Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TheSopranosS4E3Christopher

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[{{UsefulNotes/Italy}} Useful Notes on Italy]]: Furio provides some exposition to his Italian American friends. North Italians look down their noses at Southern Italians, and have for centuries. And the way he describes it will sound eerily similar to how race relations in America could be described. Furio himself, and a great many Italians from the southern part of the land of the sun, therefore do not necessarily view ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' as a hero worthy of acclaim or adoration, as he was from Genoa.

to:

* [[{{UsefulNotes/Italy}} Useful Notes on Italy]]: Furio provides some exposition to his Italian American friends. North Italians look down their noses at Southern Italians, and have for centuries. And the way he describes it will sound [[{{DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything}} eerily similar similar]] to how race relations in America could be described. Furio himself, and a great many Italians from the southern part of the land of the sun, therefore do not necessarily view ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' as a hero worthy of acclaim or adoration, as he was from Genoa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MistreatmentInducedBetrayal: Paulie, motivated by simmering resentments against Tony, tells Johnny Sack about Ralph's [[{{FatComicRelief}} fat joke]] at Ginny's expense, as well as Tony's score off the [[{{RealEstateScam}} Freelingheysen Avenue]] property. The former almost starts an EnemyCivilWar, while the latter costs Tony money.

to:

* MistreatmentInducedBetrayal: Paulie, motivated by simmering resentments against Tony, tells Johnny Sack about Ralph's [[{{FatComicRelief}} fat joke]] at Ginny's expense, as well as Tony's score off the [[{{RealEstateScam}} Freelingheysen Avenue]] property. The former almost starts an kicks off a brief EnemyCivilWar, while the latter costs Tony money.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Janice is seeing a [[{{TheShrink}} Shrink]] of her own. The session itself, right down to detailed references to her [[{{AllGirlsWantBadBoys}} questionable taste in men]], and an OedipusComplex towards either Johnny Boy or Tony himself, is a dead ringer for several sessions Tony has had with Dr. Melfi.

to:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Janice is seeing a [[{{TheShrink}} Shrink]] of her own. The first session itself, right down to detailed references to her [[{{AllGirlsWantBadBoys}} questionable taste in men]], and an OedipusComplex towards either Johnny Boy or Tony himself, is a dead ringer for several sessions Tony has had with Dr. Melfi.

Added: 978

Changed: 507

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad: Played with and a matter of perspective. Tony and the rest of the crew regard the Native American protests against Columbus Day as an example of the trope. These protests are actually a [[{{TruthInTelevision}} pretty frequent thing]]. And it's not without reason that the protesters make an association between Columbus Day and historical atrocities inflicted on their ancestors as well as current conditions. [[{{CorruptPolitician}} Assemblyman Zellman]] won't touch it precisely out of fear of a political correctness blowback, "sensitive stuff".

to:

* PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad: Played with and a matter of perspective.
**
Tony and the rest of the crew regard the Native American protests against Columbus Day as an example of the trope. These protests are actually a [[{{TruthInTelevision}} pretty frequent thing]]. And it's not without reason that the protesters make an association between Columbus Day and historical atrocities inflicted on their ancestors as well as current conditions. [[{{CorruptPolitician}} Assemblyman Zellman]] won't touch it precisely out of fear of a political correctness blowback, "sensitive stuff".stuff".
** Silvio also regards the names of sports teams like the Cleveland Indians and the Atlanta Braves becoming a politically charged issue as an example of the trope. But again, a lot of Native Americans do feel sincerely offended by the names in question.


Added DiffLines:

* SelfMadeMan: Tony invokes this trope, along with some praise for ''Creator/GaryCooper'', to try and talk Silvio into easing down a notch or two from his [[{{PatrioticFervor}} ethnic pride as an Italian American]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouOweMe: Chief Doug Smith plays Tony like a fiddle: he completely fails to do anything about the demonstration, but the fact that he "tried" now [[HonorAmongThieves obligates]] Tony to do what he can to get Frankie Valli to sing at the casino.

to:

* YouOweMe: Chief Doug Smith plays Tony like a fiddle: he completely fails to do anything about the demonstration, but the fact that he "tried" now [[HonorAmongThieves obligates]] Tony to do what he can to get [[{{Music/FrankieValliAndTheFourSeasons}} Frankie Valli Valli]] to sing at the casino.NativeAmericanCasino.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CelebrityParadox: Doug Smith's price for 'trying' to deal with Del Redclay is that Tony has to get [[{{Music/FrankieValliAndTheFourSeasons}} Frankie Valli]] to sing at Smith's NativeAmericanCasino. Want to guess who plays Rusty Millio starting season 5?


Added DiffLines:

* MurderIsTheBestSolution: Silvio openly expresses the thought, after other tries have gone nowhere, that they should whack Del Redclay. Tony shuts it down hard.


Added DiffLines:

* PunishmentDetail: Tony over the course of the episode becomes irate at Silvio for tying the crime family to the Columbus Day parade in ways that were questionable for the family business. So Silvio is assigned the task of contacting [[{{Music/FrankieValliAndTheFourSeasons}} Frankie Valli]] to play at Chief Smith's NativeAmericanCasino.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CountryMatters: Ralph calls Janice one after getting pushed down the stairs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NativeAmericanCasino: Tony and the guys spend a day in one, with the entry free of charge. Of course, the latter bit is part of a [[{{YouOweMe}} ploy]] by Doug Smith.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SingleWomanWantsGoodMan: Janice moves from having a [[{{AllGirlsWantBadBoys}} thing for bad boys like Richie and Ralph]] to becoming fascinated with Bobby after seeing his genuine love for Karen and his devastation at losing her.

to:

* SingleWomanWantsGoodMan: SingleWomanSeeksGoodMan: Janice moves from having a [[{{AllGirlsWantBadBoys}} thing for bad boys like Richie and Ralph]] to becoming fascinated with Bobby after seeing his genuine love for Karen and his devastation at losing her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SingleWomanWantsGoodMan: Janice moves from having a [[{{AllGirlsWantBadBoys}} thing for bad boys like Richie and Ralph]] to becoming fascinated with Bobby after seeing his genuine love for Karen and his devastation at losing her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KnowWhenToFoldEm: Tony decides to pull the plug on the whole Columbus Day thing after Del Redclay essentially causes a ThreatBackfire. Silvio would like to expose Redclay as [[{{SexualExtortion}} sleeping with his own graduate student]]. But Tony remains firm that it's time to put the whole thing to bed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThreatBackfire: Del Redclay ultimately blows off the threat to expose Iron Eyes Cody, likening it to Italian Americans finding out that ''Creator/JamesCaan'' isn't Italian. It wouldn't exactly be an earth shattering scandal if the public at large knew.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FeminineWomenCanCook: Subverted hard in the case of Janice. Other members of the extended family bring Bobby plenty of home-cooked meals grounded in Italian American cuisine to console him over his loss of Karen. Janice brings over some ''UsefulNotes/KentuckyFriedChicken'', which in her case amounts to a gender-flipped version of DadsCantCook. Also doubles as {{Foreshadowing}}, as her road to winning over Bobby doesn't end up a particularly smooth one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeritageDisconnect: Doug Smith's Native American heritage is questionable to begin with, but it becomes obvious that [[{{ItsAllAboutMe}} he's only in it]] for the perks that being chief and head of a casino provides him.

to:

* HeritageDisconnect: Doug Smith's Native American heritage is questionable to begin with, but it becomes obvious that [[{{ItsAllAboutMe}} he's only in it]] for the perks that being chief and head of a casino provides him. Tony even shows a definite HyperAwareness by lampshading that Smith staking a claim to Mohonk ancestry apparently coincides with the passing of legislation authorizing the casino.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeritageDisconnect: Doug Smiths' Native American heritage is questionable to begin with, but it becomes obvious that [[{{ItsAllAboutMe}} he's only in it]] for the perks that being chief and head of a casino provides him.

to:

* HeritageDisconnect: Doug Smiths' Smith's Native American heritage is questionable to begin with, but it becomes obvious that [[{{ItsAllAboutMe}} he's only in it]] for the perks that being chief and head of a casino provides him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeritageDisconnect: Doug Smiths' Native American heritage is questionable to begin with, but it becomes obvious that [[{{ItsAllAboutMe}} he's only in it]] for the perks that being chief and head of a casino provides him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KnowsAGuyWhoKnowsAGuy: Tony connects with his friend Hesh, who points in the direction of his Jewish friend named Marty, who in turn introduces Tony to Chief Doug Smith.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PatrioticFervor: A major and recurring theme in this episode, with plenty of other examples besides the obvious one that pits the main characters and the Native American protesters against each other. Heck, even Hesh, who previously told [[{{SelfDeprecation}} Self Deprecating jokes]] that played into GreedyJew stereotypes in order to score points with his Mafia buddies, has a moment of Jewish pride that results in a severed friendship.

to:

* PatrioticFervor: A major and recurring theme in this episode, with plenty of other examples besides the obvious one that pits the main characters and the Native American protesters against each other. Heck, even Hesh, who previously told [[{{SelfDeprecation}} Self Deprecating jokes]] that played into GreedyJew stereotypes in order to score points with his Mafia buddies, has a moment of Jewish pride that results in a [[{{WeUsedToBeFriends}} severed friendship.friendship]].

Added: 526

Removed: 526

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[{{UsefulNotes/Italy}} Useful Notes on Italy]]: Furio provides some exposition to his Italian American friends. North Italians look down their noses at Southern Italians, and have for centuries. And the way he describes it will sound eerily similar to how race relations in America could be described. Furio himself, and a great many Italians from the southern part of the land of the sun, therefore do not necessarily view ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' as a hero worthy of acclaim or adoration, as he was from Genoa.


Added DiffLines:

* [[{{UsefulNotes/Italy}} Useful Notes on Italy]]: Furio provides some exposition to his Italian American friends. North Italians look down their noses at Southern Italians, and have for centuries. And the way he describes it will sound eerily similar to how race relations in America could be described. Furio himself, and a great many Italians from the southern part of the land of the sun, therefore do not necessarily view ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' as a hero worthy of acclaim or adoration, as he was from Genoa.

Added: 43

Removed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TraumaCongaLine: More than one character.



* TraumaCongaLine: More than one character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoSympathy: How Ralph treats Rosalie while she's reeling from a TraumaCongaLine. It precipitates their breakup.


Added DiffLines:

* TraumaCongaLine: More than one character.
** Rosalie has lost Jackie Sr., Richie, Jackie Jr. and now Karen. [[{{FeelingTheirAge}} Feeling older]] doesn't help either.
** Bobby, in addition to being a regular ButtMonkey for the other mobsters, has lost his father and now Karen too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GutFeeling: Both Silvio and Tony have a sense that somebody is saying too much to the Lupertazzi family in New York. They're entirely correct of course.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SuppressedRage: Johnny Sack is in this mode towards Ralph over the fat joke at Ginny's expense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ADayInTheLimelight: Silvio gets sort of one in this episode, as his intense pride in being Italian American combined with the Columbus day protests drives him into actions and decisions [[{{OOCIsSeriousBusiness}} that are quite out of character for him]].

to:

* ADayInTheLimelight: Silvio gets sort of one in this episode, as his intense pride in being Italian American combined with the Columbus day Day protests drives him into actions and decisions [[{{OOCIsSeriousBusiness}} that are quite out of character for him]].



* PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad: Played with and a matter of perspective. Tony and the rest of the crew regard the Native American protests against Columbus day as an example of the trope. These protests are actually a [[{{TruthInTelevision}} pretty frequent thing]]. And it's not without reason that the protesters make an association between Columbus day and historical atrocities inflicted on their ancestors as well as current conditions. [[{{CorruptPolitician}} Assemblyman Zellman]] won't touch it precisely out of fear of a political correctness blowback, "sensitive stuff".

to:

* PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad: Played with and a matter of perspective. Tony and the rest of the crew regard the Native American protests against Columbus day Day as an example of the trope. These protests are actually a [[{{TruthInTelevision}} pretty frequent thing]]. And it's not without reason that the protesters make an association between Columbus day Day and historical atrocities inflicted on their ancestors as well as current conditions. [[{{CorruptPolitician}} Assemblyman Zellman]] won't touch it precisely out of fear of a political correctness blowback, "sensitive stuff".



** Imagine any negative stereotypes you can possibly think of with respect to Native Americans, lazy, ungrateful for handouts, [[{{AddledAddict}} Addled Addicts]], etc. Silvio and the others bring up all of them to express their resentments towards the Columbus day protesters. Even [[{{NiceGuy}} Bobby]] of all people gets into it.

to:

** Imagine any negative stereotypes you can possibly think of with respect to Native Americans, lazy, ungrateful for handouts, [[{{AddledAddict}} Addled Addicts]], etc. Silvio and the others bring up all of them to express their resentments towards the Columbus day Day protesters. Even [[{{NiceGuy}} Bobby]] of all people gets into it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even Tony takes up the argument over the SuppressedHistory of ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' with A.J. In the course of the argument Tony ascribes to the viewpoint that the Indigenous peoples Columbus did enslave were just a bunch of [[{{TheSavageIndian}} primitive savages]] not worth making a fuss over, therefore there was no injustice that could have been committed, therefore Columbus couldn't possibly anything less than a Hero. It verges on InsaneTrollLogic by today's standards.

to:

** Even Tony takes up the argument over the SuppressedHistory of ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' with A.J. In the course of the argument Tony ascribes to the viewpoint that the Indigenous peoples Columbus did enslave were just a bunch of [[{{TheSavageIndian}} primitive savages]] not worth making a fuss over, therefore there was no injustice that could have been committed, therefore Columbus couldn't possibly be anything less than a Hero. It verges on InsaneTrollLogic by today's standards.

Added: 826

Changed: 329

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[{{PoliticallyIncorrectVillain}} Politically Incorrect Villains]]: Imagine any negative stereotypes you can possibly think of with respect to Native Americans, lazy, ungrateful for handouts, [[{{AddledAddict}} Addled Addicts]], etc. Silvio and the others bring up all of them to express their resentments towards the Columbus day protesters. Even [[{{NiceGuy}} Bobby]] of all people gets into it.

to:

* [[{{PoliticallyIncorrectVillain}} Politically Incorrect Villains]]: Villains]]:
**
Imagine any negative stereotypes you can possibly think of with respect to Native Americans, lazy, ungrateful for handouts, [[{{AddledAddict}} Addled Addicts]], etc. Silvio and the others bring up all of them to express their resentments towards the Columbus day protesters. Even [[{{NiceGuy}} Bobby]] of all people gets into it.it.
** Even Tony takes up the argument over the SuppressedHistory of ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' with A.J. In the course of the argument Tony ascribes to the viewpoint that the Indigenous peoples Columbus did enslave were just a bunch of [[{{TheSavageIndian}} primitive savages]] not worth making a fuss over, therefore there was no injustice that could have been committed, therefore Columbus couldn't possibly anything less than a Hero. It verges on InsaneTrollLogic by today's standards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[{{UsefulNotes/Italy}} Useful Notes on Italy]]: Furio provides some exposition to his Italian American friends. North Italians look down their noses at Southern Italians, and have for centuries. And the way he describes will sound eerily similar to how race relations in America could be described. Furio himself, and a great many Italians from the southern part of the land of the sun, therefore do not necessarily view ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' as a hero worthy of acclaim or adoration, as he was from Genoa.

to:

* [[{{UsefulNotes/Italy}} Useful Notes on Italy]]: Furio provides some exposition to his Italian American friends. North Italians look down their noses at Southern Italians, and have for centuries. And the way he describes it will sound eerily similar to how race relations in America could be described. Furio himself, and a great many Italians from the southern part of the land of the sun, therefore do not necessarily view ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' as a hero worthy of acclaim or adoration, as he was from Genoa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuppressedHistory: ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' is the subject of the History when it comes to this episode's use of the trope. It's a given that the Italian characters have a more flattering view of Columbus (possibly excepting Furio), while the Native American protesters have a more negative view of the man. Whether he was the great hero and mover and shaker the main characters view him as, or whether he was the racist murderer and rampager and slave trader the protesters cast him as, is not a question that the show even tries to provide any answers for. It's enough to bring out the different viewpoints by way of gradual {{Exposition}} in order to set up the story arc for this episode.

to:

* SuppressedHistory: ''UsefulNotes/ChristopherColumbus'' is the subject of the History when it comes to this episode's use of the trope. It's a given that the Italian characters have a more flattering view of Columbus (possibly excepting Furio), Furio and A.J.), while the Native American protesters have a more negative view of the man. Whether he was the great hero and mover and shaker the main characters view him as, or whether he was the racist murderer and rampager and slave trader the protesters cast him as, is not a question that the show even tries to provide any answers for. It's enough to bring out the different viewpoints by way of gradual {{Exposition}} in order to set up the story arc for this episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadBoss: Tony gives Patsy one for publicly getting himself arrested during the EscalatingBrawl with the Native American protesters.

to:

* BadBoss: Tony gives Patsy one a DopeSlap for publicly getting himself arrested during the EscalatingBrawl with the Native American protesters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** How Ralph attempts to get leverage over Del Redclay. It's based on a threat to reveal that Iron Eyes Cody was actually Italian American without a drop of Native American blood. Although Redclay [[{{ScrewYourUltimaturm}} blows off]] Ralph, he afterwards admits to being worried about the PR implications.

to:

** How Ralph attempts to get leverage over Del Redclay. It's based on a threat to reveal that Iron Eyes Cody was actually Italian American without a drop of Native American blood. Although Redclay [[{{ScrewYourUltimaturm}} [[{{ScrewYourUltimatum}} blows off]] Ralph, he afterwards admits to being worried about the PR implications.

Top