Follow TV Tropes

Following

History PlayingWith / TenderTomboyishnessFoulFemininity

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sam [[TookALevelInKindness tries to be nicer]] because she don't want to be a rude tomboy, while Julie thinks [[BeingGoodSucks being nice isn't satisficed enough]] while [[EvilIsCool being mean brat is cooler]], so she [[TookALevelInJerkass becomes a jerk]].
** Julie starts [[WhosLaughingNow revenging against people who treats her like a shit]] [[RealWomenDontWearDresses due to her girliness.]] Meanwhile, Sam has no reason to revenge because she can get away from them and she has been already EasilyForgiven to everyone else.
** A [[HeManWomanHater misogynic]] [[ItMakesSenseInContext wizard]] who is a firm believer in RealWomenDontWearDresses casts a spell that will turn all [[GirlyGirl feminine women]] ranging from [[TomboyWithAGirlyStreak tomboys with girly streaks]] to full blown {{girly girl}}s into {{jerk|ass}}s[[note]][[CompleteMonster Or even worse]] if they’re [[ProperLady that]] feminine.[[/note]] so that people will think his cynical view on feminine women was right all along.[[note]](Doubles as {{Exploited|Trope}})[[/note]]

to:

** Sam [[TookALevelInKindness tries to be nicer]] because she don't doesn't want to be a rude tomboy, while Julie thinks [[BeingGoodSucks being nice isn't satisficed satisficactory enough]] while [[EvilIsCool being a mean brat is cooler]], so she [[TookALevelInJerkass becomes a jerk]].
** Julie starts [[WhosLaughingNow revenging taking revenge against people who treats treated her like a shit]] badly]] [[RealWomenDontWearDresses due to her girliness.]] Meanwhile, Sam has no reason to take revenge because she can get away from them and she has been already EasilyForgiven to by everyone else.
** A [[HeManWomanHater misogynic]] misogynistic]] [[ItMakesSenseInContext wizard]] who is a firm believer in RealWomenDontWearDresses casts a spell that will turn all [[GirlyGirl all feminine women]] women ranging from [[TomboyWithAGirlyStreak tomboys with girly streaks]] to full blown {{girly girl}}s into {{jerk|ass}}s[[note]][[CompleteMonster Or even worse]] if they’re [[ProperLady that]] feminine.[[/note]] so that people will think his cynical view on feminine women was right all along.[[note]](Doubles as {{Exploited|Trope}})[[/note]]

Added: 456

Changed: 203

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Played For Drama''': Julie bullies and harasses Sam for not being feminine and pretty enough, causing Sam to hate her masculine behaviors and activities, and even begins to [[DrivenToSuicide contemplate suicide]] due to it.

to:

* '''Played For Drama''': Drama''':
**
Julie bullies and harasses Sam for not being feminine and pretty enough, causing Sam to hate her masculine behaviors and activities, and even begins to [[DrivenToSuicide contemplate suicide]] due to it.it.
** A HenpeckedHusband version of MasculineFeminineGayCouple; [[ButchLesbian Sam]] always caves to [[LipstickLesbian Julie]]'s decisions, even if she doesn't really agree with her. Sam never stands for herself even if Julie [[DomesticAbuse abuse her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Both can be qualified as [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold jerks with hearts of gold]], it's just that Sam leans more on the Heart of Gold part while Julie leans more on the Jerk part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sam is a well-mannered [[SensitiveGuy sensitive]] NiceGuy and enjoys cooking and sewing while Julius is an aggressive [[TheBully big bully]] JerkJock.

to:

** Sam is a well-mannered [[SensitiveGuy [[InTouchWithHisFeminineSide sensitive]] NiceGuy and enjoys cooking and sewing while Julius is an aggressive [[TheBully big bully]] JerkJock.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* '''Played for Horror''': Sam is [[TheHero the cop]] in a horror movie who is hired to take down [[NothingNiceAboutSugarAndSpice Julie]], a FauxAffablyEvil SerialKiller who [[{{Sadist}} enjoys]] indulging in ColdBloodedTorture and/or {{Cruel and Unusual Death}}s.

Added: 163

Changed: 801

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** All GirlyGirl characters [[AlwaysChaoticEvil are portrayed as]] {{Complete Monster}}s while all {{tomboy}}ish [[TheLadette ones]] [[AlwaysLawfulGood are portrayed as]] [[IncorruptiblePurePureness obstinately good.]]

to:

** All GirlyGirl characters [[AlwaysChaoticEvil are portrayed as]] {{Complete Monster}}s {{jerk|ass}}s while all {{tomboy}}ish [[TheLadette ones]] [[AlwaysLawfulGood are portrayed as]] [[IncorruptiblePurePureness obstinately good.]][[NiceGirl polite]].



** “Finally! A TomboyAndGirlyGirl pairing where the {{tomboy}} is the nice one, while the {{girly girl}} is the mean one, instead of [[InvertedTrope vice versa]]!”



** This starts an {{Unfortunate|Implications}} stereotype about girly girls. If being girly is mean and being boyish is nice according to the way Sam and Julie behave, then people will [[RealWomenDontWearDresses shun women for being feminine.]]

to:

** This starts an {{Unfortunate|Implications}} stereotype about girly girls. If Julie is so mean to the point where people ''can’t even tolerate girls being traditionally feminine'' without the thought of Julie’s cruelty coming to their minds. [[FromBadToWorse To make matters even worse]], Sam being a NiceGirl leads to the people who hate Julie’s guts thinking that [[InsaneTrollLogic being girly is mean and being boyish is nice nice]] according to the way Sam and Julie behave, then people will behaves. This leads to a ''[[UnfortunateImplications horrible]]'' [[AlwaysChaoticEvil stereotype]] about {{girly girl}}s, and a [[RealWomenDontWearDresses shun women for being feminine.]]shunning of feminine women]] that could have been avoided if Julie wasn’t such a {{jerkass}}.



*** Alternately, the CharacterDevelopment causes Julie to become a JerkWithAHeartOfGold and shows everyone that GoodIsNotNice.

to:

*** Alternately, the CharacterDevelopment causes Julie to become a has her JerkassRealization [[EveryoneHasStandards by the sheer thought of something like this happening]] if she continues her abrasive behavior. So she [[CharacterDevelopment becomes a]] JerkWithAHeartOfGold and shows everyone that GoodIsNotNice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ClassPrincess {{Fashionista}} Julie is an AllLovingHeroine, while Sam is a StrawFeminist {{Psycho|Lesbian}} ButchLesbian.

to:

** ClassPrincess {{Fashionista}} Julie is an AllLovingHeroine, while TheLadette Sam is a StrawFeminist {{Psycho|Lesbian}} ButchLesbian.StrawFeminist.

Added: 269

Changed: 359

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Inverted''': Sam is a {{Tomboy}} and the aggressive, {{Hotblooded}} bully who [[DoubleStandardAbuseFemaleOnMale likes to physically attack guys]] while Julie is the [[TheCutie sweet-hearted]] EnglishRose {{fashionista}}.

to:

* '''Inverted''': '''Inverted''':
**
Sam is a {{Tomboy}} and the aggressive, {{Hotblooded}} bully who [[DoubleStandardAbuseFemaleOnMale likes to physically attack guys]] BarbaricBully, while Julie is the [[TheCutie sweet-hearted]] EnglishRose {{fashionista}}.sweet-hearted, mild-mannered]] ProperLady.
** ClassPrincess {{Fashionista}} Julie is an AllLovingHeroine, while Sam is a StrawFeminist {{Psycho|Lesbian}} ButchLesbian.



*** As mean as Julie was, she was never outright sexist. [[HeWhoFightsMonsters As a result, the femininity shaming mob has officially grown worse than Julie,]] or they are already the HateSink characters at first.

to:

*** As mean as Julie was, she was never outright sexist. sexist, while the femininity shaming mob are already the HateSink characters. [[HeWhoFightsMonsters As a result, the femininity shaming mob has they have officially grown worse than Julie,]] or they are already the HateSink characters at first.Julie.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sam and Julie have similar fashion senses and they even share some interests, but Sam is an energetic [[NoIndoorVoice loud]] PassionateSportsGirl who gets along with the boys better than [[BuxomBeautyStandard Buxom]] HeadTurningBeauty Julie, [[GossipyHens who likes gossips]] and looks down with anyone but the GirlPosse and her MrFanservice boyfriend.

to:

** Sam and Julie have similar fashion senses and they even share some interests, but PetitePride Sam is an energetic [[NoIndoorVoice loud]] PassionateSportsGirl who gets along with the boys better than [[BuxomBeautyStandard Buxom]] HeadTurningBeauty Julie, [[GossipyHens who likes gossips]] and looks down with anyone but the GirlPosse and her MrFanservice boyfriend.



** Both of them are Villainesses but Sam is a boyish AffablyEvil while Julie is a girly JerkWithAHeartOfJerk.

to:

** Both of them are Villainesses but Sam is a boyish AffablyEvil while Julie is a girly JerkWithAHeartOfJerk.CompleteMonster.



** Alternatively: The author was bullied by an AlphaBitch and/or have negative experiences with any [[GirlyGirl feminine women]] and can't get over it. [[AuthorTract So they portrays a tomboyish character as nice and a girly character as a jerk in order]].

to:

** Alternatively: The author was bullied by an AlphaBitch and/or have negative experiences with any [[GirlyGirl feminine women]] [[NothingNiceAboutSugarAndSpice feminine]] [[EvilMatriarch mot]][[MommyIssues her]] or [[PsychoExGirlfriend girlfriend]] and can't get over it. [[AuthorTract So they portrays a tomboyish character as nice and a girly character as a jerk in order]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** All GirlyGirl characters [[AlwaysChaoticEvil are portrayed as]] [[CompleteMonster Complete Monsters]] while all {{tomboy}}[[TheLadette ish ones]] [[AlwaysLawfulGood are portrayed as]] [[IncorruptiblePurePureness obstinately good.]]

to:

** All GirlyGirl characters [[AlwaysChaoticEvil are portrayed as]] [[CompleteMonster Complete Monsters]] {{Complete Monster}}s while all {{tomboy}}[[TheLadette ish {{tomboy}}ish [[TheLadette ones]] [[AlwaysLawfulGood are portrayed as]] [[IncorruptiblePurePureness obstinately good.]]



** The show has plenty of TomboyAndGirlyGirl characters of various levels of morality and common sense favoring neither of them, even if Sam and Julie in isolation would seem to be playing it straight. So people are able to distinguish gender expression from morality. Plus none of the characters are stupid enough to think all girly girls are as mean as Julie.

to:

** The None of the characters are stupid enough to think all girly girls are as mean as Julie. Plus the show has plenty of TomboyAndGirlyGirl characters of various levels of morality and common sense favoring neither of them, even if Sam and Julie in isolation would seem to be playing it straight. So people are able to distinguish gender expression from morality. Plus none of the characters are stupid enough to think all girly girls are as mean as Julie.



*** As mean as Julie was, she was never outright sexist. [[HeWhoFightsMonsters As a result, the femininity shaming mob has officially grown worse than Julie.]]

to:

*** As mean as Julie was, she was never outright sexist. [[HeWhoFightsMonsters As a result, the femininity shaming mob has officially grown worse than Julie.]]Julie,]] or they are already the HateSink characters at first.

Changed: 349

Removed: 91

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively: [[HeManWomanHater The author]] has a [[RealWomenDontWearDresses negative view]] on [[GirlyGirl feminine women]] as a whole [[AuthorTract so he portrays Sam, a tomboyish character as nice and Julie, a feminine character as a jerk in order to preach his prejudiced beliefs]].

to:

** Alternatively: [[HeManWomanHater The author]] has a [[RealWomenDontWearDresses author was bullied by an AlphaBitch and/or have negative view]] on experiences with any [[GirlyGirl feminine women]] as a whole and can't get over it. [[AuthorTract so he So they portrays Sam, a tomboyish character as nice and Julie, a feminine girly character as a jerk in order to preach his prejudiced beliefs]].order]].



** Sam and Julie are in an ImprobablyFemaleCast that features TomboyAndGirlyGirl of various levels of morality and common sense favoring neither of them, even if Sam and Julie in isolation would seem to be playing it straight. So people are able to distinguish gender expression from morality.

to:

** Sam and Julie are in an ImprobablyFemaleCast that features The show has plenty of TomboyAndGirlyGirl characters of various levels of morality and common sense favoring neither of them, even if Sam and Julie in isolation would seem to be playing it straight. So people are able to distinguish gender expression from morality. Plus none of the characters are stupid enough to think all girly girls are as mean as Julie.



*** None of the characters are stupid enough to think all girly girls are as mean as Julie.

Added: 1035

Changed: 223

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Enforced''': The author notices how tomboys are typically portrayed as rude, mean and aggressive while girly girls are nice, gentle, and passive, and this gave him an idea to create two new female characters with inverted personalities.

to:

* '''Enforced''': '''Enforced''':
**
The author notices how tomboys are typically portrayed as rude, mean and aggressive while girly girls are nice, gentle, and passive, and this gave him an idea to create two new female characters with inverted personalities.personalities.
** Alternatively: [[HeManWomanHater The author]] has a [[RealWomenDontWearDresses negative view]] on [[GirlyGirl feminine women]] as a whole [[AuthorTract so he portrays Sam, a tomboyish character as nice and Julie, a feminine character as a jerk in order to preach his prejudiced beliefs]].


Added DiffLines:

** A [[HeManWomanHater misogynic]] [[ItMakesSenseInContext wizard]] who is a firm believer in RealWomenDontWearDresses casts a spell that will turn all [[GirlyGirl feminine women]] ranging from [[TomboyWithAGirlyStreak tomboys with girly streaks]] to full blown {{girly girl}}s into {{jerk|ass}}s[[note]][[CompleteMonster Or even worse]] if they’re [[ProperLady that]] feminine.[[/note]] so that people will think his cynical view on feminine women was right all along.[[note]](Doubles as {{Exploited|Trope}})[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It turns out Julie was a completely nice gal who just held the {{jerkass ball}} while [[KindnessBall the same goes for]] [[{{Bitch}} Sam]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Neither Sam nor Julie is seen as particularly nice or mean.

to:

** [[GreyAndGrayMorality Neither Sam nor Julie is seen as particularly nice or mean.mean]].

Top