Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheNightingale

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
He fell ill five years later.


* ArtisticLicenseOrnithology: As with most songbirds, only male nightingales sing. Some translations, such as Erik Haugaard's 1974 version, make the nightingale in the story male.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseOrnithology: As with most songbirds, only male nightingales sing. Some translations, such as Erik Haugaard's 1974 version, make the nightingale in the story male. Also, the nightingale is already an adult by the time the Emperor hears of it, spends time in the palace, then the mechanical bird lasts for a year, and then five years pass before the Emperor falls ill. It's uncommon for nightingales to live more than five years, and unheard of for them to live more than eight.



* NewTechnologyIsEvil: The mechanical nightingale makes the Emperor dependent on it, but when it breaks he immediately falls ill because he misses its sound so much. However, in the end when the Emperor says that he'll break the machine into pieces, the real nightingale tells him not to do so, because "the bird did very well as long as it could".

to:

* NewTechnologyIsEvil: The mechanical nightingale makes the Emperor dependent on it, but when it breaks he immediately falls ill because he misses its sound so much.and causes him to forget the real bird. However, in the end when the Emperor says that he'll break the machine into pieces, the real nightingale tells him not to do so, because "the bird did very well as long as it could".

Added: 393

Changed: 430

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!! This fairy tale provides examples of

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: At least one Chinese translation of the story remarks in a footnote that the story is based on what Danish people ''thought'' Imperial China was like, rather than what Imperial China was actually like, and as such most descriptions of life in China are pure conjecture. Furthermore, nightingales are not native to China, and so they almost certainly would not have nested near the Emperor's palace.

to:

!! This fairy tale provides examples of

of:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: At least one Chinese translation of the story remarks in a footnote that the story is based on what Danish people ''thought'' Imperial China was like, rather than what Imperial China was actually like, and as such most descriptions of life in China are pure conjecture.conjecture (the Imperial Palace was not built out of porcelain, for starters). Furthermore, nightingales are not native to China, and so they almost certainly would not have nested near the Emperor's palace.



* ClockPunk: The mechanical nightingale
* ComeBackMyPet: At his death bed the Emperor wishes the real nightingale would return.

to:

* ClockPunk: The mechanical nightingale
nightingale.
* ComeBackMyPet: At his death bed the Emperor wishes the real nightingale would return. [[LoyalAnimalCompanion She does.]]



* GratuitousForeignLanguage: When the Emperor demands to see the Nightingale, the courtier responds with "Tsing-pe!" This is likely intended as a rendition of the Chinese 钦佩, which means "admiration" or "esteem" and does not make sense as a response to anything in conversation, much less a command from an Emperor.

to:

* TheGhost: The Emperor of Japan is mentioned a few times throughout the narrative, but never appears in person.
* GratuitousForeignLanguage: When the Emperor demands to see the Nightingale, the courtier chamberlain responds with "Tsing-pe!" This is likely intended as a rendition of the Chinese 钦佩, which means "admiration" or "esteem" and does not make sense as a response to anything in conversation, much less a command from an Emperor.Emperor, and was most likely thrown in by Andersen just because it sounded Chinese.



* ReportsOfMyDeathWereGreatlyExaggerated: The royal entourage arrives at the Emperor's bedroom assuming he must have died by now, only to have him greet everybody with the words: "Good morning!."

to:

* ReportsOfMyDeathWereGreatlyExaggerated: The royal entourage arrives at the Emperor's bedroom assuming he must have died by now, only to have him greet everybody with the words: "Good morning!." morning!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GratuitousForeignLanguage: When the Emperor demands to see the Nightingale, the courtier responds with "Tsing-pe!" This is likely intended as a rendition of the Chinese 钦佩, which means "admiration" or "esteem" and does not make sense as a response to anything in conversation, much less a command from an Emperor.


Added DiffLines:

* WowingCthulhu: Even ''Death himself'' can't resist the beauty of the nightingale's song and ends up sparing the Emperor's life in exchange for one, which essentially causes him to get homesick and leave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DyingAlone: Everyone abandons the Emperor when his death seems inevitable... everyone but the nightingale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/nightingale_02.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
the mechanical nightingale was a gift from the Emperor of Japan


In ImperialChina, the Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale, one of which happens to live in his very own gardens. Though put off at first by the bird's plain appearance, he is so delighted with her song that he brings her into his palace as a permanent "guest". By and by, however, his engineers produce a bejeweled mechanical bird, which quickly captures the attention of the Emperor and his court. As they play the mechanical bird nearly to the point of breakdown, the real nightingale returns to the gardens.

to:

In ImperialChina, the Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale, one of which happens to live in his very own gardens. Though put off at first by the bird's plain appearance, he is so delighted with her song that he brings her into his palace as a permanent "guest". By and by, however, his engineers produce he receives a bejeweled mechanical bird, bird as a gift, which quickly captures the attention of the Emperor and his court. As they play the mechanical bird nearly to the point of breakdown, the real nightingale returns to the gardens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseOrnithology: As with most songbirds, only male nightingales sing.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseOrnithology: As with most songbirds, only male nightingales sing. Some translations, such as Erik Haugaard's 1974 version, make the nightingale in the story male.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*TearsOfJoy: The first time the Emperor hears the nightingale's BeautifulSingingVoice, he's left with tears rolling down his cheeks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In ImperialChina, the Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale, one of which happens to live in his very own gardens. Though put off at first by the bird's plain appearance, he is so delighted with her song that he brings her into his palace as a permanent "guest." By and by, however, his engineers produce a bejeweled mechanical bird, which quickly captures the attention of the Emperor and his court. As they play the mechanical bird nearly to the point of breakdown, the real nightingale returns to the gardens.

Then the Emperor falls ill, to the point where his successor has been chosen and TheGrimReaper is sitting at his bedside. In despair he cries that if he could only turn the key of the mechanical bird and hear its song one more time, he would have the strength to fight back. At that moment, the real nightingale bursts into song from his window, restoring his strength and shaming Death into departing. From then on, she tells the Emperor, she will not live as his prisoner but will still return frequently to tell him what is happening in his empire, so that he will be known as the wisest emperor ever to live.

to:

In ImperialChina, the Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale, one of which happens to live in his very own gardens. Though put off at first by the bird's plain appearance, he is so delighted with her song that he brings her into his palace as a permanent "guest." "guest". By and by, however, his engineers produce a bejeweled mechanical bird, which quickly captures the attention of the Emperor and his court. As they play the mechanical bird nearly to the point of breakdown, the real nightingale returns to the gardens.

Then the Emperor falls ill, to the point where his successor has been chosen and TheGrimReaper is sitting at his bedside. In despair despair, he cries that if he could only turn the key of the mechanical bird and hear its song one more time, he would have the strength to fight back. At that moment, the real nightingale bursts into song from his window, restoring his strength and shaming Death into departing. From then on, she tells the Emperor, she will not live as his prisoner but will still return frequently to tell him what is happening in his empire, so that he will be known as the wisest emperor ever to live.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MisplacedWildlife: Nightingales are not native to China.

Added: 82

Changed: 78

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseBiology: As with most songbirds, only male nightingales sing.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: As with most songbirds, only male nightingales sing.


Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseOrnithology: As with most songbirds, only male nightingales sing.

Added: 643

Changed: 87

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: At least one Chinese translation of the story remarks in a footnote that the story is based on what Danish people ''thought'' Imperial China was like, rather than what Imperial China was actually like, and as such most descriptions of life in China are pure conjecture. Furthermore, nightingales are not native to China, and so they almost certainly would not have nested near the Emperor's palace.



* BigDamnHeroes: The nightingale returns just in time to save the Emperor from the Grim Reaper.



* GameBreakingInjury: The mechanical nightingale eventually suffers an internal breakdown that cripples its ability to sing.



* PleaseSpareHimMyLiege: The nightingale persuades the Grim Reaper to spare the Emperor's life.

to:

* PleaseSpareHimMyLiege: The nightingale persuades the Grim Reaper to spare the Emperor's life. She also does this for the mechanical bird when the Emperor wishes to have it smashed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReportsOfMyDeathWereGreatlyExaggerated: The royal entourage arrives at the Emperor's bedroom assuming he must have died by now, only to have him greet everybody with the words: "Good morning everybody."

to:

* ReportsOfMyDeathWereGreatlyExaggerated: The royal entourage arrives at the Emperor's bedroom assuming he must have died by now, only to have him greet everybody with the words: "Good morning everybody.morning!."

Added: 205

Removed: 182

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackFromTheDead: The royal entourage arrives at the Emperor's bedroom assuming he must have died by now, only to have him greet everybody with the words: "Good morning everybody."


Added DiffLines:

* ReportsOfMyDeathWereGreatlyExaggerated: The royal entourage arrives at the Emperor's bedroom assuming he must have died by now, only to have him greet everybody with the words: "Good morning everybody."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UpperClassTwit: The imperial court is full of them. The chamberlain is so above people that he never bothers to speak a word to common folk, but when it comes to finding the nightingale, none of them can distinguish a bird from a cow, or a frog. The fishermen, on the other hand...

to:

* UpperClassTwit: The imperial court is full of them. The chamberlain is so above people that he never bothers to speak a word to common folk, but when it comes to finding the nightingale, none of them can distinguish a bird from a cow, or a frog. The fishermen, on the other hand...hand...
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsianAnd Nerdy: The mechanical robot nightingale is gift of the ''Japanese'' Emperor.

to:

* AsianAnd Nerdy: AsianAndNerdy: The mechanical robot nightingale is gift of the ''Japanese'' Emperor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AsianAnd Nerdy: The mechanical robot nightingale is gift of the ''Japanese'' Emperor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[SimilarlyNamedWorks Not to be confused]] with the 2015 historical fiction novel by Kristin Hannah.

to:

[[SimilarlyNamedWorks Not to be confused]] with the [[Literature/TheNightingaleKristinHannah 2015 historical fiction novel by Kristin Hannah.Hannah]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[SimilarlyNamedWorks Not to be confused]] with the 2015 historical fiction novel about French sisters during World War II by Kristin Hannah.

to:

[[SimilarlyNamedWorks Not to be confused]] with the 2015 historical fiction novel about French sisters during World War II by Kristin Hannah.

Added: 141

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added distinction from Kristin Hannah novel



[[SimilarlyNamedWorks Not to be confused]] with the 2015 historical fiction novel about French sisters during World War II by Kristin Hannah.



* UpperClassTwit: The imperial court is full of them. The chamberlain is so above people that he never bothers to speak a word to common folk, but when it comes to finding the nightingale, none of them can distinguish a bird from a cow, or a frog. The fishermen, on the other hand...

to:

* UpperClassTwit: The imperial court is full of them. The chamberlain is so above people that he never bothers to speak a word to common folk, but when it comes to finding the nightingale, none of them can distinguish a bird from a cow, or a frog. The fishermen, on the other hand...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NamelessNarrative: Nobody in the story has a name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: As with most songbirds, only male nightingales sing.


Added DiffLines:

* AFriendInNeed: The nightingale.


Added DiffLines:

* TrueBeautyIsOnTheInside: The real nightingale's beauty is all in her song. When the mechanical bird appears with a much nicer appearance and a pretty song, the real bird is gradually forgotten -- but she is the one with the purity of heart and song to return to the emperor when he is in need.

Added: 194

Changed: 283

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComeBackMyPet: At his death bed the Emperor wishes the real nightingale would return.
* DudeWheresMyRespect: After singing for the Emperor for so long the monarch just forgets the real nightingale for a fake one.

to:

* ComeBackMyPet: At his death bed the Emperor wishes the real nightingale would return.
return.
* CreativeSterility: The mechanical bird knows only one song. Over time, the Emperor and his court prefer it because it's a recognizable tune they can whistle, not the organic and free-form songs of the real bird.
* DudeWheresMyRespect: After singing for the The Emperor for so long the monarch just forgets completely ignores the real nightingale for a fake one. when the mechanical bird appears, despite long months of faithful service. He doesn't even notice when she flies away.



* LoyalAnimalCompanion: The nightingale remains loyal to the Emperor.

to:

* LoyalAnimalCompanion: The nightingale remains loyal was the last member of the imperial court to remember the Emperor.

Added: 614

Changed: 867

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The story takes place in ImperialChina. The Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale. He is so delighted with the bird's song that he keeps the nightingale in captivity. When the Emperor is given a bejeweled mechanical bird he loses interest in the real nightingale, who returns to the forest. The mechanical bird eventually breaks down due to overuse. The Emperor then falls ill and TheGrimReaper is even sitting on his chest, waiting until he dies. The real nightingale learns of the Emperor's condition and returns to the palace. The Grim Reaper is so moved by the nightingale's song that he departs and the emperor recovers. The nightingale agrees to sing to the emperor of all the happenings in the empire, that he will be known as the wisest emperor ever to live.

to:

The story takes place in ImperialChina. The In ImperialChina, the Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale. He nightingale, one of which happens to live in his very own gardens. Though put off at first by the bird's plain appearance, he is so delighted with the bird's her song that he keeps the nightingale in captivity. When the Emperor is given brings her into his palace as a permanent "guest." By and by, however, his engineers produce a bejeweled mechanical bird he loses interest in bird, which quickly captures the real nightingale, who returns to attention of the forest. The Emperor and his court. As they play the mechanical bird eventually breaks down due nearly to overuse. The the point of breakdown, the real nightingale returns to the gardens.

Then the
Emperor then falls ill ill, to the point where his successor has been chosen and TheGrimReaper is even sitting on at his chest, waiting until bedside. In despair he dies. The cries that if he could only turn the key of the mechanical bird and hear its song one more time, he would have the strength to fight back. At that moment, the real nightingale learns of the Emperor's condition and returns to the palace. The Grim Reaper is so moved by the nightingale's bursts into song that he departs from his window, restoring his strength and shaming Death into departing. From then on, she tells the emperor recovers. The nightingale agrees Emperor, she will not live as his prisoner but will still return frequently to sing to the emperor of all the happenings tell him what is happening in the his empire, so that he will be known as the wisest emperor ever to live.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The story takes place in ImperialChina. The Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale. He Emperor is so delighted with the bird's song that he keeps the nightingale in captivity. When the Emperor is given a bejeweled mechanical bird he loses interest in the real nightingale, who returns to the forest. The mechanical bird eventually breaks down due to overuse. The Emperor then falls ill and TheGrimReaper is even sitting on his chest, waiting until he dies. The real nightingale learns of the Emperor's condition and returns to the palace. The Grim Reaper is so moved by the nightingale's song that he departs and the emperor recovers. The nightingale agrees to sing to the emperor of all the happenings in the empire, that he will be known as the wisest emperor ever to live.

to:

The story takes place in ImperialChina. The Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale. He Emperor is so delighted with the bird's song that he keeps the nightingale in captivity. When the Emperor is given a bejeweled mechanical bird he loses interest in the real nightingale, who returns to the forest. The mechanical bird eventually breaks down due to overuse. The Emperor then falls ill and TheGrimReaper is even sitting on his chest, waiting until he dies. The real nightingale learns of the Emperor's condition and returns to the palace. The Grim Reaper is so moved by the nightingale's song that he departs and the emperor recovers. The nightingale agrees to sing to the emperor of all the happenings in the empire, that he will be known as the wisest emperor ever to live.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


"The Nightingale", also known as "The Chinese Nightingale" and "The Emperor and the Nightingale" is a famous 19th century fairy tale written by Creator/HansChristianAndersen.

to:

"The Nightingale", also known as "The Chinese Nightingale" and "The Emperor and the Nightingale" is a famous 19th century fairy tale written by Creator/HansChristianAndersen. \n It was first published in 1843.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NewTechnologyIsEvil: The mechanical nightingale makes the Emperor dependent on it, but when it breaks he immediately falls ill because he misses its sound so much.

to:

* NewTechnologyIsEvil: The mechanical nightingale makes the Emperor dependent on it, but when it breaks he immediately falls ill because he misses its sound so much. However, in the end when the Emperor says that he'll break the machine into pieces, the real nightingale tells him not to do so, because "the bird did very well as long as it could".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UpperClassTwit: The imperial court is full of them. The chamberlain is so above people that he never bothers to speak a word to common folk, but when it comes to finding the nightingale, none of them can distinguish a bird from a cow, or a frog. The fishermen, on the other hand...

Changed: 2

Removed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Bowlderise}}: Some child oriented versions just let the Emperor be very ill and [[NeverSayDie omit the entire scene with the Grim Reaper]].

to:

* {{Bowlderise}}: {{Bowdlerise}}: Some child oriented versions just let the Emperor be very ill and [[NeverSayDie omit the entire scene with the Grim Reaper]].



* MiraculousRecovery: As soon as the Emperor hears the nightingale sing he recovers from his illness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

"The Nightingale", also known as "The Chinese Nightingale" and "The Emperor and the Nightingale" is a famous 19th century fairy tale written by Creator/HansChristianAndersen.

The story takes place in ImperialChina. The Emperor learns that one of the most beautiful sounds on Earth is the song of the nightingale. He Emperor is so delighted with the bird's song that he keeps the nightingale in captivity. When the Emperor is given a bejeweled mechanical bird he loses interest in the real nightingale, who returns to the forest. The mechanical bird eventually breaks down due to overuse. The Emperor then falls ill and TheGrimReaper is even sitting on his chest, waiting until he dies. The real nightingale learns of the Emperor's condition and returns to the palace. The Grim Reaper is so moved by the nightingale's song that he departs and the emperor recovers. The nightingale agrees to sing to the emperor of all the happenings in the empire, that he will be known as the wisest emperor ever to live.
----
!! This fairy tale provides examples of
* AttentionDeficitOohShiny: Sort of. When the Emperor sees the bejeweled mechanical bird he prefers it over the grey real nightingale and forgets the latter completely.
* BackFromTheDead: The royal entourage arrives at the Emperor's bedroom assuming he must have died by now, only to have him greet everybody with the words: "Good morning everybody."
* {{Bowlderise}}: Some child oriented versions just let the Emperor be very ill and [[NeverSayDie omit the entire scene with the Grim Reaper]].
* ClockPunk: The mechanical nightingale
* ComeBackMyPet: At his death bed the Emperor wishes the real nightingale would return.
* DudeWheresMyRespect: After singing for the Emperor for so long the monarch just forgets the real nightingale for a fake one.
* TheGrimReaper: Appears when the Emperor is about to die.
* ImperialChina: The story takes place in this time period.
* LoyalAnimalCompanion: The nightingale remains loyal to the Emperor.
* MiraculousRecovery: As soon as the Emperor hears the nightingale sing he recovers from his illness.
* NewTechnologyIsEvil: The mechanical nightingale makes the Emperor dependent on it, but when it breaks he immediately falls ill because he misses its sound so much.
* NightmareFace: Andersen describes how the Emperor looks straight into the hollow eyes of Death.
* PleaseSpareHimMyLiege: The nightingale persuades the Grim Reaper to spare the Emperor's life.
* SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute: The mechanical nightingale who can sing just as beautifully as the real nightingale and looks prettier due to the jewelry on its body.
* TalkingAnimal: The nightingale agrees to go to the Emperor's Palace and argues with the Grim Reaper over keeping the Emperor alive.

Top