Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / WintersTale

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FullNameBasis: Peter Lake is always called by both his names, first in order to differentiate him from the other Baymen children named Peter, and later simply because he's used to it.
* ValuesDissonance: InUniverse. One of the reasons Peter is sent to New York City after twelve years on the marshes is that he'll never be able to fully participate in the Baymen community since, as a foundling, he can never engage in a truly incestuous relationship, which is considered a rite of passage.

to:

* FullNameBasis: Peter Lake is always called by both his names, first in order to differentiate him from the other Baymen Bayman children named Peter, and later simply because he's used to it.
* ValuesDissonance: InUniverse. One of the reasons Peter is sent to New York City after twelve years on the marshes is that he'll never be able to fully participate in the Baymen Bayman community since, as a foundling, he can never engage in a truly incestuous relationship, which is considered a rite of passage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


TheFilmOfTheBook was released on Valentine's Day in 2014, starring Colin Farrell as Peter Lake, Jessica Brown Findlay as Beverly Penn, and Creator/RussellCrowe as Pearly Soames.

to:

TheFilmOfTheBook was released on Valentine's Day in 2014, starring Colin Farrell Creator/ColinFarrell as Peter Lake, Jessica Brown Findlay as Beverly Penn, and Creator/RussellCrowe as Pearly Soames.



----

to:

----

Added: 387

Changed: 163

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Winter's Tale'' (alternatively titled ''A New York Winter's Tale'' in the UK and some other markets) is a 1983 novel by Mark Helprin. It's usually described as belonging to the school of MagicRealism, incorporating elements of fantasy, romance, and historical fiction. It follows a burglar named Peter Lake, who meets a dying young woman, Beverly, when robbing her father's fortress-like home in New York, and his subsequent efforts to save her life.

to:

''Winter's Tale'' (alternatively titled ''A New York Winter's Tale'' in the UK and some other markets) is a 1983 novel by Mark Helprin. It's usually described as belonging to the school of MagicRealism, incorporating elements of fantasy, romance, and historical fiction. It follows a burglar named Peter Lake, who meets a dying young woman, Beverly, when robbing her father's fortress-like home in New York, York in TheEdwardianEra, and his subsequent efforts to save her life.
life, which end up having unexpected results decades down the line.



* WhiteStallion / CoolHorse: Athansor

to:

* WhiteStallion / CoolHorse: Athansor
Athansor.



** A very minor one. Beverly is aged up to 21 from 18 in the book.
** Willa is aged up from a three-year-old toddler to a kid of six or seven.

to:

** A very minor one. one: Beverly is aged up to 21 from 18 in the book.
** Willa is aged up from a three-year-old toddler to a kid of six or seven.seven (probably because toddler actors are rare-to-nonexistent).



* BeardOfSorrow: Peter has one after the TimeSkip (and, more importantly, [[spoiler: Beverly's death]]) but loses it as he begins to remember his identity.



* GodIsEvil: Pearly suggests that this is the reason why there's so much suffering in the world by way of taunting Peter after [[spoiler: Beverly's death]] -- that God likes to watch the endless, doomed struggle of good versus evil.



* NoodleIncident: What happened the last time Pearly was allowed out of the city.
* {{Satan}}: [[spoiler:The Judge, whom Pearly also addresses as either "Lucifer" or "Lu."]]

to:

* NoodleIncident: What happened the last ''last'' time Pearly was allowed out of the city.
* {{Satan}}: [[spoiler:The Turns out to be [[spoiler: The Judge, whom Pearly also addresses as either "Lucifer" or "Lu."]]



----

to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added namespaces.


Not to be confused with the play ''TheWintersTale'' by WilliamShakespeare.

to:

Not to be confused with the play ''TheWintersTale'' ''Theatre/TheWintersTale'' by WilliamShakespeare.Creator/WilliamShakespeare.

Added: 107

Changed: 305

Removed: 325

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
To paraphrase the Word Cruft page, a trope cannot be \"somewhat averted\" any more than an expectant mother can be \"somewhat pregnant\". Also fixing alphabetisation, and The Film Of The Book is more of a genre than a trope.


* VictorianNovelDisease: Beverly suffers from consumption (tuberculosis), which is ''the'' physical illness associated with this trope, since it allows the heroine to die tragically while retaining her beauty right up until the end.[[note]]RealLife cases of tuberculosis are not quite as pretty, it's important to note.[[/note]]
** It's somewhat {{Averted}} in the novel in that she's often flushed bright red as a side-effect of her symptoms, and when she eventually dies Peter Lake describes her as ranting mad and horribly emaciated. PlayedStraight in the film adaptation, though.

to:

* VictorianNovelDisease: Beverly suffers from consumption (tuberculosis), which is ''the'' physical illness associated with this trope, since it allows the heroine to die tragically while retaining her beauty right up until the end.[[note]]RealLife cases of tuberculosis are not quite as pretty, it's important to note.[[/note]]
** It's somewhat
[[/note]] {{Averted}} in the novel in that she's often flushed bright red as a side-effect of her symptoms, and when she eventually dies Peter Lake describes her as ranting mad and horribly emaciated. PlayedStraight in the film adaptation, though.



* AgeLift: A very minor one. Beverly is aged up to 21 from 18 in the book.

to:

* AgeLift: AgeLift:
**
A very minor one. Beverly is aged up to 21 from 18 in the book.



* EvilIsHammy: Both the Judge and Pearly.



* EvilIsHammy: Both the Judge and Pearly.



* TheFilmOfTheBook: Obviously.



* ScaryBlackMan:[[spoiler: Creator/WillSmith]] as The Judge, complete with VoiceOfTheLegion at certain points in his scenes.

to:

* ScaryBlackMan:[[spoiler: Creator/WillSmith]] ScaryBlackMan: [[spoiler:Creator/WillSmith]] as The Judge, complete with VoiceOfTheLegion at certain points in his scenes.



* VoiceOfTheLegion: The Judge

to:

* VoiceOfTheLegion: The JudgeJudge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonForeigner: [[Spoiler: Creator/WillSmith]]'s character "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. [[{{Satan}} Lucifer]]]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.

to:

* CanonForeigner: [[Spoiler: [[spoiler: Creator/WillSmith]]'s character "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. [[{{Satan}} Lucifer]]]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.



* ScaryBlackMan:[[Spoiler: Creator/WillSmith]] as The Judge, complete with VoiceOfTheLegion at certain points in his scenes.

to:

* ScaryBlackMan:[[Spoiler: ScaryBlackMan:[[spoiler: Creator/WillSmith]] as The Judge, complete with VoiceOfTheLegion at certain points in his scenes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It\'s better the spoilered out this particular actor... Adds up to the surprise for viewers.


* CanonForeigner: [[Spoiler Creator/WillSmith]]'s character "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. [[{{Satan}} Lucifer]]]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.

to:

* CanonForeigner: [[Spoiler [[Spoiler: Creator/WillSmith]]'s character "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. [[{{Satan}} Lucifer]]]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It\'s better the spoilered out this particular actor... Adds up to the sur


* CanonForeigner: Creator/WillSmith's character "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. [[{{Satan}} Lucifer]]]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.

to:

* CanonForeigner: Creator/WillSmith's [[Spoiler Creator/WillSmith]]'s character "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. [[{{Satan}} Lucifer]]]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.



* ScaryBlackMan: Creator/WillSmith as The Judge, complete with VoiceOfTheLegion at certain points in his scenes.

to:

* ScaryBlackMan: Creator/WillSmith ScaryBlackMan:[[Spoiler: Creator/WillSmith]] as The Judge, complete with VoiceOfTheLegion at certain points in his scenes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnachronismStew: Deliberately with the Judge; he's wearing a Music/JimiHendrix t-shirt in 1915.

to:

* AnachronismStew: Deliberately with the Judge; he's wearing a Music/JimiHendrix t-shirt in and reading ''[[StephenHawking A Brief History of Time]]''. In 1915.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CompositeCharacter: Willa becomes the head of the Penn family's newspaper empire and a major character in the modern day parts of the film; in the book, it was her brother [[AdaptedOut Harry]] who became editor and eventually reconnected with Peter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two-hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Reverend Mootfowl, Jackson Mead, Hardesty Marratta and Martin Gamely (Virginia's husband and son from her first marriage, respectively), Virginia's mother, Harry's daughter Jessica, Jessica's fiancé Praeger de Pinto, and Asbury and Christiana (friends and co-workers of the Penns, Marrattas and Praeger, and later of Peter Lake as well). Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature, a.k.a. Cecil Wooley, makes it into the film, but his role is greatly reduced, not to mention changed so much that all the two characters have in common is their name and their broad function as Peter's maybe-guardian angel. Basically, the only main characters from the exclusively modern-day sections of the book to make it into the film are Virginia and Abby, with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day through sheer coincidence. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller, since the elderly Harry is essentially a main character in the book but only makes a cameo appearance as a young adolescent in the film.

to:

* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two-hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Reverend Mootfowl, Jackson Mead, Beverly and Willa's two brothers, Hardesty Marratta and Martin Gamely (Virginia's husband and son from her first marriage, respectively), Virginia's mother, Harry's daughter Jessica, Jessica's fiancé Praeger de Pinto, and Asbury and Christiana (friends and co-workers of the Penns, Marrattas and Praeger, and later of Peter Lake as well). Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature, a.k.a. Cecil Wooley, makes it into the film, but his role is greatly reduced, not to mention changed so much that all the two characters have in common is their name and their broad function as Peter's maybe-guardian angel. Basically, the only main characters from the exclusively modern-day sections of the book to make it into the film are Virginia and Abby, with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day through sheer coincidence. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, coincidence - though a sharp viewer will notice that Beverly's father does mention that their roles next-door neighbours are much smaller, since named the elderly Harry is essentially a main character in the book but only makes a cameo appearance as a young adolescent in the film.Gamelys at one point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two-hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature (a.k.a. Cecil Wooley), Reverend Mootfowl, Jackson Mead, Hardesty Marratta and Martin Gamely (Virginia's husband and son from her first marriage, respectively), Virginia's mother, Harry's daughter Jessica, Jessica's fiancé Praeger de Pinto, and Asbury and Christiana (friends and co-workers of the Penns, Marrattas and Praeger, and later of Peter Lake as well). Basically, the only main characters from the exclusively modern-day sections of the book to make it into the film are Virginia and Abby, with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day through sheer coincidence. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller, since the elderly Harry is essentially a main character in the book but only makes a cameo appearance as a young adolescent in the film.

to:

* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two-hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Reverend Mootfowl, Jackson Mead, Hardesty Marratta and Martin Gamely (Virginia's husband and son from her first marriage, respectively), Virginia's mother, Harry's daughter Jessica, Jessica's fiancé Praeger de Pinto, and Asbury and Christiana (friends and co-workers of the Penns, Marrattas and Praeger, and later of Peter Lake as well). Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature (a.Mature, a.k.a. Cecil Wooley), Reverend Mootfowl, Jackson Mead, Hardesty Marratta Wooley, makes it into the film, but his role is greatly reduced, not to mention changed so much that all the two characters have in common is their name and Martin Gamely (Virginia's husband and son from her first marriage, respectively), Virginia's mother, Harry's daughter Jessica, Jessica's fiancé Praeger de Pinto, and Asbury and Christiana (friends and co-workers of the Penns, Marrattas and Praeger, and later of Peter Lake their broad function as well).Peter's maybe-guardian angel. Basically, the only main characters from the exclusively modern-day sections of the book to make it into the film are Virginia and Abby, with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day through sheer coincidence. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller, since the elderly Harry is essentially a main character in the book but only makes a cameo appearance as a young adolescent in the film.

Added: 769

Changed: 2875

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Winter's Tale'' (alternatively titled ''A New York Winter's Tale'' in the UK and some other markets) is a 1983 novel by Mark Helprin. It's usually described as belonging to the school of [[MagicRealism Magical Realism]], incorporating elements of fantasy, romance, and historical fiction. It follows a burglar named Peter Lake, who meets a dying young woman, Beverly, when robbing her father's fortress-like home in New York, and his subsequent efforts to save her life.

TheFilmOfTheBook was released on Valentine's Day in 2014, starring Colin Farrell as Peter Lake, Jessica Brown Findlay as Beverly Penn, and RussellCrowe as Pearly Soames.

to:

''Winter's Tale'' (alternatively titled ''A New York Winter's Tale'' in the UK and some other markets) is a 1983 novel by Mark Helprin. It's usually described as belonging to the school of [[MagicRealism Magical Realism]], MagicRealism, incorporating elements of fantasy, romance, and historical fiction. It follows a burglar named Peter Lake, who meets a dying young woman, Beverly, when robbing her father's fortress-like home in New York, and his subsequent efforts to save her life.

TheFilmOfTheBook was released on Valentine's Day in 2014, starring Colin Farrell as Peter Lake, Jessica Brown Findlay as Beverly Penn, and RussellCrowe Creator/RussellCrowe as Pearly Soames.









* WhiteStallion[=/=]CoolHorse: Athansor.

to:

* WhiteStallion[=/=]CoolHorse: Athansor.
WhiteStallion / CoolHorse: Athansor



* BrotherSisterIncest: A common - one might even call it traditional - practice among the adolescents in the community of Baymen who raise Peter. Peter himself practices it with his foster sister Anarinda, though because they aren't blood relatives it's actually frowned upon by the community.

to:


* BrotherSisterIncest: A common - common, one might even call it traditional - traditional, practice among the adolescents in the community of Baymen who raise Peter. Peter himself practices it with his foster sister Anarinda, though because they aren't blood relatives relatives, it's actually frowned upon by the community.



* ValuesDissonance: In-universe: One of the reasons Peter is sent to New York City after twelve years on the marshes is that he'll never be able to fully participate in the Baymen community, since as a foundling he can never engage in a truly incestuous relationship which is considered a rite of passage.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: In-universe: InUniverse. One of the reasons Peter is sent to New York City after twelve years on the marshes is that he'll never be able to fully participate in the Baymen community, since community since, as a foundling foundling, he can never engage in a truly incestuous relationship relationship, which is considered a rite of passage.



* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature (a.k.a. Cecil Wooley), Reverend Mootfowl, Jackson Mead, Hardesty Marratta and Martin Gamely (Virginia's husband and son from her first marriage, respectively), Virginia's mother, Harry's daughter Jessica, Jessica's fiancé Praeger de Pinto, and Asbury and Christiana (friends and co-workers of the Penns, Marrattas and Praeger, and later of Peter Lake as well). Basically the only main characters from the exclusively modern day sections of the book to make it into the film are Virginia and Abby - with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day through sheer coincidence. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller, since the elderly Harry is essentially a main character in the book but only makes a cameo appearance as a young adolescent in the film.
* AgeLift: A very minor one: Beverly is aged up to 21, from 18 in the book.

to:


* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two hour two-hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature (a.k.a. Cecil Wooley), Reverend Mootfowl, Jackson Mead, Hardesty Marratta and Martin Gamely (Virginia's husband and son from her first marriage, respectively), Virginia's mother, Harry's daughter Jessica, Jessica's fiancé Praeger de Pinto, and Asbury and Christiana (friends and co-workers of the Penns, Marrattas and Praeger, and later of Peter Lake as well). Basically Basically, the only main characters from the exclusively modern day modern-day sections of the book to make it into the film are Virginia and Abby - Abby, with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day through sheer coincidence. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller, since the elderly Harry is essentially a main character in the book but only makes a cameo appearance as a young adolescent in the film.
* AgeLift: A very minor one: one. Beverly is aged up to 21, 21 from 18 in the book.



* AnachronismStew: Deliberately with Judge: he's wearing a JimiHendrix t-shirt, in 1915.
* CanonForeigner: WillSmith's character, "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. {{Lucifer}}]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.

to:

* AnachronismStew: Deliberately with Judge: the Judge; he's wearing a JimiHendrix t-shirt, Music/JimiHendrix t-shirt in 1915.
* CanonForeigner: WillSmith's character, Creator/WillSmith's character "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. {{Lucifer}}]] [[{{Satan}} Lucifer]]]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.novel.
* FauxAffablyEvil: Both Pearly and the Judge.



* EvilIsHammy: Both the Judge and Pearly.



* MindScrew: The plot is amazing complicated, and any reviewer attempting to explain it tends to come across as insane.
* NoodleIncident: What happened the last time Pearley was allowed out of the city.

to:

* MindScrew: The plot is amazing amazingly complicated, and any reviewer attempting to explain it tends to come across as insane.
* NoodleIncident: What happened the last time Pearley Pearly was allowed out of the city.



* TimeSkip: Following [[spoiler:Beverly's death]], the movie skips forward ninety-nine years.

to:

* {{Satan}}: [[spoiler:The Judge, whom Pearly also addresses as either "Lucifer" or "Lu."]]
* ScaryBlackMan: Creator/WillSmith as The Judge, complete with VoiceOfTheLegion at certain points in his scenes.
* TimeSkip: Following [[spoiler:Beverly's death]], the movie skips forward ninety-nine years.years.
* VoiceOfTheLegion: The Judge
* WickedCultured: The first time we meet the Judge, he's calmly reading a book.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoodleIncident: What happened the last time Pearley was allowed out of the city.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MindScrew: The plot is amazing complicated, and any reviewer attempting to explain it tends to come across as insane.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesDissonance: One of the reasons Peter is sent to New York City after twelve years on the marshes is that he'll never be able to fully participate in the Baymen community, since as a foundling he can never engage in a truly incestuous relationship which is considered a rite of passage.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: In-universe: One of the reasons Peter is sent to New York City after twelve years on the marshes is that he'll never be able to fully participate in the Baymen community, since as a foundling he can never engage in a truly incestuous relationship which is considered a rite of passage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature, Mootfowl, the bridge architect, and all of the extensive Gamely clan apart from Virginia and her daughter - with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller.

to:

* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature, Mature (a.k.a. Cecil Wooley), Reverend Mootfowl, the bridge architect, Jackson Mead, Hardesty Marratta and all Martin Gamely (Virginia's husband and son from her first marriage, respectively), Virginia's mother, Harry's daughter Jessica, Jessica's fiancé Praeger de Pinto, and Asbury and Christiana (friends and co-workers of the extensive Gamely clan apart Penns, Marrattas and Praeger, and later of Peter Lake as well). Basically the only main characters from the exclusively modern day sections of the book to make it into the film are Virginia and her daughter Abby - with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day. day through sheer coincidence. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller.smaller, since the elderly Harry is essentially a main character in the book but only makes a cameo appearance as a young adolescent in the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VictorianNovelDisease: Beverly suffers from consumption (tuberculosis), which is ''the'' physical illness associated with this trope, since it allows the heroine to die tragically while retaining her beauty right up until the end.[[note]]RealLife cases of tuberculosis are not quite as pretty, it's important to note.[[/note]]
** It's somewhat {{Averted}} in the novel in that she's often flushed bright red as a side-effect of her symptoms, and when she eventually dies Peter Lake describes her as ranting mad and horribly emaciated. PlayedStraight in the film adaptation, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature, and all of the extensive Gamely clan apart from Virginia and her daughter - with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller.

to:

* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature, Mootfowl, the bridge architect, and all of the extensive Gamely clan apart from Virginia and her daughter - with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FullNameBasis: Peter Lake is always called by both his names, first in order to differentiate him from the other Baymen children named Peter, and later simply because he's used to it.


Added DiffLines:

* AdaptedOut: Due to the difficulties of turning an 800-page novel into a two hour film, a great many important characters from the book are entirely absent, including most of the Baymen and the Short Tails, Peter's childhood friend Cecil Mature, and all of the extensive Gamely clan apart from Virginia and her daughter - with the consequence that the Gamelys are no longer old family friends of the Penns, but just a couple of people Peter meets in the present day. Beverly and Willa's brothers do appear in a few scenes, making them two of the few supporting characters not to be cut entirely, though their roles are much smaller.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Willa is aged up from a three-year-old toddler to a kid of six or seven.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ValuesDissonance: One of the reasons Peter is sent to New York City after twelve years on the marshes is that he'll never be able to fully participate in the Baymen community, since as a foundling he can never engage in a truly incestuous relationship which is considered a rite of passage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* BrotherSisterIncest: A common - one might even call it traditional - practice among the adolescents in the community of Baymen who raise Peter. Peter himself practices it with his foster sister Anarinda, though because they aren't blood relatives it's actually frowned upon by the community.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MarketBasedTitle: The film was released as ''A New York Winter's Tale'' in the UK, presumably so audiences wouldn't confuse it with the Shakespeare play. The movie tie-in edition of the novel has also been released under this title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImprobableAge: Peter meets Beverly's young sister Willa in 1915, when she's about six years old. They meet again in 2014, when Willa looks to be in her early eighties at the eldest, despite the fact that she must be well over one hundred years old by this point.

to:

* ImprobableAge: Peter meets Beverly's young sister Willa in 1915, when she's about six years old. They meet again in 2014, when with Willa looks to be in being played by 90-year-old Eva Marie Saint (and very much not looking her early eighties at the eldest, actor's age); this despite the fact that she must be well over one hundred years old by this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ImprobableAge: Peter meets Beverly's young sister Willa in 1915, when she's about six years old. They meet again in 2014, when Willa looks to be in her early eighties at the eldest, despite the fact that she must be well over one hundred years old by this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TimeSkip: Following [[spoiler:Beverly's death]], the movie skips forward one hundred years.

to:

* TimeSkip: Following [[spoiler:Beverly's death]], the movie skips forward one hundred ninety-nine years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheFilmOfTheBook: Obviously.

to:

* TheFilmOfTheBook: Obviously.Obviously.
* TimeSkip: Following [[spoiler:Beverly's death]], the movie skips forward one hundred years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


TheFilmOfTheBook was released in 2014, starring Colin Farrell as Peter Lake, Jessica Brown Findlay as Beverly Penn, and RussellCrowe as Pearly Soames.

to:

TheFilmOfTheBook was released on Valentine's Day in 2014, starring Colin Farrell as Peter Lake, Jessica Brown Findlay as Beverly Penn, and RussellCrowe as Pearly Soames.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''Winter's Tale'' (alternatively titled ''A New York Winter's Tale'' in the UK and some other markets) is a 1983 novel by Mark Helprin. It's usually described as belonging to the school of [[MagicRealism Magical Realism]], incorporating elements of fantasy, romance, and historical fiction. It follows a burglar named Peter Lake, who meets a dying young woman, Beverly, when robbing her father's fortress-like home in New York, and his subsequent efforts to save her life.

TheFilmOfTheBook was released in 2014, starring Colin Farrell as Peter Lake, Jessica Brown Findlay as Beverly Penn, and RussellCrowe as Pearly Soames.

Not to be confused with the play ''TheWintersTale'' by WilliamShakespeare.

----
!!Tropes in both the book and the film:
* IllGirl: Beverly, who is dying from consumption.
* WhiteStallion[=/=]CoolHorse: Athansor.

!!Tropes in the book:

!!Tropes in the film:
* AgeLift: A very minor one: Beverly is aged up to 21, from 18 in the book.
* AnachronismStew: Deliberately with Judge: he's wearing a JimiHendrix t-shirt, in 1915.
* CanonForeigner: WillSmith's character, "The Judge" [[spoiler:a.k.a. {{Lucifer}}]] is not an explicit presence in the novel.
* TheFilmOfTheBook: Obviously.

Top