Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheLabyrinthOfSpirits

Go To

OR

Added: 738

Changed: 356

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MorallyBankruptBanker: Miguel Ángel Ubach, Enrique Sarmiento, and Ignacio Sanchís. Subverted by [[spoiler: Sanchís' HeelFaceTurn]].
* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: Sergio Vilajuana is obviously a fictional version of Sergio Vila-Sanjuán, a real life journalist and writer whom Zafón was a friend of.
* NoNameGiven: Subverted. Daniel's father had gone unnamed for all the three previous books, but here he's revealed to be named Juan.

to:

* MorallyBankruptBanker: Multiple cases, the main being Miguel Ángel Ubach, Enrique Sarmiento, and Ignacio Sanchís. Subverted by [[spoiler: Sanchís' HeelFaceTurn]].
* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: NoCelebritiesWereHarmed:
**
Sergio Vilajuana is obviously a fictional version of Sergio Vila-Sanjuán, a real life journalist and writer whom Zafón was a friend of.
** Juan Manuel Vargas is trickier because he doesn't resemble much the real person, but his name and role in the story sound too much like a reference to José Manuel Villarejo, a former Francoist police detective turned private eye whose famous trial for political troubleshooting was still ongoing when the novel was released.
* NoNameGiven: NoHistoricalFiguresWereHarmed: As seen in their very names, Miguel Ángel Ubach is roughly in place of Juan March, a wealthy banker that funded the National side during the Civil War in real life (although March eventually stopped supporting Franco, something Ubach doesn't).
* NoNameGiven:
**
Subverted. Daniel's father had gone unnamed for all the three previous books, but here he's revealed to be named Juan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheScrappy: Daniel. Many readers disliked his portrayal as an ineffectual amateur detective and aspiring writer in Shadow of the Wind, and his portrayal in The Prisoner of Heaven only doubled down on his worst traits while making him even more of a non-entity in his own story. Now, he's a weird, creepy, possessive [[spoiler: almost rapist]] who's even less proactive in saving his own family. Zafon seems to be openly welcoming readers to hate him at this point after trying to make him the hero of two previous novels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChivalrousPervert: Fermin. Though he's faithful to his wife and loyal to the Sempere family, about 1/3 of everything he says involves women he finds attractive and movie stars he would sleep with given the chance. It's such an issue that Daniel warns him not to discuss movies with his son because he knows what direction the conversation will go.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*TheScrappy: Daniel. Many readers disliked his portrayal as an ineffectual amateur detective and aspiring writer in Shadow of the Wind, and his portrayal in The Prisoner of Heaven only doubled down on his worst traits while making him even more of a non-entity in his own story. Now, he's a weird, creepy, possessive [[spoiler: almost rapist]] who's even less proactive in saving his own family. Zafon seems to be openly welcoming readers to hate him at this point after trying to make him the hero of two previous novels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllGaysArePedophiles: Excluding the AmbiguouslyBi Alicia, who doesn't make it much better given that she was predatory fantasies, Virgilio is the only character openly stated to be gay, and a couple of his lines imply he is also an ephebophile.

to:

* AllGaysArePedophiles: Excluding the AmbiguouslyBi Alicia, who doesn't make it much better given that she was has predatory fantasies, fantasies for Bea, Virgilio is the only character openly stated to be gay, and a couple of his lines imply he is also an ephebophile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllGaysArePedophiles: Excluding the AmbiguouslyBi Alicia, who doesn't make it much better given that she was predatory fantasies, Virgilio is the only character openly stated to be gay, and a couple of his lines imply he is also an ephebophile.


Added DiffLines:

* PsychoLesbian: Probably [[DepravedBisexual bi]] rather than lesbian, but still. Alicia, whom we know to be at least a bit messed up, fantasizes with forcing herself on Bea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObviousVillainSecretVillain: The reader knows from his first appearance that Hendaya is a psycho cop, and it comes as no surprise when SmugSnake [[spoiler: Leandro]] turns out to be corrupt. However, [[spoiler: Rovira]] seems like yet another inept tail like Fernandito, so that it comes as a surprise when he's revealed to be a serial killer called The Observer hired to help [[spoiler: Leandro]] eliminate witnesses.


Added DiffLines:

* PsychoForHire: [[spoiler: Rovira]] is a serial killer who calls himself The Observer with a room full of crazy dedicated to Alicia. He also rents out his services to the Secret Police to eliminate members of their own force they want eliminated without drawing attention to themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: For this book and the entire Cemetery of Forgotten Books series. [[spoiler: Alicia kills everyone involved in the child trafficking plot and sends evidence of it to a prominent Spanish journalist, who exposes the government for its complicity. She gets to go to America and spends the rest of her life traveling the country, but dies in her early sixties of a terminal disease. The Sempere family survives a possible attempt on their lives and Daniel sees justice done to the man who killed his mother, but his all-consuming hatred for Valls has deteriorated his relationship with his family. Even though he and Bea agree to have another child, the marriage remains strained, and rather than grow up to become the successful novelist the character dreamed of being in the previous two books, he instead ages into a bitter, neurotic man obsessed with his dead mother's memory. Julian Sempere finally gets to meet his namesake, Julian Carax, who helps him write his family's story, but Carax himself is a broken shell of a man who's stopped writing again after only publishing one new novel. He now spends most of his time hanging around Nuria Montfort's grave out of guilt for his role in her death, and eventually dies of a heart attack there. In the final scenes, an adult Julian Sempere visits Fermin, whom it's implied is close to death, and the pair ruminate that while the 1992 Barcelona Olympics are a high-water mark for the city, the radical change to its culture as a result of the event means the place they loved no longer exists.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: For this book and the entire Cemetery of Forgotten Books series. [[spoiler: Alicia kills everyone involved in the child trafficking plot and sends evidence of it to a prominent Spanish journalist, who exposes the government for its complicity. She gets to go to America and spends the rest of her life traveling the country, but dies in her early sixties of a terminal disease. Ariadna and Victoria Mataix finally reunite, but their loved ones have all been murdered, and rather than live with the memories of the sexual and psychological abuse they survived, they opt to commit suicide together. The Sempere family survives a possible attempt on their lives and Daniel sees justice done to the man who killed his mother, but his all-consuming hatred for Valls has deteriorated his relationship with his family. Even though he and Bea agree to have another child, the marriage remains strained, and rather than grow up to become the successful novelist the character dreamed of being in the previous two books, he instead ages into a bitter, neurotic man obsessed with his dead mother's memory. Julian Sempere finally gets to meet his namesake, Julian Carax, who helps him write his family's story, but Carax himself is a broken shell of a man who's stopped writing again after only publishing one new novel. He now spends most of his time hanging around Nuria Montfort's grave out of guilt for his role in her death, and eventually dies of a heart attack there. In the final scenes, an adult Julian Sempere visits Fermin, whom it's implied is close to death, and the pair ruminate that while the 1992 Barcelona Olympics are a high-water mark for the city, the radical change to its culture as a result of the event means the place they loved no longer exists.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: Julian Carax is described as having a full beard in old age, despite his entire face and body being covered in third degree burns. Third degree burns destroy the layer of skin that contains hair follicles, so there's no way he could have facial hair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TogetherInDeath: The fate of the [[spoiler: Mataix sisters]], who after finally being reunited agree they don't want to live with the memories of their parents' murders and the subsequent sexual abuse they suffered. Alicia finds them together in bed after peacefully ODing on morphine.

to:

* TogetherInDeath: The fate of the [[spoiler: Mataix sisters]], who after finally being reunited agree they don't want to live with the memories of their parents' murders and the subsequent sexual abuse they suffered. Alicia finds them together in bed after peacefully ODing overdosing on morphine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UnexplainedRecovery: Near the end of the previous book, Daniel comments that his father is dying. At the start of this book he's perfectly fine and [[spoiler: lives for several more years beyond the events of ''Prisoner of Heaven.'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatDoesSheSeeInHim: Fermin invokes this to Daniel regarding Bea. As the book goes on and Daniel becomes more bitter, neurotic, and withdrawn, Fermin points out that he's becoming someone unworthy of her affection. Alicia has similar thoughts while fantasizing about Bea, although she also contemplates life with Daniel herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** David Martin. Early on it's confirmed that he died at some point between The Angel's Game and this book, but his imprisonment and torture are one of several factors motivating the revenge plot against Valls.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PetRat: [[spoiler: Rovira]] to [[spoiler: Leandro]]. The former is directly on the latter's payroll as opposed to being an official agent of the secret police, so that he can commit even more brutal extrajudicial violence than even Franco's already notoriously corrupt agents will allow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** At the outset of the story, Valls' wife has been dying for years of some sort of degenerative illness implied to be multiple sclerosis or possibly early-onset Parkinson's Disease. By the time [[spoiler: Ariadna]] finds her, she's little more than a breathing skeleton. The narration implies that it's a mercy when [[spoiler: Ariadna suffocates her]].

to:

** At the outset of the story, Valls' wife has been dying for years of some sort of degenerative illness implied to be multiple sclerosis or possibly early-onset Parkinson's Disease.Disease, which has left her bedridden and gruesomely deteriorating. By the time [[spoiler: Ariadna]] finds her, she's little more than a breathing skeleton. The narration implies that it's a mercy when [[spoiler: Ariadna suffocates her]].

Added: 354

Changed: 171

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: For this book and the entire Cemetery of Forgotten Books series. [[spoiler: Alicia kills everyone involved in the child trafficking plot and sends evidence of it to a prominent Spanish journalist, who exposes the government for its complicity. She gets to go to America and spends the rest of her life traveling the country, but dies in her early sixties of a terminal disease. The Sempere family survives a possible attempt on their lives and Daniel sees justice done to the man who killed his mother, but his bitterness has deteriorated his relationship with his family. Even though he and Bea agree to have another child, the marriage remains strained, and rather than grow up to become the successful novelist the character dreamed of being in the previous two books, he instead ages into a bitter, neurotic man who still maintains an unhealthy relationship with his dead mother's memory. Julian Sempere finally gets to meet his namesake, Julian Carax, who helps him write his family's story, but Carax himself is a broken man who stopped writing again and now spends most of his time hanging around Nuria Montfort's grave out of guilt for his role in her death. In the final scenes, an adult Julian Sempere visits Fermin, whom it's implied is close to death, and the pair ruminate that while the 1992 Barcelona Olympics are a high-water mark for the city, the radical change to its culture as a result of the event means the place they loved no longer exists.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: For this book and the entire Cemetery of Forgotten Books series. [[spoiler: Alicia kills everyone involved in the child trafficking plot and sends evidence of it to a prominent Spanish journalist, who exposes the government for its complicity. She gets to go to America and spends the rest of her life traveling the country, but dies in her early sixties of a terminal disease. The Sempere family survives a possible attempt on their lives and Daniel sees justice done to the man who killed his mother, but his bitterness all-consuming hatred for Valls has deteriorated his relationship with his family. Even though he and Bea agree to have another child, the marriage remains strained, and rather than grow up to become the successful novelist the character dreamed of being in the previous two books, he instead ages into a bitter, neurotic man who still maintains an unhealthy relationship obsessed with his dead mother's memory. Julian Sempere finally gets to meet his namesake, Julian Carax, who helps him write his family's story, but Carax himself is a broken shell of a man who who's stopped writing again and after only publishing one new novel. He now spends most of his time hanging around Nuria Montfort's grave out of guilt for his role in her death.death, and eventually dies of a heart attack there. In the final scenes, an adult Julian Sempere visits Fermin, whom it's implied is close to death, and the pair ruminate that while the 1992 Barcelona Olympics are a high-water mark for the city, the radical change to its culture as a result of the event means the place they loved no longer exists.]]


Added DiffLines:

** At the outset of the story, Valls' wife has been dying for years of some sort of degenerative illness implied to be multiple sclerosis or possibly early-onset Parkinson's Disease. By the time [[spoiler: Ariadna]] finds her, she's little more than a breathing skeleton. The narration implies that it's a mercy when [[spoiler: Ariadna suffocates her]].

Added: 707

Changed: 360

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousSituation: Why does [[spoiler: Leandro goad Alicia into killing him? Is it because all of his allies are dead and he's afraid of being the one man to go down for the scheme he concocted with Valls? Because Alicia refuses to ally with him to help build a "New Spain"? Because he feels guilty about setting her up to get killed by Rovira? Or some combination of the above?]]

to:

* AmbiguousSituation: A few:
** Was David Martin just a paranoid schizophrenic, or did he really make a deal with a demon named Andreas Corelli? Other characters maintain that Martin was simply mentally ill, but, if that's the case, how did one physically frail man who'd been tortured and malnourished for months overpower and kill Valls' henchmen and escape the country?
**
Why does [[spoiler: Leandro goad Alicia into killing him? Is it because all of his allies are dead and he's afraid of being the one man to go down for the scheme he concocted with Valls? Because Alicia refuses to ally with him to help build a "New Spain"? Because he feels guilty about setting her up to get killed by Rovira? Or some combination of the above?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OutOfFocus: After narrating the opening chapters of the book, Daniel ceases to be a central character in the story and fades into the background for most of the novel. The narrative first switches perspectives to Fermin remembering the bombing raid on Barcelona that he and Alicia survived, and then new character Alicia Gris becomes the focal point of the rest of the book until the final fifty pages, when [[spoiler: Julian Sempere]] abruptly becomes the narrator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllThereInTheManual: Although the preface claims that the Cemetery of Forgotten Books series can be read in any order, this book never explains the significance of Julian Carax, whose backstory is featured prominently in ''The Shadow of the Wind.'' Readers who aren't already familiar with that book will be utterly baffled as to why Daniel named his son after him, why Carax is horribly disfigured, and why he spends all of his time hanging around Nuria Montfort's grave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LetMeGetThisStraight: Near the end of the book, multiple chapters are dedicated to Leandro interrogating [[spoiler: Victoria Ubach/Ariadna Mataix]], which serves the purpose of conclusively outlining the book's numerous convoluted subplots and intersecting conspiracies. Some of the material covered was even explained just a few chapters before, but gets repeated so the reader understands the entire scope of the book's multiple, decades-spanning plot threads.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Invoked by an adult Julian Sempere, who believes that the 1992 Olympics in Barcelona are the last great thing the city will achieve, and that the event will mark the beginning of its decline.

to:

** Invoked by an adult Julian Sempere, who believes that the 1992 Olympics in Barcelona are the last great thing the city will achieve, and achieve. Somewhat of a case of RealLifeWritesThePlot, as the culture of the city did radically change as a result of the rapid urban renewal that occurred to prepare for the event will mark event, and the beginning world depicted in the Cemetery of its decline.Forgotten Books series no longer exists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: For this book and the entire Cemetery of Forgotten Books series. [[spoiler: Alicia kills everyone involved in the child trafficking plot and sends evidence of it to a prominent Spanish journalist, who exposes the government for its complicity. She gets to go to America and spends the rest of her life traveling the country, but dies in her early sixties of a terminal disease. The Sempere family survives a possible attempt on their lives and Daniel sees justice done to the man who killed his mother, but his bitterness has deteriorated his relationship with his family. Even though he and Bea agree to have another child, the marriage remains strained, and rather than grow up to become the successful novelist the character dreamed of being in the previous two books, he instead ages into a bitter, neurotic man who still maintains an unhealthy relationship with his dead mother's memory. Julian Sempere finally gets to meet his namesake, Julian Carax, who helps him write his family's story, but Carax himself is a broken man who stopped writing again and now spends most of his time hanging around Nuria Montfort's grave out of guilt for his role in her death. In the final scenes, an adult Julian Sempere visits Fermin, whom it's implied is close to death, and the pair ruminate that the 1992 Barcelona Olympics are both a high-water mark for the city but that it will probably be the last great thing it achieves.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: For this book and the entire Cemetery of Forgotten Books series. [[spoiler: Alicia kills everyone involved in the child trafficking plot and sends evidence of it to a prominent Spanish journalist, who exposes the government for its complicity. She gets to go to America and spends the rest of her life traveling the country, but dies in her early sixties of a terminal disease. The Sempere family survives a possible attempt on their lives and Daniel sees justice done to the man who killed his mother, but his bitterness has deteriorated his relationship with his family. Even though he and Bea agree to have another child, the marriage remains strained, and rather than grow up to become the successful novelist the character dreamed of being in the previous two books, he instead ages into a bitter, neurotic man who still maintains an unhealthy relationship with his dead mother's memory. Julian Sempere finally gets to meet his namesake, Julian Carax, who helps him write his family's story, but Carax himself is a broken man who stopped writing again and now spends most of his time hanging around Nuria Montfort's grave out of guilt for his role in her death. In the final scenes, an adult Julian Sempere visits Fermin, whom it's implied is close to death, and the pair ruminate that while the 1992 Barcelona Olympics are both a high-water mark for the city but that it will probably be city, the last great thing it achieves.radical change to its culture as a result of the event means the place they loved no longer exists.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AffablyEvil: [[spoiler: Leandro]], a kindly, avuncular figure who treats his proteges as his children, and who in contrast to his more brutal colleagues performs his interrogations over tea in a luxury hotel (albeit with a low dose of heroin to loosen his subjects' lips). None of that prevents him from [[spoiler: having had hundreds of families murdered so their children could be sold to Franco sympathizers, or orchestrating a series of further murders to help cover up his past crimes]].
* TheAlcoholic: Since this is late-50s and early-60s Spain, quite a few characters are functioning alcoholics. Vargas is mindful of his intake after killing his family in a drunk driving accident, while Alicia readily admits that she self-medicates with booze and is chugging white wine in virtually every scene she's in. Meanwhile, Fermin travels everywhere with a flask of what's essentially moonshine and drinks champagne for breakfast.

to:

* AffablyEvil: [[spoiler: Leandro]], a kindly, avuncular figure who treats his proteges as his children, and who in contrast to his more brutal colleagues performs his interrogations over tea in a luxury hotel (albeit with a low dose of heroin to loosen his subjects' lips). None of that prevents him from [[spoiler: having had hundreds dozens of families murdered so their children could be sold to Franco sympathizers, or orchestrating a series of further murders to help cover up his past crimes]].
* TheAlcoholic: Since this is late-50s and early-60s Spain, Spain and massive alcohol consumption was just an accepted part of the culture, quite a few characters are functioning alcoholics. Vargas is mindful of his intake after killing his family in a drunk driving accident, accident but still has brandy in his coffee, while Alicia readily admits that she self-medicates for both pain and PTSD with booze and is chugging white wine in virtually every scene she's in. Meanwhile, Fermin travels everywhere with a flask of what's essentially moonshine and drinks champagne for breakfast.



* FourEyesZeroSoul: Both Mauricio Valls and [[spoiler: Leandro]] are described as having a scholarly, bookish appearance due to their glasses. Both men [[spoiler: orchestrated the mass murders of hundreds of families so their children could be sold to high-ranking government officials, and Valls spent a large portion of his life as the warden of a political prison where he sadistically tortured inmates to vent his own frustrations at not having been given more power in the Franco regime.]]

to:

* FourEyesZeroSoul: Both Mauricio Valls and [[spoiler: Leandro]] are described as having a scholarly, bookish appearance due to their glasses. Both men [[spoiler: orchestrated the mass murders of hundreds dozens of families so their children could be sold to high-ranking government officials, and Valls spent a large portion of his life as the warden of a political prison where he sadistically tortured inmates to vent his own frustrations at not having been given more power in the Franco regime.]]

Added: 445

Changed: 414

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EndOfAnAge: Invoked by Leandro. The book is set during a period when Franco's regime was loosening its totalitarian control of Spain in an effort to have better relations with its European neighbors as well as the United States. Leandro even admits that ruthless torturers and murderers like Hendaya and Valls will have no place in the coming Spain, whereas conscience-driven individuals like Alicia will be in higher demand.

to:

* EndOfAnAge: A theme of the book.
**
Invoked by Leandro.Leandro regarding Spain in the 1960s. The book is set during a period when Franco's regime was loosening its totalitarian control of Spain in an effort to have better relations with its European neighbors as well as the United States. Leandro even admits that ruthless torturers and murderers like Hendaya and Valls will have no place in the coming Spain, whereas conscience-driven individuals like Alicia will be in higher demand.

Top