Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / RecordsOfTheGrandHistorian

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->''...Chen She, born in a humble hut with tiny windows and a wattle door, a day labourer in the fields and a garrison conscript, whose abilities could not match even the average, who had neither the worth of Confucius and Mao Zi nor the wealth of Tao Zhu or Yi Dun, stepped from the ranks of the common soldiers, rose up from the paths of the fields, and led a band of several hundred poor, weary soldiers in revolt against Qin. [...] After [Qin] had become master of the six directions and established its palaces within the Pass, a single commoner opposed it and its seven ancestral temples toppled, its ruler died by the hands of men, and it became the laughingstock of the world.''

to:

-->''...-->...Chen She, born in a humble hut with tiny windows and a wattle door, a day labourer in the fields and a garrison conscript, whose abilities could not match even the average, who had neither the worth of Confucius and Mao Zi nor the wealth of Tao Zhu or Yi Dun, stepped from the ranks of the common soldiers, rose up from the paths of the fields, and led a band of several hundred poor, weary soldiers in revolt against Qin. [...] After [Qin] had become master of the six directions and established its palaces within the Pass, a single commoner opposed it and its seven ancestral temples toppled, its ruler died by the hands of men, and it became the laughingstock of the world.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->''...Chen She, born in a humble hut with tiny windows and a wattle door, a day labourer in the fields and a garrison conscript, whose abilities could not match even the average, who had neither the worth of Confucius and Mao Zi nor the wealth of Tao Zhu or Yi Dun, stepped from the ranks of the common soldiers, rose up from the paths of the fields, and led a band of several hundred poor, weary soldiers in revolt against Qin. [...] After [Qin] had become master of the six directions and established its palaces within the Passm a single commoner opposed it and its seven ancestral temples toppled, its ruler died by the hands of men, and it became the laughingstock of the world.''

to:

-->''...Chen She, born in a humble hut with tiny windows and a wattle door, a day labourer in the fields and a garrison conscript, whose abilities could not match even the average, who had neither the worth of Confucius and Mao Zi nor the wealth of Tao Zhu or Yi Dun, stepped from the ranks of the common soldiers, rose up from the paths of the fields, and led a band of several hundred poor, weary soldiers in revolt against Qin. [...] After [Qin] had become master of the six directions and established its palaces within the Passm Pass, a single commoner opposed it and its seven ancestral temples toppled, its ruler died by the hands of men, and it became the laughingstock of the world.''

Added: 2114

Changed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Note that characters are troped as the ''Records'' depict them, not necessarily as they were in RealLife or other historical sources. No history can be 100% accurate, and tropers are encouraged to keep debates about "what really happened" off work pages.

to:

Note that characters are troped as the ''Records'' depict them, not necessarily as they were in RealLife or other historical sources. No history can be 100% accurate, and tropers Tropers are encouraged to keep debates about "what really happened" off work pages.



* ByTheBookCop: Zhang Shizhi, although he was an imperial commandant of justice rather than anything like a modern policeman. Emperor Wen got angry at him several times for giving criminals Wen who disliked ''only'' the sentences prescribed by law.
-->'''Zhang Shizhi:''' The law must be upheld by the Son of Heaven and by everyone in the empire alike, and that is the penalty the law prescribes. If I were to oppose a heavier penalty in special cases, then the people would cease to have any faith in the laws. [...] It is my responsibility to see that everyone in the empire is treated with absolute fairness. Should I once deviate from that standard of fairness, then the entire legal system of the empire would lose its impartiality and the people would be at a loss to know how to conduct themselves. May I ask Your Majesty to consider these consequences?\\
'''Emperor Wen:''' ''({{beat}})''...The sentence which you propose is quite correct.



** Guan Gao tried to usurp the Emperor on behalf of his king, Zhang Ao, [[TheCreon who begged him not to]]. When he got caught, Zhang Ao was also assumed to be guilty, so Guan Gao survived horrible tortures long enough to testify that he was innocent. After succeeding in this, Guan Gao killed himself (although the Emperor had pardoned both him and Zhang Ao).

to:

** Guan Gao tried to usurp the Emperor on behalf of his king, Zhang Ao, [[TheCreon who begged him not to]]. When he got caught, Zhang Ao was also assumed to be guilty, so Guan Gao survived horrible tortures long enough to testify that he was innocent. After succeeding in this, Guan Gao killed himself (although himself, even though the Emperor had pardoned both him and Zhang Ao).Ao.
* RagsToRiches: Chen She, a day labourer who began the rebellion against the Qin empire and ruled as king of Chen for six months. Sima Qian quotes an earlier author, Jia Yi [[note]]translation is Burton Watson's[[/note]] on the subject.
-->''...Chen She, born in a humble hut with tiny windows and a wattle door, a day labourer in the fields and a garrison conscript, whose abilities could not match even the average, who had neither the worth of Confucius and Mao Zi nor the wealth of Tao Zhu or Yi Dun, stepped from the ranks of the common soldiers, rose up from the paths of the fields, and led a band of several hundred poor, weary soldiers in revolt against Qin. [...] After [Qin] had become master of the six directions and established its palaces within the Passm a single commoner opposed it and its seven ancestral temples toppled, its ruler died by the hands of men, and it became the laughingstock of the world.''
* ReviveTheAncientCustom: Shusun Tong persuaded the emperor of the time to offer ripe cherries to his ancestors, apparently in emulation of an old practice called the "Presentation of Fruits". This started (restarted?) a trend of fruit offerings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The ''Records of the Grand Historian'' (太史公書/太史公书, ''Tàishǐ Gōngshū''), more commonly known in Chinese as ''Shǐjì'' (史記/史记, "Historical Records") were written around 91 B.C as a summary of all ancient Chinese history up until the life of its author, Sīmǎ Qiān (司馬遷/司马迁)[[note]]working with his dad, Sīmǎ Tán (司馬談/司马谈)[[/note]]. The ''Records'' are notable for being one of the first extant histories of China[[note]]Most previous ones being destroyed in the wars that unified China or the UsefulNotes/QinDynasty's censorship crusade[[/note]], Sīmǎ Qiān's focus on objective facts and diverse sources, and their episodic structure. Rather than writing one continuous narrative, Sīmǎ Qiān wrote standalone accounts of individuals, dynasties, imperial structures, etc., which were meant to be read as a whole. Postscripts reveal his personal opinion on the topics.

to:

The ''Records of the Grand Historian'' (太史公書/太史公书, ''Tàishǐ Gōngshū''), more commonly known in Chinese as ''Shǐjì'' (史記/史记, "Historical Records") were written around 91 B.C as a summary of all ancient Chinese history up until the life of its author, Sīmǎ Qiān (司馬遷/司马迁)[[note]]working with his dad, Sīmǎ Tán (司馬談/司马谈)[[/note]]. The ''Records'' are notable for being one of the first extant histories of China[[note]]Most previous ones being destroyed in the wars that unified China or the UsefulNotes/QinDynasty's censorship crusade[[/note]], Sīmǎ Qiān's Sima Qian's focus on objective facts and diverse sources, and their episodic structure. Rather than writing one continuous narrative, Sīmǎ Qiān Sima Qian wrote standalone accounts of individuals, dynasties, imperial structures, etc., which were meant to be read as a whole. Postscripts reveal his personal opinion on the topics.



* DeliberateUnderPerformance: The minister Xiao He, advised that his popularity was making the Emperor feel threatened, protected himself by committing crimes that made his subjects hate him. When the Emperor chastised him for these crimes, Xiao He reverted to his previous altruistic self- and the Emperor [[ProperlyParanoid immediately had him imprisoned]].

to:

* DeliberateUnderPerformance: The minister Xiao He, advised that his popularity was making the Emperor feel threatened, protected himself by committing crimes that made his subjects hate him. When the Emperor chastised him for these crimes, Xiao He reverted to his previous altruistic self- self -- and the Emperor [[ProperlyParanoid immediately had him imprisoned]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The ''Records of the Grand Historian'' (or ''Shi ji''), written around 91 B.C, were a summary of all Ancient Chinese history up until the life of its author, Sima Qian [[note]]working with his dad, Sima Tan[[/note]]. The ''Records'' are notable for being one of the first extant histories of China [[note]]most previous ones being destroyed in the wars that unified China or the Qin's censorship crusade[[/note]], Sima Qian's focus on objective facts and diverse sources, and their episodic structure. Rather than writing one continuous narrative, Sima Qian wrote standalone accounts of individuals, dynasties, imperial structures, etc., which were meant to be read as a whole. Postscripts reveal his personal opinion on the topics.

to:

The ''Records of the Grand Historian'' (or ''Shi ji''), (太史公書/太史公书, ''Tàishǐ Gōngshū''), more commonly known in Chinese as ''Shǐjì'' (史記/史记, "Historical Records") were written around 91 B.C, were C as a summary of all Ancient ancient Chinese history up until the life of its author, Sima Qian [[note]]working Sīmǎ Qiān (司馬遷/司马迁)[[note]]working with his dad, Sima Tan[[/note]]. Sīmǎ Tán (司馬談/司马谈)[[/note]]. The ''Records'' are notable for being one of the first extant histories of China [[note]]most China[[note]]Most previous ones being destroyed in the wars that unified China or the Qin's UsefulNotes/QinDynasty's censorship crusade[[/note]], Sima Qian's Sīmǎ Qiān's focus on objective facts and diverse sources, and their episodic structure. Rather than writing one continuous narrative, Sima Qian Sīmǎ Qiān wrote standalone accounts of individuals, dynasties, imperial structures, etc., which were meant to be read as a whole. Postscripts reveal his personal opinion on the topics.



* SympatheticPOV: Often negative facts about one "protagonist" were only revealed in the account of another. For example, Emperor Gaozu's attempts to push his children out of a carriage are described in the chapter about his nemesis, Xiang Yu- not the chapter about Gaozu himself.

to:

* SympatheticPOV: Often negative facts about one "protagonist" were only revealed in the account of another. For example, Emperor Gaozu's attempts to push his children out of a carriage are described in the chapter about his nemesis, Xiang Yu- Yu -- not the chapter about Gaozu himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

The ''Records of the Grand Historian'' (or ''Shi ji''), written around 91 B.C, were a summary of all Ancient Chinese history up until the life of its author, Sima Qian [[note]]working with his dad, Sima Tan[[/note]]. The ''Records'' are notable for being one of the first extant histories of China [[note]]most previous ones being destroyed in the wars that unified China or the Qin's censorship crusade[[/note]], Sima Qian's focus on objective facts and diverse sources, and their episodic structure. Rather than writing one continuous narrative, Sima Qian wrote standalone accounts of individuals, dynasties, imperial structures, etc., which were meant to be read as a whole. Postscripts reveal his personal opinion on the topics.

Note that characters are troped as the ''Records'' depict them, not necessarily as they were in RealLife or other historical sources. No history can be 100% accurate, and tropers are encouraged to keep debates about "what really happened" off work pages.
----
!!This work includes the following tropes:

* DeliberateUnderPerformance: The minister Xiao He, advised that his popularity was making the Emperor feel threatened, protected himself by committing crimes that made his subjects hate him. When the Emperor chastised him for these crimes, Xiao He reverted to his previous altruistic self- and the Emperor [[ProperlyParanoid immediately had him imprisoned]].
* DrivenToSuicide: Many characters commit suicide rather than live in disgrace. Sima Qian, having been pressured to do the same after his imprisonment and castration, often criticizes this norm.
** Xiang Yu, who believed Heaven itself was foiling his plans to rule China, cut his own throat in the middle of [[DoNotGoGentle a battle]]. This indirectly killed several of his opponents, who trampled each other to death fighting over his corpse (and the significant bounty that would come with it).
** Guan Gao tried to usurp the Emperor on behalf of his king, Zhang Ao, [[TheCreon who begged him not to]]. When he got caught, Zhang Ao was also assumed to be guilty, so Guan Gao survived horrible tortures long enough to testify that he was innocent. After succeeding in this, Guan Gao killed himself (although the Emperor had pardoned both him and Zhang Ao).
* SympatheticPOV: Often negative facts about one "protagonist" were only revealed in the account of another. For example, Emperor Gaozu's attempts to push his children out of a carriage are described in the chapter about his nemesis, Xiang Yu- not the chapter about Gaozu himself.

----

Top