Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / Emma

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!The book


Added DiffLines:


!!2020 Film
* Harriet comes to tell Emma that she's engaged to Robert Martin and that she's discovered her father is a galoshes merchant. The way she says this, she clearly expects Emma to break off their friendship as being too low a connection (which, in fact, is pretty much what happens in the book). Instead Emma tells her that she must bring her father to Hartfield, and they hug.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Just before that Mr. Knightley has another rather sweet moment when he notices Jane is getting tired from singing and tells her to stop, even when the others plead for one last song. Miss Bates, anxious for her niece, is very grateful.

to:

** Just before Before that Mr. Knightley has another rather sweet moment when he notices Jane is getting tired from singing and tells her to stop, even when the others plead for one last song. Miss Bates, anxious for her niece, niece's health, is very grateful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Just before that Mr. Knightley has another rather sweet moment when he notices Jane is getting tired from singing and tells her to stop, even when the others plead for one last song. Miss Bates, anxious for her niece, is very grateful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mr Knightley's opinion of Harriet starts off as rather low; he considered her a simple-minded flatterer and a very wrong sort of friend for the clever, self-assured Emma. However, after they dance together, he makes an effort to become acquaintances with her and later at Donwell Emma finds the two of them in pleasant conversation as he tells her about the agriculture of the estate. When he brings Emma the news that she and Martin are engaged, he describes her warmly as "an artless, amiable girl" with both good notions and good principles, and expresses his confidence that she will make a good wife for Mr. Martin.

to:

* Mr Knightley's opinion of Harriet starts off as rather low; he considered her a simple-minded flatterer and a very wrong sort of friend for the clever, self-assured Emma.Emma, believing (not unreasonably) that neither of them would benefit from the imbalance in personality. However, after they dance together, he makes an effort to become acquaintances with her and later at Donwell Emma finds the two of them in pleasant conversation as he tells her about the agriculture of the estate. When he brings Emma the news that she and Martin are engaged, he describes her warmly as "an artless, amiable girl" with both good notions and good principles, and expresses his confidence that she will make a good wife for Mr. Martin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->She loved every body, was interested in every body’s happiness, quicksighted to every body’s merits; thought herself a most fortunate creature, and surrounded with blessings in such an excellent mother, and so many good neighbours and friends, and a home that wanted for nothing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mr Knightley's opinion of Harriet at that point is rather low; he considered her an ignorant flatterer and a very wrong sort of friend for the clever, self-assured Emma. However, after they dance together, he makes an effort to become acquaintances with her and later at Donwell Emma finds the two of them in pleasant conversation as he tells her about the agriculture of the estate. When he brings Emma the news that she and Martin are engaged, he describes her warmly as "an artless, amiable girl" with both good notions and good principles, and expresses his confidence that she will make a good wife for Mr. Martin.

to:

* Mr Knightley's opinion of Harriet at that point is starts off as rather low; he considered her an ignorant a simple-minded flatterer and a very wrong sort of friend for the clever, self-assured Emma. However, after they dance together, he makes an effort to become acquaintances with her and later at Donwell Emma finds the two of them in pleasant conversation as he tells her about the agriculture of the estate. When he brings Emma the news that she and Martin are engaged, he describes her warmly as "an artless, amiable girl" with both good notions and good principles, and expresses his confidence that she will make a good wife for Mr. Martin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mr Knightley's opinion of Harriet at that point is rather low; he considered her an ignorant flatterer and a very wrong sort of friend for the clever, self-assured Emma. However, after they dance together, he makes an effort to become acquaintances with her and later at Donwell Emma finds the two of them in pleasant conversation as he tells her about the agriculture of the estate. When he brings Emma the news that she and Martin are engaged, he describes her warmly as "an artless, amiable girl" with both good notions and good principles, and expresses his confidence that she will make a good wife for Mr. Martin.

Changed: 1267

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth. Mr. Knightley's estate is a paradise in England. The abundance of strawberries and orchard trees in bloom -- oddly unseasonal for June -- but it fits to the idea of pastoral countryside.

to:

* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth. Mr. Mr Knightley's estate is a paradise in England. The abundance of strawberries and orchard trees in bloom -- oddly unseasonal for June -- but it fits to the idea of pastoral countryside.



* Mr. Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. He's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slightest.

to:

* Mr. Mr Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. He's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slightest.



* Emma caring for her father. You'd think a spirited, energetic young woman would resent having to structure her life around taking care of a hypochondriac father, but Emma loves him absolutely and actually enjoys spending time with him and keeping him happy. [[spoiler: Even when she's engaged to Mr. Knightley, she utterly refuses to marry him if it means leaving her father. He decides to move in with her instead so that they can both take care of Mr. Woodhouse.]]
* Mr. Knightley's comment to Emma during the ball that she would have picked a better wife for Mr. Elton than he had picked for himself, partially vindicating Emma's attachment to Harriet in the process.
* Despite professing a dislike of dancing, and having privately expressed his doubts of Harriet Smith, Mr. Knightley asks her to dance after seeing Mr. Elton publicly snub her. In the 2009 version, he very pointedly crosses the room to do so. This act completely wins over Emma, who was becoming quite distressed at her friend's sitting alone despite being caught up in a very energetic dance.
* Emma and Knightley's conversation after this, where she says his "secret" has been revealed and asks him to ask her to dance the next.
* While Miss Bates's situation is a tearjerker, her response to it is this trope; she's an almost absurdly happy woman who considers herself perfectly contended and fortunate to have her mother, her niece, and her many, many friends and acquaintances. She's easily the worst-off character in the book, but she's also probably the most cheerful.
* After all his fickleness and deception earlier in the novel, it's very sweet to see Frank absolutely ''gushing'' over [[spoiler: Jane Fairfax]] after their secret is revealed, reassuring the reader that, despite all his faults, he's honestly crazy about her.

to:

* Emma caring for her father. You'd think a spirited, energetic young woman would resent having to structure her life around taking care of a hypochondriac father, but Emma loves him absolutely and actually enjoys spending time with him and keeping him happy. [[spoiler: Even when she's engaged to Mr. Mr Knightley, she utterly refuses to marry him if it means leaving her father. He decides to move in with her instead so that they can both take care of Mr. Woodhouse.]]
* Mr. Knightley's comment to Emma during the ball that she would have picked a better wife for Mr. Elton than he had picked for himself, partially vindicating Emma's attachment to Harriet in the process.
Mr Woodhouse.
* Despite professing a dislike of dancing, and having privately expressed his doubts of Harriet Smith, Mr. Mr Knightley asks her to dance after seeing Mr. Mr Elton publicly snub her. In the 2009 version, he very pointedly crosses the room to do so. This act completely wins over Emma, who was becoming quite distressed at her friend's sitting alone despite being caught up in a very energetic dance.
* Emma and Mr Knightley's conversation after this, he dances with Harriet, where she says his "secret" (that he's a good dancer) has been revealed and asks him to ask her to dance for the next.
* Mr Knightley's comment to Emma during the ball that she would have picked a better wife for Mr Elton than he had picked for himself, partially vindicating Emma's attachment to Harriet in the process.
* While Miss Bates's situation is a tearjerker, her response to it is this trope; sad, she copes unusually well; she's an almost absurdly happy woman who considers herself perfectly contended and fortunate to have her mother, her niece, and her many, many friends and acquaintances. She's easily the worst-off character in the book, but she's also probably the most cheerful.
* After all his fickleness and deception earlier in the novel, it's very sweet to see Frank absolutely ''gushing'' over [[spoiler: Jane Fairfax]] Fairfax after their secret is revealed, reassuring the reader that, despite all his faults, he's honestly crazy about her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Despite professing a dislike of dancing, and having privately expressed his doubts of Harriet Smith, Mr. Knightley asks her to dance after seeing Mr. Elton publicly snub her. In the 2009 version, he very pointedly crosses the room to do so. This act completely wins over Emma, who was becoming quite distressed at her friend's sitting alone despite being caught up in a very energetic dance.
* Emma and Knightley's conversation after this, where she says his "secret" has been revealed and asks him to ask her to dance the next.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth. Mr Knightley's estate is a paradise in England. The abundance of strawberries and orchard trees in bloom -- oddly unseasonal for June -- but it fits to the idea of pastoral countryside.

to:

* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth. Mr Mr. Knightley's estate is a paradise in England. The abundance of strawberries and orchard trees in bloom -- oddly unseasonal for June -- but it fits to the idea of pastoral countryside.



* Mr Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. He's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slightest.

to:

* Mr Mr. Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. He's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slightest.



* Emma's caring for her father. You'd think a spirited, energetic young woman would resent having to structure her life around taking care of a hypochondriac father, but Emma loves him absolutely and actually enjoys spending time with him and keeping him happy. [[spoiler: Even when she's engaged with Mr. Knightly, she utterly refuses to marry him if it means leaving her father. He decides to move in with her instead so that they can both take care of Mr. Woodhouse.]]
* Mr. Knightly's comment to Emma during the ball that she would have picked a better wife for Mr. Elton than he had picked for himself, partially vindicating Emma's attachment to Harriet in the process.
* While Miss Bate's situation is a tearjerker, her response to it is this trope; she's an almost absurdly happy woman who considers herself perfectly contended and fortunate to have her mother, her niece, and her many, many friends and acquaintances. She's easily the worst-off character in the book, but she's also probably the most cheerful.

to:

* Emma's Emma caring for her father. You'd think a spirited, energetic young woman would resent having to structure her life around taking care of a hypochondriac father, but Emma loves him absolutely and actually enjoys spending time with him and keeping him happy. [[spoiler: Even when she's engaged with to Mr. Knightly, Knightley, she utterly refuses to marry him if it means leaving her father. He decides to move in with her instead so that they can both take care of Mr. Woodhouse.]]
* Mr. Knightly's Knightley's comment to Emma during the ball that she would have picked a better wife for Mr. Elton than he had picked for himself, partially vindicating Emma's attachment to Harriet in the process.
* While Miss Bate's Bates's situation is a tearjerker, her response to it is this trope; she's an almost absurdly happy woman who considers herself perfectly contended and fortunate to have her mother, her niece, and her many, many friends and acquaintances. She's easily the worst-off character in the book, but she's also probably the most cheerful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* After all his fickleness and deception earlier in the novel, it's very sweet to see Frank absolutely ''gushing'' over [[spoiler: Jane Fairfax]] after their secret is revealed, reassuring the reader that, despite all his faults, he's honestly crazy about her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* While Miss Bate's situation is a tearjerker, her response to it is this trope; she's an almost absurdly happy woman who considers herself perfectly contended and fortunate to have her mother, her niece, and her many, many friends and acquaintances. She's easily the worst-off character in the book, but she's also probably the most cheerful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mr. Knightly's comment to Emma during the ball that she would have picked a better wife for Mr. Elton than he had picked for himself.

to:

* Mr. Knightly's comment to Emma during the ball that she would have picked a better wife for Mr. Elton than he had picked for himself.himself, partially vindicating Emma's attachment to Harriet in the process.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mr. Knightly's comment to Emma during the ball that she would have picked a better wife for Mr. Elton than he had picked for himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All of Emma and Jane's interactions near the end of the book. They may not have a chance to be the friends they ought to have been, but they make as good a beginning as possible.

to:

* All of Emma and Jane's interactions near the end of the book. They may not have a chance to be the friends they ought to have been, but they make as good a beginning as possible.they possibly can.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* All of Emma and Jane's interactions near the end of the book. They may not have a chance to be the friends they ought to have been, but they make as good a beginning as possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Emma's caring for her father. You'd think a spirited, energetic young woman would resent having to structure her life around taking care of a hypochondriac father, but Emma loves him absolutely and actually enjoys spending time with him and keeping him happy. [[spoiler: Even when she's engaged with Mr. Knightly, she utterly refuses to marry him if it means leaving her father. He decides to move in with her instead so that they can both take care of Mr. Wodhouse.]]

to:

* Emma's caring for her father. You'd think a spirited, energetic young woman would resent having to structure her life around taking care of a hypochondriac father, but Emma loves him absolutely and actually enjoys spending time with him and keeping him happy. [[spoiler: Even when she's engaged with Mr. Knightly, she utterly refuses to marry him if it means leaving her father. He decides to move in with her instead so that they can both take care of Mr. Wodhouse.Woodhouse.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Emma's caring for her father. You'd think a spirited, energetic young woman would resent having to structure her life around taking care of a hypochondriac father, but Emma loves him absolutely and actually enjoys spending time with him and keeping him happy. [[spoiler: Even when she's engaged with Mr. Knightly, she utterly refuses to marry him if it means leaving her father. He decides to move in with her instead so that they can both take care of Mr. Wodhouse.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixed typo


* Mr Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. e's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slightest.

to:

* Mr Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. e's He's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slightest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Harriet Smith's 'tradesman' father's generous support of his illegitimate daughter is heartwarming considering how easy it would have been for him to ignore his responsibility in the matter. Given the social conditions of their time he basically does everything that can be done for a girl in her position. Open acknowledgement would only trash his reputation - and possibly cost him his livelihood - while doing Harriet no good at all.

Added: 287

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mr Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. e's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slighttest.

to:

* Mr Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. e's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slighttest.slightest.
* Mr Knightley's LoveConfession to Emma in the Paltrow/Northam version. "I rode through the rain -- but I'd ride through worse than that if I could just hear your voice telling me I might at least have some chance to win you...!" Try not to swoon, ladies -- but you probably will anyway.

Added: 436

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Emma''': There is no charm equal to tenderness of heart. There is nothing to be compared to it. Warmth and tenderness of heart, with an affectionate, open manner, will beat all the clearness of head in the world, for attraction, I am sure it will. It is tenderness of heart which makes my dear father so generally beloved -- which gives Isabella all her popularity. -- I have it not --but I know how to prize and respect it. Harriet is my superior in all the charm and all the felicity it gives. Dear Harriet! I would not change you for the clearest-headed, longest-sighted, best-judging female breathing. Oh! the coldness of a Jane Fairfax! Harriet is worth a hundred such -- And for a wife -- a sensible man's wife -- it is invaluable. I mention no names; but happy the man who changes Emma for Harriet!

to:

-->'''Emma''': -->'''Emma:''' There is no charm equal to tenderness of heart. There is nothing to be compared to it. Warmth and tenderness of heart, with an affectionate, open manner, will beat all the clearness of head in the world, for attraction, I am sure it will. It is tenderness of heart which makes my dear father so generally beloved -- which gives Isabella all her popularity. -- I have it not --but I know how to prize and respect it. Harriet is my superior in all the charm and all the felicity it gives. Dear Harriet! I would not change you for the clearest-headed, longest-sighted, best-judging female breathing. Oh! the coldness of a Jane Fairfax! Harriet is worth a hundred such -- And for a wife -- a sensible man's wife -- it is invaluable. I mention no names; but happy the man who changes Emma for Harriet!Harriet!
* Mr Knightley playing with his nieces and nephews. e's a fun uncle who adores them and they love him in turn. Similarly, Emma is a great and loving aunt. The line about her telling her nephews John and Henry a story about Harriet and gypsies and how they corrected her every time she deviated from her original account is very sweet and very accurate. Children always correct the narrators if their stories vary even in the slighttest.

Added: 841

Changed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
extended one entry and moved a second one from Tear Jerker page. But really, heart-warmth fits better.


* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth.

to:

* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth. Mr Knightley's estate is a paradise in England. The abundance of strawberries and orchard trees in bloom -- oddly unseasonal for June -- but it fits to the idea of pastoral countryside.
* This mental rant of Emma's:
-->'''Emma''': There is no charm equal to tenderness of heart. There is nothing to be compared to it. Warmth and tenderness of heart, with an affectionate, open manner, will beat all the clearness of head in the world, for attraction, I am sure it will. It is tenderness of heart which makes my dear father so generally beloved -- which gives Isabella all her popularity. -- I have it not --but I know how to prize and respect it. Harriet is my superior in all the charm and all the felicity it gives. Dear Harriet! I would not change you for the clearest-headed, longest-sighted, best-judging female breathing. Oh! the coldness of a Jane Fairfax! Harriet is worth a hundred such -- And for a wife -- a sensible man's wife -- it is invaluable. I mention no names; but happy the man who changes Emma for Harriet!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth.

to:

* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth.heart-warmth.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The alfresco strawberry picking party at Donwell Abbey. It radiates heart-warmth.

Top