Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekVoyagerS4E23One

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a possible explanation to the "Infinite Supplies" quandry

Added DiffLines:

** Although it's not mentioned, one possible explanation is that they ended up recycling the crew's furniture, uniforms and equipment to make the necessary stasis pods, since those items wouldn't be needed during the trip. Although such a feat wouldn't consume any extra matter (since it was all likely replicated originally), the task would probably end up consuming a fair amount of energy in the process -- and then doubly so after they exited the nebula. But, considering their only other alternative would be an extra year added onto their voyage, this course of action was probably the 'better' of the two outcomes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Although given the width of the nebula they were presumably traveling at warp speed so shutting down propulsion would have collapsed the warp field and required them to drift out of the nebula at sub-light speeds which would have taken a lot longer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotBall: In the teaser, Janeway orders Voyager to enter an unknown nebula without a comprehensive scan for harmful effects like radiation beforehand. Ensign Kim detects radiation as they enter but the ship is already being irradiated, causing the bridge crew and many crew members to start becoming incapacitated. Lt. Tuvok has to limp to the navigation console to save the day from the potentially fatal error.

to:

* IdiotBall: In the teaser, Janeway orders Voyager to enter an unknown nebula without a comprehensive scan for harmful effects like radiation beforehand. Ensign Kim detects radiation as they enter but the ship is already being irradiated, causing the bridge crew and many crew members to start becoming incapacitated. Lt. Cmdr. Tuvok has to limp to the navigation console to save the day from the potentially fatal error.

Changed: 198

Removed: 205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwoDSpace: It would take a year to go around the nebula and a month to go through, but based on the graphic shown, this would only be true if the year-long route had them fly to the far edge of nebula. Simply going up and over seems like it would at best add an additional month to their journey -- two at most -- without having to risk the ridiculously deadly radiation.
** That said, the nebula may be larger all around than it appears to be.

to:

* TwoDSpace: It would take a year to go around the nebula and a month to go through, but based on the graphic shown, scan shown in Astrometrics, this would only be true if the year-long route had them fly to the far edge of nebula. Simply going up and over seems like it would at best add an additional month to their journey -- two at most -- without having to risk the ridiculously deadly radiation.
** That said, the nebula may be larger all around than it appears to be.
radiation.



** Additionally, there's no friction in space. If ''Voyager'' was at the edge of the nebula there would have been no need for Seven to take extreme measures to keep propulsion online. As long as the ship had enough head of steam, it could literally have coasted through the last few thousand kilometers.
*** Potentially justified if assuming that something in the nebula exerted some form of resistance to ''Voyager'' passing through it.

to:

** Additionally, there's no friction in space. If ''Voyager'' was at the edge of the nebula there would have been no need for Seven to take extreme measures to keep propulsion online. As long as the ship had enough head of steam, it could literally have coasted through the last few thousand kilometers.
*** Potentially justified if assuming that something in the
kilometers. The nebula exerted would either have to be dense enough to cause significant friction or exerting some form of resistance other force that would require continued thrust to ''Voyager'' passing through it. overcome.



* {{Claustrophobia}}: Tom Paris doesn't like sleeping in what seems to be like coffins to him. He ends up breaking out of his stasis multiple times.

to:

* {{Claustrophobia}}: Tom Paris doesn't like sleeping in what seems to be like coffins to him. He ends up breaking out of his stasis chamber multiple times.



* InfiniteSupplies: No explanation is given for how they're able to produce stasis pods to hold every member of the crew.

to:

* InfiniteSupplies: No explanation is given for how they're able to produce enough stasis pods to hold every member of the crew.



* ParalyzingFearOfSexuality: There's an air of sexual menace in Trajis' interactions with Seven. While this is played for the usual AloneWithThePsycho tension at the time, TheReveal that Trajis only exists on Seven's head implies this trope.

to:

* ParalyzingFearOfSexuality: There's an air of sexual menace in Trajis' interactions with Seven. While this is played for the usual AloneWithThePsycho tension at the time, TheReveal that Trajis only exists on in Seven's head implies this trope.

Added: 207

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That said, the nebula may be larger all around than it appears to be.



*** Potentially justified if assuming that something in the nebula exerted some form of resistance to ''Voyager'' passing through it.



* BookEnds: Seven practicing her social skills. [[CharacterDevelopment She does much better at the end.]]

to:

* BookEnds: Seven practicing her social skills. [[CharacterDevelopment She does much better at the end.]]end]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
1) Voyager's crew is about 150. 2) Newton. Unless Voyager were to encounter some sort of phenomenon that would directly act on the ship, she would continue to drift at whatever her current velocity.


** The end of the episode suggests that taking life support offline would kill Seven within minutes. The entire crew save Seven are in stasis chambers with independent life support. The air supply of a ship designed to crew 400+ individuals is thus exclusively available to a single person. It would take days if not ''weeks'' for Seven by herself to use up all of the available oxygen already within the ship's living spaces, and likewise it would take a decent amount of time for the temperature on the ship to drop to a point that it would become life threatening, especially since Seven would have ample access to heating elements. For comparison, ''Apollo XIII'' was able to remain livable for days despite almost complete systems failure, and that was three men in a cramped space. The cargo bay alone makes the module's habitable area look like a walk-in closet by comparison, and Seven could just open every door on the ship to expand that.
** Additionally, there's no friction in space. If ''Voyager'' was at the edge of the nebula there would have been no need for Seven to take extreme measures to keep propulsion online. As long as the ship had enough head of steam, it could literally have coasted through the last few thousand kilometers, just not as quickly as it would under power.

to:

** The end of the episode suggests that taking life support offline would kill Seven within minutes. The entire crew save Seven are in stasis chambers with independent life support. The air supply of a ship designed to for a crew 400+ individuals of about 150 is thus exclusively available to a single person. It would take days if not ''weeks'' for Seven by herself to use up all of the available oxygen already within the ship's living spaces, and likewise it would take a decent amount of time for the temperature on the ship to drop to a point that it would become life threatening, especially since Seven would have ample access to heating elements. For comparison, ''Apollo XIII'' was able to remain livable for days despite almost complete systems failure, and that was three men in a cramped space. The cargo bay alone makes the module's habitable area look like a walk-in closet by comparison, and Seven could just open every door on the ship to expand that.
** Additionally, there's no friction in space. If ''Voyager'' was at the edge of the nebula there would have been no need for Seven to take extreme measures to keep propulsion online. As long as the ship had enough head of steam, it could literally have coasted through the last few thousand kilometers, just not as quickly as it would under power.kilometers.

Added: 172

Changed: 130

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlotDrivenBreakdown: The radiation doesn't do wonders for the ship, either, which coupled with the staffing shortage leads to Seven having to make some difficult choices.



* RidiculouslyDifficultRoute: Janeway would rather take the short hazardous route than go around.

to:

* RidiculouslyDifficultRoute: Janeway would rather take the short hazardous route than go around.the long safe one by going around, a difference of 11 months that she simply won't tolerate in light of all the other crap they've survived.

Added: 460

Changed: 971

Removed: 87

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!This episode provides examples of

to:

!!This episode provides examples ofof:
* TwoDSpace: It would take a year to go around the nebula and a month to go through, but based on the graphic shown, this would only be true if the year-long route had them fly to the far edge of nebula. Simply going up and over seems like it would at best add an additional month to their journey -- two at most -- without having to risk the ridiculously deadly radiation.



** The end of the episode suggests that taking life support offline would kill Seven within minutes. However given the size of ''Voyager'', and with the rest of the biological crew tucked away in stasis chambers with independent life support, it could take days if not ''weeks'' for Seven by herself to use up all of the available oxygen already within the ship's living spaces. Even loss of environmental control might take considerable time to become life threatening (consider that ''Apollo XIII'' was able to operate for a considerable amount of time with almost every system shut down, and while the landing module did get ''extremely'' cold[[note]]because vacuum is such a poor conductive, the ships had to be overly engineered for waste heat reduction[[/note]] the crew was nonetheless able to endure remain warm using materials they already had on-hand).
** Additionally, there's no friction in space. If ''Voyager'' was at the edge of the nebula there would have been no need for Seven to take extreme measures to keep propulsion online. As long as the ship had enough head of steam, it could literally have coasted through the last few thousand kilometers.

to:

** The end of the episode suggests that taking life support offline would kill Seven within minutes. However given the size of ''Voyager'', and with the rest of the biological The entire crew tucked away save Seven are in stasis chambers with independent life support, it could support. The air supply of a ship designed to crew 400+ individuals is thus exclusively available to a single person. It would take days if not ''weeks'' for Seven by herself to use up all of the available oxygen already within the ship's living spaces. Even loss of environmental control might spaces, and likewise it would take considerable a decent amount of time for the temperature on the ship to drop to a point that it would become life threatening (consider that threatening, especially since Seven would have ample access to heating elements. For comparison, ''Apollo XIII'' was able to operate remain livable for a considerable amount of time with days despite almost complete systems failure, and that was three men in a cramped space. The cargo bay alone makes the module's habitable area look like a walk-in closet by comparison, and Seven could just open every system shut down, and while door on the landing module did get ''extremely'' cold[[note]]because vacuum is such a poor conductive, the ships had ship to be overly engineered for waste heat reduction[[/note]] the crew was nonetheless able to endure remain warm using materials they already had on-hand).
expand that.
** Additionally, there's no friction in space. If ''Voyager'' was at the edge of the nebula there would have been no need for Seven to take extreme measures to keep propulsion online. As long as the ship had enough head of steam, it could literally have coasted through the last few thousand kilometers.kilometers, just not as quickly as it would under power.



* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Seven gets a collective one from a hallucination of the crew.



* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: Once again, the writers assume that life-support failure means instant suffocation, even though ''Voyager'' has more than enough air for Seven to breathe.

to:

* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: Once again, the writers assume that life-support failure means instant suffocation, even though ''Voyager'' has more than enough air for Seven to breathe.breathe for a long time before the air becomes toxic.



* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Seven gets a collective one from a hallucination of the crew.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics:
** The end of the episode suggests that taking life support offline would kill Seven within minutes. However given the size of ''Voyager'', and with the rest of the biological crew tucked away in stasis chambers with independent life support, it could take days if not ''weeks'' for Seven by herself to use up all of the available oxygen already within the ship's living spaces. Even loss of environmental control might take considerable time to become life threatening (consider that ''Apollo XIII'' was able to operate for a considerable amount of time with almost every system shut down, and while the landing module did get ''extremely'' cold[[note]]because vacuum is such a poor conductive, the ships had to be overly engineered for waste heat reduction[[/note]] the crew was nonetheless able to endure remain warm using materials they already had on-hand).
** Additionally, there's no friction in space. If ''Voyager'' was at the edge of the nebula there would have been no need for Seven to take extreme measures to keep propulsion online. As long as the ship had enough head of steam, it could literally have coasted through the last few thousand kilometers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotBall: In the teaser, Janeway orders Voyager to enter an unknown nebula without a comprehensive scan for harmful effects like radiation beforehand. Ensign Kim detects radiation as they enter but the ship is already being irradiated, causing the bridge crew to start becoming incapacitated. Lt. Tuvok has to limp to the navigation console to save the day from the potentially fatal error.

to:

* IdiotBall: In the teaser, Janeway orders Voyager to enter an unknown nebula without a comprehensive scan for harmful effects like radiation beforehand. Ensign Kim detects radiation as they enter but the ship is already being irradiated, causing the bridge crew and many crew members to start becoming incapacitated. Lt. Tuvok has to limp to the navigation console to save the day from the potentially fatal error.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IdiotBall: In the teaser, Janeway orders Voyager to enter an unknown nebula without a comprehensive scan for harmful effects like radiation beforehand. Ensign Kim detects radiation as they enter but the ship is already being irradiated, causing the bridge crew to start becoming incapacitated. Lt. Tuvok has to limp to the navigation console to save the day from the potentially fatal error.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpaceFriction: Seven has to keep diverting power to the engines to get ''Voyager'' through the nebula.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ParalyzingFearOfSexuality: There's an air of sexual menace in Trajis' interactions with Seven. While this is played for the usual AloneWithThePsycho tension at the time, TheReveal that Trajis only exists on Seven's head implies this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoMadFromTheIsolation: The entire purpose of the episode is to show how Seven of Nine handles herself as the only crew member who wasn't affected by the Nebula, and the burden of getting Voyager through. Her SeparationAnxiety from the Borg only makes things worse as she's now separated from the rest of the crew.

to:

* GoMadFromTheIsolation: The entire purpose of the episode is to show how Seven of Nine handles herself as the only crew member who wasn't affected by the Nebula, and the burden of getting Voyager through. Her SeparationAnxiety separation anxiety from the Borg only makes things worse as she's now separated from the rest of the crew.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HoldYourHippogriffs:
--> '''Doctor:''' Home, sweet [[labelnote:Sickbay]]home[[/labelnote]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ButtMonkey: A subtle example, but the first one to feel ill from the radiation is Harry "ChewToy" Kim. Fortunately, his main character PlotArmor saves him from the same fate as one RedShirt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WorstAid: If anything else had gone wrong, Seven's HeroicSacrifice might have condemned the entire ship. There's a reason the priority of an emergency responder is to protect their own life first, ''then'' the casualty.

to:

* WorstAid: If anything else had gone wrong, Seven's HeroicSacrifice might have condemned the entire ship. There's a reason the priority of an emergency responder is to protect their own life first, ''then'' the casualty.casualty.
* YouAreInCommandNow: Janeway puts the Doctor in command. Seven doesn't seem thrilled at [[WhatMeasureIsANonHuman following a hologram's orders]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RidiculouslyDifficultRoute: Janeway would rather take the short hazardous route than go around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: Once again, the writers assume that life-support failure means instant suffocation, even though ''Voyager'' has more than enough air for Seven to breathe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneEpisodeFear: Tom Paris has claustrophobia because closed spaces remind him of coffins, leading him to get out of his stasis pod. Apparently, he's always been like this and still is, but it has never before or since shown up due to being irrelevant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Seven gets a collective one from a hallucination of the crew.

to:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Seven gets a collective one from a hallucination of the crew.crew.
* WorstAid: If anything else had gone wrong, Seven's HeroicSacrifice might have condemned the entire ship. There's a reason the priority of an emergency responder is to protect their own life first, ''then'' the casualty.

Added: 68

Changed: 393

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Claustrophobia}}: Tom Paris doesn't like sleeping in what seems to be like coffins to him.

to:

* {{Claustrophobia}}: Tom Paris doesn't like sleeping in what seems to be like coffins to him. He ends up breaking out of his stasis multiple times.



-->'''The Doctor:''' Sounds like the computer could use a stimulant.



* GoMadFromTheIsolation
* {{Hallucinations}}: And very real ones at that. So real that Seven of Nine fires a phaser at one.

to:

* GoMadFromTheIsolation
GoMadFromTheIsolation: The entire purpose of the episode is to show how Seven of Nine handles herself as the only crew member who wasn't affected by the Nebula, and the burden of getting Voyager through. Her SeparationAnxiety from the Borg only makes things worse as she's now separated from the rest of the crew.
* {{Hallucinations}}: And very Very real ones at that. So real that Seven of Nine fires a phaser at one.



* NoSocialSkills: As shown in Seven's holodeck training in this field. At the beginning of the episode, Seven asks B'Elanna and Harry personal questions, but doesn't give them time to answer the questions when she immediately fires off the next question. Later on, Seven attends a holodeck party, but can't put aside her work to become friendly with the other crew members when she calls Janeway and Neelix over to help her out with a problem.

to:

* NoSocialSkills: As shown in Seven's holodeck training in this field. At the beginning of the episode, Seven asks B'Elanna and Harry personal questions, but doesn't give them time to answer the questions when she immediately fires off the next question.question relating to completely different topics. Later on, Seven attends a holodeck party, but can't put aside her work to become friendly with the other crew members when she calls Janeway and Neelix over to help her out with a problem.

Removed: 240

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TelevisionIsTryingToKillYou: If anything else had gone wrong, Seven's HeroicSacrifice might have condemned the entire ship. There's a reason the priority of an emergency responder is to protect their own life first, ''then'' the casualty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImaginaryEnemy: Seven creates an imaginary explorer who antagonizes her for most of the second half of the episode, which is later joined by mutilated crew members and Borg hallucinations. She's deluded to the point that they can be handed objects and open doors.

to:

* ImaginaryEnemy: Seven Seven's mind unwittingly creates an imaginary explorer who antagonizes her for most of the second half of the episode, which is later joined by mutilated crew members and Borg hallucinations. She's deluded to the point that they can be handed objects and open doors.

Top