Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheWarlordChronicles

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A TV series adaptation of the first book, also called ''The Winter King'', was announced in 2020 for Creator/MGMPlus, just before the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic hit. The production eventually moved to Creator/{{ITV}}, filming having begun in 2022. The series eventually premiered on MGM+ in August 2023 in the US only. A UK release is due to follow on ITVX later in the year.

to:

A TV series adaptation of the first book, also called ''The Winter King'', ''Series/TheWinterKing'', was announced in 2020 for Creator/MGMPlus, just before the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic hit. The production eventually moved to Creator/{{ITV}}, filming having begun in 2022. The series eventually premiered on MGM+ in August 2023 in the US only. A UK release is due to follow on ITVX later in the year.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseLinguistics: Nimue renames the injured Saxon boy in her care "Derfel", and says it means "strong", and so he'll pull through. It's "Cadarn", his future epithet and the name of the Camelot-equivalent fortress Caer Cadarn, that's supposed to mean "strong" or "mighty".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Baby Mordred is Uther's son instead of grandson, and thus Arthur's half-brother instead of nephew (and brother to the elder Mordred instead of his son).
** Mordred's mother Norwenna is thus Uther's latest wife and queen rather than daughter-in-law (the elder Mordred's wife).

to:

** Baby Mordred is Uther's son instead of grandson, and thus Arthur's half-brother instead of nephew (and brother probably half-brother to the elder Mordred instead of his son).
** Mordred's mother Norwenna is thus Uther's latest wife and queen rather than daughter-in-law (the elder Mordred's wife). wife), despite being much younger, young enough to be the latter as in the books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Baby Mordred is Uther's son instead of grandson, and thus Arthur's half-brother instead of nephew (and also brother to the elder Mordred.

to:

** Baby Mordred is Uther's son instead of grandson, and thus Arthur's half-brother instead of nephew (and also brother to the elder Mordred.Mordred instead of his son).

Added: 750

Changed: 793

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbledInTheAdaptation: Morgan is introduced in the first book as scarred and disfigured from a fire, wearing a mask to hide her face. She is (yet) unburned in the show.

to:

* AbledInTheAdaptation: AbledInTheAdaptation:
**
Morgan is introduced in the first book as scarred and disfigured from a fire, wearing a mask to hide her face. She is (yet) unburned in the show.show.
** While Gundleus assaults Nimue, he doesn't take her eye.



* AgeLift: Merlin is portrayed as being early to mid-middle-aged at most, not elderly, even after there's a TimeSkip of 8 years where Derfel geos from a boy to a young man.

to:

* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: Merlin leads Nimue to believe she has VirginPower and therefore must forsake her attraction to Derfel, and this becomes more of an issue after Gundleus rapes her, at least partly to remove her power or so he believes. In her despair, she has suicidal thoughts and Derfel has to snap her out of it. In the book, she is under no such belief or restriction, not being a virgin thanks to the dirty old man Merlin, and she takes her rape and maiming in dissonantly far better stride, as she believes the trial empowered her in the eyes of the gods.
* AdaptationNameChange: Gorfyddyd (pronounced "Gor-fith-id") is simplified to Gorfydd ("Gor-fith").
* AgeLift: Merlin is portrayed as being early to mid-middle-aged at most, not elderly, even after there's a TimeSkip of 8 years where Derfel geos goes from a boy to a young man.



* NoHoldsBarredBeatdown: How Uther punishes a wounded Arthur after the first Modred's death in battle

to:

* NoHoldsBarredBeatdown: How Uther punishes a wounded Arthur after the first Modred's Mordred's death in battlebattle.



[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]] * RelatedDifferentlyInTheAdaptation:
** Baby Mordred is Uther's son instead of grandson, and thus Arthur's half-brother instead of nephew (and also brother to the elder Mordred.
** Mordred's mother Norwenna is thus Uther's latest wife and queen rather than daughter-in-law (the elder Mordred's wife).
[[/folder]]

Added: 435

Changed: 401

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoodShepherd: Bishop Bedwin, even when in pagan Avalon with Norwenna.



* HistoricalFantasy: The first episode waffles a bit on MaybeMagicMaybeMundane early on, like with Merlin doing what could be stage-magic with birds or not, but later it shows Merlin's and Nimue's powers as unambiguously real, as they both see visions only they and/or the other can see, like spirit animals that are invisible to Derfel. Merlin touches the boy Derfel and seems to telepathically sense his doomed village, but it could just be Merlin imagining the obvious since Arthur told him about it. But later Merlin touches baby Mordred and sees bloody visions that have no reason to happen unless it's actually foresight.

to:

* HistoricalFantasy: The first episode waffles a bit on MaybeMagicMaybeMundane early on, like with MaybeMagicMaybeMundane: Played with, as in the books. There are moments where Merlin doing what could be stage-magic with birds or not, but later it shows Merlin's and Nimue's powers as seem to be unambiguously real, as they both see visions only they and/or the other can see, like spirit animals that are invisible to Derfel. Merlin touches the boy Derfel and seems to telepathically sense his doomed village, but it could just be Merlin imagining the obvious since Arthur told him about it. But later Merlin touches baby Mordred and sees bloody visions that have no reason to happen unless it's actually foresight. On the other hand, the birds Merlin releases in during the bull idol ceremony seem to have just been pre-placed, and Nimue clearly uses fire trickery when trying to defend Avalon against Gundleus.


Added DiffLines:

* PoliticallyCorrectHistory: For a show set in 5th-Century Britain, the amount of black Africans in Avalon is odd to say the least. (Sagramor's presence in Arthur's band notwithstanding, as the books explain him to be a Numidian auxiliary of the old Roman army.) The apparent HandWave explanation is that Merlin's Avalon is a place for "those who don't fit in."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OohMeAccent'sSlipping: Stuart Campbell (Derfel) noticeably slips into his natural Scottish accent while berating Gundleus for his treachery.

to:

* OohMeAccent'sSlipping: OohMeAccentsSlipping: Stuart Campbell (Derfel) noticeably slips into his natural Scottish accent while berating Gundleus for his treachery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OohMeAccent'sSlipping: Stuart Campbell (Derfel) noticeably slips into his natural Scottish accent while berating Gundleus for his treachery.

Added: 401

Changed: 474

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This extends to the names of characters with no real equivalent in later works. Arthur's sons are called "Amhar" and Loholt" - "Amhar" is a 12th century form of the Welsh name "Amr" who appears in the 9th century ''Literature/HistoriaBrittonum'', while "Loholt" comes from 12th and 13th century French works like ''Érec et Énide'' and ''Perlesvaus''. "Culhwch", Arthur's kinsman from the older Welsh tale ''Culhwch and Olwen'' collected in the ''Literature/{{Mabinogion}}'', rubs shoulders with people like "Lancelot", "Galahad" and "Sagramor," whose names come from much later French works.
** Cornwell admits in the author's notes that he deliberately kept the more anachronistic names like Mordred, Guinevere, and Lancelot because they were simply too iconic to replace in his mind.

to:

** This extends to the names of characters with no real equivalent in later works. Arthur's sons are called "Amhar" and Loholt" - "Amhar" is a 12th century form of the Welsh name "Amr" who appears in the 9th century ''Literature/HistoriaBrittonum'', while "Loholt" comes from 12th and 13th century French works like ''Érec et Énide'' and ''Perlesvaus''. "Culhwch", Arthur's kinsman from the older Welsh tale ''Culhwch and Olwen'' collected in the ''Literature/{{Mabinogion}}'', rubs shoulders with people like "Lancelot", "Galahad" and "Sagramor," whose names come from much later French works.
**
works. Cornwell admits in the author's notes that he deliberately kept the more anachronistic names like Mordred, Guinevere, and Lancelot because they were simply too iconic to replace in his mind.mind.
** The Thirteen Treasures have their traditional names despite many of those names referring to figures who post-date both the narrative and the framing device, such as the Chariot of Morgan Mwynfawr, who TheOtherWiki dates to around 730.


Added DiffLines:

* PublicDomainArtifact: The Thirteen Treasures of Britain provide the focal point of Merlin and Nimue's plans. The Cauldron of Clyddno Eiddyn is a composite of the Halter of Clyddno Eiddyn, the Cauldron of Dwrnach the Giant (who is [[DoingInTheWizard reimagined]] as a mundane if bloodthirsty Irishman named Diwrnach) and the Holy Grail, [[spoiler:and Dwrnwyn the sword is composited with Excalibur]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DecoyProtagonist: The first half of the pilot episode specifically focuses on Arthur and his banishment (an off-page event in the books), before shifting focus to Derfel, the book protagonist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FaceDeathWithDignity: Arthur doesn't resist when Uther is about to execute him for failing to protect the original Mordred, though intervention from Morgan and Merlin spares Arthur from this.


Added DiffLines:

* NoHoldsBarredBeatdown: How Uther punishes a wounded Arthur after the first Modred's death in battle
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleaning up some earlier edits


** Lancelot is one with [[spoiler:Geoffrey of Monmouth's depiction of Mordred, Arthur's regent who seduces Guinevere and allies with the Saxons]].
** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant and a Saxon like the version of Kay from ArthurOfTheBritons [[spoiler:and the killer of one of Arthur's sons as in ''Perlesvaus'']], and, ironically, Lancelot (specifically, the version depicted in ''Lanzelet''). Also, as his first lover is Lunete (Lynette), he can be viewed as a stand-in for Sir Gareth.

to:

** Lancelot is one with [[spoiler:Geoffrey [[spoiler: [[Literature/HistoriaRegumBritanniae Geoffrey of Monmouth's depiction of Mordred, Mordred]], Arthur's regent who seduces Guinevere and allies with the Saxons]].
** Derfel ultimately becomes is one with both [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of for Kay, being Arthur's close confidant and (he's even a Saxon like the version of Kay from ArthurOfTheBritons Series/ArthurOfTheBritons) [[spoiler:and the killer of one of Arthur's sons as in ''Perlesvaus'']], and, ironically, Lancelot (specifically, the version depicted in ''Lanzelet''). Also, as his first lover is Lunete (Lynette), he can be viewed as a stand-in for Sir Gareth.Gareth, while his relationship with Nimue brings to mind Sir Pelleas. He ultimately becomes one with both Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and [[spoiler:Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water]].



** Ceinwyn is a composite of Amide (Percivale's sister and the Grail Maiden) and one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads, being Arthur's first betrothed. [[spoiler:She also becomes a stand-in for Percivale's lady love Blancheflour like Derfel does for Percivale himself.]]
** Argante takes the name of a faerie queen from Layamon's ''Brut'', but as [[spoiler:Arthur's third wife she stands in for one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads (even being barren like later depictions of Guenivere) and given that he sets Guenivere aside to marry her and then sets her aside to take Guenivere back, this makes her the "False" Guenivere.]] As Mordred's wife she combines his two traditional wives Gwenhwyfach and Saint Cywyllog.

to:

** Ceinwyn is a composite of Amide (Percivale's sister and the Grail Maiden) and one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads, being Arthur's first betrothed. [[spoiler:She She also becomes a stand-in for Percivale's lady love Blancheflour like Derfel does for Percivale himself.]]
himself.
** Argante takes the name of a faerie queen from Layamon's ''Brut'', but as [[spoiler:Arthur's third wife she stands in for one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads (even being barren like later depictions of Guenivere) Guinevere) and given that he sets Guenivere Guinevere aside to marry her and then sets her aside to take Guenivere Guinevere back, this makes her the "False" Guenivere.]] As Mordred's wife she combines his two traditional wives Gwenhwyfach and Saint Cywyllog.

Added: 367

Changed: 451

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In general, the books are less a ''truly'' "historically accurate" or "possible/plausible truth behind the legend" version of Arthur and more a {{Deconstruction}} of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great battle (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King''), Lancelot shows up, there is a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at the equivalent of Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are in the final book, and none of Arthur's eleven other traditional battles are given so much of a nod.
** At one point Merlin remarks to Derfel how much of Christianity is taken from earlier pagan religions, but it's mostly based on DatedHistory that was pushed in the 18th century onward, the kind repeated in pop culture like ''Zeitgeist'' and ''Literature/TheDaVinciCode'' that secular historians today generally have moved past.

to:

** In general, the books are less a ''truly'' "historically accurate" or "possible/plausible truth behind the legend" version of Arthur in the vein of Literature/SwordAtSunset or Literature/HereLiesArthur and more a {{Deconstruction}} of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great battle (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King''), Lancelot shows up, there is a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at the equivalent of Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are in the final book, and none of Arthur's eleven other traditional battles are given so much of a nod.
** At one point Merlin remarks to Derfel how much of Christianity is taken from earlier pagan religions, religions (specifically Mithraism), but it's mostly based on DatedHistory that was pushed in the 18th century onward, the kind repeated in pop culture like ''Zeitgeist'' and ''Literature/TheDaVinciCode'' that secular historians today generally have moved past.



* TheGhost: Clovis, the famous High King of the Franks, indirectly aids the Saxons and opposes Arthur, but never actually makes an appearance.

to:

* TheGhost: Clovis, the famous High King of the Franks, indirectly aids the Saxons and opposes Arthur, but never actually makes an appearance. Likewise, Budic of Broceliande is brother-in-law to Arthur, father of Gawain and one of Mark's wives, his conflicts with the Franks make up a major part of first Arthur's and then Mordred's military experience - but he never shows up in person and so we know nothing of his character [[spoiler:or even how he reacted to Gawain's death]].



* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Sansum is loosely - very loosely - based on Saint Samson of Dol, who is traditionally portrayed as a monastic reformer and one of the Seven Founding Saints of Brittany. Here he is TheFundamentalist, a {{Hypocrite}}, implied to be a pederast, and generally the most antagonistic figure in the entire narrative.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Sansum is loosely - very loosely - based on Saint Samson of Dol, who is traditionally portrayed as a monastic reformer and one of the Seven Founding Saints of Brittany. Here he is TheFundamentalist, a {{Hypocrite}}, implied to be a pederast, [[PedophilePriest pederast]], and generally the most antagonistic figure in the entire narrative.


Added DiffLines:

* PersonalDictionary: Sansum repeatedly refers to himself (and a handful of other characters he likes) as a living saint - an oxymoron even in the 6th century, as a saint by nature needs to Heaven (in other words, ''dead''). Derfel adopts this habit when referring to figures like Cadoc and Carannog, likely because Sansum was his main source on the nature of saints.

Changed: 310

Removed: 409

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
With Adaptational Villainy added in, Historical Villain Upgrade no longer fits for the ahistorical Lancelot


* HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
** Lancelot isn't historical, but he's unusually portrayed as a complete bastard and DirtyCoward.
** Sansum is loosely - very loosely - based on Saint Samson of Dol, who is traditionally portrayed as a monastic reformer and one of the Seven Founding Saints of Brittany. Here he is TheFundamentalist, a {{Hypocrite}}, implied to be a pederast, and generally the most antagonistic figure in the entire narrative.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
** Lancelot isn't historical, but he's unusually portrayed as a complete bastard and DirtyCoward.
**
HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Sansum is loosely - very loosely - based on Saint Samson of Dol, who is traditionally portrayed as a monastic reformer and one of the Seven Founding Saints of Brittany. Here he is TheFundamentalist, a {{Hypocrite}}, implied to be a pederast, and generally the most antagonistic figure in the entire narrative.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbledInTheAdaptation: Morgan is introduced in the first book as scarred and disfigured from a fire, wearing a mask to hide her face. She is (yet) unburned in the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalFantasy: The first episode waffles a bit on MaybeMagicMaybeMundane early on, like with Merlin doing what could be stage-magic with birds or not, but later it shows Merlin's and Nimue's powers as unambiguously real, as they both see visions only they or the other can see. Merlin touches the boy Derfel and seems to telepathically sense his doomed village, but it could just be Merlin imagining the obvious since Arthur told him about it. But later Merlin touches baby Mordred and sees bloody visions that have no reason to happen unless it's actually foresight.

to:

* HistoricalFantasy: The first episode waffles a bit on MaybeMagicMaybeMundane early on, like with Merlin doing what could be stage-magic with birds or not, but later it shows Merlin's and Nimue's powers as unambiguously real, as they both see visions only they or and/or the other can see.see, like spirit animals that are invisible to Derfel. Merlin touches the boy Derfel and seems to telepathically sense his doomed village, but it could just be Merlin imagining the obvious since Arthur told him about it. But later Merlin touches baby Mordred and sees bloody visions that have no reason to happen unless it's actually foresight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:TV series]]
!! ''The Winter King'' miniseries further includes:

* AdaptationExpansion: The show doesn't have the FramingDevice of old Derfel telling the story, and it has an omniscient shifting point of view going and forth between subplots and characters rather than stick to just Derfel's. This means Arthur gets more focus early on in the first episode as it shows him getting banished from Britain by Uther, but not before saving Derfel as a child and taking him to Avalon.
* AgeLift: Merlin is portrayed as being early to mid-middle-aged at most, not elderly, even after there's a TimeSkip of 8 years where Derfel geos from a boy to a young man.
* HistoricalFantasy: The first episode waffles a bit on MaybeMagicMaybeMundane early on, like with Merlin doing what could be stage-magic with birds or not, but later it shows Merlin's and Nimue's powers as unambiguously real, as they both see visions only they or the other can see. Merlin touches the boy Derfel and seems to telepathically sense his doomed village, but it could just be Merlin imagining the obvious since Arthur told him about it. But later Merlin touches baby Mordred and sees bloody visions that have no reason to happen unless it's actually foresight.
* RaceLift: The first episode includes Sagramor, but a number of Celtic British characters including Merlin himself are portrayed by black actors.
[[/folder]]

Changed: 38

Removed: 165

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Irrelevant and doesn't actually support the trope


* TokenMinority: Sagramor. In the original stories he was a Hungarian prince, but this more historically-accurate setting being a few centuries too early for them, Cornwell has him a Nubian (making him a CompositeCharacter with "African" or "Saracen" knights like Palamedes and Segwarides) who made his way to Gaul serving in the Roman army and wound up in Arthur's service. The Saxons (and Argante's druid) think he's a demon and [[ScaryBlackMan he does nothing to discourage this impression.]]
** TruthInTelevision: There have been upper-class graves discovered in Britain with people of African descent in them - Roman Britain was a truly cosmopolitan place.

to:

* TokenMinority: Sagramor. In the original stories he was a Hungarian prince, but this more historically-accurate setting being a few centuries too early for them, Cornwell has him a Nubian (making him a CompositeCharacter with "African" or "Saracen" knights like Palamedes and Segwarides) who made his way to Gaul serving in the Roman army and wound up in Arthur's service. The Due to his being unique and exotic, the Saxons (and Argante's druid) think he's a demon and [[ScaryBlackMan he does nothing to discourage this impression.]]
** TruthInTelevision: There have been upper-class graves discovered in Britain with people of African descent in them - Roman Britain was a truly cosmopolitan place.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one book, Culhwch mocks another character using the Latin phrase "cassus belli" (reason/cause for war) by saying "cow's belly". He and Derfel reminisce about this many years later in the next book. But this only works in English, not the Old Briton they would have been speaking, and for that matter [[TranslationConvention it wouldn't have worked in the Old Briton Derfel is supposed to be writing in.]]

to:

** In one book, Culhwch mocks another character using the Latin phrase "cassus belli" (reason/cause for war) by saying "cow's belly". He and Derfel reminisce about this many years later in the next book. But this only works in English, not the Old Briton they would have been speaking, and for that matter [[TranslationConvention it wouldn't have worked in the Old Briton English Derfel is supposed to be writing in.]]

Added: 2865

Changed: 659

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Damn, didn't see the edit conflict, sorry


** In one book, Culhwch mocks another character using the Latin phrase "cassus belli" (reason/cause for war) by saying "cow's belly". He and Derfel reminisce about this many years later in the next book. But this only works in English which they would not be speaking, and [[TranslationConvention it doesn't work in Welsh either.]]

to:

** In one book, Culhwch mocks another character using the Latin phrase "cassus belli" (reason/cause for war) by saying "cow's belly". He and Derfel reminisce about this many years later in the next book. But this only works in English which English, not the Old Briton they would not be have been speaking, and for that matter [[TranslationConvention it doesn't work wouldn't have worked in Welsh either.the Old Briton Derfel is supposed to be writing in.]]



** Lancelot is one with [[spoiler:Geoffrey of Monmouth's depiction of Mordred, Arthur's regent who seduces Guinevere and allies with the Saxons.]]
** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant, and, ironically, Lancelot.
** Culhwch takes on a lot of the traits traditionally given to Gawaine, being a BoisterousBruiser who is friendly with everyone (except Lancelot).
* CoolHorse: Arthur and his knights use large warhorses to intimidate their enemies, rather that the smaller horses normally used by the Britons for scouting and skirmishing.

to:

** Lancelot is one with [[spoiler:Geoffrey of Monmouth's depiction of Mordred, Arthur's regent who seduces Guinevere and allies with the Saxons.]]
Saxons]].
** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant, confidant and a Saxon like the version of Kay from ArthurOfTheBritons [[spoiler:and the killer of one of Arthur's sons as in ''Perlesvaus'']], and, ironically, Lancelot.
Lancelot (specifically, the version depicted in ''Lanzelet''). Also, as his first lover is Lunete (Lynette), he can be viewed as a stand-in for Sir Gareth.
** Culhwch takes on a lot of the traits traditionally given to Gawaine, Gawain, being a BoisterousBruiser who is friendly with everyone (except Lancelot).
** Mardoc, being the son of Mordred, is one with Melehan.
** Ceinwyn is a composite of Amide (Percivale's sister and the Grail Maiden) and one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads, being Arthur's first betrothed. [[spoiler:She also becomes a stand-in for Percivale's lady love Blancheflour like Derfel does for Percivale himself.]]
** Argante takes the name of a faerie queen from Layamon's ''Brut'', but as [[spoiler:Arthur's third wife she stands in for one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads (even being barren like later depictions of Guenivere) and given that he sets Guenivere aside to marry her and then sets her aside to take Guenivere back, this makes her the "False" Guenivere.]] As Mordred's wife she combines his two traditional wives Gwenhwyfach and Saint Cywyllog.
** Guinevere, Ceinwyn, and Seren [[spoiler: ultimately become the three ladies who help Morgan take Arthur to Avalon.]]
* CoolHorse: Arthur and his knights use large warhorses to intimidate their enemies, rather that the smaller horses normally used by the Britons for scouting and skirmishing. Arthur himself rides a majestic mare named Llamrei.



* OneSteveLimit: Averted, with two Igraines (Arthur's mother and Derfel's patron) and also two seperate characters named Gawaine (one a member of Arthur's warband, the other a more plot relevant character in ''Excalibur'' who seems to have no relation to the prior).

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted, with two Mordreds who are father and son, two Igraines (Arthur's mother and Derfel's patron) and also two seperate characters named Gawaine Gawain (one a member of Arthur's warband, the other a more plot relevant character in ''Excalibur'' who seems to have no relation to the prior).



* RelatedInTheAdaptation:
** Mardoc, an Italian interpretation of Meleagaunt, is made Mordred's son.
** Peredur (Percivale) is the son of Lancelot and Ade (a minor love interest of Lancelot's from the Prose Lancelot).
** [[spoiler: Derfel Cadarn is the son of Aelle.]]
* RelatedDifferentlyInTheAdaptation:
** Mordred here is Arthur's paternal nephew, not his maternal one (let alone his incestous son).
** Morgan and Arthur are full siblings, rather than half-siblings. Extending this, Igraine was Uther's mistress rather than his wife, and Cunedda's daughter instead of granddaughter.
** Lancelot and Galahad are half-brothers rather than father and son.
** Budic is Uther's son-in-law rather than cousin, and by extent is the father of Gawain here instead of Lot.
** Gwydre is the legitimate son of Arthur and Guenivere rather than being one of Arthur's bastards.
** Tristan is the son of Mark instead of his nephew.



* SparedByTheAdaptation: [[spoiler: Galahad doesn't die at the conclusion of the Grail Quest analog, and in fact survives Camlann. Likewise, Gwydre doesn't die in a boar hunt and also survives Camlann.]]



* TokenMinority: Sagramor. In the original stories he was a Hungarian prince, but this more historically-accurate setting being a few centuries too early for them, Cornwell has him a Nubian (making him a CompositeCharacter with ''African'' or ''Saracen'' knights like Palamedes and Segwarides) who made his way to Gaul serving in the Roman army and wound up in Arthur's service. The Saxons think he's a demon and [[ScaryBlackMan he does nothing to discourage this impression.]]

to:

* TokenMinority: Sagramor. In the original stories he was a Hungarian prince, but this more historically-accurate setting being a few centuries too early for them, Cornwell has him a Nubian (making him a CompositeCharacter with ''African'' "African" or ''Saracen'' "Saracen" knights like Palamedes and Segwarides) who made his way to Gaul serving in the Roman army and wound up in Arthur's service. The Saxons (and Argante's druid) think he's a demon and [[ScaryBlackMan he does nothing to discourage this impression.]]


Added DiffLines:

* UnrelatedInTheAdaptation:
** There is both a Culhwch and an Olwen in the narrative, but they never meet or interact in any way, let alone become love interests.
** Cadoc doesn't appear to be related to Gundleus in any way, beyond Derfel suspecting he might have once been a spearman in the Silurian warband - certainly, no indication is given that he is Gundleus's son.
** Hywel is Derfel's initial mentor, not his father, and isn't related to Budic in any manner.
** There is no indication that Bors is related to Lancelot.
** In the Welsh Genealogies Cadwy is the son of Geraint, while here they belong to the same generation and are only connected by both being Dumnonian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: In the council at Glevum early in ''The Winter King'', a lot of hay is made about protecting King Meriadoc of Stronggore. Meriadoc is namedropped a couple more times before he and Stronggore are completely forgotten about.

Added: 330

Changed: 993

Removed: 3113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one book, Culhwch mocks another character using the Latin phrase "cassus belli" (reason/cause for war) by saying "cow's belly". He and Derfel reminisce about this many years later in the next book. But this only works in English, not the Old Briton they would have been speaking, and for that matter[[TranslationConvention it wouldn't have worked in the Old English Derfel is supposed to be writing in.]]

to:

** In one book, Culhwch mocks another character using the Latin phrase "cassus belli" (reason/cause for war) by saying "cow's belly". He and Derfel reminisce about this many years later in the next book. But this only works in English, not the Old Briton English which they would have been not be speaking, and for that matter[[TranslationConvention [[TranslationConvention it wouldn't have worked doesn't work in the Old English Derfel is supposed to be writing in.Welsh either.]]



** The Saxons are depicted as little more than berserkers who use [[ZergRush human wave tactics]] and [[AttackAnimal war dogs]]. This is a case of DatedHistory, as scholarly opinion and archaeological evidence now shows the Saxons used shieldwall tactics similar to what the Britons are depicted using in the books, complete with cavalry support - and there is no evidence of war dogs having ever been a thing.
** In general, the books are less a ''historically accurate'' version of Arthur and more a {{Deconstruction}} of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great battle (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King''), Lancelot shows up, there is a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are in the final book, and none of Arthur's eleven other traditional battles are given so much of a nod.

to:

** The Saxons are depicted as little more than berserkers who use [[ZergRush human wave tactics]] and [[AttackAnimal war dogs]]. This is a case of DatedHistory, Perhaps this was to play up the contrast between the factions, as scholarly opinion and archaeological evidence now shows the Saxons used shieldwall tactics similar to what the Britons are depicted using against them and each other in the books, complete with cavalry support - and there is no evidence of war dogs having ever been a thing.
thing. Plus there are a few mentions of them wearing horned helmets which is clearly DatedHistory. The later series ''Literature/TheSaxonStories'' by the same author do heavily emphasize them using shieldwalls in warfare.
** In general, the books are less a ''historically accurate'' ''truly'' "historically accurate" or "possible/plausible truth behind the legend" version of Arthur and more a {{Deconstruction}} of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great battle (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King''), Lancelot shows up, there is a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at the equivalent of Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are in the final book, and none of Arthur's eleven other traditional battles are given so much of a nod.nod.
** At one point Merlin remarks to Derfel how much of Christianity is taken from earlier pagan religions, but it's mostly based on DatedHistory that was pushed in the 18th century onward, the kind repeated in pop culture like ''Zeitgeist'' and ''Literature/TheDaVinciCode'' that secular historians today generally have moved past.



** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant and a Saxon like the version of Kay from ArthurOfTheBritons [[spoiler:and the killer of one of Arthur's sons as in ''Perlesvaus'']], and, ironically, Lancelot (specifically, the version depicted in ''Lanzelet''). Also, as his first lover is Lunete (Lynette), he can be viewed as a stand-in for Sir Gareth.
** Culhwch takes on a lot of the traits traditionally given to Gawain, being a BoisterousBruiser who is friendly with everyone (except Lancelot).
** Mardoc, being the son of Mordred, is one with Melehan.
** Ceinwyn is a composite of Amide (Percivale's sister and the Grail Maiden) and one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads, being Arthur's first betrothed. [[spoiler:She also becomes a stand-in for Percivale's lady love Blancheflour like Derfel does for Percivale himself.]]
** Argante takes the name of a faerie queen from Layamon's ''Brut'', but as [[spoiler:Arthur's third wife she stands in for one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads (even being barren like later depictions of Guenivere) and given that he sets Guenivere aside to marry her and then sets her aside to take Guenivere back, this makes her the "False" Guenivere.]] As Mordred's wife she combines his two traditional wives Gwenhwyfach and Saint Cywyllog.
** Guinevere, Ceinwyn, and Seren [[spoiler: ultimately become the three ladies who help Morgan take Arthur to Avalon.]]
* CoolHorse: Arthur and his knights use large warhorses to intimidate their enemies, rather that the smaller horses normally used by the Britons for scouting and skirmishing. Arthur himself rides a majestic mare named Llamrei.

to:

** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant and a Saxon like the version of Kay from ArthurOfTheBritons [[spoiler:and the killer of one of Arthur's sons as in ''Perlesvaus'']], confidant, and, ironically, Lancelot (specifically, the version depicted in ''Lanzelet''). Also, as his first lover is Lunete (Lynette), he can be viewed as a stand-in for Sir Gareth.
Lancelot.
** Culhwch takes on a lot of the traits traditionally given to Gawain, Gawaine, being a BoisterousBruiser who is friendly with everyone (except Lancelot).
** Mardoc, being the son of Mordred, is one with Melehan.
** Ceinwyn is a composite of Amide (Percivale's sister and the Grail Maiden) and one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads, being Arthur's first betrothed. [[spoiler:She also becomes a stand-in for Percivale's lady love Blancheflour like Derfel does for Percivale himself.]]
** Argante takes the name of a faerie queen from Layamon's ''Brut'', but as [[spoiler:Arthur's third wife she stands in for one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads (even being barren like later depictions of Guenivere) and given that he sets Guenivere aside to marry her and then sets her aside to take Guenivere back, this makes her the "False" Guenivere.]] As Mordred's wife she combines his two traditional wives Gwenhwyfach and Saint Cywyllog.
** Guinevere, Ceinwyn, and Seren [[spoiler: ultimately become the three ladies who help Morgan take Arthur to Avalon.]]
* CoolHorse: Arthur and his knights use large warhorses to intimidate their enemies, rather that the smaller horses normally used by the Britons for scouting and skirmishing. Arthur himself rides a majestic mare named Llamrei.



* OneSteveLimit: Averted, with two Igraines (Arthur's mother and Derfel's patron) and also two seperate characters named Gawain (one a member of Arthur's warband, the other a more plot relevant character in ''Excalibur'' who seems to have no relation to the prior).

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted, with two Igraines (Arthur's mother and Derfel's patron) and also two seperate characters named Gawain Gawaine (one a member of Arthur's warband, the other a more plot relevant character in ''Excalibur'' who seems to have no relation to the prior).



* RelatedInTheAdaptation:
** Mardoc, an Italian interpretation of Meleagaunt, is made Mordred's son.
** Peredur (Percivale) is the son of Lancelot and Ade (a minor love interest of Lancelot's from the Prose Lancelot).
** [[spoiler: Derfel Cadarn is the son of Aelle.]]
* RelatedDifferentlyInTheAdaptation:
** Mordred here is Arthur's paternal nephew, not his maternal one (let alone his incestous son).
** Morgan and Arthur are full siblings, rather than half-siblings. Extending this, Igraine was Uther's mistress rather than his wife, and Cunedda's daughter instead of granddaughter.
** Lancelot and Galahad are half-brothers rather than father and son.
** Budic is Uther's son-in-law rather than cousin, and by extent is the father of Gawain here instead of Lot.
** Gwydre is the legitimate son of Arthur and Guenivere rather than being one of Arthur's bastards.
** Tristan is the son of Mark instead of his nephew.



* SparedByTheAdaptation: [[spoiler: Galahad doesn't die at the conclusion of the Grail Quest analog, and in fact survives Camlann. Likewise, Gwydre doesn't die in a boar hunt and also survives Camlann.]]



* TokenMinority: Sagramor. In the original stories he was a Hungarian prince, but this more historically-accurate setting being a few centuries too early for them, Cornwell has him a Nubian (making him a CompositeCharacter with "African" or "Saracen" knights like Palamedes and Segwarides) who made his way to Gaul serving in the Roman army and wound up in Arthur's service. The Saxons (and Argante's druid) think he's a demon and [[ScaryBlackMan he does nothing to discourage this impression.]]

to:

* TokenMinority: Sagramor. In the original stories he was a Hungarian prince, but this more historically-accurate setting being a few centuries too early for them, Cornwell has him a Nubian (making him a CompositeCharacter with "African" ''African'' or "Saracen" ''Saracen'' knights like Palamedes and Segwarides) who made his way to Gaul serving in the Roman army and wound up in Arthur's service. The Saxons (and Argante's druid) think he's a demon and [[ScaryBlackMan he does nothing to discourage this impression.]]



* UnrelatedInTheAdaptation:
** There is both a Culhwch and an Olwen in the narrative, but they never meet or interact in any way, let alone become love interests.
** Cadoc doesn't appear to be related to Gundleus in any way, beyond Derfel suspecting he might have once been a spearman in the Silurian warband - certainly, no indication is given that he is Gundleus's son.
** Hywel is Derfel's initial mentor, not his father, and isn't related to Budic in any manner.
** There is no indication that Bors is related to Lancelot.
** In the Welsh Genealogies Cadwy is the son of Geraint, while here they belong to the same generation and are only connected by both being Dumnonian.



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: In the council at Glevum early in ''The Winter King'', a lot of hay is made about protecting King Meriadoc of Stronggore. Meriadoc is namedropped a couple more times before he and Stronggore are completely forgotten about.

Added: 3113

Changed: 612

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one book, Culhwch mocks another character using the Latin phrase "cassus belli" (reason/cause for war) by saying "cow's belly". He and Derfel reminisce about this many years later in the next book. But this only works in English which they would not be speaking, and [[TranslationConvention it doesn't work in Welsh either.]]

to:

** In one book, Culhwch mocks another character using the Latin phrase "cassus belli" (reason/cause for war) by saying "cow's belly". He and Derfel reminisce about this many years later in the next book. But this only works in English which English, not the Old Briton they would not be have been speaking, and [[TranslationConvention for that matter[[TranslationConvention it doesn't work wouldn't have worked in Welsh either.the Old English Derfel is supposed to be writing in.]]



** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant, and, ironically, Lancelot.
** Culhwch takes on a lot of the traits traditionally given to Gawaine, being a BoisterousBruiser who is friendly with everyone (except Lancelot).
* CoolHorse: Arthur and his knights use large warhorses to intimidate their enemies, rather that the smaller horses normally used by the Britons for scouting and skirmishing.

to:

** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant, confidant and a Saxon like the version of Kay from ArthurOfTheBritons [[spoiler:and the killer of one of Arthur's sons as in ''Perlesvaus'']], and, ironically, Lancelot.
Lancelot (specifically, the version depicted in ''Lanzelet''). Also, as his first lover is Lunete (Lynette), he can be viewed as a stand-in for Sir Gareth.
** Culhwch takes on a lot of the traits traditionally given to Gawaine, Gawain, being a BoisterousBruiser who is friendly with everyone (except Lancelot).
** Mardoc, being the son of Mordred, is one with Melehan.
** Ceinwyn is a composite of Amide (Percivale's sister and the Grail Maiden) and one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads, being Arthur's first betrothed. [[spoiler:She also becomes a stand-in for Percivale's lady love Blancheflour like Derfel does for Percivale himself.]]
** Argante takes the name of a faerie queen from Layamon's ''Brut'', but as [[spoiler:Arthur's third wife she stands in for one of the three Gwenhwyfars of the Welsh Triads (even being barren like later depictions of Guenivere) and given that he sets Guenivere aside to marry her and then sets her aside to take Guenivere back, this makes her the "False" Guenivere.]] As Mordred's wife she combines his two traditional wives Gwenhwyfach and Saint Cywyllog.
** Guinevere, Ceinwyn, and Seren [[spoiler: ultimately become the three ladies who help Morgan take Arthur to Avalon.]]
* CoolHorse: Arthur and his knights use large warhorses to intimidate their enemies, rather that the smaller horses normally used by the Britons for scouting and skirmishing. Arthur himself rides a majestic mare named Llamrei.



* OneSteveLimit: Averted, with two Igraines (Arthur's mother and Derfel's patron) and also two seperate characters named Gawaine (one a member of Arthur's warband, the other a more plot relevant character in ''Excalibur'' who seems to have no relation to the prior).

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted, with two Igraines (Arthur's mother and Derfel's patron) and also two seperate characters named Gawaine Gawain (one a member of Arthur's warband, the other a more plot relevant character in ''Excalibur'' who seems to have no relation to the prior).



* RelatedInTheAdaptation:
** Mardoc, an Italian interpretation of Meleagaunt, is made Mordred's son.
** Peredur (Percivale) is the son of Lancelot and Ade (a minor love interest of Lancelot's from the Prose Lancelot).
** [[spoiler: Derfel Cadarn is the son of Aelle.]]
* RelatedDifferentlyInTheAdaptation:
** Mordred here is Arthur's paternal nephew, not his maternal one (let alone his incestous son).
** Morgan and Arthur are full siblings, rather than half-siblings. Extending this, Igraine was Uther's mistress rather than his wife, and Cunedda's daughter instead of granddaughter.
** Lancelot and Galahad are half-brothers rather than father and son.
** Budic is Uther's son-in-law rather than cousin, and by extent is the father of Gawain here instead of Lot.
** Gwydre is the legitimate son of Arthur and Guenivere rather than being one of Arthur's bastards.
** Tristan is the son of Mark instead of his nephew.



* SparedByTheAdaptation: [[spoiler: Galahad doesn't die at the conclusion of the Grail Quest analog, and in fact survives Camlann. Likewise, Gwydre doesn't die in a boar hunt and also survives Camlann.]]



* TokenMinority: Sagramor. In the original stories he was a Hungarian prince, but this more historically-accurate setting being a few centuries too early for them, Cornwell has him a Nubian (making him a CompositeCharacter with ''African'' or ''Saracen'' knights like Palamedes and Segwarides) who made his way to Gaul serving in the Roman army and wound up in Arthur's service. The Saxons think he's a demon and [[ScaryBlackMan he does nothing to discourage this impression.]]

to:

* TokenMinority: Sagramor. In the original stories he was a Hungarian prince, but this more historically-accurate setting being a few centuries too early for them, Cornwell has him a Nubian (making him a CompositeCharacter with ''African'' "African" or ''Saracen'' "Saracen" knights like Palamedes and Segwarides) who made his way to Gaul serving in the Roman army and wound up in Arthur's service. The Saxons (and Argante's druid) think he's a demon and [[ScaryBlackMan he does nothing to discourage this impression.]]


Added DiffLines:

* UnrelatedInTheAdaptation:
** There is both a Culhwch and an Olwen in the narrative, but they never meet or interact in any way, let alone become love interests.
** Cadoc doesn't appear to be related to Gundleus in any way, beyond Derfel suspecting he might have once been a spearman in the Silurian warband - certainly, no indication is given that he is Gundleus's son.
** Hywel is Derfel's initial mentor, not his father, and isn't related to Budic in any manner.
** There is no indication that Bors is related to Lancelot.
** In the Welsh Genealogies Cadwy is the son of Geraint, while here they belong to the same generation and are only connected by both being Dumnonian.


Added DiffLines:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: In the council at Glevum early in ''The Winter King'', a lot of hay is made about protecting King Meriadoc of Stronggore. Meriadoc is namedropped a couple more times before he and Stronggore are completely forgotten about.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A TV series adaptation of the first book, also called ''The Winter King'', was announced in 2020 for Creator/MGMPlus, just before the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic hit. The production eventually moved to Creator/{{ITV}}, filming having begun in 2022. The series eventually premiered on MGMPlus in August 2023 in the US only. A UK release is due to follow on ITVX later in the year. No reason has so far been given for the delay to the British release of a British production.

to:

A TV series adaptation of the first book, also called ''The Winter King'', was announced in 2020 for Creator/MGMPlus, just before the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic hit. The production eventually moved to Creator/{{ITV}}, filming having begun in 2022. The series eventually premiered on MGMPlus MGM+ in August 2023 in the US only. A UK release is due to follow on ITVX later in the year. No reason has so far been given for the delay to the British release of a British production.
year.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A TV series adaptation of the first book, also called ''The Winter King'', was announced in 2020 for Creator/MGMPlus, just before the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic hit. The production eventually moved to Creator/{{ITV}}, filming having begun in 2022.

to:

A TV series adaptation of the first book, also called ''The Winter King'', was announced in 2020 for Creator/MGMPlus, just before the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic hit. The production eventually moved to Creator/{{ITV}}, filming having begun in 2022.
2022. The series eventually premiered on MGMPlus in August 2023 in the US only. A UK release is due to follow on ITVX later in the year. No reason has so far been given for the delay to the British release of a British production.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant, and, ironically, Lancelot.

to:

** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[Percivale, [[spoiler:Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant, and, ironically, Lancelot.

Added: 1336

Changed: 882

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In general, the books are less a ''historically accurate'' version of Arthur and more a [[Deconstruction]] of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great battle (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King''), Lancelot shows up, there is a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are in the final book, and none of Arthur's eleven other traditional battles are given so much of a nod.

to:

** In general, the books are less a ''historically accurate'' version of Arthur and more a [[Deconstruction]] {{Deconstruction}} of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great battle (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King''), Lancelot shows up, there is a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are in the final book, and none of Arthur's eleven other traditional battles are given so much of a nod.



* CompositeCharacter: Galahad being Lancelot's illegetimate half-brother, makes him one for Ector Demaris

to:

* CompositeCharacter: CompositeCharacter:
**
Galahad being Lancelot's illegetimate illegitimate half-brother, makes him one for Ector Demarisde Maris and, oddly enough, Lancelot himself (Lancelot's baptismal name in the Vulgate was "Galahad, son of Ban").
** Lancelot is one with [[spoiler:Geoffrey of Monmouth's depiction of Mordred, Arthur's regent who seduces Guinevere and allies with the Saxons.]]
** Derfel ultimately becomes one with both [[Percivale, the good friend of Galahad and hero of a mystic quest, and Bedivere, the one-armed final survivor of Camlann who returns Excalibur to the water.]] He also has elements of Kay, being Arthur's close confidant, and, ironically, Lancelot.
** Culhwch takes on a lot of the traits traditionally given to Gawaine, being a BoisterousBruiser who is friendly with everyone (except Lancelot).



* DemotedToExtra: Ironically, the figures from the Welsh stories get this in favor of later Romance figures. Gawain, Kay, and Bedivere barely appear [[spoiler:and are killed off quickly]]. Rather unusual for [[{{Demythification}} "historical"]] Arthurian retellings, since in the earliest version of the legends the last two formed a team of three with Arthur, while Gawain was Arthur's best warrior before Lancelot was introduced. Derfel and Culhwch (who are, admittedly, also from the Welsh tales) take on their usual roles somewhat, and at the end Derfel is the [[SoleSurvivor only surviving]] warrior of Arthur [[spoiler: who throws Excalibur into the sea after the last battle]].

to:

* DemotedToExtra: Ironically, the figures from the Welsh stories get this in favor of later Romance figures. Gawain, Kay, and Bedivere barely appear [[spoiler:and are killed off quickly]]. Rather unusual for [[{{Demythification}} "historical"]] Arthurian retellings, since in the earliest version of the legends the last two formed a team of three with Arthur, while Gawain was Arthur's best warrior before Lancelot was introduced. Derfel and Culhwch (who are, admittedly, also from the Welsh tales) and Sagramor (who is an invention of the Romances) take on their usual roles somewhat, and at the end Derfel is the [[SoleSurvivor only surviving]] warrior of Arthur [[spoiler: who throws Excalibur into the sea after the last battle]].



* EvenBadMenLoveTheirMamas: Mordred never knew his mother, but he's still irritated that no one ever thought to give her a more distinguished resting place than a grassy mound.

to:

* EvenBadMenLoveTheirMamas: Mordred never knew his mother, but he's still irritated that no one ever thought to give her a more distinguished resting place than a grassy mound. mound, and later demands that Arthur and Derfel bring to justice Ligessac, whose actions resulted in her death. [[spoiler: As a result, Arthur and Derfel don't question if Mordred had ulterior motives in getting them out of Dumnonia, or if Lancelot and Sansum had been manipulating this part of him.]]



** Somewhat subverted in the cases of Sansum and Morgan. It's made very clear that Sansum is primarily driven by his own greedy ambition [[spoiler: and Morgan reluctantly uses her pagan magic to remove Nimue's curse on Ceinwynn.]]

to:

** Somewhat subverted in the cases of Sansum and Morgan. It's made very clear that Sansum is primarily driven by his own greedy ambition [[spoiler: and Morgan reluctantly uses her pagan magic to remove Nimue's curse on Ceinwynn.Ceinwyn.]]



* GoodShepherd: Bishop Emrys.

to:

* GoodShepherd: Bishop Emrys. Bishop Bedwin is implied to have been this before him, but he doesn't live long enough in the story for it to really come across.



* HeroOfAnotherStory: [[spoiler: Peredur, Lancelot's son,]] is mentioned by Derfel to have become a figure of legend in his own right by the "present."



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Derfel is based on an obscure British saint of the same name who, if tradition is to be believed, really was a warrior before becoming a monk.
** Tewdric, Meurig, Aelle, Cerdic, Clovis and possibly Cuneglas (there is a historical king named Cuneglas, but he was from Rhos, not Powys, and his father was Owain Ddantgwyn and not Gorfyddyd, who is fictional).
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Lancelot isn't historical, but he's unusually portrayed as a complete bastard and DirtyCoward.

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Derfel is based on an obscure British saint of the same name who, if tradition is to be believed, really was a warrior before becoming a monk.monk (and in Welsh tradition was a survivor of Camlann).
** Tewdric, Meurig, Aelle, Cerdic, Clovis and possibly Cuneglas (there is a historical king named Cuneglas, but he was from Rhos, not Powys, and his father was Owain Ddantgwyn and not Gorfyddyd, who is fictional).
fictional) are all figures from either historical records or Welsh tradition, although Tewdric and Meurig's timeframe has been difficult to pin down.
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
**
Lancelot isn't historical, but he's unusually portrayed as a complete bastard and DirtyCoward.DirtyCoward.
** Sansum is loosely - very loosely - based on Saint Samson of Dol, who is traditionally portrayed as a monastic reformer and one of the Seven Founding Saints of Brittany. Here he is TheFundamentalist, a {{Hypocrite}}, implied to be a pederast, and generally the most antagonistic figure in the entire narrative.



** While ostensibly a Christian, Mordred makes use of Druids when it suits him.

to:

** While ostensibly a Christian, Mordred makes use of Druids when it suits him.him (and he ultimately apostates).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Saxons are depicted as little more than berserkers who use HumanWave tactics and [[AttackAnimal war dogs]]. This is a case of DatedHistory, as scholarly opinion and archaeological evidence now shows the Saxons used shieldwall tactics similar to what the Britons are depicted using in the books, complete with cavalry support - and there is no evidence of war dogs having ever been a thing.
** In general, the books are less a ''historically accurate'' version of Arthur and more a Deconstruction of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great battle (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King''), Lancelot shows up, there is a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are in the final book, and none of Arthur's eleven other traditional battles are given so much of a nod.

to:

** The Saxons are depicted as little more than berserkers who use HumanWave tactics [[ZergRush human wave tactics]] and [[AttackAnimal war dogs]]. This is a case of DatedHistory, as scholarly opinion and archaeological evidence now shows the Saxons used shieldwall tactics similar to what the Britons are depicted using in the books, complete with cavalry support - and there is no evidence of war dogs having ever been a thing.
** In general, the books are less a ''historically accurate'' version of Arthur and more a Deconstruction [[Deconstruction]] of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great battle (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King''), Lancelot shows up, there is a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are in the final book, and none of Arthur's eleven other traditional battles are given so much of a nod.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Despite being a "historical" spin on the Arthurian mythos, this is still in effect. Actually, writing "Arthur as a real historical figure" falls into this by default since so little is definitively known and so much is conjecture about the topic.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Despite being billing itself as a "historical" spin on the Arthurian mythos, this is still in effect. Actually, writing "Arthur as a real historical figure" falls into this by default since so little is definitively known and so effect, thanks in part to how much is conjecture about there is on the topic.subject:



** The series doesn't mention Ambrosius Aurelianus and Vortigern, the immediate predecessors to Uther and Arthur as British kings/rulers according to Arthurian lore - and generally accepted to be real persons by historians, unlike them. Likewise, no mention is made of Saint Germanus, whose visits to Britain would have been in living memory for the older characters, and Pelagius and his followers are only given a off-hand mention in ''Excalibur'', despite the Pelagian-Chalcedonian rivalry being given great importance by contemporary writers (Paganism, by contrast, is barely mentioned by those same writers).

to:

** The series doesn't mention Ambrosius Aurelianus and Vortigern, the immediate predecessors to Uther and Arthur as British kings/rulers according to Arthurian lore - and generally accepted to be real persons by historians, unlike them.Cunedda, the founder of Gwynedd, is named as Uther's predecessor in books. Likewise, no mention is made of Saint Germanus, whose visits to Britain would have been in living memory for the older characters, and Pelagius and his followers are only given a off-hand mention in ''Excalibur'', despite the Pelagian-Chalcedonian rivalry being given great importance by contemporary writers (Paganism, by contrast, is barely mentioned by those same writers).



** In the series, the heir of the British High King is called the Edling. But this is a later Welsh loanword from the Old English ''[=Æ=]þeling'' (Aetheling) and wouldn't have been used yet.

to:

** In the series, the heir of the British High King kings is called the Edling. But this is a later Welsh loanword from the Old English ''[=Æ=]þeling'' (Aetheling) and wouldn't have been used yet.



** Ynys Trebes is a fictional depiction of Mont Saint-Michel, serving as the capital for King Ban (a character invented by the Romances) before it falls to the Franks.
** The climatic battle of Lugg Vale in ''The Winter King'' is fictional.
** The battles of Mynydd Baddon and Camlann are shrouded in mystery. Mynydd Baddon (also known as Badon Hill or Mount Badon) is generally considered to have been a real battle, in either the late fifth or early sixth century, that temporarily checked the Anglo-Saxon expansion. However, its exact date and location have never been proven. The battle of Camlann, on the other hand, is believed to be only a legend, as the earliest known reference to it is from the tenth century.

to:

** Ynys Trebes is a Arthur and later Derfel's conflicts with the Franks centers around the fictional depiction kingdom of Mont Saint-Michel, serving as the capital for Ynys Trebes, ruled by King Ban (a character invented by and involves Derfel meeting Ban's sons Lancelot and Galahad - Trebes, Ban, Lancelot, and Galahad are all inventions of the Romances) before it falls to Romances, and no mention is made whatsoever of Syagrius, the Franks.
Roman ruler of Gaul who Clovis ''actually'' fought during this time.
** The climatic Saxons are depicted as little more than berserkers who use HumanWave tactics and [[AttackAnimal war dogs]]. This is a case of DatedHistory, as scholarly opinion and archaeological evidence now shows the Saxons used shieldwall tactics similar to what the Britons are depicted using in the books, complete with cavalry support - and there is no evidence of war dogs having ever been a thing.
** In general, the books are less a ''historically accurate'' version of Arthur and more a Deconstruction of the Romances using the Dark Ages as a backdrop. Arthur is still mentored by Merlin, receives Excalibur from a mystical figure in the presence of a stone, and defeats antagonistic British kings at a great
battle of (Bedegraine in the Romances, Lugg Vale in the ''The Winter King'' King''), Lancelot shows up, there is fictional.
**
a quest for a sacred container involving Galahad, a round table is set up at Camelot, and Guinevere commits adultery with Lancelot - all of which were elements invented in the Romances and not present even in Geoffrey of Monmouth's version of events. The battles of Mynydd Baddon big exceptions are Badon (which most historians agree happened, even if they disagree if Arthur was involved) and Camlann (which has traditions dating back to the 11th Century in writing), but both are shrouded in mystery. Mynydd Baddon (also known as Badon Hill or Mount Badon) is generally considered to have been a real battle, in either the late fifth or early sixth century, that temporarily checked the Anglo-Saxon expansion. However, its exact date final book, and location have never been proven. The battle none of Camlann, on the Arthur's eleven other hand, is believed to be only traditional battles are given so much of a legend, as the earliest known reference to it is from the tenth century.nod.



* DemotedToExtra: Gawain, Kay, and Bedivere barely appear [[spoiler:and are killed off quickly]]. Rather unusual for [[{{Demythification}} "historical"]] Arthurian retellings, since in the earliest version of the legends the last two formed a team of three with Arthur, while Gawain was Arthur's best warrior before Lancelot was introduced. Derfel takes on their usual roles somewhat, and at the end he is the [[SoleSurvivor only surviving]] warrior of Arthur [[spoiler: who throws Excalibur into the sea after the last battle]].

to:

* DemotedToExtra: Ironically, the figures from the Welsh stories get this in favor of later Romance figures. Gawain, Kay, and Bedivere barely appear [[spoiler:and are killed off quickly]]. Rather unusual for [[{{Demythification}} "historical"]] Arthurian retellings, since in the earliest version of the legends the last two formed a team of three with Arthur, while Gawain was Arthur's best warrior before Lancelot was introduced. Derfel takes and Culhwch (who are, admittedly, also from the Welsh tales) take on their usual roles somewhat, and at the end he Derfel is the [[SoleSurvivor only surviving]] warrior of Arthur [[spoiler: who throws Excalibur into the sea after the last battle]].

Top