Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ArtisticLicenseLawEnforcement

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not only that, but she and the other officers get their daily assignments directly from the Chief of Police. In a large city, the Chief is mostly an administrative position, and rarely gets involved in such day-to-day management. That's what precinct captains are for.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WebVideo/SMPLive'': Police officer is a role held by one or two server members at time and passed around weekly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/Forever2014'':
** In "The Frustrating Thing About Psychopaths" a mysterious package is found on Hanson's desk, with blood leaking from it. Henry unties the bow to open it; proper forensic technique would call for cutting the ribbon somewhere away from the bow so as to preserve it. The type of knot and exactly how it was tied, as well as any hairs, fibers, or particulates caught up in the knot, could be important evidence.
** Also in "The Frustrating Thing About Psychopaths," Henry seems to think that the original Jack the Ripper would have been able to recreate Mary Kelley's murder more precisely than a copycat. In reality ''only'' a copycat would have bothered to recreate an old murder so precisely. The original killer wouldn't have noted the exact location, length, and shape of every mark on the victim; they'd see a new murder as a new murder, likely showing the style of other scenes but not the exact details.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/SonicTheHedgehog'': Subverted. In the trailer, Sonic is tranquilized by Sheriff Tom Wachowski, but in the actual movie, it is revealed that the tranquilizer gun belongs to his wife, a veterinarian, rather than being issued to him to carry out his duties.

to:

* ''Film/SonicTheHedgehog'': ''Film/SonicTheHedgehog2020'': Subverted. In the trailer, Sonic is tranquilized by Sheriff Tom Wachowski, but in the actual movie, it is revealed that the tranquilizer gun belongs to his wife, a veterinarian, rather than being issued to him to carry out his duties.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the pilot episode, after Murtaugh [[{{Irony}} shoots his suicidal partner Riggs in the foot to save him from a sniper atop a building]], he's isn't put on administrative leave and there's no investigation to see whether or not the use of said firearm was necessary.

to:

** In the pilot episode, after Murtaugh [[{{Irony}} shoots his suicidal partner Riggs in the foot to save him from a sniper atop a building]], he's he isn't put on administrative leave and there's no investigation to see whether or not the use of said firearm was necessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the pilot episode, after Murtaugh [[{{Irony}} shoots his suicidal partner Riggs in the foot to save him from a sniper atop a building]], he's isn't put on administrative leave and no investigation is conducted.

to:

** In the pilot episode, after Murtaugh [[{{Irony}} shoots his suicidal partner Riggs in the foot to save him from a sniper atop a building]], he's isn't put on administrative leave and there's no investigation is conducted.to see whether or not the use of said firearm was necessary.

Added: 404

Changed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/LethalWeapon2016'': In "Flight Risk", Murtaugh interrogates his daughter, Riana. In RealLife, an officer would never be asked to interrogate a family member and they would get a different officer for that.

to:

* ''Series/LethalWeapon2016'': ''Series/LethalWeapon2016'':
**
In "Flight Risk", Murtaugh interrogates his daughter, Riana. In RealLife, an officer would never be asked to interrogate a family member and they would get a different officer for that.
** In the pilot episode, after Murtaugh [[{{Irony}} shoots his suicidal partner Riggs in the foot to save him from a sniper atop a building]], he's isn't put on administrative leave and no investigation is conducted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CopKillerManhunt: A police officer's colleagues may hunt down someone who has killed him/her, but the priority shall always be to arrest, not [[VigilanteExecution summarily execute]], the murderer. Even the slightest suspicion of trying to exploit a fellow officer's death to justify PoliceBrutality usually gets InternalAffairs (and other superiors) very mad and the suspected officers to have very short careers.

to:

* CopKillerManhunt: A police officer's colleagues may hunt down someone who has killed him/her, but the priority shall always be to arrest, not [[VigilanteExecution summarily execute]], the murderer. Even the slightest suspicion of trying to exploit a fellow officer's death or injury to justify PoliceBrutality usually gets InternalAffairs (and other superiors) very mad and the suspected officers to have very short careers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Being a pastiche of [[CowboyCop Cowboy Cops]] in general. ''VideoGame/PursuitForce'' features the titular elite task force where they regularly engage in high-speed shootouts and generally engage in lethal force against criminals (and when they do make an arrest, it involves violent beatdowns before cuffing them), own a helicopter ''armed'' with a Gatling gun, using guns owned by criminals, and, in the second game, one of the rookie PF officers is even armed with a ''light machine gun''.
* The first ''VideoGame/ResidentEvil1'' (and ''[[VideoGame/ResidentEvilRemake Remake]]'') has the S.T.A.R.S. (for what is technically supposed to be an elite police force) be equipped with heavy duty, military-grade equipment such a grenade launcher, and even a ''rocket launcher'' (something that will not be issued to a real life law enforcement). Barry is an egregious case as he is armed with a .44 Magnum in a police operation (again, it is considered an unapproved firearm and such a caliber is forbidden for obvious reasons).

to:

* Being a pastiche of [[CowboyCop Cowboy Cops]] in general. ''VideoGame/PursuitForce'' features the titular elite task force where they regularly engage in high-speed shootouts and generally engage in lethal force against criminals (and when they do make an arrest, it involves violent beatdowns before cuffing them), own a helicopter ''armed'' with a Gatling gun, using guns owned by criminals, and, in the second game, one of the rookie PF officers is even armed with a ''light machine gun''.
gun''. This makes one wonder if the InternalAffairs isn't gonna go bonkers over the fact of this unit's very existence.
* The first ''VideoGame/ResidentEvil1'' (and ''[[VideoGame/ResidentEvilRemake Remake]]'') has the S.T.A.R.S. (for what is technically supposed to be an elite police force) be equipped with heavy duty, military-grade equipment such a grenade launcher, and even a ''rocket launcher'' (something that will not be issued to a real life law enforcement). Barry is an egregious case case, as he is armed with a .a version of the Samurai Edge modified to fire a ''.44 Magnum Magnum'', in what is essentiallly a police operation (again, it is considered an unapproved firearm and such a caliber is forbidden for obvious reasons).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FingertipDrugAnalysis: Crime labs are supposed to handle drug analysis. A cop who touches (or worse, ''tastes'') an unknown substance contaminates the crime scene and risks exposure to what may be a deadly toxin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
respect the hyphen


* ''Film/SpiderManHomecoming'': [=SpiderMan=] scales the Washington Monument while being pursued by a police helicopter. Contrary to popular belief, police helicopters are not a frontline service; they're a support for the ground units, since it's hard to shoot accurately from a helicopter.

to:

* ''Film/SpiderManHomecoming'': [=SpiderMan=] Spider-Man scales the Washington Monument while being pursued by a police helicopter. Contrary to popular belief, police helicopters are not a frontline service; they're a support for the ground units, since it's hard to shoot accurately from a helicopter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/PrisonBreak'': In the second season, Bellick is shown actively participating in the manhunt for the escaped prisoners. This wouldn't happen. He's a prison guard, not a law enforcement officer. His authority ends at the prison gate. State and local police would have handled the manhunt. Although, Bellick is basically acting as a CowboyCop at that point, pursuing the escapees out of pure anger for tying him up to secure their escape and embarassing him. When the escaped prisoners board a train and start to disperse through the country, the FBI takes over and Bellick is fired for his awful performance.

to:

* ''Series/PrisonBreak'': In the second season, Bellick is shown actively participating in the manhunt for the escaped prisoners. This wouldn't happen. He's a prison guard, not a law enforcement officer. His authority ends at the prison gate. State and local police would have handled the manhunt. Although, Bellick is basically acting as a CowboyCop at that point, pursuing the escapees out of pure anger for tying him up to secure their escape and embarassing him. When the escaped prisoners board a train and start to disperse through the country, the FBI takes over and Bellick is fired for his awful performance. While he does continue to pursue the Fox River Eight after that, it's without any kind of legal authority: Bellick and his partner are simply interested in retrieving the money that one of the men who took part in the escape plan had buried somewhere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/PrisonBreak'': In the second season, Bellick is shown actively participating in the manhunt for the escaped prisoners. This wouldn't happen. He's a prison guard, not a law enforcement officer. His authority ends at the prison gate. State and local police would have handled the manhunt.

to:

* ''Series/PrisonBreak'': In the second season, Bellick is shown actively participating in the manhunt for the escaped prisoners. This wouldn't happen. He's a prison guard, not a law enforcement officer. His authority ends at the prison gate. State and local police would have handled the manhunt. Although, Bellick is basically acting as a CowboyCop at that point, pursuing the escapees out of pure anger for tying him up to secure their escape and embarassing him. When the escaped prisoners board a train and start to disperse through the country, the FBI takes over and Bellick is fired for his awful performance.

Added: 441

Changed: 446

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''Series/{{Monk}}'': In "Mr. Monk And The Really, Really Dead Guy", the FBI are called in to take the lead on a case involving a victim who was murdered in an exceptionally brutal manner. In real life, the FBI wouldn't be anywhere near this case unless unless the killer had crossed state lines while committing the crime, the crime was committed during a federal offense, or the murder was a political assassination. None of these apply to the case in this episode.

to:

* ''Series/{{Monk}}'': ''Series/{{Monk}}'':
**
In "Mr. Monk And The Really, Really Dead Guy", the FBI are called in to take the lead on a case involving a victim who was murdered in an exceptionally brutal manner. In real life, the FBI wouldn't be anywhere near this case unless unless the killer had crossed state lines while committing the crime, the crime was committed during a federal offense, or the murder was a political assassination. None of these apply to the case in this episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cross-wick

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/LifeOnMars2006'': During an interview John Stalker, Deputy Chief Constable of Greater Manchester in the early 1980s and himself a Detective Inspector in 1973, has stated that the depiction of the police "has got nothing to do with real policing in the 1970s. It could not be more inaccurate in terms of procedure, the way they talk or the way they dress. In all the time I was in the CID in the 1970s I never saw a copper in a leather bomber jacket and I never heard an officer call anyone 'guv' ... Actually, there were a few police officers in London who started to behave like Regan and Carter in ''Series/TheSweeney'', but that was a case of life following art, not the other way round". The journalist who interviewed Stalker, Ray King, remarks that the depiction of the police can be defended if we assume that Sam is indeed in a coma and that we are seeing his imaginary idea of 1973, filtered through 1970s police shows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleting a paragraph that was added by a troper who was ban evading at the time.


Searching someone's vehicle requires that police either be given permission, have a search warrant, or that the driver be placed under arrest (conducting a Search-Incident-To-Arrest of a vehicle is allowed). However, if a police officer asks to search your vehicle and you refuse, they cannot search your vehicle and would be violating your Fourth Amendment rights if they went ahead and searched it anyway, plus any evidence they find would be ruled inadmissable. In fiction, cops ignore this all all the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MustStateIfYoureACop: Contrary to popular belief, a police officer is not under obligation to answer truthfully when asked if they're a cop.

to:

* MustStateIfYoureACop: Contrary to popular belief, a An undercover police officer is legally allowed to say "no, I'm not under obligation to answer truthfully when a cop" if asked if they're about it. (Real cops aren't exactly in a cop.hurry to correct this UrbanLegend, since it helps with their job.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Searching someone's vehicle requires that police either be given permission, have a search warrant, or that the driver be placed under arrest (conducting a Search-Incident-To-Arrest of a vehicle is allowed). However, if a police officer asks to search your vehicle and you refuse, they cannot search your vehicle and would be violating your Fourth Amendment rights if they went ahead and searched it anyway, plus any evidence they find would be ruled inadmissable. In fiction, cops ignore this all all the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GenericCopBadges: Cop badges in fiction are poorly detailed and don't reflect the ones from RealLife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Johnny Gat's backstory in ''VideoGame/AgentsOfMayhem'' reveals that he was kicked out of the Newark Police Department for his brutal methods with dealing with criminals. That is realistic in itself, but what makes it unrealistic is that the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency found his abilities to be very useful and is transferred to Seoul, Korea to fight crime. The real life SMPA would never allow the likes of Gat to join their ranks due to their even stricter rules and regulations compared to their American counterparts.

to:

* Johnny Gat's backstory in ''VideoGame/AgentsOfMayhem'' reveals that he was kicked out of the Newark Police Department for his brutal methods with when dealing with criminals. That is realistic in itself, but what makes it unrealistic is that the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency found his abilities to be very useful and is transferred to Seoul, Korea to fight crime. The real life SMPA would never allow the likes of Gat to join their ranks due to their even stricter rules and regulations compared to their American counterparts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Johnny Gat's backstory in ''VideoGame/AgentsOfMayhem'' reveals that he was kicked out of the Newark Police Department for his brutal methods with dealing with criminals. That is realistic in itself, but what makes it unrealistic is that the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency found his abilities to be very useful and is transferred to Seoul, Korea to fight crime. The real life SMPA would never allow the likes of Gat to join their ranks due to their even stricter rules and regulations compared to their American counterparts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/AWindNamedAmnesia'': There is a character named Little John who is shown as being the former sheriff of the LAPD (Los Angeles municipal Police Department). This is completely wrong. The sheriff is the head of the LASD (Los Angeles county Sheriff's Department) which handles matters of Los Angeles county, while the LAPD handles the matters of the city of Los Angeles. The LAPD has a Commissioner and Chief of Police but no sheriff. The confusion is somewhat understandable- since the city of Los Angeles is within the county of Los Angeles, the sheriff does have some power but is not the "top cop" there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/TheNutJob'': Part of the robbers' getaway plan was to cross state lines, apparently expecting the police that were hot on their tails to suddenly break off pursuit at that invisible boundary. Police ''can'' cross state lines in pursuit of a suspect if the person is suspected of a felony (e.g. robbing a bank); that is the very definition of the term, "Hot Pursuit".

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/TheNutJob'': Part of the robbers' getaway plan was to cross state lines, apparently expecting the police that were hot on their tails to suddenly break off pursuit at that invisible boundary. Police ''can'' cross state lines in pursuit of a suspect if the person is suspected of a felony (e.g. robbing a bank); that is the very definition of the term, "Hot Pursuit". Crossing a state line in the commission of a felony also means that the police can escalate it to federal law enforcement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Anime/DominionTankPolice'' parodies the over-militarization of police forces to extreme levels (such as issuing tanks to every police division just to fight crime), so it never takes itself too seriously despite the plot. An early scene features a JackBauerInterrogationTechnique where-in a criminal has a grenade shoved into his mouth, and the officers turn the interrogation into a game featuring a spin wheel and Leona dressed up as a PlayboyBunny. Police chief Brenten ''encourages'' this behavior.

to:

* ''Anime/DominionTankPolice'' parodies the over-militarization of police forces to extreme levels (such as issuing tanks to every police division just to fight crime), so it never takes itself too seriously despite the plot. An early scene features a JackBauerInterrogationTechnique where-in a criminal has a grenade shoved into his mouth, and the officers turn the interrogation into a game featuring throwing knives, a spin wheel wheel, and Leona dressed up as a PlayboyBunny. Police chief Brenten ''encourages'' this behavior.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/{{Zootopia}}'': Judy is excited to begin her first day as a police officer, only to find out she's stuck on parking duty. Most major cities in real life have a whole separate department of parking services whose primary job is issuing citations so that the police are free to handle bigger crimes. While suburbs and smaller towns (at least in the United States and its FantasyCounterpartCultures) might still leave this task to the police, a city as huge as Zootopia would not.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/{{Zootopia}}'': Judy is excited to begin her first day as a police officer, only to find out she's stuck on parking duty. Most major cities in real life have a whole separate department of parking services whose primary job is issuing citations so that the police are free to handle bigger crimes. While suburbs and smaller towns (at least in the United States and its FantasyCounterpartCultures) {{Fantasy Counterpart Culture}}s) might still leave this task to the police, a city as huge as Zootopia would not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He says the French police judiciaire is the equivalent of the FBI. It's not-this refers simply to detectives. The closest France has to the FBI is the National Police, but there is no exact equivalent because of the way France's government is organized. It is not federated like the US, so there's no need for an interstate agency. The National Police takes care of civil law enforcement duties for the entire country -- except in smaller towns and more remote areas, where the Gendarmerie has jurisdiction, and municipal police exist in some towns and cities -- and the police judiciaire is the section of the National Police that investigates the most serious crimes such as murders. Whether this is a case of CreatorProvincialism or just another case of Dan not doing the research (or both) isn't clear.

to:

** He says the French police judiciaire is the equivalent of the FBI. It's not-this not- this refers simply to detectives. The closest France has to the FBI is the National Police, but there is no exact equivalent because of the way France's government is organized. It is not federated like the US, so there's no need for an interstate agency. The National Police takes care of civil law enforcement duties for the entire country -- except in smaller towns and more remote areas, where the Gendarmerie has jurisdiction, and municipal police exist in some towns and cities -- and the police judiciaire is the section of the National Police that investigates the most serious crimes such as murders. Whether this is a case of CreatorProvincialism or just another case of Dan not doing the research (or both) isn't clear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the other side of the issue, non-lethal weapons are treated as completely free in their use: You can use them to pacify defiant civilians and have no punishment in using them well beyond the point where a suspect is neutralised, both examples of which would be be considered improper use of force in reality.

to:

** On the other side of the issue, non-lethal weapons are treated as completely free in their use: You can use them to pacify defiant on perfectly cooperative civilians and have no punishment in using them well beyond the point where a suspect is neutralised, both examples of which would be be considered improper use of force in reality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It is illegal to shoot a fleeing suspect as long as they have not fired their weapon. The ability for the police to shoot at fleeing suspects is one of the most controversial parts of police procedure, but to summarise, an armed and fleeing suspect who has already demonstrated themselves to be a threat to civilians or the police is generally seen as permissible to use deadly force against. In the context of the game, killing an armed suspect in the midst of a hostage situation would likely be easily justified due to the risk that letting them flee could allow them to harm civilians or get into a better defensive position.

to:

** It is illegal to shoot a fleeing suspect as long as they have not fired their weapon. The ability for the police to shoot at fleeing suspects is one of the most controversial parts of police procedure, but to summarise, an armed and fleeing suspect who has already demonstrated themselves to be a threat to civilians or the police is generally seen as permissible to use deadly force against. In the context of the game, killing an armed suspect in the midst of a hostage situation would likely be easily justified due to the risk that letting them flee could allow them to harm civilians or get into a better defensive position.position, and whether they have fired their gun or not is irrelevant to making that judgement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/SWAT4'' features Use of Deadly Force regulations as a key part of its gameplay loop: You cannot use lethal force against a suspect without first giving them a chance to surrender, or against a suspect who is not directly threatening you or a civilian with a weapon. As a concession to gameplay, the portrayal of Deadly Force laws is never quite accurate in a range of ways:
** Many missions involve dealing with suspects who are active shooters intent on harming civilians, or are militia and terrorist-level threats. Deadly force would almost certainly be given blanket authorisation in these situations.
** It is illegal to shoot a fleeing suspect as long as they have not fired their weapon. The ability for the police to shoot at fleeing suspects is one of the most controversial parts of police procedure, but to summarise, an armed and fleeing suspect who has already demonstrated themselves to be a threat to civilians or the police is generally seen as permissible to use deadly force against. In the context of the game, killing an armed suspect in the midst of a hostage situation would likely be easily justified due to the risk that letting them flee could allow them to harm civilians or get into a better defensive position.
** Snipers are exempt from the rules of engagement, so the game has no issues with them assassinating suspects while you're serving a warrant.
** On the other side of the issue, non-lethal weapons are treated as completely free in their use: You can use them to pacify defiant civilians and have no punishment in using them well beyond the point where a suspect is neutralised, both examples of which would be be considered improper use of force in reality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the ''Series/ICarly'' episode "iToe Fat Cakes" Sam is caught smuggling Canadian Fat Cakes (which are illegal in the US) back to America. But in real life the Canada police cannot make Canadian Fat Cakes illegal in the United States. That would be up to the United States Congress to pass such laws mandating that. If Canadian Fat Cakes were banned from importation into the United States, this would be a violation of the North American Free Trade Agreement. This would almost certainly result in Canada filing a complaint with the World Trade Organization.

Top