Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ButIReadABookAboutIt

Go To

OR

Changed: 229

Removed: 188

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Scriber Jaqueramaphan from ''{{A Fire Upon The Deep}}'' by VernorVinge is all about this trope; he also tends to be pretty incompetent in most of the things he's read about.
** Terrifying the hell out of his friend when they're about to sneak through the army of a feared warlord. Scriber is a spy, and is therefore assumed by the others to know what he's doing.

to:

* Scriber Jaqueramaphan from ''{{A Fire Upon The Deep}}'' ''Literature/AFireUponTheDeep'' by VernorVinge is all about this trope; VernorVinge; he also tends to be pretty incompetent in most of the things he's read about.
**
about. Terrifying the hell out of his friend when they're about to sneak through the army of a feared warlord. Scriber is a spy, and is therefore assumed by the others to know what he's doing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''HarryPotter'', [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Characters/HarryPotterMinistryOfMagic Dolores Umbridge]] states that just having a theoretical basis in Defense Against the Dark Arts should be enough to prepare the students to successfully take their exams. (In a subversion, though, the ''real'' reason for the dumbed-down, book-taught Defense Against the Dark Arts class is to ensure the students ''don't'' have any practical knowledge.)
** Hermione gets a few of these in ''HarryPotter''.

to:

* In ''HarryPotter'', [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Characters/HarryPotterMinistryOfMagic ''Literature/HarryPotter'', Dolores Umbridge]] Umbridge states that just having a theoretical basis in Defense Against the Dark Arts should be enough to prepare the students to successfully take their exams. (In a subversion, though, the ''real'' reason for the dumbed-down, book-taught Defense Against the Dark Arts class is to ensure the students ''don't'' have any practical knowledge.)
** Hermione gets a few of these in ''HarryPotter''.these.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He also tries to find a book on how to make friends. All he can find is a children's book, ''Stu the Cockatoo is New at the Zoo'', but he figures he can interpolate the information to fit his needs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Among the many lesser-known things the U.S. government habitually does is pay for the creation of (often mind-numbingly) detailed publications and manuals on pretty much any random thing a citizen might need to know how to do. For example, cooking a turkey or safely cutting down an evergreen tree with a chainsaw. Said publications are cheaply (cost of printing and postage) or freely available, especially with the rise of the Internet, and there have been accounts of people (usually in the bureaucracy, who know about them and can ''find'' given topics) who learn skills mainly from these.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the first ''ShortCircuit'' movie, Number 5 reads the entire encyclopedia before his adventures. The next day he reads the manual for Stephanie's van immediately before driving it.

to:

* In the first ''ShortCircuit'' ''Film/ShortCircuit'' movie, Number 5 reads the entire encyclopedia before his adventures. The next day he reads the manual for Stephanie's van immediately before driving it.

Changed: 86

Removed: 128

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Noir}}'', the ActionGirl Kirika reads a book on making tea and henceforth enjoys it to no end. Which is kinda cute, once you consider that making tea is the only thing she can do well besides killing people, and the only thing she ever learned on her own.

to:

* In ''{{Noir}}'', ''Anime/{{Noir}}'', the ActionGirl Kirika reads a book on making tea and henceforth enjoys it to no end. Which is kinda cute, once you consider that making tea is the only thing she can do well besides killing people, and the only thing she ever learned on her own.



* In the ''{{Discworld}}'' novel ''Discworld/{{Wintersmith}}'', Roland believes that he will be an expert swordsman because he has read the fencing manuals and fought many imaginary swordfights in his mind.

to:

* In the ''{{Discworld}}'' ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'' novel ''Discworld/{{Wintersmith}}'', Roland believes that he will be an expert swordsman because he has read the fencing manuals and fought many imaginary swordfights in his mind.



** I cannot help but be reminded of [[GrowingUpCullen Growing Up]] [[http://oxymoronassoc.livejournal.com/462027.html Cullen]].



* In ''BuffyTheVampireSlayer'', Wesley bragged that in the new Watcher training, he had even taken on two vampires "under controlled circumstances, of course". Giles quickly countered that he wouldn't encounter those in [[CityOfAdventure Sunnydale]]... controlled circumstances, that is.

to:

* In ''BuffyTheVampireSlayer'', ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'', Wesley bragged that in the new Watcher training, he had even taken on two vampires "under controlled circumstances, of course". Giles quickly countered that he wouldn't encounter those in [[CityOfAdventure Sunnydale]]... controlled circumstances, that is.



* [[TheBigBangTheory Sheldon Cooper]] attempted to learn to swim on the internet. And to rock climb.

to:

* [[TheBigBangTheory On ''Series/TheBigBangTheory'', Sheldon Cooper]] Cooper attempted to learn to swim on the internet. And to rock climb.



* This is actually a knack in ''{{Scion}}''. Basically means that the Scion has read so much about stuff they can try them even if they have no training.
* The Factotum class (dungeonscape) in ''DungeonsAndDragons'' has this as it's premise. As a result it's class skills are "All", even obscure class specific ones are treated as class skills for a factotum.

to:

* This is actually a knack in ''{{Scion}}''.''TabletopGame/{{Scion}}''. Basically means that the Scion has read so much about stuff they can try them even if they have no training.
* The Factotum class (dungeonscape) in ''DungeonsAndDragons'' ''TabletopGame/DungeonsAndDragons'' has this as it's premise. As a result it's class skills are "All", even obscure class specific ones are treated as class skills for a factotum.



* Parodied in ''FamilyGuy'':

to:

* Parodied in ''FamilyGuy'':''WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the ''{{All in the Family}}'' episode "Edith Writes a Song," Mike tries to placate two African American burglars whom Archie has racially insulted, by explaining that Archie doesn't know what it's like to grow up in the inner city. One of the burglars responds, "Oh, and you do?" Mike sheepishly replies that he learned about it in his sociology course.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'', "Fall Weather Friends": Grade-A bookworm Twilight Sparkle enters a big marathon, the Running of the Leaves, alongside her more athletic friends Applejack and Rainbow Dash. The two of them scoff when Twilight claims she's read a book on running techniques in preparation for the race, but in the end she manages a respectable fifth place from pacing herself, while Applejack and Rainbow Dash end up tied for dead last because the two of them were too preoccupied with making sure the other doesn't win.

to:

* ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'', ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'', "Fall Weather Friends": Grade-A bookworm Twilight Sparkle enters a big marathon, the Running of the Leaves, alongside her more athletic friends Applejack and Rainbow Dash. The two of them scoff when Twilight claims she's read a book on running techniques in preparation for the race, but in the end she manages a respectable fifth place from pacing herself, while Applejack and Rainbow Dash end up tied for dead last because the two of them were too preoccupied with making sure the other doesn't win.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Eyeshield 21}}'': The Amino Cyborgs team do only a middling amount of training, and spend more time getting juiced up and reading books on how to play football. This leaves them with low stamina when they play the Devil Bats.

to:

* ''{{Eyeshield 21}}'': The Amino Cyborgs team do only a middling amount of training, and spend more time getting juiced up and reading books on how to play football. This leaves them with low stamina and a poor grasp of football fundamentals when they play the Devil Bats.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a musical inversion.

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:{{Music}}]]
*''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nw7d4pVKHyo Read About Love]]'' by {{Richard Thompson}} would be an inversion: the character portrayed has [[{{title drop}} "read about love"]] and doesn't understand why he makes girls cry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When Gohan of DragonballZ has to play baseball in high school, he notes that he has read about it after admitting that he never played it before. Of course, being a superhuman half-alien who spent a sizable portion of his life in TrainingFromHell, any physical activity is pretty much a cakewalk for him, once he understands what he's supposed to be doing.



* In the first ''ShortCircuit'' movie, Number 5 reads the entire encyclopedia before his adventures. The next day he reads the manual for Stephanie's van immediately before driving it.

to:

* In the first ''ShortCircuit'' movie, Number 5 reads the entire encyclopedia before his adventures. The next day he reads the manual for Stephanie's van immediately before driving it.
it.
** A subversion in that he's still an abysmal driver, and nearly gets himself and Stephanie killed several times within a span of a couple minutes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This trope is the literary equivalent of IKnowMortalKombat and TaughtByTelevision -- that is, the character in question gets his knowledge by reading about it. Unlike those tropes, however, it's at least plausible for a person to actually be competent when he has to apply his book knowledge in RealLife.

to:

This trope is the literary equivalent of IKnowMortalKombat and TaughtByTelevision -- that is, the character in question gets his their knowledge by reading about it. Unlike those tropes, however, it's at least plausible for a person to actually be competent when he has they have to apply his their book knowledge in RealLife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Eyeshield 21}}'': The Amino Cyborgs team spent most of their training time getting juiced up and reading books on how to play football. This leaves them with low stamina when they play the Devil Bats.

to:

* ''{{Eyeshield 21}}'': The Amino Cyborgs team spent most do only a middling amount of their training training, and spend more time getting juiced up and reading books on how to play football. This leaves them with low stamina when they play the Devil Bats.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''HarryPotter'', [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Characters/HarryPotter Dolores Umbridge]] states that just having a theoretical basis in Defense Against the Dark Arts should be enough to prepare the students to successfully take their exams. (In a subversion, though, the ''real'' reason for the dumbed-down, book-taught Defense Against the Dark Arts class is to ensure the students ''don't'' have any practical knowledge.)

to:

* In ''HarryPotter'', [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Characters/HarryPotter php/Characters/HarryPotterMinistryOfMagic Dolores Umbridge]] states that just having a theoretical basis in Defense Against the Dark Arts should be enough to prepare the students to successfully take their exams. (In a subversion, though, the ''real'' reason for the dumbed-down, book-taught Defense Against the Dark Arts class is to ensure the students ''don't'' have any practical knowledge.)



* Parodied with Dave in ''FlightOfTheConchords'', who acts like an expert in all things, especially being a ladies' man. Judging by his tendency toward {{Malapropisms}} and the way he (deniedly) lives with his parents...
* ''XFiles'': "I play ''{{Dungeons and Dragons}}''. I know a thing or two about courage"
* [[TheBigBangTheory Sheldon Cooper]] attempted to learn to swim on the internet. And to rock climb.
** He's actually pretty good at the climbing. It's when he looks down that it all goes wrong.

to:

* Parodied with Dave in ''FlightOfTheConchords'', who acts like an expert in all things, especially being a ladies' man. Judging by his tendency toward {{Malapropisms}} and the way he (deniedly) lives with his parents...
parents...
* ''XFiles'': "I play ''{{Dungeons and Dragons}}''. I know a thing or two about courage"
courage"
* [[TheBigBangTheory Sheldon Cooper]] attempted to learn to swim on the internet. And to rock climb.
climb.
** He's actually pretty good at the climbing. It's when he looks down that it all goes wrong.




to:

* Manuel in FawltyTowers. [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5035TY5RSpg "I speak English well. I learn it from a book."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Subverted in ''FamilyGuy'', for a CrowningMomentOfFunny.

to:

* Subverted Parodied in ''FamilyGuy'', for a CrowningMomentOfFunny.''FamilyGuy'':




to:

* ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'', "Fall Weather Friends": Grade-A bookworm Twilight Sparkle enters a big marathon, the Running of the Leaves, alongside her more athletic friends Applejack and Rainbow Dash. The two of them scoff when Twilight claims she's read a book on running techniques in preparation for the race, but in the end she manages a respectable fifth place from pacing herself, while Applejack and Rainbow Dash end up tied for dead last because the two of them were too preoccupied with making sure the other doesn't win.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[AnalogyBackfire But mules don't learn military tactics by experience on the battlefield; people do.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* In the first ''ShortCircuit'' movie, Number 5 reads the entire encyclopedia before his adventures. The next day he reads the manual for Stephanie's van immediately before driving it. (Though the manual for a motor vehicle [[WallBanger usually concentrates on routine maintenance and service, not how to drive]])

to:

* In the first ''ShortCircuit'' movie, Number 5 reads the entire encyclopedia before his adventures. The next day he reads the manual for Stephanie's van immediately before driving it. (Though the manual for a motor vehicle [[WallBanger usually concentrates on routine maintenance and service, not how to drive]])\n
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[{{Twilight}} Edward Cullen]]. While the rest of his family was having housebreaking sex, he was by his lonesome spending his sleepless nights studying everything there is to study. For example, he cooks perfect meals for Bella on his first try, despite never having a reason to cook before.

to:

* [[{{Twilight}} [[Literature/{{Twilight}} Edward Cullen]]. While the rest of his family was having housebreaking sex, he was by his lonesome spending his sleepless nights studying everything there is to study. For example, he cooks perfect meals for Bella on his first try, despite never having a reason to cook before.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''BattleRoyale'' uses this for two of [[{{Badass}} Kazuo]] [[TheUnfettered Kiriyama's]] Crowing Moments Of Awesome, both in {{Flashback}}. [[spoiler: The first has him breaking the arms, nose, and jaw of a bunch of bullies, with the explanation that "I simply used the information I learned from this book" * shows a human anatomy text* . The second has a [[SadisticTeacher mean judo coach]] with a penchant for humiliating his students pick Kiriyama, reading a book in back, for the next spar. Kiriyama closes his book with the title facing the reader: "[[OhCrap Introduction to Judo]]" Read on for more :).]]

to:

* ''BattleRoyale'' uses this for two of [[{{Badass}} Kazuo]] [[TheUnfettered Kiriyama's]] Crowing Moments Of Awesome, both in {{Flashback}}. [[spoiler: The first has him breaking the arms, nose, and jaw of a bunch of bullies, with the explanation that "I simply used the information I learned from this book" * shows a human anatomy text* . The second has a [[SadisticTeacher [[SadistTeacher mean judo coach]] with a penchant for humiliating his students pick Kiriyama, reading a book in back, for the next spar. Kiriyama closes his book with the title facing the reader: "[[OhCrap Introduction to Judo]]" Read on for more :).]]




to:

* Yuu from ''{{Holyland}}'' first learnt boxing from a book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Scriber Jaqueramaphan from ''A Fire Upon The Deep'' by VernorVinge is all about this trope; he also tends to be pretty incompetent in most of the things he's read about.

to:

* Scriber Jaqueramaphan from ''A ''{{A Fire Upon The Deep'' Deep}}'' by VernorVinge is all about this trope; he also tends to be pretty incompetent in most of the things he's read about. about.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''PokemonSpecial'', the main reason Platinum went on her journey was to try out first hand the many things she read about. That said, sometimes she initially sucks at whatever she's trying out even when she recites whatever the book told her on the subject, like when she kept falling down when she was on a bike for the first time in her life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Subversion. According to CSLewis in ''The Discarded Image''(a series of lectures about the cultural background of Medieval literature) many medieval beliefs, even those that sound like holdovers from primeval superstition were in fact simply because somebody had read a book about them. Books were so expensive and such fine pieces of craftsmanship that no one could really quite make themselves believe that a book could actually be wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the first ''ShortCircuit'' movie, Number 5 reads the entire encyclopedia before his adventures. The next day he reads the manual for Stephanie's van immediately before driving it. (Though the manual for a motor vehicle [[WallBanger usually concentrates on routine maintenance and service, not how to drive]])
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Flight of the Phoenix}}'', one of the characters says he has experience building and designing aircraft. He later reveals he works with model aircraft, but it turns out the principles are much the same, just on a smaller scale.

to:

* In ''{{Flight of the Phoenix}}'', ''TheFlightOfThePhoenix'', one of the characters says he has experience building and designing aircraft. He later reveals he works with model aircraft, but it turns out the principles are much the same, just on a smaller scale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This trope is the literary equivalent of IKnowMortalKombat and TaughtByTelevision -- that is, the character in question gets his knowledge by reading about it. Unlike those tropes, however, it's not entirely implausible for a person to actually be competent when he has to apply his book knowledge in RealLife.

to:

This trope is the literary equivalent of IKnowMortalKombat and TaughtByTelevision -- that is, the character in question gets his knowledge by reading about it. Unlike those tropes, however, it's not entirely implausible at least plausible for a person to actually be competent when he has to apply his book knowledge in RealLife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''{{Flight of the Phoenix}}'', one of the characters says he has experience building and designing aircraft. He later reveals he works with model aircraft, but it turns out the principles are much the same, just on a smaller scale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->'''Fraser:''' I did read a flight training manual in my grandmother's library. There were a couple of pages missing, but I'm sure nothing vital... And I'm guessing that there are a lot of similarities between a Sopwith Camel and today's light aircraft.
-->--''DueSouth''
Camacan MOD

Changed: 82

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Umbridge was renamed and is now about the story arc not the character.


* ''BattleRoyale'' uses this for two of [[{{Badass}} Kazuo]] [[TheUnfettered Kiriyama's]] CMOAs, both in {{Flashback}}. [[spoiler: The first has him breaking the arms, nose, and jaw of a bunch of bullies, with the explanation that "I simply used the information I learned from this book" * shows a human anatomy text* . The second has a [[SadisticTeacher mean judo coach]] with a penchant for humiliating his students pick Kiriyama, reading a book in back, for the next spar. Kiriyama closes his book with the title facing the reader: "[[OhCrap Introduction to Judo]]" Read on for more :).]]

to:

* ''BattleRoyale'' uses this for two of [[{{Badass}} Kazuo]] [[TheUnfettered Kiriyama's]] CMOAs, Crowing Moments Of Awesome, both in {{Flashback}}. [[spoiler: The first has him breaking the arms, nose, and jaw of a bunch of bullies, with the explanation that "I simply used the information I learned from this book" * shows a human anatomy text* . The second has a [[SadisticTeacher mean judo coach]] with a penchant for humiliating his students pick Kiriyama, reading a book in back, for the next spar. Kiriyama closes his book with the title facing the reader: "[[OhCrap Introduction to Judo]]" Read on for more :).]]



* In ''HarryPotter'', [[TheUmbridge Dolores Umbridge]] states that just having a theoretical basis in Defense Against the Dark Arts should be enough to prepare the students to successfully take their exams. (In a subversion, though, the ''real'' reason for the dumbed-down, book-taught Defense Against the Dark Arts class is to ensure the students ''don't'' have any practical knowledge.)

to:

* In ''HarryPotter'', [[TheUmbridge [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Characters/HarryPotter Dolores Umbridge]] states that just having a theoretical basis in Defense Against the Dark Arts should be enough to prepare the students to successfully take their exams. (In a subversion, though, the ''real'' reason for the dumbed-down, book-taught Defense Against the Dark Arts class is to ensure the students ''don't'' have any practical knowledge.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the film ''Three Days of the Condor'', based on the novel ''Six Days of the Condor'', Joe Turner's job for the CIA is to read books, newspapers, and magazines from around the world, looking for hidden meanings and new ideas. When the CallToAdventure comes to him, he uses his book learning to survive.

to:

* In the film ''Three ''{{Three Days of the Condor'', Condor}}'', based on the novel ''Six Days of the Condor'', Joe Turner's job for the CIA is to read books, newspapers, and magazines from around the world, looking for hidden meanings and new ideas. When the CallToAdventure comes to him, he uses his book learning to survive.
* In ''Train of Life'', the driver of the locomotive had to teach himself from a book. Actually, it works.



* In the ''{{Discworld}}'' novel ''Wintersmith'', Roland believes that he will be an expert swordsman because he has read the fencing manuals and fought many imaginary swordfights in his mind.
** The Rupert in ''Monstrous Regiment'' does the same thing. He actually cuts his own hand practicing out of a book.

to:

* In the ''{{Discworld}}'' novel ''Wintersmith'', ''Discworld/{{Wintersmith}}'', Roland believes that he will be an expert swordsman because he has read the fencing manuals and fought many imaginary swordfights in his mind.
** The Rupert in ''Monstrous Regiment'' ''Discworld/MonstrousRegiment'' does the same thing. He actually cuts his own hand practicing out of a book.



* Taken to its logical extreme in FlightOfTheConchords.

to:

* Taken to its logical extreme in FlightOfTheConchords.''FlightOfTheConchords''.



* The Factotum class (dungeonscape) in DungeonsAndDragons has this as it's premise. As a result it's class skills are "All", even obscure class specific ones are treated as class skills for a factotum.

to:

* The Factotum class (dungeonscape) in DungeonsAndDragons ''DungeonsAndDragons'' has this as it's premise. As a result it's class skills are "All", even obscure class specific ones are treated as class skills for a factotum.



* Subverted in FamilyGuy, for a CrowningMomentOfFunny.

to:

* Subverted in FamilyGuy, ''FamilyGuy'', for a CrowningMomentOfFunny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** His sword hand, in fact. Do not ask how.

Top