Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TearJerker / StarTrekDiscovery

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Saru admits he was angry with Michael mostly out of jealousy, as Georgiou died before Michael could go do her own thing, and thus he could be taught everything that she was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Poor Tilly automatically assumes that Michael doesn’t want to be friends with her, and when reassured Michael’s bad mood isn’t because of her, says that’s so rarely the case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: "Choose To Live"]]
* It ends happily, but Adira crying because they can’t feel Tal anymore, and hoping he’ll come back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Book’s constant rewinding of what happened in the beginning. Michael tries to comfort him but her captain duties call her away, and he wants her to leave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Michael is still reeling from the deaths under her command in the last episode, trying too hard at first to be the distant Captain as well as the attentive partner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: "Anomaly"]]
* As if spending the episode in a HeroicBSOD isn't bad enough for Book, he starts seeing hallucinations of Leto running around like the CheerfulChild he was, clearly nowhere close to truly processing what happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Kwejian has been destroyed. Book's brother and nephew are most likely dead, along with most (if not all) of their people.

to:

* Kwejian has been destroyed. Book's brother and nephew are most likely dead, along with most (if not all) of their people. What makes this even more devastating is the lead up. Book barely survived the distortion and wants Kwejian brought up on deep space scanners. Owo puts in the coordinates, but... nothing's there. Then they realize there's something out there from where the planet should be... and they find Kwejian, a ShatteredWorld, completely lifeless. Burnham's OhCrap gasp of shock sells as it as well as the looks of horror as we see everyone, even the President, reacting to the sight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There’s a HopeSpot of everyone coming back safe in the shuttle, but it’s hit and Nalas dies. Michael looks completely destroyed, taking deaths and injuries personally when many others survived.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Season 4]]

[[AC: "Kobayashi Maru"]]
* Kwejian has been destroyed. Book's brother and nephew are most likely dead, along with most (if not all) of their people.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Lorca’s IronicEcho to Kirk in ''Film/StarTrekVTheFinalFrontier''. “We choose our own pain. Mine helps me remember.”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* While Stamets is a dick to Michael initially, he has an impassioned rant over Starfleet using his and his partner’s research for fighting a war, splitting them up, and now his partner is dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When Michael sees Saru on Discovery, he turns his back on her, thinking that he hates her too now, but some time later, he walks with her and offers her blueberries. He’s not friends with her though, believing she’s dangerous and failed at protecting her captain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Michael’s guilt over using Ripper for the spore drive. Before, he was like a happy puppy licking her face when she brought him food, but after, he shies away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Even if Mirror Detmer might (or might not?) have been evil and just trying to save her own skin, it's oddly heart-wrenching to see the pained shock in her eyes when Michael suddenly stabs her. Made especially poignant as Detmer had tried to comfort Michael while she was in the brig, as she likely was one of Michael's closest friends and confidants (if not actually the closest). Detmer may also have been the only Terran (other than Georgiou, who's also had the benefit of living in the Prime universe) shown to display emotions like concern and affection, rather than simple bloodlust or cruelty.

to:

* Even if Mirror Detmer might (or might not?) have been evil and just trying to save her own skin, it's oddly heart-wrenching to see the pained shock in her eyes when Michael suddenly stabs her. Made especially poignant as Detmer had tried to comfort Michael while she was in the brig, as she likely was one of Michael's closest friends and confidants (if not actually the closest). Detmer may also have been the only Terran (other than Georgiou, who's also had the benefit of living in the Prime universe) shown to display positive emotions like concern and affection, rather than simple bloodlust or cruelty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Georgiou’s video will, made before Michael seemingly ruined everything, talking about how proud she is of her, like Michael was her own daughter. You can ''tell'' that Michael is feeling “[[Recap/StarTrek S2E1AmokTime I have killed my captain and my friend]]”.

to:

* Georgiou’s video will, made before Michael seemingly ruined everything, talking about how proud she is of her, like Michael was her own daughter. You can ''tell'' that Michael is feeling “[[Recap/StarTrek S2E1AmokTime “[[Recap/StarTrekS2E1AmokTime I have killed my captain and my friend]]”.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Georgiou’s video will, made before Michael seemingly ruined everything, talking about how proud she is of her, like Michael was her own daughter. You can ''tell'' that Michael is feeling “[[Recap/StarTrek S2E1AmokTime I have killed my captain and my friend]]”.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Georgiou’s calm but DisappointedInYou WhatTheHellHero speech to Michael, calling herself a fool for thinking Michael’s humanity might win over the Vulcan shell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Michael doesn’t even get to collect Georgiou’s body, being transported back to the ship and scream-sobbing out of grief, regret and guilt for all she’s done. When being court martialled, she admits that after the attack in her childhood, she devoted her life to the service (much like Kirk will after Tarsus IV), and that’s all up in smoke.

Added: 26

Removed: 26

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC: "The Vulcan Hello"]]



[[AC: "The Vulcan Hello"]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Michael as a child on Vulcan, traumatised by a Klingon raid and overwhelmed by the test not letting up when she's too triggered to answer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** There's also Amanda, giving clear indications of being the StoicWoobie - she is a human on Vulcan, has chosen to live on a planet where if she expresses an emotion publicly, it will reflect poorly on her and her family. She has raised children in this environment. She says explicitly that she does not believe that Sarek would have followed her to Earth had she chosen to live there. All of this, and she has never complained. Even in saying this, it is not to express the unfairness of her situation... But Spock's. That he was alone on a planet that would never accept him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Landry suffers an absolutely ''brutal'' mauling by "Ripper" when she tries to sedate the tardigrade and take one of its claws by force. Burnham gets her an emergency transport back to sickbay, but all Dr. Culber can do about her [[BodyHorror extensive injuries]] is to apply a MercyKill via hypospray and move on.

to:

* Landry suffers an absolutely ''brutal'' mauling by "Ripper" when she tries to sedate the tardigrade and take one of its claws by force. Burnham gets her an emergency transport back to sickbay, but all Dr. Culber can do about her [[BodyHorror extensive injuries]] is to apply a MercyKill via hypospray {{hypospray}} and move on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding apostrophes.


** Stamets realising the reason Hugh is trapped in the network is that Paul bought him there himself in his fugue state. Having briefly woken up, he found Hughs dead body, and subconsciously pulled his energy into the network while cradling him and crying. It's not a fun flashback.

to:

** Stamets realising the reason Hugh is trapped in the network is that Paul bought him there himself in his fugue state. Having briefly woken up, he found Hughs Hugh's dead body, and subconsciously pulled his energy into the network while cradling him and crying. It's not a fun flashback.



** Special mention goes to the moment where he blows up at Paul, leading to Pauls voice cracking over asking Hugh why he's so angry at him.

to:

** Special mention goes to the moment where he blows up at Paul, leading to Pauls Paul's voice cracking over asking Hugh why he's so angry at him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n** Admiral Vance tearing into ''both'' of them over what happened. While most of his harsh words are for Michael, he still gives Saru an earful for not bringing the matter to his attention, as he might well have signed off on the mission had he been aware of it, but Saru failed to bring potentially important information to the Admiral's attention. As far as he's concerned, they ''both'' failed Starfleet, and while ''Discovery'' and her crew have earned some trust, they still have a long way to go before they're properly integrated into the modern Starfleet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Added DiffLines:

* Stamets arrives in Federation Headquarters hoping for someone to hear him out, but Vance is in full agreement with Burnham's decision to space him for the good of everyone. To twist the knife, he even acknowledges the sacrifice Stamets is being forced to make, but they're simply not in a position to help him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The pride and joy of everyone moving out to start a new chapter in the Federation is marred by one person - Stamets. While he's very thankful to be reunited with Hugh and Adira, he's still hurting that Burnham did was she did last episode.

to:

* The pride and joy of everyone moving out to start a new chapter in the Federation is marred by one person - Stamets. While he's very thankful to be reunited with Hugh and Adira, he's still hurting that Burnham did was what she did last episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The pride and joy of everyone moving out to start a new chapter in the Federation is marred by one person - Stamets. While he's very thankful to be reunited with Hugh and Adira, he's still hurting that Burnham did was she did last episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** We see what caused the Burn - Su'Kal accidentally deactivating the holo environment and seeing his dying mother, who begs him to wait for the Federation before the radiation finally kills her. Su'Kal's grief at what happened caused him to send out the subspace pulse that wiped out almost everything. The entire universe was nearly sent into a Dark Age because of ''one'' child's immeasurable sorrow.
** Gray's panic and terror knowing that they have to turn off the holo, because he'll disappear again and he can't go back to no one except Adira seeing him.

to:

** * We see what caused the Burn - Su'Kal accidentally deactivating the holo environment and seeing his dying mother, who begs him to wait for the Federation before the radiation finally kills her. Su'Kal's grief at what happened caused him to send out the subspace pulse that wiped out almost everything. The entire universe was nearly sent into a Dark Age because of ''one'' child's immeasurable sorrow.
** * Gray's panic and terror knowing that they have to turn off the holo, because he'll disappear again and he can't go back to no one except Adira seeing him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: "That Hope Is You, Part II"]]
** We see what caused the Burn - Su'Kal accidentally deactivating the holo environment and seeing his dying mother, who begs him to wait for the Federation before the radiation finally kills her. Su'Kal's grief at what happened caused him to send out the subspace pulse that wiped out almost everything. The entire universe was nearly sent into a Dark Age because of ''one'' child's immeasurable sorrow.
** Gray's panic and terror knowing that they have to turn off the holo, because he'll disappear again and he can't go back to no one except Adira seeing him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Stamets is desperate to rescue Hugh from the nebula, not only for himself but for Adira. Then Burnham tells him that Adira left the ship to help Hugh. He becomes so distraught he immediately begins prepping ''Discovery'' for a jump despite the fact that the ship is still under the Emerald Chain's control. Burnham has to physically restrain him and finally neck pinch him to stop him. She has to get him off the ship so that Osyraa can't use the spore drive to escape, and knows he won't leave the ship willingly, so seals him in an emergency forcefield before setting her phaser to overload and cause a hull breach. Just before the phaser goes off, he gives her an absolutely ''blistering'' WhatTheHellHero speech through clear emotional agony.

to:

* Stamets is desperate to rescue Hugh from the nebula, not only for himself but for Adira. Then Burnham tells him that Adira left the ship to help Hugh. He becomes so distraught he immediately begins prepping ''Discovery'' for a jump despite the fact that the ship is still under the Emerald Chain's control. Burnham has to physically restrain him and finally neck pinch him to stop him. She has to get him off the ship so that Osyraa can't use the spore drive to escape, and knows he won't leave the ship willingly, so she seals him in an emergency forcefield before setting her phaser to overload and cause a hull breach. Just before the phaser goes off, he gives her an absolutely ''blistering'' WhatTheHellHero speech through clear emotional agony.

Top