Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Retcon / WesternAnimation

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not really a retcon. Yes, had only season one come out viewers would have assumed Katara was the only living member, but nothing in the season actually indicated this, so no events needed rewriting.


* Katara was originally written as the only member of the ''WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender'' main cast to be alive during ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra''. Somewhere in the development of future seasons they decided that Zuko was also alive, and in the last book the viewer learns that [[spoiler:Toph]] is alive but WalkingTheEarth. That means at least half of the "[[FanNickname Gaang]]" is alive, though whether Suki is alive or not is [[WhateverHappenedToTheMouse never mentioned]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Season 32 episode "Uncut Femmes" established that Chief Wiggum was unaware that his wife Sarah had a criminal past as a jewel thief, contradicting a throwaway bit in the Season 14 episode "A Star Is Born-Again", where they both reminisce over the day they met:
--->'''Wiggum:''' Sarah, you're as lovely as the day I first arrested you.\\
'''Sarah:''' Oh, Clancy. You know, I planted that crystal meth just to meet you.\\
'''Wiggum:''' I was so shy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The episode “Manger Things” depicts Maude Flanders pregnant with Todd when Bart was four and Lisa was two, whereas past episodes had Todd being Bart’s age and “Lisa’s First Word” had him being around before Lisa was born.

Added: 465

Changed: 462

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''The Simpsons'' FloatingTimeline being what it is, this retcon actually makes sense. The Simpsons' time exists on a sliding line, so even though every episode happens in "the present", the past keeps moving forward. Also note that while the kids' ages [[NotAllowedToGrowUp never change]], Marge and Homer have been, albeit very slowly, getting older; being in their mid-thirties in early episodes and now nearing forty (presumably to reflect the aging American population), which does leave a gap for the events of "that 90's show" to take place.

to:

** ''The Simpsons'' FloatingTimeline being what it is, this retcon actually makes sense. sense.
***
The Simpsons' time exists on a sliding line, so even though every episode happens in "the present", the past keeps moving forward. Also note that while the kids' ages [[NotAllowedToGrowUp never change]], Marge and Homer have been, albeit very slowly, getting older; being in their mid-thirties in early episodes and now nearing forty (presumably to reflect the aging American population), which does leave a gap for the events of "that 90's show" to take place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Originally when the fairies were shown as babies they looked like miniature diaper clad versions of themselves, but when Poof was introduced it was retconned that all baby fairies look like little round balls with faces, short stubby limbs, tiny wings, and hair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The episode “Do Pizzabots Dream Of Electric Guitars?” will depict Homer as a teenager in the 1990’s, whereas early seasons had him as a teen in the 1970’s, this is because as the years go on, this becomes more and more unlikely that the early seasons could’ve happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has previously been established. This may possibly be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambiguous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed, though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".

to:

** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has previously been established. This may possibly be an error, as South Park has never been consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambiguous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed, though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has previously been established. This may possible be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambiguous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed, though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".

to:

** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has previously been established. This may possible possibly be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambiguous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed, though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has previously been established. This may possible be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambiguous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed,though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".

to:

** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has previously been established. This may possible be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambiguous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed,though, progressed, though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has previously been established. This may possible be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambigous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed,though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".

to:

** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has previously been established. This may possible be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambigous ambiguous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed,though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has been previously been established. This may possible be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambigous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed,though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".

to:

** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has been previously been established. This may possible be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambigous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed,though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Jimbo Kern, Stan's uncle, has been inconsistently portrayed as being both Sharon's and Randy's brother over the course of the series, but an interview with series co-creator Creator/MattStone established him as being Randy's half-brother; as they were birthed by the same mother but share different fathers, explaining the discrepancy between their surnames. However, despite this confirmation, Sharon referred to Jimbo as her brother in ''The Pandemic Special'', which directly contradicts what fraternity has been previously been established. This may possible be an error, as South Park has never consistent with these topics. A similar situation exists with Marvin Marsh, a wheelchair-bound 102-year-old who previously lived with Randy and Sharon. Earlier episodes were ambigous about the Marsh family tree, with both Sharon and Randy referring to Marvin as their father. As the series progressed,though, he was more heavily implied to be Randy's father, sharing his surname as well. It was first hinted by implying a genetic link between Marvin's addictions, Randy's drinking problem, and Stan's own addiction issues in notably "Freemium isn't Free", and later by Marvin describing his son's conception in "Nobody Got Cereal?".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [=SpongeBob=] can speak snail, yet he doesn't believe Gary's thoughts against Puffy Fluffy in "A Pal For Gary".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Another'' retcon with "Sponge on the Run" occurs when [=SpongeBob=] has a flashback of adopting Gary at Kamp Koral. In the Season 8 episode "Treats!", [=SpongeBob=] looks at a photo of himself adopting Gary at the ''pound''.

to:

** ''Another'' retcon with "Sponge ''Sponge on the Run" Run'' occurs when [=SpongeBob=] has a flashback of adopting Gary at Kamp Koral. In the Season 8 episode "Treats!", [=SpongeBob=] looks at a photo of himself adopting Gary at the ''pound''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''WesternAnimation/TheSpongeBobMovieSpongeOnTheRun'' and its spin-off "Kamp Koral", it's revealed [=SpongeBob=] gave Mr. Krabs the inspiration to open his own restaurant. This retcons "Truth or Square", which showed a flashback of [=SpongeBob=] before he was born eating a Krabby Patty for the first time. Granted, it's impossible to remember events from before you were born, but at the same time, it's [=SpongeBob=].
** ''Sponge on the Run'' also features a flashback of Sandy meeting [=SpongeBob=] for the first time at Kamp Koral, which retcons season 1 episode "Tea at the Treedome" (explainable, in that there was likely a huge time gap between those two events.)
** ''Another'' retcon with "Sponge on the Run" occurs when [=SpongeBob=] has a flashback of adopting Gary at Kamp Koral. In the Season 8 episode "Treats!", [=SpongeBob=] looks at a photo of himself adopting Gary at the ''pound''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding a Sponge Bob section

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/SpongeBobSquarePants'':
** The episode "Grandma's Secret Recipe" Introduces Plankton's grandmother, who has 2 eyes. She later reappears in a Season 11 episode called "Grandmum's the Word". She sports basically the same design, but with one notable change: She now has 1 eye, just like her grandson and real-life copepods.
** In "Something Smells", when Patrick is monologuing about how ugly he is, he mentions that he doesn't have a sister. This is retconned in a later episode called "Big Sister Sam", where Patrick's long lost sister, Samantha, visits. This could, however, be interpreted as Patrick attempting to repress a traumatic memory (the loss of his sister), rather than a retcon.
** A few episodes have shown Patrick's house being demolished or broken in some way, such as "The Monster who came to Bikini Bottom". These are retconned in a Season 12 episode called "Shell Games", where it's revealed Patrick's "rock" was actually the shell of an overslept sea turtle this whole time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Twice in the first season of ''WesternAnimation/FanboyAndChumChum'', they mention the Christmas holiday as if they celebrate it (Fanboy says the word "Christmas" in "Eyes on the Prize" while Yo mentions Santa Clause in "Night Morning"). Come the second, it is shown they celebrate ''[[YouMeanXmas Icemas]]'', a holiday that's like Christmas but with ice, and Man-Arctica is their equivalent of Santa Clause.

to:

* Twice in the first season of ''WesternAnimation/FanboyAndChumChum'', they mention the Christmas holiday as if they celebrate it (Fanboy says the word "Christmas" in "Eyes on the Prize" while Yo mentions Santa Clause in "Night Morning"). Come the second, it is shown they celebrate ''[[YouMeanXmas Icemas]]'', a holiday that's like Christmas but with ice, and Man-Arctica is their equivalent of Santa Clause.SantaClaus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one ''Oh Yeah! Cartoons'' episode Vicky mentions having a little brother. This brother was never heard from again but instead she has a little sister named Tootie.

to:

** In one ''Oh Yeah! Cartoons'' episode Vicky mentions having a little brother. This Said brother was never heard from mentioned again but instead she has a little sister named Tootie.



** Blukic and Driba were only introduced in ''WesternAnimation/Ben10Omniverse'', but they had [[RememberTheNewGuy allegedly been around the whole time even though we had never seen them]]. Flashbacks in-between the original series and ''WesternAnimation/Ben10AlienForce'' inject them into the continuity even though there was never any mention of them. The real kick is they had been on Earth since Max was young, and were actually the first aliens to officially make contact with humans, being the [[RoswellThatEndsWell alien captured during the Roswell Incident]].

to:

** Blukic and Driba were only introduced in ''WesternAnimation/Ben10Omniverse'', but they had [[RememberTheNewGuy allegedly been around the whole time even though we had never seen them]]. Flashbacks in-between the original series and ''WesternAnimation/Ben10AlienForce'' inject them into the continuity even though there was never any mention of them. The real kick explanation for this is that they had been on Earth since Max was young, and were actually the first aliens to officially make contact with humans, being the [[RoswellThatEndsWell alien captured during the Roswell Incident]].



* ''WesternAnimation/ReadyJetGo'': Due to the episodes airing out of production order, there are some. For example, the kids mention having a treehouse in "Jet 2", but they build the treehouse in "Treehouse Observatory".

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/ReadyJetGo'': Due to the episodes airing out of production order, there are some. For example, the kids mention having a treehouse in "Jet 2", but they build the said treehouse in "Treehouse Observatory".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Remy was PutOnTheBus for 4 seasons until season 9's ''Country Clubbed''. Despite being a reoccuring antagonist of Timmy's, the episode acts as if the two have never met. The episode also depicts Remy as not having a fairy and even [[YouDontLookLikeYou gave him a redesign]].

to:

** Remy was PutOnTheBus PutOnABus for 4 seasons until season 9's ''Country Clubbed''. Despite being a reoccuring antagonist of Timmy's, the episode acts as if the two have never met. The episode also depicts Remy as not having a fairy and even [[YouDontLookLikeYou gave him a redesign]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
simpsons


** The fact that Maggie shot Mr. Burns has been gradually retconned as part of MythologyGag about the controversy and implausibility of that being the answer to the famous "Who Shot Mr. Burns" mystery of Season 6-7. In the season 9 episode "The Cartridge Family" Homer says "I thought Smithers did it?" to which Lisa suspiciously replies "That would have made a lot more sense..." Then, in season 18, Homer in a passing moment outright claims that he framed Maggie.

to:

** The fact that Maggie shot Mr. Burns has been gradually retconned back into an unsolved mystery as part of MythologyGag about the controversy and implausibility of that being the answer to the famous "Who Shot Mr. Burns" mystery of Season 6-7. In the season 9 episode "The Cartridge Family" Homer says "I thought Smithers did it?" to which Lisa suspiciously replies "That agrees, in a suspicious tone, "that would have made a lot more sense..." Then, in season 18, Homer in a passing moment outright claims that he framed Maggie. In Season 22, Homer at one point instructs the viewer to go back and look for clues as to who "really" shot Mr. Burns. Marge scolds him that it was Maggie, but Homer seems unconvinced — "Oh sure, a ''baby'' shot a guy."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There is no "Rai dub" of Winx Club; Rai was never involved in any English dubbing. The dubbing was actually done by Cinélume, a Canadian studio.


*** (2) In the same flashback in season 8, Icy is shown to have had natural curly blonde hair before changing it to straight and silver-blue, but in the season 3 episode ''The Black Willow's Tears'' when Icy, Darcy, and Stormy are regressed to children, Icy is shown with natural straight silver-blue hair.[[note]] It is of note that some fans use this episode as so-called "proof" that the Trix aren't actual sisters (the dubbing errors of the 4kids and Rai dubs of the episode where Stormy comments that they're friends don't help. It's worth pointing out that the 4kids dub was infamous for creating numerous [[DubInducedPlotHole Dub-Induced Plot Holes]] and the Rai dub was not without its own errors, such as claiming Tecna was a cyborg. The Nick dub, however, corrects this by having Stormy accurately say they're sisters) due to the fact that after the Trix are turned back into children, Icy comments on Darcy's hair, "Your hair used to look like that?", leaving some fans wondering why she wouldn't remember how she used to look if they were really sisters. However, the reason is simply that they forgot how they used to look when they were kids, which isn’t all that shocking since there are a lot of people who forget how they and their siblings/relatives used to look when they were younger, especially if they look ''vastly'' different than how they used to when they were young[[/note]].

to:

*** (2) In the same flashback in season 8, Icy is shown to have had natural curly blonde hair before changing it to straight and silver-blue, but in the season 3 episode ''The Black Willow's Tears'' when Icy, Darcy, and Stormy are regressed to children, Icy is shown with natural straight silver-blue hair.[[note]] It is of note that some fans use this episode as so-called "proof" that the Trix aren't actual sisters (the dubbing errors of the 4kids and Rai Cinélume dubs of the episode where Stormy comments that they're friends don't help. It's worth pointing out that the 4kids dub was infamous for creating numerous [[DubInducedPlotHole Dub-Induced Plot Holes]] and the Rai Cinélume dub was not without its own errors, such as claiming Tecna was a cyborg. The Nick dub, however, corrects this by having Stormy accurately say they're sisters) due to the fact that after the Trix are turned back into children, Icy comments on Darcy's hair, "Your hair used to look like that?", leaving some fans wondering why she wouldn't remember how she used to look if they were really sisters. However, the reason is simply that they forgot how they used to look when they were kids, which isn’t all that shocking since there are a lot of people who forget how they and their siblings/relatives used to look when they were younger, especially if they look ''vastly'' different than how they used to when they were young[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Grammar


** Coinciding with EarlyInstallmentWeirdness, in a season one episode Twilight is [[TakenForGranite turned to stone]] by looking a cockatrice in the eye. When she's later unfrozen, she appears to have no knowledge that any time has past. In later seasons, however, it is said explicitly by [[GodOfChaos Discord]] that a person remains fully aware and conscious while petrified. This is further confirmed in season nine when Maud's boyfriend, Mudbriar, is petrified by a cockatrice and remembers the experience.

to:

** Coinciding with EarlyInstallmentWeirdness, in a season one episode Twilight is [[TakenForGranite turned to stone]] by looking a cockatrice in the eye. When she's later unfrozen, she appears to have no knowledge that any time has past.passed. In later seasons, however, it is said explicitly by [[GodOfChaos Discord]] that a person remains fully aware and conscious while petrified. This is further confirmed in season nine when Maud's boyfriend, Mudbriar, is petrified by a cockatrice and remembers the experience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The series most dramatic and controversial retcon occurred in the 2008 episode, "That 90's Show." In the earlier episodes, Homer and Marge attended high school in the late 1970's got married three or four years after graduating from high school after Marge became pregnant with Bart, Bart was born in 1980, Lisa was born in 1982, and Maggie was born in 1989, and the show took place in the 1990s, with the characters never aging. By the 2000s, however, this timeline had become increasingly implausible, and was given a hard reset in "That 90's Show." Homer and Marge were now shown to have met in what appears to be the mid 1990s, which implies the kids were born in the early 2000s. Other changes were made as well: Marge in previous episodes had never gone to college, but was now established as having attended in the mid 90's; Homer had a Grunge band, whereas in an earlier episode he didn't understand grunge at all; and they also showed us that they dated for at least ten years before getting married and having the kids, who are now retconned into being born in the early 2000's. "That 90's Show" itself seems to have been since retconned, with "the past" now depicted far more generically, rather than tied to any specific decades. Presumably this is because in the 2020s, even the idea of Homer and Marge meeting in the 90s now seems increasingly unlikely if they're supposed to be in their 30s.

to:

** The series most dramatic and controversial retcon occurred in the 2008 episode, "That 90's Show." In the earlier episodes, Homer and Marge attended high school in the late 1970's got married three or four years after graduating from high school after Marge became pregnant with Bart, Bart was born in 1980, Lisa was born in 1982, and Maggie was born in 1989, and the show took place in the 1990s, with the characters never aging. By the 2000s, however, this timeline had become increasingly implausible, and was given a hard reset in "That 90's Show." Homer and Marge were now shown to have met in what appears to be the mid 1990s, which implies the kids were born in the early 2000s. Other changes were made as well: Marge in previous episodes had never gone to college, but was now established as having attended in the mid 90's; Homer had a Grunge band, whereas in an earlier episode he didn't understand grunge at all; and they also showed us that they dated for at least ten years before getting married and having the kids, who are now retconned into being born in the early 2000's. "That 90's Show" itself seems to have been since retconned, with "the past" now depicted far more generically, rather than tied to any specific decades. Presumably this is because in the 2020s, even the idea of Homer and Marge meeting being college-age in the 90s now seems increasingly unlikely if they're currently supposed to be in their 30s.

Changed: 1232

Removed: 543

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More on "That 90s show"


** The series has gone through a retcon as of the episode "That 90's Show." In the earlier episodes, Homer and Marge attended high school in the late 1970's got married three or four years after graduating from high school after Marge became pregnant with Bart, Bart was born in 1980, Lisa was born in 1982, and Maggie was born in 1989, but the series was retconned in the aforementioned episode. Marge in previous episodes had never gone to college, but was suddenly attending in the mid 90's; it led us to believe Homer had a Grunge band, whereas in an earlier episode he didn't understand grunge at all; and they also showed us that they dated for at least ten years before getting married and having the kids, who are now retconned into being born in the early 2000's. "That 90's Show" itself seems to be retconned since, though with the floating timeline it means Homer and Marge should be older than their 30s.
** Prior to this the characters were stuck in the 90's and never aged.
** ''The Simpsons'' time line being what it is, this retcon actually makes sense. The Simpsons' time exists on a sliding line, so even though every episode happens in "the present", the past keeps moving forward. Also note that while the kids' ages [[NotAllowedToGrowUp never change]], Marge and Homer have been, albeit very slowly, getting older; being in their mid-thirties in early episodes and now nearing forty (presumably to reflect the aging American population), which does leave a gap for the events of "that 90's show" to take place.

to:

** The series has gone through a most dramatic and controversial retcon as of occurred in the episode 2008 episode, "That 90's Show." In the earlier episodes, Homer and Marge attended high school in the late 1970's got married three or four years after graduating from high school after Marge became pregnant with Bart, Bart was born in 1980, Lisa was born in 1982, and Maggie was born in 1989, but and the series was retconned show took place in the aforementioned episode. 1990s, with the characters never aging. By the 2000s, however, this timeline had become increasingly implausible, and was given a hard reset in "That 90's Show." Homer and Marge were now shown to have met in what appears to be the mid 1990s, which implies the kids were born in the early 2000s. Other changes were made as well: Marge in previous episodes had never gone to college, but was suddenly attending now established as having attended in the mid 90's; it led us to believe Homer had a Grunge band, whereas in an earlier episode he didn't understand grunge at all; and they also showed us that they dated for at least ten years before getting married and having the kids, who are now retconned into being born in the early 2000's. "That 90's Show" itself seems to be retconned since, though have been since retconned, with "the past" now depicted far more generically, rather than tied to any specific decades. Presumably this is because in the floating timeline it means 2020s, even the idea of Homer and Marge should be older than their 30s.
** Prior to this the characters were stuck
meeting in the 90's and never aged.
90s now seems increasingly unlikely if they're supposed to be in their 30s.
** ''The Simpsons'' time line FloatingTimeline being what it is, this retcon actually makes sense. The Simpsons' time exists on a sliding line, so even though every episode happens in "the present", the past keeps moving forward. Also note that while the kids' ages [[NotAllowedToGrowUp never change]], Marge and Homer have been, albeit very slowly, getting older; being in their mid-thirties in early episodes and now nearing forty (presumably to reflect the aging American population), which does leave a gap for the events of "that 90's show" to take place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The fact that Maggie shot Mr. Burns has been gradually retconned as part of MythologyGag about the controversy and implausibility of that being the answer to the famous "Who Shot Mr. Burns" mystery of Season 6-7. In the season 9 episode "The Cartridge Family" Homer says "I thought Smithers did it?" to which Lisa suspiciously replies "That would have made a lot more sense..." Then, in season 18, Homer in a passing moment outright claims that he framed Maggie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Terrance and Philip

Added DiffLines:

** Early episodes refer to the Terrance and Phillip show as a cartoon, and indeed a parody of South Park itself, which is why it's "drawn" in such a blocky way. It was later established that Terrance and Phillip are actually real people who look like that, as they live in Canada where everything is blocky-looking. Similarly, the weird way baby Ike is drawn was originally just how all babies in South Park were going to look (in "Starvin' Marvin" you can even see an Ike-looking Ethiopian baby in a crowd shot at one point). This premise was later abandoned in favor of making Ike a Canadian baby.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** (3) Her actions (knowingly endangering the lives of/attempting to murder people for ''fun'', which started as early as ''episode 3''; stating she ''liked'' being evil and was actually annoyed at being referred to as anything less; assaulting ''children'', Flora's sister Miele and Mitzi's sister Macy, who happen to be little sisters like [[CousinOliver Sapphire]]) and motivations (wanting to become powerful for the repeated explicit purpose of ''conquering'' the Magic Dimension) ever since the beginning of season 1 ''do not'' align whatsoever with what season 8 is trying to establish her goals to be.

to:

*** (3) Her actions (knowingly endangering the lives of/attempting to murder people for ''fun'', which started as early as ''episode 3''; stating she ''liked'' being evil and was actually annoyed at being referred to as anything less; freezing a fairy's wings off for trying to escape her; assaulting ''children'', Flora's sister Miele and Mitzi's sister Macy, who happen to be little sisters like [[CousinOliver Sapphire]]) and motivations (wanting to become powerful for the repeated explicit purpose of ''conquering'' the Magic Dimension) ever since the beginning of season 1 ''do not'' align whatsoever with what season 8 is trying to establish her goals to be.



*** (6) And most importantly, the creator of the show, Iginio Straffi, [[https://www.corriereadriatico.it/SPETTACOLI/rainbow_avventure_winx_iginio_straffi_villa_musone_marche_rai2/notizie/421983.shtml actually had the story all planned out and was going to end the series after season 3 (with the first movie being the "grand finale" of the series)]], but since Winx became such a cash cow franchise, it got renewed for a fourth season and continued after that, so it ''cannot'' be said that this was planned from the start.




to:

*** (6) And most importantly, the creator of the show, Iginio Straffi, [[https://www.corriereadriatico.it/SPETTACOLI/rainbow_avventure_winx_iginio_straffi_villa_musone_marche_rai2/notizie/421983.shtml actually had the story all planned out and was going to end the series after season 3 (with the first movie being the "grand finale" of the series)]], but since Winx became such a cash cow franchise, it got renewed for a fourth season and continued after that, so it ''cannot'' be said that this was planned from the start. \n\n\n\n Hell, Straffi himself and much of the production crew that worked on the previous seasons weren't even part of the production for season 8.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A minor one in ''WesternAnimation/{{Wakfu}}'': in Season One, [[SealedEvilInACan Rubilax]] and his fellow Shushu Shadowfang are described by the former as a "[[ElementalPower four-element and five-element Shushu]]. In season 2, she's instead described as a "Level-5 Shushu" without explanation.

to:

* A minor one in ''WesternAnimation/{{Wakfu}}'': in Season One, [[SealedEvilInACan Rubilax]] and his fellow Shushu Shadowfang are described by the former as a "[[ElementalPower "[[ElementalPowers four-element and five-element Shushu]].Shushu]]". In season 2, she's instead described as a "Level-5 Shushu" without explanation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** (6) And most importantly, the creator of the show, Iginio Straffi, actually had the story all planned out and was going to end the series after season 3 (with the first movie being the "grand finale" of the series), but since Winx became such a cash cow franchise, it got renewed for a fourth season and continued after that, so it ''cannot'' be said that this was planned from the start.




to:

*** (6) And most importantly, the creator of the show, Iginio Straffi, [[https://www.corriereadriatico.it/SPETTACOLI/rainbow_avventure_winx_iginio_straffi_villa_musone_marche_rai2/notizie/421983.shtml actually had the story all planned out and was going to end the series after season 3 (with the first movie being the "grand finale" of the series), series)]], but since Winx became such a cash cow franchise, it got renewed for a fourth season and continued after that, so it ''cannot'' be said that this was planned from the start.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** (1) Her actions (knowingly endangering the lives of/attempting to murder people for ''fun'', which started as early as ''episode 3''; stating she ''liked'' being evil and was actually annoyed at being referred to as anything less; assaulting ''children'', Flora's sister Miele and Mitzi's sister Macy, who happen to be little sisters like [[CousinOliver Sapphire]]) and motivations (wanting to become powerful for the repeated explicit purpose of ''conquering'' the Magic Dimension) ever since the beginning of season 1 ''do not'' align whatsoever with what season 8 is trying to establish her goals to be.
*** (2) Icy claims to not be powerful enough to undo the spell the shaman witch placed on Sapphire... ''except'' she has been shown to be skilled at transmutation, having transformed Mirta into a pumpkin in season 1 and (along with Darcy and Stormy) turned Griffin into a crow in season 6. There's also the fact that Icy, Darcy, and Stormy have been receiving powerful upgrades throughout the series and in seasons 6 and 7, have been shown to be stronger than the ''Winx'' on several occasions, becoming their strongest in season 7 when they achieved ''Shape-Shifting'' Witch forms derived from the power of magical animals, so the excuse of Icy not being powerful enough falls flat.
*** (3) Near the end of season 8, Icy decides to help the Winx because she "can't stand to see another world crumble" even though when she revealed Bloom's heritage to her in season 1, she smugly told her how the Ancestral Witches, ''her'' ancestors, destroyed her home world Domino and throughout the series had been (along with Darcy and Stormy) allying with villains whose plans involved ''destroying'' worlds (Ex. Tritannus) with no objections and was attracted to Valtor, someone who destroyed Domino alongside her ancestors, because of how ''evil'' he was.
*** (4) And most importantly, the creator of the show, Iginio Straffi, actually had the story all planned out and was going to end the series after season 3 (with the first movie being the "grand finale" of the series), but since Winx became such a cash cow franchise, it got renewed for a fourth season and continued after that, so it ''cannot'' be said that this was planned from the start.




to:

*** (1) In the season 8 flashback, Icy is shown to be a young adult, possibly 16 at the youngest, but in season 1, she was an 18-year-old senior witch. Bloom was 1-year-old when Domino fell and it only faded from the minds of the people because it had been destroyed for 15 years by the time the show starts. For Icy's retconned backstory to be true, it would have to mean that Dyamond was conquered not too long before the start of the show, so there's no way people could forget about Dyamond it if was conquered recently and there's no way Icy wouldn't have been recognized as the Princess of Dyamond. If not as herself, then people would mistake her for Sapphire. There's also the fact that Faragonda and Griselda remembered the Earth Fairies when most other people didn't and they disappeared at around the same time Domino fell, so they would definitely be aware of some planet called Dyamond if some witch took it over recently.
*** (2) In the same flashback in season 8, Icy is shown to have had natural curly blonde hair before changing it to straight and silver-blue, but in the season 3 episode ''The Black Willow's Tears'' when Icy, Darcy, and Stormy are regressed to children, Icy is shown with natural straight silver-blue hair.[[note]] It is of note that some fans use this episode as so-called "proof" that the Trix aren't actual sisters (the dubbing errors of the 4kids and Rai dubs of the episode where Stormy comments that they're friends don't help. It's worth pointing out that the 4kids dub was infamous for creating numerous [[DubInducedPlotHole Dub-Induced Plot Holes]] and the Rai dub was not without its own errors, such as claiming Tecna was a cyborg. The Nick dub, however, corrects this by having Stormy accurately say they're sisters) due to the fact that after the Trix are turned back into children, Icy comments on Darcy's hair, "Your hair used to look like that?", leaving some fans wondering why she wouldn't remember how she used to look if they were really sisters. However, the reason is simply that they forgot how they used to look when they were kids, which isn’t all that shocking since there are a lot of people who forget how they and their siblings/relatives used to look when they were younger, especially if they look ''vastly'' different than how they used to when they were young[[/note]].
*** (3)
Her actions (knowingly endangering the lives of/attempting to murder people for ''fun'', which started as early as ''episode 3''; stating she ''liked'' being evil and was actually annoyed at being referred to as anything less; assaulting ''children'', Flora's sister Miele and Mitzi's sister Macy, who happen to be little sisters like [[CousinOliver Sapphire]]) and motivations (wanting to become powerful for the repeated explicit purpose of ''conquering'' the Magic Dimension) ever since the beginning of season 1 ''do not'' align whatsoever with what season 8 is trying to establish her goals to be.
*** (2) (4) Icy claims to not be powerful enough to undo the spell the shaman witch placed on Sapphire... ''except'' she has been shown to be skilled at transmutation, having transformed Mirta into a pumpkin in season 1 and (along with Darcy and Stormy) turned Griffin into a crow in season 6. There's also the fact that Icy, Darcy, and Stormy have been receiving powerful upgrades throughout the series and in seasons 6 and 7, have been shown to be stronger than the ''Winx'' on several occasions, becoming their strongest in season 7 when they achieved ''Shape-Shifting'' Witch forms derived from the power of magical animals, so the excuse of Icy not being powerful enough falls flat.
*** (3) (5) Near the end of season 8, Icy decides to help the Winx because she "can't stand to see another world crumble" even though when she revealed Bloom's heritage to her in season 1, she smugly told her how the Ancestral Witches, ''her'' ancestors, destroyed her home world Domino and throughout the series had been (along with Darcy and Stormy) allying with villains whose plans involved ''destroying'' worlds (Ex. Tritannus) with no objections and was attracted to Valtor, someone who destroyed Domino alongside her ancestors, because of how ''evil'' he was.
*** (4) (6) And most importantly, the creator of the show, Iginio Straffi, actually had the story all planned out and was going to end the series after season 3 (with the first movie being the "grand finale" of the series), but since Winx became such a cash cow franchise, it got renewed for a fourth season and continued after that, so it ''cannot'' be said that this was planned from the start.



Top