Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / ForWantOfANail

Go To

OR

Added: 206

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EverythingIsBiggerInTexas: Texas, here called Jefferson, is the place where the American Revolutionaries sojourn after their uprising is crushed.

to:

* EverythingIsBiggerInTexas: EverythingIsBigInTexas: Texas, here called Jefferson, is the place where the American Revolutionaries sojourn after their uprising is crushed.


Added DiffLines:

* FantasyWorldMap: There's a map at the front of the book, which makes it reminiscent in purpose of this trope. (Seen here: http://static1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130208010529/fwoan/images/b/b3/Sobel.jpg .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OneNationCopyright: Kramer Associates have ''de facto'' control over Taiwan, the Philippines, Brazil, Argentina and likely other nations; Mexico was also this for a while.

to:

* OneNationCopyright: OneNationUnderCopyright: Kramer Associates have ''de facto'' control over Taiwan, the Philippines, Brazil, Argentina and likely other nations; Mexico was also this for a while.

Added: 2333

Changed: 1

Removed: 178

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BalkanizeMe: Quito and Rio Negro both secede from Brazil when it gained independence following the Trans-Oceanic War.



* CaptainErsatz: The United Workers of the World, compared to the RealLife International Workers of the World. The same also applies to the Confederation Bureau of Investigation.



* DeepSouth: The Southern Confederation in the CNA, appropriately enough.



* {{Eagleland}}: The Confederacy of North America is mostly a Type 1, while the United States of Mexico falls hard into a Type 2.



* EverythingIsBiggerInTexas: Texas, here called Jefferson, is the place where the American Revolutionaries sojourn after their uprising is crushed.



* FictionalCounterpart: The United Workers of the World, compared to the RealLife International Workers of the World. The same also applies to the Confederation Bureau of Investigation.



* FlyoverCountry: In the CNA, the Confederations of Indiana, Northern and Southern Vandalia ([[AndZoidberg and Manitoba]]) all qualify as this.



* GuiltComplex: Governor-General Richard Mason has a big one for the CNA's sidestepping of the Global War, which informs his foreign policy.

to:

* GuiltComplex: Governor-General Richard Mason has a big one for the CNA's sidestepping of the Global War, which informs his foreign policy.


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: There are some mostly in the earlier part of the book that get prominent roles, but this tapers off towards the end.


Added DiffLines:

* HitlersTimeTravelExemptionAct: Yet another notable ''aversion'', because nothing like the Holocaust ever takes place and there is never anyone even remotely as bad as Hitler described in the book.


Added DiffLines:

* InsistentTerminology: It's the "North American Rebellion", not the AmericanRevolution.


Added DiffLines:

* IstanbulNotConstantinople: New Grenada remains, in lieu of Colombia, Ecuador, Panama and Venezuela.


Added DiffLines:

* KarmaHoudini: Bernard Kramer and his successors.


Added DiffLines:

* LiteraryAllusionTitle: In addition to the title of the RealLife book, the InUniverse name for it (''Scorpions in a Bottle'') is a reference to a speech made by Pedro Hermión about the continental rivalry between the Confederacy of North America and the United States of Mexico.


Added DiffLines:

* NoHuggingNoKissing: Justified because this is essentially an overview of history, but one could plausibly assume almost all of the main characters are bachelors.


Added DiffLines:

* OneNationCopyright: Kramer Associates have ''de facto'' control over Taiwan, the Philippines, Brazil, Argentina and likely other nations; Mexico was also this for a while.
* OppressiveStatesOfAmerica: [[spoiler: The United States of Mexico]] gains a PoliceState.


Added DiffLines:

* PleaseSelectNewCityName: Fort Pitt (and possibly all of Pittsburgh) is renamed Burgoyne, and becomes the capital of the Confederacy of North America.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Quebec}}: Becomes a more or less self-ruling associated state of the CNA in 1889.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnyOneCanDie: And not just because it covers so much history. [[spoiler: Among them Governor of the North Confederation Daniel Webster, Indianan Grand Council member Dudley Graves, and two Mexican presidents: Pedro Hermión and Omar Kinkaid.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WeAllLiveInAmerica: The RealWorld American author Robert Sobel depicts a parliamentary system... [[FridgeLogic that draws up impeachment measures in lieu of a vote of no confidence.]]

to:

* WeAllLiveInAmerica: The RealWorld RealLife American author Robert Sobel depicts a parliamentary system... [[FridgeLogic that draws up impeachment measures in lieu of a vote of no confidence.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WeAllLiveInAmerica: The RealWorld American author Robert Sobel depicts a parliamentary system... [[FridgeLogic that draws up impeachment measures in lieu of a vote of no confidence.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PragmaticVillainy: Kramer Associates, whose support of [[the Benito Hermíon dictatorship]] fluctuates according to how much it benefits them.

to:

* PragmaticVillainy: Kramer Associates, whose support of [[the [[spoiler: the Benito Hermíon dictatorship]] fluctuates according to how much it benefits them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacter: Dozens of characters come in and out of focus, which is [[JustifiedTrope understandable]] considering it covers approximately two centuries of history.

to:

* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacter: LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Dozens of characters come in and out of focus, which is [[JustifiedTrope understandable]] considering it covers approximately two centuries of history.



* PresidentEvil: [[Spoiler: Benito Hermíon is a (dubiously) elected leader of the USM, and his goal soon escalates into a plot to TakeOverTheWorld.]]

to:

* PresidentEvil: [[Spoiler: [[spoiler: Benito Hermíon is a (dubiously) elected leader of the USM, and his goal soon escalates into a plot to TakeOverTheWorld.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Fiction500: Kramer Associates' executives.

to:

* Fiction500: {{Fiction500}}: Kramer Associates' executives.

Added: 1156

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbitionIsEvil: Subverted, as some of the ambitious characters merely go onto become pragmatic and competent leaders. Although there are shades of this with Bernard Kramer.



* Fiction500: Kramer Associates' executives.



* FramingDevice: An undergraduate history book... [[AlternateHistory from a world where history went a little bit differently.]]
* FromNobodyToNightmare: Bernard Kramer went from an immigrant miner to a CorruptCorporateExecutive who is responsible for [[spoiler: installing a dictator in Mexico.]]



* GreyAndGrayMorality: Part of what gives this book verisimilitude is its restrained portrayal of the morality of both sides despite some InUniverse AuthorAppeal.



* NouveauRiche: Bernard Kramer and his successors qualify as this.



* PresidentEvil: [[Spoiler: Benito Hermíon is a (dubiously) elected leader of the USM, and his goal soon escalates into a plot to TakeOverTheWorld.]]



* QueenVicky: Shows up in the timeline briefly.

to:

* QueenVicky: Shows up in the timeline briefly. briefly.
* RagsToRiches: Bernard Kramer goes from being a miner immigrant to founding one of the most successful corporations in all of this world's history.


Added DiffLines:

* ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney: Kramer Associates, frequently.


Added DiffLines:

* SelfMadeMan: Bernard Kramer (see RagsToRiches above).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 440

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BananaRepublic: [[spoiler: The United States of Mexico becomes one:]] Populist dictator? Check. Latin American? Check. Controlled by a multinational corporation? Double check.

to:

* BananaRepublic: [[spoiler: The United States of Mexico becomes one:]] Populist dictator? Check. [[spoiler: Latin American? Check. Controlled by a multinational corporation? Double check. ]]


Added DiffLines:

* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacter: Dozens of characters come in and out of focus, which is [[JustifiedTrope understandable]] considering it covers approximately two centuries of history.


Added DiffLines:

* QueenVicky: Shows up in the timeline briefly.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: When they aren't being overly idealistic, the leaders of the Confederacy of North America tend to be this.


Added DiffLines:

* TakeOverTheWorld: The aim of [[spoiler: Mexican Emperor Benito Hermíon]].

Added: 1028

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DracoInLeatherPants: InUniverse, Robert Sobel is accused of doing this to Kramer Associates (and the CNA) as a whole.



* EthnicMenialLabor: A staple of the United States of Mexico.

to:

* EthnicMenialLabor: A staple of the United States of Mexico. Mexico.
* EqualOpportunityEvil: It's subtle, but [[spoiler: the Mexican dictatorship is led by Benito Hermíon, a part of the Hispano minority, and Bernard Kramer, a German immigrant.]]


Added DiffLines:

* MiddleEasternCoalition: Following the Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Empire as well as the Global War, the Middle East remains unified under the German protectorate of Arabia.


Added DiffLines:

* PragmaticVillainy: Kramer Associates, whose support of [[the Benito Hermíon dictatorship]] fluctuates according to how much it benefits them.


Added DiffLines:

* RonTheDeathEater: The author does this to the United States of Mexico, as well as the American revolutionaries, according to InUniverse critique of the author.


Added DiffLines:

* UnitedEurope: With the exception of the United Kingdom, Spain and a few others, Germany has successfully unified Europe after the Global War.


Added DiffLines:

* VillainWithGoodPublicity: The executives of Kramer Associates, implied to be InUniverse AuthorAppeal.

Changed: 58

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CommieLand: {{Averted}} entirely as far as we know, which implies that the United States helped produce [[CreateYourOwnVillain the Soviet Union.]]

to:

* CommieLand: {{Averted}} entirely as far as we know, which implies that in our timeline, the United States helped produce indirectly contributed to the creation of [[CreateYourOwnVillain the Soviet Union.]]

Added: 2802

Removed: 122

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[FutureSlang Alternate History Terminology]]: “Vitavision” for television, “locomobile” for the automobile, and so on.


Added DiffLines:

* AmericaSavesTheDay: Subverted. Neither the Confederacy of North America or the United States of Mexico does anything akin to the United States of America's entry into WorldWarI or WorldWarII, as the former mostly stays neutral and the latter is merely prone to opportunistic land grabs.
* AmericaTakesOverTheWorld: Although the book is centered on this region, it seems as though the equivalent of the ColdWar for this timeline takes place between two superpowers on the North American continent, perhaps even three if one counts [[MegaCorp Kramer Associates]] due to their Mexican origins.


Added DiffLines:

* CallARabbitASmeerp: “Vitavision” for television, “locomobile” for the automobile, and so on.


Added DiffLines:

* CheeseEatingSurrenderMonkeys: France easily capitulates to German invasion during the Global War.


Added DiffLines:

* CommieLand: {{Averted}} entirely as far as we know, which implies that the United States helped produce [[CreateYourOwnVillain the Soviet Union.]]


Added DiffLines:

* CultColony: Manitoba is a beacon for Utopian philosophers and radicals of all stripes... yet remains the land without politics.


Added DiffLines:

* EasilyConqueredWorld: The Russian Empire during the Great Northern War, which has Alaska and Siberia taken from it in the course of two years by the increasingly powerful United States of Mexico. France also falls into this trope during the Global War.
* EthnicMenialLabor: A staple of the United States of Mexico.
* FalseFlagOperation: Features into many of the political machinations in the book.


Added DiffLines:

* FullCircleRevolution: [[spoiler: The United States of Mexico escapes from the yoke of British oppression... to later become one of the most oppressive regimes on the face of the planet.]]


Added DiffLines:

* HegemonicEmpire: The British Empire, naturally.


Added DiffLines:

* NaturalizedName: Bernard Kramer, a German immigrant who became a world-class Mexican industrialist, can be inferred to have this.


Added DiffLines:

* SlaveLiberation: Is delayed in Mexico until ''1920''.


Added DiffLines:

* SpaceFillingEmpire: Germany could be considered an example of this, having most of continental Europe and the former Ottoman Empire under its rule after the Global War.


Added DiffLines:

* TheAlliance: Subverted, because the CNA avoids entering the Global War in arms with the United Kingdom (likewise with Spain, who declares neutrality despite a pre-existing alliance).


Added DiffLines:

* TheCommonwealthOfNations: A parallel to it arises in the United British Commonwealth of Nations.


Added DiffLines:

** Imperial Germany succeeds in conquering most of continental Europe during the Global War, although they've been met with some widespread opposition a few decades into their rule.


Added DiffLines:

* ThePlague: An influenza epidemic occurs during the Global War, piling onto the misery.


Added DiffLines:

* TheTheocracy: From what we know, this is averted like it is with [[CommieLand "communist"]] or fascist nations.


Added DiffLines:

* WideEyedIdealist: Many of the CNA's politicians fall into this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WriterOnBoard: An InUniverse example, as the alternate Robert Sobel resides in Australia, which is essentially a Kramer Associates protectorate that is party to the United British Commonwealth of Nations. As such he frames Kramer Associates and the CNA in a rosy light, in comparison to the United States of Mexico.

to:

* WriterOnBoard: An InUniverse example, as the alternate Robert Sobel is an Australian that resides in Australia, which Taiwan; the latter is essentially a Kramer Associates protectorate that and the former is party to the United British Commonwealth of Nations. As such he frames Kramer Associates and the CNA in a rosy light, in comparison to the United States of Mexico.

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WriterOnBoard: An InUniverse example, as the alternate Robert Sobel resides in Australia, which is essentially a Kramer Associates protectorate that is party to the United British Commonwealth of Nations. As such he frames Kramer Associates and the CNA in particularly rosy light, in comparison to the United States of Mexico.

to:

* WriterOnBoard: An InUniverse example, as the alternate Robert Sobel resides in Australia, which is essentially a Kramer Associates protectorate that is party to the United British Commonwealth of Nations. As such he frames Kramer Associates and the CNA in particularly a rosy light, in comparison to the United States of Mexico.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: InUniverse accusations are lodged at the author for making the leaders of the United States of Mexico slightly more incompetent and immoral in comparison to his home nation, the Confederacy of North America.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: InUniverse accusations are lodged at the author for making the leaders of the United States of Mexico slightly more incompetent and immoral in comparison to his home nation, the Confederacy of North America.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The PointOfDivergence is the arrival of reinforcements for British General Horatio Gates during the Battle of Saratoga, which turns the tide of the American Revolutionary War to the favor of the United Kingdom, which then stamp out the rebellion. Afterward, the colonies are reorganized into the more centralized and autonomous Confederacy of North America (CNA), while thousands of revolutionaries that weren't executed or imprisoned sojourn westward, founding the nation of Jefferson in the place Texas would have been. Under the charismatic yet steady leadership of AndrewJackson, it unifies with the neighboring Republic of Mexico to create the United States of Mexico (USM) in 1820. The new republic is soon embroiled in a continental power struggle with the Confederacy of North America.

to:

The PointOfDivergence is the arrival of reinforcements for British General Horatio Gates during the Battle of Saratoga, which turns the tide of the American Revolutionary War to the favor of the United Kingdom, which then stamp stamps out the rebellion. Afterward, the colonies are reorganized into the more centralized and autonomous Confederacy of North America (CNA), while thousands of revolutionaries that weren't executed or imprisoned sojourn westward, founding the nation of Jefferson in the place Texas would have been. Under the charismatic yet steady leadership of AndrewJackson, it unifies with the neighboring Republic of Mexico to create the United States of Mexico (USM) in 1820. The new republic is soon embroiled in a continental power struggle with the Confederacy of North America.

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The PointOfDivergence for its narrative is the arrival of reinforcements for British General Horatio Gates during the Battle of Saratoga, which turns the tide of the American Revolutionary War to the favor of the United Kingdom, which then stamp out the rebellion. Afterward, the colonies are reorganized into the more centralized and autonomous Confederacy of North America (CNA), while thousands of revolutionaries that weren't executed or imprisoned sojourn westward, founding the nation of Jefferson in the place Texas would have been. Under the charismatic yet steady leadership of AndrewJackson, it unifies with the neighboring Republic of Mexico to create the United States of Mexico (USM) in 1820. The new republic is soon embroiled in a continental power struggle with the Confederacy of North America.

to:

The PointOfDivergence for its narrative is the arrival of reinforcements for British General Horatio Gates during the Battle of Saratoga, which turns the tide of the American Revolutionary War to the favor of the United Kingdom, which then stamp out the rebellion. Afterward, the colonies are reorganized into the more centralized and autonomous Confederacy of North America (CNA), while thousands of revolutionaries that weren't executed or imprisoned sojourn westward, founding the nation of Jefferson in the place Texas would have been. Under the charismatic yet steady leadership of AndrewJackson, it unifies with the neighboring Republic of Mexico to create the United States of Mexico (USM) in 1820. The new republic is soon embroiled in a continental power struggle with the Confederacy of North America.

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlidingScaleofGenderInequality: Level 1, as there are very scant mentions to women all throughout the work.

to:

* SlidingScaleofGenderInequality: Level 1, as there are very scant scarce mentions to women at all throughout in the work.

Added: 109

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlidingScaleofAlternateHistoryPlausibility: A Type 1, with no obvious AlternateHistoryWank or clear instances of AlienSpaceBats.

to:

* SlidingScaleofAlternateHistoryPlausibility: A Type 1, with no obvious AlternateHistoryWank or clear instances of AlienSpaceBats. AlienSpaceBats.
* SlidingScaleofGenderInequality: Level 1, as there are very scant mentions to women all throughout the work.

Changed: 31

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSmurfettePrinciple: There are only three named female characters in the entire book, none of which have very significant roles. Women's suffrage is also only addressed in a footnote.

to:

* TheSmurfettePrinciple: There are only three named female characters in the entire book, none of which have very significant roles. Women's suffrage within the CNA, given in 1908, is also only addressed in a footnote.

Changed: 130

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSmurfettePrinciple: There are only three named female characters in the entire book, none of which have very significant roles. Women's suffrage is also not addressed, perhaps implying that they [[FridgeHorror don't have the right to vote]] in the described nations or the world in general.

to:

* TheSmurfettePrinciple: There are only three named female characters in the entire book, none of which have very significant roles. Women's suffrage is also not addressed, perhaps implying that they [[FridgeHorror don't have the right to vote]] only addressed in the described nations or the world in general.a footnote.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSmurfettePrinciple: There are only three named female characters in the entire book, none of which have very significant roles. Women's suffrage is also not addressed, perhaps implying that they [[FridgeHorror don't have the right to vote]] in the described nation or te world in general.

to:

* TheSmurfettePrinciple: There are only three named female characters in the entire book, none of which have very significant roles. Women's suffrage is also not addressed, perhaps implying that they [[FridgeHorror don't have the right to vote]] in the described nation nations or te the world in general.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheSmurfettePrinciple: There are only three named female characters in the entire book, none of which have very significant roles. Women's suffrage is also not addressed, perhaps implying that they [[FridgeHorror don't have the right to vote]] in the described nation or te world in general.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShownTheirWork: Much of the statistics and descriptions of economic processes in the book clearly show the author's professional bbackground in the subject, especially when it comes to innovative programs like the National Financial Administration in the CNA.

to:

* ShownTheirWork: Much of the statistics and descriptions of economic processes in the book clearly show the author's professional bbackground background in the subject, especially when it comes to innovative programs like the National Financial Administration in the CNA.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShownTheirWork: Much of the statistics and descriptions of economic processes in the book clearly show the author's professional bbackground in the subject, especially when it comes to innovative programs like the National Financial Administration in the CNA.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WriterOnBoard: An InUniverse example, as the alternate Robert Sobel resides in Australia, which is essentially a Kramer Associates protectorate that is party to the United British Commonwealth of Nations. As such he frames Kramer Associates and the CNA in particularly rosy light, in comparison to the United States of Mexico.

Top