Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / BabylonFiveS04E09Atonement

Go To

OR

Added: 25

Removed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ThePatriarch: Callenn.



** ThePatriarch: Callenn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ConnectedAllAlong: Delenn and Sinclair's relationship acquires an odd tone as it turns out he was her ancestor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut trope


* StockEpisodeTitles

Removed: 294

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Doesn't appear to be what the trope name refers to


* UnstoppableRage: Delenn's reaction to Dukhat's death.
-->"No mercy! No mercy!"
** The Minbari in general during the war with the humans. As one of Delenn's colleagues tells her, they are "a world gone mad", and the fires of their madness cannot now be controlled; they must burn out over time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StockEpisodeTitles
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MandatoryLine: Ivanova's brief appearance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CharacterDevelopment: The change in Franklin's character is quite pronounced here; the old Franklin could barely drag himself away from Medlab long enough for a good night's sleep. Here he agrees to an extended mission that will have him away from Babylon 5 for possibly weeks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IntriguedByHumanity: Delenn is curious enough about humans to start researching them on her own time after hearing about the Grey Council's deliberations on the subject.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Later in his office, he briefs Stephen and Marcus on a mission he's sending them on. Clark's propaganda machine has been pounding on them for weeks and Sheridan wants to make a counter move before it's too late to do anything. He's sending them to make contact with the Resistance on Mars. That will enable them to establish alternate lines of communication and begins getting ready for the inevitable fight with Earth. Franklin will go representing B5 command staff, since he's not as likely to draw attention as Sheridan, and Marcus will act as his bodyguard. And they are to leave as soon as possible, since it will take a long time to go the roundabout way.

to:

Later in his office, he briefs Stephen and Marcus on a the mission he's sending them on. Clark's propaganda machine has been pounding on them for weeks and Sheridan wants to make a counter move before it's too late to do anything. He's sending them to make contact with the Resistance on Mars. That will enable them to establish alternate lines of communication and begins getting ready for the inevitable fight with Earth. Franklin will go representing B5 command staff, since he's not as likely to draw attention as Sheridan, and Marcus will act as his bodyguard. And they are to leave as soon as possible, since it will take a long time to go the roundabout way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


On the ''Valen'tha'', Dukhat marches past, calling Delenn for to come with him. He brings her before the Grey Council and begins explaining an issue they have been debating for some time, whether or not to make contact with a race known as humans. Each of the three castes has said "no", and he asks if she would like to hear why.

to:

On the ''Valen'tha'', Dukhat marches past, calling for Delenn for to come with him. He brings her before the Grey Council and begins explaining an issue they have been debating for some time, whether or not to make contact with a race known as humans. Each of the three castes has said "no", and he asks if she would like to hear why.

Added: 248

Changed: 37

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FantasticRacism: Callenn seeks to keep Minbari "pure".

to:

* FantasticRacism: FantasticRacism:
**
Callenn seeks to keep Minbari "pure"."pure".
** The Warrior Caste's reason for not making contact with the humans is that it would be a waste of time and effort, which basically boils down to, "They're not Minbari, therefore they're not worth noticing."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


On a Warcruiser, Dukhat marches past, calling Delenn to follow him. He brings her before the Grey Council and begins explaining an issue they have been debating for some time, whether or not to make contact with a race known as humans. Each of the three castes has said "no", and he asks if she would like to hear why.

to:

On a Warcruiser, the ''Valen'tha'', Dukhat marches past, calling Delenn for to follow come with him. He brings her before the Grey Council and begins explaining an issue they have been debating for some time, whether or not to make contact with a race known as humans. Each of the three castes has said "no", and he asks if she would like to hear why.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As she speaks, a regal looking Minbari appears, sitting perfectly still as a younger Delenn approaches nervously. He invites her to sit with him and tell him her name, Delenn of the Family of Mir, a name he recognizes.

to:

As she speaks, a regal dignified looking Minbari appears, sitting perfectly still as a younger Delenn approaches nervously. He invites her to sit with him and tell him her name, Delenn of the Family of Mir, a name he recognizes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwfulTruth: Callenn clearly regards the fact that many modern Minbari have human DNA as this, and Delenn is able to use it to leverage an agreement where he approves her marriage as an ancient Minbari reconciliation custom in exchange for her keeping it to herself.

to:

* AwfulTruth: Callenn clearly regards the fact that many countless modern Minbari have human DNA as this, and Delenn is able to use it to leverage an agreement where he approves her marriage as an ancient Minbari reconciliation custom in exchange for her keeping it to herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RewatchBonus: The meeting between Delenn and King Arthur get this after you find out about Delenn's part in starting the Earth-Minbari war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DiedinYourArmsTonight: Delenn holds Dukhat in his final moments.

to:

* DiedinYourArmsTonight: DiedInYourArmsTonight: Delenn holds Dukhat in his final moments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*FantasticRacism: Callenn seeks to keep Minbari "pure".

Added: 252

Changed: 296

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AltarDiplomacy: Minbari have a custom dating back to the days when they actually made war on each other where the winning side would offer a daughter in marriage as a symbol of life. Delenn's family decides to pass off her marriage to Sheridan as this.

to:

*AllThereInTheManual: Supplementary material reveals that Delenn's clan is called the Tenth Fane of Elleya. Her family (Mir) is part of it.
* AltarDiplomacy: Minbari have a custom dating back to the days when they actually made war on each other where the winning side would offer a daughter in marriage as a symbol of life. Delenn's family clan decides to pass off her marriage to Sheridan as this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UndyingLoyalty: Lennier reestablishes just how loyal he is to Delenn after finding out about her vote.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Dukhat mentions the Centauri have had dealings with the humans for some time. If you recall, the Centauri were the [[Recap/BabylonFiveS01E01MidnightOnTheFiringLine first aliens humanity encountered]].

Added: 55

Changed: 203

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnstoppableRage: Delenn's reaction to Dukhat's death.

to:

* UnevenHybrid: Turns out Delenn was partially human even before entering the chrysalis. Countless other partially-human minbari are also out there, most likely without even realizing it.
* UnstoppableRage: Delenn's reaction to Dukhat's death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WartsAndAll: Delenn fears that her standing with Lennier would be harmed from his knowing her involvement in starting the Earth/Minbari War. [[Heartwarming/BabylonFive She's wrong]]; Lennier holds no grudge despite losing family on the Black Star.

to:

* WartsAndAll: Delenn fears that her standing with Lennier would be harmed from his knowing her involvement in starting the Earth/Minbari War. [[Heartwarming/BabylonFive She's wrong]]; Lennier holds no grudge despite losing family on the Black Star.Star.
* WeComeInPeaceShootToKill: The Warrior Caste's tradition of approaching with gun ports open is misinterpreted by the Earth ships as hostile intention and they take preemptive action, leading to a devastating war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The worker caste are worried about their position if new sources of food and artifacts becomes availible, the religious caste are worried about the influence of a primitive and violent culture on their own, and the warriors just think they're not worth the effort. He then asks Delenn what she thinks. She tries to protest, but he insists, with some mild prodding, she give an answer. With the entire leadership of her people watching her (probably glaring at her), the girl tries to stammer out an intelligent and thoughtful-sounding answer, that the Universe presents mysteries (such as the humans) as a gift, and that common politeness would demand at least attempting to understand it.

to:

The worker caste are worried about their position if new sources of food and artifacts becomes availible, the religious caste are worried about the influence of a primitive and violent culture on their own, and the warriors just think they're not worth the effort. He then asks Delenn what she thinks. She tries to protest, but he insists, with some mild prodding, she give an answer. With the entire leadership of her people watching her (probably glaring at her), the girl tries to stammer out an intelligent and thoughtful-sounding answer, answer. She starts by quoting Valen, but Dukhat is more interested in what she thinks. She ventures the opinion that the Universe presents mysteries (such as the humans) as a gift, and that common politeness would demand at least attempting to understand it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShroudedInMyth: The origins of Valen and the Triluminaries have been lost to history by the time Delenn joins the Grey Council.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Later, Lennier comes with a scroll of family histories that he "obtained" from the archoves of the Grey Council. Delenn waves it in Callenn's face, explaining that she is a descendent of Valen, originally the human Jeffrey Sinclair. After his change, Valen was still partially human, and passed that down through his children to the modern age. How many, she asks, carry his legacy? Callenn admits they cannot be counted. Delenn decides that she will make the case that she was never fully Minbari to begin with and so there will be nothing to lose by marrying a human. Callenn fears it will cause [[AwfulTruth great confusion among their people]], but since Delenn is not willing to relent, he comes up with an alternative. In ancient times, after a war between their peoples, the winning side would [[AltarDiplomacy give a daughter in marriage to the other as a symbol of life]]. He offers to pass her union with Sheridan as this tradition, an offering to the humans who died in the Earth-Minbari War, which he imagines would be a great sacrifice. Delenn just gives him a knowing smirk.

Back on B5, Sheridan is waiting as Delenn arrives. She just tells him everything's fine now. He's simultaniously amused and annoyed that she won't say what it was all about but the important thing is she's back. As they walk off, she asks about Stephen and Marcus, who are already on their way to Mars. Sheridan thinks they'll probably turn this into a sight-seeing tour, take the time to enjoy themselves.

to:

Later, Lennier comes with a scroll of family histories that he "obtained" from the archoves archives of the Grey Council. Delenn waves it in Callenn's face, explaining that she is a descendent of Valen, originally the human Jeffrey Sinclair. After his change, Valen was still partially human, and passed that down through his children to the modern age. How many, she asks, carry his legacy? Callenn admits they cannot be counted. Delenn decides that she will make the case that she was never fully Minbari to begin with and so there will be nothing to lose by marrying a human. Callenn fears it will cause [[AwfulTruth great confusion among their people]], but since Delenn is not willing to relent, he relent. As she and Lennier start to leave, Callen comes up with an alternative. In ancient times, after a war between their peoples, the winning side would [[AltarDiplomacy give a daughter in marriage to the other as a symbol of life]]. He offers to pass her union with Sheridan as this tradition, an offering to the humans who died in the Earth-Minbari War, which he imagines would be a great sacrifice. Delenn just gives him a knowing smirk.

Back on B5, Sheridan is waiting as Delenn arrives. She just tells him everything's fine now. He's simultaniously simultaneously amused and annoyed that she won't say what it was all about but the important thing is she's back. As they walk off, she asks about Stephen and Marcus, who are already on their way to Mars. Sheridan thinks they'll probably turn this into a sight-seeing tour, take the time to enjoy themselves.

Added: 215

Changed: 58

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Delenn''' Perhaps anothe might be better suited to...\\

to:

-->'''Delenn''' Perhaps anothe another might be better suited to...\\



The worker caste are worried about their position if new sources of food and artifacts becomes availible, the religious caste are worried about the influence of a primitive and violent culture on their own, and the warriors just think they're not worth the effort. He then asks Delenn what she thinks. She tries to protest, but he insists, with some mild prodding, she give an answer. With the entire leadership of her people watching her (probably glaring at her), the girl tries to stammer out an intelligent and thoughtful-sounding answer, that the Universe presents mysteries (such as the humans) as a gift, and that common politness would demand at least attempting to understand it.

to:

The worker caste are worried about their position if new sources of food and artifacts becomes availible, the religious caste are worried about the influence of a primitive and violent culture on their own, and the warriors just think they're not worth the effort. He then asks Delenn what she thinks. She tries to protest, but he insists, with some mild prodding, she give an answer. With the entire leadership of her people watching her (probably glaring at her), the girl tries to stammer out an intelligent and thoughtful-sounding answer, that the Universe presents mysteries (such as the humans) as a gift, and that common politness politeness would demand at least attempting to understand it.



He and Delenn return to the Council Chamber, where the display shows a groups of unknown ships approaching their location. Delenn believes thay are human ships (she'd done some investigating on her own) but they cannot understand their transmissions. Per Warrior Caste tradition they are approaching with gunports open, but when Soul Hunter ships appear, they realizes something terrible is about to happen. Dukhat orders the ports closed, but the human ships open fire, doing serious damage to the cruiser and killing many on board. Dukhat is among those wounded, and as Delenn tries to pull him to safety he dies in her arms. Moments later, another of the Council comes tells her the Council is split on whether to pursue and exact revenge, or wait to analyze what happened and asks for her vote to break the tie. Grief-stricken, Delenn orders retaliation, strike them all down, kill them all!

to:

He and Delenn return to the Council Chamber, where the display shows a groups of unknown ships approaching their location. Delenn believes thay they are human ships (she'd done some investigating on her own) but they cannot understand their transmissions. Per Warrior Caste tradition they are approaching with gunports open, but when Soul Hunter ships appear, [[FiveSecondForeshadowing they realizes something terrible is about to happen.happen]]. Dukhat orders the ports closed, but the human ships open fire, doing serious damage to the cruiser and killing many on board. Dukhat is among those wounded, and as Delenn tries to pull him to safety he [[DiedinYourArmsTonight dies in her arms.arms]]. Moments later, another of the Council comes tells her the Council is split on whether to pursue and exact revenge, or wait to analyze what happened and asks for her vote to break the tie. Grief-stricken, Delenn orders retaliation, strike them all down, kill them all!


Added DiffLines:

* DiedinYourArmsTonight: Delenn holds Dukhat in his final moments.


Added DiffLines:

* FiveSecondForeshadowing: When the Soul Hunters appear, the Minbari realize tragedy is about to strike, but it's too late to do anything about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The worker caste are worried about their position if new sources of food and artifacts becomes availible, the religious caste are worried about the influence of a primitive and violent culture on their own, and the warriors just think they're not worth the effort. He then asks Delenn what she thinks. She tries to protest, but he insists, with some mild prodding, she give an answer. With the entire leadership of her people watching her (probably glaring at her), the girl tries to stammer out an intelligent and thoughtful-sounding, that the Universe presents mysteries (such as the humans) as a gift, and that common politness would demand at least attempting to understand it.

to:

The worker caste are worried about their position if new sources of food and artifacts becomes availible, the religious caste are worried about the influence of a primitive and violent culture on their own, and the warriors just think they're not worth the effort. He then asks Delenn what she thinks. She tries to protest, but he insists, with some mild prodding, she give an answer. With the entire leadership of her people watching her (probably glaring at her), the girl tries to stammer out an intelligent and thoughtful-sounding, thoughtful-sounding answer, that the Universe presents mysteries (such as the humans) as a gift, and that common politness would demand at least attempting to understand it.



As Delenn follows him out, she asks if they will make contact. No, they will be even more stubborn and overruling them at this point would do no good, but she has impressed him enough to take her on as his personal aide. She is astounded, but gladly accepts.

to:

As Delenn follows him out, she asks if they will make contact. No, they will be even more stubborn and overruling them at this point would do no good, but she has impressed him Dukhat enough to take her on as his personal aide. She is astounded, but gladly accepts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sinclair going back in time and becoming Valen had more ramifications than just reorganizing Minbari society.

to:

** [[Recap/BabylonFiveS03E17WarWithoutEndPart2 Sinclair going back in time and becoming Valen Valen]] had more ramifications than just reorganizing Minbari society.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Dukhat'': You have a proud heritage, Delenn of Mir, prouder than you know.

to:

-->'''Dukhat'': -->'''Dukhat''': You have a proud heritage, Delenn of Mir, prouder than you know.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MoodWhiplash: The start of the Dreaming goes from the tranquil first meeting between Delenn and Dukhat to a full-scale space battle in a matter of seconds.

Top