Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TombRaider2013

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


** All of the survivors aside from Lara and Sam seems to have a clinical case of TooDumbToLive. If they're not making ''pointless'' HeroicSacrifices that could have easily been avoided, they're sitting around complaining and brushing off everything Lara has to say despite the fact she's the only one who seems to be able to take care of herself.

to:

** All of the survivors aside from Lara and Sam seems to have a clinical case of TooDumbToLive. If they're not making ''pointless'' HeroicSacrifices {{Heroic Sacrifice}}s that could have easily been avoided, they're sitting around complaining and brushing off everything Lara has to say despite the fact she's the only one who seems to be able to take care of herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Critical Research Failure is a disambiguation page


** The CPR is nothing more than CriticalResearchFailure. The rest is RuleOfDrama, dialed up to eleven. Which ends up as {{Narm}}.

to:

** The CPR is nothing more than CriticalResearchFailure.Critical Research Failure. The rest is RuleOfDrama, dialed up to eleven. Which ends up as {{Narm}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


** The CPR is nothing more than CriticalResearchFailure. The rest is RuleOfDrama, dialed UpToEleven. Which ends up as {{Narm}}.

to:

** The CPR is nothing more than CriticalResearchFailure. The rest is RuleOfDrama, dialed UpToEleven.up to eleven. Which ends up as {{Narm}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** There may be another reason, remember the Stormguard are not just a zombie army, they seem to be some form of revenant, as they are clearly sentient, maybe they ''hate'' their existence and instead of what looks like them protecting Himiko[[spoiler:'s corpse]] they are actively preventing anyone bringing her a [[spoiler:new vessel]] not much justification but outside of Himikos' legend we know not much about the stormguard themselves, remember Mathias had to sneak himself and Sam in, despite the fact that he would probably know exactly what to say to them.
N

Changed: 429

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Marines ran into problems with the paper shells when they went to the Pacific theater, so they switched over to brass shells. There were still bits that could be damaged from getting too wet, but whatever was loaded in the shotgun was given a bit of extra protection from the elements by the gun itself, so most of the rain may have never reached the actual shells. Corrosion could still be an issue from the humidity, though.
N

Changed: 374

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** She'd been almost fully immersed in fetid water with the massive puncture wound in her side a couple times by that point, so she was already at high risk of going septic anyway. Like pulling out the rebar in the earlier scene, though, in theory it's a necessary risk. Terrible infections are a tomorrow problem while being able to avoid being shot is a right now problem.
N

Changed: 321

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** She was in a hurry to get to the top of the ziggurat area, so she didn't have time to look for a safe and easy path. After she'd rescued Sam, she might have wanted to get down relatively quickly but wasn't under as much immediate pressure, so she was able to take her time a bit more and find an easier/safer way down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As far as ''how'' anyone knew the island was there to fortify it, OcchamsRazor: The 'location'' of the island was well-charted and never lost. What was lost was its ''identity'', which faded into obscurity after the collapse of its influence. It's the same reason why Atlantis was "lost" right under everyone's noses for millennia, until new research strongly connected it to Santorini and the catastrophic eruption of Mt. Thera. Everyone knew right where Santorini was, they just didn't realize it was also what was left of Atlantis.

to:

** As far as ''how'' anyone knew the island was there to fortify it, OcchamsRazor: OccamsRazor: The 'location'' ''location'' of the island was well-charted and never lost. What was lost was its ''identity'', which faded into obscurity after the collapse of its influence. It's the same reason why Atlantis was "lost" right under everyone's noses for millennia, until new research strongly connected it to Santorini and the catastrophic eruption of Mt. Thera. Everyone knew right where Santorini was, they just didn't realize it was also what was left of Atlantis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** As far as ''how'' anyone knew the island was there to fortify it, OcchamsRazor: The 'location'' of the island was well-charted and never lost. What was lost was its ''identity'', which faded into obscurity after the collapse of its influence. It's the same reason why Atlantis was "lost" right under everyone's noses for millennia, until new research strongly connected it to Santorini and the catastrophic eruption of Mt. Thera. Everyone knew right where Santorini was, they just didn't realize it was also what was left of Atlantis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And ''still'' there are numerous other wrecks and other sites closer and safer where some toolbox could be found or assembled from single tools. No-one even bothered to check the PT boat, which should carry tools - if it still carry functional [=MGs=], then it means no-one before was trying to salvage the boat or it's equipment. One could wonder how actually Alex was able to get to the Endurance in the first place, if it took Lara half a day with lots of LeParkour. And WW2-era boat engines can be easily fixed with hammer, spanner and screwdriver - the exact tools (minus hammer) Lara got from Alex.

to:

** And ''still'' there are numerous other wrecks and other sites closer and safer where some toolbox could be found or assembled from single tools. No-one even bothered to check the PT boat, which should carry tools - if it still carry functional [=MGs=], then it means no-one before was trying to salvage the boat or it's equipment. One could wonder how actually Alex was able to get to the Endurance in the first place, if it took Lara half a day with lots of LeParkour. And WW2-era UsefulNotes/WW2-era boat engines can be easily fixed with hammer, spanner and screwdriver - the exact tools (minus hammer) Lara got from Alex.



* Ok, so the storms that wreck ships or aircraft that approach the island [[spoiler: are the result of Himiko's rage at being [[SealedEvilInACan trapped in her rotting corpse]] for nearly [[AndIMustScream two-thousand years]].]] The implication is that ''any'' ships and aircraft that stray too near are sunk or brought down, and no one gets off the island again. However among the wreckage from previous inhabitants is a large and heavily fortified shore battery dating to WorldWarII ([[spoiler: the installation you enter en route to the wreck of ''Endurance'']]) with its guns still in place. This isn't a temporary sandbag structure, but a fixed-position ''concrete bunker'' designed to withstand heavy naval bombardment, high up on the cliffs with a wide field of fire out to sea. Furthermore, those are some pretty ''big'' guns. Even if you assume most of the structure relies on natural rock, there's still a ''lot'' of excavation needed that would require fairly heavy-duty equipment, and it's clear much of the finished structure is indeed made from concrete, not the local rock. Not to mention getting guns ''that'' large into position is a pretty tall order before the advent of large utility helicopters. There's other fairly heavy wartime construction (the radio tower and its command bunker I believe is implied to have dated from the same period, probably a part of the same defense system as the gun emplacement we explore during the game) on the island as well. So clearly, there ''had'' to have been a fairly reliable flow of heavy equipment and construction personnel arriving at the island to build finished structures of this sort. Additionally, if the Japanese thought this island was important enough to fortify it so heavily, its location must have been known well enough to be viewed as strategically vital. Meanwhile, the United States had to consider its ''capture'' strategically important to have actually landed Marines ([[spoiler: based on the Semper Fi artifact collection]]) on it, (the Island Hopping strategy dictated bypassing strong points such as Rabaul altogether and just pounding them into rubble from the air and sea. Peleliu, Iwo Jima, Saipan and Okinawa were targeted for capture because they were viewed as vital for advancing towards the Japanese Home Islands) which means they ''also'' must have known about it. And of course, [[spoiler: Trinity]] knew enough about the island and what could be found there that it sent an agent to investigate. For such a lost and mysterious island, there's certainly a ''lot'' of activity in its fairly recent history that would practically ''require'' people freely coming and going from the place.

to:

* Ok, so the storms that wreck ships or aircraft that approach the island [[spoiler: are the result of Himiko's rage at being [[SealedEvilInACan trapped in her rotting corpse]] for nearly [[AndIMustScream two-thousand years]].]] The implication is that ''any'' ships and aircraft that stray too near are sunk or brought down, and no one gets off the island again. However among the wreckage from previous inhabitants is a large and heavily fortified shore battery dating to WorldWarII UsefulNotes/WorldWarII ([[spoiler: the installation you enter en route to the wreck of ''Endurance'']]) with its guns still in place. This isn't a temporary sandbag structure, but a fixed-position ''concrete bunker'' designed to withstand heavy naval bombardment, high up on the cliffs with a wide field of fire out to sea. Furthermore, those are some pretty ''big'' guns. Even if you assume most of the structure relies on natural rock, there's still a ''lot'' of excavation needed that would require fairly heavy-duty equipment, and it's clear much of the finished structure is indeed made from concrete, not the local rock. Not to mention getting guns ''that'' large into position is a pretty tall order before the advent of large utility helicopters. There's other fairly heavy wartime construction (the radio tower and its command bunker I believe is implied to have dated from the same period, probably a part of the same defense system as the gun emplacement we explore during the game) on the island as well. So clearly, there ''had'' to have been a fairly reliable flow of heavy equipment and construction personnel arriving at the island to build finished structures of this sort. Additionally, if the Japanese thought this island was important enough to fortify it so heavily, its location must have been known well enough to be viewed as strategically vital. Meanwhile, the United States had to consider its ''capture'' strategically important to have actually landed Marines ([[spoiler: based on the Semper Fi artifact collection]]) on it, (the Island Hopping strategy dictated bypassing strong points such as Rabaul altogether and just pounding them into rubble from the air and sea. Peleliu, Iwo Jima, Saipan and Okinawa were targeted for capture because they were viewed as vital for advancing towards the Japanese Home Islands) which means they ''also'' must have known about it. And of course, [[spoiler: Trinity]] knew enough about the island and what could be found there that it sent an agent to investigate. For such a lost and mysterious island, there's certainly a ''lot'' of activity in its fairly recent history that would practically ''require'' people freely coming and going from the place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Japanese-flagged helo, American pilot...wearing a Commonwealth Air Force's (RAF, RCAF, RAAF, etc.) flightsuit. Anyone else catch that?

Changed: 175

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**My thoughts: Hoshi stabbed herself as Himiko entered her, and died moments after the ritual was complete and it was too late. Himiko's soul is trapped in Hoshi's dead body.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**Lara remarks in-game about how any of the structures seem to have power. There's a remote chance that the Solarii, in all their years of fiddling around in every nook and cranny of the island, have somehow managed to cobble together generators to pump life into the place. Even in-game, as Lara makes her way to the Endurance to find Alex, the Solarii are scavenging generators. Several of the Solarii even remark, when not engaged in combat, about how they've already salvaged quite a few generators from other parts of the island and wonder aloud what exactly they're being used to power up. It's also possible that the radio tower is being run on a different power grid than the one she blew up on her way there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Mathias has been on Yamatai since 1985, according to one of several journal entries scattered across the island. When the game came out in 2013, the math adds up: that's over thirty years he's been trapped on Yamatai. He's had time to observe things. And it's not as though the Dragon's Triangle is policed constantly or has signs posted at its borders warning people away. Not everyone who owns a boat is instantly a seasoned mariner to know what areas to avoid and how to read the weather correctly. Granted, there were probably plenty of experienced sailors--and pilots, given the state of how many planes have crash-landed as well on Yamatai--who ended up on the island, too. Couple all that with Himiko being the biggest influence in creating the erratic storms that plague that particular system, and it's quite possible to see how frighteningly easy it is for Mathias to gather that many men in thirty years.

Top