Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TombRaider2013

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Officially, he's a New Zealander who grew up in Hawaii.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** A New Zealand rugby club that doesn't exist. Maiava is indeed a Samoan surname (V doesn't exist in the Maori alphabet), and Ngapuhi is a tribe, not a place. At least [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pania_Of_The_Reef Pania of the Reef is a real New Zealand myth]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** Really it should be obvious..unlike the American, Nazi and Japanese, Lara knows that Himoko's tomb is the source of the Storm and the Zombie Samurai Stormguards, so she did a DungeonBypass and just go directly to the tomb and killed her, as oppose to the rest of Americans, Japanese, and Nazi's who made the mistake of trying to attack a supernatural army head-on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why was the rescue plane trying to land to pick up the Endurance's crew? A casual look at Yamatai Island would show any experienced pilot that there is no place on it flat enough, long enough, and sufficiently free of obstructions in which to land a four-engine aircraft, much less have it take off again. The most the pilot should have been able to do was get the GPS coordinates for the island to a boat, seaplane or helicopter, because any attempt to land to pick up survivors himself would have wrecked the plane even if Himiko had been asleep.

to:

* Why was the rescue plane trying to land to pick up the Endurance's crew? A casual look at Yamatai Island would show any experienced pilot that there is no place on it flat enough, long enough, and sufficiently free of obstructions in which to land a four-engine aircraft, much less have it take off again. The most the pilot should have been able to do was get the GPS coordinates for the island to a boat, seaplane or helicopter, because any attempt to land to pick up survivors himself would have wrecked the plane even if Himiko had been asleep.asleep.
** Knowing US Coast Guard doctrine, the C-130 pilot was probably trying to get a better picture of the area for follow-on rescuers and drop rescue supplies. US Air Force/Air National Guard squadrons would go further by dropping pararescue jumpers (parachuting mountain climbing scuba diving paramedics) along with the supplies, in order to treat the wounded. What really bugs me more is the Japanese Coast Guard helo, which is being flown by an American pilot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Hoshi killed herself in such a way that the ritual was unable to continue or be done again (it's mentioned in a letter that this is why she killed herself during the ceremony) to spare others of her fate.

to:

** Hoshi killed herself in such a way that the ritual was unable to continue or be done again (it's mentioned in a letter that this is why she killed herself during the ceremony) to spare others of her fate.fate.
* Why was the rescue plane trying to land to pick up the Endurance's crew? A casual look at Yamatai Island would show any experienced pilot that there is no place on it flat enough, long enough, and sufficiently free of obstructions in which to land a four-engine aircraft, much less have it take off again. The most the pilot should have been able to do was get the GPS coordinates for the island to a boat, seaplane or helicopter, because any attempt to land to pick up survivors himself would have wrecked the plane even if Himiko had been asleep.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So Queen Himiko bodysurfs between her priestesses, so that she can live forever. Hoshi puts a stop to that by killing herself. How come the people in charge of Yamatai didn't try to find another girl to replace her?

to:

* So Queen Himiko bodysurfs between her priestesses, so that she can live forever. Hoshi puts a stop to that by killing herself. How come the people in charge of Yamatai didn't try to find another girl to replace her?her?
** Hoshi killed herself in such a way that the ritual was unable to continue or be done again (it's mentioned in a letter that this is why she killed herself during the ceremony) to spare others of her fate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How often do ships get wrecked in the Devil's Triangle? Matthias has several hundred mooks on the island, and many more died without joining the Solarii. Gathering that many people takes time.

to:

* How often do ships get wrecked in the Devil's Triangle? Matthias has several hundred mooks on the island, and many more died without joining the Solarii. Gathering that many people takes time. Especially since since the fact that the Devil's Triangle is a known navigational hazard means that people will have long since charted flight paths and shipping lanes that go around it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Warning: There may be unmarked spoilers below, so read at your own risk''

to:

''Warning: '''Warning: There may be unmarked spoilers below, so read at your own risk''
risk'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''Warning: There may be unmarked spoilers below, so read at your own risk''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How often do ships get wrecked in the Devil's Triangle? Matthias has several hundred mooks on the island, and many more died without joining the Solarii. Gathering that many people takes time.

to:

* How often do ships get wrecked in the Devil's Triangle? Matthias has several hundred mooks on the island, and many more died without joining the Solarii. Gathering that many people takes time.time.
* So Queen Himiko bodysurfs between her priestesses, so that she can live forever. Hoshi puts a stop to that by killing herself. How come the people in charge of Yamatai didn't try to find another girl to replace her?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Dropping to the ground would have, almost without question, gotten them both killed. Sure, he could have tried shooting from the ground, but he certainly wouldn't be able to kill all three pursuers after falling, and it would have made both him and Lara an easier target.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pretty sure the game specifically said he was ''Maori''. Maori (as is Jonah) are from New Zealand. The Samoans are from the Samoan Islands. They may both be Pacific Islander, but that's like calling an Apache and Iroquois, just because both are Native American.

to:

** Pretty sure the game specifically said he was ''Maori''. Maori (as is Jonah) are from New Zealand. The Samoans are from the Samoan Islands. They may both be Pacific Islander, Islanders, but that's like calling an Apache and an Iroquois, just because both are Native American.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For your first question, she probably should have bled out, but it's a video game. For your second, yes it's generally bad to pull something out that's impaling you, but you're also not supposed to move either. If she was running around with that piece of rebar or whatever sticking out of her side, it would have been reaming out the wound the whole time. If it had caught on something and ripped out her side, it would have been much, much worse.

to:

** For your first question, she probably should have bled out, but it's a video game. For your second, yes it's generally bad to pull something out that's impaling you, but you're also not supposed to move either. If she was running around with that piece of rebar or whatever sticking out of her side, it would have been reaming out the wound the whole time. If it had caught on something and ripped out her side, it would have been much, much worse.worse.
* How often do ships get wrecked in the Devil's Triangle? Matthias has several hundred mooks on the island, and many more died without joining the Solarii. Gathering that many people takes time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Scavenger's Den, Lara yanks out a stick thing that goes through her body, and doesn't appear to treat it until reaching the helicopter in the Shanty Town. How come she didn't bleed out at any point between then, considering all the extra-strenuous activity she does afterwards? Also, isn't it considered WorstAid to yank a foreign object out of a wound if it's impaling you?

to:

* In the Scavenger's Den, Lara yanks out a stick thing that goes through her body, and doesn't appear to treat it until reaching the helicopter in the Shanty Town. How come she didn't bleed out at any point between then, considering all the extra-strenuous activity she does afterwards? Also, isn't it considered WorstAid to yank a foreign object out of a wound if it's impaling you?you?
** For your first question, she probably should have bled out, but it's a video game. For your second, yes it's generally bad to pull something out that's impaling you, but you're also not supposed to move either. If she was running around with that piece of rebar or whatever sticking out of her side, it would have been reaming out the wound the whole time. If it had caught on something and ripped out her side, it would have been much, much worse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The storms were erratic, not constant. The helicopter pilot was lucky enough to have a moment where things weren't as chaotic as usual.

to:

** The storms were erratic, not constant. The helicopter pilot was lucky enough to have a moment where things weren't as chaotic as usual.usual.
* In the Scavenger's Den, Lara yanks out a stick thing that goes through her body, and doesn't appear to treat it until reaching the helicopter in the Shanty Town. How come she didn't bleed out at any point between then, considering all the extra-strenuous activity she does afterwards? Also, isn't it considered WorstAid to yank a foreign object out of a wound if it's impaling you?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The spike on top of the radio tower isn't that wide, she could have wrapped her legs and arms around it and shimmied her way past the broken section. Certainly not easy, but it is possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** Even simpler explanation: One of the logs, I think by the Japanese soldier, said they were attacked by hundreds of Stormguard. Lara fights maybe a few dozen. So maybe there were a lot more Stormguard before they fought the Japanese, Germans, and Americans. Maybe fighting off three modern armies, plus constant skirmishes with the Solarii, thinned their numbers to the point where Lara could finish them off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Really, it might not even be *that* complicated. The average Western Allied unit- like the USMC- was an absolute beast in terms of equipment and training, but was it ever divulged how large the USMC forces were? For all we know, the units of them that the Stormguard destroyed weren't that much larger than a rifle squad or two; certainly highly formidable and containingly well equipped, trained, and experienced soldiers, but in a deeply strange environment and facing an enemy like nothing they had experienced before in numbers far in excess of themselves. Lara's greatest advantage and what eventually leads to defeat her enemies is unparalleled adaptivity and the ability to survive long enough against the enemy to learn their weaknesses; she's not *really* dependent on anybody else to survive from hour to hour, and her combat power isn't massively diminished by going it alone (one of the justifiable reasons where a single person can fare better than an entire unit). In contrast, the USMC would have been cutting their teeth against the Japanese and- maybe- the Germans (conventional forces with a very distinctive way of operating) and operating in disciplined units that possessed massive firepower but also depended on proper coordination to use as effectively as possible. The new threat would have caught them offguard, and the strategies they employed would have cut them into small units of disoriented men who had probably been forced to ditch most of their heavy equipment and who were operating separately from anyone not in their immediate viewing range; once they're like that they could be overwhelmed with brute force. In contrast, the Japanese land forces were effectively in a MedievalStasis that lasted from 1904 to the end of the Empire, and on the whole were miserably equipped, poorly trained (again, a common nickname for soldiers was "Bullets" or "Senrin" (a unit of money that is to the Yen what a penny is to a Dollar, and the average price of a conscription notice), thoroughly malnourished on an institutional level, and wedded to strategies that were costly and risky in 1904. On top of this, they lacked the advanced small unit training the USMC received, were stuck in an unfamiliar territory, and were stuck in an insanely hierarchical system where they looked to their officers for almost everything. I find it all too plausible that the Stormguard could have destroyed them in a straight up battle if they had to, especially after whittling away at their strength (like we see in one of the letters) beforehand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** You could make the same complain about a LOT of action movies and videogames where a lone character overcomes challenges that proved impossible to larger, better trained and armed forces. Supesion of disbelief, my friend. Plus, it could be handwaved that the Japanese and American forces took a toll on each other before the Stormguard finished them off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** No, she doesn't. Not immediately, anyway; she just "appears" down a level on the tower after the cutscene, even though she pretty much effectively destroyed her way down while climbing up in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[spoiler:But Jonah would have been the far better choice. Both in-story and from a meta perspective, it made no sense for Alex to go beyond the last-second revelation that he was crushing on Lara. Jonah, in the prequel comic -- which Pratchett also wrote -- is shown being able to physically beat up thugs without apparently suffering any damage himself, using a gun while saving Whitman from the mafia, being fully willing to kill people with said gun without flinching, not even hesitating to act while being shot at, and brushing off a bullet graze like it's no big deal while saying that he's had worse. He is obviously pretty used to dangerous and life-threatening situations.\\

to:

*** [[spoiler:But Jonah would have been the far better choice. Both in-story and from a meta perspective, it made no sense for Alex to go beyond the last-second revelation that he was crushing on Lara.Lara, which is a pretty damn flimsy excuse to begin with. Jonah, in the prequel comic -- which Pratchett also wrote -- is shown being able to physically beat up thugs without apparently suffering any damage himself, using a gun while saving Whitman from the mafia, being fully willing to kill people with said gun without flinching, not even hesitating to act while being shot at, and brushing off a bullet graze like it's no big deal while saying that he's had worse. He is obviously pretty used to dangerous and life-threatening situations.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler:But Jonah would have been the far better choice. Both in-story and from a meta perspective, it made no sense for Alex to go beyond the last-second revelation that he was crushing on Lara. Jonah, in the prequel comic -- which Pratchett also wrote -- is shown being able to physically beat up thugs without apparently suffering any damage himself, using a gun while saving Whitman from the mafia, being fully willing to kill people with said gun without flinching, not even hesitating to act while being shot at, and brushing off a bullet graze like it's no big deal while saying that he's had worse. He is obviously pretty used to dangerous and life-threatening situations.\\
Even if Reyes didn't know about any of that -- which I find unlikely, but even so -- Jonah is obviously a large, physically capable guy who knows how to use his strength. Meanwhile, Alex is someone who, by his own admission, is the least badass person in the group besides, you know, [[DamselInDistress Samantha]]. And whether Alex knows how to use a gun or not (and knowing how to ''shoot'' a gun doesn't necessary mean you can shoot it ''well''), exactly ''how'' many combat situations has he been in before landing on Yamatai? It's probably safe to assume that the number of those would be a grand total of ''zero''. What was he supposed to do when his tiny pistol ran out of bullets? Jonah, at least, would have had a chance at physically subduing his enemies if he managed to sneak up on them. Alex would have been screwed. Which he was. To be honest, I ''can'' see Reyes being like "Yeah, sure, whatever, knock yourself out," when Alex volunteered to get the tools, but that isn't ''just'' grossly irresponsible and stupid. It's ''cold''. I'd like to think she felt some guilt about that afterward, because she basically sent Alex to his death. And, bottom line, it still ''makes no sense'' from a story perspective besides killing Alex off as a DeusAngstMachina]]. Yes, yes, I know. That's how it all played out, end of story. But the fact that it ''did'' play out that way in the first place still confuses the ''hell'' out of me.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So how did the helicopter get in, in the first place? The plane gets shot down almost immediately but the helicopter apparently flies in, lands to pick up Roth and the hovers around looking for Lara. Only after picking her up does the storm really have any affect and it seems clear that he could have landed for a second time if he had only heeded Lara's warnings.

to:

* So how did the helicopter get in, in the first place? The plane gets shot down almost immediately but the helicopter apparently flies in, lands to pick up Roth and the hovers around looking for Lara. Only after picking her up does the storm really have any affect and it seems clear that he could have landed for a second time if he had only heeded Lara's warnings.warnings.
** The storms were erratic, not constant. The helicopter pilot was lucky enough to have a moment where things weren't as chaotic as usual.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** You never find out, but its clear from his victims that he kills women. If you fail the QTE, he appears slightly consoling as Lara dies, suggesting that possibly he was trying to save her from the worse fate (burning or being the queen's vessel).

to:

** You never find out, but its clear from his victims that he kills women. If you fail the QTE, he appears slightly consoling as Lara dies, suggesting that possibly he was trying to save her from the worse fate (burning or being the queen's vessel).vessel).
* So how did the helicopter get in, in the first place? The plane gets shot down almost immediately but the helicopter apparently flies in, lands to pick up Roth and the hovers around looking for Lara. Only after picking her up does the storm really have any affect and it seems clear that he could have landed for a second time if he had only heeded Lara's warnings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Um, doesn't she use a zipline to get down from that tower?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The best way for a prepared organization to get people and things to and from the island would be by submarine, nothing we've seen Himiko do would bother a sub too much. As for how they got all the concrete and equipment there, well, it's easy to get ships TO the island if you don't mind wrecking them in the process, it's leaving that's the problem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Between early 1943 and mid 1944 a US Marine Corps Battalion had a strength of approximately 1000 men. A more specific breakdown can be seen [[http://www.bayonetstrength.150m.com/UnitedStates/Marine/MarineInfantry/united_states_marine_battalion%20early%201943%20to%20mid%201944.htm here]], but in 1944 you have one Weapons Company (one mortar platoon and three machine gun platoons, with bazookas held by HQ) and three Rifle Companies (each with their own mortar and machine gun sections, and three platoons of three rifle squads). The machine guns would be Browning M1917 or M1919 light machine guns (with the occasional Browning M2 heavy machine gun, generally attached to battalion HQ). Each rifle squad would have at least two [=BARs=], with the rest of the riflemen armed with M1 Garand rifles. You'd also have the occasional Thompson M1928 submachine gun or Winchester M97 (later the M12) trenchgun. A number of members of each rifle squad would also carry rifle grenades. By 1945 the separate weapons company was eliminated and its machine guns and mortars were attached directly to the rifle companies. Oh, and [[KillItWithFire flamethrowers]] were added to the battalion's arsenal as well. The amount of automatic firepower a Marine battalion could bring to bear in the latter stages of WWII was ''phenomenal''. So no. When it comes to equipment Lara couldn't even match the firepower of a single ''rifle squad'', much less an entire Marine battalion. If the Stormguard were as vulnerable to the weapons of the Marines as they are to Lara's, any assault against even an only marginally-prepared defensive position would have been a massacre (this is precisely why the Japanese abandoned the [[HumanWaveAttack Banzai Charge]] in the later stages of the war: Sending a massed body of men into a direct assault against ''that'' much firepower was like throwing meat into a grinder).

to:

*** Between early 1943 and mid 1944 a US Marine Corps Battalion had a strength of approximately 1000 men. A more specific breakdown can be seen [[http://www.bayonetstrength.150m.com/UnitedStates/Marine/MarineInfantry/united_states_marine_battalion%20early%201943%20to%20mid%201944.htm here]], but in 1944 you have one Weapons Company (one mortar platoon and three machine gun platoons, with bazookas held by HQ) and three Rifle Companies (each with their own mortar and machine gun sections, and three platoons of three rifle squads). The machine guns would be Browning M1917 or M1919 light machine guns (with the occasional Browning M2 heavy machine gun, generally attached to battalion HQ). Each rifle squad would have at least two [=BARs=], with the rest of the riflemen armed with M1 Garand rifles. You'd also have the occasional Thompson M1928 submachine gun or Winchester M97 (later the M12) trenchgun. A number of members of each rifle squad would also carry rifle grenades. By 1945 the separate weapons company was eliminated and its machine guns and mortars were attached directly to the rifle companies. Oh, and [[KillItWithFire flamethrowers]] were added to the battalion's arsenal as well. The amount of automatic firepower a Marine battalion could bring to bear in the latter stages of WWII was ''phenomenal''. So no.'''So no'''. When it comes to equipment Lara couldn't even match the firepower of a single ''rifle squad'', much less an entire Marine battalion. If the Stormguard were as vulnerable to the weapons of the Marines as they are to Lara's, any assault against even an only marginally-prepared defensive position would have been a massacre (this is precisely why the Japanese abandoned the [[HumanWaveAttack Banzai Charge]] in the later stages of the war: Sending a massed body of men into a direct assault against ''that'' much firepower was like throwing meat into a grinder).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The same thing happens earlier on, with radio tower. It's falling apart as you climb up and final ladder literally breaks down when Lara was ''already'' jumping between lacking rungs. At this point she's not even carrying any rope to help herself. So how did she get down after the transmission? Sure, she didn't have to go to the bottom of the tower, but that still doesn't explain how she was able to get down even by that smaller bit.

Top