Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TintinExplorersOnTheMoon

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: When the Thompsons emerge from the hold, Wolff is the only one drawn with an exclamation mark, because he thought it was Jorgen coming up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SeenItAllSuicide: Discussed when Calculus mentions that after seeing Earth from more than 10,000 kilometers, you can die happy. Tintin counters with it being fine, but he himself would rather wait a few years.

Added: 275

Changed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Murder" implies that Jorgen killed someone else than himself, which isn't the case here.


* SingleMaltVision: Thinking everyone is doomed, Captain Haddock decides he may as well get drunk. He then insults Thompson and Thomson, causing them to angrily demand an apology, to which Haddock complies because he feels intimidated from seeing the two men as four persons.



* [[ThrownOutTheAirlock Threw Himself Out The Airlock]]: Wolff decides to leave the rocket and let himself wander in space until his death as a HeroicSacrifice to ensure the others can get to Earth alive.

to:

* [[ThrownOutTheAirlock Threw Himself Out The Airlock]]: ThrownOutTheAirlock: Wolff decides to leave the rocket and let himself wander in space until his death as a HeroicSacrifice to ensure the others can get to Earth alive.



* VillainHasAPoint: While Jorgen's [[MurderIsTheBestSolution actions]] are firmly villainous, his reasoning proves entirely correct; with three more passengers than planned, plus the various delays encountered, the characters are running out of oxygen, and it's pretty clear that despite Tintin's best efforts, they cannot hope to survive in the current situation. In the end, only after Jorgen's AccidentalMurder and Wolff's HeroicSacrifice do they manage to survive the trip, and even then they only barely make it.

to:

* VillainHasAPoint: While Jorgen's [[MurderIsTheBestSolution actions]] are firmly villainous, his reasoning proves entirely correct; with three more passengers than planned, plus the various delays encountered, the characters are running out of oxygen, and it's pretty clear that despite Tintin's best efforts, they cannot hope to survive in the current situation. In the end, only after Jorgen's AccidentalMurder accidental suicide and Wolff's HeroicSacrifice do they manage to survive the trip, and even then they only barely make it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removal by of potholes to What An Idiot


* SneakyDeparture: Frank Wolff has to go about his HeroicSacrifice in a stealthy manner, lest the others wake up and try to dissuade him. Of course, Thomson wakes up and, [[WhatAnIdiot showing the presence of mind expected of them,]] permits him to go down into the hold anyway.

to:

* SneakyDeparture: Frank Wolff has to go about his HeroicSacrifice in a stealthy manner, lest the others wake up and try to dissuade him. Of course, Thomson wakes up and, [[WhatAnIdiot showing the presence of mind expected of them,]] them, permits him to go down into the hold anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CuttingTheKnot: Being back on Earth, MissionControl Mr. Baxter mostly has to use rather creative methods to help the protagonists in space. But when the rocket finally lands and the crew can't open the doors because they've already passed out from lack of oxygen, Baxter just elects to hack the rocket open with electric saws to get them out in time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AccidentalAstronaut: Shortly after Calculus's rocket has taken off, the protagonists realize that [[ThoseTwoGuys the Thompsons]], who were supposed to be on guard before the launch, are still inside because they mistook the time of the takeoff. The two end up being obliged to participate in the exploration of the Moon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PratFall: Haddock [[VisualPun when he says his final line]], so he's lying on the ground.

to:

* PratFall: ThePratfall: Haddock [[VisualPun when he says his final line]], so he's lying on the ground.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Thompson:''' Definitely not! Because there are two sets of tracks, [[TooDumbToLive and we're alone!]]

to:

-->'''Thompson:''' Definitely not! Because there are two sets of tracks, [[TooDumbToLive and we're alone!]]alone!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%RepairDontRespond** More an inversion in this case: a direct ascent (SSTO = single stage to orbit) and landing requires either much more efficient rockets or MUCH bigger spaceships: both are as much out of reach now as they were then. In fact, a manned landing on the moon is impossible today or in the foreseeable future - but wasn't 50 years ago...

to:

%%RepairDontRespond** %%Administrivia/RepairDontRespond** More an inversion in this case: a direct ascent (SSTO = single stage to orbit) and landing requires either much more efficient rockets or MUCH bigger spaceships: both are as much out of reach now as they were then. In fact, a manned landing on the moon is impossible today or in the foreseeable future - but wasn't 50 years ago...

Added: 393

Removed: 308

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExactTimeToFailure: Averted. Although estimations are made about how long it will take for the oxygen supply to deplete, it is made clear that it is simply that: Estimations. Even when the characters use spare oxygen tanks to improve their odds, they're not sure how much difference they've actually made.



* ExactTimeToFailure: Averted. Although estimations are made about how long it will take for the oxygen supply to deplete, it is made clear that it is simply that: Estimations. Even when the characters use spare oxygen tanks to improve their odds, they're not sure how much difference they've actually made.


Added DiffLines:

* WelcomeBackTraitor: Tintin accepts Wolff back into the crew after Jorgen is killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VillainHasAPoint: While Jorgen's [[MurderIsTheBestSolution actions]] are firmly villainous, his reasoning proves entirely correct; with three more passengers than planned, plus the various delays encountered, the characters are running out of oxygen, and it's pretty clear that despite Tintin's best effort, they cannot hope to survive in the current situation. In the end, only after Jorgen's AccidentalMurder and Wolff's HeroicSacrifice do they manage to survive the trip, and even then they only barely make it.

to:

* VillainHasAPoint: While Jorgen's [[MurderIsTheBestSolution actions]] are firmly villainous, his reasoning proves entirely correct; with three more passengers than planned, plus the various delays encountered, the characters are running out of oxygen, and it's pretty clear that despite Tintin's best effort, efforts, they cannot hope to survive in the current situation. In the end, only after Jorgen's AccidentalMurder and Wolff's HeroicSacrifice do they manage to survive the trip, and even then they only barely make it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedemptionEqualsDeath: Wolff throws himself out the airlock so that the rest of the explorers will have enough oxygen to get back to Earth. Considering that they just ''barely'' make it back alive (and still need supplemental oxygen administered), his sacrifice probably did make the difference.

to:

* RedemptionEqualsDeath: Wolff throws himself out the airlock so that the rest of the explorers will have enough oxygen to get back to Earth. Considering that they just ''barely'' make it back alive (and still need supplemental oxygen administered), his sacrifice probably did make the a difference.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlmostOutOfOxygen: The biggest problem during the book, beginning with the discovery that the Thompsons accidentally found themselves on board during liftoff... and even that doesn't cover the extent of the stowaways on board. It's solved partly by the decision to stay on the Moon for a shorter time, and partly by the HeroicSacrifice of TheMole.

to:

* AlmostOutOfOxygen: The biggest problem during the book, beginning with the discovery that the Thompsons accidentally found themselves on board during liftoff... and even that doesn't cover the extent of the stowaways on board. It's solved partly by the decision to stay on leave the Moon for a shorter time, early, and partly by the HeroicSacrifice of TheMole.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlmostOutOfOxygen: The biggest problem during the book, beginning with the discovery that the Thompsons accidentally found themselves on board during liftoff... and even that doesn't cover the extent of the stowaways on board. It's solved in part by the decision to stay on the Moon for a shorter time, and partly by the HeroicSacrifice of TheMole.

to:

* AlmostOutOfOxygen: The biggest problem during the book, beginning with the discovery that the Thompsons accidentally found themselves on board during liftoff... and even that doesn't cover the extent of the stowaways on board. It's solved in part partly by the decision to stay on the Moon for a shorter time, and partly by the HeroicSacrifice of TheMole.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 237

Removed: 319

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoNonsenseNemesis: Unlike other villains in the series, Jorgen puts ''all'' the recurring cast into life-threatening danger, not just Tintin; and is played completely seriously, not facing any of the series' usual {{slapstick}} comedy.



* VileVillainSaccharineShow: Downplayed example, since the comic isn't especially lighthearted, but Jorgen does stand out among other villains. He puts ''all'' the recurring cast into life-threatening danger, not just Tintin; and is played completely seriously, not facing any of the series' usual {{slapstick}} comedy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ExactTimeToFailure: Averted. Although estimations are made about how long it will take for the oxygen supply to deplete, it is made clear that it is simply that: Estimations. Even when the characters use spare oxygen tanks to improve their odds, they're not sure how much difference they've actually made.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheLoad: Thomson and Thompson are easily the most incompetent they've ever been here. Not only do they accidentally stow away on-board the rocket (leading to the oxygen crisis), unwittingly release Jorgen and generally make a nuisance of themselves throughout the storyline, at no point do they ever do anything that even vaguely helps the mission, unless you count Thomson's not stopping Wolff when he sneaks out to eject himself into space (and even then Thomson failed at the job he was actually given).

to:

* TheLoad: Thomson and Thompson are easily the most incompetent they've ever been here. Not only do they accidentally stow away on-board the rocket (leading to the oxygen crisis), unwittingly release Jorgen[[note]]which does admittedly end up resolving the oxygen crisis, as it sparks off a chain of events that leads to the deaths of both Jorgen and Wolff[[/note]] and generally make a nuisance of themselves throughout the storyline, at no point do they ever do anything that even vaguely helps the mission, unless you count Thomson's not stopping Wolff when he sneaks out to eject himself into space (and even then Thomson failed at the job he was actually given).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpaceClothes: Enormous bulky amber-colored spacesuits, representing a very endearingly retro vision of lunar operations (the book was published in 1954, a good fifteen years before Neil Armstrong's historic jaunt). When suited up, the characters look like fat [[StarWars C-3PO units]].

to:

* SpaceClothes: Enormous bulky amber-colored spacesuits, representing a very endearingly retro vision of lunar operations (the book was published in 1954, a good fifteen years before Neil Armstrong's historic jaunt). When suited up, the characters look like fat [[StarWars [[Franchise/StarWars C-3PO units]].

Added: 998

Changed: 1386

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Discovering there were two accidental stowaways (which is by itself a jarring circumstance) would have been enough to abort a real life space mission and force them to return to Earth. In this particular case, with their fictitious spaceship being a nuclear-powered SSTO, the decision would have been even more reasonable given that the logistic expenses of a brief return and a second takeoff would have been minimal, if any. But that, of course, would have removed all the drama from the story.
* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The book portrays the Moon landing as producing exactly the same amount and direction of pressure they all suffered in the takeoff, that is, vertical and downwards. Going without mentioning that an inverse acceleration should intuitively produce pressure in the opposite direction (''upwards''), a free descent gently decelerated by the main engine acting as a retrorocket would generate infinitely less vertical acceleration than a takeoff, unless they wanted to get propelled into space again instead of performing a landing.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: ArtisticLicenseMilitary:
**
Discovering there were two accidental stowaways (which is by itself a jarring circumstance) would have been enough to abort a real life space mission and force them to return to Earth. In this particular case, with their fictitious fictional spaceship being a nuclear-powered SSTO, the decision would have been even more reasonable given that the logistic expenses of a brief return and a second takeoff would have been minimal, if any.minimal. But that, of course, would have removed all the drama from the story.
** The rocket carries a landing vehicle, in this case a presurized tank with its own airlock, but it is such a heavy and cumbersome thing that it doesn't even fit in the rocket and has to be cobbled together from pieces (itself an engineering feat that is left sadly offscreen, with a bit of {{Hammerspace}} thrown in), making it very unlikely that a real life space agency would have wanted to include such thing in their very first trip.
* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The book portrays In the story, the Moon landing as producing produces exactly the same amount and direction of pressure they all suffered in the takeoff, that is, vertical and downwards. Going without mentioning that an inverse acceleration should intuitively produce pressure in the opposite direction (''upwards''), (vertical and ''upwards''), a free descent gently decelerated by the main engine acting as a retrorocket retro-rocket would generate infinitely less vertical acceleration than a takeoff, unless they wanted to get propelled into space again instead of performing a landing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The rocket lands on autopilot in Syldavia, with the entire crew unconscious from lack of oxygen. Despite a brief scare with Haddock, everyone has survived. Calculus makes a grand speech claiming that man will return to the moon prompting an enraged Haddock to vow never to enter a rocket again, claiming that "Man's proper place...is on dear old Earth!"

to:

The rocket lands on autopilot in Syldavia, with the entire crew unconscious from lack of oxygen. Despite a brief scare with Haddock, everyone has survived. Calculus makes a grand speech claiming that man will return to the moon -- prompting an enraged Haddock to vow never to enter a rocket again, claiming that "Man's proper place...is on dear old Earth!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The rocket lands on autopilot in Syldavia, with the entire crew unconscious from lack of oxygen. Despite a brief scare with Haddock, everyone has survived. Calculus makes a grand speech claiming that man will return to the moon prompting an enraged Haddock to vow never to enter a rocket again, claiming that "Man's proper place...is in dear old Earth!"

to:

The rocket lands on autopilot in Syldavia, with the entire crew unconscious from lack of oxygen. Despite a brief scare with Haddock, everyone has survived. Calculus makes a grand speech claiming that man will return to the moon prompting an enraged Haddock to vow never to enter a rocket again, claiming that "Man's proper place...is in on dear old Earth!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ImmediateSequel: The only Tintin book whose beginning seamlessly dovetails in from the previous one.

Added: 176

Changed: 24

Removed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** SpaceSuitsAreSCUBAGear: Notably averted, however, despite how classically retro the spacesuit design looks otherwise. There are no vulnerable oxygen tubes on the exterior of the suit.



* SpaceIsNoisy: Deliberately refuted in the original comic. The animated version by Belvision embraced this trope, however: while the meteor was silent in the original comic, in the cartoon there is a meteor shower that makes a lot of noise!

to:

* SpaceIsNoisy: Deliberately refuted in the original comic. The animated version by Belvision embraced this trope, however: while the meteor was silent in the original comic, in the cartoon there is a meteor shower that makes a lot of noise!noise.
* SpaceSuitsAreSCUBAGear: Notably averted, despite how classically retro the spacesuit design looks otherwise. There are no vulnerable oxygen tubes on the exterior of the suit.



** More an inversion in this case: a direct ascent (SSTO = single stage to orbit) and landing requires either much more efficient rockets or MUCH bigger spaceships: both are as much out of reach now as they were then. In fact, a manned landing on the moon is impossible today or in the foreseeable future - but wasn't 50 years ago...

to:

** %%RepairDontRespond** More an inversion in this case: a direct ascent (SSTO = single stage to orbit) and landing requires either much more efficient rockets or MUCH bigger spaceships: both are as much out of reach now as they were then. In fact, a manned landing on the moon is impossible today or in the foreseeable future - but wasn't 50 years ago...



* TragicVillain: Frank Wolff was the first character in the Tintin universe who wasn't particularly good, but not particulary bad either. He sides with Colonel Jorgen to sabotage the flight, but is more or less manipulated by him. When Jorgen wants to shoot everybody Wolff protests and interferes, killing Jorgen accidentally with his own gun. Wolff is forgiven by Tintin, but later feels remorse and decides to commit suicide by throwing himself out of the rocket so that the others can safely travel home again.

to:

* TragicVillain: Frank Wolff was the first character in the Tintin universe who wasn't particularly good, but not particulary particularly bad either. He sides with Colonel Jorgen to sabotage the flight, but is more or less manipulated by him. When Jorgen wants to shoot everybody Wolff protests and interferes, killing Jorgen accidentally with his own gun. Wolff is forgiven by Tintin, but later feels remorse and decides to commit suicide by throwing himself out of the rocket so that the others can safely travel home again.



* VileVillainSaccharineShow: Downplayed example, since the comic isn't especially lighthearted, but Jorgen does stand out among other villains. He puts ''all'' the recurring cast into life-threatening danger, not just Tintin; and is played completely seriously, not facing any of the series' usual {{Slapstick}} comedy.

to:

* VileVillainSaccharineShow: Downplayed example, since the comic isn't especially lighthearted, but Jorgen does stand out among other villains. He puts ''all'' the recurring cast into life-threatening danger, not just Tintin; and is played completely seriously, not facing any of the series' usual {{Slapstick}} {{slapstick}} comedy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StickyShoes: The crew are issued magnetic boots in case the engine (and its' gravity-mimicking acceleration) cuts out. Captain Haddock is still tying his on when they turn it off to decelerate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Calculus:''' Then they're footsteps made by '''two''' of us, nitwit!... I expect you've gone back on your tracks, and those are your footmarks!
-->'''Thomson:''' Great Scotland Yard! Have we been going round in circles, following our own tracks -- as in [[Recap/TintinLandOfBlackGold the desert?]]
-->'''Thompson:''' Definitely not! Because there are two sets of tracks, [[TooDumbToLive and we're alone!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InsaneTrollLogic: The Thom(p)sons are out on a jaunt on the moon, when they spot human tracks. They immediately radio back with the news that there are other people on the moon! When Calculus points out the ''blatantly obvious'' -- that the tracks were made by one of their own crew members -- the Thom(p)sons retort that that's impossible -- because there are TWO sets of tracks!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SneakyDeparture: Frank Wolff has to go about his HeroicSacrifice in a stealthy manner, lest the others wake up and try to dissuade him. Of course, Thomson wakes up and, [[WhatAnIdiot showing the presence of mind expected of the twins,]] permits him to go down into the hold anyway.

to:

* SneakyDeparture: Frank Wolff has to go about his HeroicSacrifice in a stealthy manner, lest the others wake up and try to dissuade him. Of course, Thomson wakes up and, [[WhatAnIdiot showing the presence of mind expected of the twins,]] them,]] permits him to go down into the hold anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DramaticSpaceDrifting: During their spacewalk, Haddock is pulled into the orbit of the asteroid and drifts off. Tintin manages to pull him back aboard with a risky maneuver.



* VileVillainSaccharineShow: Downplayed example, since the comic isn't especially lighthearted, but Jorgen does stand out among other villains. He puts ''all'' the recurring cast into life-threatening danger, not just Tintin; and is played completely seriously, not facing any of the series' usual {{Slapstick}} comedy.

to:

* VileVillainSaccharineShow: Downplayed example, since the comic isn't especially lighthearted, but Jorgen does stand out among other villains. He puts ''all'' the recurring cast into life-threatening danger, not just Tintin; and is played completely seriously, not facing any of the series' usual {{Slapstick}} comedy.comedy.
* YouHadUsWorriedThere: MissionControl is increasingly worried when there is no response from the rocket crew 30 minutes after their moon landing. Cue Tintin hailing that all is good.
----

Top