Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / LowestCosmicDenominator

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** One episode in Sokar's season in the spotlight (4th?) had him posing as Satan to control some primitive screwheads he'd grabbed from Medieval Europe. They were very careful to have Teal'c claim he didn't think a Goa'uld would ever act like capital-G God, though.

Removed: 2789

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''HarryPotter'': Christian hymns are occasionally mentioned in regards to the celebration of Christmas and Easter is celebrated similarly. WordOfGod says Harry had a Christening, so it seems that "godparent" does mean the same thing to wizards as it does to muggles. The biggest reference to religion would be the Bible verses on the Potters and Dumbledore family's graves, which spell out the biggest themes of the series. Otherwise, the subject of religion is never really brought up, though there is a "man in black robes" at a funeral and a wedding who seems to be a wizard clergyman.
** Wizards probably don't have a specific religion: they just practice the same religion they would have if they were Muggles. It's obvious from the World Cup scenes that magic is not limited to one particular culture.
*** The question of why most wizards would accept the divinity of Christ when his best-known miracles(such as walking on water and conjuring loaves and fishes) would be doable tasks by at least the more competent members of their society.... goes unanswered.
**** [[FanDumb Not at all]]. For one thing, it's stated in the seventh HarryPotter book that conjuring food by magic actually is impossible. (You can teleport it from somewhere else, but not create it completely anew.) Other miracles are probably better-known than those, namely raising the dead and rising from death himself, and both are beyond the Potterverse's magic. (Creating zombies is possible and ghosts are well-understood, but zombies are just animated corpses rather than the people they were in life and ghosts are spirits that chose not to go on to the afterlife and don't know what, if anything, awaits.) Mainly, though, most wizards we see in the series are British, and British culture is generally less credulous about the more fundamentalist aspects of religion than American culture, so British wizards may very well think of themselves as Christian without believing that Jesus literally rose from the dead.
**** Most Christians would probably argue that [[CompletelyMissingThePoint the miracles referenced above]], while certainly "flashy", pale in comparison to, say, dying for the sins of all mankind, allowing each individual human the chance to repent and gain access to the eternal Kingdom of Heaven (just as an example). With little to no metaphysical framework established for Magic itself, there is nothing inconsistent about the existence Magic and the divinity of Jesus in the Potterverse (though the existence of Magic and the Laws of Physics...)
**** [[FridgeBrilliance What if the "miracles" of creating fish and bread, as well as reanimation, are STILL miracles to the Wizarding World?]] Doesn't mean that one religion is correct; Just that, in that world, Jesus did something impossible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's TheThemeParkVersion of religion, where everybody's NotUsingTheZedWord. Related is WitchSpecies.

to:

It's TheThemeParkVersion of religion, where everybody's NotUsingTheZedWord.not using the "G" word. Related is WitchSpecies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** [[FridgeBrilliance What if the "miracles" of creating fish and bread, as well as reanimation, are STILL miracles to the Wizarding World?]] Doesn't mean that one religion is correct; Just that, in that world, Jesus did something impossible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If one were to class vampires as demons (technically correct, by the show's mythology), then many of them claim to have been present at the Crucifixion. [[LampshadeHanging Lampshaded]] by Spike, who pointed out that if every vampire who claimed to be at the Crucifixion actually was, there'd be no room for the crosses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Powers correspond to the gods of ''every'' religion (although some are closer to the mark than others). For example, in the ''BookOfNightWithMoon'' series, the main Egyptian gods are stated to be close cognates of the feline aspects of the Powers. (In the same book, a wizardly cat is bemused and disturbed at how badly an unnamed human religion - which is clearly some branch of Christianity - misinterprets the nature of the Powers, in particular the idea that the One requires affirmation of Its existence or the sort of extreme and self-effusive praise that would make a person who thinks anything like a sane mortal incredibly uncomfortable, and that insufficiently good people will be sent to {{Hell}} after their deaths.) They're not ''just'' Christian angels and the Christian God with the serial numbers rubbed off, although they would fit pretty well into some liberal, non-traditional interpretations of Christianity.

to:

** The Powers correspond to the gods of ''every'' religion (although some are closer to the mark than others). For example, in the ''BookOfNightWithMoon'' ''TheBookOfNightWithMoon'' series, the main Egyptian gods are stated to be close cognates of the feline aspects of the Powers. (In the same book, a wizardly cat is bemused and disturbed at how badly an unnamed human religion - which is clearly some branch of Christianity - misinterprets the nature of the Powers, in particular the idea that the One requires affirmation of Its existence or the sort of extreme and self-effusive praise that would make a person who thinks anything like a sane mortal incredibly uncomfortable, and that insufficiently good people will be sent to {{Hell}} after their deaths.) They're not ''just'' Christian angels and the Christian God with the serial numbers rubbed off, although they would fit pretty well into some liberal, non-traditional interpretations of Christianity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the YoungWizards series, God is called the One, His angels are called the PowersThatBe, and the devil is called the Lone Power (because it is separate from its fellow angels).

to:

* In the YoungWizards ''YoungWizards'' series, God is called the One, His angels are called the PowersThatBe, and the devil is called the Lone Power (because it is separate from its fellow angels).




to:

** The Powers correspond to the gods of ''every'' religion (although some are closer to the mark than others). For example, in the ''BookOfNightWithMoon'' series, the main Egyptian gods are stated to be close cognates of the feline aspects of the Powers. (In the same book, a wizardly cat is bemused and disturbed at how badly an unnamed human religion - which is clearly some branch of Christianity - misinterprets the nature of the Powers, in particular the idea that the One requires affirmation of Its existence or the sort of extreme and self-effusive praise that would make a person who thinks anything like a sane mortal incredibly uncomfortable, and that insufficiently good people will be sent to {{Hell}} after their deaths.) They're not ''just'' Christian angels and the Christian God with the serial numbers rubbed off, although they would fit pretty well into some liberal, non-traditional interpretations of Christianity.

Added: 550

Removed: 546

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Most Christians would probably argue that [[CompletelyMissingThePoint the miracles referenced above]], while certainly "flashy", pale in comparison to, say, dying for the sins of all mankind, allowing each individual human the chance to repent and gain access to the eternal Kingdom of Heaven (just as an example). With little to no metaphysical framework established for Magic itself, there is nothing inconsistent about the existence Magic and divinity of Jesus in the Potterverse (though the existence of Magic and the Laws of Physics...)


Added DiffLines:

**** Most Christians would probably argue that [[CompletelyMissingThePoint the miracles referenced above]], while certainly "flashy", pale in comparison to, say, dying for the sins of all mankind, allowing each individual human the chance to repent and gain access to the eternal Kingdom of Heaven (just as an example). With little to no metaphysical framework established for Magic itself, there is nothing inconsistent about the existence Magic and the divinity of Jesus in the Potterverse (though the existence of Magic and the Laws of Physics...)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Most Christians would probably argue that [[CompletelyMissingThePoint the miracles referenced above]], while certainly "flashy", pale in comparison to, say, dying for the sins of all mankind, allowing each individual human the chance to repent and gain access to the eternal Kingdom of Heaven (just as an example)

to:

**** Most Christians would probably argue that [[CompletelyMissingThePoint the miracles referenced above]], while certainly "flashy", pale in comparison to, say, dying for the sins of all mankind, allowing each individual human the chance to repent and gain access to the eternal Kingdom of Heaven (just as an example)example). With little to no metaphysical framework established for Magic itself, there is nothing inconsistent about the existence Magic and divinity of Jesus in the Potterverse (though the existence of Magic and the Laws of Physics...)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Most Christians would probably argue that [[CompletelyMissingThePoint the miracles referenced above]], while certainly "flashy", pale in comparison to, say, dying for the sins of all mankind, allowing each individual human the chance to repent and gain access to the eternal Kingdom of Heaven (just as an example)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While the actual religious practices are not elaborated on in detail, the [[spoiler:Bright Shiners become major players in the latter parts of the story. The ''Eighth'' Bright Shiner, who refused to take part in creating Charter Magic, turns out to be Mogget -- and not a nice guy, should he ever become '''Un'''sealed Evil From A Can...and then he was unsealed and decided "Screw that, I like the world dammit.]]

to:

** While the actual religious practices are not elaborated on in detail, the [[spoiler:Bright Shiners become major players in the latter parts of the story. The ''Eighth'' Bright Shiner, who refused to take part in creating Charter Magic, Magic and stayed on the sidelines when the Seven were opposed by the ''Ninth'', turns out to be Mogget -- and not a nice guy, should he ever become '''Un'''sealed Evil From A Can...and then he was unsealed and on learning that #9 was trying for TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt), decided "Screw that, I like the world dammit.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Disney studios used to be so cautious about religion that they coldn't even use the word "Bible". In their JohnnyAppleseed animated short, Johnny's cherised Bible was only referred to with the generic term "a holy book".

to:

* Disney studios used to be so cautious about religion that they coldn't even use the word "Bible". In their JohnnyAppleseed animated short, the ''Johnny Appleseed'' segment from MelodyTime, Johnny's cherised Bible was only referred to with the generic term "a holy book".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They do address [[ChristianityIsCatholic Christianity]] early on, with Piper worrying that she is "evil" because she's a witch. Her worries are relieved when she enters a church without bursting into flame.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC:WesternAnimation]]
* Disney studios used to be so cautious about religion that they coldn't even use the word "Bible". In their JohnnyAppleseed animated short, Johnny's cherised Bible was only referred to with the generic term "a holy book".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Asatrú, Religio Romana, Celtic Heathenry, Slavic Heathenry and Druidism are still active.

Changed: 63

Removed: 65

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In HisDarkMaterials, one of the most famed examples: God is 'The Authority', the church is 'Magisterium', Inquisition-for-children is 'Gobblers', and so on.
** Justified in that the books take place in alternate universes.

to:

* In HisDarkMaterials, one of the most famed examples: God is 'The Authority', the church is 'Magisterium', Inquisition-for-children is 'Gobblers', and so on.
**
on. Justified in that the books take place in alternate universes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** [[FanDumb Not at all]]. For one thing, it's stated in the seventh HarryPotter book that conjuring food by magic actually is impossible. (You can teleport it from somewhere else, but not create it completely anew.) Other miracles are probably better-known than those, namely raising the dead and rising from death himself, and both are beyond the Potterverse's magic. (Creating zombies is possible and ghosts are well-understood, but zombies are just animated corpses rather than the people they were in life and ghosts are spirits that chose not to go on to the afterlife and don't know what, if anything, awaits.) Mainly, though, most wizards we see in the series are British, and British culture is generally less credulous about the more fundamentalist aspects of religion than American culture, so British wizards may very well think of themselves as Christian without believing that Jesus literally rose from the dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The question of why most wizards would accept the divinity of Christ when his best-known miracles(such as walking on water and conjuring loaves and fishes) would be doable tasks by at least the more competent members of their society.... goes unanswered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the YoungWizards series, God is called the One, his angels are called the PowersThatBe, and the devil is called the Lone Power (because it is separate from its fellow angels).

to:

* In the YoungWizards series, God is called the One, his His angels are called the PowersThatBe, and the devil is called the Lone Power (because it is separate from its fellow angels).
** On the other hand, it's made pretty obvious that the Lone Power is {{Satan}} (without ever explicitly saying so), a few line explicitly compare the Powers to Abrahamic angels, and the Power who's duties/role closely match that of the archangel Michael is referred to as "Mike" by the Lone Power.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Wizards probably don't have a specific religion: they just practice the same religion they would have if they were Muggles. It's obvious from the World Cup scenes that magic is not limited to one particular culture.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Justified in that the books take place in alternate universes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Seriously asking, don't remind any reference.

Added DiffLines:

** When Judeo-Christian-Islam had been name-checked?

Changed: 180

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added young Wizards example



to:

* In the YoungWizards series, God is called the One, his angels are called the PowersThatBe, and the devil is called the Lone Power (because it is separate from its fellow angels).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
A few spelling fixes


* In HisDarkMaterials, one of the most famed example: God is 'The Authority', the church is 'Magisterium', Inquisition-for-childern is 'Gobblers', and so on.
* PlayedWith in ''LordOfTheRings''. Archangels are "Valar", demons are "Balrogs", and God is also called "Illuvatar" (approximately similar to [[GeniusBonus "all-father"]] in Sanskrit, which is also the word for Jupiter in Latin.) But Tolkien avoided showing anyone practising religion save for the Numenoreans, who were extremely ecumenical in their beliefs. According to Tolkien's Catholic theology, all of the characters were "virtuous pagans" and as such anyone they worshiped could potentially count as "actually being" angels or demons according to the tenets of Catholic syncretism.

to:

* In HisDarkMaterials, one of the most famed example: examples: God is 'The Authority', the church is 'Magisterium', Inquisition-for-childern Inquisition-for-children is 'Gobblers', and so on.
* PlayedWith in ''LordOfTheRings''. Archangels are "Valar", demons are "Balrogs", and God is also called "Illuvatar" (approximately similar to [[GeniusBonus "all-father"]] in Sanskrit, which is also the word for Jupiter in Latin.) But Tolkien avoided showing anyone practising practicing religion save for the Numenoreans, who were extremely ecumenical in their beliefs. According to Tolkien's Catholic theology, all of the characters were "virtuous pagans" and as such anyone they worshiped could potentially count as "actually being" angels or demons according to the tenets of Catholic syncretism.



* In ''{{Mother 3}}'', God is reffered to as "Guy in the Sky" when Lucky leaves club Titiboo, although, this being a ''[[NoFourthWall Mother]]'' game, it could very well be referring to the [[HumansAreCthulhu player]] instead. Either way, euphemism is used.

to:

* In ''{{Mother 3}}'', God is reffered referred to as "Guy in the Sky" when Lucky leaves club Titiboo, although, this being a ''[[NoFourthWall Mother]]'' game, it could very well be referring to the [[HumansAreCthulhu player]] instead. Either way, euphemism is used.

Added: 362

Removed: 40

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Darksiders is the poster boy for this.


Added DiffLines:

[[AC:NewspaperComics]]
* ''{{Dilbert}}'' was originally to feature Satan, but due to ExecutiveMeddling it wound up with "Phil, the Prince of Insufficient Light," who sometimes darns people to Heck. (The writer has admitted this is funnier than what he originally planned.) On the other hand, God and angels have occasionally been referred to in more proper terms.

Added: 143

Changed: 370

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In The MarvelUniverse, the Fantastic Four met the One-Above-All. It was JackKirby.

to:

* In The MarvelUniverse, direct mentions of Judeo-Christian entities such as Satan were not uncommon (The "Son of Satan" even had his own series) but in the Fantastic Four 80's it was stated (in the Handbook of the Marvel Universe) that NO such character had ever appeared in a Marvel comic; even Son Of Satan's father was [[RetCon retconned]] into being another demon. This has loosened in recent years.
**The FantasticFour
met the One-Above-All. One-Above-All (in other words, God) in one adventure. It was [[AFormYouAreComfortableWith took the form]] of JackKirby.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In The MarvelUniverse, the Fantastic Four met the One-Above-All. It was Jack Kirby.

to:

* In The MarvelUniverse, the Fantastic Four met the One-Above-All. It was Jack Kirby.JackKirby.

Changed: 475

Removed: 795

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''HarryPotter''. Christian hymns are occasionally mentioned in regards to the celebration of Christmas and a church appears in the seventh book, but that's about it. Not that that stopped the MoralGuardians.
** JK Rowling shied away from giving wizards any cosmic beliefs whatsoever, which is a bit of a copout and bizarre as wizards happily celebrate Christmas.. [[http://www.ferretbrain.com/ Ferretbrain]] wrote [[http://www.ferretbrain.com/articles/article-161.html an article]] about the influence of poorly-remembered Calvinism.
** Celebrating Christmas in a western society doesn't necessarily make someone Christian, anyway. Same goes for Easter to a lesser extent.
*** Although it's generally accepted that these now-secular holidays stem from a particular religious history in a nation's culture, so it can be seen to imply that Christianity played some role in the history of wizardry.
**** Or, like the radio in the Burrow, the wizarding world simply adopted it because they thought it was neat.

to:

* ''HarryPotter''. ''HarryPotter'': Christian hymns are occasionally mentioned in regards to the celebration of Christmas and Easter is celebrated similarly. WordOfGod says Harry had a church appears in the seventh book, but that's about it. Not Christening, so it seems that that stopped "godparent" does mean the MoralGuardians.
** JK Rowling shied away from giving
same thing to wizards any cosmic beliefs whatsoever, as it does to muggles. The biggest reference to religion would be the Bible verses on the Potters and Dumbledore family's graves, which spell out the biggest themes of the series. Otherwise, the subject of religion is never really brought up, though there is a bit of "man in black robes" at a copout funeral and bizarre as wizards happily celebrate Christmas.. [[http://www.ferretbrain.com/ Ferretbrain]] wrote [[http://www.ferretbrain.com/articles/article-161.html an article]] about the influence of poorly-remembered Calvinism.
** Celebrating Christmas in
a western society doesn't necessarily make someone Christian, anyway. Same goes for Easter wedding who seems to a lesser extent.
*** Although it's generally accepted that these now-secular holidays stem from a particular religious history in a nation's culture, so it can
be seen to imply that Christianity played some role in the history of wizardry.
**** Or, like the radio in the Burrow, the wizarding world simply adopted it because they thought it was neat.
a wizard clergyman.

Added: 110

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Although it's generally accepted that these now-secular holidays stem from a particular religious history in a nation's culture, so it can be seen to imply that Christianity played some role in the history of wizardry.

to:

*** Although it's generally accepted that these now-secular holidays stem from a particular religious history in a nation's culture, so it can be seen to imply that Christianity played some role in the history of wizardry. wizardry.
**** Or, like the radio in the Burrow, the wizarding world simply adopted it because they thought it was neat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PlayedWith in ''LordOfTheRings''. Archangels are "Valar", demons are "Balrogs", and God is also called "Illuvatar" (approximately similar to [[GeniusBonus "all-father"]] in Sanskrit, which is also the word for Jupiter in Latin.) But Tolkien avoided showing anyone practising religion save for the Numenoreans, who were extremely ecumenical in their beliefs. According to Tolkien's Catholic theology, all of the characters were "virtuous pagans" and as such anyone they worshiped could potentially count as "actually being" angels or demons according to the tenets of Catholic syncretism.

Top