Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / Stalag17

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Cookie mentions that Sefton pays him 5 cigarettes a day to take care of the mice, but Cookie (like Sefton) is only ever seen smoking cigars, meaning that Sefton made sure that Cookie is getting 'spending money' and not just smoking his pay away.

to:

* Cookie mentions that Sefton pays him 5 five cigarettes a day to take care of the mice, but Cookie (like Sefton) is only ever seen smoking cigars, meaning that Sefton made sure that Cookie is getting 'spending money' and not just smoking his pay away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Just looking at Joey, you can see that the others are seeing to his hygiene and other needs as he is relatively clean shaven and not emaciated from not eating anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Cookie mentions that Sefton pays him 5 cigarettes a day to take care of the mice, but Cookie (like Sefton) is only ever seen smoking cigars, meaning that Sefton made sure that Cookie is getting 'spending money' and not just smoking his pay away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When everyone steps forward to take the blame with Animal for dirtying the commandant's boots, there's no indication in the wide shots that Sefton didn't step forward.

to:

* When everyone steps forward to take the blame with Animal for dirtying the commandant's boots, there's no indication in the wide shots that Sefton didn't step forward.steps with them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds (although it's implied that at least some of it is due to Sefton failing officer school while Dunbar passed), with the former spending a lot of time baiting the latter for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.

to:

* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds (although it's implied that at least some of it is due to Sefton failing officer school while Dunbar passed), with the former spending a lot of time baiting the latter for his wealthy, privileged background.status. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds, with the former spending a lot of time baiting the latter for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.

to:

* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds, backgrounds (although it's implied that at least some of it is due to Sefton failing officer school while Dunbar passed), with the former spending a lot of time baiting the latter for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When the commandant is gloating over the deaths of Manfredi and Johnson, Animal uses Joey's ocarina to splash mud on Scherbach's shiny boots. Joey - already suffering from shell-shock - doesn't take it well. But later on, the guys had a new ocarina created for him for Christmas, and Joey's frozen face breaks into a smile.

to:

** When the commandant is gloating over the deaths of Manfredi and Johnson, Animal uses Joey's ocarina to splash mud on Scherbach's shiny boots. Joey - -- already suffering from shell-shock - -- doesn't take it well. But later on, the guys had have a new ocarina created for him for Christmas, and Joey's frozen face breaks into a smile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds, and the former spends a lot of time baiting the latter for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.

to:

* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds, and with the former spends spending a lot of time baiting the latter for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds, and Sefton spends a lot of time baiting Dunbar for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.

to:

* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds, and Sefton the former spends a lot of time baiting Dunbar the latter for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds, and Sefton spends much of the film baiting Dunbar for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.

to:

* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different socio-economic backgrounds, and Sefton spends much a lot of the film time baiting Dunbar for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Sefton:''' ''(after cutting their way through the wire)'' Let's blow, Chauncey.

to:

-->'''Sefton:''' ''(after cutting their way through the barbed wire)'' Let's blow, Chauncey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How the whole barracks - including JerkAss Sefton - go out of their way to treat [[TheWoobie Joey]] right.

to:

* How the whole barracks - -- including JerkAss Sefton - -- go out of their way to treat [[TheWoobie Joey]] right.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but from different rungs on the socio-economic ladder, and Sefton spends much of the film baiting Dunbar for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.

to:

* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but from take an almost instant dislike to one another due to their very different rungs on the socio-economic ladder, backgrounds, and Sefton spends much of the film baiting Dunbar for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Sefton and Dunbar are fellow Boston natives, but from different rungs on the socio-economic ladder, and Sefton spends much of the film baiting Dunbar for his wealthy, privileged background. But when the critical moment comes, it's Sefton who ends up saving Dunbar's life by escorting him out of the camp and (hopefully) to freedom.
-->'''Sefton:''' ''(after cutting their way through the wire)'' Let's blow, Chauncey.
-->'''Dunbar:''' ''(grinning)'' Let's.
-->''(they run off into the woods together, Sefton with his arm around Dunbar to hold him up)''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Animal is seen carving a new ocarina to replace the one he broke.

to:

** Animal is seen carving a new ocarina to replace the one he broke. He even turns away from Joey to keep it a surprise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The men take a moment from filling in the tunnel to show respects to the fallen. Even Sefton extinguishes his cigar and removes his hat for them.

to:

** The men take a moment from filling in the tunnel to show respects to the fallen. Even Sefton extinguishes his cigar and removes his hat for them. The guards, rather than ordering them to continue working, allow them to show their respects.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When everyone steps forward to take the blame with Animal for dirtying the commandant's boots, there's no indication in the wide shots that Sefton didn't step forward.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** After an argument with Duke that he says has spoiled his appetite, Sefton gives his fancy (by comparison) breakfast that he traded for to Joey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It is also revealed during mail call that the others have been writing letters to Joey's family in his behalf.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Animal is seen carving a new ocarina to replace the one he broke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Whatever else the commandant did, he kept his word and gave Manfredi and Johnson a proper funeral with proper coffins.
** The men take a moment from filling in the tunnel to show respects to the fallen. Even Sefton extinguishes his cigar and removes his hat for them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When Duke admits that they were wrong about Sefton, Sefton just tells him to forget it and strikes a match off Duke's stubble -- something that usually makes him extremely angry, but Duke just smiles in a mix of penance and admiration.
** Duke's final lines are expressing happiness that Sefton pulled it off.
* Sefton saluting the barracks men with a grin before he leaves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When the commandant is gloating over the deaths of Manfredi and Johnson, Animal uses Joey's ocarina to splash mud on Scherbach's shiny boots. Joey - already suffering from shell-shock - doesn't take it well. But later on, the guys had a new ocarina created for him for Christmas, and Joey's frozen face breaks into a smile.

to:

** When the commandant is gloating over the deaths of Manfredi and Johnson, Animal uses Joey's ocarina to splash mud on Scherbach's shiny boots. Joey - already suffering from shell-shock - doesn't take it well. But later on, the guys had a new ocarina created for him for Christmas, and Joey's frozen face breaks into a smile.smile.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When the commandant is gloating over the deaths of Manfredi and Johnson, Animal uses Joey's whistle to splash mud on Scherbach's shiny boots. Joey - already suffering from shell-shock - doesn't take it well. But later on, the whistle is returned to him all cleaned up, and Joey's frozen face breaks into a smile.

to:

** When the commandant is gloating over the deaths of Manfredi and Johnson, Animal uses Joey's whistle ocarina to splash mud on Scherbach's shiny boots. Joey - already suffering from shell-shock - doesn't take it well. But later on, the whistle is returned to guys had a new ocarina created for him all cleaned up, for Christmas, and Joey's frozen face breaks into a smile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When the commandant is gloating over the deaths of Manfredi and Johnson, Animal uses Joey's whistle to splash mud on Scherbach's shiny boots. Joey - already suffering from shell-shock - doesn't take it well. But later on, the whistle is returned to him all cleaned up, and Joey's frozen face breaks into a smile.

Top