Follow TV Tropes

Following

History MoralEventHorizon / WilliamShakespeare

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For many viewers, Claudio can come pretty close to the MEH for publicly and loudly shaming Hero. Although he has been cruelly manipulated by Don John and Borachio into thinking she was sleeping around on the night before the wedding, there is no way he would have been unaware of the consequences of calling her out in public - rather than, for instance, quietly breaking things off with her. Don Pedro also, as he takes part, knowing full well what an utter [[ManipulativeBastard]] his brother is (the bastard part literally).

to:

** For many viewers, Claudio can come pretty close to the MEH for publicly and loudly shaming Hero. Although he has been cruelly manipulated by Don John and Borachio into thinking she was sleeping around on the night before the wedding, there is no way he would have been unaware of the consequences of calling her out in public - rather than, for instance, quietly breaking things off with her. Don Pedro also, as he takes part, knowing full well what an utter [[ManipulativeBastard]] utterly Manipulative Bastard his brother is (the bastard part literally).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For many viewers, Claudio can come pretty close to the MEH for publicly and loudly shaming Hero. Although he has been cruelly manipulated by Don John and Borachio into thinking she was sleeping around on the night before the wedding, there is no way he would have been unaware of the consequences of calling her out in public - rather than, for instance, quietly breaking things off with her.

to:

** For many viewers, Claudio can come pretty close to the MEH for publicly and loudly shaming Hero. Although he has been cruelly manipulated by Don John and Borachio into thinking she was sleeping around on the night before the wedding, there is no way he would have been unaware of the consequences of calling her out in public - rather than, for instance, quietly breaking things off with her. Don Pedro also, as he takes part, knowing full well what an utter [[ManipulativeBastard]] his brother is (the bastard part literally).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

----

Added: 273

Removed: 273

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Angelo of ''Theatre/MeasureForMeasure'' crosses when he coerces Isabella into sleeping with him [[ScarpiaUltimatum under the promise of saving Claudio]], then goes back on his word and orders Claudio's execution anyway. Thank goodness this didn't go quite as he planned.



* Angelo of ''Theatre/MeasureForMeasure'' crosses when he coerces Isabella into sleeping with him [[ScarpiaUltimatum under the promise of saving Claudio]], then goes back on his word and orders Claudio's execution anyway. Thank goodness this didn't go quite as he planned.

Added: 974

Changed: 391

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[DependingOnTheWriter Depending on the production]], Tybalt from ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' may cross the line by stabbing Mercutio under Romeo's arm. Some adaptations avert this, such as the Zeffirelli version, in which Tybalt is characterized as a jovial troublemaker who duels with Mercutio all in good fun and kills him [[AccidentalMurder by mistake]], after which he is [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone visibly horrified]].

to:

* ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'':
**
[[DependingOnTheWriter Depending on the production]], Tybalt from ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' may cross the line by stabbing Mercutio under Romeo's arm. Some adaptations avert this, such as the Zeffirelli version, in which Tybalt is characterized as a jovial troublemaker who duels with Mercutio all in good fun and kills him [[AccidentalMurder by mistake]], after which he is [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone visibly horrified]].horrified]].
** Lord Capulet arguably crosses it when he forces Juliet to marry Paris just to gain political power or favor. He'd been uncomfortable with how quickly Paris wanted the marriage at the start of the play, but he basically orders his thirteen-year-old child to suck it up and do it. In the Zeffirelli version he screams abuse at her, and manhandles her at one point. From this point on, Juliet feels her only other option is death, until Friar Laurence convinces her otherwise. Lord Capulet - and indeed his wife too - made their child think death and running away were her only options.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If Tamora doesn't cross it then, she does by having Titus's sons Quintus and Martius falsely condemned to death, forcing Titus to cut his hand off to save them, then executing them anyway and sending Titus their severed heads.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** To some, Titus may have crossed it either by ordering Alarbus brutally executed in order to punish Tamora or by casually murdering Lavinia in order to preserve his family honour. InUniverse his [=MEH=] is considered to be when he kills his son Mutius in a fight.

Added: 81

Changed: 78

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Goneril and Regan possibly also cross at this point for fully supporting this action, if they haven't already with their treatment of their father. Plus, at this point, Regan stabs a servant in the back while he is duelling with her husband.

to:

** Goneril and Regan possibly also cross at this point for fully supporting this action, if they haven't already with their treatment of their father. Plus, at this point, Regan stabs a servant in the back InTheBack while he is duelling with her husband. husband and gives the order to cast Gloucester out into the wilderness to die.
-->'''Regan''': Go, thrust him out the gates, and let him smell/his way to Dover.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
...yeah, the Bolingbroke example isn't really one either. Neither Richard nor Bolingbroke is depicted as totally evil.


* Bolingbroke in ''Theatre/RichardII'' crosses by his deposition and humiliation of Richard, due to the fact that this ends up triggering a struggle for the crown that we now know as The Wars Of The Roses.

Changed: 229

Removed: 217

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed the first example from Richard II as it's not shown as something that makes him permanently, irredeemably evil. It ensures his deposition, but that's not the same thing. (The Bolingbroke example is actually debatable too.)


* ''Theatre/RichardII'' crosses by taking Gaunt's land and money away from Bolingbroke, the rightful heir to them, and Richard is explicitly warned that once he does it there's no going back. He doesn't care.
** For those who know what is to come, Bolingbroke crosses by his deposition and humiliation of Richard, due to the fact that this ends up triggering a struggle for the crown that we now know as The Wars Of The Roses.

to:

* Bolingbroke in ''Theatre/RichardII'' crosses by taking Gaunt's land and money away from Bolingbroke, the rightful heir to them, and Richard is explicitly warned that once he does it there's no going back. He doesn't care.
** For those who know what is to come, Bolingbroke
crosses by his deposition and humiliation of Richard, due to the fact that this ends up triggering a struggle for the crown that we now know as The Wars Of The Roses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[DependingOnTheWriterDepending on the production]], Tybalt from ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' may cross the line by stabbing Mercutio under Romeo's arm. Some adaptations avert this, such as the Zeffirelli version, in which Tybalt is characterized as a jovial troublemaker who duels with Mercutio all in good fun and kills him [[AccidentalMurder by mistake]], after which he is [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone visibly horrified]].

to:

* [[DependingOnTheWriterDepending [[DependingOnTheWriter Depending on the production]], Tybalt from ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' may cross the line by stabbing Mercutio under Romeo's arm. Some adaptations avert this, such as the Zeffirelli version, in which Tybalt is characterized as a jovial troublemaker who duels with Mercutio all in good fun and kills him [[AccidentalMurder by mistake]], after which he is [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone visibly horrified]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Depending on the production, Tybalt from ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' may cross the line by stabbing Mercutio under Romeo's arm. Some adaptations avert this, such as the Zeffirelli version, in which Tybalt is characterized as a jovial troublemaker who duels with Mercutio all in good fun and kills him [[AccidentalMurder by mistake]], after which he is [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone visibly horrified]].

to:

* Depending [[DependingOnTheWriterDepending on the production, production]], Tybalt from ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' may cross the line by stabbing Mercutio under Romeo's arm. Some adaptations avert this, such as the Zeffirelli version, in which Tybalt is characterized as a jovial troublemaker who duels with Mercutio all in good fun and kills him [[AccidentalMurder by mistake]], after which he is [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone visibly horrified]].



* In the last scene of ''Theatre/TwoGentlemenOfVerona'', Proteus tries to rape Silvia (before being talked down by Valentine) and his being [[EasilyForgiven rather suddenly forgiven by both Valentine and Julia]] does not ring true for many modern viewers.

to:

* In the last scene of ''Theatre/TwoGentlemenOfVerona'', Proteus tries to rape Silvia (before being talked down by Valentine) and his being [[EasilyForgiven rather suddenly forgiven by both Valentine and Julia]] does not ring true [[ValuesDissonance for many modern viewers.viewers]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Theatre/HenryV'', we are expected to root for the English over the French, despite the fact that the English have a very flimsy justification for going to war and the play admits this. So to make sure the audience knows the French are nasty customers, Shakespeare has the French soldiers, [[SoreLoser when they realize they're going to lose]], massacre the teenage boys who carry the english army's supplies, one of the highest war crimes possible in those days.

to:

* In ''Theatre/HenryV'', we are expected to root for the English over the French, despite the fact that the English have a very flimsy justification for going to war and the play admits this. So to make sure the audience knows the French are nasty customers, Shakespeare has the French soldiers, [[SoreLoser when they realize they're going to lose]], massacre the teenage boys who carry the english English army's supplies, one of the highest war crimes possible in those days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For many viewers, Claudio can come pretty close to the MEH for publicly and loudly shaming Hero. Although he has been cruelly manipulated by Don John and Borachio into thinking she was sleeping around on the night before the wedding, there is no way he would have been unaware of the consequences of calling her out loudly and publicly - rather than, for instance, quietly breaking things off with her.

to:

** For many viewers, Claudio can come pretty close to the MEH for publicly and loudly shaming Hero. Although he has been cruelly manipulated by Don John and Borachio into thinking she was sleeping around on the night before the wedding, there is no way he would have been unaware of the consequences of calling her out loudly and publicly in public - rather than, for instance, quietly breaking things off with her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Lady Macbeth crosses the line by manipulating Macbeth into the murder of Duncan, triggering his StartOfDarkness.

to:

* ** Lady Macbeth crosses the line by manipulating Macbeth into the murder of Duncan, triggering his StartOfDarkness.

Added: 246

Changed: 321

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Theatre/{{Macbeth}}'' reaches this point when [[spoiler:he has Macduff's family, including the kids, murdered,]] if he hadn't already done so with the murders of Duncan and Banquo (less likely with the former, as he was essentially manipulated into it by Lady Macbeth, who herself crosses it in doing so, as the act was his StartOfDarkness).

to:

* ''Theatre/{{Macbeth}}'' reaches this point when [[spoiler:he has ''Theatre/{{Macbeth}}'':
* Lady Macbeth crosses the line by manipulating Macbeth into the murder of Duncan, triggering his StartOfDarkness.
** Macbeth himself crosses either by setting killers on Banquo and young Fleance, or by having
Macduff's family, including the kids, murdered,]] if he hadn't already done so with the murders of Duncan wife and Banquo (less likely with the former, as he was essentially manipulated into it by Lady Macbeth, who herself crosses it in doing so, as the act was his StartOfDarkness).children murdered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Theatre/{{Macbeth}}'' reaches this point when [[spoiler:he has Macduff's family, including the kids, murdered,]] if he hadn't already done so with the murders of Duncan and Banquo.

to:

* ''Theatre/{{Macbeth}}'' reaches this point when [[spoiler:he has Macduff's family, including the kids, murdered,]] if he hadn't already done so with the murders of Duncan and Banquo.Banquo (less likely with the former, as he was essentially manipulated into it by Lady Macbeth, who herself crosses it in doing so, as the act was his StartOfDarkness).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Antiochus, who is engaged in an incestuous relationship with his daughter, falsely offering her to any man who cracks a riddle, then killing them regardless of whether or not they can do so.

to:

** Antiochus, who is engaged in an incestuous relationship with his daughter, falsely offering her hand to any man who cracks can guess the answer to a riddle, then killing them all men who try, regardless of whether or not they can do so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Theatre/PericlesPrinceOfTyre'':
** Antiochus, who is engaged in an incestuous relationship with his daughter, falsely offering her to any man who cracks a riddle, then killing them regardless of whether or not they can do so.
** Dionyza repaying Pericles' generous salvation of her and her husband during a famine by plotting to murder his daughter Marina out of jealousy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Quite a few Shakespearian characters cross the MoralEventHorizon, although in some cases this may vary from production to production according to AlternativeCharacterInterpretation.

* In ''Theatre/{{Cymbeline}}'', the previously LaughablyEvil HarmlessVillain Cloten crosses it when he plans to kill Posthumus and rape Imogen on top of his corpse. A good thing he is killed by Guiderius before he can do so.
* Claudius from ''Theatre/{{Hamlet}}'' crossed this line before the beginning of the story by murdering his brother in his sleep.
* In ''Theatre/HenryV'', we are expected to root for the English over the French, despite the fact that the English have a very flimsy justification for going to war and the play admits this. So to make sure the audience knows the French are nasty customers, Shakespeare has the French soldiers, [[SoreLoser when they realize they're going to lose]], massacre the teenage boys who carry the english army's supplies, one of the highest war crimes possible in those days.
* In ''Theatre/HenryVIPart3'', Queen Margaret taunts a captive York about the murder of his young son, and offers him a cloth ''stained with the son's blood'' to dry his tears.
* ''Theatre/KingLear'':
** Edmund crosses it when he sets his own father up to be tortured. Just in case there's any doubt, he then orders [[spoiler: Lear and Cordelia to be hanged in prison. Even he ends up regretting this and hastily trying to stop it]].
** Cornwall crosses when he brutally blinds Gloucester.
** Goneril and Regan possibly also cross at this point for fully supporting this action, if they haven't already with their treatment of their father. Plus, at this point, Regan stabs a servant in the back while he is duelling with her husband.
* ''Theatre/{{Macbeth}}'' reaches this point when [[spoiler:he has Macduff's family, including the kids, murdered,]] if he hadn't already done so with the murders of Duncan and Banquo.
* Don John and Borachio of ''Theatre/MuchAdoAboutNothing'' cross this line by deliberately setting up Hero to be framed for infidelity on the night before her wedding, which would have led to her life and reputation being ruined, her virtue impugned, and her marriage prospects gone forever.
** For many viewers, Claudio can come pretty close to the MEH for publicly and loudly shaming Hero. Although he has been cruelly manipulated by Don John and Borachio into thinking she was sleeping around on the night before the wedding, there is no way he would have been unaware of the consequences of calling her out loudly and publicly - rather than, for instance, quietly breaking things off with her.
* Angelo of ''Theatre/MeasureForMeasure'' crosses when he coerces Isabella into sleeping with him [[ScarpiaUltimatum under the promise of saving Claudio]], then goes back on his word and orders Claudio's execution anyway. Thank goodness this didn't go quite as he planned.
* In ''Theatre/{{Othello}}'', Iago's crossing is the enactment of his plan to ruin Othello, setting off multiple murders in the process.
* ''Theatre/RichardII'' crosses by taking Gaunt's land and money away from Bolingbroke, the rightful heir to them, and Richard is explicitly warned that once he does it there's no going back. He doesn't care.
** For those who know what is to come, Bolingbroke crosses by his deposition and humiliation of Richard, due to the fact that this ends up triggering a struggle for the crown that we now know as The Wars Of The Roses.
* In ''Theatre/RichardIII'', the title character's murder of the Little Princes catapults him over the line and causes many of his allies to rebel against him.
** Not only that, but ''the play itself'' rebels against him. Before the murder of the princes, Richard is dazzlingly evil and full of vitality. After their murder, he loses his vitality and his way with words. Taken from him just like *that!*.
* Depending on the production, Tybalt from ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' may cross the line by stabbing Mercutio under Romeo's arm. Some adaptations avert this, such as the Zeffirelli version, in which Tybalt is characterized as a jovial troublemaker who duels with Mercutio all in good fun and kills him [[AccidentalMurder by mistake]], after which he is [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone visibly horrified]].
* In ''Theatre/TitusAndronicus'', Demetrius, Chiron, Tamora and Aaron all cross the MEH with Lavinia's brutal rape and mutilation: the former two carried it out, Aaron masterminded it, and Tamora fully condoned and encouraged it. And what's worse, Demetrius and Chiron ''taunt her about it afterwards'', mockingly daring her to try and tell anyone who abused her so thoroughly.
* In the last scene of ''Theatre/TwoGentlemenOfVerona'', Proteus tries to rape Silvia (before being talked down by Valentine) and his being [[EasilyForgiven rather suddenly forgiven by both Valentine and Julia]] does not ring true for many modern viewers.

Top