Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / GilmoreGirlsS01E17

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cutting these two things because they're putting all the blame on Rory, when the episode in question never made it clear who's at fault.


** Rory insists it was Dean who didn't want to be her boyfriend, giving the impression that it was he who did the breaking up.



** Dean takes the blame for town darling Rory getting her feelings hurt for the first time, although the worst thing he did was get disappointed that she wouldn't say she loved him back.

Added: 181

Changed: 310

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigFancyHouse: Madeline's house is one of these. When Lane asks if Rory's grandparent's house is the same size she disagrees that it's not as "Hearst castle".

to:

* BigFancyHouse: Madeline's house is one of these. When Lane asks if Rory's grandparent's house is the same size she disagrees that it's not as "Hearst castle".castle."



* BreakTheHaughty: Tristan's girlfriend Summer rudely breaks up with him very loudly and publically at Madeline's party; this leads to him sitting in a room alone and acting noticeably sad and unlike the obnoxious jerk we usually see.

to:

* BreakTheHaughty: Tristan's girlfriend Summer rudely breaks up with him very loudly and publically publicly at Madeline's party; this leads to him sitting in a room alone and acting noticeably sad and unlike the obnoxious jerk we usually see.



* ComicallyMissingThePoint: Madline informs Rory that it's her stepfather's house, just as Louise asks Rory where "he" is, meaning Dean. Madeline replies that he's in Japan.
* ContinuityNod: Rory mentions Dean seeing her room for the first time and picking up Colonel Clucker, which happened in episode 7.

to:

* ComicallyMissingThePoint: Madline Madeline informs Rory that it's her stepfather's house, just as Louise asks Rory where "he" is, meaning Dean. Madeline replies that he's in Japan.
* ContinuityNod: Rory mentions [[Recap/GilmoreGirlsS01E07 Dean seeing her room for the first time time]] and picking up Colonel Clucker, which happened in episode 7.Clucker.



* DramaticallyMissingThePoint: Jackson yells at Sookie that she's missing the point of him cooking dinner for them as she keeps trying to take over, thinking ''he's'' doing this trope by using the wrong ladle.

to:

* DramaticallyMissingThePoint: DramaticallyMissingThePoint:
**
Jackson yells at Sookie that she's missing the point of him cooking dinner for them as she keeps trying to take over, thinking ''he's'' doing this trope by using the wrong ladle.



* {{Pun}}: When Lane introduces herself, Louise asks if it's as in "walk down a".

to:

* {{Pun}}: When Lane introduces herself, Louise asks if it's as in "walk down a".a."



** Lorelai has read every Literature/NancyDrew mystery ever written.
** Film/LoveStory, Film/TheChamp, Film/AnAffairToRemember, and Film/{{Ishtar}} are all good post-breakup wallow movies according to Lorelai.
** She wonders if they should include Film/OldYeller, although she admits that might be just a guy's crying movie.
** Upon learning that she might not get coffee that morning, Lorelai quotes Creator/KevinBacon's character's reaction to Creator/ChrisPenn's character's revelation of the no dancing rule in Film/{{Footloose}}.

to:

** Lorelai has read every Literature/NancyDrew ''Literature/NancyDrew'' mystery ever written.
** Film/LoveStory, Film/TheChamp, Film/AnAffairToRemember, ''Film/LoveStory'', ''Film/TheChamp'', ''Film/AnAffairToRemember'', and Film/{{Ishtar}} ''Film/{{Ishtar}}'' are all good post-breakup wallow movies according to Lorelai.
** She wonders if they should include Film/OldYeller, ''Film/OldYeller'', although she admits that might be just a guy's crying movie.
** Upon learning that she might not get coffee that morning, Lorelai quotes Creator/KevinBacon's character's reaction to Creator/ChrisPenn's character's revelation of the no dancing rule in Film/{{Footloose}}.''Film/{{Footloose}}''.



** Climbing through the back alley makes Lorelai feel like Film/GIJane except she gets to keep her hair.

to:

** Climbing through the back alley makes Lorelai feel like Film/GIJane ''Film/GIJane'' except she gets to keep her hair.



** Summer would rather dance to Music/{{Outkast}}'s ''Miss Jackson'' than talk to Tristan.
** Paris doesn't think Madame Curie was voted most likely to dress like Creator/JenniferLopez.

to:

** Summer would rather dance to Music/{{Outkast}}'s ''Miss Jackson'' "Miss Jackson" than talk to Tristan.
** Paris doesn't think [[UsefulNotes/MarieCurie Madame Curie Curie]] was voted most "most likely to dress like Creator/JenniferLopez."

Added: 81

Removed: 91

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Incredibly Lame Pun is a redirect and not a trope by itself.


* IncrediblyLamePun: When Lane introduces herself, Louise asks if it's as in "walk down a".


Added DiffLines:

* {{Pun}}: When Lane introduces herself, Louise asks if it's as in "walk down a".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityNod: Rory mentions Dean coming seeing her room for the first time and picking up Colonel Clucker, which happened in episode 7.

to:

* ContinuityNod: Rory mentions Dean coming seeing her room for the first time and picking up Colonel Clucker, which happened in episode 7.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ContinuityNod: Rory mentions Dean coming seeing her room for the first time and picking up Colonel Clucker, which happened in episode 7.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FunnyBackgroundEvent: As Lorelai assures Rory that the town has bigger things to worry about than Dean breaking up with Rory, Luke wrestles Dean right outside the window they’re sitting next to.

Added: 35

Changed: 130

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Catch22Dilemma: You have to get to Luke's, but you'd have to go past either the store where Dean works or the school where he plays basketball when he does not work. You don't know whether he works today or not.

to:

* Catch22Dilemma: You have to get to Luke's, but you'd have to go past either the store where Dean works or the school where he plays basketball when he does not work. You don't know whether he works today or not. There's always Peach Street, except Dean ''lives'' on Peach Street.



** Lorelai quotes Creator/KevinBacon's character's reaction to Creator/ChrisPenn's character's revelation of the no dancing rule in Film/{{Footloose}}.

to:

** Upon learning that she might not get coffee that morning, Lorelai quotes Creator/KevinBacon's character's reaction to Creator/ChrisPenn's character's revelation of the no dancing rule in Film/{{Footloose}}.Film/{{Footloose}}.
--->'''Lorelai:''' Whoa, step back!



* TakeAThirdOption: As it turns out, you don't have to go by the school ''or'' the store, you can climb a high fence and wade through an alley full of garbage cans.

to:

* TakeAThirdOption: As it turns out, you don't ''don't'' have to go by the school ''or'' the store, you can climb a high fence and wade through an alley full of garbage cans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObsessedAreTheListmakers: To get over the break-up, Rory makes a detailed to-do list concerning grocery shopping and home improvement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Summer would rather dance to Music/{{Outkast}}'s ''Miss Jackson'' than talk to Tristan.

Added: 137

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseLaw: Luke exercises his right not to serve Dean… but Dean hasn't ordered anything and has in fact not entered the diner.



* ContinuitySnarl: Paris claims to have gone to Chilton for nine years, though it's supposed to be a high school and those last a maximum of six years and Chilton only seems to be four years, with Paris in ssophomore year.

to:

* ContinuitySnarl: Paris claims to have gone to Chilton for nine years, though it's supposed to be a high school and those last a maximum of six years and Chilton only seems to be four years, with Paris in ssophomore sophomore year.

Added: 1672

Changed: 895

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Season 1, episode 17'''

!!The Breakup, Part 2



----
!!This episode contains examples of:

to:

----
!!This episode contains examples of:

!!Tropes:
* AcousticLicense: Rory asks Lane if she is to pretend to be sick and having to go home while Lane is slow-dancing with Henry, who doesn't seem to hear a thing.



* ComicallyMissingThePoint: Madline informs Rory that it's her stepfather's house, Louise asks Rory where "he" is, meaning Dean. Madeline replies that he's in Japan.

to:

* ComicallyMissingThePoint: Madline informs Rory that it's her stepfather's house, just as Louise asks Rory where "he" is, meaning Dean. Madeline replies that he's in Japan.Japan.
* ContinuitySnarl: Paris claims to have gone to Chilton for nine years, though it's supposed to be a high school and those last a maximum of six years and Chilton only seems to be four years, with Paris in ssophomore year.
* DatingWhatDaddyHates: Lane subverts this and lampshades it. Henry is exactly what her mother wants her to date.
* DramaticallyMissingThePoint: Jackson yells at Sookie that she's missing the point of him cooking dinner for them as she keeps trying to take over, thinking ''he's'' doing this trope by using the wrong ladle.
** Rory starts crying when Tristan kisses her, and he thinks it's because he accidentally bit her lip.
* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: Lorelai claims to have been in labor for fourteen hours. In later episodes it will have been about half an hour.



* HeadlockOfDominance: Luke puts Dean in a headlock, claiming it's part of exercising his right not to serve him, despite being on the street outside the diner.



* {{Hypocrite}}: Lorelai calls herself a hypocrite for telling Rory how to get over a guy when she herself hasn't gotten over Max.
* IncrediblyLamePun: When Lane introduces herself, Louise asks if it's as in "walk down a".



* TheScapegoat: Dean takes the blame for town darling Rory getting her feelings hurt for the first time, although the worst thing he did was get disappointed that she wouldn't say she loved him back.

to:

* TheScapegoat: TheScapegoat:
**
Dean takes the blame for town darling Rory getting her feelings hurt for the first time, although the worst thing he did was get disappointed that she wouldn't say she loved him back.back.
** Miss Patty, Luke, and Kirk all want to take the blame for Rory and Dean getting together in the first place.



** Film/WhosAfraidOfVirginiaWoolf
** Film/AnAffairToRemember
** Film/{{Ishtar}}
** Film/OldYeller
** Film/{{Footloose}}
** Literature/TheBellJar

to:

** Film/WhosAfraidOfVirginiaWoolf
Lorelai has read every Literature/NancyDrew mystery ever written.
** Film/AnAffairToRemember
Film/LoveStory, Film/TheChamp, Film/AnAffairToRemember, and Film/{{Ishtar}} are all good post-breakup wallow movies according to Lorelai.
** Film/{{Ishtar}}
She wonders if they should include Film/OldYeller, although she admits that might be just a guy's crying movie.
** Film/OldYeller
Lorelai quotes Creator/KevinBacon's character's reaction to Creator/ChrisPenn's character's revelation of the no dancing rule in Film/{{Footloose}}.
** Film/{{Footloose}}
Climbing through the back alley makes Lorelai feel like Film/GIJane except she gets to keep her hair.
** Literature/TheBellJarLorelai figures staying home reading ''Literature/TheBellJar'' would have the same effect as going to a Chilton party.



* TakeAThirdOption: Actually, you don't have to go by the school ''or'' the store, you can climb a high fence and wade through an alley full of garbage cans.

to:

* TakeAThirdOption: Actually, As it turns out, you don't have to go by the school ''or'' the store, you can climb a high fence and wade through an alley full of garbage cans.

Added: 228

Changed: 97

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Rory is mourning her breakup by avoiding thinking about it, letting everyone think Dean dumped ''her''. She decides to go to a Chilton party with Lane to get her mind off him. Paris is there because her mother forced her to go.

to:

Rory is mourning her breakup by avoiding thinking about it, letting everyone think Dean dumped ''her''. She decides to go to a Chilton party with Lane to get her mind off him. Paris is there because her mother forced her to go. Lane meets Henry and gives him her phone number by telling him how to find it in the phone book.


Added DiffLines:

* PlotParallel: Tristan gets dumped by Summer at the party, and Lane is finding her first boyfriend while Lorelai is getting back with an ex, so now Rory ends up comforting Tristan who is in roughly the same position as herself.

Added: 487

Changed: 135

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Rory is mourning her breakup by avoiding thinking about it, letting everyone think Dean dumped ''her''.

to:

Rory is mourning her breakup by avoiding thinking about it, letting everyone think Dean dumped ''her''. She decides to go to a Chilton party with Lane to get her mind off him. Paris is there because her mother forced her to go.



* AmusingInjuries: Played with. Babette thinks Rory will find it encouraging to learn about all the truly awful men she dated before she met Morrey.
-->'''Babette:''' I got pushed out of a moving car once!



* CatchTwentyTwoDilemma: You have to get to Luke's, but you'd have to go past either the store where Dean works or the school where he plays basketball when he does not work. You don't know whether he works today or not.

to:

* CatchTwentyTwoDilemma: Catch22Dilemma: You have to get to Luke's, but you'd have to go past either the store where Dean works or the school where he plays basketball when he does not work. You don't know whether he works today or not.not.
* ComicallyMissingThePoint: Madline informs Rory that it's her stepfather's house, Louise asks Rory where "he" is, meaning Dean. Madeline replies that he's in Japan.


Added DiffLines:

** Literature/TheBellJar
** Paris doesn't think Madame Curie was voted most likely to dress like Creator/JenniferLopez.

Added: 1085

Changed: 293

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Rory is mourning her breakup by avoiding thinking about it, letting everyone think Dean dumped ''her''.



* BlatantLies:
** Rory insists it was Dean who didn't want to be her boyfriend, giving the impression that it was he who did the breaking up.
** Lorelai lets Rory think she's getting rid of the Dean box, but she hides it in a closet where Rory is bound to find it eventually.



* CatchTwentyTwoDilemma: You have to get to Luke's, but you'd have to go past either the store where Dean works or the school where he plays basketball when he does not work. You don't know whether he works today or not.



* SexWithTheEx: When Rory asks Lorelai how long it took her to get over Max, she can't give an answer. This leads her to thinking about Max which leads her to go Max's which leads her and him to...well.

to:

* TheScapegoat: Dean takes the blame for town darling Rory getting her feelings hurt for the first time, although the worst thing he did was get disappointed that she wouldn't say she loved him back.
* SexWithTheEx: When Rory asks Lorelai how long it took her to get over Max, she can't give an answer. This leads her to thinking about Max which leads her to go Max's which leads her and him to...well.to… well.
* ShoutOut:
** Film/WhosAfraidOfVirginiaWoolf
** Film/AnAffairToRemember
** Film/{{Ishtar}}
** Film/OldYeller
** Film/{{Footloose}}
* TakeAThirdOption: Actually, you don't have to go by the school ''or'' the store, you can climb a high fence and wade through an alley full of garbage cans.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeartbreakAndIceCream: After leaving Max's, Lorelai comes home to find Rory in tears, on the couch with a huge tub of ice cream.
-->'''Rory''': [in tears] I'm ready to wallow now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FlippingTheTable: Played with. Max places a table between himself and Lorelai as a way of keeping their hands off each other. Max quickly flips the table away from them and they get back at it.

to:

* FlippingTheTable: Played with. Max places a table between himself and Lorelai as a way of keeping their hands off each other. Max quickly flips the table away from them and they get back at it.it.
* SexWithTheEx: When Rory asks Lorelai how long it took her to get over Max, she can't give an answer. This leads her to thinking about Max which leads her to go Max's which leads her and him to...well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FirstKiss: This episode includes Rory and Tristan's first, and only, kiss of the series.

to:

* FirstKiss: This episode includes Rory and Tristan's first, and only, kiss of the series.series.
* FlippingTheTable: Played with. Max places a table between himself and Lorelai as a way of keeping their hands off each other. Max quickly flips the table away from them and they get back at it.

Added: 90

Changed: 197

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FirstKiss: This episode includes Rory and Tristan's first, and only kiss of the series.
* BreakTheHaughty: Tristan's girlfriend Summer rudely breaks up with him very loudly and publically at Madeline's party; this leads to him sitting in a room alone and acting noticeably sad and unlike the obnoxious jerk we usually see.

to:

* FirstKiss: This episode includes Rory and Tristan's first, and only kiss BigFancyHouse: Madeline's house is one of these. When Lane asks if Rory's grandparent's house is the series.
same size she disagrees that it's not as "Hearst castle".
* BreakTheHaughty: Tristan's girlfriend Summer rudely breaks up with him very loudly and publically at Madeline's party; this leads to him sitting in a room alone and acting noticeably sad and unlike the obnoxious jerk we usually see.see.
* FirstKiss: This episode includes Rory and Tristan's first, and only, kiss of the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

----
!!This episode contains examples of:
* FirstKiss: This episode includes Rory and Tristan's first, and only kiss of the series.
* BreakTheHaughty: Tristan's girlfriend Summer rudely breaks up with him very loudly and publically at Madeline's party; this leads to him sitting in a room alone and acting noticeably sad and unlike the obnoxious jerk we usually see.

Top