Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / TintinTintinInTheLandOfTheSoviets

Go To

OR

Added: 744

Changed: 766

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: As Herge despised the story and refused to republish it, for many years only the original 1930's editions remained available in circulation and at very high prices; notably this led many fans to visit the Bibliothèque Nationale in order to read the copy held there. Fan demand finally led to a tiny run of 500 being published in 1969 but this did nothing to decrease demand and by the 1970's a number of bootleg editions were being produced and sold. As such Herge relented and in 1973 it would be reprinted in the Archives Hergé collection. With bootlegs still circulating Casterman finally produced a facsimile edition in 1981. English readers had to wait until 1989 to finally read the book in an official edition.

to:

* FirstAppearance: As the first installment in the ''Tintin'' series, it is naturally the first appearance of the titular hero, but it is also the first appearance of Snowy.
* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: As Herge Hergé despised the story and refused to republish it, for many years only the original 1930's editions remained available in circulation and at very high prices; notably this led many fans to visit the Bibliothèque Nationale in order to read the copy held there. Fan demand finally led to a tiny run of 500 being published in 1969 but this did nothing to decrease demand and by the 1970's a number of bootleg editions were being produced and sold. As such Herge Hergé relented and in 1973 it would be reprinted in the Archives Hergé collection. With bootlegs still circulating Casterman finally produced a facsimile edition in 1981. English readers had to wait until 1989 to finally read the book in an official edition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not Trivia.


* ScrewTheMoneyIHaveRules: Real life example for Herge and this book, inspite of multiple offers and requests he stuck to his guns for more than forty years when it came to not reprinting Soviet's under any circumstances. This included turning down a World War II request from a German company who wanted to use it in the Axis war effort as Anti-Soviet propaganda!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a retrospective example, the Soviet officials are seen holding a crowd of voters at gunpoint and then declaring that, since none of them have said otherwise, their votes will all be counted for the Communist Party. In reality, the Soviets ''did'' have a law stating that, unless voters cast a ballot to the contrary, they would be assumed as supporting the Communists. However, said law wasn't implemented until a few years after the story finished publication, and even then, it wasn't usually enforced at gunpoint.

to:

** In a retrospective example, the Soviet officials are seen holding a crowd of voters at gunpoint and then declaring that, since none of them have said otherwise, their votes will all be counted for the Communist Party. In reality, the Soviets ''did'' have a law stating that, unless voters cast a ballot to the contrary, they would be assumed as supporting the Communists. However, said law wasn't implemented until a few years after the story finished publication, and even then, it wasn't usually enforced at gunpoint. They had more subtle ways of enforcing such a policy. [[note]]In Soviet elections, the ballot was already largely filled out for the voter with the (Communist or Communist-aligned) candidate the only person on the ballot, and the Soviet government bent over backwards to entice people to vote. The voter just had to drop it into the ballot box. There ''was'' a booth for those who wanted to vote otherwise. The catch was that people taking advantage of the secret ballot to write in another candidate were caught out as taking advantage of the secret ballot to write for an unapproved candidate and were marked for secret police scrutiny. The people's workaround for this was to just not show up to vote if the candidate was unpalatable -- if the candidate couldn't get a majority of raw turnout, it was still seen as a rejection of the candidate.[[/note]]

Added: 344

Removed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bury Your Art is a new trope covering Old Shame (which is likely to become In Universe Examples Only in the near future)


* BuryYourArt: Hergé regretted making this comic and refused to let it be republished. He eventually gave in and let it be reprinted in 1973, but only because there were so many bootleg copies already out there. Even though he let it be republished, he still refused to redraw and color the book like he had done with many of his older stories.



* OldShame: Hergé came to regret making this one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a retrospective example, the Soviet officials are seen holding a crowd of voters at gunpoint and then declaring that, since none of them have said otherwise, their votes will all be counted for the Communist Party. In reality, the Soviets ''did'' have a law stating that, unless voters cast a ballot to the contrary, they would be assumed as supporting the Communists. However, said law wasn't implemented until a few years after the book was published, and even then, it wasn't usually enforced at gunpoint.

to:

** In a retrospective example, the Soviet officials are seen holding a crowd of voters at gunpoint and then declaring that, since none of them have said otherwise, their votes will all be counted for the Communist Party. In reality, the Soviets ''did'' have a law stating that, unless voters cast a ballot to the contrary, they would be assumed as supporting the Communists. However, said law wasn't implemented until a few years after the book was published, story finished publication, and even then, it wasn't usually enforced at gunpoint.

Added: 1162

Changed: 646

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentallyCorrectWriting: While nearly everything about the UsefulNotes/SovietUnion's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate (due to the fact that Creator/{{Herge}} never visited the country and lifted entire scenes from a popular anti-communist tract), one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former Soviet citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviets' more subtle way of purging.

to:

* AccidentallyCorrectWriting: AccidentallyCorrectWriting:
**
While nearly everything about the UsefulNotes/SovietUnion's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate (due to the fact that Creator/{{Herge}} never visited the country and lifted entire scenes from a popular anti-communist tract), one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former Soviet citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviets' more subtle way of purging.purging.
** In a retrospective example, the Soviet officials are seen holding a crowd of voters at gunpoint and then declaring that, since none of them have said otherwise, their votes will all be counted for the Communist Party. In reality, the Soviets ''did'' have a law stating that, unless voters cast a ballot to the contrary, they would be assumed as supporting the Communists. However, said law wasn't implemented until a few years after the book was published, and even then, it wasn't usually enforced at gunpoint.

Added: 49

Changed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentallyCorrectWriting: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate (due to the fact that Herge never visited the country and lifted entire scenes from a popular anti-communist tract), one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviet's more subtle way of purging.
* CreatorBacklash: Not exactly what Creator/{{Herge}} would call his favorite Tintin strip.

to:

* AccidentallyCorrectWriting: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's UsefulNotes/SovietUnion's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate (due to the fact that Herge Creator/{{Herge}} never visited the country and lifted entire scenes from a popular anti-communist tract), one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR Soviet citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviet's Soviets' more subtle way of purging.
* CreatorBacklash: Not exactly what Creator/{{Herge}} Hergé would call his favorite Tintin strip.


Added DiffLines:

* OldShame: Hergé came to regret making this one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentallyCorrectWriting: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate, one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviet's more subtle way of purging.

to:

* AccidentallyCorrectWriting: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate, inaccurate (due to the fact that Herge never visited the country and lifted entire scenes from a popular anti-communist tract), one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviet's more subtle way of purging.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorBacklash: Not exactly what Hergé would call his favorite Tintin strip.

to:

* CreatorBacklash: Not exactly what Hergé Creator/{{Herge}} would call his favorite Tintin strip.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorBacklash: Not exactly what Hergé would call his favorite Tintin strip right now.

to:

* CreatorBacklash: Not exactly what Hergé would call his favorite Tintin strip right now.strip.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: As Herge despised the story and refused to republish it, for many years only the original 1930's editions remained available in circulation and at very high prices; notably this led many fans to visit the Bibliothèque Nationale in order to read the copy held there. Fan demand finally led to a tiny run of 500 being published in 1969 but this did nothing to decrease demand and by the 1970's a number of bootleg editions were being produced and sold. Finally in 1973 it would be reprinted in the Archives Hergé collection. With bootlegs still circulating Casterman finally produced a facsimile edition in 1981. English readers had to wait until 1989 to finally read the book in an official edition.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: As Herge despised the story and refused to republish it, for many years only the original 1930's editions remained available in circulation and at very high prices; notably this led many fans to visit the Bibliothèque Nationale in order to read the copy held there. Fan demand finally led to a tiny run of 500 being published in 1969 but this did nothing to decrease demand and by the 1970's a number of bootleg editions were being produced and sold. Finally As such Herge relented and in 1973 it would be reprinted in the Archives Hergé collection. With bootlegs still circulating Casterman finally produced a facsimile edition in 1981. English readers had to wait until 1989 to finally read the book in an official edition.

Added: 365

Changed: 769

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: This was the case for several decades after its publication. Hergé felt this story was an OldShame and refused to have it redrawn or reprinted. It's not even considered part of the canon. Only in the 1970s, when several bootleg copies kept popping up, did he finally decide to publish again.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: This was As Herge despised the case for several decades after its publication. Hergé felt this story was an OldShame and refused to have it redrawn or reprinted. It's not even considered part of republish it, for many years only the canon. Only original 1930's editions remained available in circulation and at very high prices; notably this led many fans to visit the 1970s, when several Bibliothèque Nationale in order to read the copy held there. Fan demand finally led to a tiny run of 500 being published in 1969 but this did nothing to decrease demand and by the 1970's a number of bootleg copies kept popping up, did he editions were being produced and sold. Finally in 1973 it would be reprinted in the Archives Hergé collection. With bootlegs still circulating Casterman finally decide produced a facsimile edition in 1981. English readers had to publish again.wait until 1989 to finally read the book in an official edition.


Added DiffLines:

* ScrewTheMoneyIHaveRules: Real life example for Herge and this book, inspite of multiple offers and requests he stuck to his guns for more than forty years when it came to not reprinting Soviet's under any circumstances. This included turning down a World War II request from a German company who wanted to use it in the Axis war effort as Anti-Soviet propaganda!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ReferencedBy: The album ''Tintin in Paris'' that Lisa grabs in the episode of ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'' "Husbands And Knives" has Tintin and Snowy striking the same pose as they did on this album cover.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: This was the case for several decades after its publication. Hergé felt this story was an OldShame and refused to have it redrawn or reprinted. It's not even considered part of the canon. Only in the 1970s, when several bootleg copies kept popping up, he finally decided to publish again.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: This was the case for several decades after its publication. Hergé felt this story was an OldShame and refused to have it redrawn or reprinted. It's not even considered part of the canon. Only in the 1970s, when several bootleg copies kept popping up, did he finally decided decide to publish again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Accidentally Accurate has been renamed per TRS thread.


* AccidentallyAccurate: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate, one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviet's more subtle way of purging.

to:

* AccidentallyAccurate: AccidentallyCorrectWriting: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate, one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviet's more subtle way of purging.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreatorBacklash: Not exactly what Hergé would call his favorite Tintin strip right now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentallyAccurate: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate, one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary.

to:

* AccidentallyAccurate: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate, one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary. Obviously the open stuff would have been the exception rather than the norm given the Soviet's more subtle way of purging.

Added: 409

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentallyAccurate: While nearly everything about the Soviet Union's depiction in this story is laughably inaccurate, one thing that actually ''was'' TruthInTelevision (albeit probably exaggerated) was the "election" seen halfway through the story, with several former USSR citizens attesting in later years that implied and even open threats of violence toward voters weren't too out of the ordinary.



* LifeImitatesArt: Hergé and his magazine colleagues staged an event where an actor portraying Tintin and a white fox terrier would arrive at the station of Brussels, just like the characters did at the end of the story. Hergé liked the publicity stunt, but didn't expect anyone to be there. To his surprise the place was crowded with enthusiastic fans! It was such a success that it was done again with ''Tintin in The Congo''.

to:

* LifeImitatesArt: Hergé and his magazine colleagues staged an event where an actor portraying Tintin and a white fox terrier would arrive at the station of Brussels, just like the characters did at the end of the story. Hergé liked the publicity stunt, but didn't expect anyone to be there. To his surprise the place was crowded with enthusiastic fans! It was such a success that it was done again with ''Tintin in The Congo''.Congo''.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: This was the case for several decades after its publication. Hergé felt this story was an OldShame and refused to have it redrawn or reprinted. It's not even considered part of the canon. Only in the 1970s, when several bootleg copies kept popping up, he finally decided to publish again.
* LifeImitatesArt: Hergé and his magazine colleagues staged an event where an actor portraying Tintin and a white fox terrier would arrive at the station of Brussels, just like the characters did at the end of the story. Hergé liked the publicity stunt, but didn't expect anyone to be there. To his surprise the place was crowded with enthusiastic fans! It was such a success that it was done again with ''Tintin in The Congo''.

Top