Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / ThomasAndFriendsS5E5JamesAndTheTroubleWithTrees

Go To

OR

Changed: 449

Removed: 567

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CallBack: Henry tells James the Fat Controller was inspecting for trees too close to the line.
* ContinuityNod: James' remark about how Henry should talk to a tree instead of shunting trucks, since he loves the forest so much, and Henry's rebuttal that the Fat Controller was inspecting the island for trees too close to the line, is a dual reference to both "[[Recap/ThomasAndFriendsS3E9HenrysForest Henry's Forest]]" as well as the fact that Rev. W. Awdry so despised the episode for its lack of realism as well as breaking standard railway code (at one point, Henry stops right on the main line, while the forest is structured dangerously close to the rails).

to:

* CallBack: Henry tells James the Fat Controller was inspecting for trees too close to the line.
* ContinuityNod: James' remark about how Henry should talk to a tree instead of shunting trucks, since he loves the forest so much, and Henry's rebuttal that the Fat Controller was inspecting the island for trees too close to the line, is a dual reference to both "[[Recap/ThomasAndFriendsS3E9HenrysForest Henry's Forest]]" as well as the fact that Rev. W. Awdry so Creator/WilbertAwdry despised the episode for its lack of realism as well as breaking standard railway code (at one point, Henry stops right on the main line, while (the trees in the forest is structured were dangerously close to the rails).railway lines).

Changed: 302

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigDamnHeroes: Thomas.
* BreakTheHaughty: Happens to James with the trees.

to:

* BigDamnHeroes: Thomas.
Thomas enters the scene and pulls James and his trucks away right before the tree falls onto the latter.
* BreakTheHaughty: Happens to James with the trees, the latter having boasted about his new paintwork and teased Henry about trees.



* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: James.

to:

* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: James.James is boastful about his paintwork and gets a laugh over Henry and the trees, but is genuinely thankful when Thomas rescues him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Trucks:''' Your colour’s nice, James! Pity about your face, though!

to:

-->'''Trucks:''' Your colour’s color's nice, James! Pity about your face, though!

Changed: 1

Removed: 436

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''James:''' I'd rather not. You're not a pleasant sight and wouldn't understand the needs of an really important engine.

to:

-->'''James:''' I'd rather not. You're not a pleasant sight and wouldn't understand the needs of an a really important engine.



* TakeThat: Henry's statement that the Fat Controller is having trees that are close to the line removed for fear that they'll end up causing trouble might have been a response to Wilbert Awdry's criticism of the third series episode, [[Recap/ThomasAndFriendsS3E9HenrysForest "Henry's Forest"]]; part of his criticism of the episode was about the trees being too close to the line and thus, be set on fire by sparks from Henry's funnel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The next morning, Henry has an accident with trucks while James is being repainted. James laughs at Henry and suggests he go talk to a tree instead since he loves the forest. Henry tells James that The Fat Controller plans to remove trees that are too close to the line. James scoffs at this, saying that if he encountered a tree, he would simply push it aside. Later that day, James shows off his new coat of paint to Thomas, Percy, and Terence while they're in the forest removing the trees. Despite the others trying to warn him not to take trees lightly, James brushes them off and leaves to collect the express. Unfortunately for James, when he arrives at the station, the Fat Controller re-assigns him to an important goods train. This puts James in a very foul mood.

to:

The next morning, Henry has an accident with trucks while James is being repainted. James laughs at Henry and suggests he go talk to a tree instead since he loves the forest. Henry tells James that The the Fat Controller plans to remove trees that are too close to the line. James scoffs at this, saying that if he encountered a tree, he would simply push it aside. Later that day, James shows off his new coat of paint to Thomas, Percy, and Terence while they're in the forest removing the trees. Despite the others trying to warn him not to take trees lightly, James brushes them off and leaves to collect the express. Unfortunately for James, when he arrives at the station, the Fat Controller re-assigns him to an important goods train. This puts James in a very foul mood.



* CallBack: Henry tells James Sir Topham Hatt was inspecting for trees too close to the line.
* ContinuityNod: James' remark about how Henry should talk to a tree instead of shunting freight cars, since he loves the forest so much, and Henry's rebuttal that Sir Topham Hatt was inspecting the island for trees too close to the line, is a dual reference to both "[[Recap/ThomasAndFriendsS3E9HenrysForest Henry's Forest]]" as well as the fact that Rev. W. Awdry so despised the episode for its lack of realism as well as breaking standard railway code (At one point, Henry stops right on the main line, while the forest is structured dangerously close to the rails).

to:

* CallBack: Henry tells James Sir Topham Hatt the Fat Controller was inspecting for trees too close to the line.
* ContinuityNod: James' remark about how Henry should talk to a tree instead of shunting freight cars, trucks, since he loves the forest so much, and Henry's rebuttal that Sir Topham Hatt the Fat Controller was inspecting the island for trees too close to the line, is a dual reference to both "[[Recap/ThomasAndFriendsS3E9HenrysForest Henry's Forest]]" as well as the fact that Rev. W. Awdry so despised the episode for its lack of realism as well as breaking standard railway code (At (at one point, Henry stops right on the main line, while the forest is structured dangerously close to the rails).



-->'''Trucks:''' Your color's nice, James! Pity about your face, though!

to:

-->'''Trucks:''' Your color's colour’s nice, James! Pity about your face, though!



-->'''James''': I'd rather not. You're not a pleasant sight and wouldn't understand the needs of an really important engine.

to:

-->'''James''': -->'''James:''' I'd rather not. You're not a pleasant sight and wouldn't understand the needs of an really important engine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Narcissist: James's new coat of paint made him too proud for his own good.

to:

* Narcissist: {{Narcissist}}: James's new coat of paint made him too proud for his own good.

Added: 123

Changed: 269

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jerkass}}: James. [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold He soon was repentant in the end.]]
* KickTheSonOfABitch: The trucks insulting James at the yards.
* NoSympathy: James show no remorse over Thomas unable to get a washdown because to his vanity, which makes him furious.

to:

* {{Jerkass}}: James. [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold He soon was repentant in the end.]]
* KickTheSonOfABitch:
The troublesome trucks insulting James at the yards.
to James.
* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: James.
* Narcissist: James's new coat of paint made him too proud for his own good.
* NoSympathy: James show no remorse over Thomas unable to get a washdown because to on account of his vanity, which makes him furious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Thomas had been working at the coaling plant all day. He is upset when he is unable to get a wash-down due to a broken hosepipe and dreads that the other engines will tease him. Arriving to the sheds, Thomas finds James boasting to the other engines. James believes he deserves a new coat of paint, and The Fat Controller informs him that he is the pride of the line. Henry rebuffs James' statement by saying they are all pride of the line. Percy whispers to Thomas that James has been boasting about getting a new coat of paint all day. Thomas complains about this and says he deserves a new coat, leading James to tell him that he doesn't understand the needs of an important engine. Thomas was furious.

Next morning, Henry has an accident while shunting trucks and James laughs at him, saying he should go talk to trees instead since he loves the forest. Henry tells James that The Fat Controller plans to remove trees that are too close to the line. James says that if he encountered a tree, he would push is aside. Later, James meets Thomas, Percy, and Terence while in the forest removing the trees. James thinks that trees are silly, but the others warn him, but the red engine just ignores them.

James then arrives at the station to collect the express. Unfortunately for him, The Fat Controller re-assigns him to an important goods train. This puts James in a very foul mood. As James arrives at the yards, the trucks tease James about his sulky face. James then sets off. They soon reach a hill and begin to climb. Up ahead, an old tree by the side of the line was being blown by the wind. The rain had softened the soil and the tree slowly moved onto the tracks right in front of James. He tries to move back, but the train is too heavy. Luckily, Thomas came to James' aid. At first, James was afraid Thomas would tease him, but he did not since there was no time for teasing. Thomas helped James move out of the way before the tree fell over.

Back at the yard, James thanked Thomas. Just then, Edward came in and says that the Fat Controller commended the two engines for their bravery. As a reward, Thomas will get a re-paint, while James will pull the express.

to:

Thomas had has been working at the coaling plant all day. day and is covered in coal dust. He is upset when he is unable to get a wash-down washdown due to a broken hosepipe and dreads worries that the other engines will tease him. Arriving to However, when he arrives at the sheds, Thomas finds James boasting to all the other engines. James believes he deserves a new coat of paint, and The Fat Controller informs him that he is the pride of the line. Henry rebuffs James' statement by saying they engines are all pride of the line.focused on James. Percy whispers to Thomas that James has been boasting about getting a new coat of paint all day. Thomas complains about this and says he he's the one who deserves a new coat, leading James to tell him that he doesn't understand the needs of an important engine. Thomas was furious.

Next
engine.

The next
morning, Henry has an accident while shunting with trucks and while James is being repainted. James laughs at him, saying Henry and suggests he should go talk to trees a tree instead since he loves the forest. Henry tells James that The Fat Controller plans to remove trees that are too close to the line. James says scoffs at this, saying that if he encountered a tree, he would simply push is it aside. Later, Later that day, James meets shows off his new coat of paint to Thomas, Percy, and Terence while they're in the forest removing the trees. James thinks that trees are silly, but Despite the others trying to warn him, but the red engine just ignores them.

him not to take trees lightly, James then arrives at the station brushes them off and leaves to collect the express. Unfortunately for him, The James, when he arrives at the station, the Fat Controller re-assigns him to an important goods train. This puts James in a very foul mood. As mood.

By the time
James arrives at the yards, the a powerful thunderstorm has set in over Sodor. The trucks tease James about the contrast between his gleaming paint and sulky face. face, but James then ignores them and sets off. They soon reach However, trouble lies partway down a hill and begin to climb. Up ahead, hill: an old tree on an embankment by the side of the line was being blown by line. With the wind. The rain had soil softened by the soil rain and the strong winds, the tree slowly moved onto slides down until it is standing in the tracks middle of James' track. His driver sees the tree and hits the brakes just in time, and James comes to a stop right in front of James. the tree. He tries to move back, but between the train is too heavy. heavy train, wet rails, and inclined tracks, he doesn't get anywhere. Luckily, Thomas came James soon hears Thomas' whistle as the small tank engine comes to James' aid. help. At first, James was is afraid Thomas would will tease him, him for getting stopped by a tree, but he did not since there was does nothing of the sort. Thomas wastes no time for teasing. in coupling to the back of James' trucks. Together, Thomas helped and James move out of force the way trucks back up the hill just before the wind blows the tree fell over.

over onto where James was just moments before.

Back at the yard, James thanked Thomas. thanks Thomas for the aid. Just then, Edward came comes in and says that the Fat Controller commended the two engines for their bravery. As a reward, Thomas will get a re-paint, while James will get to pull the express.
express the next day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityNod: James' remark about how Henry should talk to a tree instead of shunting freight cars, since he loves the forest so much, and Henry's rebuttal that Sir Topham Hatt was inspecting the island for trees too close to the line, is a dual reference to both "[[Recap/ThomasTheTankEngineS3E9HenrysForest Henry's Forest]]" as well as the fact that Rev. W. Awdry so despised the episode for its lack of realism as well as breaking standard railway code (At one point, Henry stops right on the main line, while the forest is structured dangerously close to the rails).

to:

* ContinuityNod: James' remark about how Henry should talk to a tree instead of shunting freight cars, since he loves the forest so much, and Henry's rebuttal that Sir Topham Hatt was inspecting the island for trees too close to the line, is a dual reference to both "[[Recap/ThomasTheTankEngineS3E9HenrysForest "[[Recap/ThomasAndFriendsS3E9HenrysForest Henry's Forest]]" as well as the fact that Rev. W. Awdry so despised the episode for its lack of realism as well as breaking standard railway code (At one point, Henry stops right on the main line, while the forest is structured dangerously close to the rails).



* TakeThat: Henry's statement that the Fat Controller is having trees that are close to the line removed for fear that they'll end up causing trouble might have been a response to Wilbert Awdry's criticism of the third series episode, [[Recap/ThomasTheTankEngineS3E9HenrysForest "Henry's Forest"]]; part of his criticism of the episode was about the trees being too close to the line and thus, be set on fire by sparks from Henry's funnel.

to:

* TakeThat: Henry's statement that the Fat Controller is having trees that are close to the line removed for fear that they'll end up causing trouble might have been a response to Wilbert Awdry's criticism of the third series episode, [[Recap/ThomasTheTankEngineS3E9HenrysForest [[Recap/ThomasAndFriendsS3E9HenrysForest "Henry's Forest"]]; part of his criticism of the episode was about the trees being too close to the line and thus, be set on fire by sparks from Henry's funnel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''Air date''': September 13th, 1998

[[quoteright:320:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/320px-jamesandthetroublewithtrees13_1537.png]]

Thomas had been working at the coaling plant all day. He is upset when he is unable to get a wash-down due to a broken hosepipe and dreads that the other engines will tease him. Arriving to the sheds, Thomas finds James boasting to the other engines. James believes he deserves a new coat of paint, and The Fat Controller informs him that he is the pride of the line. Henry rebuffs James' statement by saying they are all pride of the line. Percy whispers to Thomas that James has been boasting about getting a new coat of paint all day. Thomas complains about this and says he deserves a new coat, leading James to tell him that he doesn't understand the needs of an important engine. Thomas was furious.

Next morning, Henry has an accident while shunting trucks and James laughs at him, saying he should go talk to trees instead since he loves the forest. Henry tells James that The Fat Controller plans to remove trees that are too close to the line. James says that if he encountered a tree, he would push is aside. Later, James meets Thomas, Percy, and Terence while in the forest removing the trees. James thinks that trees are silly, but the others warn him, but the red engine just ignores them.

James then arrives at the station to collect the express. Unfortunately for him, The Fat Controller re-assigns him to an important goods train. This puts James in a very foul mood. As James arrives at the yards, the trucks tease James about his sulky face. James then sets off. They soon reach a hill and begin to climb. Up ahead, an old tree by the side of the line was being blown by the wind. The rain had softened the soil and the tree slowly moved onto the tracks right in front of James. He tries to move back, but the train is too heavy. Luckily, Thomas came to James' aid. At first, James was afraid Thomas would tease him, but he did not since there was no time for teasing. Thomas helped James move out of the way before the tree fell over.

Back at the yard, James thanked Thomas. Just then, Edward came in and says that the Fat Controller commended the two engines for their bravery. As a reward, Thomas will get a re-paint, while James will pull the express.

!!This episode contains examples of:
* BigDamnHeroes: Thomas.
* BreakTheHaughty: Happens to James with the trees.
* CallBack: Henry tells James Sir Topham Hatt was inspecting for trees too close to the line.
* ContinuityNod: James' remark about how Henry should talk to a tree instead of shunting freight cars, since he loves the forest so much, and Henry's rebuttal that Sir Topham Hatt was inspecting the island for trees too close to the line, is a dual reference to both "[[Recap/ThomasTheTankEngineS3E9HenrysForest Henry's Forest]]" as well as the fact that Rev. W. Awdry so despised the episode for its lack of realism as well as breaking standard railway code (At one point, Henry stops right on the main line, while the forest is structured dangerously close to the rails).
* DeadpanSnarker: The trucks get a zing at James:
-->'''Trucks:''' Your color's nice, James! Pity about your face, though!
* EarnYourHappyEnding: Thomas and James reconciled and then receive their respective rewards.
* HumblePie: This causes James to thank Thomas for rescuing him.
* {{Jerkass}}: James. [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold He soon was repentant in the end.]]
* KickTheSonOfABitch: The trucks insulting James at the yards.
* NoSympathy: James show no remorse over Thomas unable to get a washdown because to his vanity, which makes him furious.
* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: After Thomas complains about how dirty he is, an [[NoSympathy unsympathetic]] and [[SmallNameBigEgo haughty]] James gives him this, infuriating him.
-->'''James''': I'd rather not. You're not a pleasant sight and wouldn't understand the needs of an really important engine.
* SmallNameBigEgo: James brags about how he's getting a new coat of paint and the Fat Controller calls him the pride of the line, though Henry clarifies to him that all of the engines are the pride of the line.
* TakeThat: Henry's statement that the Fat Controller is having trees that are close to the line removed for fear that they'll end up causing trouble might have been a response to Wilbert Awdry's criticism of the third series episode, [[Recap/ThomasTheTankEngineS3E9HenrysForest "Henry's Forest"]]; part of his criticism of the episode was about the trees being too close to the line and thus, be set on fire by sparks from Henry's funnel.
* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: The episode is inspired by an event that occurred during David Maidment's time as stationmaster of Aberbeeg (1964-1965): During a storm, a tree slid down a bank and stood upright in the middle of the track between Ebbw Vale and Aberbeeg.
----

Top