Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TheMandalorianS3E3Chapter19TheConvert

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: The Mind Flayer is a clear allegory for electroshock therapy before the invention of the much safer ECT. The fact that Pershing recognizes it as a torture device may be a reference to how electroshock therapy was originally used to torture patients into "sanity", and later (mostly from the 1940's to 80's) used as a method of punishment for difficult patients. Even in it's safer modern version, memory loss is a common side effect.

to:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: The Mind Flayer is a clear allegory for electroshock therapy before the invention of the much safer ECT. The fact that Pershing recognizes it as a torture device may be a reference to how electroshock therapy was originally used to torture patients into "sanity", and later (mostly from the 1940's to 80's) used as a method of punishment for difficult patients. Even in it's its safer modern version, memory loss is a common side effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmorPiercingQuestion: The Armorer asks Bo-Katan if she had ever removed her helmet since emerging from the Living Waters of Mandalore. It is there that Bo realizes that she ''[[OOCIsSeriousBusiness never]]'' did, even before Din advised her to keep her helmet on when meeting the Children of the Watch. After being unwittingly accepted into the clan, she looks at the skull of the Mythosaur and wonders if her encounter with the beast was a sign for her.

to:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: The Armorer asks Bo-Katan if she had ever removed her helmet since emerging from the Living Waters of Mandalore. It is there that Bo realizes that she ''[[OOCIsSeriousBusiness never]]'' did, even before Din advised her to keep her helmet on when meeting the Children of the Watch. After being unwittingly accepted into the clan, she looks at the skull of the beskar Mythosaur skull ornament in the Armorer's hall and wonders if her encounter with the legendary beast was a sign for her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AndNowForSomeoneCompletelyDifferent: The episode starts with Din and Bo-Katan escaping a flight of Imperial TIE Interceptors, and then after they make a HyperspeedEscape it jumps to Coruscant to follow Dr. Pershing for the rest of the episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FormerRegimePersonnel: Like Operation Paperclip, the Amnesty Program reintegrates former Imperials into New Republic government jobs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouAreNumberSix: All Imperials in the amnesty program are referred to be letter-number designations. They even use these designations among each other instead of names.

to:

* YouAreNumberSix: All Imperials in the amnesty program are referred to be letter-number designations. They even use these designations among each other instead of names. [[MirroringFactions This is not dissimilar to how the Empire treats stormtroopers.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bo-Katan notes that the TIE squadron is too big to be sent by an Imperial warlord, suggesting that an old enemy is behind the attack.

to:

** Bo-Katan notes that the TIE squadron is too big to be sent by an Imperial warlord, suggesting that an old enemy whoever mustered it is behind the attack.much more organized and has reason to want Bo-Katan dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"No spoiler on a recap page" also means don't put spoiler for incoming episodes.


** Kane's motivation: is she recovering the research for Gideon (or somebody else) to continue the strand-cast project? Is she ensuring the erasure of anything Pershing knows that could cause Gideon bother? Does she set up and betray Pershing to increase her own standing in the New Republic? A simple case of {{revenge}}? All of the above? It's eventually revealed that Gideon had Pershing incapacitated to deny Brendol Hux Pershing's research so he can work on his own cloning project.

to:

** Kane's motivation: is she recovering the research for Gideon (or somebody else) to continue the strand-cast project? Is she ensuring the erasure of anything Pershing knows that could cause Gideon bother? Does she set up and betray Pershing to increase her own standing in the New Republic? A simple case of {{revenge}}? All of the above? It's eventually revealed that Gideon had Pershing incapacitated to deny Brendol Hux Pershing's research so he can work on his own cloning project. above?



** Rumors that Moff Gideon managed to escape custody or that he was hooked up to a Mind Flayer are mentioned by a couple of the former Imperials at the Amnesty Center, but whether there's any truth to them is never made clear. It's revealed the former was true due to Phase 4 Dark Troopers rescuing him from New Republic custody, while the latter was false.

to:

** Rumors that Moff Gideon managed to escape custody or that he was hooked up to a Mind Flayer are mentioned by a couple of the former Imperials at the Amnesty Center, but whether there's any truth to them is never made clear. It's revealed the former was true due to Phase 4 Dark Troopers rescuing him from New Republic custody, while the latter was false.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlmightyJanitor: Despite talking about using his credentials to help the New Republic, Pershing is shoved into an undignified desk job where he can make little use of these skills, which have been outlawed by the New Republic.

to:

* AlmightyJanitor: Despite talking about using his credentials to help the New Republic, Pershing is shoved into an undignified desk job where he can make little use of these skills, which have been outlawed by the New Republic.Republic, due to Clone Troopers helping the Empire come into being.



** Kane's motivation: is she recovering the research for Gideon (or somebody else) to continue the strand-cast project? Is she ensuring the erasure of anything Pershing knows that could cause Gideon bother? Does she set up and betray Pershing to increase her own standing in the New Republic? A simple case of {{revenge}}? All of the above?

to:

** Kane's motivation: is she recovering the research for Gideon (or somebody else) to continue the strand-cast project? Is she ensuring the erasure of anything Pershing knows that could cause Gideon bother? Does she set up and betray Pershing to increase her own standing in the New Republic? A simple case of {{revenge}}? All of the above?above? It's eventually revealed that Gideon had Pershing incapacitated to deny Brendol Hux Pershing's research so he can work on his own cloning project.



** Rumors that Moff Gideon managed to escape custody or that he was hooked up to a Mind Flayer are mentioned by a couple of the former Imperials at the Amnesty Center, but whether there's any truth to them is never made clear.

to:

** Rumors that Moff Gideon managed to escape custody or that he was hooked up to a Mind Flayer are mentioned by a couple of the former Imperials at the Amnesty Center, but whether there's any truth to them is never made clear. It's revealed the former was true due to Phase 4 Dark Troopers rescuing him from New Republic custody, while the latter was false.



** Bo-Katan notes that the TIE squadron is too big to be sent by an Imperial warlord, suggesting that someone far worse and higher ranking is behind the attack.

to:

** Bo-Katan notes that the TIE squadron is too big to be sent by an Imperial warlord, suggesting that someone far worse and higher ranking an old enemy is behind the attack.

Added: 1900

Removed: 1891

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foil is a character trope.


* {{Foil}}: The New Republic is set up as a direct contrast to the Children of the Watch.
** The New Republic government on the surface appears very inviting. It's bright, colorful, and people have plenty to see and do to occupy their time. Even the former Imperials seem to enjoy it. But beneath the surface there are smug elites who don't really see any difference between current life and the time under Imperial rule, casual dismissal of outer rim territories, and a desire to bury their head in the sand in regards to forgetting the past. This leads to a dark turn when it's revealed they are brainwashing former Imperials into compliance and stripping them of their freedom of choice.
** The Children of the Watch on the other hand seem far less inviting. They are dogmatic in their beliefs, and are secluded in harsh living conditions in the outer territories. But beneath the surface, the Watch is fairly reasonable. When Din proves he has been redeemed, he is welcomed back with open arms. When Bo-Katan reveals she too went through the same process, she is also invited into the clan under the condition she never remove her helmet. The important difference is that the Children of the Watch emphasis the freedom of ''choice,'' as it is made very clear Bo can come and go as she wishes, which is a far cry from the conditions the former Imperials face in the New Republic.
** The small things show the biggest differences. Former Imperials are stripped of their names and jobs, living in an isolated barracks and working demeaning make-work jobs. Pershing is drawn in by Kane thanks to a gift of ''travel biscuits'', an admittedly crappy but common treat in the empire (think twinkies). By contrast, when Bo-Katan is welcomed into the covert, multiple Children come to her to place a hand on her shoulder in welcome, probably the greatest physical intimacy available to them in armor.


Added DiffLines:

* MirroringFactions: The New Republic is set up as a direct contrast to the Children of the Watch.
** The New Republic government on the surface appears very inviting. It's bright, colorful, and people have plenty to see and do to occupy their time. Even the former Imperials seem to enjoy it. But beneath the surface there are smug elites who don't really see any difference between current life and the time under Imperial rule, casual dismissal of outer rim territories, and a desire to bury their head in the sand in regards to forgetting the past. This leads to a dark turn when it's revealed they are brainwashing former Imperials into compliance and stripping them of their freedom of choice.
** The Children of the Watch on the other hand seem far less inviting. They are dogmatic in their beliefs, and are secluded in harsh living conditions in the outer territories. But beneath the surface, the Watch is fairly reasonable. When Din proves he has been redeemed, he is welcomed back with open arms. When Bo-Katan reveals she too went through the same process, she is also invited into the clan under the condition she never remove her helmet. The important difference is that the Children of the Watch emphasis the freedom of ''choice,'' as it is made very clear Bo can come and go as she wishes, which is a far cry from the conditions the former Imperials face in the New Republic.
** The small things show the biggest differences. Former Imperials are stripped of their names and jobs, living in an isolated barracks and working demeaning make-work jobs. Pershing is drawn in by Kane thanks to a gift of ''travel biscuits'', an admittedly crappy but common treat in the empire (think twinkies). By contrast, when Bo-Katan is welcomed into the covert, multiple Children come to her to place a hand on her shoulder in welcome, probably the greatest physical intimacy available to them in armor.

Changed: 435

Removed: 436

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything:
** The Mind Flayer is a clear allegory for electroshock therapy before the invention of the much safer ECT. The fact that Pershing recognizes it as a torture device may be a reference to how electroshock therapy was originally used to torture patients into "sanity", and later (mostly from the 1940's to 80's) used as a method of punishment for difficult patients. Even in it's safer modern version, memory loss is a common side effect.

to:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything:
**
DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: The Mind Flayer is a clear allegory for electroshock therapy before the invention of the much safer ECT. The fact that Pershing recognizes it as a torture device may be a reference to how electroshock therapy was originally used to torture patients into "sanity", and later (mostly from the 1940's to 80's) used as a method of punishment for difficult patients. Even in it's safer modern version, memory loss is a common side effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DodgeByBraking: To get rid of the last of the TIE interceptors chasing her, Bo-Katan does a hard brake by using the mobile wings of her ''Gauntlet'' starfighter, thus turning around fully before gunning down the TIE. This makes her ship stall and freefall for a short while, but she recovers control before it hits the sea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding new information.

Added DiffLines:

*ForbiddenFruit: The yellow travel biscuits are used as a metaphor for the seductive sway that the Empire still holds over Pershing, despite his best intentions. Ella Kane uses them as a means to gain Pershing’s trust. After that, Pershing is shown eating a travel biscuit whenever he’s considering restarting his research. Ella Kane is also shown eating the travel biscuits when she is working on Moff Gideon’s behalf.


Added DiffLines:

Added: 130

Changed: 18

Removed: 130

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Children of the Watch on the other hand seem far less inviting. They are dogmatic in their beliefs, and are secluded in harsh living conditions in the outer territories. But beneath the surface, the Watch is fairly reasonable. When Din proves he has been redeemed, he is welcomed back with open arms. When Bo Katan reveals she too went through the same process, she is also invited into the clan under the condition she never remove her helmet. The important difference is that the Children of the Watch emphasis the freedom of ''choice,'' as it is made very clear Bo can come and go as she wishes, which is a far cry from the conditions the former Imperials face in the New Republic.

to:

** The Children of the Watch on the other hand seem far less inviting. They are dogmatic in their beliefs, and are secluded in harsh living conditions in the outer territories. But beneath the surface, the Watch is fairly reasonable. When Din proves he has been redeemed, he is welcomed back with open arms. When Bo Katan Bo-Katan reveals she too went through the same process, she is also invited into the clan under the condition she never remove her helmet. The important difference is that the Children of the Watch emphasis the freedom of ''choice,'' as it is made very clear Bo can come and go as she wishes, which is a far cry from the conditions the former Imperials face in the New Republic.



* LEGOGenetics: In his speech, Dr. Pershing's research into cloning is described as such: figuring out how to splice genes from different organisms together in order to combine their strengths.

to:

* LEGOGenetics: LegoGenetics: In his speech, Dr. Pershing's research into cloning is described as such: figuring out how to splice genes from different organisms together in order to combine their strengths.



** When Pershing potentially returning to the field of cloning is discussed, a sinister low chorus is heard vocalizing. This calls back to not only ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'' (which the motif was made for during the opera scene) and ''Film/TheForceAwakens'' (which repurposed the motif for Snoke), but also [[Recap/TheMandalorianS2E4Chapter12TheSiege "Chapter 12: The Siege"]] (which played the motif when the Mandalorian and his allies looked at a tank of clone experiment).

to:

** When Pershing potentially returning to the field of cloning is discussed, a sinister low chorus is heard vocalizing. This calls back to not only ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith'' (which the motif was made for during the opera scene) and ''Film/TheForceAwakens'' (which repurposed the motif for Snoke), but also [[Recap/TheMandalorianS2E4Chapter12TheSiege "Chapter "[[Recap/TheMandalorianS2E4Chapter12TheSiege Chapter 12: The Siege"]] Siege]]" (which played the motif when the Mandalorian and his allies looked at a tank of clone experiment).



** Despite the fact that even the technicians operating it acknowledge that the only difference between a Mind Flayer and a 602 Mitigator is the power setting, the fact that it ''still has'' a brain-melting power setting with no failsafe to prevent it from being dialed up to the max is an issue. And since they leave Pershing strapped to it completely alone after starting it up, with no one around to notice or intervene if something goes wrong with the procedure, Kane gets the chance to dial it up just like that.

to:

** Despite the fact that even the technicians operating it acknowledge that the only difference between a Mind Flayer and a 602 Mitigator is the power setting, the fact that it ''still has'' a brain-melting power setting with no failsafe to prevent it from being dialed up to the max is an issue. And since they leave Pershing strapped to it completely alone after starting it up, with no one no-one around to notice or intervene if something goes wrong with the procedure, Kane gets the chance to dial it up just like that.



* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Bo-Katan's encounter with the Mythosaur -- a creature she once dismissed as mere religious superstition -- has shaken her to the point that she subconsciously ''never'' takes off her helmet in the entire episode after [[SymbolicBaptism emerging from the Living Waters of Mandalore]]. She herself doesn't seem to fully realize it until the Armorer [[ArmorPiercingQuestion directly asks her if she has]]. Basically it was the InvertedTrope of CrisisOfFaith--a very secular Mandalorian ''finding'' some faith.

to:

* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Bo-Katan's encounter with the Mythosaur -- a creature she once dismissed as mere religious superstition -- has shaken her to the point that she subconsciously ''never'' takes off her helmet in the entire episode after [[SymbolicBaptism emerging from the Living Waters of Mandalore]]. She herself doesn't seem to fully realize it until the Armorer [[ArmorPiercingQuestion directly asks her if she has]]. Basically it was the InvertedTrope of CrisisOfFaith--a CrisisOfFaith -- a very secular Mandalorian ''finding'' some faith.



* SignificantNameShift: After their bonding experience in the mines, and the second teamwork display of shooting down half a dozen TIE Interceptors together, Din calls Bo-Katan "Bo."

to:

* SignificantNameShift: After their bonding experience in the mines, and the second teamwork display of shooting down half a dozen TIE Interceptors together, Din calls Bo-Katan "Bo.""Bo".



* ThreePointLanding: Averted: When Din lands after jumping out of Bo-Katan's ship, he sprawls forward, nearly sliding on his face.


Added DiffLines:

* ThreePointLanding: Averted: When Din lands after jumping out of Bo-Katan's ship, he sprawls forward, nearly sliding on his face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The small things show the biggest differences. Former Imperials are stripped of their names and jobs, living in an isolated barracks and working demeaning make-work jobs. Pershing is drawn in by Kane thanks to a gift of ''travel biscuits'', an admittedly crappy but common treat in the empire (think twinkies). By contrast, when Bo-Katan is welcomed into the covert, multiple Children come to her to place a hand on her shoulder in welcome, probably the greatest physical intimacy available to them in armor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SignificantNameShift: After their bonding experience in the mines, and the second teamwork display of shooting down half a dozen TIE Interceptors together, Din calls Bo-Katan "Bo."
-->'''Din:''' Bo, we've got company. Bo, listen to me. You have to get out of there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That trope is much more specific than that example implies. Even if you let it count for non-Jesus messiahs, it doesn't apply here.


* SecondComing: Bo-Katan and Din are welcomed back into the Watch as full members, with Bo even allowed to leave at any time if she wishes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Thoughtcrime}}: Though both Pershing and Kane are caught red-handed during their robbery, only Pershing is arrested, suggesting that the entire ordeal was an entrapment meant to test if he had truly broken from his old ways as an Imperial scientist. Essentially, he is really arrested for his lingering interest in his Imperial research, and is subsequently reprogrammed with an invasive mind control machine for it.

Top