Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / ShtetlDays

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


''[[https://www.tor.com/2011/04/14/shtetl-days/ Shetel Days]]'' is a 2011 AlternateHistory novella by Creator/HarryTurtledove.

to:

''[[https://www.tor.com/2011/04/14/shtetl-days/ Shetel Shtetl Days]]'' is a 2011 AlternateHistory novella by Creator/HarryTurtledove.



* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: The actors all play Ashkenazim. This is justified since this is a recreation of a shtetl in Eastern Europe, where almost all Jewish people were Ashkenasim.

to:

* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: The actors all play Ashkenazim. This is justified since this is a recreation of a shtetl in Eastern Europe, where almost all Jewish people were Ashkenasim.Ashkenazim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LivingIsMoreThanJustSurviving: A recurring theme is that, even in the hyper-paranoid security state of the Reich, plenty of people skirt or lightly break the rules in ways that can get them thrown in jail or killed on the spot, because life isn't worth living otherwise.

to:

* LivingIsMoreThanJustSurviving: LivingIsMoreThanSurviving: A recurring theme is that, even in the hyper-paranoid security state of the Reich, plenty of people skirt or lightly break the rules in ways that can get them thrown in jail or killed on the spot, because life isn't worth living otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LivingIsMoreThanJustSurviving: A recurring theme is that, even in the hyper-paranoid security state of the Reich, plenty of people skirt or lightly break the rules in ways that can get them thrown in jail or killed on the spot, because life isn't worth living otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoneHorriblyRight: The Nazis recreated the shtetl so well, the actors are starting to identify with their fake Jewish identity than their Aryan "roots."

to:

* GoneHorriblyRight: The Nazis recreated the shtetl so well, the actors are starting to identify with their fake Jewish identity more than their Aryan "roots."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualSuccessor: To ''Literature/InThePresenceOfMineEnemies'' by the same author. Both stories deal with a secret "Jewish" community in a world ruled by Nazis, albeit from completely different angles. The protagonists of ''Enemies'' are crypto-Jews hiding from the Reich by pretending to be Aryans; however, the "Jews" in ''Shetl Days'' are ethnic Germans who have adopted Jewish traditions and culture and are HiddenInPlainSight as certified Aryans whose job is to pretend to be Jewish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpiritualSuccessor: To ''Literature/InThePresenceOfMineEnemies'' by the same author. Both stories deal with a secret "Jewish" community in a world ruled by Nazis, albeit from completely different angles. The protagonists of ''Enemies'' are crypto-Jews hiding from the Reich by pretending to be Aryans; however, the "Jews" in ''Shetl Days'' are ethnic Germans who have adopted Jewish traditions and culture and are HiddenInPlainSight as certified Aryans whose job is to pretend to be Jewish.

Added: 170

Removed: 198

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoWomansLand: Downplayed. The Nazi-ruled world is clearly very patriarchal. Even in the mid-21st Century it's taken for granted that the wife does all the [[StayInTheKitchen cooking and cleaning]]


Added DiffLines:

* StayInTheKitchen: The Nazi-ruled world is clearly very patriarchal. Even in the mid-21st Century it's taken for granted that the wife does all the cooking and cleaning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WrittenByTheWinners: As shown by their title of World War II, the War of Retribution, the Nazis have framed their war of aggression as a just cause.

Added: 613

Changed: 583

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorCouple: InUniverse, Veit and Kristina are married and work together, playing a Jewish couple. Apparently most of the couples in the park are married in real life too, as it supposedly enhances their perfromances.
* DyeingForYourArt: Kristina[=/=]Bertha shaved off her natural blond hair for the role of an Orthodox Jewish woman, and presumably the other actresses at the park did too.

to:

* CreatorCouple: InUniverse, Veit and Kristina are married and work together, playing a Jewish couple. Apparently most Most of the couples in the park are married in real life too, life, as it supposedly enhances their perfromances.
performances.
* DyeingForYourArt: InUniverse, Kristina[=/=]Bertha shaved off her natural blond hair for the role of an Orthodox Jewish woman, and presumably presumably, the other actresses at the park did too.



* GoneHorriblyRight: The Nazis recreated the shtetl so well, the actors are starting to identify with their fake Jewish identity than their Aryan "roots."



* ProperlyParanoid: The Judaised actors are well aware that they'll be executed if they get caught, so they're very careful not to arouse suspicion. Veit and Kristina fast on [[UsefulNotes/JewishHolidays Yom Kippur]]; but they turn on their oven for as long as it should take to cook something, sit at the table and talk for an appropriate amount of time and wash their perfectly clean dishes, so anyone who listens in or checks their utility usage won't see anything unusual.

to:

* ProperlyParanoid: ProperlyParanoid:
**
The Judaised actors are well aware that they'll be executed if they get caught, so they're very careful not to arouse suspicion. Veit and Kristina fast on [[UsefulNotes/JewishHolidays Yom Kippur]]; but they turn on their oven for as long as it should take to cook something, sit at the table and talk for an appropriate amount of time and wash their perfectly clean dishes, so anyone who listens in or checks their utility usage won't see anything unusual.



* RayOfHopeEnding: The story ends with the Nazi Reich still more or less in charge, but Harlan's own infatuation with his Jewish identity over his Aryan "identity" implies that the Reich's foundation is not nearly as steady as it seems.

to:

* RayOfHopeEnding: The story ends with the Nazi Reich still more or less in charge, but Harlan's own infatuation with his Jewish identity over his Aryan "identity" "identity," on top of scenes where the Reich has to use threats and execution to keep people in line, implies that the Reich's foundation is not nearly as steady as it seems.

Changed: 91

Removed: 492

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: Justified, since this is a recreation of a shtetl in Eastern Europe.

to:

* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: Justified, The actors all play Ashkenazim. This is justified since this is a recreation of a shtetl in Eastern Europe.Europe, where almost all Jewish people were Ashkenasim.



* SpiritualSuccessor: To ''Literature/InThePresenceOfMineEnemies'' by the same author. Both stories deal with a secret "Jewish" community in a world ruled by Nazis, albeit from completely different angles. The protagonists of ''Enemies'' are crypto-Jews hiding from the Reich by pretending to be Aryans; however, the "Jews" in ''Shetl Days'' are ethnic Germans who have adopted Jewish traditions and culture and are HiddenInPlainSight as certified Aryans whose job is to pretend to be Jewish.

Added: 3196

Changed: 119

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheChurch: The German Christian Church is the state religion of the Reich, no other religions or even permitted Christian denominations are mentioned. It's explicitly stated that the Church really worships the Reich, not God.
* CrapsaccharineWorld: The Reich provides a high material standard of living (for Aryans), but it's artistically bereft, the SS can detain and interrogate anyone they like whenever they feel like it, and everyone is constantly fearful and suspicious of their neighbours. This is why the actors started to prefer their roles to their actual lives- they may be poor, but they're part of a real community which nobody in the outside world is.



* CreatorCouple: InUniverse, Veit and Kristina are married and work together, playing a Jewish couple.

to:

* CreatorCouple: InUniverse, Veit and Kristina are married and work together, playing a Jewish couple. Apparently most of the couples in the park are married in real life too, as it supposedly enhances their perfromances.
* DyeingForYourArt: Kristina[=/=]Bertha shaved off her natural blond hair for the role of an Orthodox Jewish woman, and presumably the other actresses at the park did too.


Added DiffLines:

* GoodShepherd: Reb Eliezer (real name Ferdinand Marian) as the "Rabbi" of the "Jews" in Wawolnice. Unlike the others, he wasn't an actor before coming to the park, he was a Christian minister who was chosen for the role because his training and consequent knowledge of Hebrew and Aramaic made him perfectly suited to play a Rabbi. He also becomes their unofficial leader outside the park as well.
* JapaneseTourist: The park is a popular attraction for them.


Added DiffLines:

* MadeASlave: The few surviving Slavs in the Reich are used as slave labour.
* NoWomansLand: Downplayed. The Nazi-ruled world is clearly very patriarchal. Even in the mid-21st Century it's taken for granted that the wife does all the [[StayInTheKitchen cooking and cleaning]]


Added DiffLines:

* ProperlyParanoid: The Judaised actors are well aware that they'll be executed if they get caught, so they're very careful not to arouse suspicion. Veit and Kristina fast on [[UsefulNotes/JewishHolidays Yom Kippur]]; but they turn on their oven for as long as it should take to cook something, sit at the table and talk for an appropriate amount of time and wash their perfectly clean dishes, so anyone who listens in or checks their utility usage won't see anything unusual.
** When Veit briefly falls under suspicion, he and Kristina make a point of going to a crowded restaurant that night and ordering two very non-Kosher meals, making sure plenty of people see them eat every bite. Then they go a few more times over the next couple of weeks, as either a one-off visit or going every night would also be suspicious.
* PublicExecution: Hangings and beheadings are broadcast on TV along with football and bad sitcoms. The park occasionally stages "pogroms" where the actors playing Poles "riot" and beat convicts dressed as Jews to death in front of paying spectators.


Added DiffLines:

* SpiritualSuccessor: To ''Literature/InThePresenceOfMineEnemies'' by the same author. Both stories deal with a secret "Jewish" community in a world ruled by Nazis, albeit from completely different angles. The protagonists of ''Enemies'' are crypto-Jews hiding from the Reich by pretending to be Aryans; however, the "Jews" in ''Shetl Days'' are ethnic Germans who have adopted Jewish traditions and culture and are HiddenInPlainSight as certified Aryans whose job is to pretend to be Jewish.


Added DiffLines:

* TwentyMinutesInTheFuture: It's set at some point in the 2040's.

Added: 138

Changed: 565

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: Justified, since this is a recreation of a shtetl which was
* AlternateHistoryNaziVictory: Exaggerated. The Nazis have gained so much hegemony that they've achieved the Final Solution in every part of the globe, although their exact reach isn't specified.

to:

* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: Justified, since this is a recreation of a shtetl which was
in Eastern Europe.
* AlternateHistoryNaziVictory: Exaggerated. The Nazis have gained so much hegemony that they've achieved the Final Solution in every part of the globe, although their exact reach isn't specified.



* CreatorCouple: InUniverse, Veit and Kristina are married and work together playing a Jewish couple.

to:

* CreatorCouple: InUniverse, Veit and Kristina are married and work together together, playing a Jewish couple.



** The Holocaust was apparently achieved around the world.

to:

** The Holocaust was apparently achieved around the world.



* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: Obviously, the Nazis who have exterminated the world's Jews, wiped out the gypsies, and enslaved the Poles. The [=SS=] officer is even enraged to hear a little bit of Yiddish.

to:

* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: Obviously, the Nazis The Nazis, who have exterminated the world's Jews, wiped out the gypsies, and enslaved the Poles. The [=SS=] officer is even enraged to hear even a little bit of Yiddish.



* TheThemeParkVersion: InUniverse Wawolnice is basically a recreation of a pre-UsefulNotes/WorldWarII shtetl replete with the stereotypes of Jewish life.
* YiddishAsASecondLanguage: Veit and the other actors not only speak fluent Yiddish in their roles but pepper in casual conversation.

to:

* RayOfHopeEnding: The story ends with the Nazi Reich still more or less in charge, but Harlan's own infatuation with his Jewish identity over his Aryan "identity" implies that the Reich's foundation is not nearly as steady as it seems.
* TheThemeParkVersion: InUniverse Wawolnice is basically a recreation of a pre-UsefulNotes/WorldWarII shtetl replete with the stereotypes of Jewish life.
* YiddishAsASecondLanguage: Veit and the other actors not only speak fluent Yiddish in their roles but and pepper Yiddish words in casual conversation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateHistoryNaziVictory: Exaggerated. The Nazis have gained so much hegemony that they've achieved the Final Solution in every part of the globe, although their reach isn't specified.

to:

* AlternateHistoryNaziVictory: Exaggerated. The Nazis have gained so much hegemony that they've achieved the Final Solution in every part of the globe, although their exact reach isn't specified.



* RageAgainstTheMachine: It's implied Veit's embrace of his Jewish identity stems from a distaste toward the Nazi Reich. At several points, he muses about [[CreativeSterility how boring and lame the culture of the Reich is]].

to:

* RageAgainstTheMachine: RageWithinTheMachine: It's implied Veit's embrace of his Jewish identity stems from a distaste toward the Nazi Reich. At several points, he muses about [[CreativeSterility how boring and lame the culture of the Reich is]].

Added: 457

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The year is 2041. A century after [[AlternateHistoryNaziVictory the victory of the German Reich in the War of Retribution]], throughout the former Polish lands, mock shtetls (Jewish villages) are set up to demonstrate. One actor who plays the role of Jakub Shlayfer, grinder of the village of Wawolnice, finds himself identifying with his role more than with his Aryan identity

to:

The year is 2041. A century after [[AlternateHistoryNaziVictory the victory of the German Reich in the War of Retribution]], throughout the former Polish lands, mock shtetls (Jewish villages) are set up to demonstrate. One actor who plays the role of Jakub Shlayfer, grinder of the village of Wawolnice, finds himself identifying with his role more than with his Aryan identityidentity.


Added DiffLines:

* CreativeSterility: The cultural output of the 2041 Nazi Reich is boring, predictable, and repetitive pap. Veit finds the then-century-old ''Film/Frankenstein1931'' to be far more interesting than any modern-day Reich production.


Added DiffLines:

* RageAgainstTheMachine: It's implied Veit's embrace of his Jewish identity stems from a distaste toward the Nazi Reich. At several points, he muses about [[CreativeSterility how boring and lame the culture of the Reich is]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreatorCouple: InUniverse, Veit and Kristina are married and work together playing a Jewish couple.

Added: 729

Changed: 36

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: Justified, since this is a recreation of a shtetl which was



* BecomingTheMask: Veit and his fellow actors go from playing Jewish caricatures.

to:

* BecomingTheMask: Veit and his fellow actors go from playing Jewish caricatures.caricatures to practically living as Ashkenazim.
* BigBrotherIsWatching: Both Veit and Kristina worry that [[StateSec Sicherheitsdienst]] could be bugging their apartment. This is semi-confirmed when Veit is confronted by an [=SS=] official about his real identity.


Added DiffLines:

* LostInCharacter: Veit is so consumed by the persona of "Jakub Shlayfer" that he even writes it as his signature. An [=SS=] officer lampshades Veit's dedication to his role by seriously asking him for his identity card.
* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: Obviously, the Nazis who have exterminated the world's Jews, wiped out the gypsies, and enslaved the Poles. The [=SS=] officer is even enraged to hear a little bit of Yiddish.

Added: 136

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BecomingTheMask: Veit and his fellow actors go from playing Jewish caricatures

to:

* BecomingTheMask: Veit and his fellow actors go from playing Jewish caricaturescaricatures.
* FinalSolution:
**The Holocaust was apparently achieved around the world.
** This fate also befell the Poles and their cultural identity.

Added: 421

Changed: 48

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Shetel Days'' is a 2011 AlternateHistory novella by Creator/HarryTurtledove.

to:

''Shetel Days'' ''[[https://www.tor.com/2011/04/14/shtetl-days/ Shetel Days]]'' is a 2011 AlternateHistory novella by Creator/HarryTurtledove.


Added DiffLines:

* AlternateHistoryNaziVictory: Exaggerated. The Nazis have gained so much hegemony that they've achieved the Final Solution in every part of the globe, although their reach isn't specified.
* BecomingTheMask: Veit and his fellow actors go from playing Jewish caricatures
* GoodFeelsGood: After reading Jewish scripture, Veit finds that he enjoys Jewish virtues and kindness more than the Nazi ideology of MightMakesRight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Set a century after [[AlternateHistoryNaziVictory the victory of the German Reich in the War of Retribution]], throughout the former Polish lands, mock shtetls (Jewish villages) are set up to demonstrate. One actor who plays the role of Jakub Shlayfer, grinder of the village of Wawolnice, finds himself identifying with his role more than with his Aryan identity

to:

Set a The year is 2041. A century after [[AlternateHistoryNaziVictory the victory of the German Reich in the War of Retribution]], throughout the former Polish lands, mock shtetls (Jewish villages) are set up to demonstrate. One actor who plays the role of Jakub Shlayfer, grinder of the village of Wawolnice, finds himself identifying with his role more than with his Aryan identity

Added: 133

Changed: 191

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Set a century after [[AlternateHistoryNaziVictory the victory of the German Reich in the War of Retribution]], throughout the former Polish lands, mock shtetls (Jewish villages) are set up to demonstrate. One actor who plays the role of Jakub Shlayfer, grinder of the village of Walnowice, finds himself identifying with his role more than with the Reich he serves.

to:

Set a century after [[AlternateHistoryNaziVictory the victory of the German Reich in the War of Retribution]], throughout the former Polish lands, mock shtetls (Jewish villages) are set up to demonstrate. One actor who plays the role of Jakub Shlayfer, grinder of the village of Walnowice, Wawolnice, finds himself identifying with his role more than with the Reich he serves.
his Aryan identity



*

to:

** TheThemeParkVersion: InUniverse Wawolnice is basically a recreation of a pre-UsefulNotes/WorldWarII shtetl replete with the stereotypes of Jewish life.
* YiddishAsASecondLanguage: Veit and the other actors not only speak fluent Yiddish in their roles but pepper in casual conversation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->Because what was Wawolnice but a Frankenstein village of Jews? It wasn’t meant to have come to life on its own, but it had, it had. So far, the outsiders hadn’t noticed. No mob of peasants with torches and pitchforks had swarmed in to destroy it—only performers playing Poles, who were every bit as artificial.

''Shetel Days'' is a 2011 AlternateHistory novella by Creator/HarryTurtledove.

Set a century after [[AlternateHistoryNaziVictory the victory of the German Reich in the War of Retribution]], throughout the former Polish lands, mock shtetls (Jewish villages) are set up to demonstrate. One actor who plays the role of Jakub Shlayfer, grinder of the village of Walnowice, finds himself identifying with his role more than with the Reich he serves.

!!The story contains the following examples.
*

Top