Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / WhomGodsWouldDestroy

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Second book explicitely confirmed it.


* AmbiguouslyJewish: Despite being from Siberia and resembling a Tuvan, Anna Sokoll has a plausibly Ashkenazi Jewish name and is able to speak Yiddish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BreakingTheFellowship: halfway through ''Archangel'', echoing Literature/TheLordOfTheRings, [[spoiler: the nine giants lose two members and are separated, with two heading to Russia and the rest heading towards Greece]].


Added DiffLines:

* {{Mordor}}: The trope looks back on itself here, as the books play up the horrific desolation of the war's battlefields to the point that it becomes a fantastical wasteland haunted by giant rats, demons, and ghosts.


Added DiffLines:

* RingOfPower: The first story in the book covers a ring which grants its owners wishes, but in a more subtle way than the typical genie rings, to the point that the narrative notes it may have been a matter of hysteria (the boys involved were already wealthy). The previous owner of the ring held that the owner had to sell the ring for less than it was purchased for or they would go to hell, but the truth of the matter is never uncovered.

Added: 333

Removed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MultinationalTeam: the Nine consist of a German, two British men, a Jewish Hungarian, an Austrian, a half-Dahomy French woman, an Italian, an Serb, and a Siberian Russian woman.
* MustHaveCaffeine: Siegfried, the FriendlySniper, is a caffeine addict, to the point that he eats powdered ersatz coffee cut with sawdust to stay awake.



* MustHaveCaffeine: Siegfried, the FriendlySniper, is a caffeine addict, to the point that he eats powdered ersatz coffee cut with sawdust to stay awake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BornLucky/WindsOfDestinyChange: Hannibal Barker, though with the downside that he seems to "bank" his luck, with improbable good fortune balanced out, in the end, by bad luck.

to:

* BornLucky/WindsOfDestinyChange: BornLucky / WindsOfDestinyChange: Hannibal Barker, though with the downside that he seems to "bank" his luck, with improbable good fortune balanced out, in the end, by bad luck.



* CastingAShadow/PowerOfTheVoid: Susan, Tom Noun's mother, has a variation, where she can manipulate and teleport anything completely obscured by darkness.

to:

* CastingAShadow/PowerOfTheVoid: CastingAShadow / PowerOfTheVoid: Susan, Tom Noun's mother, has a variation, where she can manipulate and teleport anything completely obscured by darkness.



* [[Spoiler: Part II confirms that they are nephilim, or rather, the 99th and 100th generation descendants of such, dumbed the Elioud]].

to:

* [[Spoiler: [[spoiler: Part II confirms that they are nephilim, or rather, the 99th and 100th generation descendants of such, dumbed the Elioud]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Transmuation}}: rooted in the concepts of alchemy and chemistry, Rowan Winepress is capable of transmutating elements at a touch.

to:

* {{Transmuation}}: {{Transmutation}}: rooted in the concepts of alchemy and chemistry, Rowan Winepress is capable of transmutating elements at a touch.

Added: 1561

Changed: 144

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuraVision: very common among the empowered individuals of the story, as it was a stock psychic power popularized at the turn of the century.



* BeethovenWasAnAlienSpy: apparently, several historical figures have been some kind of supernatural being, [[spoiler: including Tarrare]].

to:

* BeethovenWasAnAlienSpy: apparently, several historical figures have been some kind of supernatural being, [[spoiler: including Tarrare]].Tarrare, who has a CannibalismSuperpower and ResurrectiveImmortality]].



* {{Biomanipulation}}: Tom Noun's ability.



* BornLucky/WindsOfDestinyChange: Hannibal Barker, though with the downside that he seems to "bank" his luck, with improbable good fortune balanced out, in the end, by bad luck.



* CastingAShadow/PowerOfTheVoid: Susan, Tom Noun's mother, has a variation, where she can manipulate and teleport anything completely obscured by darkness.
* ChameleonCamouflage: the [[spoiler: fae]] have ghillie suits that resemble Green-Man costumes, and are far more advanced than anything humanity has in the 1910s.



* {{Hellfire}}: depicted as a hot gas connected to the planet Venus (the Morning Star), which may be Hell itself. It seems to be manipulated by demonic entities, and it is treated like SuperSmoke.



* MagicalEye: [[spoiler: the supernatural abilities of Nephilim seem to be attached to eyes, due their descent from the class of angels known as the Watchers/Grigori]].



* PlagueDoctor: A seemingly demonic entity - the Goetic "Amy" - associated with the H1N1 or "Spanish" Flu travels from Kansas to Europe, shifting from a classical horned and hairy devil to a hypnotist (associated with Edgar Cayce) to a classic European plague doctor along the way.

to:

* PlagueDoctor: A seemingly demonic entity - the Goetic "Amy" - associated with the H1N1 or "Spanish" Flu travels from Kansas to Europe, shifting from a classical horned and hairy devil to a hypnotist (associated with Edgar Cayce) to a classic European plague doctor along the way. The entity returns, with PestController powers.



* RealityWarper: Certain entities (possibly PhysicalGods) and places seem to actively warp what's possible, and [[{{Muggles}} mundane people]] [[BrownNote who witness it seem to have to roll a Sanity Save.]] Though it may all be simple PsychicPowers. Part II confirms that [[spoiler: the nephilim are surrounded by a gap in a reality called "aretztikapha, a 'world of distortion,' a term apparently taken from an angelic title in the Book of Enoch. Within this 'sinus,' they warp reality to their whims]].

to:

* RealityWarper: Certain entities (possibly PhysicalGods) and places seem to actively warp what's possible, and [[{{Muggles}} mundane people]] [[BrownNote who witness it seem to have to roll a Sanity Save.]] Though it may all be simple PsychicPowers. Part II confirms that it is a DomainHolder situation, and [[spoiler: the nephilim are surrounded by a gap in a reality called "aretztikapha, a 'world of distortion,' a term apparently taken from an angelic title in the Book of Enoch. Within this 'sinus,' they warp reality to their whims]].


Added DiffLines:

* SemanticSuperpower: Angels appear to be rooted in the concept they embody, and have mastery of any variant on that idea.


Added DiffLines:

* SuperheroPackingHeat: Even the super-powered characters usually resort to simply pulling a trigger when violence is needed.


Added DiffLines:

* Telepathy: a stock psionic ability which crops up regularly, as it was a common fascination of Edwardian occultists and paranormalists.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Transmuation}}: rooted in the concepts of alchemy and chemistry, Rowan Winepress is capable of transmutating elements at a touch.

Added: 204

Changed: 306

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RealityWarper: Certain entities (possibly PhysicalGods) and places seem to actively warp what's possible, and [[{{Muggles}} mundane people]] [[BrownNote who witness it seem to have to roll a Sanity Save.]] Though it may all be simple PsychicPowers.

to:

* RealityWarper: Certain entities (possibly PhysicalGods) and places seem to actively warp what's possible, and [[{{Muggles}} mundane people]] [[BrownNote who witness it seem to have to roll a Sanity Save.]] Though it may all be simple PsychicPowers. Part II confirms that [[spoiler: the nephilim are surrounded by a gap in a reality called "aretztikapha, a 'world of distortion,' a term apparently taken from an angelic title in the Book of Enoch. Within this 'sinus,' they warp reality to their whims]].



* TitleDrop: Delivered early, in its Latin form, by Thomas Noun.

to:

* TitleDrop: Delivered early, early in part I, in its Latin form, and then later on in English in part II, by Thomas Noun.


Added DiffLines:

** In Part II, [[spoiler: a demoness calling herself Nama'ah rants about the true nature of the cosmos and the War in Heaven, proclaiming that God created the world unwillingly, because "God was raped."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[Spoiler: Part II confirms that they are nephilim, or rather, the 99th and 100th generation descendants of such, dumbed the Elioud]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Many historical figures get name-checked, but Kaiser Wilhelm II, Carl Jung, Morgan Robertson, and paranormal investigator Elliott O'Donnell get the most attention in the first book. Along with a certain [[UnexpectedCharacter 18th century figure]]. ''Archangel'', similarly, opens with a chance meeting of Creator/HenryDarger, Charles Dellschau, and Vida Henry. Oddly enough, there is a striking [[AvertedTrope lack]]

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Many historical figures get name-checked, but Kaiser Wilhelm II, Carl Jung, Morgan Robertson, and paranormal investigator Elliott O'Donnell get the most attention in the first book. Along with a certain [[UnexpectedCharacter 18th century figure]]. ''Archangel'', similarly, opens with a chance meeting of Creator/HenryDarger, Charles Dellschau, and Vida Henry. Oddly enough, there is a striking [[AvertedTrope lack]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Whom Gods Would Destroy: An Occult History of the First World War'' is a 2023 novel trilogy by Tyler Kimball told in the form of [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a paranormal survey of ]][[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI the First World War]]. It begins as a relatively straight-forward historical investigation based in [[ParanoiaFuel “real life” events]] [[VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory blended with fantastical elements]], but various characters and plotlines began to interweave, resulting in [[GenreBuster an apocalyptic dark fantasy]] [[GenreRoulette superhero religious horror war story.]]..[[MindScrew thing]].

to:

''Whom Gods Would Destroy: An Occult History of the First World War'' is a 2023 novel trilogy by Tyler Kimball told in the form of [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a paranormal survey of ]][[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI the First World War]].War]], with the three parts entitled ''The Architects of Hell'', ''Archangel'', and ''Armageddon''. It begins as a relatively straight-forward historical investigation based in [[ParanoiaFuel “real life” events]] [[VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory blended with fantastical elements]], but various characters and plotlines began to interweave, resulting in [[GenreBuster an apocalyptic dark fantasy]] [[GenreRoulette superhero religious horror war story.]]..[[MindScrew thing]].



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Many historical figures get name-checked, but Kaiser Wilhelm II, Carl Jung, Morgan Robertson, and paranormal investigator Elliott O'Donnell get the most attention. Along with a certain [[UnexpectedCharacter 18th century figure]].

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Many historical figures get name-checked, but Kaiser Wilhelm II, Carl Jung, Morgan Robertson, and paranormal investigator Elliott O'Donnell get the most attention.attention in the first book. Along with a certain [[UnexpectedCharacter 18th century figure]]. ''Archangel'', similarly, opens with a chance meeting of Creator/HenryDarger, Charles Dellschau, and Vida Henry. Oddly enough, there is a striking [[AvertedTrope lack]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TexbookHumor: during a description of the battle of Tanga, which involved a destructive attack by a massive bee swarm, the academic, historical style suddenly starts treating the queen bee as if it were a legitimate head of state of a belligerent nation, and lauded as the most successful monarch of the Great War.

to:

* TexbookHumor: TextbookHumor: during a description of the battle of Tanga, which involved a destructive attack by a massive bee swarm, the academic, historical style suddenly starts treating the queen bee as if it were a legitimate head of state of a belligerent nation, and lauded as the most successful monarch of the Great War.

Added: 1357

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ApocalypseCult: mutliple crop up before and during the war, and the Nine may be one.

to:

* ApocalypseCult: mutliple multiple crop up before and during the war, and the Nine may be one.



* BadassLongcoat: a majority of characters who are described physically seem to wear a version. It is the era that put the ''trench'' in trench coat, and leads to a cast tricked out in CoatHatMask and GasMaskLongcoat styles.



* BizarreAndImprobableBallistics / ImprobableAimingSkills: Jacoba van der Aarde seems to have a [[CompellingVoice supernatural command over anyone who hears her voice]], rendering them completely helpless. This is far more than standard mind control, to the point that any shot she fires will hit them. She demonstrates this by firing a gun into her own mouth, which hits a target.



* InfoDump: much of the first half of the book.

to:

* InfoDump: much of the first half of the book.book


Added DiffLines:

* MustHaveCaffeine: Siegfried, the FriendlySniper, is a caffeine addict, to the point that he eats powdered ersatz coffee cut with sawdust to stay awake.


Added DiffLines:

* PlagueDoctor: A seemingly demonic entity - the Goetic "Amy" - associated with the H1N1 or "Spanish" Flu travels from Kansas to Europe, shifting from a classical horned and hairy devil to a hypnotist (associated with Edgar Cayce) to a classic European plague doctor along the way.


Added DiffLines:

* TexbookHumor: during a description of the battle of Tanga, which involved a destructive attack by a massive bee swarm, the academic, historical style suddenly starts treating the queen bee as if it were a legitimate head of state of a belligerent nation, and lauded as the most successful monarch of the Great War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GovernmentConspiracy: multiple occult organizations with the governments of Europe and America are mentioned, most prominently a British MI18.

to:

* GovernmentConspiracy: multiple occult organizations with the governments of Europe and America are mentioned, most prominently a British MI18.MI-18.



* PoliticallyIncorrectHero/PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: few of the characters are above the casual bigotry and extreme nationalism of the era.

to:

* PoliticallyIncorrectHero/PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: PoliticallyIncorrectHero and PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: few of the characters are above the casual bigotry and extreme nationalism of the era.

Added: 2443

Changed: 286

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AncientConspiracy: [[ConspiracyKitchenSink multiple overlapping ones are mentioned]][[GambitPileup a chunk of their story involves their struggles for supremacy in Edwardian occultism]]. Though the conspiracies are often not-so-ancient, such as the Ordo Templi Orientis and the Oddfellows.

to:

* AncientConspiracy: [[ConspiracyKitchenSink multiple overlapping ones are mentioned]][[GambitPileup a chunk of their story involves their struggles for supremacy in Edwardian occultism]]. Though the conspiracies are often not-so-ancient, such as the Ordo Templi Orientis Orientis, the Esoteric Order of Enoch, and the Oddfellows.



* ArtifactOfAttraction: the Cambridge Cabal's ring, which may be [[[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor something of a monkey's paw.]]

to:

* ArtifactOfAttraction: the Cambridge Cabal's ring, which may be [[[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor [[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor something of a monkey's paw.]]



* ConspiracyTheorist: many, though Willis George Emerson and Elliott O'Donnell take the cake.

to:

* ConspiracyTheorist: many, though Willis George Emerson and Elliott O'Donnell take the cake. Through his plotline as an amateur journalist, Hannibal Barker slowly descends into conspiratorial madness, clutching at threads such as apocalyptic cults, serial killers, anomalous airships, giant bones, and the high strangeness events in San Bernadino.


Added DiffLines:

* CrapsackWorld: even away from the War front, the world of WGWD seems to be a miserable, hateful, decaying wreck.
* CrossoverCosmology: angels, demons, fairies, aliens, the giants of all cultures, kraken, and atmospheric entities all seem to be in play.


Added DiffLines:

* DecoyProtagonist: [[spoiler: Hannibal Barker]] appears early in the story and seems to be the guiding investigator piecing together the various plotlines. [[spoiler: He doesn't make it to the end of the first book of a trilogy]].


Added DiffLines:

* GovernmentConspiracy: multiple occult organizations with the governments of Europe and America are mentioned, most prominently a British MI18.


Added DiffLines:

* TheGrotesque: the highly-scarred but intelligent Baron von Bohm and the foul-smelling and frog-like, but ultimately helpful and oddly wise, Adolphe Bouchard.
* {{Hallucinations}}: a cosmic hallucination involving Leviathan and the Titanic occur to Siegfried while under the effects of anaesthesia.


Added DiffLines:

* HumanSacrifice: A recurring mythical/historical motif, bringing up Punic, Canaanite, and Mesoamerican practices, particularly the god Moloch.


Added DiffLines:

* InfoDump: much of the first half of the book.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Lunacy}}: The dangerous Machado seems capable of projecting herself across the world, but only by reflecting herself off moonlight.


Added DiffLines:

* MaleSunFemaleMoon: Noun actually holds that the opposite is true, with a generative female Sun and a wandering, reflective Male moon.


Added DiffLines:

* PoliticallyIncorrectHero/PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: few of the characters are above the casual bigotry and extreme nationalism of the era.


Added DiffLines:

* PyrrhicVictory: the Assassination of Franz Ferdinand is portrayed in a modernist short story by Thomas Noun. The assassins are framed as the pyrrhic victors.
* RainOfBlood: multiple historical instances are discussed, though the narrator chalks up the Wartime incidents to disturbed red soil from entrenchment.


Added DiffLines:

* ShownTheirWork: the hundreds of footnotes often lead to genuine historical events.


Added DiffLines:

* SurroundedByIdiots: Tom Noun's general reaction to his peers, particularly some Tommies who believe they were sent off the protect the "Beligums."


Added DiffLines:

* UnstuckInTime: Siegfried's bizarre hallucination has him shifting backwards and forwards in time, possibly into past lives.


Added DiffLines:

* VerbalTic: Thomas Noun tends to add a Bertie Wooster-esque ", what?" to the end of his sentences, while Celeste tends to have French constructions in her (translated) dialogue, such as a final "no?" or saying "if you will" instead of "please."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AncientConspiracy: [[ConspiracyKitchenSink multiple overlapping ones are mentioned]][[GambitPileup and their struggles for supremacy in Edwardian occultism]], and some not-so-ancient, such as the Ordo Templi Orientis and the Oddfellows.

to:

* AncientConspiracy: [[ConspiracyKitchenSink multiple overlapping ones are mentioned]][[GambitPileup and a chunk of their story involves their struggles for supremacy in Edwardian occultism]], and some occultism]]. Though the conspiracies are often not-so-ancient, such as the Ordo Templi Orientis and the Oddfellows.

Added: 157

Changed: 36

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnimalisticAbomination: the rat-king, the Hound of the Somme.



* EasterEgg: besides the openly explained elements, there are sideways references to multiple paranormal events, such as Mothman (Dr. Laurent notes that witnessing certain supernatural powers caused [[EyeScream Actinic conjunctivitis]] among his staff, something connected to Mothman sightings by John Keel in ''TheMothmanProphecies'').

to:

* EasterEgg: besides the openly explained elements, there are sideways references to multiple paranormal events, such as Mothman (Dr. Laurent notes that witnessing certain supernatural powers caused [[EyeScream Actinic conjunctivitis]] among his staff, something connected to Mothman sightings by John Keel in ''TheMothmanProphecies'').[[Film/TheMothmanProphecies ''The Mothman Prophecies'']]).


Added DiffLines:

* TheLostLenore: Hermann von Bohm's wife.


Added DiffLines:

* SanitySlippage: Implied to happen to all of Europe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EasterEgg: besides the openly explained elements, there are sideways references to multiple paranormal events, such as Mothman.

to:

* EasterEgg: besides the openly explained elements, there are sideways references to multiple paranormal events, such as Mothman.Mothman (Dr. Laurent notes that witnessing certain supernatural powers caused [[EyeScream Actinic conjunctivitis]] among his staff, something connected to Mothman sightings by John Keel in ''TheMothmanProphecies'').
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BodyHorror: Warping flesh, rats eating people alive, locusts swarming people,

to:

* BodyHorror: Warping flesh, rats eating people alive, locusts swarming people, over the hills of Jerusalem, polyphagia, trench foot, and the horrifying statue-sickness "encephalitis lethargica."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagicRealism: elements of it, such as in the tale of the Orkney Isle “mermaids” and the Rat-king.

to:

* MagicRealism: elements of it, such as in the tale of the Orkney Isle “mermaids” and [[PestController the Rat-king.Rat-king]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheEmperor: An essay explains the lingering culture power of the Kaiser as a meme, and the actual personality of Wilhelm II.

to:

* TheEmperor: An essay explains the lingering culture power of the Kaiser as a meme, TheButcher of Belgium, and the actual personality of Wilhelm II.

Added: 423

Changed: 42

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PsychicDreamsForEveryone: Carl Jung, multiple minor characters, and Siegfried Gottlieb [[DreamingOfThingsToCome all have prophetic dreams.]] Gottlieb's dream has him blend consciousness with writer Morgan Robertson, known for the ''Wreck of the Titan,'' and connects [[UsefulNotes/RMSTitanic ''The Titanic'']] with the Biblical Leviathan.

to:

* PsychicDreamsForEveryone: Carl Jung, multiple minor characters, and Siegfried Gottlieb [[DreamingOfThingsToCome all have prophetic dreams.]] Gottlieb's dream has him blend consciousness with writer Morgan Robertson, known for the ''Wreck of the Titan,'' and connects [[UsefulNotes/RMSTitanic ''The Titanic'']] with the Biblical Leviathan.Leviathan, the demon of Pride.



* RedBaron: Zrno, meaning both bullet and seed, is used as an alias by a superhumanily fast Serb. Venetianer is known as der Krahenkönig, the Crow-King, Baron von Böhm is the Storm-Lord, Céleste is the Salamander, Gottlieb is known as Geist (Ghost) or Eisengeist (Iron Ghost), and Amée Hart is known as the Laugh-Man (and, presumably, the Plague Doctor). The actual Red Baron is mentioned, but does not feature prominently.



* RoomFullOfCrazy: Tom Noun's bed in the Somme hospital is covered in anti-fairy wards.

to:

* RoomFullOfCrazy: Tom Noun's bed in the Somme hospital is covered in anti-fairy wards.wards and stolen iron nails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Though never outright confirmed, there may be some name-magic-related reason why three characters - Amadeo, Gottlieb, and John Rowan ''Theophilus'' Winepress - all have names which mean "Loved by God."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OverlyLongName: Hermann [[[GenderBlenderName Maria]] Ernst Freiherr Przibislaus z Lipé von Böhm, though not unrealistic for Austrian aristocrats of the time.

to:

* OverlyLongName: Hermann [[[GenderBlenderName [[GenderBlenderName Maria]] Ernst Freiherr Przibislaus z Lipé von Böhm, though not unrealistic for Austrian aristocrats of the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmbiguouslyJewish: Despite being from Siberia and resembling a Tuvan, Anna Sokoll has a plausibly Ashkenazi Jewish name and is able to speak Yiddish.


Added DiffLines:

* ApopheniaPlot: the first two thirds of the text are more anthology than novel, jumping from topic to topic with only the war and larger themes connecting them.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Epigraph}}: Several, including one from the Errol Morris documentary, "The Umbrella Man," about the anomalous micro-level of history.


Added DiffLines:

* FogOfWar: a theme, most prominent with the essay on the Angels of Mons.


Added DiffLines:

** Alter Venetianer appears to follow this twofold - he frequently uses pseudonyms for some reason, and is named "Alter," or "Old Man," an Ashkenazi Jewish tradition said to hide a sickly child from the angel of Death.


Added DiffLines:

* MagicalJew: Venetianer is both Jewish and a enigmatic [[TheMentor mentor]] figure to Siegfried.


Added DiffLines:

* OverlyLongName: Hermann [[[GenderBlenderName Maria]] Ernst Freiherr Przibislaus z Lipé von Böhm, though not unrealistic for Austrian aristocrats of the time.


Added DiffLines:

* SecretHistory: The premise of the series.


Added DiffLines:

* TitleDrop: Delivered early, in its Latin form, by Thomas Noun.


Added DiffLines:

* WarIsHell: and literally so, at times.

Added: 121

Changed: 232

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSwarm: Jerusalem experiences a major locusts during the War, with all the creepy-crawly horror that entails.

to:

* SuperSpeed: Zrno is able to accelerate and decelerate objects. This causes severe bleeding and clothing damage, as there is still wind resistance. He makes up for it with a HealingFactor.
* TheSwarm: Jerusalem experiences a major locusts locust outbreak during the War, with all the creepy-crawly horror that entails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ResurrectiveImmortality: While the limits of his "death" are never tested, "Adolphe Bouchard" appears to be able to resurrect himself with a new body after severe physical decline by bursting out of his own rotting body like a cocoon, with all the puss and decay involved described in detail. [[Spoiler: he has been doing this since at least the late 18th century, and he hints at being far, far older]].

to:

* ResurrectiveImmortality: While the limits of his "death" are never tested, "Adolphe Bouchard" appears to be able to resurrect himself with a new body after severe physical decline by bursting out of his own rotting body like a cocoon, with all the puss and decay involved described in detail. [[Spoiler: he He has been doing this since at least the late 18th century, and he hints at being far, far older]].older.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Whom Gods Would Destroy: An Occult History of the First World War'' is a 2023 novel trilogy by Tyler Kimball told in the form of a paranormal survey of [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI the First World War]]. It begins as a relatively straight-forward historical investigation based in [[ParanoiaFuel “real life” events]] [[VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory blended with fantastical elements]], but various characters and plotlines began to interweave, resulting in [[GenreBuster an apocalyptic dark fantasy]] [[GenreRoulette superhero religious horror war story.]]..[[MindScrew thing]].

to:

''Whom Gods Would Destroy: An Occult History of the First World War'' is a 2023 novel trilogy by Tyler Kimball told in the form of [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a paranormal survey of [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI ]][[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI the First World War]]. It begins as a relatively straight-forward historical investigation based in [[ParanoiaFuel “real life” events]] [[VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory blended with fantastical elements]], but various characters and plotlines began to interweave, resulting in [[GenreBuster an apocalyptic dark fantasy]] [[GenreRoulette superhero religious horror war story.]]..[[MindScrew thing]].

Added: 2653

Changed: 750

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Anachronistic Order: A brief slip from the general chronological order: The “Finwife” story takes place in 1919.

to:

* Anachronistic Order: AnachronicOrder: A brief slip from the general chronological order: The “Finwife” story takes place in 1919.



* AuthorAppeal: It's pretty clear that the Author is interested in niche paranormal topics, since most of the many, many characters are as well, to an obsessive degree. Then again, characters surrounded by occult weirdness would probably want to know more about it.

to:

* AuthorAppeal: It's pretty clear that the Author author is interested in niche obscure paranormal topics, trivia, since most of the many, many characters are as well, to an obsessive degree. Then again, characters surrounded by occult weirdness would probably want to know more about it.



* BodyHorror: Warping flesh, rats eating people alive, locusts swarming people,



* TheEmperor: An essay explains the lingering culture power of the Kaiser as a meme, and the actual personality of Wilhelm II.



* {{Hammerspace}}: "Adolphe Bouchard" seems able to regurgitate anything from his gullet, even years after swallowing.
* HealingFactor: Tom Noun seems to have this, in addition to body manipulation abilities.
* Myth/HebrewMythology: Invoked occasionally, usually by Venetianer.



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Many historical figures get name-checked, but Kaiser Wilhelm II and paranormal investigator Elliott O'Donnell get the most attention. Along with a certain [[UnexpectedCharacter 18th century figure]].

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Many historical figures get name-checked, but Kaiser Wilhelm II II, Carl Jung, Morgan Robertson, and paranormal investigator Elliott O'Donnell get the most attention. Along with a certain [[UnexpectedCharacter 18th century figure]].



* JigsawPuzzlePlot

to:

* JigsawPuzzlePlotJigsawPuzzlePlot: all the pieces do see to come together into a whole by the end of the first book, but it takes its bloody time.



* MythicalMotifs: Along with common angelic and demonic imagery, [Myth/ClassicalMythology Medea]] and Moloch are recurring symbols of a culture sacrificing its own children.

to:

* MrExposition: Venetianer and Winepress seems to be the only ones who know what's going on.
* MythicalMotifs: Along with common angelic and demonic imagery, [Myth/ClassicalMythology [[Myth/ClassicalMythology Medea]] and Moloch are recurring symbols of a culture sacrificing its own children.



* OurAngelsAreDifferent: there are strong hints that there was some basis to the Angels of Mons, and the religious visions of the Welsh Revival.
* OurArchonsAreDifferent: owing the the religious horror of the plot and a note on the Gnosticism-tinged prophetic dreams of psychologist Jung, this may be what's behind everything.
* OurCryptidsAreMoreMysterious: from sea serpents, atmospheric beasts, and giant rats to...an animated white bag thingy.
* OurFairiesAreDifferent: hinted at being more like the wildmen of European lore, and cannibalistic. Though they could all be a delusion of Thomas Noun.
* OurGhoulsAreCreepier: there was something ghoulish, or possibly [[OurDemonsAreDifferent demonic]], stalking around the British Army centre known as the "Destructor."
*OurMermaidsAreDifferent: based on the finwives and selkies of Orkney folklore, these AmbiguouslyHuman beings don't seem to be physically different than human women, apart from a clammy skin tone and possession of what may be an enchanted shawl.
* OurGiantsAreBigger: legends of giants crop up multiple times, including alleged pre-War giant bone findings across the Americas, along with references to figures such as Gogmagog, the {{Nephilim}}, the Giants of Ath, and Greek [[OurTitansAreDifferent Titans]]. [[spoiler: It becomes apparent that the Nine may be nephilim of some sort, but none stand over two meters tall]].



* PosthumousCharacter: technically everyone, as the narrator is in the modern day, but Morgan Robertson is dead before even the WWI-era characters hear of him.



* PsychicDreamsForEveryone: Carl Jung, multiple minor characters, and Siegfried Gottlieb [[DreamingOfThingsToCome all have prophetic dreams.]] Gottlieb's dream has him blend consciousness with writer Morgan Robertson, known for the ''Wreck of the Titan,'' and connects [[UsefulNotes/RMSTitanic ''The Titanic'']] with the Biblical Leviathan.



* RedEyesTakeWarning

to:

* RedEyesTakeWarningResurrectiveImmortality: While the limits of his "death" are never tested, "Adolphe Bouchard" appears to be able to resurrect himself with a new body after severe physical decline by bursting out of his own rotting body like a cocoon, with all the puss and decay involved described in detail. [[Spoiler: he has been doing this since at least the late 18th century, and he hints at being far, far older]].



* SpyFiction: Many elements of WWI-era spy fiction, along with actual historical esponiage, crop up in the book, particularly the actions carried out by Alister Crowley.

to:

* SpyFiction: Many elements of WWI-era spy fiction, along with actual historical esponiage, espionage, crop up in the book, particularly the actions carried out by Alister Crowley.Crowley.
* TheSwarm: Jerusalem experiences a major locusts during the War, with all the creepy-crawly horror that entails.



* WeirdHistoricalWar, including elements that feel like predacessors to SovietSuperscience and {{Ghostapo}}

to:

* WeirdHistoricalWar, including elements that feel like predacessors predecessors to SovietSuperscience and {{Ghostapo}}

Changed: 2

Removed: 1011

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AluminiumChristmasTrees: perhaps the creepiest moments occur when you look up some of the events noted in the book and find out that they actually happened.
* AmbiguousDisorder: many characters seem to be either mentally ill, neurotypical, or physically odd, though the psychiatric and medical science of the 1910s leaves it vague.



* BeigeProse: Occasionally, particularly when quoting from jouranlistic sources. Tom Noun writes in a notably Modernist, PurpleProse.
* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: the “Brief Incident in Cuba,” recounting the tale of some sort of growing white blob thing.

to:

* BeigeProse: Occasionally, particularly when quoting from jouranlistic journalistic sources. Tom Noun writes in a notably Modernist, PurpleProse.
* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: the “Brief Incident in Cuba,” recounting the tale of some sort of growing white blob thing.
PurpleProse.



* CreepyAwesome: Celeste and Tom Noun are rather creepy, but among the most fascinating characters in the tale. [[spoiler: also Tarrare, for a given value of awesome]].



* GeniusBonus: WGWD rewards a knowledge of both the First World War and the occult.



* JerkassWoobie: many of the characters portray hints of cruelty, casual bigotry, and murderous intent, but it's pretty clear that they're breaking down from the horrors of war.



* RealismInducedHorror: The most unsettling events of the story arise from AluminiumChristmasTrees and the very real horrors of war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
starting

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/whom_gods_would_destroy_part_i.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350: ''"...they first drive mad."'']]

''Whom Gods Would Destroy: An Occult History of the First World War'' is a 2023 novel trilogy by Tyler Kimball told in the form of a paranormal survey of [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI the First World War]]. It begins as a relatively straight-forward historical investigation based in [[ParanoiaFuel “real life” events]] [[VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory blended with fantastical elements]], but various characters and plotlines began to interweave, resulting in [[GenreBuster an apocalyptic dark fantasy]] [[GenreRoulette superhero religious horror war story.]]..[[MindScrew thing]].
----
!!''Whom Gods Would Destroy'' contains examples of:

*AbsurdlySpaciousSewer: Part of the story takes place in the make-shift underground cities constructed along the western front, which even had chapels and entertainment areas.
*AgentPeacock: Tom Noun. Notably feminine, literary, and pretty, to the point of being a convincing crossdresser; also incredibly tough and dangerous.
*AluminiumChristmasTrees: perhaps the creepiest moments occur when you look up some of the events noted in the book and find out that they actually happened.
*AmbiguousDisorder: many characters seem to be either mentally ill, neurotypical, or physically odd, though the psychiatric and medical science of the 1910s leaves it vague.
*AmbiguouslyHuman: whatever the Nine are isn't quite human.
*Anachronistic Order: A brief slip from the general chronological order: The “Finwife” story takes place in 1919.
*AncientConspiracy: [[ConspiracyKitchenSink multiple overlapping ones are mentioned]][[GambitPileup and their struggles for supremacy in Edwardian occultism]], and some not-so-ancient, such as the Ordo Templi Orientis and the Oddfellows.
*AndZoidberg: in one of the snarkier bits, Bulgaria gets this treatment among the War's powers.
*ApocalypseCult: mutliple crop up before and during the war, and the Nine may be one.
*ApocalypticLog
*AuthorAppeal: It's pretty clear that the Author is interested in niche paranormal topics, since most of the many, many characters are as well, to an obsessive degree. Then again, characters surrounded by occult weirdness would probably want to know more about it.
*ArtifactOfAttraction: the Cambridge Cabal's ring, which may be [[[BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor something of a monkey's paw.]]
*AstralProjection: Machado, a Portuguese psychic who astrally projects herself down from Moonlight. [[AxCrazy She is a brutal, raging assailant who cannot be reasoned with.]]
*AwesomeButImpractical: experimental weaponry, communications technology, fringe science, occult gambits, and new tactics get explored frequently. They are rarely worth it.
*BedlamHouse: quite a chunk of the story takes places in wartime hospitals and asylums, places of disease, madness, drug abuse, and psychic horror.
*BeethovenWasAnAlienSpy: apparently, several historical figures have been some kind of supernatural being, [[spoiler: including Tarrare]].
*BeigeProse: Occasionally, particularly when quoting from jouranlistic sources. Tom Noun writes in a notably Modernist, PurpleProse.
*BigLippedAlligatorMoment: the “Brief Incident in Cuba,” recounting the tale of some sort of growing white blob thing.
*BilingualBonus
*BrownNote: Witnessing various paranormal events seems to cause psychological distress and physical ailments, though not to a [[GoMadFromTheRevelation Lovecraftian extent of complete sanity loss]].
*TheChessmaster: Both Venetianer and Winepress seem to be subtly gathering superpowered individuals and gathering them together [[ThePlan for some purpose.]]
*ChristmasEpisode: The famed Christmas Truce is featured in Gottlieb's introduction.
*ClingyMacguffin: The Ring of the Cambridge Cabal seemingly teleports after gaining a new legal owner- after having fallen into a stream.
*ConspiracyTheorist: many, though Willis George Emerson and Elliott O'Donnell take the cake.
*CosmicHorrorStory: what may be happening.
*CreepyAwesome: Celeste and Tom Noun are rather creepy, but among the most fascinating characters in the tale. [[spoiler: also Tarrare, for a given value of awesome]].
*CultureClash: On a macro-level, European cultures and their values clash; on a micro-level, the Siberian Anna Sokoll and everyone else, and Venetianer and his gentile cohorts.
*DeadpanSnarker: Celeste is fairly witty, with a calm yet cruel edge.
*DeliberateValuesDissonance: The fictional bits don't exactly shy away from the values of the Edwardian and WWI eras.
*DocumentaryOfLies: quite a bit of the history is correct, for a given value of “correct” when dealing with occult and paranormal events. However, it's the skeletal structure of a fictional narrative.
*DirectLineToTheAuthor: As one would expect from the conceit of a paranormal investigation, the “author's” commentary tinges and shapes much of the tale.
*DreamWeaver: Venetianer seems to be able to do this, [[CreepyCrows via some association with crows.]]
*DroppedABridgeOnHim / TooCoolToLive [[spoiler: The fate of Hannibal Barker happens rather abruptly, though he goes out with an epic final flight]]. But then again, they NeverFoundTheBody.
*DualWielding: the classical trench-raider combination of pistol and melee weapon is often employed.
*EasterEgg: besides the openly explained elements, there are sideways references to multiple paranormal events, such as Mothman.
*TheEdwardianEra: naturally, the portions that take place before the War, though the paranormal elements push it into a GaslampFantasy feel.
*TheEmpire: how Britain, France, Germany, Russia, and the Austro-Hunagian Empire are portrayed.
*FantasyAmericana: the parts that take place in America (natch) focus on the idiosyncrasies of American mythology, particularly baseball.
*FootnoteFever: There are hundreds of footnoted references, and most seem to be real. [[FictionalDocument Some are not.]]
*ForegoneConclusion: by it's very nature, there's quite a bit of historical irony involving the ultimate fate of the nations involved in the war.
*GeniusBonus: WGWD rewards a knowledge of both the First World War and the occult.
*GeniusBruiser: most of the Nine seem to be huge (apart from Anna Sokoll), physically powerful, and highly intelligent.
*GeniusLoci: [[NothingIsScarier whatever]] Amadeo Avezzana encountered in the mountains may have been this, a delusion,or [[EpilepticTrees the Whore of Babylon.]]
*GodIsEvil: a possibility of what the UnseenEvil driving the plot may be.
*GratuitousForeignLanguage: As expected of a work taking place in many places across the world, it is littered with multiple languages.
*GravityMaster: The talent of Anna Sokoll, though she may be using some sort of telekenetic levitation ability.
*HeroicAlbino: Sigfried Gottlieb, perhaps the nicest and most gentle of the main characters, is a big Bavarian farmboy with albinism. His eyesight is also poor, and [[LightEmUp he uses a light manipulation talent to see better.]] [[{{Invisibility}} And turn invisible.]]
*HistoricalDomainCharacter: Many historical figures get name-checked, but Kaiser Wilhelm II and paranormal investigator Elliott O'Donnell get the most attention. Along with a certain [[UnexpectedCharacter 18th century figure]].
*IcyBlueEyes: Celeste's eyes are noted to be strikingly bright blue and either blazing or cold by everyone she meets, and she appears to be a heat manipulator of some sort, both an IcePerson and a PlayingWithFire. Even more noticable as she's half-African, a Dahomey.
*IHaveManyNames: “Alter Venetianer” seems to have multiple aliases, including Alter Sandmann and the Crow-King.
* IKnowYourTrueName : Thomas Noun believes in some form of name magic, and claims his surname, which simply means “Name,” is the result of an act of Name magic that hid his family's TrueName in the last words of the last man. Indeed, attempting to record the name seems to cause people's memories to glitch and misspell it.
*JerkassWoobie: many of the characters portray hints of cruelty, casual bigotry, and murderous intent, but it's pretty clear that they're breaking down from the horrors of war.
*JigsawPuzzlePlot
*LemonyNarrator: The narrator is largely journalistic in tone, but occasionally drops some humorous asides.
*LongList: Crops up, occasionally, particularly in the lists of airship sighting.
*LuckManipulationMechanic: What appears to be Hannibal Barker's “superpower,” the ability to gain fortune now and misfortune later, or vice-versa.
*MagicRealism: elements of it, such as in the tale of the Orkney Isle “mermaids” and the Rat-king.
*MaybeMagicMaybeMundane: The Cambridge Cabal and their “magic ring” - the ring behaved oddly, once, in rolling on the bridge after allegedly falling into the water below. But all the good fortune it grants could have easily happened anyway to the privileged group.
*MeaningfulName: Hannibal Barker, in a world that focused on the “name” of. And of course, Noun.
*{{Mundanger}}: Sometimes non-supernatural but historical oddities are thrown in, including the national myths and delusions of the various Great Powers, and how they led to war.
*MilkmanConspiracy: a real conspiracy of Ophthalmologists is mentioned.
*MythicalMotifs: Along with common angelic and demonic imagery, [Myth/ClassicalMythology Medea]] and Moloch are recurring symbols of a culture sacrificing its own children.
*NighInvulnerable: Thomas Noun easily recovers from evisceration due to a powerful HealingFactor.
*NothingIsScarier: the implications of most of the high strangeness is simply implied.
*OccultDetective: Winepress and Noun serve this role in the British Armed Forces. Also, the narrator.
*OneSteveLimit: Some common names, like Thomas and variations of Marie/Mary/Maria occur multiple times in the text, and there are both a von Böhm and a minor character called Böhm.
*OrderliesAreCreeps: Dr. Laurent's hospital is unsettling, and the odd people in it don't help.
*PerspectiveFlip: the tale jumps across many, many perspectives, with both the Allies and Central Powers taking turns as the evil enemy.
*PostModernism
*PowerBornOfMadness: a possible explanation for the “superpowers” of the protagonists.
*RealismInducedHorror: The most unsettling events of the story arise from AluminiumChristmasTrees and the very real horrors of war.
*RealityWarper: Certain entities (possibly PhysicalGods) and places seem to actively warp what's possible, and [[{{Muggles}} mundane people]] [[BrownNote who witness it seem to have to roll a Sanity Save.]] Though it may all be simple PsychicPowers.
*RedEyesTakeWarning
*RoomFullOfCrazy: Tom Noun's bed in the Somme hospital is covered in anti-fairy wards.
*ScrapbookStory: the narrative even includes historical newspaper articles alongside journal entries.
*ScienceFantasy, of the FantasyKitchenSink variety.
*ShellShockedVeteran: Well, Noun and Siegfried Gottlieb are both Shell-Shocked current participants of the Great War.
*SkepticismFailure: happens multiple times, most notably when Thom Murdock witnesses “the finwife.”
*SpyFiction: Many elements of WWI-era spy fiction, along with actual historical esponiage, crop up in the book, particularly the actions carried out by Alister Crowley.
*StylisticSuck: some of the first-person accounts, both the real ones and the (seemingly) fictional accounts can be notably worse in spelling, grammar, and diction than the rest of the text.
*UnreliableNarrator: as expected for a tale proposing to piece together a secret history from first-person and second-hand accounts, there are multiple instances of misinterpretations, AlternateCharacterInterpretation, and people believing things that are flat out wrong or written ThroughTheEyesOfMadness. Also, the reliance on such sources leads to many cases of TheUnreveal, ThatWasTheLastEntry, and WhatHappenedToTheMouse.
*UnwittingPawn: Practically everyone in the war, but Siegfried in particular is a jerked around by his superiors, who remain mum on their ultimate goals.
*WeatherManipulation: what seems to be Baron von Bohm's superpower, based on the real life popularity of “Weather-shooting” in Austria.
*WeirdHistoricalWar, including elements that feel like predacessors to SovietSuperscience and {{Ghostapo}}
*WhamLine: In the final lines of the first book, Winepress reveals that the enemy they are uniting against [[spoiler: are angels, and the references to the Battle of Armageddon and allusions to the Book of Revelation are not metaphorical]].
*WorldOfMysteries: while many elements seem to converge on the Nine and [[spoiler: the angels]], some things, like the ratking and mermaids, simply seem to be around.
*YourMindMakesItReal: Jacques Vallée's theories surrounding culture shaping our perception of Unidentified Flying Objects plays a minor role in the story's worldbuilding.

Top