Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TearJerker / Oliver

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Fagin:''' Sikes... what did you do? ''What did you do?'' \\

to:

-->'''Fagin:''' --->'''Fagin:''' Sikes... what did you do? ''What did you do?'' \\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Even though they were ill-gotten gains, it is somewhat sad to see Fagin lose his precious jewels and treasure to the muddy river during the evacuation of his hideout. Particularly when he desperately tries to fish through the mud and only getting a muddy hand in return. This is all because of the actions of Bill Sykes, a friend of Fagin.

to:

* Even though they were ill-gotten gains, it is somewhat sad to see Fagin lose his precious jewels and treasure to the muddy river during the evacuation of his hideout. Particularly when he desperately tries to fish through the mud and only getting a muddy hand in return. This is all because of the actions of Bill Sykes, a friend of Fagin. It is even more sad for the rightful owners of the treasure as this is a fortune gone forever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Even though they were ill-gotten gains, it is somewhat sad to see Fagin lose his precious jewels and treasure to the muddy river during the evacuation of his hideout. Particularly when he desperately tries to fish through the mud and only getting a muddy hand in return. This is all because of the actions of Bill Sykes, a friend of Fagin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


!!The film:
* The aftermath of when Bill hits Nancy. The sheer MoodWhiplash as CerebusSyndrome sets in. All of the boys immediately go silent and stare at the scene in shock or terror. The scene shows that these are children who have just seen a woman they love and admire (Nancy is clearly a CoolBigSis or even a TeamMom to some of them) assaulted and left crying on the floor. It also hammers home that they're utterly terrified of Bill Sikes.
* Oliver is ForcedToWatch when Nancy is beaten to death - complete with close-ups of his reaction as all we hear are the sounds. Then he's used as a human shield multiple times by Bill.

Added: 484

Changed: 162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The aftermath of her death. After Sikes makes one last return to Fagin's hideout, the latter notices him bloodied and shaken, and asks where Nancy is. Though Sikes doesn't answer, Fagin quickly catches on and [[EvenEvilHasStandards screams mortified for him to get out of his sight]].

to:

** The aftermath of her death. After Sikes makes one last return to Fagin's hideout, the latter notices him bloodied and shaken, and asks where Nancy is. Though Sikes doesn't answer, Fagin quickly catches this exchange happens.
-->'''Fagin:''' Sikes... what did you do? ''What did you do?'' \\
'''Bill:''' She won't peach
on and [[EvenEvilHasStandards screams mortified nobody no more. \\
'''Fagin:''' ''(winces)'' You... shouldn't have done that! She peached? You sure? \\
'''Bill:''' But she must have done, mustn't she? She was handin the boy over to Brownlow on the bridge. He was there waiting
for him to get out of his sight]].her. \\
'''Fagin:''' ''([[EvenEvilHasStandards horrified]])'' Then what did you come here for?! ''Get out!!'' ''You hear me?!'' '''''[[GetOut GET OUT!!]]'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!The stage musical
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Making it worse is the fact that Nancy was only in a position to be killed by him because she turned down Mr. Brownlow's offer to go to the police. Even with her HeelFaceTurn, she still loved Sykes enough to keep him out of prison; and the heartless wretch ends up killing her because of it.

to:

** Making it worse is the fact that Nancy was only in a position to be killed by him because she turned down Mr. Brownlow's offer to go to the police. Even with her HeelFaceTurn, she still loved Sykes Sikes enough to keep him out of prison; and the heartless wretch ends up killing her because of it.



** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child, and she knows he isn't good enough for her? "If you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes exploits]].

to:

** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child, and she knows he isn't good enough for her? "If you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes Sikes exploits]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child, and she knows he isn't good enough for her? "When you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes exploits]].

to:

** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child, and she knows he isn't good enough for her? "When "If you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes exploits]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The aftermath of her death. After Sikes makes one last return to Fagin's hideout, the latter notices him bloodied and shaken, and asks where Nancy is. Though Sikes doesn't answer, Fagin quickly catches on and screams mortified for him to get out of his sight.

to:

** The aftermath of her death. After Sikes makes one last return to Fagin's hideout, the latter notices him bloodied and shaken, and asks where Nancy is. Though Sikes doesn't answer, Fagin quickly catches on and [[EvenEvilHasStandards screams mortified for him to get out of his sight.sight]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The aftermath of her death. After Sikes makes one last return to Fagin's hideout, the latter notices him bloodied and shaken, and asks where Nancy is. Though Sikes doesn't answer, Fagin quickly catches on and screams mortified for him to get out of his sight.

Added: 561

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''first'' version of "Reviewing the Situation" both on the stage and in the movie, as Fagin pleads his case partially to the audience and partially to himself: "A man's got a heart, hasn't he? All joking apart, hasn't he?" Then he lays out for us how he's screwed if he tries to reform in any way, and he's screwed if he ''doesn't'' reform too. While he's admittedly got only himself to blame for getting himself into such a sticky situation with his life of crime, one feels rather inclined to [[SympathyForTheDevil shed some tears for this poor devil]].



** Making it worse is the fact that Nancy was only in a position to be killed by him because she turned down Mr. Brownlow's offer to go to the police. Even with her HeelFaceTurn, she still loved Sikes enough to keep him out of prison. And the bastard ends up killing her because of it.
** Also the fact that she gave Oliver one last hug before she dies is gut wrenching.
** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child and she knows isn't good enough for her? "When you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes takes advantage of]].

to:

** Making it worse is the fact that Nancy was only in a position to be killed by him because she turned down Mr. Brownlow's offer to go to the police. Even with her HeelFaceTurn, she still loved Sikes Sykes enough to keep him out of prison. And prison; and the bastard heartless wretch ends up killing her because of it.
** Also the fact that she gave Also, her giving Oliver one last hug before she dies is gut wrenching.
** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child child, and she knows he isn't good enough for her? "When you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes takes advantage of]].exploits]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "He doesn't act as though he cares, but deep inside, I know he cares. And that is why I'm tied right by his side."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up, knows that he's total garbage but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child? "When you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes takes advantage of]].

to:

** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up, knows that he's total garbage up but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child? child and she knows isn't good enough for her? "When you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes takes advantage of]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up, knows that he's total garbage but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child? "When you're lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes takes advantage of]].

to:

** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up, knows that he's total garbage but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child? "When you're you are lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes takes advantage of]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Why does she stay with a man who not only beats her up, knows that he's total garbage but ends up killing her when she tries to save an innocent child? "When you're lonely, then you will know. When someone needs you, you love them so." Given the hell of a life she's had, she wants to feel needed and appreciated...and it's that desire that [[KickTheDog Sykes takes advantage of]].

Added: 212

Changed: 205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Example indentation.


* Nancy's death, and her situation, really. A child pickpocket who was unable to get out and stuck with an abusive boyfriend. She tries to save Oliver from what she knows will happen and ''is beaten to death!!''

to:

* Nancy's Nancy:
** Her
death, and her situation, really. A child pickpocket who was unable to get out and stuck with an abusive boyfriend. She tries to save Oliver from what she knows will happen and ''is beaten to death!!''



** Also the fact that she gave Oliver one last hug before she dies is gut wrenching.

to:

** Also the fact that she gave Oliver one last hug before she dies is gut wrenching.wrenching.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Making it worse is the fact that Nancy was only in a position to be killed by him because she turned down Mr. Brownlow's offer to go to the police. Even with her HeelFaceTurn, she still loved Sikes enough to keep him out of prison. And the bastard ends up killing her because of it.

to:

** Making it worse is the fact that Nancy was only in a position to be killed by him because she turned down Mr. Brownlow's offer to go to the police. Even with her HeelFaceTurn, she still loved Sikes enough to keep him out of prison. And the bastard ends up killing her because of it.it.
** Also the fact that she gave Oliver one last hug before she dies is gut wrenching.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Nancy's death, and her situation, really. A child pickpocket who was unable to get out and stuck with an abusive boyfriend. She tries to save Oliver from what she knows will happen and ''is beaten to death!!''

to:

* Nancy's death, and her situation, really. A child pickpocket who was unable to get out and stuck with an abusive boyfriend. She tries to save Oliver from what she knows will happen and ''is beaten to death!!''death!!''
** Making it worse is the fact that Nancy was only in a position to be killed by him because she turned down Mr. Brownlow's offer to go to the police. Even with her HeelFaceTurn, she still loved Sikes enough to keep him out of prison. And the bastard ends up killing her because of it.

Changed: 348

Removed: 238

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "Where is Love?", "As Long As He Needs Me", the reprise of "As Long...", and the reprise of "Reviewing the Situation" (it's different in the movie) all make this troper tear up.
* This troper can pretty much take or leave ''Oliver!'', but -- "''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eol-bDzyekI oh, hell, I've got my pride]]''." Jesus.
* Nancy's death, and her entire situation, really. A child pickpocket who was unable to get out and stuck with an [[CompleteMonster abusive boyfriend]]. She tries to save Oliver from what she knows will happen and ''is beaten to death!!''

to:

* "Where is Love?", "As Long As He Needs Me", the reprise of "As Long...", and the reprise of "Reviewing the Situation" (it's different in the movie) all make this troper tear up.
* This troper can pretty much take or leave ''Oliver!'', but -- "''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eol-bDzyekI oh, hell, I've got my pride]]''." Jesus.
movie).
* Nancy's death, and her entire situation, really. A child pickpocket who was unable to get out and stuck with an [[CompleteMonster abusive boyfriend]].boyfriend. She tries to save Oliver from what she knows will happen and ''is beaten to death!!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Nancy's death, and her entire situation, really. A child pickpocket who was unable to get out and stuck with an [[CompleteMonster abusive boyfriend]]. She tries to save Oliver from what she knows will happen and ''is beaten to death!!''

Top