Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TearJerker / KaitouSaintTail

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fix for spoilers-off policy


* Meimi's severe insecurity hits peak in chapter 21/episode 40 when her [[OneDialogueTwoConversations utter misinterpretation]] of what Asuka Jr. had told her in the previous chapter/episode leads her to believe that he'd found some other girl he'd fallen in love with, meaning that Meimi is so unwilling to believe he could ever love her that she has an easier time believing he'd found some unnamed girl with some accidental resemblance to Saint Tail. [[spoiler:Which is only made worse by the fact that in a later bonus manga chapter, even after everything is settled, Meimi is ''still'' convinced that she's just some inferior version of Saint Tail to him, meaning it really is that hard for her to register the idea that he can actually love her.]]
* [[spoiler:In the last chapter/episode, Asuka Jr. wonders if Meimi was [[WasItAllJustALie enjoying the idea of messing around with him]], based on the fact he'd just learned from Rosemary that Meimi had actively wanted to hide her identity from him for some unspecified reason; firstly, this confirms that Meimi's fears about him hating her purely for deception were largely unfounded and that [[PoorCommunicationKills this would have been solved much earlier]] if she'd just ''told'' him, and secondly, it suggests that, Asuka Jr.'s [[ObliviousToLove infamous denseness]] aside, he has an easier time believing that Meimi was ''using his suffering as a coping method'' than the more obvious alternative.]]

to:

* Meimi's severe insecurity hits peak in chapter 21/episode 40 when her [[OneDialogueTwoConversations utter misinterpretation]] of what Asuka Jr. had told her in the previous chapter/episode leads her to believe that he'd found some other girl he'd fallen in love with, meaning that Meimi is so unwilling to believe he could ever love her that she has an easier time believing he'd found some unnamed girl with some accidental resemblance to Saint Tail. [[spoiler:Which Which is only made worse by the fact that in a later bonus manga chapter, even after everything is settled, Meimi is ''still'' convinced that she's just some inferior version of Saint Tail to him, meaning it really is that hard for her to register the idea that he can actually love her.]]
her.
* [[spoiler:In In the last chapter/episode, Asuka Jr. wonders if Meimi was [[WasItAllJustALie [[WasItAllALie enjoying the idea of messing around with him]], based on the fact he'd just learned from Rosemary that Meimi had actively wanted to hide her identity from him for some unspecified reason; firstly, this confirms that Meimi's fears about him hating her purely for deception were largely unfounded and that [[PoorCommunicationKills this would have been solved much earlier]] if she'd just ''told'' him, and secondly, it suggests that, Asuka Jr.'s [[ObliviousToLove infamous denseness]] aside, he has an easier time believing that Meimi was ''using his suffering as a coping method'' than the more obvious alternative.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* Asuka Jr. seeing Meimi in Saint Tail's reflection in chapter/episode 13 is especially played this way in the manga version, where his expression looks completely ''shattered'' as he parses the implication that the girl he's been developing a crush on might also be the thief he's been charged with arresting, along with all of the other uncomfortable implications that comes with. It's no wonder he has to rely on SelectiveObliviousness to cope afterwards.

Added: 389

Changed: 484

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es), General clarification on works content


* Chapter 15/Episode 23 is both the chapter/episode that properly reveals the full meaning of the flower-and-snow CreationMyth and the chapter Meimi starts actively pushing Asuka Jr. away out of fear, making the immediate contrast between her mention of "the flower that could be near the snow" (i.e. her feelings of wanting to be with him) before pushing him away even more heartbreaking.



* Meimi's severe insecurity hits peak in chapter 21/episode 40 when her [[OneDialogueTwoConversations utter misinterpretation]] of what Asuka Jr. had told her in the previous chapter/episode leads her to believe that he'd found some other girl he'd fallen in love with, meaning that Meimi is ''so'' unwilling to believe he could ever love her that she has an easier time believing he'd found some unnamed girl with some accidental resemblance to Saint Tail.
* [[spoiler:In the last chapter/episode, Asuka Jr. wonders if Meimi was [[WasItAllJustALie enjoying the idea of messing around with him]], based on the fact he'd just learned from Rosemary that Meimi had actively wanted to hide her identity from him for some unspecified reason; firstly, this confirms that Meimi's fears were largely unfounded and that [[PoorCommunicationKills this would have been solved much earlier]] if she'd just ''told'' him, and secondly, it suggests that, Asuka Jr.'s [[ObliviousToLove infamous denseness]] aside, he's still so convinced that Meimi must secretly dislike him that he thinks it's completely possible Meimi was ''using his suffering as a coping method''.]]

to:

* Meimi's severe insecurity hits peak in chapter 21/episode 40 when her [[OneDialogueTwoConversations utter misinterpretation]] of what Asuka Jr. had told her in the previous chapter/episode leads her to believe that he'd found some other girl he'd fallen in love with, meaning that Meimi is ''so'' so unwilling to believe he could ever love her that she has an easier time believing he'd found some unnamed girl with some accidental resemblance to Saint Tail.
Tail. [[spoiler:Which is only made worse by the fact that in a later bonus manga chapter, even after everything is settled, Meimi is ''still'' convinced that she's just some inferior version of Saint Tail to him, meaning it really is that hard for her to register the idea that he can actually love her.]]
* [[spoiler:In the last chapter/episode, Asuka Jr. wonders if Meimi was [[WasItAllJustALie enjoying the idea of messing around with him]], based on the fact he'd just learned from Rosemary that Meimi had actively wanted to hide her identity from him for some unspecified reason; firstly, this confirms that Meimi's fears about him hating her purely for deception were largely unfounded and that [[PoorCommunicationKills this would have been solved much earlier]] if she'd just ''told'' him, and secondly, it suggests that, Asuka Jr.'s [[ObliviousToLove infamous denseness]] aside, he's still so convinced he has an easier time believing that Meimi must secretly dislike him that he thinks it's completely possible Meimi was ''using his suffering as a coping method''.method'' than the more obvious alternative.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing indentation


** Chapter 19/Episode 29 has Asuka Jr. staring at Saint Tail with an expression that's somewhat difficult to read but has a [[LongingLook very clear sense of longing]] (this is particularly clear in the manga version of the scene, where you can see the pain ''very'' visibly on his face). At this point, he's in a very difficult state with his complicated feelings about potentially losing Meimi, his subconscious suspicion that he's actually looking at her right now, and desperation to get a proper answer to all of this... but not only is he forced to let go, Saint Tail also ''still'' thinks he only wants her to stay so he can arrest her.

to:

** * Chapter 19/Episode 29 has Asuka Jr. staring at Saint Tail with an expression that's somewhat difficult to read but has a [[LongingLook very clear sense of longing]] (this is particularly clear in the manga version of the scene, where you can see the pain ''very'' visibly on his face). At this point, he's in a very difficult state with his complicated feelings about potentially losing Meimi, his subconscious suspicion that he's actually looking at her right now, and desperation to get a proper answer to all of this... but not only is he forced to let go, Saint Tail also ''still'' thinks he only wants her to stay so he can arrest her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* [[spoiler:In the last chapter/episode, Asuka Jr. wonders if Meimi was [[WasItAllJustALie enjoying the idea of messing around with him]] based on the fact he'd just learned from Rosemary that Meimi had actively wanted to hide her identity from him for some unspecified reason, firstly confirming that Meimi's fears were largely unfounded and that [[PoorCommunicationKills this would have been solved much earlier]] if she'd just ''told'' him, and secondly suggesting that, Asuka Jr.'s [[ObliviousToLove infamous denseness]] aside, he's still so convinced that Meimi must secretly dislike him that he thinks it's completely possible Meimi was ''using his suffering as a coping method''.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:In the last chapter/episode, Asuka Jr. wonders if Meimi was [[WasItAllJustALie enjoying the idea of messing around with him]] him]], based on the fact he'd just learned from Rosemary that Meimi had actively wanted to hide her identity from him for some unspecified reason, firstly confirming reason; firstly, this confirms that Meimi's fears were largely unfounded and that [[PoorCommunicationKills this would have been solved much earlier]] if she'd just ''told'' him, and secondly suggesting secondly, it suggests that, Asuka Jr.'s [[ObliviousToLove infamous denseness]] aside, he's still so convinced that Meimi must secretly dislike him that he thinks it's completely possible Meimi was ''using his suffering as a coping method''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* Meimi's severe insecurity hits peak in chapter 21/episode 40 when her [[OnePersonTwoConversations utter misinterpretation]] of what Asuka Jr. had told her in the previous chapter/episode leads her to believe that he'd found some other girl he'd fallen in love with, meaning that Meimi is ''so'' unwilling to believe he could ever love her that she has an easier time believing he'd found some unnamed girl with some accidental resemblance to Saint Tail.

to:

* Meimi's severe insecurity hits peak in chapter 21/episode 40 when her [[OnePersonTwoConversations [[OneDialogueTwoConversations utter misinterpretation]] of what Asuka Jr. had told her in the previous chapter/episode leads her to believe that he'd found some other girl he'd fallen in love with, meaning that Meimi is ''so'' unwilling to believe he could ever love her that she has an easier time believing he'd found some unnamed girl with some accidental resemblance to Saint Tail.

Added: 688

Changed: 1300

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s), General clarification on works content


* Many of the times [[ObliviousToLove Asuka jr. fails to see that Meimi/Saint Tail is in love with him]].
** Especially in the last chapter, where, after discovering her identity, he wonders if she was just playing with his heart.
*** This one is made worse by the fact Meimi has ''nightmares'' about this possibility, as shown in episode 24.

to:

* Many The ObliviousToLove treatment on both ends effectively makes it hell for both Meimi and Asuka Jr. for an extended period of time as they both ''continually'' fail to notice each other's feelings, all while suffering.
** Chapter 19/Episode 29 has Asuka Jr. staring at Saint Tail with an expression that's somewhat difficult to read but has a [[LongingLook very clear sense of longing]] (this is particularly clear in the manga version
of the times scene, where you can see the pain ''very'' visibly on his face). At this point, he's in a very difficult state with his complicated feelings about potentially losing Meimi, his subconscious suspicion that he's actually looking at her right now, and desperation to get a proper answer to all of this... but not only is he forced to let go, Saint Tail also ''still'' thinks he only wants her to stay so he can arrest her.
* Meimi's severe insecurity hits peak in chapter 21/episode 40 when her [[OnePersonTwoConversations utter misinterpretation]] of what Asuka Jr. had told her in the previous chapter/episode leads her to believe that he'd found some other girl he'd fallen in love with, meaning that Meimi is ''so'' unwilling to believe he could ever love her that she has an easier time believing he'd found some unnamed girl with some accidental resemblance to Saint Tail.
* [[spoiler:In the last chapter/episode, Asuka Jr. wonders if Meimi was [[WasItAllJustALie enjoying the idea of messing around with him]] based on the fact he'd just learned from Rosemary that Meimi had actively wanted to hide her identity from him for some unspecified reason, firstly confirming that Meimi's fears were largely unfounded and that [[PoorCommunicationKills this would have been solved much earlier]] if she'd just ''told'' him, and secondly suggesting that, Asuka Jr.'s
[[ObliviousToLove Asuka jr. fails to see infamous denseness]] aside, he's still so convinced that Meimi/Saint Tail is in love with him]].
** Especially in the last chapter, where, after discovering her identity, he wonders if she was just playing with his heart.
*** This one is made worse by the fact
Meimi has ''nightmares'' about this possibility, must secretly dislike him that he thinks it's completely possible Meimi was ''using his suffering as shown in episode 24.a coping method''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** This one is made worse by the fact Meimi has ''nightmares'' about this possibility, as shown in episode 24.
* Both scenes at Pandora's Fortune Teller House in episode 41, aside for the [[ItMakesSenseInContext bathroom smell]] part.

to:

*** This one is made worse by the fact Meimi has ''nightmares'' about this possibility, as shown in episode 24.
* Both scenes at Pandora's Fortune Teller House in episode 41, aside for the [[ItMakesSenseInContext bathroom smell]] part.
24.

Added: 123

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** This one is made worse by the fact Meimi has ''nightmares'' about this possibility, as shown in episode 24

to:

*** This one is made worse by the fact Meimi has ''nightmares'' about this possibility, as shown in episode 2424.
* Both scenes at Pandora's Fortune Teller House in episode 41, aside for the [[ItMakesSenseInContext bathroom smell]] part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Especially in the last chapter, where, after discovering her identity, he wonders if she was just playing with his heart.

to:

** Especially in the last chapter, where, after discovering her identity, he wonders if she was just playing with his heart.heart.
*** This one is made worse by the fact Meimi has ''nightmares'' about this possibility, as shown in episode 24
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Many of the times [[ObliviousToLove Asuka jr. fails to see that Meimi/Saint Tail is in love with him]].
** Especially in the last chapter, where, after discovering her identity, he wonders if she was just playing with his heart.

Top