Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies. The shock and emotional trauma of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur when he's significantly stressed.
*** Strangely enough, this could explain why Roy Tinns in particular appeared to the kids even though Frances admitted to Pete that she had no idea whose mining hat it was; they would only have imagined someone they knew.
*** Strangely enough, this could explain why Roy Tinns in particular appeared to the kids even though Frances admitted to Pete that she had no idea whose mining hat it was; they would only have imagined someone they knew.
to:
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies. The shock and emotional trauma of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur when he's significantly stressed.
*** Strangely enough, this could explain why Roy Tinns in particular appeared to the kids even though Frances admitted to Pete that she had no idea whose mining hat it was; they would only have imagined someone they knew.stressed.
*** Strangely enough, this could explain why Roy Tinns in particular appeared to the kids even though Frances admitted to Pete that she had no idea whose mining hat it was; they would only have imagined someone they knew.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies. The shock and emotional trauma of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur when he's significantly stressed.
to:
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies. The shock and emotional trauma of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur when he's significantly stressed.stressed.
*** Strangely enough, this could explain why Roy Tinns in particular appeared to the kids even though Frances admitted to Pete that she had no idea whose mining hat it was; they would only have imagined someone they knew.
*** Strangely enough, this could explain why Roy Tinns in particular appeared to the kids even though Frances admitted to Pete that she had no idea whose mining hat it was; they would only have imagined someone they knew.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies, because the shock and emotional stress of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur when he's significantly stressed.
to:
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies, because the bodies. The shock and emotional stress trauma of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur when he's significantly stressed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 2 (click to see context) from:
* How come the kids never came across their fathers' corpses? Chet recognised the area they got caved in as the area the original accident happened, after all, and Pete did say the bodies were still there (albeit that could have been what he imagined the mine to be like at the time).
to:
* How come the kids never came across their fathers' corpses? Chet recognised the area they got caved in as the area the original accident happened, after all, and Pete did say at the start of the musical that the bodies were still there (albeit (although that could have just been what he imagined the mine to be like at the time).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies, because the shock and emotional stress of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur in his times of need.
to:
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies, because the shock and emotional stress of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur in his times of need.when he's significantly stressed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1 (click to see context) from:
* How do the kids manage to communicate with the miners, considering that we know for sure that the dads are dead, but (according to Miner Twitchell) the kids aren't dead - 'not yet'. Also, unlike the Alamo heroes, all five kids see all the miners at the same time and not just their respective parents (as evidenced by Dusty being able to talk to both Miner Twitchell and Roy Tinns). The most plausible explanation therefore is that the kids met the ''ghosts'' of their fathers, but then how are they able to physically hug them?
to:
* How do the kids manage to communicate with the miners, considering that we know for sure that the dads are dead, but (according to Miner Twitchell) the kids aren't dead - 'not yet'. yet'? Also, unlike the Alamo heroes, all five kids see all the miners at the same time and not just their respective parents (as evidenced by Dusty being able to talk to both Miner Twitchell and Roy Tinns). The most plausible explanation therefore is that the kids met the ''ghosts'' of their fathers, but then how are they able to physically hug them?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 2 (click to see context) from:
* If according to Pete, ''"The bodies are still there!"'', then how come the kids never came across their fathers' corpses? Chet recognised the area they got caved in as the area the original accident happened, after all.
to:
* If according to Pete, ''"The bodies are still there!"'', then how How come the kids never came across their fathers' corpses? Chet recognised the area they got caved in as the area the original accident happened, after all.all, and Pete did say the bodies were still there (albeit that could have been what he imagined the mine to be like at the time).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 2 (click to see context) from:
* If according to Pete, "the bodies are still there!", then how come the kids never came across their fathers' corpses? Chet recognised the area they got caved in as the area the original accident happened, after all.
to:
* If according to Pete, "the ''"The bodies are still there!", there!"'', then how come the kids never came across their fathers' corpses? Chet recognised the area they got caved in as the area the original accident happened, after all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1 (click to see context) from:
* How do the kids manage to communicate with the miners, considering that we know for sure that the dads are dead, but (according to Miner Twitchell) the kids aren't dead - 'not yet'. Also, unlike the Alamo heroes, all five kids see all the miners at the same time and not just their respective parents (as evidenced by Dusty being able to talk to both Miner Twitchell and Roy Tinns). The most plausible explanation therefore is that the kids met the ''ghosts'' of their fathers, but then how are they able to physically hug them?
to:
* How do the kids manage to communicate with the miners, considering that we know for sure that the dads are dead, but (according to Miner Twitchell) the kids aren't dead - 'not yet'. Also, unlike the Alamo heroes, all five kids see all the miners at the same time and not just their respective parents (as evidenced by Dusty being able to talk to both Miner Twitchell and Roy Tinns). The most plausible explanation therefore is that the kids met the ''ghosts'' of their fathers, but then how are they able to physically hug them?them?
* If according to Pete, "the bodies are still there!", then how come the kids never came across their fathers' corpses? Chet recognised the area they got caved in as the area the original accident happened, after all.
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies, because the shock and emotional stress of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur in his times of need.
* If according to Pete, "the bodies are still there!", then how come the kids never came across their fathers' corpses? Chet recognised the area they got caved in as the area the original accident happened, after all.
** It would make sense if they ''did'' see the bodies, because the shock and emotional stress of that could have caused them all to imagine their fathers as alive, much like Pete's fantasies which only occur in his times of need.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1 (click to see context) from:
* So Pete communicating with the Alamo heroes makes sense to a degree- they're his imaginary friends, essentially. But how do the kids manage to communicate with the miners, considering that we know for sure that the dads are dead, but (according to Miner Twitchell) the kids aren't dead - 'not yet'. Also, unlike the Alamo heroes, ''all five kids'' see ''all the miners'' at the same time and not just their respective parents (as evidenced by Dusty being able to talk to both Miner Twitchell and Roy Tinns). The most plausible explanation therefore is that the kids met the ''ghosts'' of their fathers, but then how are they able to hug them?
to:
* So Pete communicating with the Alamo heroes makes sense to a degree- they're his imaginary friends, essentially. But how How do the kids manage to communicate with the miners, considering that we know for sure that the dads are dead, but (according to Miner Twitchell) the kids aren't dead - 'not yet'. Also, unlike the Alamo heroes, ''all all five kids'' kids see ''all all the miners'' miners at the same time and not just their respective parents (as evidenced by Dusty being able to talk to both Miner Twitchell and Roy Tinns). The most plausible explanation therefore is that the kids met the ''ghosts'' of their fathers, but then how are they able to physically hug them?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* So Pete communicating with the Alamo heroes makes sense to a degree- they're his imaginary friends, essentially. But how do the kids manage to communicate with the miners, considering that we know for sure that the dads are dead, but (according to Miner Twitchell) the kids aren't dead - 'not yet'. Also, unlike the Alamo heroes, ''all five kids'' see ''all the miners'' at the same time and not just their respective parents (as evidenced by Dusty being able to talk to both Miner Twitchell and Roy Tinns). The most plausible explanation therefore is that the kids met the ''ghosts'' of their fathers, but then how are they able to hug them?
