Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Wintergirls

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BerserkButton: Jennifer gets touchy whenever she thinks Lia is being a bad influence on her daughter, one example being when she compares people being eaten by tigers in the Coliseum to middle school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SelfServingMemory: In fifth grade, after Cassie got in trouble for beating up a bully named Thatcher who snapped her bra, the popular girls called her a "dyke lesbo" and threw her out of their clique. Lia stood up for Cassie by daring Thatcher to punch her, winning the respect of the other girls. After Lia was able to get them to let Cassie back in, they were happy to pretend the whole thing was all Thatcher’s fault.

to:

* SelfServingMemory: In fifth grade, after Cassie got in trouble for beating up a bully named Thatcher who snapped her bra, the popular girls called her a "dyke lesbo" and threw her out of their clique. Lia stood up for Cassie by daring Thatcher to punch her, winning the respect of the other girls. After Lia was able to get them to let Cassie back in, they were happy to pretend they'd never bullied her and the whole thing was all Thatcher’s fault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SelfServingMemory: In fifth grade, after Cassie got in trouble for beating up a bully named Thatcher who snapped her bra, the popular girls threw her out of their clique. Lia stood up for Cassie by daring Thatcher to punch her, winning the respect of the other girls. After Lia was able to get them to let Cassie back in, they were happy to pretend the whole thing had been entirely Thatcher’s fault.

to:

* SelfServingMemory: In fifth grade, after Cassie got in trouble for beating up a bully named Thatcher who snapped her bra, the popular girls called her a "dyke lesbo" and threw her out of their clique. Lia stood up for Cassie by daring Thatcher to punch her, winning the respect of the other girls. After Lia was able to get them to let Cassie back in, they were happy to pretend the whole thing had been entirely was all Thatcher’s fault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SelfServingMemory: In fifth grade, after Cassie got in trouble for beating up a bully named Thatcher who snapped her bra, the popular girls threw her out of their clique. Lia stood up for Cassie by daring Thatcher to punch her, winning the respect of the other girls. After Lia was able to get them to let Cassie back in, they were happy to pretend the whole thing had been entirely Thatcher’s fault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgonyOfTheFeet: Lia wears a dress and high heels to Cassie's funeral, but the second she gets out of Elijah's car, she realizes she can't walk in them. At less than 100 pounds, her feet are probably more bone than flesh.

to:

* AgonyOfTheFeet: Lia wears a dress and high heels to Cassie's funeral, but the second she gets out of Elijah's car, she realizes she can't walk in them. At less than 100 pounds, her feet are probably more bone than flesh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AgonyOfTheFeet: Lia wears a dress and high heels to Cassie's funeral, but the second she gets out of Elijah's car, she realizes she can't walk in them. At less than 100 pounds, her feet are probably more bone than flesh.

Added: 1083

Changed: 361

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvancedTech2000: In her head, Lia refers to the bathroom scale in her house as the "Blubber-O-Meter 3000".
* TheAloner: Lia. She has no social life whatsoever, no friends beyond her nine-year-old stepsister, and abuses her fragile medical history to sleep away sessions in the nurse's office or flunk school altogether whenever she can.

to:

* AdvancedTech2000: In her head, Lia refers to the bathroom scale in her house as the "Blubber-O-Meter 3000".
3000". Advanced though it may be, it's only as good as the person being weighed, and its results are easily manipulated. Lia has a separate, secret scale of her own in hiding, which she uses to find out how much she ''really'' weighs.
* TheAloner: Lia. She has no social life whatsoever, no friends beyond her nine-year-old stepsister, and abuses her fragile medical history to sleep away sessions in the nurse's office or flunk school altogether whenever she can. can.
* AsleepInClass: When she's not napping in the nurse's office, Lia is napping in class (particularly Physics).



* BigEater: Usually averted, as Lia avoids food because she knows one bite could lead to a binge. At one point, though, this is exactly what happens: she eats a few pomegranate seeds from a cupcake at a bake sale, and then ends up snarfing down ''every last one'' of the cupcakes - and that's just for starters. She then stays awake all night with horrendous stomach pains and heart palpitations, likely a combination of the laxatives she took after getting home and the fact that her body isn't used to ingesting so much sugar and carbs all at once.
** Some of the kids in the drama group Cassie belonged to ''are'' big eaters, as Lia observes when she notes what each of them buys for lunch in the school cafeteria.



* BlatantLies: Lia becomes a master of deception to try to cover up the progression of her disease, from staging dirty dishes to make it appear as though she has eaten to guzzling water and sewing coins into her bathrobe to cheat in her weekly weigh-ins.



* DaintyLittleBalletDancers: Lia is a former ballet dancer who has always had a small, waifish figure even before her bout with anorexia.

to:

* DaintyLittleBalletDancers: Lia is a former ballet dancer who has always had a small, waifish figure even before her bout with anorexia. That is, until puberty hit and she became slightly pudgy, and her ballet teacher took away her solo and told her to go on a diet.

Added: 755

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BewareTheNiceOnes: Told in flashback. Lia stood up to Thatcher, a bully who was tormenting Cassie, and dared him to hit her. [[WouldHitAGirl He did]], but Lia was hailed by her female classmates as a hero afterward for proving that girls could be as tough as boys. She wanted nothing to do with them unless they accepted Cassie into their clique, which they did.



** Cassie's father, a strict, unloving and authoritarian parent who treats his only daughter like a TrophyChild, never seems to be satisfied with her achievements, and is always berating her for not being perfect.

to:

** Cassie's father, a strict, unloving and authoritarian parent who treats treated his only daughter like a TrophyChild, never seems seemed to be satisfied with her achievements, and is was always berating her for not being perfect.


Added DiffLines:

*** The "glittering girls" in their class were no better, not only shutting Cassie out of their clique but spreading rumors that she was a lesbian. The torment ended after Lia stood up to Thatcher (getting punched in the face for her trouble) and was hailed by the "glittering girls" as a feminist hero, but insisted that if they wanted her in their clique, they had to also accept Cassie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth: Lia's mother cries in the shower after losing one of her patients, a social worker who took in foster kids. She had received a heart transplant, but it failed and the woman died before Dr. Marrigan and her doctors could do anything.

to:

* TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth: Lia's mother cries in the shower after losing one of her patients, a social worker who took in foster kids.children. She had received a heart transplant, but it failed and the woman died before Dr. Marrigan and her doctors team could do anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NeglectedGarden: Lia's mother is stressed over her difficult, emotionally draining job as a cardiologist and her daughter's anorexia. Her garden hasn't been taken care of in a long time and is covered in weeds and dead plants.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PaintingTheMedium: Whenever Lia sees food and briefly thinks about wanting to eat it or how good it'll taste, it's in crossed-out text, followed by thoughts about how the food is actually disgusting or will taste bad.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** David isn't there because he's at an early meeting, but his absence shows that he's not a great family man, especially during a time like this when his daughter's best friend has just been found dead.

to:

** David isn't there because he's at an early meeting, but his absence shows that he's not a great family man, especially during a time like this when his daughter's best friend since childhood has just been found dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PlotTriggeringDeath: The plot is kicked off by Lia learning about her ex-best friend's death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarmfulToMinors: [[spoiler:Emma is the one who catches Lia slashing herself bloody in the bathroom. The incident seems to have given her PTSD-like symptoms, as Jennifer later mentions that she can only sleep a few hours a night and has nightmares about their family being eaten by monsters.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->We [me and Cassie] held hands when we walked down the gingerbread path into the forest, blood dripping from our fingers. We danced with witches and kissed monsters. We turned us into wintergirls, when she tried to leave, I pulled her back into the snow because I was afraid to be alone.

to:

-->We [me and Cassie] held hands when we walked down the gingerbread path into the forest, blood dripping from our fingers. We danced with witches and kissed monsters. We turned us into wintergirls, and when she tried to leave, [[ToxicFriendInfluence I pulled her back into the snow because I was afraid to be alone.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FairytaleMotif: Fairytale imagery is a prominent motif in the dialogue and narrative, relating to how Lia wishes her life could be more like a happy story where everything works out and everyone lives happily ever after. At one point, she brings up the fairytale story that her parents used to tell her of how they fell in love, and then mentally compares it to the real version of events where her dad got her mom pregnant in college, they had a ShotgunWedding, couldn't stand each other by the time she was born, and ended up getting a divorce. The novel even begins with a quote from the original version of ''Literature/SleepingBeauty.''
-->We [me and Cassie] held hands when we walked down the gingerbread path into the forest, blood dripping from our fingers. We danced with witches and kissed monsters. We turned us into wintergirls, when she tried to leave, I pulled her back into the snow because I was afraid to be alone.

Added: 322

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth: Lia's mother cries in the shower after losing one of her patients, a social worker who took in foster kids. She received a heart transplant, but it failed and the woman died before Dr. Marrigan and her doctors could do anything.

to:

* TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth: Lia's mother cries in the shower after losing one of her patients, a social worker who took in foster kids. She had received a heart transplant, but it failed and the woman died before Dr. Marrigan and her doctors could do anything.


Added DiffLines:

* TrophyChild: Cassie's parents were "pillars of the community" and pressured their daughter to be the same, but her father especially didn't care about her emotional well-being or the negative effects that said pressure were having on her. Lia describes it as "trying to stuff her into a mannequin shell that didn't fit."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoodleIncident: Before Cassie moved to Lia's neighborhood when they were 9, something bad happened to her in her old neighborhood involving a boy, implied to be some kind of sexual assault. We never find out what it was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Cassie was a model student who actively participated in sports and theatre, described by the school superintendent in a newspaper as "what we all want our children to be - bright, hardworking, and kind." She also suffered from bulimia, alcoholism, self-esteem issues, and was always fighting with her parents, who had been pressuring her non-stop to be their perfect TrophyChild since her childhood. Until the moment of her death, she was pretending everything was fine at school, while feeling dead inside and hating herself for dumping her best friend Lia, but not being able to apologize to her until she was in the middle of a drinking binge. When Lia didn't answer after 33 calls, Cassie continued binging, purging, and drinking until her esophagus ruptured and she died alone on the bathroom floor of her motel room.

to:

** Cassie was a model student who actively participated in sports and theatre, described by the school superintendent in a newspaper as "what we all want our children to be - bright, hardworking, and kind." She also suffered from bulimia, alcoholism, self-esteem issues, and was always fighting with her parents, who had been pressuring her non-stop to be their perfect TrophyChild since her childhood.a young age. Until the moment of her death, she was pretending everything was fine at school, while feeling dead inside and hating herself for dumping her best friend Lia, but not being able to apologize to her until she was in the middle of a drinking binge. When Lia didn't answer after 33 calls, Cassie continued binging, purging, and drinking until her esophagus ruptured and she died alone on the bathroom floor of her motel room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Cassie was a model student who actively participated in sports and theatre, but suffered from bulimia, alcoholism, self-esteem issues, and was always fighting with her parents. Until the moment of her death, she was pretending everything was fine at school, while feeling dead inside and hating herself for dumping her best friend Lia, but not being able to apologize to her until she was in the middle of a drinking binge. When Lia didn't answer after 33 calls, Cassie continued binging, purging, and drinking until her esophagus ruptured and she died alone on the bathroom floor of her motel room.
** Really, the whole Parrish family has shades of this trope post-Cassie's death. They (or at least Cassie's parents) worked hard to be seen as pillars of the community, with Mr. Parrish working as an elementary school teacher, Mrs. Parrish being the ideal "PTA mom" who led Girl Scout troops, sewed costumes for the school play, and held book club and scrapbooking meetings, and as mentioned above, Cassie seemed like the perfect student. But behind closed doors, they had a fractured and troubled family life that ultimately resulted in their only daughter's awful death.
** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon who "works miracles the other way people flip burgers" (in her daughter's words), but her family life isn't so great, either. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration. Her garden hasn't been taken care of in a long time and is covered in weeds and dead plants.

to:

** Cassie was a model student who actively participated in sports and theatre, but described by the school superintendent in a newspaper as "what we all want our children to be - bright, hardworking, and kind." She also suffered from bulimia, alcoholism, self-esteem issues, and was always fighting with her parents.parents, who had been pressuring her non-stop to be their perfect TrophyChild since her childhood. Until the moment of her death, she was pretending everything was fine at school, while feeling dead inside and hating herself for dumping her best friend Lia, but not being able to apologize to her until she was in the middle of a drinking binge. When Lia didn't answer after 33 calls, Cassie continued binging, purging, and drinking until her esophagus ruptured and she died alone on the bathroom floor of her motel room.
** Really, the whole Parrish family has shades of this trope post-Cassie's death. They (or at least Cassie's parents) worked hard to be seen as pillars of the community, with Mr. Parrish working as an elementary school teacher, Mrs. Parrish being the ideal "PTA mom" who led Girl Scout troops, sewed costumes for the school play, and held book club and scrapbooking meetings, and as mentioned above, Cassie seemed like the perfect student. But behind closed doors, they had a fractured and troubled family life that ultimately resulted in their only daughter's awful death.
** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon who "works miracles the other way people flip burgers" (in her daughter's words), but her family life isn't so great, either. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in adorned with half-hearted attempts at redecoration. Her garden hasn't been taken care of in a long time and is covered in weeds and dead plants.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ObsessedWithFood: Lia, though the usual spirit of the trope is inverted because she's obsessed with ''avoiding'' food rather than eating it. In her case, she's eating as little calories as she possibly can and constantly trying to force herself to stop thinking about being hungry all the time.

to:

* ObsessedWithFood: Lia, though the usual spirit of the trope is inverted because she's obsessed with ''avoiding'' food rather than eating it. In her case, she's eating She counts the calories in every bite of food, eats as little calories as she possibly can can, and constantly trying tries to force herself to stop thinking about being hungry all the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon who "works miracles the other way people flip burgers" (in her daughter's words), but her family life isn't so great, either. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration.

to:

** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon who "works miracles the other way people flip burgers" (in her daughter's words), but her family life isn't so great, either. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration. Her garden hasn't been taken care of in a long time and is covered in weeds and dead plants.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MissingTime: While at her mother's house, Lia spaces out and loses about ten minutes, which tips her mother off that she's not been doing so well at her father's house.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TooGoodForThisSinfulEarth: Lia's mother cries in the shower after losing one of her patients, a social worker who took in foster kids. She received a heart transplant, but it failed and the woman died before Dr. Marrigan and her doctors could do anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon, but her family life isn't so great, either. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration.

to:

** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon, surgeon who "works miracles the other way people flip burgers" (in her daughter's words), but her family life isn't so great, either. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon, but her family life isn't so great. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration.

to:

** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon, but her family life isn't so great.great, either. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Really, the whole Parrish family has shades of this trope post-Cassie's death. They (or at least Cassie's parents) worked hard to be seen as pillars of the community, with Mr. Parrish working as an elementary school teacher, Mrs. Parrish being the ideal "PTA mom" who led Girl Scout troops, sewed costumes for the school play, and held book club and scrapbooking meetings, and as mentioned above, Cassie seemed like the perfect student. But they had a fractured and troubled family life that ultimately resulted in their only daughter's awful death.

to:

** Really, the whole Parrish family has shades of this trope post-Cassie's death. They (or at least Cassie's parents) worked hard to be seen as pillars of the community, with Mr. Parrish working as an elementary school teacher, Mrs. Parrish being the ideal "PTA mom" who led Girl Scout troops, sewed costumes for the school play, and held book club and scrapbooking meetings, and as mentioned above, Cassie seemed like the perfect student. But behind closed doors, they had a fractured and troubled family life that ultimately resulted in their only daughter's awful death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Really, the whole Parrish family has shades of this trope post-Cassie's death. They (or at least Cassie's parents) worked hard to be seen as pillars of the community, with Mr. Parrish working as an elementary school teacher, Mrs. Parrish being the ideal "PTA mom" who led Girl Scout troops, sewed costumes for the school play, and held book club and scrapbooking meetings, and as mentioned above, Cassie seemed like the perfect student. But they had a fractured and troubled family life that ultimately resulted in their only daughter's awful death.

Added: 903

Changed: 349

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlaveToPR: Jennifer is obsessed with maintaining her image of being a perfect wife, mother and accountant at the bank she works at, which extends to pushing her daughter Emma into various extracurricular activities. The novel opens with Jennifer crumbling the edges of the cookies she's taking to Emma's school so they'll look homemade instead of store-bought.

to:

* SlaveToPR: SlaveToPR:
**
Jennifer is obsessed with maintaining her image of being a perfect wife, mother and accountant at the bank she works at, which extends to pushing her daughter Emma into various extracurricular activities. The novel opens with Jennifer crumbling the edges of the cookies she's taking to Emma's school so they'll look homemade instead of store-bought.store-bought.
** To some extent, Cassie's mother is also implied to have a reputation she's trying to uphold, volunteering for field trips, leading Girl Scout troops, scrapbooking, and running a book club. The SlaveToPR part comes from her appearing at the elementary school holiday concert dressed as Mrs. Claus after Cassie's death. She's still trying to be a pillar of the community, but her heart's not in it, as seen when a group of little kids run up to her and ask her to tell Santa they've been good this year, and she either doesn't notice or ignores them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chloe isn't there either, but Lia comments that she prefers talking to her ex-husband David over the phone because face-to-face takes too much time and usually ends in screaming, implying an acrimonious divorce.

to:

** Chloe isn't there either, but Lia comments that she prefers talking to her ex-husband David over the phone because face-to-face takes too much time and usually ends in screaming, implying an acrimonious divorce. Her reaction to the news is to communicate to Lia to see her therapist as soon as possible. She does care about Lia, but doesn't seem able to provide the emotional support she needs at this time.

Top