Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / Dieppe

Go To

OR

Added: 306

Removed: 315

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheHedonist: Casey is portrayed as this, carrying on an affair with a married British girl and then threatening to break it off once her husband is killed. He explains that he had to join the Army to escape a similar predicament in Canada. [[spoiler: Subverted in the end when he agrees to marry Leith.]]



* TheHedonist: Casey is portrayed as this, carrying on an affair with a married British girl and then threatening to break it off once her husband is killed. He explains that he had to join the Army to escape a similar predicament in Canada. [[spoiler: subverted in the end when he agrees to marry his girlfriend.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LovableRogue: Casey. He steals a roast beef dinner from the brass, and sleeps with a married English girl, yet suffers no consequences and seems to be popular with the other principal characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*AllGirlsWantBadBoys: Leith's attraction to Casey is never overtly explained, though he fits a number of tropes that sync with this idea, such as AntiHero, LovableRogue, etc. Casey is presented as such in his introductory scene, when he advises a comrade "if we did everything we were told - we'd be Nazis."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ImprobableUseOfAWeapon: Casey tries to blow up a barbed wire entanglement with a hand grenade. This was generally done with a much bigger explosive charge designed for the task, either a satchel charge or a Bangalore torpedo (as depicted in The Big Red One or Saving Private Ryan).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a scene at the Dieppe seawall, Casey tries to blow up barbed wire with an American grenade. Unusual in that the correct Mills Bomb type grenades are shown being fuzed in a scene set on the transport. A continuity error also occurs when Casey initially places the grenade - there is no fuze on the bottom of the American grenade, just a hole where it should be. When the camera cuts away and back, a propmaster had obviously caught the error, and the hole in the grenade is now packed with grey putty.

to:

** In a scene at the Dieppe seawall, Casey tries to blow up barbed wire with an American grenade. Unusual in that the correct Mills Bomb type grenades are shown being fuzed in a an earlier scene set on the transport. A continuity error also occurs when Casey initially places the grenade - there is no fuze on the bottom of the American grenade, just a hole where it should be. When the camera cuts away and back, a propmaster had obviously must have caught the error, and as the hole in the grenade is now magically packed with grey putty.

Added: 1993

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImproperlyPlacedFirearms: A couple of these.
**The standard battle rifle at the time of Dieppe was the Number III Mark I. While some of these can be seen floating in the water with casualties during the climactic landing scenes, the principal actors carry Number 4 Mark I rifles, which weren't made available until 1943. The most visible difference between the two are the bayonets; the First World War era No. 3 had a long sword-blade bayonet, the No. 4 had a much shorter spike resembling a screwdriver.
**Canadian firearms laws at the time of filming prohibited "high-capacity magazines", including that for the Bren, all of which had to be pinned by firearms owners to restrict capacity to 5 rounds. During the scene in which Jawarski is shooting the Bren Gun over the heads of his men, it is obvious he can only fire 5 rounds at a time despite the actual magazine capacity of 28 rounds.
**The standard submachine gun of the time was the Thompson. Sten guns were issued out specially to the 2nd Division for Dieppe. They trained with the guns, which required much finishing work to make the actions run smoothly. When Operation Rutter was cancelled, the guns were returned. When Operation Jubilee was remounted, brand new Sten guns were issued out at the last minute, with all the imperfections of the first batch. While the film does show Sten guns, the cast are depicted as being extremely familiar with them (to the point of having contests to see how fast they can assemble them).
**In a scene at the Dieppe seawall, Casey tries to blow up barbed wire with an American grenade. Unusual in that the correct Mills Bomb type grenades are shown being fuzed in a scene set on the transport. A continuity error also occurs when Casey initially places the grenade - there is no fuze on the bottom of the American grenade, just a hole where it should be. When the camera cuts away and back, a propmaster had obviously caught the error, and the hole in the grenade is now packed with grey putty.



* WeAREStrugglingTogether: Denied battleship support, General Roberts desperately appeals to the head of Bomber Command, Air Marshal Arthur Harris. Harris agrees to provide 150 heavy bombers but asks what would happen if it was too foggy for his planes to take off on the day. Roberts replies he'd have no choice to press on. Harris thanks him and Roberts leaves the meeting convinced he has his bombers. It later turns out that Harris went over Roberts' head to the combined chiefs with a refusal to participate, because Roberts in effect stated their presence wasn't absolutely necessary.

to:

* WeAREStrugglingTogether: Denied battleship support, General Roberts desperately appeals to the head of Bomber Command, Air Marshal Arthur Harris. Harris agrees to provide 150 heavy bombers but asks what would happen if it was too foggy for his planes to take off on the day. Roberts replies he'd have no choice but to press on. Harris thanks him and Roberts leaves the meeting convinced he has his bombers. It later turns out that Harris went over Roberts' head to the combined chiefs with a refusal to participate, because Roberts in effect stated their presence wasn't absolutely necessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MilitarySalute: the correct service salutes are rendered for the most part, though at least one of the extras is obviously from the post-Unification era Canadian Forces, as they are wearing an Army uniform but render a naval salute (which was the style adopted by the entire Canadian Forces after the three services were merged in 1968).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

The four hour, two-part series is largely based on the book "Unauthorized Action" by Brian Loring-Villa. His contention was that the Dieppe Raid was never actually authorized, and that Mountbatten proceeded to mount the raid in the face of objections by his superiors, amidst a complicated political climate that gave rise to the conditions where he could do so. More recent scholarship has come to light in the years since, notably One Day in August by David O'Keefe, who contends the raid was a cover for a special forces mission to capture German code machine parts.

The thrust of the show is to demonstrate how the senior commanders came to the decision to launch what turned out to be a disaster, and the effects on the common soldiers at the bottom of the chain of command, who paid the price.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigBadassBattleSequence: Inasmuch as a limited Canadian television budget can portray. The climax of the miniseries is the assault on Blue Beach. The planning for the raid takes up the first three-quarters of the series, with the landings and the aftermatch both given reasonable coverage. Budget considerations prevented the portrayal of the other landing beaches (Yellow, Orange, Green, Red and White) but the script focused its attention on a single platoon landing at Blue Beach, so the viewer gets a taste of the overall action.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PinnedDown: played straight, and TruthInTelevision, the landings at Blue Beach were at a shallow stretch of pebbles backed by tall cliffs. The Canadians landed directly underneath German machine guns in concrete bunkers. In real life, 500 Canadians landed and were opposed by just 60 German Air Force troops, who did not require reinforcement during the battle. In the show, as in life, the Canadians could do little more than press themselves against the stone sea-wall.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoodleIncident: when Roberts orders Morton to get out of his jeep and walk with his men during a 250 mile route march, adding the threat of cashiering unless he smartens up, Magnus asks "is it true he saved your life?" Roberts says "that's right" but it's never explained how, when or why it happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*InsaneAdmiral: a number of these. Mountbatten is more interested in publicity than winning the war. Sir Dudley Pound, the naval chief of staff, fears losing battleships more than he cares about supporting the other services. Sir Arthur Harris thinks he can win the war single-handedly with Bomber Command and is loathe to divert his airplanes away from their strategic mission.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*MajorlyAwesome: the two officers ranked as Major also have similar names (Magnus and Morton). Magnus is portrayed as attractive, with several English girlfriends, fearless and calm both under fire and [[spoiler: once they are forced to surrender]]. In line with the trope, he begins the film as a planner, but volunteers to land on the beach to participate in the fighting.
**Morton's level of awesome never rises to that of Magnus. He is initially seen as blustery and lazy. On the beach itself, he does little more than give impossible orders until [[spoiler: he is shot in the stomach and presumably killed]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** American commanders are portrayed as bullies, heedless of British and Canadian contributions to the war, and eager to satisfy the latter simply to get into the war faster.

to:

** American commanders are portrayed as bullies, heedless of British and Canadian contributions to the war, and eager to satisfy sacrifice the latter simply to so they can get into the war faster.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GeneralFailure: Some of the British officers are treated roughly. Montgomery points out that Mountbatten had two battleships shot out from under him, and when Mountbatten boasts of being the youngest Vice Admiral since Nelson, the naval chief of staff reminds him his rank is acting, not substantive. Mountbatten is portrayed as more interested in publicity than winning the war.
**Captain Hughes-Hallett is shown giving Roberts bad advice to call off desperately needed air support.
**Canadian General McNaughton also kvetches about how two Canadian battalions where wiped out by being under British command at Hong Kong.
**American commanders are portrayed as bullies, heedless of British and Canadian contributions to the war, and eager to satisfy the latter simply to get into the war faster.
**Crerar and McNaughton are both shown as putting ambition and politics ahead of military necessity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*FrontlineGeneral: averted, despite some generals OutrankingYourJob, with General Roberts where he was historically during the raid, on the bridge of HMS Calpe. Other senior officers listen intently from headquarters in the UK.


Added DiffLines:

* OutrankingYourJob: the commander of the 2nd Canadian Division seems to have much time on his hands. The first (referred to in dialogue as 'Brian' but in real life Victor Odlum) is depicted as playing DrillSergeantNasty to a single platoon of soldiers. He is replaced by Hamilton Roberts, who in one scene drops by the barracks of the heroes to chat about fishing and remark on a Sten Gun assembly contest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheHedonist: Casey is portrayed as this, carrying on an affair with a married British girl and then threatening to break it off once her husband is killed. He explains that he had to join the Army to escape a similar predicament in Canada. [[spoiler: subverted in the end when he agrees to marry his girlfriend.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WeAREStrugglingTogether: General Roberts is shown as desperate to get fire support for the raid. When he talks to Air Marshal Arthur Harris (head of Bomber Command) to obtain heavy bombers, Harris agrees but asks what would happen if it was too foggy for his planes to take off on the day. Roberts replies he'd have no choice to press on. Harris thanks him and Roberts leaves the meeting convinced he has his bombers. It later turns out that Harris refused to participate since Roberts in effect stated their presence wasn't absolutely necessary.

to:

* WeAREStrugglingTogether: Denied battleship support, General Roberts is shown as desperate desperately appeals to get fire support for the raid. When he talks to head of Bomber Command, Air Marshal Arthur Harris (head of Bomber Command) to obtain heavy bombers, Harris. Harris agrees to provide 150 heavy bombers but asks what would happen if it was too foggy for his planes to take off on the day. Roberts replies he'd have no choice to press on. Harris thanks him and Roberts leaves the meeting convinced he has his bombers. It later turns out that Harris refused went over Roberts' head to participate since the combined chiefs with a refusal to participate, because Roberts in effect stated their presence wasn't absolutely necessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* WeAREStrugglingTogether: General Roberts is shown as desperate to get fire support for the raid. When he talks to Air Marshal Arthur Harris (head of Bomber Command) to obtain heavy bombers, Harris agrees but asks what would happen if it was too foggy for his planes to take off on the day. Roberts replies he'd have no choice to press on. Harris thanks him and Roberts leaves the meeting convinced he has his bombers. It later turns out that Harris refused to participate since Roberts in effect stated their presence wasn't absolutely necessary.
**Harris wasn't being completely selfish; he states his belief in dialogue that Bomber Command is doing important work, and he has no desire to derail his master plan for a "Dickie Mountbatten sideshow."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IgnoredExpert: General Montgomery advises the planners that heavy fire support will be necessary for the plan to succeed. By the time Operation Jubilee is launched, [[spoiler: the battleship support has been deleted and the Royal Air Force refused to commit its heavy bombers to the operation, leaving only the element of surprise in the Allies' favour.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericaSavesTheDay: played with and averted. While General Eisenhower threatens to "take our war to the Pacific" if they can't convince the British to invade France in 1942, the British remind them that the bulk of forces in such an invasion would be British and Canadian. The Americans grudgingly go along, and while they send 50 Army Rangers to Dieppe, bide time while the British make the main effort in Europe through its commando raiding program and the aerial bombing of Germany. General Crerar is anxious to get Canadian soldiers into action before the Americans, presumably so this trope will be averted and the British and Canadians will get some of the credit for the victory.

to:

* AmericaSavesTheDay: played with and averted. While General Eisenhower threatens to "take our war to the Pacific" if they can't convince the British to invade France in 1942, the British remind them that the bulk of forces in such an invasion would be British and Canadian. The Americans grudgingly go along, relent, and while they send 50 Army Rangers to Dieppe, bide time while the British make the main effort in Europe through its commando raiding program and the aerial bombing of Germany. General Crerar is anxious to get Canadian soldiers into action before the Americans, presumably so this trope will be averted and the British and Canadians will get some of the credit for the victory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StiffUpperLip: to be expected in a movie inhabited by British officers, but subtly used here to cast the British in a more villainous role. As reports of the disaster on the beaches come in, Mountbatten calmly remarks that the air force and navy are doing a fine job, it's only too bad the Canadians' military plan was so bad.

-->'''Crerar:''' ''My'' plan?\\
'''Mountbatten:''' Hardly mine.

**Captain Hughes-Hallett also shows little reaction to the disaster as it unfolds, and calmly talks Roberts out of several courses of action that may have helped the landings be successful, or at least saved lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeadpanSnarker: a few examples, especially Lord Mountbatten.

-->'''Construction Worker:''' (after Mountbatten complains his office renovations are behind schedule) 'Ere, Rome wasn't built in a day!\\
'''Mountbatten:''' That's because it was built by foreigners.
**And another, blasphemous, example:
-->'''Hughes-Hallett:''' Do you think he (General Roberts) is any good?\\
'''Mountbatten:''' What's goodness got to do with it? Jesus was very good, but no one ever won a war by lounging about on a cross all day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GetAHoldOfYourselfMan: Stefan suffers from claustrophobia to the point he needs to be tied up and gagged while in the hold of the transport taking them to Dieppe. When released, he goes berserk trying to get out, until Major Morton grabs him and shakes him. Stefan explains he was trapped in a septic tank as a child, and Morton jokes that the smelly hold they're in means they're all in a septic tank.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CanucksWithChinooks: While the senior commanders in the film are British and American, the soldiers who are committed to carrying out the Dieppe Raid are Canadians. They are portrayed as independent, tough-minded and eager to fight after sitting in the UK for long years of training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BritsWithBattleships: The senior commanders on the Allied side are Prime Minister Winston Churchill, the combined chiefs of staff of the British armed forces, and the head of Combined Operations, Lord Mountbatten. The trope is portrayed literally as several discussions revolve around the commitment to Dieppe of a Royal Navy battleship for fire support and the unwillingness of the combined chiefs to lose another capital ship in combat. British sailors are featured prominently as background in many planning sequences, and as extras manning the landing craft that the Canadians ride to shore.

Added: 688

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!![Dieppe] contains examples of:

to:

!![Dieppe] !!''Dieppe'' contains examples of:
of:

* AmericaSavesTheDay: played with and averted. While General Eisenhower threatens to "take our war to the Pacific" if they can't convince the British to invade France in 1942, the British remind them that the bulk of forces in such an invasion would be British and Canadian. The Americans grudgingly go along, and while they send 50 Army Rangers to Dieppe, bide time while the British make the main effort in Europe through its commando raiding program and the aerial bombing of Germany. General Crerar is anxious to get Canadian soldiers into action before the Americans, presumably so this trope will be averted and the British and Canadians will get some of the credit for the victory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuspiciouslySmallArmy: When Lord Mountbatten and General Eisenhower come to inspect the Canadian assault force, a hundred or so infantrymen, and a single extra wearing the insignia of the tank regiment that landed at Dieppe, are in the crowd. Another scene shows the general commanding the 2nd Canadian Division - a force in reality of 10 infantry battalions and supporting services numbering over 10,000 men - beasting a single platoon. The tight perspectives of the Blue Beach scenes also make the small budget and tiny shooting location obvious.


to:

* SuspiciouslySmallArmy: When Lord Mountbatten and General Eisenhower come to inspect the Canadian assault force, a hundred or so infantrymen, and a single extra wearing the insignia of the tank regiment that landed at Dieppe, are in make up the crowd. audience. Another scene shows the general commanding the 2nd Canadian Division - a force in reality of 10 infantry battalions and supporting services numbering over 10,000 men - beasting acting as DrillSergeantNasty to a single platoon. The tight perspectives of the Blue Beach scenes also make the small budget and tiny shooting location obvious.

Added: 46

Changed: 82

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[quoteright:347:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/dieppebattle2.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:347:StormingTheBeaches]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

A Canadian mini-series airing on the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation network in 1993. Focus of the series shifts back and forth between those planning the raid on Dieppe on August 19, 1942, and one of the platoons of Canadian infantrymen that was charged with carrying out the landings.

----
!![Dieppe] contains examples of:

* AntiHero: Casey is an adulterous rule-breaker who threatens to break things off with his English girlfriend as soon as he finds out her husband, fighting overseas, has been killed. Boasts about not actually carrying anything in his pack on route marches, and leads a raid on General McNaughton's dinner party in order to steal their roast beef and wine.
* BandagedFace: Plenty of these as the force withdraws from Dieppe and returns to England. Lord Mountbatten gives a shocked 'Good God' on seeing one particularly badly wounded soldier.
* TheBigBoard: interspersed with combat scenes during the landings, the planners in England review the board and dicker about air support. Also used to illustrate the complexity of the landings - and why the inflexible plan can't be changed in the face of new intelligence.
* EconomyCast: Major Magnus is variously depicted both commanding an infantry company, and planning the raid at divisional headquarters as a staff officer.
* EstablishingCharacterMoment: Jean (see below under HitchhikerHeroes) is introduced drinking alone until his older comrades point one of the local girls toward him. He confesses to her that he is underage, and she takes him to a local park to relieve him of his virginity. Afterwards, he boasts (ComicallyMissingThePoint) that she told him he was "the fastest" she's ever had.
* HitchhikerHeroes: Jean, an underage recruit, confesses that his attempt to enlist with his home town regiment, Les Fusiliers Mont-Royal, was refused. He was able to sign up at fifteen with The Royal Regiment of Canada because "they don't ask so many questions in Toronto."
* StormingTheBeaches: the climax of the series is the assault on Blue Beach. [[spoiler: TruthInTelevision, the landings on Blue Beach are a disaster and all who set foot there are killed, wounded or taken prisoner.]]
* SuspiciouslySmallArmy: When Lord Mountbatten and General Eisenhower come to inspect the Canadian assault force, a hundred or so infantrymen, and a single extra wearing the insignia of the tank regiment that landed at Dieppe, are in the crowd. Another scene shows the general commanding the 2nd Canadian Division - a force in reality of 10 infantry battalions and supporting services numbering over 10,000 men - beasting a single platoon. The tight perspectives of the Blue Beach scenes also make the small budget and tiny shooting location obvious.


----

Top