Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 22 (click to see context) from:
* RemovingTheCrucialTeammate: Literally kicking Roa out of their party was the biggest mistake the self-proclaimed "Hero" party could have ever made. Not only were they exploiting the hell out of their country's apprenticeship system to get free labor, of excellent quality to boot, but they were ''entirely'' dependent on everything he did for them and on using his familiars as their own. Sure, they manage to coast along for a while because the familiars don't catch on right away, but the instant the familiars do realize what went on, and bolt, their fame and fortune collapses in epic fashion, ''and'' they trigger a major disaster involving mithril golems running amok, because they couldn't be bothered to follow written instructions their "talentless loser" left behind.
to:
* RemovingTheCrucialTeammate: Literally kicking Roa out of their party was the biggest mistake the self-proclaimed "Hero" party could have ever made. Not only were they exploiting the hell out of their country's apprenticeship system to get free labor, of excellent quality to boot, but they were ''entirely'' dependent on everything he did for them and on using his familiars as their own. Sure, they manage to coast along for a while because the familiars don't catch on right away, but the instant the familiars do realize what went on, and bolt, their fame and fortune collapses in epic fashion, ''and'' they trigger a major disaster involving mithril golems running amok, because they couldn't be bothered to follow written instructions their "talentless loser" left behind.behind.
---------
---------
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Copying to a new page due to a typo in the title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 18 (click to see context) from:
** Mentor/Apprentice relationships '''have no oversight''', so the mentor can "train" the apprentice any way he likes, ''or not at all'' as is the case with Roa and the so-called hero party. Since the mentor is the one who decides if the apprentice graduates, this can lead to serfdom for the apprentice, thanks to the "quitter" policy above. Furthermore, any and all conflict between mentors and apprentices are always blamed on the apprentice, thus further reinforcing mentors who think themselves above their apprentices and never graduate anybody.
to:
** Mentor/Apprentice relationships '''have no oversight''', so the mentor can "train" the apprentice any way he likes, ''or not at all'' as is the case with Roa and the so-called hero party. Since the mentor is the one who decides if the apprentice graduates, this can lead to serfdom for the apprentice, thanks to the "quitter" policy above. Furthermore, any and all conflict between mentors and apprentices are always blamed on the apprentice, thus further reinforcing mentors who think themselves above their apprentices and never graduate anybody. If the apprentice is expelled from the apprenticeship, he is seen as the problem, and is also treated as radioactive because no other mentor wants to be associated with a "talentless loser" or "problem child with an attitude problem." The reason for the expulsion is never questioned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 18 (click to see context) from:
* {{Dystopia}}: Of the false meritocracy variety. The country Roa hails from touts its apprenticeship system as a meritocracy, separating wheat from chaff, but it's a heavily flawed system that is far more often than not resulting in success ''by sheer luck'' and all the ones who are screwed over by the system are treated as the problem.
to:
** Mentor/Apprentice relationships '''have no oversight''', so the mentor can "train" the apprentice any way he likes, ''or not at all'' as is the case with Roa and the so-called hero party. Since the mentor is the one who decides if the apprentice graduates, this can lead to serfdom for the apprentice, thanks to the "quitter" policy above. Furthermore, any and all conflict between mentors and apprentices are always blamed on the apprentice, thus further reinforcing mentors who think themselves above their apprentices and never graduate anybody.
** If an expelled apprentice, like Roa, winds up doing well ''in spite'' of the system, and what's worse, his dismissal shows that the mentor was just stealing the apprentice's accomplishments for himself, as in Roa's case, the top brass sends ''assassins'' at the apprentice in question, or sends the apprentice on an UriahGambit and then pretends the apprentice never existed.
** The system ''encourages'' StealingTheCredit because if the apprentice achieves something he hasn't been certified in, like beast taming, the mentor will take the credit to keep things legal.
* {{Dystopia}}: Of the false meritocracy variety. The country Roa hails from touts its apprenticeship system as a meritocracy, separating wheat from chaff, but it's a heavily flawed system that is far more often than not resulting in success ''by sheer luck'' and all the ones who are screwed over by the system are treated as theproblem.problem.
* RemovingTheCrucialTeammate: Literally kicking Roa out of their party was the biggest mistake the self-proclaimed "Hero" party could have ever made. Not only were they exploiting the hell out of their country's apprenticeship system to get free labor, of excellent quality to boot, but they were ''entirely'' dependent on everything he did for them and on using his familiars as their own. Sure, they manage to coast along for a while because the familiars don't catch on right away, but the instant the familiars do realize what went on, and bolt, their fame and fortune collapses in epic fashion, ''and'' they trigger a major disaster involving mithril golems running amok, because they couldn't be bothered to follow written instructions their "talentless loser" left behind.
** If an expelled apprentice, like Roa, winds up doing well ''in spite'' of the system, and what's worse, his dismissal shows that the mentor was just stealing the apprentice's accomplishments for himself, as in Roa's case, the top brass sends ''assassins'' at the apprentice in question, or sends the apprentice on an UriahGambit and then pretends the apprentice never existed.
** The system ''encourages'' StealingTheCredit because if the apprentice achieves something he hasn't been certified in, like beast taming, the mentor will take the credit to keep things legal.
* {{Dystopia}}: Of the false meritocracy variety. The country Roa hails from touts its apprenticeship system as a meritocracy, separating wheat from chaff, but it's a heavily flawed system that is far more often than not resulting in success ''by sheer luck'' and all the ones who are screwed over by the system are treated as the
* RemovingTheCrucialTeammate: Literally kicking Roa out of their party was the biggest mistake the self-proclaimed "Hero" party could have ever made. Not only were they exploiting the hell out of their country's apprenticeship system to get free labor, of excellent quality to boot, but they were ''entirely'' dependent on everything he did for them and on using his familiars as their own. Sure, they manage to coast along for a while because the familiars don't catch on right away, but the instant the familiars do realize what went on, and bolt, their fame and fortune collapses in epic fashion, ''and'' they trigger a major disaster involving mithril golems running amok, because they couldn't be bothered to follow written instructions their "talentless loser" left behind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* CircularReasoning: The apprenticeship system Roa suffered under for seven years is glaringly flawed and glaringly self-reinforcing in its flaws.
** Apprenticeships don't do interviews. So there's no way to know if the mentor an apprentice chooses, or is appointed to, suits them until they sign up, but once they sign up, they ''can not change or withdraw'' without being treated as a "quitter" and thus will be treated as radioactive by any other mentor the apprentice might want to try.
** Apprenticeships don't do interviews. So there's no way to know if the mentor an apprentice chooses, or is appointed to, suits them until they sign up, but once they sign up, they ''can not change or withdraw'' without being treated as a "quitter" and thus will be treated as radioactive by any other mentor the apprentice might want to try.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/5c7358df_e5dc_45fa_bc4f_5b57ac113c68.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Now this is a nice piece of Mithril!]] Roa (the boy with the gem in the page image) was drafted as an unpaid intern in the "Hero" party for a good 7 years, per the apprenticeship system sponsored by his home country.\\
\\
Naturally, once this party reaches A-rank, they get it in their heads that having "an all-rounder" in their roster will somehow shame them, so they literally throw him out of their base, with little more than the clothes on his back, and pointedly ignore all the instructions he left behind, since, per their native culture, "all rounder" is the lowest possible adventurer rank, due to being an uncertified apprentice, [[CircularReasoning and since they never bothered to certify him]], he's just "a talentless loser."\\
\\
They manage to coast along, for a while, because the party's self-proclaimed tamer uses Roa's familiars as his own, seeing as the beasts didn't realize Roa had been literally kicked out right away.\\
\\
The instant said familiars realize their master, whom they all see as family, has been evicted unjustly, thanks to the so-called "hero's" own boasts, they abandon this abusive and exploitive party to their fate.\\
\\
This is ''just the beginning'' of Roa's woes, as the country's top brass is strangely proud of this heavily flawed apprenticeship system, and often, very often, uses assassins to eliminate all evidence of the glaring flaws present, by assassinating and erasing from all records the very apprentices that prove the system isn't as flawless as the country wants to believe.
! Associated Tropes:
* BelievingTheirOwnLies: The country Roa calls home has a top brass that believes its own propaganda that the apprenticeship system they tout as flawless, doing a great job of separating the wheat from the chaff, since ''over 80%'' of the apprentices wash out, which makes sense on paper. In reality, the system is anything '''but''' flawless, and who knows how many of those 80% were simply victims of being screwed over by abusive or exploitive mentors, not being psychic and choosing a mentor for the job they're most suited to, since there's no magical appraisal tools or spells, and any apprentice trying to change mentors is just summarily treated as a "cowardly quitter."
* BlamingTheVictim: Whenever there's a conflict between apprentice and mentor, the apprentice is held to blame, even if the mentor has a glaring criminal record and is ObviouslyEvil.
* {{Dystopia}}: Of the false meritocracy variety. The country Roa hails from touts its apprenticeship system as a meritocracy, separating wheat from chaff, but it's a heavily flawed system that is far more often than not resulting in success ''by sheer luck'' and all the ones who are screwed over by the system are treated as the problem.
[[caption-width-right:350:Now this is a nice piece of Mithril!]] Roa (the boy with the gem in the page image) was drafted as an unpaid intern in the "Hero" party for a good 7 years, per the apprenticeship system sponsored by his home country.\\
\\
Naturally, once this party reaches A-rank, they get it in their heads that having "an all-rounder" in their roster will somehow shame them, so they literally throw him out of their base, with little more than the clothes on his back, and pointedly ignore all the instructions he left behind, since, per their native culture, "all rounder" is the lowest possible adventurer rank, due to being an uncertified apprentice, [[CircularReasoning and since they never bothered to certify him]], he's just "a talentless loser."\\
\\
They manage to coast along, for a while, because the party's self-proclaimed tamer uses Roa's familiars as his own, seeing as the beasts didn't realize Roa had been literally kicked out right away.\\
\\
The instant said familiars realize their master, whom they all see as family, has been evicted unjustly, thanks to the so-called "hero's" own boasts, they abandon this abusive and exploitive party to their fate.\\
\\
This is ''just the beginning'' of Roa's woes, as the country's top brass is strangely proud of this heavily flawed apprenticeship system, and often, very often, uses assassins to eliminate all evidence of the glaring flaws present, by assassinating and erasing from all records the very apprentices that prove the system isn't as flawless as the country wants to believe.
! Associated Tropes:
* BelievingTheirOwnLies: The country Roa calls home has a top brass that believes its own propaganda that the apprenticeship system they tout as flawless, doing a great job of separating the wheat from the chaff, since ''over 80%'' of the apprentices wash out, which makes sense on paper. In reality, the system is anything '''but''' flawless, and who knows how many of those 80% were simply victims of being screwed over by abusive or exploitive mentors, not being psychic and choosing a mentor for the job they're most suited to, since there's no magical appraisal tools or spells, and any apprentice trying to change mentors is just summarily treated as a "cowardly quitter."
* BlamingTheVictim: Whenever there's a conflict between apprentice and mentor, the apprentice is held to blame, even if the mentor has a glaring criminal record and is ObviouslyEvil.
* {{Dystopia}}: Of the false meritocracy variety. The country Roa hails from touts its apprenticeship system as a meritocracy, separating wheat from chaff, but it's a heavily flawed system that is far more often than not resulting in success ''by sheer luck'' and all the ones who are screwed over by the system are treated as the problem.
