Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* InheritanceMurder: It's implied that Rowena Drake had a hand in her aunt Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe's death -- even if it was adjudged to be of natural causes -- so that said aunt's estate would then pass to her. Rowena also makes sure of it by implicating Olga, her aunt's au pair, in forging the will, and killing her when Olga inevitably confronts her for it.
Changed line(s) 61 (click to see context) from:
* UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom: The Reverend Cottrell's scheme to help young ladies get a job in Woodleigh Manor, as well-meaning as it was, turns tragic when it results in the controversial will of Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe and the disappearance (and later confirmed murder) of her au pair.
to:
* UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom: The Reverend Cottrell's scheme to help young ladies get a job in Woodleigh Manor, Common, as well-meaning as it was, turns tragic when it results in the controversial will of Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe and the disappearance (and later confirmed murder) of her au pair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 15 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationExpansion: The murders of Lesley Ferrier and Leopold Reynolds are elucidated in the adaptation; Garfield stabbed Ferrier and drowned Leopold.
to:
* AdaptationExpansion: AdaptationExpansion:
** The murders of Lesley Ferrier and Leopold Reynolds are elucidated in the adaptation; Garfield stabbed Ferrier and drownedLeopold. Leopold.
** The adaptation confirms that Michael and Rowena were behind Mr Drake's death, with Michael hitting him with his car. Poirot also hints at possible foul play in the death of Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe, though he chooses to ultimately leave that up to the police for investigation.
** The murders of Lesley Ferrier and Leopold Reynolds are elucidated in the adaptation; Garfield stabbed Ferrier and drowned
** The adaptation confirms that Michael and Rowena were behind Mr Drake's death, with Michael hitting him with his car. Poirot also hints at possible foul play in the death of Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe, though he chooses to ultimately leave that up to the police for investigation.
Added DiffLines:
* GreenEyedMonster: Rowena Drake adds envy to her list of sins when she goes after Judith Butler after the latter is revealed to have had a child with Michael Garfield, Judith's daughter Miranda, indicating that it should have been her who was in a relationship with Michael.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AccidentalMisnaming: At one point Olga Seminoff is called Olga Molotov by someone.
Changed line(s) 15 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalBadass: It's Poirot himself who comes to Miranda's rescue, whacking Michael Garfield with his cane. In the original it was two boys named Nicholas Ransom and Desmond Holland who do so at Poirot's behest.
to:
* AdaptationalBadass: It's Poirot himself who comes to Miranda's rescue, whacking Michael Garfield with his cane. In the original it was two boys named Nicholas Ransom and Desmond Holland who do so rescue Miranda at Poirot's behest.
Changed line(s) 26 (click to see context) from:
* CanonForeigner: Rowena Drake was childress in the novel, but has two adult children from her late husband here: Frances and Edmund Drake.
to:
* CanonForeigner: Rowena Drake was childress childless in the novel, but has two adult children from her late husband here: Frances and Edmund Drake.Drake.
* CatapultNightmare: Ariadne has one when she dreams of a figure wearing a jack-o'-lantern scaring her.
* CatapultNightmare: Ariadne has one when she dreams of a figure wearing a jack-o'-lantern scaring her.
* EurekaMoment: When Ariadne wakes up with a start from her nightmare, a glass bottle containing her medication smashes to the ground, causing her to remember a key detail at the party -- that Rowena Drake dropped a flower vase after she saw something or someone in the library.
* {{Foreshadowing}}: After the morning service at church, Michael Garfield comments that he wouldn't mind being buried as compost to feed his plants. Of course, he's then later revealed to have buried someone within his garden.
* HistoryRepeats: Elizabeth Whittaker finds Leopold Reynolds' drowned body, not unlike the time she had found her lover's drowned body.
Changed line(s) 37 (click to see context) from:
* KinslayingIsASpecialKindOfEvil: The murderers are
to:
* ItsAllAboutMe: Michael Garfield is revealed to be ultimately self-absorbed and egotistical after he confirms that he didn't really love Rowena Drake and simply used her for his own ends. Given that he was willing to kill his own daughter right before this...
* KinslayingIsASpecialKindOfEvil: The murderers are shown to be especially vile due to their willingness to murder family members for their aims, including Rowena's aunt and husband as well as Michael's own daughter.
* KinslayingIsASpecialKindOfEvil: The murderers are shown to be especially vile due to their willingness to murder family members for their aims, including Rowena's aunt and husband as well as Michael's own daughter.
Changed line(s) 41 (click to see context) from:
* MeaningfulEcho: At the start of the episode Poirot tells George to change the radio station because he's not a fan of the custom of telling horror stories during Hallowe'en, in lieu of the Belgian custom of lighting candles in respect for the dead. At the end of the episode he tells Ariadne and Judith Butler that they should have been lighting candles for the dead, given the numerous murder victims they had sought justice for.
to:
* MeaningfulEcho: At the start of the episode Poirot tells George to change the radio station because he's not a fan of the custom of telling horror stories during Hallowe'en, in lieu of the Belgian custom of lighting candles in respect for the dead. At the end of the episode he tells Ariadne and Judith Butler that they should have been lighting candles for the dead, given the numerous murder victims they had sought justice for.for, even after Poirot himself had told a macabre story during TheSummation..
Added DiffLines:
* RedHerring: A plot point regarding witchcraft being the cause of Joyce Reynolds' revelation of a murder turns out to be this, after two characters make allusions to the Witchfinder General, witches being tried by drowning, and the allusion to a Biblical verse from Exodus about witches, implying that Mrs Reynolds (who was religiously inclined) could have offed her own stepdaughter due to this. It turns out to be unimportant to the overall case.
Added DiffLines:
* StylisticSuck: Lesley Ferrier made a deliberately mediocre forgery of the codicil of Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe's will to prevent the original version of the will being supplanted by the genuine codicil, allowing Rowena Drake to inherit her aunt's estate.
Added DiffLines:
* UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom: The Reverend Cottrell's scheme to help young ladies get a job in Woodleigh Manor, as well-meaning as it was, turns tragic when it results in the controversial will of Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe and the disappearance (and later confirmed murder) of her au pair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 9 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalDeviation:
to:
* AdaptationalDeviation: AbsenceOfEvidence: Poirot deduces that Judith Butler is a single mother and not a widow because she does ''not'' have pictures of her supposed husband.
* AdaptationDeviation:
* AdaptationDeviation:
Changed line(s) 12 (click to see context) from:
** The murders of Leslie Ferrier and Leopold Reynolds are elucidated in the adaptation; Garfield stabbed Ferrier and drowned Leopold.
to:
** Since Ariadne Oliver is sidelined by the flu in the adaptation, Judith Butler serves as Poirot's primary companion in the episode.
* AdaptationExpansion: The murders ofLeslie Lesley Ferrier and Leopold Reynolds are elucidated in the adaptation; Garfield stabbed Ferrier and drowned Leopold.
* AdaptationExpansion: The murders of
Added DiffLines:
* AdaptationalEarlyAppearance: Poirot first meets Michael Garfield on the train heading to Woodleigh Common rather than at his garden as in the original.
* AdaptationalJobChange: Elizabeth Whittaker was a maths teacher in the novel, but is a church organist in the adaptation.
* AdaptationalNameChange: Janet White from the novel is now Beatrice White in the adaptation.
* AdaptationalRomanceDowngrade: Michael Garfield isn't shown to be interested in Olga in the episode.
* AdaptationalJobChange: Elizabeth Whittaker was a maths teacher in the novel, but is a church organist in the adaptation.
* AdaptationalNameChange: Janet White from the novel is now Beatrice White in the adaptation.
* AdaptationalRomanceDowngrade: Michael Garfield isn't shown to be interested in Olga in the episode.
Added DiffLines:
* CompositeCharacter: Elizabeth Whittaker combines traits of her book counterpart and Nora Ambrose, who was hinted at to be Janet White's lover in the novel.
Added DiffLines:
* InelegantBlubbering: Rowena Drake is reduced to this after being revealed as one of the murderers and that Michael Garfield, her paramour, would have likely disposed of her once she outlived her usefulness.
Added DiffLines:
* KinslayingIsASpecialKindOfEvil: The murderers are
Added DiffLines:
* MatchCut: Edmund and Frances burning away Hallowe'en party paraphernalia is juxtaposed with their mother Rowena burning away old correspondence.
* MeaningfulEcho: At the start of the episode Poirot tells George to change the radio station because he's not a fan of the custom of telling horror stories during Hallowe'en, in lieu of the Belgian custom of lighting candles in respect for the dead. At the end of the episode he tells Ariadne and Judith Butler that they should have been lighting candles for the dead, given the numerous murder victims they had sought justice for.
* NeverHeardThatOneBefore: The reason Frances Drake insists on being called "Frankie" is because of all the jokes she gets from her name being similar to that of UsefulNotes/SirFrancisDrake.
* NotNowKiddo: People keep interrupting Joyce's attempts to tell the story of a murder she had chanced upon. It's later revealed to be not because they disregard her for being a child, but because she was disregarded because she was a CompulsiveLiar.
* MeaningfulEcho: At the start of the episode Poirot tells George to change the radio station because he's not a fan of the custom of telling horror stories during Hallowe'en, in lieu of the Belgian custom of lighting candles in respect for the dead. At the end of the episode he tells Ariadne and Judith Butler that they should have been lighting candles for the dead, given the numerous murder victims they had sought justice for.
* NeverHeardThatOneBefore: The reason Frances Drake insists on being called "Frankie" is because of all the jokes she gets from her name being similar to that of UsefulNotes/SirFrancisDrake.
* NotNowKiddo: People keep interrupting Joyce's attempts to tell the story of a murder she had chanced upon. It's later revealed to be not because they disregard her for being a child, but because she was disregarded because she was a CompulsiveLiar.
Added DiffLines:
* PromotedToLoveInterest: Downplayed with Lesley Ferrier having once dated Frances Drake. In the novel Ferrier had an affair with the AdaptedOut Sandra Griffin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* AdaptationalDeviation:
** Olga Seminoff's body is found buried within Michael Garfield's garden rather than a well.
** Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe discovers the affair between Garfield and Rowena from Olga, who is then rewarded by becoming her employer's heiress.
** The murders of Leslie Ferrier and Leopold Reynolds are elucidated in the adaptation; Garfield stabbed Ferrier and drowned Leopold.
* AdaptationalBadass: It's Poirot himself who comes to Miranda's rescue, whacking Michael Garfield with his cane. In the original it was two boys named Nicholas Ransom and Desmond Holland who do so at Poirot's behest.
** Olga Seminoff's body is found buried within Michael Garfield's garden rather than a well.
** Mrs Llewellyn-Smythe discovers the affair between Garfield and Rowena from Olga, who is then rewarded by becoming her employer's heiress.
** The murders of Leslie Ferrier and Leopold Reynolds are elucidated in the adaptation; Garfield stabbed Ferrier and drowned Leopold.
* AdaptationalBadass: It's Poirot himself who comes to Miranda's rescue, whacking Michael Garfield with his cane. In the original it was two boys named Nicholas Ransom and Desmond Holland who do so at Poirot's behest.
Added DiffLines:
* AdaptedOut: Several characters are excised from the adaptation, including Charlotte Benfield, Ann Reynolds, and recurring character Superintendent Spence.
Added DiffLines:
* DueToTheDead: Elizabeth Whittaker hid her lover Beatrice White's suicide note so that Beatrice wouldn't be buried in an unconsecrated grave, given that at the time suicide was seen as a mortal sin.
Added DiffLines:
* SettingUpdate: Downplayed, as with the rest of the series the episode takes place during the 1930s as opposed to the book being set in the 1960s. It does affect a minor detail in the story, though it's not as drastic as the adaptations of ''Literature/CatAmongThePigeons'' and ''Literature/ThirdGirl''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5,6 (click to see context) from:
'''Recurring cast:''' Ariadne Oliver, George
to:
'''Recurring cast:''' Ariadne Oliver, George
George \\
'''Based on:''' ''Literature/HalloweenParty''
'''Based on:''' ''Literature/HalloweenParty''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation: Beatrice White (or Janet, as she was called in the novel) was originally strangled to death [[RiddleForTheAges by an unknown culprit]]. The adaptation adds some closure to her by revealing it was a suicide -- this also meant changing her cause of death to drowning.
Changed line(s) 22 (click to see context) from:
* OffingTheOffspring: Michael Garfield attempts to "sacrifice" his own estranged daughter Miranda by compelling her to drink the poison. Fortunately, Poirot and his team stop him in the nick of time.
to:
* OffingTheOffspring: Michael Garfield attempts to "sacrifice" his own estranged daughter Miranda by compelling her to drink the poison. Fortunately, Poirot and his team stop him in the nick of time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 8 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalSexuality: Beatrice White and Elizabeth Whittaker.
to:
* AdaptationalSexuality: Beatrice White and Elizabeth Whittaker.Whittaker are revealed to have been lovers in this version. In the novel, two teenage boys actually gossip about this possibility, but it's never treated seriously.
* CanonForeigner: Rowena Drake was childress in the novel, but has two adult children from her late husband here: Frances and Edmund Drake.
Changed line(s) 16 (click to see context) from:
* HalloweenEpisode: [[CaptainObvious What do you expect in an episode based on a Poirot novel]]
to:
* HalloweenEpisode: [[CaptainObvious What do you expect in an episode based on a Poirot novel]]novel?]]
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
* LookBothWays: We learn at the end that Rowena's husband, Mr. Drake, was run over by a car, which was driven by none other than Michael Garfield himself (this was implied, but never confirmed in the novel).
to:
* LookBothWays: We learn at the end that Rowena's husband, Mr. Drake, was run over by a car, which turns out was driven by none other than Michael Garfield himself (this was implied, but never confirmed in the novel).
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
* OffingTheOffspring: Michael Garfield attempts to "sacrifice" his own estranged daughter Miranda by compelling her to drink the poison. Fortunately, Poirot and his team stop him in the nick of time.]]
to:
* OffingTheOffspring: Michael Garfield attempts to "sacrifice" his own estranged daughter Miranda by compelling her to drink the poison. Fortunately, Poirot and his team stop him in the nick of time.]]
* UnrelatedInTheAdaptation: Mrs Reynolds is the stepmother of Joyce and Leopold in this adaptation, possibly to make the murder of her entire family less heartbreaking (the oldest daughter, Ann, was AdaptedOut).
Changed line(s) 25 (click to see context) from:
* WouldHurtAChild: Two, and almost three, children are killed in this episode.
to:
* WouldHurtAChild: Two, and Two (and almost three, three) children are killed in this episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
!Hallowe'en Party
-->'''Original Airdate''': 27 October 2010\\
'''Written by:''' Mark Gatiss\\
'''Directed by:''' Charles Palmer\\
'''Recurring cast:''' Ariadne Oliver, George
!!Tropes
* AdaptationalSexuality: Beatrice White and Elizabeth Whittaker.
* AgeLift: Leopold Reynolds from goes from being Joyce's nine-year-old younger brother to her teenage older brother.
* AssholeVictim: Leopold Reynolds, who cared so little for his stepsister that he blackmails her killer for his own gain. Needless to say, [[BlackmailBackfire what happens to him later]] [[BullyingADragon is no surprise]].
* AsTheGoodBookSays: We hear Reverend Cottrell recite the KJV version of Luke 18:15-17[[note]]called "The Blessing of the Children", also in Matthew 19:13-15 and Mark 10:13-16[[/note]], and in another scene Edmund Drake recites Exodus 22:18 (KJV) when he and his sister Frances are seated at the library where the murder had occurred. After the murder of Leopold Reynolds, when Poirot approaches Reverend Cottrell and Mrs. Reynolds, she recites Job 1:16bc (KJV) before leaving.
* CaneFu: Poirot stops Michael from poisoning Miranda by whacking him with his cane and having the police arrest him just in time.
* FlashbackEffects: Flashbacks are shown with a slow shutter effect, giving them an erratic and dreamlike look.
* GardenOfEvil: Michael Garfield has an innocent-looking garden with [[TheMaze a maze]] of some sort. However, this garden is not as innocent as it may seem...
* GayngstInducedSuicide: We learn that Beatrice White and Elizabeth Whittaker were lesbian lovers, but once their relationship was found out, [[DrivenToSuicide Beatrice drowned herself]], leaving Mrs. Whittaker heartbroken and alone.
* HalloweenEpisode: [[CaptainObvious What do you expect in an episode based on a Poirot novel]]
* IronicNurseryTune: Children are chanting the snapdragon poem while playing snapdragon at the party. Their chant of "Snip! Snap!" echoes in the background music throughout the rest of the episode after Joyce Reynolds was murdered, and whenever a murder occurs, all the way to the end.
* ItWasADarkAndStormyNight: Poirot begins the tale like this in the {{Denouement}}, lampshading the fact that the beginning of the episode does take place on a dark and stormy night. (Ironically, Poirot dislikes telling horror stories, since he believes that it is a custom in Belgium to light candles in respect for the dead on Halloween, not to "tell stories macabre", but he makes an exception in extreme circumstances, such as a murder.)
* LookBothWays: We learn at the end that Rowena's husband, Mr. Drake, was run over by a car, which was driven by none other than Michael Garfield himself (this was implied, but never confirmed in the novel).
* LukeIAmYourFather: Michael is Miranda's father.
* OffingTheOffspring: Michael Garfield attempts to "sacrifice" his own estranged daughter Miranda by compelling her to drink the poison. Fortunately, Poirot and his team stop him in the nick of time.]]
* SickEpisode: Mrs. Oliver spends most of the episode in bed with the flu.
* SparedByTheAdaptation: Michael Garfield doesn't commit suicide to avoid being arrested like in the novel, and is therefore alive to personally confirm to his accomplice Rowena Drake that he never actually loved her.
* VaderBreath: Mrs. Oliver has a dream in which she hears someone breathing unnaturally and approaching her in her bed. As soon as she hears it, she turns around to see someone in a jack-o-lantern mask before she wakes up screaming, possibly foreshadowing the fact that someone could be Michael Garfield, Miranda's dad.
* WouldHurtAChild: Two, and almost three, children are killed in this episode.
----
-->'''Original Airdate''': 27 October 2010\\
'''Written by:''' Mark Gatiss\\
'''Directed by:''' Charles Palmer\\
'''Recurring cast:''' Ariadne Oliver, George
!!Tropes
* AdaptationalSexuality: Beatrice White and Elizabeth Whittaker.
* AgeLift: Leopold Reynolds from goes from being Joyce's nine-year-old younger brother to her teenage older brother.
* AssholeVictim: Leopold Reynolds, who cared so little for his stepsister that he blackmails her killer for his own gain. Needless to say, [[BlackmailBackfire what happens to him later]] [[BullyingADragon is no surprise]].
* AsTheGoodBookSays: We hear Reverend Cottrell recite the KJV version of Luke 18:15-17[[note]]called "The Blessing of the Children", also in Matthew 19:13-15 and Mark 10:13-16[[/note]], and in another scene Edmund Drake recites Exodus 22:18 (KJV) when he and his sister Frances are seated at the library where the murder had occurred. After the murder of Leopold Reynolds, when Poirot approaches Reverend Cottrell and Mrs. Reynolds, she recites Job 1:16bc (KJV) before leaving.
* CaneFu: Poirot stops Michael from poisoning Miranda by whacking him with his cane and having the police arrest him just in time.
* FlashbackEffects: Flashbacks are shown with a slow shutter effect, giving them an erratic and dreamlike look.
* GardenOfEvil: Michael Garfield has an innocent-looking garden with [[TheMaze a maze]] of some sort. However, this garden is not as innocent as it may seem...
* GayngstInducedSuicide: We learn that Beatrice White and Elizabeth Whittaker were lesbian lovers, but once their relationship was found out, [[DrivenToSuicide Beatrice drowned herself]], leaving Mrs. Whittaker heartbroken and alone.
* HalloweenEpisode: [[CaptainObvious What do you expect in an episode based on a Poirot novel]]
* IronicNurseryTune: Children are chanting the snapdragon poem while playing snapdragon at the party. Their chant of "Snip! Snap!" echoes in the background music throughout the rest of the episode after Joyce Reynolds was murdered, and whenever a murder occurs, all the way to the end.
* ItWasADarkAndStormyNight: Poirot begins the tale like this in the {{Denouement}}, lampshading the fact that the beginning of the episode does take place on a dark and stormy night. (Ironically, Poirot dislikes telling horror stories, since he believes that it is a custom in Belgium to light candles in respect for the dead on Halloween, not to "tell stories macabre", but he makes an exception in extreme circumstances, such as a murder.)
* LookBothWays: We learn at the end that Rowena's husband, Mr. Drake, was run over by a car, which was driven by none other than Michael Garfield himself (this was implied, but never confirmed in the novel).
* LukeIAmYourFather: Michael is Miranda's father.
* OffingTheOffspring: Michael Garfield attempts to "sacrifice" his own estranged daughter Miranda by compelling her to drink the poison. Fortunately, Poirot and his team stop him in the nick of time.]]
* SickEpisode: Mrs. Oliver spends most of the episode in bed with the flu.
* SparedByTheAdaptation: Michael Garfield doesn't commit suicide to avoid being arrested like in the novel, and is therefore alive to personally confirm to his accomplice Rowena Drake that he never actually loved her.
* VaderBreath: Mrs. Oliver has a dream in which she hears someone breathing unnaturally and approaching her in her bed. As soon as she hears it, she turns around to see someone in a jack-o-lantern mask before she wakes up screaming, possibly foreshadowing the fact that someone could be Michael Garfield, Miranda's dad.
* WouldHurtAChild: Two, and almost three, children are killed in this episode.
----
