wedding'' - Twilight Sparkle definitely throws magic blasts around. Though that could of course be self-thought self-taught from some obscure books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding to the gun section.


** Possibly the gun is also a recent invention, to weak and unreliable to be used (see [[http://pooryorickda.deviantart.com/gallery/37506217 "Equestria Divided"]] by [=PoorYorick=] on DeviantArt for examples I am thinking of) besides a morale busting weapon outside of giant cannons. Earth Ponies may not of had not enough need to develop weapon technology (see above reasons) or were not ALLOWED to develope weapon technology, do to there former statuses of serfs.

to:

*** Except they aren't ''called'' tanks back then; the term 'tank' as applied to an armored vehicle dates only to WWII, when the development committee was renamed to Water Tank development as a counter-espionage effort.
** Possibly the gun is also a recent invention, to too weak and unreliable to be used (see [[http://pooryorickda.deviantart.com/gallery/37506217 "Equestria Divided"]] by [=PoorYorick=] on DeviantArt for examples I am thinking of) besides a morale busting weapon outside of giant cannons. Earth Ponies may not of had not enough need to develop weapon technology (see above reasons) or were not ALLOWED to develope weapon technology, do to there former statuses of serfs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The Royal Guards dye their coats and manes.]]
Similar to having a buzzcut and standard uniform for Real Life military.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: A pony has the option to change their name when they get their cutie mark.]]
It explains why some ponies have names that match their cutie mark (Silver Spoon, Diamond Tiara) and others don't (Pinkie Pie, Rarity).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: A stallion will adopt his wife's surname upon marriage.]]
Equestria is a female dominated society; it only makes sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
A stallion adopts his wife\'s surname upon marriage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Alternatively, all stallions are required by law to serve in the military at some point, unless they have some sort of special exemption (such as essential worker). Those ponies who have military related cutie marks form a core of professional career soldiers, while regular ponies serve their time and go back to civilian life. Mr. Cake, Rarity's father and Pinie Pie's father are all old enough to have done their time, while Macintosh has an exemption. The career soldiers (who are actually good at military matters) are stationed in the more important areas which need professional soldiers, while the non-careers are kept in safer areas (as a sort of civil defense force) to free up the career soldiers for more important duties. This would explain why the guard keeps getting beaten; they aren't up to the task of facing a real threat, only the minor disturbances that regular ponies would cause.

Added: 463

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Humans would probably be the BadassNormal in pony mythology. We lack magic, special powers, or even physical strength but because of our cunning and dexterity we can do things that would seem damn near impossible to ponies. It took a goddess and some of their most powerful weapons in order to send someone to the moon? We've expand our domain into other planets. They need to find water, diamonds, gold, and other resources in nature? We can create our own water, gold, diamonds, and etc. (Mind you it is impractical and expensive but we are capable of it.) They use spears, cannons, and whatever their magic can preform? We have weapons that can wipe out entire cities in a blink of an eye. And so on and so forth. As for how we're characterized, we'd probably be defined as curious, ambitious, well meaning, extremely self-centered, and greedy. For every good thing we've done, we've done an equally horrible thing. For every discovery and invention we find both a good and bad application for it. Also, I always theorized that Lyra was the equine equivalent of a brony. (Ponman? Equine Sapiens? I'm still trying to think of a name.)

to:

** Humans would probably be the BadassNormal in pony mythology. We lack magic, special powers, or even physical strength but because of our cunning and dexterity we can do things that would seem damn near impossible to ponies. It took a goddess and some of their most powerful weapons in order to send someone to the moon? We've expand our domain into other planets. They need to find water, diamonds, gold, and other resources in nature? We can create our own water, gold, diamonds, and etc. (Mind you it is impractical and expensive but we are capable of it.) They use spears, cannons, and whatever their magic can preform? We have weapons that can wipe out entire cities in a blink of an eye. And so on and so forth. As for how we're characterized, we'd probably be defined as curious, ambitious, well meaning, extremely self-centered, and greedy. For every good thing we've done, we've done an equally horrible thing. For every discovery and invention we find both a good and bad application for it. Also, I always theorized that Lyra was the equine equivalent of a brony. (Ponman? Equine Sapiens? I'm still trying to think of a name.) )
** Simply the fact that humans live in a place where the ENTIRE WORLD RUNS ITSELF and can create wonders and horrors in equal measure WITHOUT MAGIC, may combine Badass Normal with Eldrich Abomination from the standpoint of the ponies. The ability to build a machine that can fly and doesn't utilize magic in any way shape or form may be both fascinating and horrifying at the same time. ("Guess what, Dashie, I just invented a machine that makes you obsolete!")

Top