Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / ArthurS3E12WhatScaredSueEllenClarissaIsCracked

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliberateValuesDissonance:

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Regarding Thora and her toys:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed per cleanup thread.


* AnAesop:
** There will be things that frighten you, but if you take the proper preparations to deal with it, you'll be able to conquer your fears. Sue Ellen follows her parents' advice on how they conquered their fear of climbing to reach a summit, and rallies the boys to confront the source of the noise.
** Don't mock somebody's stories or interests just because they didn't resonate with you, as they will find little reason to be interested in yours. Sue Ellen puts down the group's scary stories because they're not real and she had more fun having adventures around the world, and Arthur points out that she can't expect them to take her scary stories seriously after she mocked theirs.

Added: 683

Removed: 683

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetizing example(s)


* {{Foil}}: While Thora and D.W. had a lot in common while they were the same age, they were shaped by their time periods. Thora was told that because she was a little girl, she was not expected to be careful with her things, so she painstakingly did what she could to make sure Clarissa stayed pristine. Even so, Thora as a grandmother says that there were times when Clarissa got broken and needed fixing. D.W. is a little more careless because she takes Clarissa for granted, and doesn't understand that she is fragile. She also has more toys in her room, because her parents were able to afford them, they're more patient with D.W.'s roughhousing, and the toys are more durable.



* {{Foil}}: While Thora and D.W. had a lot in common while they were the same age, they were shaped by their time periods. Thora was told that because she was a little girl, she was not expected to be careful with her things, so she painstakingly did what she could to make sure Clarissa stayed pristine. Even so, Thora as a grandmother says that there were times when Clarissa got broken and needed fixing. D.W. is a little more careless because she takes Clarissa for granted, and doesn't understand that she is fragile. She also has more toys in her room, because her parents were able to afford them, they're more patient with D.W.'s roughhousing, and the toys are more durable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Character reaction.


* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: Clarissa manages to be fixed before D.W. has to give her back to Grandma Thora, but D.W. still feels guilty and confesses to Thora that she broke Clarissa. She expects Thora to be angry at her for not being more careful, but Thora takes it in stride, saying that Clarissa has been cracked more than once since she's had the doll for such a long time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

Added: 511

Changed: 378

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CallBack: During a montage of D.W. spending time with Clarissa, we see all sorts of examples that she doesn't know how to properly care for a porcelain doll, such as letting friends hold the doll despite having dirty hands, or going down a slide too roughly. Later, during the flashback to when Thora got Clarissa for her birthday, she's seen doing all the same activities D.W. did, but being more careful with her, like making sure someone's hands were clean before holding the doll or going down a slide more carefully. This is meant to drive home the point for D.W. how important Clarissa was to her grandmother, helping her [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realize]] she'd been taking her for granted.

to:

* CallBack: During a montage of D.W. spending time with Clarissa, we see all sorts of examples that she doesn't know how to properly care for a porcelain doll, such as letting friends hold the doll despite having dirty hands, or going down a slide too roughly. Later, during the flashback to when Thora got Clarissa for her birthday, she's seen doing all the same activities D.W. did, but being more careful with her, like making sure someone's hands were clean before holding the doll or going down a slide more carefully. This is meant to drive home the point for D.W. how important Clarissa was to her grandmother, helping her [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realize]] she'd been taking her the doll for granted.



* CoolBigBro: For what it's worth, Thora's three older brothers would give their old toys to her and refashion them into items more suitable for girls. She didn't appreciate it at the time but told her mother she wanted a toy of her own and didn't blame them.

to:

* CoolBigBro: CoolBigBro:
**
For what it's worth, Thora's three older brothers would give their old toys to her and refashion them into items more suitable for girls. She didn't appreciate it at the time but told her mother she wanted a toy of her own and didn't blame them. them.
** Arthur also doesn't mind taking D.W. to see a puppet show while he's at the library (even when there's a delay from one of the puppets breaking) and suggests going to Mr. Ratburn for help when seeing D.W. despondent over not being able to fix Clarissa in time.



** Toys were a lot more fragile when Thora was a little girl, so most of Thora's toys were hand-me-downs from her brothers or handmade. She's given a brand new toy only when she turns a certain age, and it's impressed that she has to take good care of Clarissa.
** It's also noted that young Thora would often go to the toy store on her own with her parent's permission, which surprises D.W. that this was allowed when she was at such an early age--Mr. and Mrs. Read explain that Elwood City was a lot smaller back when Thora was a kid, so everyone was more familiar with one another rather than being total strangers (as shown when an elderly woman and a traffic cop help Thora cross the road, and both of them know her by name).
* DoubleStandard: Thora was given less toys, compared to her three older brothers, because she's younger, and a girl, and was expected to not take care of them. She does protest this, though her brothers try to help by fashioning new toys for her out of theirs or out of household objects.

to:

** Toys were a lot more expensive and fragile when Thora was a little girl, so most of Thora's her toys were hand-me-downs from her brothers or handmade. She's Thora is given a brand new toy only when she turns a certain age, and it's impressed that she has to take good care of Clarissa.
** It's also noted that young Thora would often go to the toy store on her own with her parent's parents' permission, which surprises D.W. that this was allowed when she was at such an early age--Mr. and Mrs. Read explain that Elwood City was a lot smaller back when Thora was a kid, so everyone was more familiar with one another rather than being total strangers (as shown when an elderly woman and a traffic cop help Thora cross the road, and both of them know her by name).
* DoubleStandard: Thora was given less toys, toys compared to her three older brothers, brothers because she's younger, and a girl, and was expected to not take care of them. She does protest this, though her brothers try to help by fashioning new toys for her out of theirs or out of household objects.



* TheGreatDepression: The flashbacks to Thora's childhood are implied to take place during this period. The town was smaller and even more tight-knit, a girl Thora's age could walk around by herself, the boys had knee length shorts instead of pants with long socks, the men had bow ties, all the adults wore hats out, the women had bobbed or CompressedHair, the mention of how Thora's family didn't have a lot of money to get her toys, and a older woman and a traffic cop complain about [[FauxHorrific "the noise'']] caused by a zeppelin flying over town.
* {{Foil}}: While Thora and D.W. had a lot in common while they were the same age, they were shaped by their time periods. Thora was told that because she was a girl she was not expected to be careful with her things, so she painstakingly did what she could to make sure Clarissa stayed pristine. Even so, Thora as a grandmother says that there were times when Clarissa got broken and needed fixing. D.W. is a little more careless because she takes Clarissa for granted, and doesn't understand that she is fragile. She also has more toys in her room, because her parents were able to afford them, and they're more patient with her roughhousing.
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: While at first D.W. doesn't understand why breaking Clarissa is a big deal, she goes through this after her parents explain how much Clarissa meant to Thora. Realizing she's been far rougher with the doll compared to Thora, she agrees that Clarissa needs to be fixed.

to:

* TheGreatDepression: The flashbacks to Thora's childhood are implied to take place during this period. The town was smaller and even more tight-knit, a girl Thora's age could walk around by herself, the boys had knee length shorts instead of pants with long socks, the men had bow ties, all the adults wore hats out, the women had bobbed or CompressedHair, the mention of it's mentioned how Thora's family didn't have a lot of money to get her toys, and a an older woman and a traffic cop complain about [[FauxHorrific "the noise'']] "[[FauxHorrific the noise]]" caused by a zeppelin flying over town.
* {{Foil}}: While Thora and D.W. had a lot in common while they were the same age, they were shaped by their time periods. Thora was told that because she was a girl little girl, she was not expected to be careful with her things, so she painstakingly did what she could to make sure Clarissa stayed pristine. Even so, Thora as a grandmother says that there were times when Clarissa got broken and needed fixing. D.W. is a little more careless because she takes Clarissa for granted, and doesn't understand that she is fragile. She also has more toys in her room, because her parents were able to afford them, and they're more patient with her roughhousing.D.W.'s roughhousing, and the toys are more durable.
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: While at first D.W. doesn't understand why breaking Clarissa is a big deal, she goes through this after her parents explain how much Clarissa meant to Thora. Realizing she's been far rougher with the doll compared to Thora, she tearfully agrees that Clarissa needs to be fixed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnAesop:
** There will be things that frighten you, but if you take the proper preparations to deal with it, you'll be able to conquer your fears. Sue Ellen follows her parents' advice on how they conquered their fear of climbing to reach a summit, and rallies the boys to confront the source of the noise.
** Don't mock somebody's stories or interests just because they didn't resonate with you, as they will find little reason to be interested in yours. Sue Ellen puts down the group's scary stories because they're not real and she had more fun having adventures around the world, and Arthur points out that she can't expect them to take her scary stories seriously after she mocked theirs.
* ArmorPiercingResponse: When Sue Ellen insists her stories from other countries are real, Arthur points out that she kept mocking all their scary stories for not being real, meaning they have little inclination to treat hers as the real deal.


Added DiffLines:

* AvengersAssemble: The climax of the episode is Sue Ellen rallying Arthur, Buster, and Binky to don protective gear and presumed weapons to go confront the source of the noise in the Dead Woods.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Jumpscare}}: During Sue Ellen's DreamWithinADream, the Baba Yaga reveals herself this way complete with a shrieking score cue.


Added DiffLines:

* ItsAllAboutMe: Discussed. Sue Ellen angrily demands the boys take her folk stories seriously, but Arthur points out that she kept mocking their scary stories - why should they take ''hers'' seriously?


Added DiffLines:

* LaserGuidedKarma: Sue Ellen makes fun of her friends for being scared of scary stories, but when she finds something she is scared of, the others have little sympathy for her at first due to how much she dismissed them.


Added DiffLines:

* ToServeMan: Like in the old folk tales, the Baba Yaga chases Sue Ellen down with the intention of eating her during her nightmare.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Toys were a lot more fragile in those days, so most of Thora's toys were hand-me-downs from her brothers or handmade. She's given a brand new toy only when she turns a certain age, and it's impressed that she has to take good care of Clarissa.

to:

** Toys were a lot more fragile in those days, when Thora was a little girl, so most of Thora's toys were hand-me-downs from her brothers or handmade. She's given a brand new toy only when she turns a certain age, and it's impressed that she has to take good care of Clarissa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS cleanup


* AdultFear: It turns out Mrs. Wood's dog Perky was lost in the woods for days and trapped under a fallen tree. Mrs. Wood thanks the group for finding her dog and getting help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGunman: Mr. Ratburn, who's seen putting on a puppet show at the library earlier in the episode. When Arthur's parents can't find anyone who can fix Clarissa, Arthur remembers that Mr. Ratburn works with puppets, and goes with D.W. to ask if he can fix the doll. Mr. Ratburn does, at no charge.

to:

* ChekhovsGunman: Mr. Ratburn, who's seen putting on a puppet show at the library earlier in the episode. When Arthur's parents can't find anyone who can fix Clarissa, Clarissa and D.W. is getting more worried, Arthur remembers that Mr. Ratburn works with puppets, and goes with D.W. to ask if he can fix the doll. Mr. Ratburn does, at no charge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EasilyForgiven: Thora forgives D.W. when the latter confesses about what happened to Clarissa, since she appreciates that D.W. also got her fixed and it isn't the first time Clarissa has been broken.

to:

* EasilyForgiven: Thora forgives D.W. when the latter confesses about what happened to Clarissa, since she appreciates that D.W. also got her fixed and it isn't the first time Clarissa has been broken.broken. In the end, she lets D.W. keep Clarissa since she's learned how to be responsible.

Added: 377

Changed: 164

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: Binky is telling an urban legend about a hook-handed killer. Arthur says he read it as well; the story was collected in ''Literature/ScaryStoriesToTellInTheDark''.

to:

* ShoutOut: ShoutOut:
**
Binky is telling an urban legend about a hook-handed killer. Arthur says he read it as well; the story was collected in ''Literature/ScaryStoriesToTellInTheDark''.
** Sue Ellen imagines Literature/BabaYaga as a possible source of the noise in the woods. True to the stories, she's depicted as a withered old crone who lives in a house that moves around on giant chicken legs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGunman: Mr. Ratburn. Arthur remembers that Mr. Ratburn works with puppets, and he was earlier putting on a show at the library, and goes to ask if he can fix Clarissa. Mr. Ratburn does, at no charge.

to:

* ChekhovsGunman: Mr. Ratburn. Ratburn, who's seen putting on a puppet show at the library earlier in the episode. When Arthur's parents can't find anyone who can fix Clarissa, Arthur remembers that Mr. Ratburn works with puppets, and he was earlier putting on a show at the library, and goes with D.W. to ask if he can fix Clarissa.the doll. Mr. Ratburn does, at no charge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CallBack: During a montage of D.W. spending time with Clarissa, we see all sorts of examples that she doesn't know how to properly care for a porcelain doll, such as letting friends hold the doll despite having dirty hands, or going down a slide too roughly. Later, after Thora gets Clarissa for her birthday, she's seen doing all the same activities D.W. did, but being more careful with her, like making sure someone's hands were clean before holding the doll or going down a slide more carefully. This is meant to drive home the point for D.W. how important Clarissa was to her grandmother, helping her [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realize]] she'd been taking her for granted.

to:

* CallBack: During a montage of D.W. spending time with Clarissa, we see all sorts of examples that she doesn't know how to properly care for a porcelain doll, such as letting friends hold the doll despite having dirty hands, or going down a slide too roughly. Later, after during the flashback to when Thora gets got Clarissa for her birthday, she's seen doing all the same activities D.W. did, but being more careful with her, like making sure someone's hands were clean before holding the doll or going down a slide more carefully. This is meant to drive home the point for D.W. how important Clarissa was to her grandmother, helping her [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realize]] she'd been taking her for granted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''D.W.''': Grandma kept Clarissa perfect her whole life, and I wrecked her! What am I going to do?

to:

--->'''D.-->'''D.W.''': Grandma kept Clarissa perfect her whole life, and I wrecked her! What am I going to do?



* NotSoDifferentRemark: When D.W. bemoans that she's not worthy of Clarissa the way her grandmother is, Thora comforts that even ''she'' accidentally broke Clarissa from time to time. If anything, she sees that D.W. is [[YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre just as capable]] of keeping Clarissa in good shape as she was when she was her granddaughter's age.

to:

* NotSoDifferentRemark: When D.W. bemoans that she's not worthy of Clarissa the way her grandmother is, Thora comforts her by saying that even ''she'' accidentally broke Clarissa from time to time. If anything, she sees that D.W. is [[YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre just as capable]] of keeping Clarissa in good shape as she was when she was her granddaughter's age.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: What Scared Sue Ellen?]]
Sue Ellen is established as having NervesOfSteel and isn't afraid of anything. But a mysterious sound in the woods frightens her, and she fears it may be a mythological creature.

!! Tropes for this episode include:

* ActuallyPrettyFunny: The kids laugh when they realize they were scared about a dog.
* AdultFear: It turns out Mrs. Wood's dog Perky was lost in the woods for days and trapped under a fallen tree. Mrs. Wood thanks the group for finding her dog and getting help.
* AscendedFridgeHorror: Mrs. Wood says she wouldn't know what to do if the kids hadn't gotten help because Perky could have been lost for weeks rather than days.
* BookEnds: The episode starts with Binky trying to tell a scary story, and failing because he could find only a book and not a hook. In the end, Sue Ellen tells a story about a two-headed wolfman, but Binky doing the JumpScare has a cowhead.
* ChekhovsGun: Sue Ellen packs a flashlight when suiting up to explore the scary noise in the woods. The flashlight reveals Perky trapped under a tree, and that she was making the noise while howling for help.
* DoingInTheWizard: Sue Ellen thinks some kind of monster is making a strange noise in the woods. It turns out that it was actually Perky, Mrs. Wood's dog, making the strange noise because she was trapped under a fallen tree, with her leg caught in a branch.
* DreamWithinADream: Sue Ellen has a nightmare of Baba Yaga chasing her through the woods. She then wakes up and Baba Yaga is outside her window, yelling at her to go to school. Sue Ellen wakes up for real and groaning.
* FauxHorrific: The kids run away when Mrs. Wood offers to kiss them as thanks for saving her dog.
* HeroicBystander: The kids run to get help offscreen when they realize Perky is trapped under a tree. Cue a cut to a maintenance man sawing away the branches and roots so Perky can get out safely, and Mrs. Wood thanks them for being so brave.
* {{Kappa}}: One of the creatures Sue Ellen suspects living in the creek. In an ImagineSpot, Buster tricks it into bowing its head by [[LookBehindYou pretending to spot a five-dollar bill]], a reference to the folklore that tricking a kappa into bowing will make it spill the water in its head and lose its power.
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Binky looks concerned when he sees that Sue Ellen, who usually has NervesOfSteel, is frightened of walking in the woods.
* ShoutOut: Binky is telling an urban legend about a hook-handed killer. Arthur says he read it as well; the story was collected in ''Literature/ScaryStoriesToTellInTheDark''.
* StatingTheSimpleSolution:
** When Sue Ellen talks about how you need to make a kappa bow its head, Buster imagines telling it LookOverThere.
** Binky's ImagineSpot shows him slamming a door in a banshee's face before it can haunt them.
* WrongGenreSavvy: Sue Ellen goes to her fairy tale books and travel folklore to decide what could have been in the woods. Her friends point out that it's unlikely that Baba Yaga would be able to walk through the woods without notice.


[[AC: Clarissa is Cracked]]
D.W. takes interest in one of Grandma Thora's old dolls, a beautiful china girl named Clarissa. D.W. breaks her by accident, and after her parents explain how important Clarissa is to Grandma Thora, D.W. scrambles to try and fix the doll before returning her.


!! Tropes for this episode

* ActuallyPrettyFunny: The kids at Ratburn's puppet show laugh when Rapunzel's head falls off.
* BrokenTreasure: The plot of the episode: D.W. borrows Grandma Thora's old doll Clarissa for a week, but is very rough with her and later breaks her by accident. However, D.W. doesn't fully understand the consequences of her actions until her parents explain to her how Grandma Thora got Clarissa in the first place and how much the doll means to her. Luckily, Mr. Ratburn is able to fix Clarissa thanks to his skills in making puppets.
* CallBack: During a montage of D.W. spending time with Clarissa, we see all sorts of examples that she doesn't know how to properly care for a porcelain doll, such as letting friends hold the doll despite having dirty hands, or going down a slide too roughly. Later, after Thora gets Clarissa for her birthday, she's seen doing all the same activities D.W. did, but being more careful with her, like making sure someone's hands were clean before holding the doll or going down a slide more carefully. This is meant to drive home the point for D.W. how important Clarissa was to her grandmother, helping her [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realize]] she'd been taking her for granted.
* ChekhovsGunman: Mr. Ratburn. Arthur remembers that Mr. Ratburn works with puppets, and he was earlier putting on a show at the library, and goes to ask if he can fix Clarissa. Mr. Ratburn does, at no charge.
* CoolBigBro: For what it's worth, Thora's three older brothers would give their old toys to her and refashion them into items more suitable for girls. She didn't appreciate it at the time but told her mother she wanted a toy of her own and didn't blame them.
* DeliberateValuesDissonance:
** Toys were a lot more fragile in those days, so most of Thora's toys were hand-me-downs from her brothers or handmade. She's given a brand new toy only when she turns a certain age, and it's impressed that she has to take good care of Clarissa.
** It's also noted that young Thora would often go to the toy store on her own with her parent's permission, which surprises D.W. that this was allowed when she was at such an early age--Mr. and Mrs. Read explain that Elwood City was a lot smaller back when Thora was a kid, so everyone was more familiar with one another rather than being total strangers (as shown when an elderly woman and a traffic cop help Thora cross the road, and both of them know her by name).
* DoubleStandard: Thora was given less toys, compared to her three older brothers, because she's younger, and a girl, and was expected to not take care of them. She does protest this, though her brothers try to help by fashioning new toys for her out of theirs or out of household objects.
* EasilyForgiven: Thora forgives D.W. when the latter confesses about what happened to Clarissa, since she appreciates that D.W. also got her fixed and it isn't the first time Clarissa has been broken.
* ExactWords: When Grandma Thora says she knows D.W. will treat Clarissa "like the treasure she is", D.W. takes that to mean she's supposed to put Clarissa on a higher pedestal than her other toys, not that she has to be careful with her.
* TheGreatDepression: The flashbacks to Thora's childhood are implied to take place during this period. The town was smaller and even more tight-knit, a girl Thora's age could walk around by herself, the boys had knee length shorts instead of pants with long socks, the men had bow ties, all the adults wore hats out, the women had bobbed or CompressedHair, the mention of how Thora's family didn't have a lot of money to get her toys, and a older woman and a traffic cop complain about [[FauxHorrific "the noise'']] caused by a zeppelin flying over town.
* {{Foil}}: While Thora and D.W. had a lot in common while they were the same age, they were shaped by their time periods. Thora was told that because she was a girl she was not expected to be careful with her things, so she painstakingly did what she could to make sure Clarissa stayed pristine. Even so, Thora as a grandmother says that there were times when Clarissa got broken and needed fixing. D.W. is a little more careless because she takes Clarissa for granted, and doesn't understand that she is fragile. She also has more toys in her room, because her parents were able to afford them, and they're more patient with her roughhousing.
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: While at first D.W. doesn't understand why breaking Clarissa is a big deal, she goes through this after her parents explain how much Clarissa meant to Thora. Realizing she's been far rougher with the doll compared to Thora, she agrees that Clarissa needs to be fixed.
--->'''D.W.''': Grandma kept Clarissa perfect her whole life, and I wrecked her! What am I going to do?
* NiceJobBreakingItHero: D.W. breaks Clarissa while pretending to be Rapunzel, and bouncing her bed.
* NotSoDifferentRemark: When D.W. bemoans that she's not worthy of Clarissa the way her grandmother is, Thora comforts that even ''she'' accidentally broke Clarissa from time to time. If anything, she sees that D.W. is [[YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre just as capable]] of keeping Clarissa in good shape as she was when she was her granddaughter's age.
* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: Clarissa manages to be fixed before D.W. has to give her back to Grandma Thora, but D.W. still feels guilty and confesses to Thora that she broke Clarissa. She expects Thora to be angry at her for not being more careful, but Thora takes it in stride, saying that Clarissa has been cracked more than once since she's had the doll for such a long time.
----

Top