History NightmareFuel / TheCoffinOfAndyAndLeyley

** Ashley holds her mother at gunpoint with an empty gun as she is trying to be kind to Andrew and draws her to the basement where she ties her up and orders Andrew to get the rope for her, at which he accidentally wakes up his father too and baits him to the basement where Ashley ties him up as well. After getting their parent's money, the Graves sibling who went to take the money comes back as Ashley summons the Entity to steal their souls and leaves them catatonic. When the siblings find their parents still alive after sacrificing their souls, Ashley personally ''kills them''. What makes this really awful is their parent's reactions; they're obviously feared of dying, are pleading for mercy and even tried to reason with Andrew to no avail. While it's implied that they're abusive degenerates who are willing to sell their children to have their organs harvested over an insurance scam, their attitude before their deaths makes it seem like they don't mind if they escaped and if you don't view Mrs. Grave's apology as a last-ditch manipulation tactic, they might still have a shred of humanity in them. Ashley on the other hand, only killed them for more money and demonic clairvoyance, with revenge being a secondary factor, making it clear that ''this girl is a vile monster''. The parents are no saints, but they do ''not'' deserve this. It doesn't help that in the Decay Route where Andrew may still have some semblances of a conscience left, he was utterly disgusted by this horrible act that he "only" helped set up.

* Ashley's vision in the Decay Route has...something constantly chasing her with ominous background music and loud thumps playing in the background. It turns out to be Andrew, who is now fed up of her antics and is going to kill her by chopping her head with a meat cleaver. Depending on situation, he either kills her, she kills him, or they perform a mutual suicide together. This vision alone is enough to ''terrify'' [[HorrifyingTheHorror this otherwise cheerful and sarcastic serial killer who has no remorse accidentally killing off people, cannibalizing her victims and summoning demons to steal their souls]], and the risk of Andrew actually going through his threats in the real world becomes increasingly real after that.
* After the vision in the Decay Route, Andrew becomes outright hostile. When Ashley goes dispose her parent's bones with him, he almost looks like he wants to murder Ashley as brutally as possible and really looks no different from the AxCrazy lunatic before him bar the snark. Things are not looking good between them in the future.
* The {{Cliffhanger}} of the Burial Route has a "mole" showing up on Andrew's palm right before they're going to leave the bridge. Aside that is no mole, and quickly turns into an eye-shaped demonic sigil. Whatever this is, it is likely not pleasant.

* While Andrew is ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is just as disturbing, if not ''far'' more than his flat-out depraved sister. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space from choosing between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or letting her shame him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, while Ashley is LaughablyEvil at ''best'' (and that's saying a lot), Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is almost always played '''dead seriously''', and even the few darkly humorous moments coming from him are signs of how more and more desensitized and apathetic he becomes to the vile crimes they commit.

* While Andrew is ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is just as disturbing, if not ''far'' more. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space from choosing between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or letting her shame him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, while Ashley is LaughablyEvil at ''best'' (and that's saying a lot), Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is almost always played '''dead seriously''', and even the few darkly humorous moments coming from him are signs of how more and more desensitized and apathetic he becomes to the vile crimes they commit.

* '''Andrew Graves''', or at least in his point of view and utterly damaged psychology, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space from choosing between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or letting her shame him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, while Ashley is LaughablyEvil at ''best'' (and that's saying a lot), Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is almost always played '''dead seriously''', and even the few darkly humorous moments coming from him are signs of how more and more desensitized and apathetic he becomes to the vile crimes they commit.

* '''Andrew Graves''', or at least in his point of view and utterly damaged psychology, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space from choosing between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or letting her shame him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, while Ashley is LaughablyEvil at ''best'' (and that's saying a lot), Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is always played '''dead seriously''' and even the few darkly humorous moments coming from him are signs of how more and more desensitized and apathetic he becomes to the vile crimes they commit.

* '''Andrew Graves''', or at least in his point of view and utterly damaged psychology, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space from choosing between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or letting her shame him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, while Ashley is LaughablyEvil at ''best'', Andrew is almost always played '''dead seriously''' and whatever "dark humor" coming from him is a sign of how more and more desensitized and apathetic he becomes to the vile crimes they commit.

* '''Andrew Graves''', or at least in his point of view and utterly damaged psychology, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space from choosing between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or letting her shame him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments (unless she's at the middle of manipulating Andrew or getting someone killed, though even then she mixes in some BlackComedy). On the other hand, Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight. Andrew ''is'' also a DeadpanSnarker but unlike Ashley's dark snark, which is LaughablyEvil, Andrew's sarcasm is both blatantly a coping mechanism as well as a sign of how more and more desensitized and apathetic he becomes to the vile crimes they commit.

* Andrew Graves, or at least in his point of view and utterly damaged psychology, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space from choosing between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or letting her shame him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments (unless she's at the middle of manipulating Andrew or getting someone killed, though even then she mixes in some BlackComedy). On the other hand, Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight. Andrew ''is'' also a DeadpanSnarker but unlike Ashley's dark snark, which is LaughablyEvil, Andrew's sarcasm is both blatantly a coping mechanism as well as a sign of how more and more desensitized and apathetic he becomes to the vile crimes they commit.

* Andrew Graves, or at least in his point of view and utterly damaged psychology, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is the ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space from choosing between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or letting her shame him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments (unless she's at the middle of manipulating Andrew or getting someone killed). On the other hand, Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight.

** The demon she summons and makes a pact with calls her "Tar Soul". She's also the only one person within the story said demon has taken a liking to, as the cultist who summoned it first got his soul stolen quick and none of the others are evil enough to even think of sacrificing a live person to successfully summon one. Even an incomprehensible abomination recognizes this woman as pure evil.

* Andrew Graves, or at least in his point of view and utterly damaged psychology, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is the ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or she shames him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments (unless she's at the middle of manipulating Andrew or getting someone killed). On the other hand, Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight.

* Andrew Graves, or at least in his point of view and utterly damaged psychology, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is the ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the far more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or she shames him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments (unless she's at the middle of manipulating Andrew or getting someone killed). On the other hand, Andrew's ever growing apathy and progression from a victim to becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight.

* Andrew Graves, or at least in his point of view, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is the ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the far more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with ever-increasingly less wriggling space between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or she shames him for killing his childhood friend publicly in front of everyone he knew, and the dire situation has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it and pick a third option at all. Also, as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments (unless she's at the middle of manipulating Andrew or getting someone killed). On the other hand, Andrew's growing apathy and progression from a victim becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight.

* Andrew Graves, or at least in his point of view, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is the ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the far more disturbing thing to witness. The worst of all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with less wriggling space between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or his sister shaming him as his childhood friend's murderer publicly in front of everyone he knew and getting him sent to prison or death row with her, and has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it at all. Also, as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments (unless she's at the middle of manipulating Andrew or getting someone killed). On the other hand, Andrew's growing apathy and progression from a victim becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight.

* Andrew Graves, or at least in his point of view, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he is the ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the far more disturbing thing to witness. This is mainly because amongst all of this is not in ''our'' viewpoint, but rather ''his'' viewpoint where he finds himself stuck with less wriggling space between becoming just as unhinged as his sister and handler or his sister shaming him as his childhood friend's murderer publicly in front of everyone he knew and getting him sent to prison or death row with her, and has reached a breaking point where he can't do anything to get out from it at all. Also, as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments (unless she's at the middle of manipulating Andrew or getting someone killed). On the other hand, Andrew's growing apathy and progression from a victim becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight.

* Andrew Graves, or at least his point of view, is Nightmare Fuel in his own right. While he ''is'' the ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing thing to witness. This is mainly because as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments while doing her evil deeds. Andrew's growing apathy and progression from a victim becoming as much a sociopath as Ashley is played '''dead''' straight.

* Andrew Graves is nightmare fuel in his own right. While he ''is'' the ALighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing character. This is mainly because as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments while doing her evil deeds. Andrew's growing apathy meanwhile is played '''dead''' straight.

* Andrew Graves is nightmare fuel in his own right. While he ''is'' the LighterShadeOfBlack compared to his deranged sister due to being a lot more sympathetic, remorseful, and ultimately a victim of Ashley's manipulation, his SanitySlippage and path to apathy in the face of it all is arguably the ''far'' more disturbing character. This is mainly because as evil as Ashley is, she has plenty of comedic moments and comments while doing her evil deeds. Andrew's growing apathy meanwhile is played '''dead''' straight.

* After coming back downstairs and finding Andrew killed the woman living below them, Ashley finally pushes Andrew too far and he starts to throttle her, to the point when she starts to believe that he'd actually go through with killing her before he finally relents.

** Her childhood self really isn't any better, and one could say she's in fact worse back then. At least her current self mostly killed people who actually try to kill her; her childhood self, on the other hand, will attempt to get rid of any girl who tried to be nice to Andy. Her mother also apparently neglected her because she was a natural-born sociopath. There was one time where she accidentally killed Andy's childhood friend as a prank by trapping her in a dust-filled box, and because she had asthma she died because of it. This would be still okay if Leyley at least tried to act remorseful over it, but nope, she was completely content with leaving her corpse in the box she locked her in if not for Andy telling her to do a cover-up and takes full advantage of it to blackmail Andy into obeying her orders or she will out him as his childhood friend's killer. It's very clear she's ''proud'' of what she ended up doing and merely sees it as getting rid of someone who got in the way of her big brother obsession.
*** When you go check Julia's dormitory in Andrew's dream sequence, you can check the trash can and the phone hung on the wall. The former contains crumpled death threat letters implied to be sent by Ashley to Julia when she was a bit younger. The latter has 127 voicemails, all of them being death threats sent to her. It's heavily implied that not only Ashley drove the poor girl into slitting her own wrists, she also drove her to a failed suicide attempt all for the sake of keeping Andrew for herself.

*** When you go check Julia's dormitory in Andrew's dream sequence, you can check the trash can and the phone hung on the wall. The former contains crumpled death threat letters implied to be sent by Ashley to Julia when she was a bit younger. The latter has 127 voicemails, all of them being death threats sent to her. It's heavily implied that not only Ashley drove the poor girl into slitting her own wrists, she also drove her to a failed suicide attempt all for the sake of keeping Andrew as her own possession.

** Ashley holds her mother at gunpoint with an empty gun as she is trying to be kind to Andrew and draws her to the basement where she ties her up and orders Andrew to get the rope for her, at which he accidentally wakes up his father too and baits him to the basement where Ashley ties him up as well. After getting their parent's money, the Graves sibling who went to take the money comes back as Ashley summons the Entity to steal their souls and leaves them catatonic. When the siblings find their parents still alive after sacrificing their souls, Ashley personally ''kills them''. What makes this really awful is their parent's reactions; they're obviously feared of dying, are pleading for mercy and even tried to reason with Andrew to no avail. While it's implied that they're abusive degenerates who are willing to sell their children to have their organs harvested over an insurance scam, their attitude before their deaths makes it seem like they don't mind if they escaped and if you don't view Mrs. Grave's apology as a last-ditch manipulation tactic, they might still have a shred of humanity in them. Ashley on the other hand, only killed them for more money and demonic clairvoyance, with revenge being a secondary factor, making it clear that ''this girl is a vile monster''. The parents are no saints, but they do ''not'' deserve this. It tells that in the Decay Route where Andrew still had a shred of his humanity left, he was utterly disgusted by this horrible act that he "only" helped set up.

** Ashley holds her mother at gunpoint with an empty gun as she is trying to be kind to Andrew and draws her to the basement where she ties her up and orders Andrew to get the rope for her, at which he accidentally wakes up his father too and baits him to the basement where Ashley ties him up as well. After getting their parent's money, the Graves sibling who went to take the money comes back as Ashley summons the Entity to steal their souls and leaves them catatonic. When the siblings find their parents still alive after sacrificing their souls, Ashley personally ''kills them''. What makes this really awful is their parent's reactions; they're obviously feared of dying, are pleading for mercy and even tried to reason with Andrew to no avail. While it's implied that they're abusive degenerates who are willing to sell their children to have their organs harvested over an insurance scam, their attitude before their deaths makes it seem like they don't mind if they escaped and if you don't view Mrs. Grave's apology as a last-ditch manipulation tactic, they might still have a shred of humanity in them. Ashley on the other hand, only killed them for more money and demonic clairvoyance, with revenge being a secondary factor, making it clear that ''this girl is a vile monster''. In the Decay Route where Andrew still had a shred of his humanity left, he was utterly disgusted by this horrible act that he "only" helped set up for a good reason.

** Ashley holds her mother at gunpoint with an empty gun as she is trying to be kind to Andrew and draws her to the basement where she ties her up and orders Andrew to get the rope for her, at which he accidentally wakes up his father too and baits him to the basement where Ashley ties him up as well. After getting their parent's money, the Graves sibling who went to take the money comes back as Ashley summons the Entity to steal their souls and leaves them catatonic. When the siblings find their parents still alive after sacrificing their souls, Ashley personally ''kills them''. What makes this really awful is their parent's reactions; they're obviously feared of dying, are pleading for mercy and even tried to reason with Andrew to no avail. While it's implied that they're abusive degenerates who are willing to sell their children to have their organs harvested over an insurance scam, their attitude before their deaths makes it seem like they don't mind if they escaped and if you don't view Mrs. Grave's apology as a last-ditch manipulation tactic, they might still have a shred of humanity in them. Ashley on the other hand, only killed them for more money and demonic clairvoyance, with revenge being a secondary factor, making it clear that ''this girl is a vile monster''. It tells when in the Decay Route where Andrew still had a shred of his humanity left, Andrew was utterly disgusted by this horrible act that he "only" helped set up.