Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / StrawAffiliation

Go To



* [[Webcomic/{{Sonichu}} Chris-chan]] is known to rant about how people with Asperger's are "stealing the glory" of autistics ([[ItMakesSenseInContext to cut a long story short]], [[DisabilityAsAnExcuseForJerkassery he uses his autism to excuse his bad behavior, which is convenient since there's so much to excuse]]); because of this, he angrily insists that the two aren't related, and that this "fact" is his idea. To make things worse, [[ItsAllAboutMe he tends to act like he's the only autistic who's special, describing other autistics as "zombies" or "windows into hell"]]. Most people on the autism spectrum [[StopBeingStereotypical refuse to assosciate with him]].

to:

* [[Webcomic/{{Sonichu}} Chris-chan]] is known to rant about how people with Asperger's are "stealing the glory" of autistics ([[ItMakesSenseInContext to cut a long story short]], [[DisabilityAsAnExcuseForJerkassery he uses his autism to excuse his bad behavior, which is convenient since there's so much to excuse]]); because of this, he angrily insists that the two aren't related, and that this "fact" is his idea. To make things worse, [[ItsAllAboutMe he tends to act like he's the only autistic who's special, describing other autistics as "zombies" or "windows into hell"]]. Most people on the autism spectrum [[StopBeingStereotypical refuse to assosciate associate with him]].


See also GayConservative, BlondeRepublicanSexKitten, NoTrueScotsman, CulturalRebel, UncleTomFoolery. Contrast MarsAndVenusGenderContrast, where gender-based Straw Affiliation is justified by the narrative.

to:

See also GayConservative, BlondeRepublicanSexKitten, NoTrueScotsman, CulturalRebel, UncleTomFoolery.UncleTomFoolery, BlackRepublican. Contrast MarsAndVenusGenderContrast, where gender-based Straw Affiliation is justified by the narrative.


* Postmodernist theorists posit a similar idea, but on a much more fundamental basis than economic class. Since language and culture is subjective, freedom of thought or affiliation as such does not even exist because every person is really a mouthpiece for underlying "power dynamics" informed by their group.

to:

* Postmodernist theorists posit a similar idea, but on a much more fundamental basis than economic class. Since language and culture is subjective, freedom of thought or affiliation as such does ''does not even exist exist'' because every person is really a mouthpiece for underlying "power dynamics" informed by their group.

Added DiffLines:

* Postmodernist theorists posit a similar idea, but on a much more fundamental basis than economic class. Since language and culture is subjective, freedom of thought or affiliation as such does not even exist because every person is really a mouthpiece for underlying "power dynamics" informed by their group.


->"Damon, you can't be a Republican!"
->"Why not?"
->"Because only Democrats fight racial stereotyping!"
->"Well... why me?"
->"Why?! Because you're '''black'''!!"

to:

->"Damon, you can't be a Republican!"
->"Why not?"
->"Because
Republican!"\\
"Why not?"\\
"Because
only Democrats fight racial stereotyping!"
->"Well...
stereotyping!"\\
"Well...
why me?"
->"Why?!
me?"\\
"Why?!
Because you're '''black'''!!"



* In ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark'', at the end of "Cripple Fight", Big Gay Al gives an inspiring speech about how he doesn't believe the government has the right to force the Scouts to accept homosexuals. A bewildered Gloria Allred quickly attacks Big Gay Al as being a homophobe.

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark'', at the end of "Cripple Fight", Big Gay Al gives an inspiring speech about how he doesn't believe the government has the right to force the Scouts to accept homosexuals.homosexuals (or anyone). A bewildered Gloria Allred quickly attacks Big Gay Al as being a homophobe.



** The issue is actually much more complicated than blacks "wanting" other blacks to stay poor and uneducated. Most of it has more to do with classicism and intra-racism ''within'' the black community.
** This goes beyond black people; any member of a minority, be it women who choose to stay at home with the kids (independent of what their husbands think) or children of immigrants who assimilate into the dominant culture, typically gets accused of this at some point.


* Heaven help you if you're a GayConservative. Or black conservative, woman conservative, Jewish conservative, etc.

to:

* Heaven help you if you're a GayConservative.GayConservative in the US. Or black conservative, woman conservative, Jewish conservative, etc.


[[folder:Live Action TV]]

to:

[[folder:Live Action [[folder:Live-Action TV]]



[[folder:WebOriginal]]

to:

[[folder:WebOriginal]][[folder:Web Original]]



[[folder:WesternAnimation]]

to:

[[folder:WesternAnimation]][[folder:Western Animation]]


* The ''Webcomic/DayByDay'' cartoon outlined at the top of the page. It gets worse. It is later revealed that Damon is an orphan, causing Jan, the [[StrawCharacter Straw Liberal]] to declare that this explains why he's a Republican as he doesn't know ''how a black person'' is supposed to act. Did I mention they're now a [[OppositesAttract couple]]? That's after notable CharacterDevelopment on Jan's part. Her position as the cast's StrawLiberal has since been taken over by Skye.
* The now defunct online comic ''QueerNation'' featured the examples of a black gay man who spoke at a Republican benefit and, during it, received superpowers; the "Lambda Rays" put him in blackface, a hobo suit, and apparently gave him the moniker "Uncle Tom". He immediately began dancing for the white crowd in front of him. An AuthorTract example of this trope in action.

to:

* The ''Webcomic/DayByDay'' ''Day By Day'' cartoon outlined at the top of the page. It gets worse. It is later revealed that Damon is an orphan, causing Jan, the [[StrawCharacter Straw Liberal]] to declare that this explains why he's a Republican as he doesn't know ''how a black person'' is supposed to act. Did I mention And they're now a [[OppositesAttract couple]]? couple]]. That's after notable CharacterDevelopment on Jan's part. Her position as the cast's StrawLiberal has since been taken over by Skye.
* The now defunct online comic ''QueerNation'' ''Queer Nation'' featured the examples of a black gay man who spoke at a Republican benefit and, during it, received superpowers; the "Lambda Rays" put him in blackface, a hobo suit, and apparently gave him the moniker "Uncle Tom". He immediately began dancing for the white crowd in front of him. An AuthorTract example of this trope in action.


The specific attitude toward this type of person can vary depending on the real or supposed affiliation of their accuser. While someone of their same (superficial) group will probably play the "traitor" card, someone in a ''different'' group (or who has voluntarily joined a different group not because they wanted to, but because they felt they ''had'' to, which is itself an example of this trope) might well respond with resentment rather than disgust. A white moderate (or [[WhiteGuilt guilty-conscience]]) liberal, for example, might feel anger toward a conservative of color because of their [[NWordPrivileges supposed unfair advantage]]: "If ''I'' said the things ''you'' said, you people would call me a redneck!"

to:

The specific attitude toward this type of person can vary depending on the real or supposed affiliation of their accuser. While someone of their same (superficial) group will probably play the "traitor" card, someone in a ''different'' group (or who has voluntarily joined a different group not because they wanted to, but because they felt they ''had'' to, which is itself an example of this trope) might well respond with resentment rather than disgust. A white moderate (or or [[WhiteGuilt guilty-conscience]]) (guilty-conscience)]] liberal, for example, might feel anger toward a conservative of color because of their [[NWordPrivileges supposed unfair advantage]]: "If ''I'' said the things ''you'' said, you people would call me a redneck!"


The specific attitude toward this type of person can vary depending on the real or supposed affiliation of their accuser. While someone of their same (superficial) group will probably play the "traitor" card, someone in a ''different'' group (or who has voluntarily joined a different group not because they wanted to, but because they felt they ''had'' to, which is itself an example of this trope) might well respond with resentment rather than disgust. A white moderate or [[WhiteGuilt (guilty-conscience)]] liberal, for example, might feel anger toward a conservative of color because of their [[NWordPrivileges supposed unfair advantage]]: "If ''I'' said the things ''you'' said, you people would call me a redneck!"

to:

The specific attitude toward this type of person can vary depending on the real or supposed affiliation of their accuser. While someone of their same (superficial) group will probably play the "traitor" card, someone in a ''different'' group (or who has voluntarily joined a different group not because they wanted to, but because they felt they ''had'' to, which is itself an example of this trope) might well respond with resentment rather than disgust. A white moderate or (or [[WhiteGuilt (guilty-conscience)]] guilty-conscience]]) liberal, for example, might feel anger toward a conservative of color because of their [[NWordPrivileges supposed unfair advantage]]: "If ''I'' said the things ''you'' said, you people would call me a redneck!"


** On the flip side, due to clashes within the atheist community, as well as clashes between feminists and prominent atheists, atheists are apparently supposed to treat feminism as just as irrational as religion. However, in different cases, an atheist is supposed to automatically consider the feminist movement indisputably righteous, and to not be affiliated with anything related to pseudo-science or anything that deals with the supposed paranormal, [[ScullySyndrome such as ghosts or aliens]]. At least part of this is thanks to a fundamental disagreement on whether 'feminism' (i.e. dictionary-definition egalitarianism which both sides claim to represent) and 'the feminist movement' are the same thing (and interchangeable terms) or directly opposed; the resulting 'debate' frequently degenerates into FourTermsFallacy with a bit of WhosOnFirst.

to:

** On the flip side, due to clashes within the atheist community, as well as clashes between feminists and prominent atheists, atheists are apparently supposed to treat feminism as just as irrational as religion. However, in different cases, an atheist is supposed to automatically consider the feminist movement indisputably righteous, and to not be affiliated with anything related to pseudo-science or anything that deals with the supposed paranormal, [[ScullySyndrome such as ghosts or aliens]]. At least part of this is thanks to a fundamental disagreement on whether 'feminism' (i.e. dictionary-definition egalitarianism which both sides claim to represent) and 'the feminist movement' are the same thing (and interchangeable terms) or terms), directly opposed; opposed (the position of those who claim modern 'feminism' is repackaged misandry), or that the latter is completely irrelevant to your opinion on the former; the resulting 'debate' frequently degenerates into FourTermsFallacy with a bit of WhosOnFirst.

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Video Games]]
* ''VideoGame/DragonAgeInquisition'': CulturalRebel elven companion Sera finds herself both on the receiving and giving end of this.
** On the one hand, she rejects people assuming she's "elfy" just because she's an elf, and thus must share other elves' values -- [[BarefootPoverty that she should go barefoot]], [[EnslavedElves whine about oppression]], [[HumansAreBastards dislike most humans]], be obsessed with regaining elven traditions and past glory, etc. She dislikes it when humans and ''especially'' other elves assume she should care about the [[EnslavedElves plight of other elves]] or share elfy views (like [[FightingForAHomeland wanting their own homeland]]) just because she's biologically elven.
** On the other hand, Sera herself is [[{{Hypocrite}} very guilty]] of perpetuating this same fallacy against most other elves. She assumes most elves she comes across are "too elfy," and puts the burden on them to prove they're [[YouAreACreditToYourRace "not like other elves"]]... [[WithUsOrAgainstUs by completely rejecting everything elven in nature like she does]]. If they embrace anything elven in nature, no matter how minor, she [[AggressiveCategorism aggressively categorizes]] them as "elfy," and thus negatively affiliates them as sharing all elfy beliefs and attitudes ([[BarefootPoverty barefoot]], [[HumansAreBastards hate humans]], [[WhiteDwarfStarlet won't let go of the past]], [[NoTrueScotsman won't tolerate non-elfy elves]], etc).
[[/folder]]


** On the flip side, due to clashes within the atheist community, as well as clashes between feminists and prominent atheists, atheists are apparently supposed to treat feminism as just as irrational as religion. However, in different cases, an atheist is supposed to automatically consider the feminist movement indisputably righteous, and to not be affiliated with anything related to pseudo-science or anything that deals with the supposed paranormal, [[ScullySyndrome such as ghosts or aliens]]. At least part of this is thanks to a fundamental disagreement on whether 'feminism' (i.e. dictionary-definition egalitarianism which both sides claim to represent) and 'the feminist movement' are the same thing or directly opposed.

to:

** On the flip side, due to clashes within the atheist community, as well as clashes between feminists and prominent atheists, atheists are apparently supposed to treat feminism as just as irrational as religion. However, in different cases, an atheist is supposed to automatically consider the feminist movement indisputably righteous, and to not be affiliated with anything related to pseudo-science or anything that deals with the supposed paranormal, [[ScullySyndrome such as ghosts or aliens]]. At least part of this is thanks to a fundamental disagreement on whether 'feminism' (i.e. dictionary-definition egalitarianism which both sides claim to represent) and 'the feminist movement' are the same thing (and interchangeable terms) or directly opposed.opposed; the resulting 'debate' frequently degenerates into FourTermsFallacy with a bit of WhosOnFirst.


** On the flip side, due to clashes within the atheist community, as well as clashes between feminists and prominent atheists, atheists are apparently supposed to treat feminism as just as irrational as religion. However, in different cases, an atheist is supposed to automatically consider the feminist movement indisputably righteous, and to not be affiliated with anything related to pseudo-science or anything that deals with the supposed paranormal, [[ScullySyndrome such as ghosts or aliens]].

to:

** On the flip side, due to clashes within the atheist community, as well as clashes between feminists and prominent atheists, atheists are apparently supposed to treat feminism as just as irrational as religion. However, in different cases, an atheist is supposed to automatically consider the feminist movement indisputably righteous, and to not be affiliated with anything related to pseudo-science or anything that deals with the supposed paranormal, [[ScullySyndrome such as ghosts or aliens]]. At least part of this is thanks to a fundamental disagreement on whether 'feminism' (i.e. dictionary-definition egalitarianism which both sides claim to represent) and 'the feminist movement' are the same thing or directly opposed.


* Happens a WhateleyUniverse story, and the person doing it gets ''blasted'' by the target's grandmother for perpetuating negative stereotypes.

to:

* Happens in a WhateleyUniverse Literature/WhateleyUniverse story, and the person doing it gets ''blasted'' by the target's grandmother for perpetuating negative stereotypes.

Showing 15 edit(s) of 63

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report